Suddenly Human
Posted by Icarus367@reddit | TNG | View on Reddit | 10 comments
I think the episodic nature of TNG is felt very acutely when one considers an episode such as Suddenly Human. If you recall, Jono's sole surviving blood relative was his grandmother, a Starfleet admiral. The admiral was elated at the prospect of getting Jono back, and then Picard decides to return Jono to his adopted alien family with no indication that he even informed the admiral beforehand. And then the Enterprise flies away, and Jono is never brought up again.
Imagine the administrative shitstorm that Picard's decision would incur in real life, or at least in a reasonably true-to-life serialized storyline. There are no doubt many ways that a Starfleet admiral can make trouble for a captain, not least via a court martial. And yet, there's no indication that Picard received so much as a sternly-worded email from the admiral. Rather than showing this headache playing out for Picard over the course of weeks or months, the Enterprise just goes off to a new adventure, with the slate wiped clean.
Reluctant_Gamer_2700@reddit
In the TNG Ep. ‘Up the Long Ladder’ Will Riker killed a clone of himself that was made without his consent. But it had not been born/ hatched yet. But a fully formed duplicate that was already living his own life was something different, a transporter-created copy of him. He couldn’t just kill him!
Also, Wesley’s nanites got their own planet. Wesley also once trapped his mother in a warp bubble during another experiment! She just barely made it out with some help from the alien Traveler.
Reluctant_Gamer_2700@reddit
I wondered about that. There was also a grandfather. They were overjoyed that their lost grandson was alive and now on his way back to them on Earth, to “carry on the line.” How did Picard explain leaving them out of the decision to return Jono to Endar? I understand why he did it, but surely there would have been hell to pay!
Icarus367@reddit (OP)
Yeah, I would imagine that was a tough call to make.
l008com@reddit
The thing about this episode which made sense in 1990 or whatever but doesn't really make sense today, is that its not like they wouldn't be able to talk. In 2021, everyone knows how email/text/facetime works. Even if Jono stayed with the aliens, his human family could still send him letters and slowly build up a relationship with them. As he grew and matured, and was given time to process, eventually he would want to go back to earth and meet them I would suspect. The episode treats it like a situation of "once you leave, you're gone forever". But it would be more like living in another state. With some effort, you can visit. But you can easily keep in touch other ways.
Reluctant_Gamer_2700@reddit
Maybe not so easy since Endar’s world is not part of the Federation…
CoconutDust@reddit
It's much worse than you think.
The episode is a horror-show train-wreck on 40 different layers.
Flelk@reddit
Reddit is no longer the place it once was, and the current plan to kneecap the moderators who are trying to keep the tattered remnants of Reddit's culture alive was the last straw.
I am removing all of my posts and editing all of my comments. Reddit cannot have my content if it's going to treat its user base like this. I encourage all of you to do the same. Lemmy.ml is a good alternative.
Reddit is dead. Long live Reddit.
Diregnoll@reddit
Naw reddit still here and your boycott did nothing to the admins. All it did is make context to search results look stupid.
ProfessorCValentine@reddit
My Number 1 out of 3 WORST episodes of all time when trying to sleep... AWOOOOOOOOOOO
If you're curious about the other two it would be The Battle (that damn high pitched mind control thing) and Phantasms when Data starts... squealing?
c_gdev@reddit
I had never seem the TNG episode “Suddenly Human.” Pretty slow. But I still liked it better than some modern Star Trek.