I believe this book was required reading for our generation
Posted by Bob_12_Pack@reddit | GenX | View on Reddit | 119 comments
I was 12 when my mom gave me this book. I had already seen it at school and must have mentioned it, mom was very thoughtful when it came to gifts. The paper cover was lost to the ages, a result of being handled very often.
Charming_Butterfly90@reddit
Yes and I still have it and some others, The Giving Tree, Runny Babbit, Falling Up and A Light in the Attic. Saving for my grandkids.
magicjenn_3@reddit
I love this book!!! Read it to my son!!
2_krazykats@reddit
Same! Read it to my kids when they were younger. One day I hope to read it for my grandkids.
Green_Chandelier@reddit
I used tuck in my kid at bedtime to “Boa Constrictor.” Whadya know, he’s nibbling at my toe (tuck in the blanket, pretend gnaw at his feet) oh gee, he’s up to my knee (same thing). Grand finale was covering up his head for the oh dread part. He got a kick out of that. 😆
2_krazykats@reddit
Super sweet. That's what childhood memories are made of. I bet they still remember it.
precious1of3@reddit
I loved his cartoons in playboy lol
SirGeremiah@reddit
Man, I recognized it from the front cover. I have that on my bookshelf in my home office.
DIYnivor@reddit
My second grade teacher read it to us regularly, so I asked my mom to buy it for me. She saw that Shel Silverstein was the author, and said "no way". I didn't understand. Neither did she. One day we were in a book store, and I brought a copy over to her. She flipped through it, and bought it for me. I still have it.
WaterFrogSnail@reddit
Ickle me, Pickle me, Tickle me too, went for a ride in a flying shoe. Hooray, what fun, it's time we flew! said Ickle me, Pickle me, Tickle me too.
So many rhymes from this book burned into my brain.
anotherspaceguy100@reddit
Never heard of it. Not everyone grew up in North America, you know.
MorpheusZzzz@reddit
You're never too old to read Shel Silverstein.
MorpheusZzzz@reddit
Sarah Cynthia Sylvia Stout. She would not take the garbage out!
Alternative-Law4626@reddit
My parents were silent Gen, so no. Therapy culture hadn’t taken over children’s books yet. My wife had another book by the author, because her Silent Gen parents were into therapy themselves.
Fugue_State76@reddit
Huh? My parents also Silent Generation and we loved Shel Silverstein books. Nothing about 'therapy culture' in those things, trust me, my parents wouldn't have been into it.
Alternative-Law4626@reddit
Other than what the OP said, I haven’t read him. When I showed my wife, she made the comment that it grew out of therapy culture. I don’t even know what that is.
MysteriousMeeting159@reddit
My parents gave me a copy of “in cold blood”
UnicornFarts1111@reddit
I was given that to read in high school. Since I was an avid reader at the time, I read it in like a week. We were given six to read it I think, lol. It was a good book. It sucks that it was a true story.
TeeLeighPee@reddit
I read that one about the same age and I've reread the series multiple times in my life since. There are 6 books total now and the series is ended. Great reads
Kindly-Individual926@reddit
He wrote the hit song Sylvia’s Mother by Dr Hook.
worrymon@reddit
He wrote the entire Dr Hook album that Sylvia's Mother was on.
Comfortable-Choice14@reddit
I enjoyed it all over again with my kids. I also made sure they had The Giving Tree, but I could never read it to them because I would always cry.
Fugue_State76@reddit
awful book. here's to hoping kids treat their parents better than that
SunnySTX@reddit
Incredible books for a young growing mind! His best was The Giving Tree.
tchrhoo@reddit
The Giving Tree has never sat right with me.
Fugue_State76@reddit
Agreed. Encouraging codependent/abusive relationships 101
Fugue_State76@reddit
You're kidding right? The book about a one-sided abusive relationship? Kids like that grow up to be the ones looting their parents' bank accounts while they lay dying in the hospital. Take Take Take to the very end from that punk kid.
inferreddit@reddit
There's that one book he wrote that definitely was not for young children - Uncle Shelby’s ABZ Book: A Primer for Adults Only
Tim-oBedlam@reddit
When I was in high school I had a creative writing class in 11th grade, and as part of it we had to do a report on a 20th century poet. I picked Shel Silverstein, and we ended up having a really deep discussion about "The Giving Tree". I read it out loud, and then asked, "anyone else really bothered by this book"?
I also remembered cracking up the class with my dramatic reading of Silverstein's epic poem, "The Battle"
Do you want to hear the tale
Of the terrible night
When I bravely fought the—no?
All right.
poss-um@reddit
Sarah Cynthia Sylvia Stout
Would not take the garbage out.
She'd wash the dishes and scrub the pans
Cook the yams and spice the hams,
And though her parents would scream and shout,
She simply would not take the garbage out.
TeeLeighPee@reddit
This is the best one imo
Secret-Ice260@reddit
When I was about 8, I brought Where the Sidewalk Ends over to my grandparents’ house because my grandmother would read to me at bedtime. I’ll never forget how tickled she got during “Me and Him.” She was laughing so hard she had tears in her eyes. That is the only time I can remember her laughing that hard for that long.
TeeLeighPee@reddit
What a great memory
Under_the_Milky_Way@reddit
Is this an American thing? Have never heard of this book or author.
Due-Surprise757@reddit
Yes definitely - very well known amd loved here. Maybe you have heard of "The Giving Tree"?
GoldberryoTulgeyWood@reddit
Man. I struggle with this book. I hate that they guy just takes everything.
Is this book the reason people are so entitled these days?? s/ but also not s/
Nerdslave2@reddit
Book still gives me trauma and probably set my outlook on life. Every time I see a stump it rushes back. Kid was an asshole.
Fugue_State76@reddit
Royal asshole kid. My millennial sister is raising her kids this way. Good luck! is all I say.
Fugue_State76@reddit
I read this book as an adult and Was Horrified by it. Story reminded me of an abusive relationship I was in during my 20s that took me ages to get out of. Wtf, Shel, loved your other books but this one was repulsive. I remember even being confused by it as a kid.
Godlove6@reddit
Am I the only Gen Xer that's never heard of this book?
Fugue_State76@reddit
Yes.
jfrorie@reddit
No. I'm clueless
Godlove6@reddit
Thanks for not leaving me hanging,,1965 btw
MACS-System@reddit
Teddy said it was a hat So I put it on Now Mom is yelling Where the heck's the toilet plunger gone
whistlepig4life@reddit
Never read this.
To me the required reading for our Gen is April Morning.
Though I think it’s required reading for everyone imo.
MACS-System@reddit
Never heard of that
HRShovenstuff1@reddit
I loved his work, but I also love his life story. The guy was an absolute party animal for a while. Look it up if you're so inclined.
Double-Carmel2193@reddit
“I cannot go to school today said little Peggy Ann McKay…”. My favorite!!!
Weird_Tea2539@reddit
Lazy
lazy
lazy
lazy
lazy
lazy Jane.
She wants a drink of water so
She waits
and waits
and waits
and waits
and waits for it to rain.
Beneficial-Cow-2544@reddit
And I think my copy looks exactly like this.
Fun but annoying fact: I read some poems to my kids awhile back and my 12 year old deemed then "innappropriate"
Ugggh, kids today! *waving at the sky*
RentOk2479@reddit
Yep. I still have my copy given from a teacher. Thanks, Mrs. Martin!
Busy_Reindeer_2935@reddit
I recited Ickle me pickle me for probably 5th grade class; I can still recite it from memory. I also describe some people as yippee yucks.
Far-Pomegranate-3541@reddit
If you like Shel Silverstein you should also check out Jack Prelutsky’s poems. I had his book “New Kid on the Block”. I still have parts of Homework! Oh, Homework! memorized and at the oddest times start internally reciting the poem to myself.
tofuttiWhereAreU@reddit
My kid loves these books! We read from this one or Light in the Attic almost every night. Peanut Butter Sandwich is her current favorite and Wild Strawberries is mine.
Embarrassed-Cause250@reddit
Not familar with that book. Required reading at my school were the Judy Blume, Steinbeck, and S.E. Hinton. Quite honestly, I felt too young and immature to deal with some of the issues in the books and sadness they evoked.
OldBanjoFrog@reddit
Bought, “Where the Sidewalk Ends” and, “A Light in the Attic” for my daughter the day she was born
NPC261939@reddit
Yup. Growing up with two teachers for parents had me reading ALL the time. Anything that interested me or not, would be tossed at me on a weekly basis.
GogglesPisano@reddit
I'm going to ride on the flying festoon.
I'll jump on his back, and I'll whistle a tune,
And we'll fly to the outermost tip of the moon,
The flying festoon and I.
We're taking some crackers, a ball, and a prune.
We're leaving this evening, precisely at noon.
Yes, I'm going to ride on the flying festoon.
(Just as soon as he learns how to fly.)
Square_Ad_4929@reddit
I’ve heard of the giving tree but don’t remember “sidewalk.” What is it about?
WhereItsAt75@reddit
He had 3 books that were collections of poems. This. Falling Up and A Light in the Attic.
VeggieDogLover@reddit
What's that you say? You say today is Saturday? I'm going out to play.
Tiny-Balance-3533@reddit
Huh. Idk why but I never read a lick of Silverstein. My mom didn’t introduce it and I never came across any in school. 🤷🏻♂️
KittiesRule1968@reddit
He wrote the Johnny Cash song, A Boy Named Sue.
Bardamu911@reddit
"hey everyone here's a widely known factoid that's barely even tangentially related to the original post"
Spc_Scott@reddit
I've read plenty of his books but had no idea he wrote the lyrics to those songs. Even had a 45 of the Irish Rovers singing the Unicorn Song...
RustySilver42@reddit
He wrote a LOT of music that we're familiar with, though. Including an entire album for Bobby Bare.
Some of the songs are rather adult, so some may find it surprising.
Bardamu911@reddit
yes, this is commonly known. I'm always confused when someone makes a post and then a bunch of dudes rush in to comment every unrelated fact they happen to have read on wikipedia this week. Yes, everyone knows he wrote lyrics. Finally and once and for all.....what does it have to do with the post????
RustySilver42@reddit
First and foremost, just because it's commonly known in your circle doesn't mean it's actually commonly known.
I saw one comment on here by someone who never even heard of the book. So I am thinking they didn't know the book author was the same one who wrote those songs.
If they just read it on Wikipedia this week and are excited to talk about it, then it clearly wasn't common knowledge to them, either.
I'm going to suggest you get used to the idea of "just let people enjoy things."
I came across this particular info at random a while back. But sometime in the last 5 years or so. I still think it's a neat fact that might interest people.
You already knew it, so you had even less reason to say anything than the people you were criticizing. It hurts no one for them to say that.
But what you said could definitely hurt feelings. Our generation has a lot of undiagnosed neurodivergent folks who are going to to love commenting random related facts. And this is absolutely related.
But then you come along with your comment and potentially fuck up some poor ND's day. RSD is a bitch.
Someone came along with a shiny trinket related to the topic at hand and wanted to share it. You could have ignored it, but instead you called their trinket unrelated trash.
But it is related and not everyone on this post knew about it. It's not like we grew up with the internet. Everyone on this sub is going to have things that didn't come up in their life.
I have huge gaps in music, TV, and movie knowledge. I grew up in a tiny ranching community in the rockies. We had one TV station and two radio stations. Which TV station was your one station depended on where your house was. Unless it rained. Then everyone got PBS. The radio stations were country and opera.
I'm sorry that kind of thing frustrates you. But if you watch the news or work with the public, you would know the only things everyone knows is stuff you learned by third grade. After that, who knows what stuck.
Bardamu911@reddit
you've really given me a lot to think about
RustySilver42@reddit
I've needed to think about it a time or two myself.
Most recently when my 29yo fwb was floored by how much 80s music I just don't know.
I'm glad you took it in the manner intended, too. I'm late diagnosed ND and can come off as rude completely unintentionally. And I can be way too literal sometimes.
Bardamu911@reddit
I can be a complete asshole I realize but I really just want everyone to understand that they deserve to be loved exactly the way that they are.
RustySilver42@reddit
🧡
Bardamu911@reddit
I can be a complete asshole I realize but I really just want everyone to know that they deserve to be loved exactly the way that they are.
Comedywriter1@reddit
He also wrote some of the songs for “Payday,” a great 70s film with Rip Torn as an aging country star who uses and abuses the people around him.
JeffEpp@reddit
Also The Unicorn song, and I Got High.
I got your green alligators, and your long necked geese
I got your humpty back camels, and you chimpanzees.
I got you cats and rats and elephants, but Lord I'm so forlorn
I just cant find no
Unicorns
"Cause I got high
Meyebackhurts@reddit
We quote from that book like a religious text. Well loved and often read. It’s part of my siblings love language.
Nira_50@reddit
Yes! The only book I kept from my childhood, and I read it to my son when he was younger.
AgainstSpace@reddit
Never heard of this author until I was well into adulthood.
24bics@reddit
Same. It wasn't until my own kids were in school that I learned of The Giving Tree/Shel Silverstein.
Coup-de-Glass@reddit
Love this book. Also got it for my kids.
Meeska-Mouska@reddit
Yes! And i bought it for my kids.
AgainstSpace@reddit
Actual required reading:
This piece of garbage was apparently so important to my literary education that two different teachers had us read the fucking thing. They did the same with A Separate Peace which is also trash. I went to a dumb school.
floppy_breasteses@reddit
Maybe in your locality but I've never heard of it.
Thegr8fan@reddit
Never read it or heard of the author and I am a prolific reader. So NO, to your required Gen X reading required question.
FormerLaugh3780@reddit
It sure as shit wasn't required at the gov't school I went to, never heard of it.
theblisters@reddit
You don't know about Shel Silverstein? I just assumed all of us gen x kids were indelibly marked by his books. I know I am
liog2step@reddit
Wait, you e never even heard of it??
smithe68@reddit
Never heard of it. American that went to school in Europe and 5 different states (both coasts and middle).
zetazen@reddit
I had a copy of A Light In The Attic. I don’t know what happened to it. It was given to me as a gift when I was in 6th grade in the 80s. It’s probably at my mom’s house somewhere in a box.
ExcelsiorUnltd@reddit
Black ones, white ones Yellow ones, red ones Necrophilliacs looking for dead ones. The greatest of the sadists And masochists too Screaming please hit me! And I’ll hit you.
PJBleakney@reddit
Poor Sarah Cynthia Sylvia Stout, I wonder if she ever thought about what she did.
TheLearnedHeckler@reddit
Different Dances is still required reading at my house.
Silly-Shoulder-6257@reddit
I still have “What a Day” memorized. Hehe
Mrowser1@reddit
I memorized “Sister for Sale” for a school recitation.
marugirl@reddit
Never heard of it
Left_Interaction_288@reddit
Same. I guess it's an American thing.
impablomations@reddit
Like most of the sub.
Mr_SunnyBones@reddit
yeah , up until the 2000s things were a lot more ..regional .. its the reason that despite growing up in the era , about 2/3rds of the things posted here are really unfamiliar (since they were just US things). But never heard of this at all.
Left_Interaction_288@reddit
Indeed. I'm from NZ and we got a lot of media from both the USA and Britain, and a little bit from Canada and Australia. But some things, like this book, I guess just weren't part of it, and other things you know about without ever actually experiencing.
NotAnotherThing@reddit
Me neither.
Reasonable-Mirror-15@reddit
I never read anything by Shel Silverstein. I was a Tolkien nerd. And I spent a lot of time reading history and classical literature. I also had an obsession with ufo's and aliens.
NotAnotherThing@reddit
Never heard of it.
Comedywriter1@reddit
Agree. Loved (and still love) this book.
FoleyV@reddit
I can still recite so many of these poems by memory. I loved Shel Silverstein!
Comedywriter1@reddit
Same.
Dramatic_Channel52@reddit
I still do, but used to as well!
shutthefuckupdonny98@reddit
Unexpected Mitch
adams361@reddit
As soon as I saw this, I started reciting a poem from it, it’s been decades!
yayayagilliganhell@reddit
Never heard of it and don't give a flying bat shit ass. So there it is, how do you like those onions. Champ
Frosty_Razzmatazz259@reddit
He had several books. They were not required in my school, but my mom was a 1st grade teacher and she got me all of his books. We loved reading them together and talking about them.
nadiaco@reddit
Never read not required
Graciebelle3@reddit
Still have my tattered copy, along with A Light in the Attic…
voidchungus@reddit
This was so foundationally ubiquitous when I was growing up that I still haven't fully processed that it was just kind of... absent from the bookshelves of schools and reading lists only a generation or two later. I thought there'd be more continued interest in it, and I'm not fully sure why that interest dissipated.
Shaved_taint@reddit
Where we learned from Sylvia Cinthya Stout the dangers of not taking the garbage out and that are parents may sell us to gypsies. I love this book
HarveyMushman72@reddit
First place my mind went.
Chad_Hooper@reddit
This is actually the first time I’ve heard of it.
In grade school, my communal reading experiences were a lot of Beverly Cleary stuff, and Julie of the Wolves.
Plus the teachers used to read a book to us in increments after lunch recess. Usually a chapter a day, I think.
The ones that stuck with me from that communal activity were A Wrinkle in Time, and the earlier Where the Red Fern Grows. The latter scarred me for life emotionally, and I bet a lot of you shared that trauma.
megaboz@reddit
Ditto. We have county islands in our city where the neighborhoods don't have sidewalks, leading to situations where the city maintained sidewalks just... end. So I imagine this is some treatise on the perils of poor urban planning.
Ordinary_Sail_414@reddit
I got mine in '78. Read it ragged.
delldarlin@reddit
Grew up on those books. I was later introduced to his recording career via stuff like "The Great Smoke-Off". That was a bit of a culture shock…
Infinite_stardust@reddit
I have this book in my sitting room and my preteen niece just read it aloud yesterday! She loves it.