During a communist party meeting, Stalin is giving a speech.
Posted by PirateKing2807@reddit | Jokes | View on Reddit | 80 comments
Suddenly somebody in the hall sneezes loudly. Everyone gasps in terror.
Stalin looks sternly at the audience, and says, "Who sneezed?".
Nobody confesses, so Stalin claps his hands. A platoon of NKVD troops with automatic weapons barges in, drags the front row out in the hallway and shoots them.
"I will ask again - who sneezed?" Nobody confesses, so the process is repeated with the second row.
After the third row has been dragged out and shot without anyone confessing, an old man in the rear, a devout Communist, decides to sacrifice himself for the younger comrades, stands up and bravely proclaims: "I sneezed, Comrade Stalin!".
Stalin looks at him sternly for a moment. "Bless you, comrade!". And he continues with the speech.
Right_Two_5737@reddit
True story:
Years after Stalin's death, the new Premier gave a speech at a communist party meeting. One of things he talked about was how bad Stalin had been. Someone in the audience asked, "If he was so bad, why didn't you do anything about it?" The Premier angrily shouted, "Who said that? WHO SAID THAT?" Dead silence. A few moments later, "You see, that's why we didn't do anything."
Jusfiq@reddit
Who? Khrushchev?
Right_Two_5737@reddit
Sorry, I don't remember. Probably either him or one of the guys between him and Stalin.
Korbiter@reddit
Kruschev is literally the one who took over after Stalin died. There was no guys between him and Stalin. And yes, it was a heckler against Kruschev, and he said the line.
Wowza-yowza@reddit
This man speaks with authority. He must be right.
relativisticcobalt@reddit
This is not true. Officially it was Malenkov. Unofficially there was a new troika with malenkov, Khrushchev and Beria, it was extremely messy.
florinandrei@reddit
It's an anecdote often repeated, but there is no record of the exchange actually taking place. The story is likely an embellishment of the famous Secret Speech given by Khrushchev in 1956.
DodgerWalker@reddit
Malenkov was leader for six months (as part of a troika) in between according to Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_leaders_of_the_Soviet_Union
TapPublic7599@reddit
Technically Malenkov was his direct successor in all of his various titles and offices for a week, then gave up some of those offices to Khrushchev but retained some for himself. Then later Khrushchev kicked him out of the Premiership and then even later kicked him out of his other offices. It was complicated.
wileysegovia@reddit
Apparently it was cold, in his little corner of the world. You could roll around the globe, and never find a warmer soul to know. ... Nikita ...
IceCreamMeatballs@reddit
Georgy Malenkov came after Stalin and before Khrushchev, but he was largely a Stalin loyalist. Khrushchev was the one who actually denounced Stalin.
LongtimeLurker916@reddit
Khrushchev was (more or less) his direct successor. He really did give a famous speech denouncing Stalin, but I would assume this story is apocryphal.
Agitated_Pattern_948@reddit
The speech in the 1950s was secret. I did an honor project to investigate De-Stalinization. The CIA got a copy of the speech ten years after it was delivered and released it to the public. After the Soviet Union collapsed in 1990 period, KGB files showed the text of the CIA copy was correct.
LongtimeLurker916@reddit
It was secret, but the basic idea (even if not the actual verbatim text) was leaked to the West pretty quickly.
skieblue@reddit
The story I heard was it was Khrushchev at a banquet/official dinner type event. It's almost certainly apocryphal as it's too pat to be true.
Relevant_Cause_4755@reddit
You should watch “Death of Stalin”.
florinandrei@reddit
There was no one, really, between Khrushchev and Stalin. Malenkov looked, briefly, like he was going to get the top job. Beria also made a lot of noise. All these did not last long. Nikita Khrushchev was the real successor.
Wowza-yowza@reddit
Krushchev sneezed.
piper63-c137@reddit
yes, i think Kruschev.
Cute_Elk_2428@reddit
yes.
Korchagin@reddit
Yes. It was on a peace of paper given to the podium. Of course that was such a great pitch to get his message across -- it's quite likely he staged it completely and it was his own "question".
Fireandmoonlight@reddit
Yes, Khrushchev. In the version I heard there was a whole minute of silence. The people were probably wondering if the Stalin story was true. I'm wondering if we'll have our own version of this story in America.
PigHillJimster@reddit
From The Gulag Archipelago, the 11 minute applause:
https://historyinsights.com/11-minute-applause/
Never be the one to stop clapping first.
markdado@reddit
I'll give you $1,000 for reasonable verification of this story. I'm not saying Stalin was fantastic, but if you believe shit like this without evidence I got a bridge to sell you.
Amrywiol@reddit
As I said in reply to another post we have footage of the alarm bell that was used to signal the audience that it was safe to stop applauding so Stalin could get on with his speech - https://youtube.com/shorts/0chXSxf1xbU?si=R78v3HGJK7sS9-7T
It stands to reason they wouldn't have needed a signal that it was safe to stop applauding if it wasn't the case that it was unsafe to stop at other times.
markdado@reddit
You see how that's completely different than story of getting arrested after 11mins of non-stop clapping, right? I also feel the need to remind you that a YouTube short voiceover isn't exactly evidence of anything. Google around finds zero first hand accounts ever talking about a bell ever being used. So again I say "please provide evidence other than USSR BAD".
There ARE stories of people being expected to clap, but that's like the "APPLAUSE" sign for a TV show's live studio audience. If you watch modern American politics you'll see similar behavior. The State of the Union involves Reps/Dems clapping until their party leader stops.
myownzen@reddit
I was ready to write a reply and then your second paragraph already covers it.
Willow-girl@reddit
And half the American population thinks we're currently living under a fascist dictatorship. LOL
garvisgarvis@reddit
Not quite a fascist dictatorship. But people in power are definitely watching what they say, and many are paying tribute. I find that chilling.
Willow-girl@reddit
If you think this is a new thing, you haven't been paying attention.
jflb96@reddit
Holy Non Sequitur, Willowgirl! You seem to have no idea what fascism or socialism are!
Willow-girl@reddit
Well, for starters, Very Bad Things -- am I right?
jflb96@reddit
No.
jflb96@reddit
I mean, Solzhenitsyn was described by his own wife as making up half of what he put in his books, so maybe don’t take as gospel the word of a guy who never forgave communism for the USSR conscripting him to fight the Nazis
Amrywiol@reddit
As I said in reply to another post we have footage of the alarm bell that was used to signal the audience that it was safe to stop applauding so Stalin could get on with his speech - https://youtube.com/shorts/0chXSxf1xbU?si=R78v3HGJK7sS9-7T
It stands to reason they wouldn't have needed a signal that it was safe to stop applauding if it wasn't the case that it was unsafe to stop at other times.
jflb96@reddit
That’s an interesting YouTube channel. Let’s look at the description.
Oh.
Amrywiol@reddit
Why don't you look at the actual video footage instead? Because it says something you don't want to hear?
But fine. If you want to play that game try this link -
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fik2-kgOgng
As to the source of this one - see that NDR in the top right corner of the video? That's Norddeutscher Rundfunk, a respectable German public service broadcaster that is not in the habit of making stuff up.
jflb96@reddit
I did look at the footage, thanks for assuming otherwise
johnlooksscared@reddit
Most "good" Soviet stories are, by virtue of that description, also made up
jflb96@reddit
I think that’s ‘good old’ as in the sort of vintage joke that gets endlessly reposted here
Amrywiol@reddit
In fact the situation got so bad that an alarm bell was introduced to signal to the audience that it was safe to stop applauding so Stalin could get on with his speech. There's footage of it here - https://youtube.com/shorts/0chXSxf1xbU?si=mvRwZHzSqTyLy0pP
Mad_Queen_Malafide@reddit
True story:
Often when someone posts an anecdote, and starts it off with the words "true story", it is not in fact a true story.
Right_Two_5737@reddit
I've never told a lie in my life!
ThoughtfulLlama@reddit
Just like 83% of cited stats being made up on the spot.
lfc94121@reddit
That sounds like a scene out of "The Death of Stalin". Which is a hilarious movie, highly recommended.
justsomechickyo@reddit
My bf discovered that movie like a month ago and has pry watched it at least 5 times by now lmao
404_GravitasNotFound@reddit
What is pry watched?
justsomechickyo@reddit
It’s shorthand for probably
skieblue@reddit
Watched it last night and it was unbelievably funny even if not very accurate
StillFireWeather791@reddit
During that period there was a joke in the USSR. After Stalin dies and Kruschevv takes over, Kruschevv receives two letters from Stalin. The first letter says "Open upon taking over" on the envelope and the second one says "Open when you are usurped".
Kruschevv opens the first envelope. In Stalin's handwriting it says "Blame everything on me." Kruschevv does this very publicly. Years later when Kruschevv faces forcible retirement by a coup, he opens the second letter. It says "Write two letters".
Waitsfornoone@reddit
... and that's one of the funnier stories about life under Communism.
The rest? Not so much.
counterfitster@reddit
*Stalinism
Mind_if_I_do_uh_J@reddit
Potato
LazyGelMen@reddit
Spudnik
Mind_if_I_do_uh_J@reddit
Gopnik
Eodbatman@reddit
They didn’t have many of those either
Brain_Hawk@reddit
Po-tay-toe! Boil em, mash em, stick em in a stew!!
markroth69@reddit
I like the one about the three guys in gulag:
Man 1: I was jailed for subverting the revolution by coming to work late
Man 2: I was imprisoned for subverting the revolution by coming to work early and showing off to earn extra to benefit myself only
Man 3: I was sent here for showing up on time. They figured I illegally possessed a watch from an imperialist state!
Amrywiol@reddit
The version I heard was:
Man 1: I'm here for supporting comrade Popov.
Man 2: I'm here for criticising comrade Popov.
Man 3: I am comrade Popov...
ScheduleCorrect3412@reddit
That was a new one for me.
Opus-the-Penguin@reddit
I remember the joke that got told in The Americans where a guy walks into a shop and asks, "Is this the place where you have no meat?" And he gets told, "Oh, no, you want the shop across the street. This is the place where we have no fish."
SquirrelNormal@reddit
An American and a Soviet die and go to hell. They're each offered a choice between American hell and Soviet hell.
"What's the difference?" Asks one.
"Well," says the Devil, "both are actually pretty cushy. But in the American hell, you have to eat one bucket of shit every day. In the Soviet hell, it's two buckets."
The American chooses the American hell, and the Soviet chooses the Soviet hell.
A week later, they meet up.
"How is the American hell?" Asks the Soviet.
"It's not bad, but man, that bucket of shit is killing me. What about Soviet hell? It's got to be worse with two buckets."
The Soviet laughs. "Oh, it's just like home. Either the shit never shows up, or there's not enough of it to go around."
Fireandmoonlight@reddit
Two guys are sitting in a bar in Moscow and one asks "If they open the border tomorrow, will you leave the country?" "Of course, why should I be the only one left?"
mattysocks@reddit
I mean, it’s funny because it’s not meant to be taken seriously. At face value it’s horrifying, but we’re in r/jokes
maceion@reddit
Real trust. My Latin teacher had been the Russian-English translator to Khrushchev at Stalingrad, as Khrushchev preferred him to the official translators (My teacher had been part of UK embassy folk). Communications over Morse code radio from Stalin to Khrushchev were sent in English as radio operators did not speak English so a level of security was obtained. Years later when Bulganin and Khrushchev visited UK. My Latin teacher 'disappeared ' from school with no reason given. Then we saw him on TV standing behind Khrushchev as translator. It appeared Khrushchev trusted his old Stalingrad English translator over the embassy appointed translator.
Special-Ocelot7425@reddit
Stalin was meeting the heads of all the communist states in 1948. He looked over and said Bulgaria? Yes comrade Stalin said the head of Bulgaria. Poland ? Yes comrade Stalin replied the polish leader. He then looked over to the next leader, Hungary? He asked. No comrade Stalin he replied. I had a full English breakfast this morning.
WanaWahur@reddit
Two old communists sit on a park bench.
- Eh, Ivan, me and you, we're getting old, we will not see Communism in our lifetime...
- Yeah, but our kids will!
- Indeed. Poor kids, so sorry about them.
markroth69@reddit
The great thing about communism is that we can share everything. Soon it will be your turn to tell this joke.
No_Constant_4968@reddit
Old number 45! Very popular in Vorkuta!
Andthentherewasbacon@reddit
What number is the joke where we number the jokes?
Ramguy2014@reddit
1
Andthentherewasbacon@reddit
Huh, I thought it would be lower.
Waitsfornoone@reddit
111.
Andthentherewasbacon@reddit
that's higher though
Stock_Bandicoot_115@reddit
-1/12
ScaryRun619@reddit
Old number 45 is almost as bad a joke as number 47. Both have been told badly.
SensitivePineapple83@reddit
krasnov isn't told badly, he's just too stupid for second-language translated eloquence.
R4ael2@reddit
Well as You know, He could never tell a joke!
rimeswithburple@reddit
It was probably Zhukov.
SensitivePineapple83@reddit
45 / 47 - is krasnov