Does "The Turk has no friend but the Turk" sentiment hold true?
Posted by No_Idea_479@reddit | AskBalkans | View on Reddit | 518 comments
Polls done on Reddit. According to the findings:
87% would support Greece against Turkey, contrast to 13%, if the former was attacked by the latter.
83% would support Greece against Turkey, contrast to 17%, even if an attacker could not be identified.
44% would support Greece against Turkey, contrast to 38%, even if the former was the one who attacked the latter.
Interesting results. Note that some countries (e.g. Kyrgyzstan, Cambodia, Mongolia, Indonesia etc.) might only have one vote and be very unrepresentative.
bugog@reddit
I don’t think it means something significant. Too little participants. And Reddit is heavily used in “western” countries which Greece is usually aligned with.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
If Greece attacks Turkey and commit massacres against us, 90% of Europe will be celebrating it.
Interesting_Piano_99@reddit
They already have, Turkish-Cypriots are victims of ethnic cleansing and also been embargoed by the west. Make that make sense.
MartinBP@reddit
Lol Turkish Cypriots are being discriminated by the Anatolian settlers taking up an increasingly large share of the population and receiving privileges from Ankara. It's not the West discriminating them or occupying them.
Sabeneben@reddit
There are also settlers from Greece in the southern part of Cyprus.
DontCareHowICallMe@reddit
Greek settlers in Cyprus? Is it, maybe, just regular migration???
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
It’s regular migration when it’s greek huh? Why doesn’t that apply to turkish people? What exactly is the difference?
DontCareHowICallMe@reddit
Cause turkey gives privileges to Turks that migrate in Cyprus
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Like what? I have never heard of such thing?
Returntomonke21@reddit
Find me ONE piece of evidence there is a mass settling program by Greece in free Cyprus. Even one. Compare to Turkey that is internationally known to have settled more than 300.000 people from Anatolia and Bulgaria into Cyprus through government programs
Boeing367-80@reddit
Google tells me that there are 25-30k Greeks (from Greece, not just ethnic) in Cyprus
There are 250-400k Turks by comparison.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
1960s were not the same with 2026.
During 1960s until 1974 they were constantly targeted by the Greek Cypriots.
PinkDisorder@reddit
Sweetie there's like 9 million of us to your 60 million. Even if we wanted to, which we don't, we simply don't have the numbers for something like this. You can rest easy.
Ps: such fantasies exist only in the minds of idiots who want to sell something by utilizing propaganda, whether the intended recipient is the Turkish public or the Greek public.
engineergaming_@reddit
i know it doesn't matter that much in this context but the inner nerd in me has to say that's actually 85 million
PinkDisorder@reddit
holy cow thats a lot of people
midefloroi@reddit
When greeks massacre turks in anatolia not even greeks supported them the country was divided
RestaurantBoring417@reddit
Turks love making up fictional scenarios that will never happen so they can feel like victims, lmao
Also massive projection because that is literally what you did to the Armenians, Greeks, Assyrians etc. about 100 years ago, which you deny to this day.
cicikusbabacik07@reddit
tung tung tung whataboutism
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Palestinians are the descendants of Philistines and Canaanites which invaded their neighbors and performed child sacrifice rituals with their children in captivity. Does that make it okay to invade Palestine today?
What happened to Greeks and Armenians surely caused massive life loss and we already recognize it. But it doesn't fulfill the conditions to be genocide. UN doesn't recognize it to be a genocide neither.
LastHomeros@reddit
He is actually right. There is a strong anti-Turkish sentiment in the Western World.
JRJenss@reddit
Perhaps, but it's definitely not this strong. Also there's a difference between the government of Turkey and Turkish people, who are basically split 50-50.
Personally I'm aware of the rise of the Turkish imperialism under Erdogan, but the most frustrating thing for me are Turkish military's actions against the Kurds in the neighboring countries - including Peshmerga who are the heroes of the war against ISIS. To my knowledge they stood by the peace agreement between the PKK and Turkey, ending hostilities in Turkey. I think some of them didn't want to give up their arms - a perfectly understandable decision given their experiences in Iraq and Syria. It had nothing to do with Turkey whose government should know better if it operated in good faith.
That being said, I would support Greece in this hypothetical scenario, but only in this scenario. In a reverse situation in which Greece were the aggressor, my support would go to Turkey.
LastHomeros@reddit
Are you aware that the Kurdish militias in neighboring countries are linked to the PKK, which has killed more than 50.000 people, including civilians like doctors, teachers, and nurses who wanted to provide service and aid to the Kurdish people living in eastern Turkey?
JRJenss@reddit
Common, why are you sounding like an outdated propagandist all of a sudden?
I'm aware of the fact that PKK first unilaterally declared a ceasefire, then their congress decided to permanently abandon its decades long armed insurgency, dissolve itself and finally its fighters layed down their arms years ago at this point. Regardless, the PKK is designated as a terrorist group.
I'm also aware that, not only are the Peshmerga not linked to the PKK, but they quite literally have opposing views, as well as opposing political goals, to the point where over the years their intense political rivalry turned them into enemies violently clashing with one another, over both ideology and territorial control in the north of Iraq...especially since the Peshmerga are the official military force of the Kurdistan Regional Government - the government running the autonomous Iraqi Kurdistan. They've always considered the PKKs incursions and establishing secret bases in the northern Iraqi mountains to be a breach of their and Iraqi sovereignty. Their conflict had been going on for a long time before the PKK finally got dissolved and layed down their arms, with the main event taking place precisely in Iraqi Kurdistan in northern Iraq, where the Peshmerga have the authority and legal jurisdiction. The only time these two groups stopped fighting each other before that, was during the common fight with ISIS. Currently, even after the dissolution of the PKK, there are still elements of it, dissatisfied with their congress' decision, so they tend to pick up the arms once more every now and again, and every time this happens, the Peshmerga fight them.
The Peshmerga affiliated group focused on northeastern Syria, are the Rojava Peshmerga as an elite type of a force, but the majority of the Syrian Kurds have generally been members of the YPG - a group that has since been rebranded as the Syrian Democratic Forces. They haven't even existed until 2011. and the start of the Syrian civil war, their only contact with the PKK was established during the common fight against ISIS - similar to how the only cordial contact between the Peshmerga and the PKK took place at the same time and for the same reason - the enemy of my enemy. Inspite of this, the Erdogan regime has used these contacts as an excuse to start attacking primarily (although not exclusively) the YPG, in the process of carving out parts of the Syrian territory with the goal of occupying them.
Are you aware of these things?
Truspace@reddit
No, your education system has made you paranoid and you persistently double down on every idiotic policy coming out of Erdo's administration. Voices calling him out are drowned to keep you paranoid.
Foreign-Scratch-7735@reddit
hes danish bruh. and yes, there is
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
LastHomeros is a well-known Turkish LARPer. He used be Kurdish apparently, but then changed to Danish.
I mean, at least he could put a dual flag like me, lol.
LastHomeros@reddit
The heck are you talking about? I am neither Turkish nor Kurdish but it’s true that I do live in Denmark. That’s all you need to know.
SOHONEYSAME@reddit
same for a "Dutch" guy here.
(generally, when u see a European person "supporting" Turkey over Greece, always look up posting history, 90% of the time it's a Turk).
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
You're right about this, but even though I'm an Eurosceptic person that published articles on Turkish subs in order to stop Pro-Europeanism in Turkey. I must say that I don't want to be unjust with all Europe and vilify a large group of people.
In Europe, there are countries who were nice with us and would actually react negative if Greece attacks Turkey. But they are not the majority.
abki12c@reddit
Danish haahahaha. More like Turk living in Denmark hiding his identity behind the Danish flag. I've seen him make many pro Turkish posts and comments. No sane Danish guy would be so pro Turkey or think about Turkey at all
HansenHSV@reddit
I wonder why.
LastHomeros@reddit
Cry me a river
Interesting_Piano_99@reddit
It's combined anti-muslim and anti-Turkish in synergy.
Voldypants_420@reddit
Not really the case from what I've observed. There's a huge amount of edgy byzaboos and "historians" on socmed, still clinging onto medieval times and crusades. It'd still be the majority of the Europeans but not 90% for sure. Most people simply wouldn't care about either side.
On the other hand, "iğneyi kendimize, çuvaldızı başkasına" as we say, we are here to blame a bit as well. Our government tends to create a ton of enemies to create the "evil outside powers" image rather than trying to hold good relations and cooperation. This clinging to power combined with our current dictatorial image doesn't help either.
RestaurantBoring417@reddit
Edgy Byzaboos are like 0.0001% of people in Europe. The real reason you are so disliked here is because your government and your most vocal ultranationalists give people reason to do that.
nggaball@reddit
If Greece was the one invading and committing massacres, I doubt anyone would support them. Also, extreme politically charged byzaboos are really rare. You should have more faith than that In Europe (especially as a Turk, since Europe likes Turkey overall, because of it's geopolitical significance in an unpredictable America world).
Sekalino@reddit
Europe does NOT “like” Turkey mate they just need us. Turkey is in a unique position with Europe, we stand between them and the “barbaric Middle East” so Europe would like us to act as a shield for them. Also the Turkish diaspora is quite large so politicians (usually left leaning ones) will also try to cater to the Turkish minority in their country. Lastly we have a kick ass military when compared to most European countries which the Europeans would very much like to have on their side if war were to break out between Europe and Russia.
Europe despite all the points I made barely tolerates Turkey and constantly tries to keep us close but not too close. And quite frankly I don’t buy that this is all because of Erdogan, he’s just a convenient excuse for Europeans.
nggaball@reddit
This isn't an insult, but your indoctrinated af!
Sekalino@reddit
I’m a diaspora Turk born and raised in Germany I’m just relaying the realities I’ve witnessed first hand.
Explain to me why you think Turks are liked in Europe, present your case and defeat me with your arguments. You absolutely can change my mind.
Voldypants_420@reddit
I'm a Turk currently living in Athens. Travelled all around Europe and The USA, including Germany. Except for maybe a couple of instances in 20+ years, I have never experienced bad treatment just because I'm a Turk. I'm not saying they love us but more often than not an average Joe doesn't care about where you're from, they just want to mind their own business. Yes, there's bad sentiment about us and yes, a good chunk of it is rooted in history and racism, but we cannot deny the fact that we also pull people's opinion to a negative space with our behavior and how our politicians position themselves. For example the only time I ever had business with police and juicidal courts was due to a Turk assaulting me for money, in Greece.
Sekalino@reddit
Absolutely I’m with you. I agree that the average European doesn’t spend a lot of time thinking about Turks good or bad. With that being said, when it comes to treatment of Turkish people in Europe, it’s most of often than not simply: respect the local laws rules and norms and you’re gonna have no problems. This is not them liking us tho this is just tolerance and them adhering to their own laws.
Look I’m not trying to occupy the victim position and act like we are perfect and it’s those dam racist Europeans all the time. I was simply stating that the average European when asked to think about their impression of Turkey will tell you it’s unfavorable and that European-Turkish cooperation is completely and utterly transactional in nature.
nggaball@reddit
This ×100.
nggaball@reddit
First of all, I said Europe (the countries) like Turkey. Whether that's because of cultural factors or political ones, I think that statement is true. And tbh I don't think the European people (the vast majority anyway) even have an opinion on Turkey or Turkish people at all. Now, while I don't know anything about you or your experiences, I'm sure you've faced racism in Germany because of your ethnicity. That's terrible, obviously. But, I'm almost certain that Europeans in general don't hate Turkish people. The reason I think that is because, for instance, there would have been much more backlash against Turkey when they occupied northern Cyprus. Like sanctions, downright denial of EU membership, no buying weapons from them, and other things. Another reason is because I doubt so many Turks would be allowed to or even want to move to Europe. There are several other examples like that.
Sekalino@reddit
You’re right you were talking about countries and when it comes to countries I think it’s way worse tbh. All the points you listed are valid but where we disagree is why Europe showed/shows leniency toward Turkey. You think it’s because they do actually kinda like us, I think it’s because they know they can’t afford to antagonize us or that it’s MUCH more beneficial for them to engage in limited cooperation with Turkey rather than branding us an enemy.
They don’t want us (the country) around but out of pragmatism they tolerate Turkey. Although to be honest it’s not like Turkey is perfect either.
Nevertheless I think that Turkey is just useful to Europe.
As for the people it’s of course very different. Racists exist in every country just like good people. I’m not going to judge an entire people by the actions of a couple of their nutjobs. With that being said I think there is this implicit hierarchy of nationalities in Germany in an Orwellian sense where some foreigners are more foreign than others. In that hierarchy Turks are not among the Europeans. This I can vouch for.
Jamesanitie@reddit
They dont hate the turks but they love the greeks, so if a hypothetical war started between the two you will see huge backing to greece. Simple as. Doesnt matter who is right or wrong.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
I wish we had nukes and low inflation so that we wouldn't have to be close with the people who want to eradicate our existence
nggaball@reddit
Why do you think they want to eradicate your existence???? Noone sane is saying that!
Gloomy-Statement-193@reddit
lol you should be thankful we are not monsters, because if were racist shitbags like yourself your people wouldn't even exist
Jamesanitie@reddit
Brother the governments will support Greece just like they are currently supporting Israel barring a few exceptions.
Trip-Advisor@reddit
almost as if the internet is not real life...
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
I live in Belgium for 7 years and share with you the scene that I directly observed.
Tribalecho@reddit
no we are not like your people who celebrated after Ukraine got invaded, after October 7th and many other terrorist attacks we suffered by the hand of muslims...handing out candy and posting it on social media was a brilliant idea
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
70% of Turkish population has their family became victim of the Russian aggression during 19th and 20th century. The opinions on Russia is inherently negative and only some people who became so Anti-European that they came to a situation to support everything against them sincerely supports Russians.
The loss that the Russian Empire caused us in Caucasus and Balkans are still in our mind and the majority of our people have a tenderness for Ukraine. Ukraine also protected the Turks of their country and saw them as fellow Ukrainians.
However, it is true that the majority of our population is also anti-Israel.
Tribalecho@reddit
Okay, I should have specified the people that were celebrating and posting were turks/muslims that live in the EU and hate us.
But no one here in any country (except Greece and Armenia) will be celebrating an attack or even massacres, probably you have never met anyone in Europe except edgy teens online that were probably from the US thinking they are Greek.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Are you Greek brother? I really don't understand what we celebrated here.
freespirit2026@reddit
yet they still lose again lmao
puzzledpanther@reddit
Nationalists, winning wars in their minds.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Greeks are the Kemal Kılıçdaroğlu of Balkans.
Fuzzy_User@reddit
Is 90% of Europe celebrating Israel attacking Gaza?
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
In Europe, we are the Israel.
We took away the Anatolia, the cradle of Christian Civilization, we took away their capital. Because most of the Europeans see Turkey as a lost land, rightfully belong to the White European Christian Civilization stolen by orcs.
Fuzzy_User@reddit
Most Europeans aren't hanging onto the now six-hundred-years-old capture of Constantinople.
If they are, they're scumbag fascists and the rest of us want them to cut their mouths off. Crusade guys are cringe in 2026. You've hung out in these /pol/ spaces for so long that you think the fuck up freaks that push these arguments are respectable, worthy people that are worth talking to.
Every_Mobile3968@reddit
Greece attacking Turkey is a suicidal idea. It's not going to happen. Just theoretical nonsense.
Celalmete@reddit
Massacres? Greek?
Dizzy-Scientist4782@reddit
I doubt Turkey would sit and do nothing in such case. A war would be declared and massacres would be commited by both sides.
P.S. Enough with that victim card already lol
lonelystar7@reddit
Celebrating would be the wrong word here ( except loud extreme right wing minority who is racist ). But EU probably wouldn't do much about it other than use diplomacy to try achieve peace. Also Greece would probably lose, Turkey has more developed army.
If Turkey attacks Greece though, EU has clause that mandates EU countries to come to defense of a member country that's being attacked. It is even more demanding than NATO's article 5. So there is no choice, they have to get militariliy involved if Turkey attacks first.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Turkey will never and ever start it. If a war happens, Turkey won't start it.
kostas_vo@reddit
Believing that your country (formerly an empire that invaded countless regions and peoples) is absolutely in the right and would never start an offensive war is dangerous. No one should fall for propaganda, wherever it may originate.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Bro, I'm anti-war already. How did you conclude that?
Gloomy-Statement-193@reddit
wtf are you smoking
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
I live in Belgium for 7 years also have some ties in other Western countries thanks to the business of my uncle.
My observation is 90% of Europeans want Turkey to be invaded and Turks to be unalived.
Temporary-Aside5306@reddit
Completely made up hypothetical. Whereas Turkey has commited a couple of genocides in the last hundred years
Capital_Kiwi_5118@reddit
Greece has done its fair share of ethnic cleansing too dont worry
Temporary-Aside5306@reddit
Allegations of it during Greece's war of independence 100 years further back sure, hardly the same thing when one is under the circumstance of trying to free yourself from an oppressor and the other is doing it to your own population, and also hardly the same thing when the Turkish genocides against Greeks and Armenians is within living memory of relatives to the victims today
bugog@reddit
“Your genocides are more genocides than my genocides” mkay.
Temporary-Aside5306@reddit
Never said that. I'm talking about emotional feelings that would make people side with one country or another. One side as accusations during their own independence with no realistic living memory of it. The other with living memory and out of purely genocidal aims. Not to mention turkey invading Cyprus and constant threats against Greece. Can't blame people for not liking them, it's all Turkeys actions which result in that feeling
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Turkey doesn't constantly threaten Greece.
Erdoğan said "We can suddenly come one night" after Greece started to arm the neighboring islands.
Temporary-Aside5306@reddit
You tend to want to arm islands when you have a neighbour who consistently questions your sovereignty. Not forgetting turkey has threatened to cut any undersea cables linking Greece and Cyprus, as if they have any right to do that. While also not forgetting turkey still don't recognise Cyprus as a country. And turkey have threatened war if Greece exercises a legal right under the UN law of the season convention. So I don't know what you call it when you foreshadow war and proclaim you will interfere between projects of two other sovereign nations that don't relate to turkey but I'd call that pretty threatening
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Turkey does it because for years it defended 2 state solution in Cyprus. In 2004 we even gave up on it and accepted to withdraw from the island if a federation that recognizes Turkish autonomy gets established. It was accepted by the Turks and rejected by Greeks.
Temporary-Aside5306@reddit
Defends a two state solution that you created by invading in the first place. Cyprus was just fine as a complete state before. Always an excuse why your imperialism is ok
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Cyprus was a state where the Turkish minority became a target for a decade and Greece openly intervened to the politics.
We took 30% of the island as a compensation for the lost Turkish lives.
If there was an American community in Cuba and they killed Americans for 10 years, USA would take a part of Cuba as compensation don't you think?
Temporary-Aside5306@reddit
That inter communal violence meaning around 360 Turkish Cypriots and 170 greek Cypriots being killed in the decade before, as opposed to Turkey then killing 4000 greek Cypriots civilians, displacing 150,000 people from the north, another case of ethnic cleansing, and performing settler colonialism with mainland Turks. Not to mention the human rights violations, widespread rapes by Turkish soldiers and torture. And turkey still occupies the island illegally under international law. You are not the good guys in this
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
There were no rapes.
However, those lost lives were a compensation for our lost lives.
Balkan countries wiated for 500 years and as long as they became independent, they attacked Turkish villagers. Then they took their revenge.
We also did wait for 10 years and then we also took our revenge. What is just for them is also just for us. We used our right of revenge.
ze4lex@reddit
I dont think 90% of Europe is celebrating what israel is doing so I dount they will celebrate if Greece is the one doing it.
Drstermak85@reddit
For west arab and turk are not exactly same. Turk is eternal enemy and arab is puppet of them. They will never see turk as a legitimate nation, ethnicity or country. Its technically anti christ for christian world. All of western world grew up with 1000 years old generational trauma againts turks. If you dehumanise any nation enough you will do not really care about genocides happened on them or ethnic cleansing againts them
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
you are underestimating antiturkism in the "west".
Angel_of_the_Light@reddit
It's hard to say. Greece have same religion as us. But 20% of our country is Muslims. But we like that Turkey isn't gay, and don't hate our people, also for me non alcohol is plus too. Also 10% of our people is Turkic people. But Russia isn't exactly Europe.
MasterNinjaFury@reddit
Most Greek people like Russia and Russians. Okay yes post 2022 is changing that but trust me before 2022 their was a lot more open russian supportes in the Greek circles. Even now the prophecies still see Russia will play a big part in Greece's restoration and etc
Angel_of_the_Light@reddit
That's so wrong. Modern Russia have no common with Greece.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
When I said 90%, I didn't talk for everybody of course.
We are so lucky that in Europe, there are some nations that respected us, accepted us and even protected us. We LOVE those nations and we are forever greatful for them.
For the reason that we had Russian Empire as a common enemy, Ukraine accepted Turkic people as their fellow Ukrainians. To an extent that they accepted 1944 Crimean Tatar Genocide as their national diseaster and in 2016, they sent Jamala (she's half Turk) to Eurovision. They literally won Eurovision 2016 with a half Turkish song.
Romania became the only country in the Balkans that didn't ethnically cleansed it Turkic population. Not only that, Romania opened its arms for Tatar refugees from Crimea.
These countries became our heros and we'll forever keep them in our hearts for the good deeds that they've done for us.
In the situation of being invaded, there will be some nations in Europe that will be in favor of us, and there will be some nations in the Islamic world that will be against us.
lkt213@reddit
Maybe you have meant Armenians instead of Europeans?
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
both 😃
monk_paparov@reddit
by the means that it will end of huge massacre of greek people as well, but Europe will be mostly happy as you said
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
There's no ongoing massacre between Turkey-Greece rn. It would end nothing.
monk_paparov@reddit
for rn, yeah 👍
int23_t@reddit
For eternity not for rn.
Seriously there is no hate between the two people it's just always governments funding hate for their own political agenda fuck them.
SOHONEYSAME@reddit
except Greece is no threatening Turkey.
if Turkey tries to annex Greek territory, what do u think will happen?
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Some people think today's world like the middle ages I think.
int23_t@reddit
That's not going to happen. Erdogan is just a clown.
I haven't seen someone that actually wants to conquer any Greek asset just "it's a shame we lost the islands"
SOHONEYSAME@reddit
is this a joke? lol.
literally 12 hours ago on this a sub Turk was saying "he will visit the islands as a soldier" (the comment is removed, now).
MANY MORE examples like this.
there's people in Turk subs posting maps w/ Turkey controlling half of Greece, & in the comments people unironically support it.
I'm not saying everyone is like that but it's very clear MANY r.
& if Turkey tries anything, we will fight back, (even I, all of us who love our country will contribute).
& u will lose.
int23_t@reddit
Oh I meant IRL, not on internet, internet has lots of trolls.
SOHONEYSAME@reddit
I (& all of us) support diplomacy & international law.
meanwhile, Turk government (& some people). don't.
monk_paparov@reddit
I didn’t see any Turkish person hates any Greek to be honest but this is Reddit and my comment assume the reflection of comments from other side, we called each other komsu, but hate is there for real, let it be like this, I just couldn’t stand raw hate toward my ethnicity, I saw lots of them with lots of upvote in this thread and it’s kinda disappointing
int23_t@reddit
Fuck reddit and governments and hate. I kinda want to ask first time(Raw hate for Turks on Reddit is way too common and they almost always get upvoted a lot) but idk, doesn't resonate to me.
But IRL hate for your people definitely isn't common here. And in my experience hate for my people in Greece isn't common either but my experience consists of Rhodes and Lesvos... It's just an imaginary thing governments create to boost popularity IMO. And it's a shame we let them do that...
Ok_Huckleberry4563@reddit
same way turkey has celebrated all the genocides throughout the years?
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
We celebrate 19 may since it is the day that our liberation movement has begun. We were a country as big as Jordan with Sevres then we gained 800,000 km2 of land. Not a genocide.
Ok_Huckleberry4563@reddit
The pontics would beg to differ
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Most of the Pontics were deported by the Kemalist Army, the massacres were not in an extent to identify it as a genocide. Plus it has nothing to do with 19 may.
Pontic Massacres started in the beginning of 1900s and lasted until the end of WW1. 350K of people died in a decade. If it is a genocide, massacre of millions of Balkan Turks during the 19th century can also be identified as a genocide.
Ok_Huckleberry4563@reddit
acting a victim and "oh poor us eu hates us" but committing genocide against pontics AND armenians, while also illegally occupying cyprus is wild
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
https://www.un.org/en/genocide-prevention/definition
Article II
In the present Convention, genocide means any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such:
Genocide according to the international law means: Intentionally im to destroy a certain unarmed, unprovocative group.
The decree that started what we call the Armenian Genocide is given by Talat Pasha. It's copies are still online and displayed in many projects about the Armenian Genocide.
It is called Tehcir Fermanı which means Decree of Deportation. Which commands to deport Armenians from Anatolia to the Levant. Armenians of Istanbul, Bursa and Edirne are exempted. Word "itlaf" basically mean "eliminate, unalive" is not present in the decree it only commands Tehcir (deportation). Which means there is no intention to destroy a group. That's why the UN still didn't recognize Armenian Genocide.
You can google Temporary Law of Deportation and examine the PDF files yourself published by numerous universities.
If deportation followed by death marches which people die on road by attacks, disease and hunger is a genocide, which I don't object, then the loss of Balkan Turks during the 19th century is also a genocide.
A decision that aims to put an end on a group existence is genocide. This is the common consensus of the international law. Like being murder "the unlawful and unjustified killing of one human being by another, committed with malice aforethought" this can be argumented of course. But in current reality, we have these contexts to define an act.
1915 Decree and following decisions always aimed Deportation and people died in death marches, where they had to walk for kilometers. However, the absolute decision was to relocate them as the official document which is also accepted by the Armenian government states.
Monterenbas@reddit
That’s Erdogan « diplomacy » for you.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Even if Turkey was as democratic as Switzerland. The thought's of 90% of Europeans wouldn't have been different. They'd still support the idea of Turkey being attacked and millions of Turks being unalived by Greeks.
Monterenbas@reddit
Who knows? Maybe you should give that a try before whining.
SiofraRiver@reddit
Pure projection.
Druidgr-93@reddit
Bro, young people in Greece hate the politicians more than to do an aggressive war to another country.
int23_t@reddit
So the same as Turkey, neat.
r/hellenoturkism in me is spreading
Unhappy_Olive2982@reddit
You are ridiculous
anythingcirclejerker@reddit
Lol bro
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
It’s not lol bro when it’s true. We talk about nato this and that. If we faced a russian invasion, I would be surprised if western europe didn’t join them. It wouldn’t be beyond thoughts and prayers level of help if it was any sort of help. And if there was any actual help, it wouldn’t be because they care about us but rather they dont want russians to expand
Umak30@reddit
Small correction.
Primarily the USA. About 50% of Reddit traffic comes from the US. 5% from the UK. 5% from India. 5% from Canada. 4% from Australia. 3% from Germany. 3% from France. 3% from Brazil.
So the biggest share from the US, and other Western countries are certainly more prevelant than non-western countries, but still small. like there are more Indians on Reddit, than Western Europeans ( minus UK ).
bugog@reddit
If you exclude US, if you exclude UK, if you count the western countries one by one instead of cumulative entity, yeah why not if you wanna make sense with your correction.
iddivision@reddit
"The Turk has no friend but the Pakistanis"
dontneedit000@reddit
Don't forget our greatest friend, Azerbaijan.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Biggest ally of Israelis bro…
dontneedit000@reddit
Ee knk? filistinliler ermenistanı savunduğu için Azerbaycanlılar da israili savunmuştu üstelik israil yüzünden kan kardeşini mi satıcan
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Amk filistin devleti mi var şuanda. Adamların götü boktan çıkmıyor ki amk israillileri yüzünden. Batının gözünde iyi gözükmek için 1 yerde ermenistanın yanındayız dediler. İsarilliler bunu aldı, azerbeycanın her yerine soktu. Her yerde propagandasını yaptı. Adamların ülkesini bombalıyorlar, çocuklarını katlediyorlar, çokta siklerindeydi azerbeycan, ermenistan. İsrail bizim en büyük düşmanımız, “kan kardeşlerimiz” bir zahmet ittifak olmasınlar, çıkıp türkiye sonraki hedef diye bağıran bir terörist grupla(israil).
Redararis@reddit
Cuba, what’s your problem exactly? Do you think Greece is too capitalistic for you? You break Koutsoubas heart…
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
It was just one guy every time. Same for Mongolia.
NigthSHadoew@reddit
I know what the poll says but I would assume Turkey is the agressor in any Greek-Turkish war. I see what our goverment does and what other people say (Had to legit argue with friends that Turkey can’t just attack and take the islands without any other country being against us even if we promise only to take the islands and nothing else)
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
but declaring a 12 mile isnt aggression, is it?
Kindly_Scientist@reddit
oh dont worry, nato knows its a really important topic for turkey. 12nm would instantly means turkey would has 0 access to mediterranean sea. nato and almost every country knows its a casus beli (reason of war) for turkey. it wont be seen as aggressor but greece wouldn’t seen as aggressor as well. small dogfights might happen but id say some negotiations would happen pretty quick and split it to 6nm to turkey and greece by agreement would happen pretty soon without too much damage- i mean, i would hope so
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Greeks will drive the region into war. I believe it’s guaranteed at this point. They have never, and from the looks of it will never sit at the table and talk. They just want to push their maximalist demands with western support.
GrogmarktheRag@reddit
Reddit is hardly a place to find a proper representative sample. Also historically most Greco-Turkish conflicts have seen Turkey as an imperialist occupying power (thus de-facto aggressor even if Greece attacks first), for example the First Balkan War would be considered a war of liberation. This probably causes a biased sample since redditors typically know more history than average.
GrogmarktheRag@reddit
Also if it makes you feel any better, a large number of Greeks (if not most) believe the EU and NATO wouldn't help us even if we were attacked, due to all the military and economic deals with Turkey.
xevoprime@reddit
Logically they are not wrong, Turkey is much more efficient in both strategic and economic fields. This Greece/Turkey whose dick is larger debate is pointless anyway.
Adistaktos34@reddit
lol, big myth. In case of war, Turkey will feed its citizens spaghetti while Greece will receive billions of euros from Europe.
Also strategically you are in a very vulnerable position because of Kurds, Gulenists, Islamists, Erdoğanists, Kemalists, etc. A lame horse that for some reason you Turks consider a racehorse
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Literally none of those groups would support anything against the turkish nation. Except kurds of course but the separatist Kurds are like less than 1% i would say. Most kurds love their nation.
xevoprime@reddit
Do not underestimate our patriotism. When it comes to our national security we don’t care about ideology, ethnics or anything else just like the war of independence.
There is political instability yes, but it is our inside business. We would not let anyone interfere or slaughter each other because of our different views.
Also, not all the Kurds are enemies of the state, a big bunch of them loves Turkey and hates separatist movements. If you don’t believe me do some research about “Köy Korucuları”. Those are armed locals of eastern anatolian villages (mainly kurdish) turned into pseudo paramilitary organization supported by government against the pkk.
Yes we are not the perfect racehorse, we have flaws but we will not let the disasters of early 20th century repeat.
FatherMozgus@reddit
They are wrong because the EU also benefited more from relations with Russia than with Ukraine but we all know which side they chose.
xevoprime@reddit
They chose Ukraine because Russia directly threatens European borders like Poland or Baltics, Turkey doesn’t possess any threats to European security. Greece is insignificant in the big picture.
FatherMozgus@reddit
And do you think Poland or the Baltics are more significant than Russia? There is no scenario where the EU takes the side of Turkey.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
This is not a Hoi4 war. No side is gonna destroy each other. Eu “could” give up some greek islands, or some greek waters, in exchange Turkish military support.
xevoprime@reddit
I didn’t say EU will support Turkey. This is reasonable and logical choice. Turkey is far more powerful in both military, geography and economic fields. But of course EU won’t stay with logical one because Turkey is not European while Greece is.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
It would be a huge mess. I believe in the end nato would support Greece but it might be too late like the support for Bosnia.
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
It’s because eu is not a military alliance and nato doesn’t have mechanisms for internal conflicts other than providing a diplomatic channel.
GrogmarktheRag@reddit
EU used to be only an economic alliance when it was the EEC. Now it is a confederation, and it includes a mutual defense clause for all member states (Article 42.7 of the Treaty of Lisbon): https://eur-lex.europa.eu/EN/legal-content/glossary/mutual-defence-clause.html
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
Yeah it’s a clause. Clauses principles whatever have no bearing when there is not structural implementation. Cant consider eu to have a military quality because of it
GrogmarktheRag@reddit
Well the eu does have the Common Security and Defence Policy, which all members' armies participate in and which would be in charge of implementing EU response to such an event. The EU may not have an army, but it has cooperation mechanisms and a military organizational structure for this.
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
Why are you just throwing more clauses at me? Texts dont fire bullets
riquelm@reddit
sorry if I have a bit of a bias towards only side in that conflict that tried to kill my people for 600 fucking years.
Now imagine if USA have been attacking your country and your people constantly since they formed as a country in 1776. they would still not be at the half of that
Barbak86@reddit
That's only because people tend to cheer for the underdog in matches that doesn't concern them, and in this case it's Greece. There is some christian solidarity in there as well.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
This is my theory too. Plus, Greece = civilization, Turkey = kebab and kurds, in the minds of non-European non-Christian/Muslim outsiders
O_945@reddit
The biggest issue with Turkey is their antipathic leader & their increasingly authoritarian regime.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
That as well. I don’t think it’s because everybody hates Turkey. It’s mostly because of wording. It clearly states Turkey is the Attacker.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
biggest issue is only historical. race, religion are different. population isnt small.
Substratas@reddit
Why would anyone support the attacker in this scenario?
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Because most of the Europeans see Turkey as a lost land, rightfully belong to the White European Christian Civilization stolen by orcs. If Greece attacks Turkey, invade it and unalive people, Europeans will perceive it as a "struggle" between humans and non-humans.
Wooden-Trouble727@reddit
No. But we remember how Turkey started a war in Cyprus for the aim of weakening Greece and we see ongoing Turkish disrespect for borders, including frequent airforce fly overs in different Greek Islands.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
Ah yes, Turkey just woke up one day and randomly started a war. It definitely had absolutely nothing to do with the Greek Junta's fascist coup trying to annex the island 5 minutes earlier
puzzledpanther@reddit
The first intervention was justified. However the Junta had fallen, the killings has stopped, they were in the middle of peace negotiations and Turkey decides to invade and capture 1/3 of the island.
Let's not mention the thousands of settlers Turkey sent over to Cyprus in breach of international law.
Everyone but the Turks say it was an invasion but according to the Turks, everyone is wrong.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Most people don’t have any idea about the conflict. So they just support the “wests” idea. It doesn’t really mean anything.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
'The killings stopped': Tell that to the victims in the mass graves of Maratha, Santalaris, and Aloda, slaughtered in August 1974 during those exact 'peace talks.' Your leadership stalled in Geneva while EOKA-B kept besieging enclaves.
'Capturing 1/3 of the island': It's called creating a defensible perimeter. When you prove you can't live with a minority without trying to exterminate them, borders get redrawn for physical separation (later formalized by the 1975 UN Population Exchange).
'Everyone says it's an invasion': 'Everyone' also ignored the 11 years of state-sponsored ethnic cleansing against Turks before 1974. International consensus is often just geopolitical convenience. We prefer the reality where Turkish Cypriots are alive today because of that 'invasion'."*
puzzledpanther@reddit
Those massacres happened DURING the invasion.
EOKA B was considered a terrorrist organization... they even killed Greek Cypriots in their attempt to sieze power.
Are you going to talk about the massacres and ethnic cleansing caused by the invading Turkish army?
Israel would be proud of your choice of words.
They did a really shitty job of trying to "ethnically cleanse" a minority for 11 years and failing to do so then...
Jamesanitie@reddit
"Those massacres happened DURING the invasion."
Then you justify the massacre? The invasion was there because of the massacres before hand, imagine how much more massacres would have happened if they were not there?
Your last comment is upset they failed to cleanse them.
Good to know.
puzzledpanther@reddit
Not at all. I was nerely saying that the massacred happened because the Turkish army invaded.
No. The Intervention was there for that. The invasion happened so they could grab land.
The hostilities had stopped, the Junta had fallen and there were peace negotiations.
Do you know how many massacres happened because of the Turkish army?
You're just reading whatever you want by now.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
Claiming 'we didn't ethnically cleanse you because you didn't all die' is a new low, even for Greek nationalist propaganda. Turkish Cypriots survived because they armed themselves in ghettos, not because your fascists were merciful. And trying to pass off EOKA-B as just some 'rogue terrorists' when they literally executed a coup and BECAME the government in 1974 is hilarious.
Also, save your dumb Israel comparisons for someone who doesn't know history. Israel occupies to expand; Turkey intervened, drew a hard line to stop you from filling more mass graves, and hasn't fired a bullet or moved a border in 50 years. You lost a war of annihilation that your own side started
puzzledpanther@reddit
Do you have the numbers of victims from both sides over these 11 years (with sources obviously)?
I am not a fascist neither am I a Cypriot.
Not sure how you came to that conclusion when I said: EOKA B was considered a terrorrist organization... they even killed Greek Cypriots in their attempt to sieze power.
You need to read what is written to you instead of fantasizing fictional opponents.
No. Turkey firstly intervened. Then Invaded to expand. Massacred thousands of Greek Cypriots and resulted in 160.000 civilians leaving their homes and their land (also 51.000 Turkish Cypriots from the south). Then imported thousands of Turkish settlers from the mainland in breach of international law.
The way you as a Turkish nationalist talk about it would make any zionist proud.
How about both Greece and Turkey leave the island to the Cypriots? Are you willing to remove your army and the thousands of settlers and let Cypriots rule their island? Of course you aren't. Because you're a colonizer force.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
Let's look at neutral, international records. According to the widely documented history of the 1963-1964 'Bloody Christmas' massacres (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bloody_Christmas_(1963) and historian Pierre Oberling's demographic records, that period alone resulted in the deaths of 364 Turkish Cypriots and 174 Greek Cypriots. More importantly, the UN Secretary-General's official report, Document S/5950 (Official UN Archive: Document Viewer ), officially recorded that 25,000 to 30,000 Turkish Cypriots were forced to abandon 103 villages, taking refuge in besieged enclaves that made up merely 3% of the island. Forcing a minority out of their homes and confining them to blockaded ghettos under the threat of violence is the textbook definition of ethnic cleansing.
And regarding your attempt to call me a 'Zionist'... The irony is absolutely palpable. You are trying to use that as an insult against a Turk, while the Greek Cypriot administration and Greece are literally Israel’s closest strategic, military, and energy allies in the Eastern Mediterranean. Your side actively conducts joint military drills with the IDF and buys their weaponry. If anyone is making them proud, it's the state you are defending. Don't throw stones from a glass house.
Regarding your link to the Solomos Solomou incident in 1996: Let's be brutally honestthat is a textbook case of 'fuck around and find out'. The man bypassed UN peacekeepers, crossed into a highly militarized buffer zone, and actively climbed a military flagpole to tear down a foreign army's flag. What exactly is the expected military protocol when a hostile actor attempts to pull down a flag at a heavily guarded border post? Confetti? He wasn't a victim of an 'invasion' expanding its borders; he was a victim of his own extreme nationalist stupidity. A Darwin Award moment at a military border does not change the fact that there has been zero systemic inter-communal violence since 1974.
Finally, you asked a crucial question: 'How about both Greece and Turkey leave the island to the Cypriots? Are you willing to remove your army and let Cypriots rule their island?'
I absolutely agree with you. In fact, we already voted on exactly that.
It was called the 2004 UN Annan Plan (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2004_Cypriot_Annan_Plan_referendums). The internationally backed plan proposed a unified, independent Cyprus, a shared government, and the withdrawal of foreign troops. 65% of Turkish Cypriots voted YES to demilitarize and let Cypriots rule their island together. 76% of Greek Cypriots voted NO. We were entirely willing to leave the island to a united Cypriot government; your side overwhelmingly rejected it because your leadership refused to share power equitably. You cannot overwhelmingly vote against a UN unification plan and then cry on the internet about being a divided island. We agreed to your exact proposal 22 years ago; you were the ones who refused it
puzzledpanther@reddit
Where did you find the "3%" from? I cannot find it.
I agree that losing your homes and having to move by force is ethnic cleansing. Very sad thing.
Do you also agree that the Turkish military did ethnic cleansing by displacing 160.000 Greek Cypriots?
You can justify it in any crude way you like... but you said the Turks didn't fire a bullet.. they did, and they killed a person who was trying to take down a flag from the buffer zone.
No you didn't. Turkish military wasn't going to completely withdraw though. The Annan plan was heavily in favour of the Turkish side. It was never going to be accepted by Greek Cypriots for numerous reasons:
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annan_Plan#Reasons_for_rejection_as_explained_by_the_Greek_Cypriots
I know you are heavily biased judging from your language but even you cannot help but accept some of the reasons and understand why it was never going to be voted for.
You also seem to refuse to address the thousands of illegal settlers Turkey has sent over to the occupied lands.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
I want to be completely sincere I deeply sympathize with the Greek Cypriot families who lost their homes in 1974, and I retract my previous harsh tone about the 1996 incidentevery civilian loss is a genuine heartbreak. To answer your specific question about the '3%' figure: it comes from historical documentation and UN reports regarding the 'enclave period' (1963-1974). It doesn't refer to the population, but to the land area. After abandoning over 100 villages, Turkish Cypriots (who made up ~18% of the population) were forced to retreat into heavily blockaded enclaves that collectively covered only about 3% of the island's territory. Understanding why the mass displacement of 1974 happened requires acknowledging this preceding decade of confinement. The resulting demographic shift was a mutual tragedy, eventually formalized by both leaderships in the 1975 Vienna Agreement. And later, the Turkish side accepted painful territorial concessions in the UN Annan Plan just to finally end this, an opportunity that was unfortunately rejected. True reconciliation means acknowledging each other's full history, not just the chapters that start in 1974.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
Unfortunately, bad things happen in wars, and the burden of these falls on civilians. My personal opinion for the future of Cyprus is that both the Greek side and the Turkish side should live in peace. But this is such a complicated issue that it is really hard to find a way out, because both sides inevitably have aspects that conflict with each other
puzzledpanther@reddit
The vast majority of Greeks are against what Israel is doing. The Greek government is very pro-israel because they need them as an ally. Maybe because we have an aggressive neighbour 8 times our size whose president has numerous times, threatened to attack us?
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Whatever helps you sleep at night bro
Jamesanitie@reddit
Get your facts straight.
Turkey was a guarantor and had approval to land troops in cyprus following massacres of Turkish cypriots which the Turkish government at the time pleaded many times for the west to intervene before it gets messier.
They did not give a fuck and the result is what it is today. Turkey is overstaying their welcome maybe but they have no reason to trust the greeks and cypriots to leave the turkish cypriots lives in their hands. They are also benefiting from northern cyprus for sure no denying that but painting the Turks as pure evil invaders is disingenious and damn right propaganda.
puzzledpanther@reddit
Get YOUR facts straight. The first time they intervened every agreed with it.. even Greeks. Then Junta fell and both parties were in the middle of peace negotiations when Turkey invaded and captured the north part of the island. Everyone agrees the first intervention was justified.. noone but Turkey agrees the invasion was justified.
Let's not mention the thousands of settlers Turkey sent over to Cyprus in breach of international law.
So you think an EU country will suddently start killing it's own populace?
rofl.. when everyone in the world agrees an invasion was an invasion, maybe you're the one gobbling down propaganda.
Jamesanitie@reddit
When did the Turks invade? 5 days after greek junta coup d'etat.
The junta was the reason they invaded. The reason junta failed was because the Turkish army invaded to prevent further massacres.
What the fuck are they teaching you?
Granted Turks overstayed as I mentioned in my reply but the fact is and still remains to this day, the main reason of invasion was not because "Hurr durr turks are out to get us they are bad people" but genuine concern for the Turkish cypriots.
The settlers were the cypriots who ran to Turkey after the rising tensions in 60's.
Why should Turkey trust that the greek cypriots will not cause grief to Turkish cypriots?
This debate goes both ways and will never end until all 3 countries involved stop fucking clinging onto the past but pride is too much for all three involved. Closest was the UN deal Annan but both parties had their issues with it.
I've said my piece. Excuse the foul language but I am gettinf fed up of the Tr/Gr bullshit thay ultimately is gonna end up a dick measuring contest for politicians and life is still gonna continue the way it is vause all fucking politicians are corrupt.
puzzledpanther@reddit
There was an intervention and then there was an invasion AFTER the Junta had fallen.
What are they teaching you?
Ethnic cleansing a local population and you distill it down to "overstayed".
Bullshit. Thousands of mainland Turks came and settled on the island in the houses owned by Crypriot Greeks. Even The Turkish Cypriots admit this. It's even mentioned in the Annan plan.
Why would they not? Cyprus is not in the same state it was back then. It's an EU member state. Do you expect an EU country to start killing it's own population?
Greek Cypriots are the ones who want a united island (Turkish Cypriots as well afaik) and will not accept it divided. It's Turkey that wants a seperate state.
Let's be honest, it vastly favoured Turkish Cypriot side and Annan knew the Greek side would never vote for it... but they were out of time and thought they would at least give it a try. Of course (sadly) it failed...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Annan_Plan#Reasons_for_rejection_as_explained_by_the_Greek_Cypriots
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I posted this so maybe Turks can see it and change their ways.
It seems like I've been counterproductive, as Turks are becoming even more nationalist and they keep spouting bullshit, lol.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
In 2024 a Greek bot came to Datça which is in our borders, landed in the beach with the excuse of "chasing a fishing boat" and come back to their lands after openly violated our borders.
Nothing happened.
Turkey never has done such a thing, if it did, it already would have been in the news everywhere and those who didn't give a sh*t when Greeks did it would actually react.
puzzledpanther@reddit
Imagine actually believing this shit. Most Europeans don't give a shit about all that stuff. The only contact they have with Turkey is having nice memories from vacations.
If you honestly believe that shit you write you really need to go out and travel a bit.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
There appears to be a lot of people of that type in Reddit. That may be where he got the idea from. But as a Turk in diaspora, i can confirm, no normal people don’t really care. I would say 90% of the population don’t even know about the history between 2 nations.
Few-Audience9921@reddit
It's a siege mentality that has allowed Turkish military industry to grow no matter what. If it works it works. If we are wrong then no harm done, but if we are right?
Tribalecho@reddit
LIES!!! We demand reconquista!!! jk you are right, no one cares
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Thats like 0.01% of the population. It’s 2026 no normal human being thinks like that. Reddit doesn’t represent reality.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Yeah i believe the results mostly because of wording.
Livid-Rip-8304@reddit
As a Turk. I think they will blame to us. Such as other things...
YogurtclosetSad9472@reddit
Well it seems some would support them no matter what...
Savings_Dragonfly806@reddit
Keep in mind, those were opinions of Redditors, with governments that's a different story.
Current-Tough7084@reddit
greece has better foreign relations, turkey tries to play all sides and comes out losing, they try to play russians, arabs and the westerners and all despise them, greece has decided to be on the westerners side and all seem to be on greece's side. Greece also is one of a few countries in europe to not be atheist or agnostic in a majority sense or nig margin, this indirectly gets support from othet christian nations and notably muslim ones who hate turkey.
Not to mention that turkey historically has been a very bad oppressor and ally, whether that be during ww1, the crimean war or literally now.
Im albanian and i personally pick greece, yeah we have our problems but by far we hate turks more.
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Whatever you believe bro
Savings_Dragonfly806@reddit
For the last part, could it also be that you have relatives here in Greece?
Current-Tough7084@reddit
no, historically turks and greeks have done us wrong, just that greeks didnt occupy us for 500 years.
Also greece is like our second biggest trade partner and greeks and albanians generally tend to visit each other countries like albanians in mykonos (sorry if i pronounced that wrong) or greeks in ksamil and sarande. Greece in my opinion has been done wrong through history by turks, brits, french germans and italians and for being the cradle of western civilisation it deserves better.
Despite never visiting greece i do want to visit it somedays, crete alone has so much id like to see. If we ever join the eu then corfu would literally be a canoe away.
SOHONEYSAME@reddit
Greece Albania relations is the (actual) "love hate" one that Turks portray the Greek Turk to be.
vast majority of Greeks dislike Turkey. that's undeniable, & backed up by polls.
Turks that visit r considered respectful "cashing cows" for tourism purposes.
there's no "special relationship" or anything like that.
but Albanians can be found across Greece (some had worked even in the most remote islands) & majority have integrated, it's different.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
"vast majority of Greeks dislike Turkey. that's undeniable, & backed up by polls."
"Turks that visit r considered respectful "cashing cows" for tourism purposes."
"there's no "special relationship" or anything like that."
that is it. there are still some turks who havent grasped the truth in these two sentences.
Few-Audience9921@reddit
The fact that neither of you understand what this "special relationship" actually means tells me you are both from a blue and white flagged country in the mediterranean, but not Greece 😄
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
ben tam olarak "türkün türkten başka dostu yoktur" kafasında biri değilim. ama batı dünyasından asla tek bir dostumuzun olamayacağının farkındayım, buna gerek de yok zaten. özel hayatımda da milletin götünde gezmeyi hayati birşey olmadıkça asla yapmam, ülkemin ve halkın da hep birilerinin peşinde koşmasını, hep birilerine şirin gözükme derdinde olmasını istemiyorum, çünkü bu olunca ucu benim gibi insanlara da dokunuyor, bizim gibiler o tipler yüzünden sebepsizce aşağılanıyor. sadece batıya değil, herhangi bir yere de "saar saar" çekenlerden nefret ederim.
Few-Audience9921@reddit
Let's use english so people understand us. You are extremely confused about what people mean if you agree with this agent. It's not that Greece is our friend (or is western for that matter) but that we keep being pulled back together for various reasons despite our best attempts to look separate.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
which various reasons lol? i think everything is progressing as it should in this matter. it is incredibly valuable to hear what i am trying to say from someone on the other side. that is what i am trying to say.
Few-Audience9921@reddit
Lmfao, come out losing in which conflict? We've practically won every single proxy war, or froze it in favor of our party.
Foreign-Scratch-7735@reddit
the crimean war? when the russians attacked turkey they were the opressor? okay pal
Current-Tough7084@reddit
no lmao do you even know why the crimean war started? Because russian iterests clashed with British and French interest in the region.
Russians wanted bulgaria with sea access to the ionian sea whilst Britain and france wanted a modern greek country. They came into an understanding where bulgwria would become a pseudo-independent state, just a very autonomous region in the ottoman empire, whilst greece became a state just around atheens. Before the war nobody was happy. Some details about the ottomans are fuzzy in my mind right now, but if i remenebr correctly then the ottomans gave napoleon the third the title of protector of christians in the ottoman empire and the russian tsar understandingly got mad as one, he held the title until then, and two majority of christians in the ottoman empire were orthodox whilst napoleon was a catholic. Kickstarting the crimean war.
The war literally started by turkey trying to play both sides.
YesGameNolife@reddit
Uhh..your opinion after I read your comment I was confused how bad an opinion it is then your last sentence explained a lot.
chato35@reddit
Komsu, tell me something.
How many of the ppl that you know will support Greek government if 🇬🇷 attacks 🇹🇷?
I don't have too many dumb friends but 100% of them will say fuck no, 50% will be on the streets.
I am from Karșiyaka (That's Kordeloi to you 😁), we are a bit different.
I had Rakı where Atatürk had rakı after the liberation of İzmir.
I also know who started the great fire.
Savings_Dragonfly806@reddit
Interesting question.
For starters, I haven't really heard anyone that would be in support of Greece attacking Turkey. Since well, we are bothered by the economy, so why go to war. So the opinion of the people will be the same as it was when Venizelos declared war in the 20s. Not in favor.
Personally, I wouldn't be in favor either. Since I know damn well how much stronger and richer your country is. So, to start a war would be a foolish move.
chato35@reddit
All wars are foolish.
I was talking about the hypothetical.
Dunno you the downvotes tho?
Remote-Snow4596@reddit
I wouldn’t expect japanese and korean to be so pro-greece ngl.
devoker35@reddit
Japan has a growing resentment against Turkey because of immigrants which are mostly Kurdish origin.
SiofraRiver@reddit
lmao yeah kurds are immigrating in large numbers to Japan.. wtf are you even talking about?
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
Bro just don’t speak about things you don’t know. Yes they are. There is a huge community of Kurdish people in japan. Compared to a turkish ore or other nationalities of course.
devoker35@reddit
I didn't say they are immigrating in large numbers. However, the majority of Turkish citizens that are seeking asylum in Japan are Kurdish origin.
annuminasguard@reddit
Actually, yes.
puzzledpanther@reddit
3.000 out of 123.000.000 population.
"large numbers"
devoker35@reddit
Japan has incredibly low number of foreigners compared to their population.
annuminasguard@reddit
Tell that to Japs. They are ones the who are complaining. They even steal the fiber cables.
puzzledpanther@reddit
The Japanese are extremely xenophobic and there's a far right sentiment inspired by MAGA growing lately.
Just because they're barking loudly that doesn't mean it's true.
3k in 123mil is by no possible comparison a large number.
annuminasguard@reddit
Oh mein brother, as i said tell that to Japanese people, it's not my problem. They are complaining about that refugees are going there in masses and destroy their culture. That's their rhetoric, not mine.
puzzledpanther@reddit
I'm replying to you because you agreed they were migrating in large numbers.
ThatOneCloneTrooper@reddit
You can do 1 google search and plenty of stuff will come up. Hell there's even a wikipedia article.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kurds_in_Japan
basedfinger@reddit
"total population 3000" doesn't seem like they're immigrating "en-masse" to me.
ThatOneCloneTrooper@reddit
The source from that is dated 2023, want to bet that numbers changed? Want to go higher or lower?
No_Tell5399@reddit
3k is a fairly large number for Japan, considering it's quite difficult to immigrate there. It's also quite likely that a lot of Kurds are considered Turks because they came from Turkey and have Turkish citizenships.
WelcomeDesigner2051@reddit
So you want to say its our kurds fault that they don't like turkey? There maybe 10.000 kurds in the whole of japan and a large number is also from iraq. Do your research, japanese people don't care about kurds. Only far right politicians use kurds as scapegoats which bringst radical islamism into their country which also doesn't make any sense because most kurds are leftists
RyokugyuFan@reddit
Well a google search is free you know? Acting with your fake ass victim card won't get you nowhere except at the door of ignorance.
I literally have seen a kurdish marriage ceremony and it was loud as fuck, and it's on the internet. Imagine being besides it?
WelcomeDesigner2051@reddit
And turkish weddings are not loud 🤣🤣 i live in germany i have been on plenty of turkish weddings its literally the same as kurdish weddings.
RyokugyuFan@reddit
I literally live near a kurdish neighborhood called Kanarya in Istanbul. Have you ever been here? The fucking ceremonies and celebrations lasts days and they don't stop the music for a minute here. Not, even for 1 MINUTE.
Every summer is the same.
WelcomeDesigner2051@reddit
I live in germany and hear turkish wedding convois with turkish flags on their cars every weekend. Just let the people celebrate special days. Even the germans dont get annoyed by these convois. Kurds are citizens of turkey just like u. And in the end we are all muslims no need for this hatred.
Tridentnutella@reddit
yeah, idk what that guy is on about.
Go in any middle sized european city, let alone metropolitan areas, and you‘ll see at least one big convoy honking and hoisting the turkish flag every month.
basedfinger@reddit
exactly this. also a lot of the anti-kurdish sentiment in japan is fueled by turkish nationalists. there is also a fringe subset of japanese nationalists who identify with turanism, and they are generally supportive of turkish nationalists. there have been cases of turkish nationalists going on twitter and pretending to be kurds in japan, posting provocative stuff.
WelcomeDesigner2051@reddit
Thank you for speaking out as someone from turkey. I am kurd from germany and I can't hear these lies anymore. Not everything involves kurds. We are an ethnic minority with no real political power outside of the KRG and maybe Rojava to some degree.
Right_Falcon_4291@reddit
It’s pathetic. Right wing Japanese people hate Muslims period yet Kurds and Turks are busy throwing mud on each other
basedfinger@reddit
Unfortunately racism runs rampant within Turkish reddit. Theres this weird synthesis of Kemalism and western alt-right ideology that seems to be popular with younger people
Dizzy-Scientist4782@reddit
Yep, blame the Kurds now 😂
abki12c@reddit
Are you sure about that
Remote-Snow4596@reddit
Well, that’s a bummer.
Tridentnutella@reddit
why wouldn't Japan allign itself more with the "western" world? They don't shy away from voicing their support for the US and NATO, of which Greece is a member of alongside Turkey. However, Turkey is a regional-power which wants to play both sides (muslim/middle eastern and western/european simulatenously) therefore they aren't considered part of the "western" world by many.
And regarding korea, I think a lot of people overestimate the bond between the two countries. Sure, there were thousands of turkish troops deployed in Korea and they did their part in assisting during the war.
But so did Canada, the UK and especially the US. And once again, the east asian countries excluding China are very keen of being part of the western world --> weaker alliance with Turkey.
But imo Korea is a bit more willing to trade and co-operate with Turkey than Japan given that they sold jet engines for turkish jets
Critical-Ad-8507@reddit
"However, Turkey is a regional power which wants to play both sides (Muslim/middle eastern and western/European simultaneously)"
This sounds like it could cause some social instability.
Remote-Snow4596@reddit
Those are people participating the poll and governments.
Tridentnutella@reddit
I mean, I am not really aware of the japanese government aiding, co-operating or supporting Turkey to such an extent that polls like this would come as a surprise.
Few-Audience9921@reddit
They would best be described as neutral, maybe fascinated with local culture.
1384d4ra@reddit
What engines?
Tridentnutella@reddit
My bad. I was thinking of turkish domestic tanks that are supposed to implement korean engines.
The turkish Kaan jets use General Motors engines for now but should use domestically produced engines in the 2030s
Impossible-Mud-3524@reddit
Korea, in particular, does not fit at all. Anyone familiar with the history of both nations knows about the deep bond they share.
Savings_Dragonfly806@reddit
For South Korea, Greece helped them in the Korean war.
8NkB8@reddit
Downvoted for speaking the truth.
Savings_Dragonfly806@reddit
The Messiah for real
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Turkey did the same. Not only that, but they've spent millions in propaganda in the country.
Obviously this didn't work much, as the average South Korean still knows almost nothing about either country. Greece = civilization, Turkey = kebab and kurds, probably.
Right_Falcon_4291@reddit
This is a pool on Reddit that’s enough justification. No need to add your racist fantasies in the mix
Early-Show2886@reddit
My Turkish ancestors most certainly did nothing to you Greeks—after all, they didn't even live in a region of the Balkans where there were any Greeks.
Remote-Snow4596@reddit
So did Turkey.
Hot_Speech900@reddit
I think Turkey did the same
SiofraRiver@reddit
Read the fucking question.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Japan has historically had a few anti-Turkish bursts (e.g. Shibusawa Eiichi, WW1 Caucasus Campaign Japanese volunteers and weapons).
Greeks might be more known in Japan because of the half-Greek race driver Sachio Fukuzawa. Every OG Japanese race-driving fan knows about him, he had a cult following back in the day.
No idea about S. Korea.
HyrkanianBlade@reddit
Also a very important Japanese literary figure, Yakumo Koizumi (Lefcadio Hearn) was also half Greek.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
You're right, I forgot. I still think Sachio would be more known to the average Japanese, as they're quite the fans of race cars.
Remote-Snow4596@reddit
I’m not sure if those are sufficient reasons for such results. The participants being redditors is doing the hard work here, imo.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Yeah I also agree. I'm simply trying to rationalize.
I'd give a 70/30 to Greece in a neutral scenario for Japan in a proper polling, perhaps 60/40 or 50/50 for South Korea. But that's just my guesstimate.
_lavoisier_@reddit
let’s be real. greeks will or can never attack a country with about 90 million population whose majority is nationalistic. that would be a suicide for them.
puzzledpanther@reddit
Finally someone with some fucking common sense.
Can you teach these simple maths to your fellow nationalist Turks?
Few_Winter_3453@reddit
They can’t do it “alone”. Greece being overall weaker doesn’t mean they can’t join an attack carried out by Israelis.
Jediuzzaman@reddit
"Greece attacking Turkiye" scenario is a nationalist Turk's wet dream, more like a fantasy for them. They do not fear-mongering upon such thing, unlike the Greek nationalists.
cicikusbabacik07@reddit
Can someone teach the meaning of "hypothetical scenarios" to you?
I'd say, even if unrealistic, this hypothetical scenario did work out well to unmask the Non-Turk stance against the Turkish kind.
puzzledpanther@reddit
I wasn't implying Turkish nationalists constrain themselves to the opinions shared on this topic, just on this thread. Quite the contrary.
Unmask? A Turkish nationalists favourite hobby is playing the victim and crying how much "The West" hates you.
_lavoisier_@reddit
Unfortunately national populism is rampant in Türkiye, of course in many countries as well, so it feels like fighting against windmills. I gave up.
Longjumping-Tear-829@reddit
I don’t understand nationalism in 2020s. It feels like an ideology to be ashamed of to me. I don’t understand how people are still attracted to and proud of it.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I agree.
Battlefleet_Sol@reddit
I trust weapons, not people, especially in international relations. That's why Turkey should acquire nuclear weapons as soon as possible.
BAT1KAN@reddit
birader tf are you talking about? no country should have nuclear weapons especially those who are ruled by stupid orcs like our sultan erdogan or Putin or any other totolatarian dumb fuck
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
xr3dxi@reddit
Obviously the defender will be favoured in terms of support when we think logically. If u really wanted to see something then the situation had to be swapped into Greece attacking Turkey. The ratio would be way more interesting tbh
andreiim@reddit
It really doesn't mean much.
The current tensions are mostly about how Turkey feels that it should have more sea rights because from their pov islands don't matter. Therefore, it makes more sense that if a conflict arises, which is unlikely, but that's what we're discussing, Turkey would be the aggressor to obtain some rights that they currently don't have, but would like to. In practice to the extreme. it may mean Greek people living in the Aegean islands would have to leave their homes and that would be a tragedy. Considering the somewhat recent imperial history of Turkey and the root of the current tension, it makes sense that most people would align with the defender. If the majority would agree that islands don't matter, Turkey would have what they want already.
With this being said and with no other context, I would also support Greece, BUT. And it's a big BUT. Turkey and Russia are competitors for control over black sea, therefore Greece, historically, tends to ally with Russia to limit Turkiy's power. From where I'm standing a more powerful Russia means I have to leave my home. Between the tragedy of Greeks having to leave their homes and my family having to leave our homes, I wouldn't think twice about who to support.
If Greeks would have the foresight to not align with Russia in any way, I'd fight to defend the rights of Greek Islanders, but never against my family.
Context matters. Luckily, this is hypothetical, but I wouldn't exclude it on the long term, and I hope all Greeks get it by then, if ever.
Self-Bitter@reddit
Be more careful in modern history lessons: Greece always sides with the West (more devotedly than Italy Spain or Germany) and not with Russia.
andreiim@reddit
Tell me there's no Greek that would give in to a Russian promise of reconquering Constantinople for Christians.
But don't tell me that no sane Greek would say this, and it's only something some nut extremists would say. Because of course it's only nuts. Sane people don't make wars.
Of course in more recent history Greece did the right thing. Hence why there were no wars, but the underlying sentiment is there and you know what I mean. Hopefully that sentiment will stay buried, but we're living through interesting times unfortunately.
prodigioustimekiller@reddit
A scenario in which Greece attacks Turkey for any reason is as likely as an interdimensional portal opening in Turkey and we get to go on an allied campaign to help fend off the aliens coming out of it.
Which means it is close to science fiction but I would watch it as a movie when I don't really have much to do.
theboltT@reddit
No difference, bring it on 🤘
BigKahunaBurger1313@reddit
Nobody likes turkeys
RestaurantBoring417@reddit
How the fuck is Azerbaijan just slightly Turkey and Russia strongly Turkey? Lmao
Also, Pakistanis licking Turkish boots as always, no surprises there
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
The Russian vote is certainly skewed. The subreddit has an issue with people LARPing as Russians and voting whatever. This isn't a thing with other ethnicities (excluding troll like North Korea and Antarctica).
TurkmenTT@reddit
We have an enemy even among the Turks
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Your name reminded me of him.
TurkmenTT@reddit
No no no not him
Icouldntfindthename4@reddit
Ofc is not true. Turanism isnt accessible and lowkey its just a nationalist propaganda
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
It is about the concept of civilization.
Turkey is an alien entity for Europe, even though most Turks are disturbed by this fact, it is the reality. You just simply won't support or have a sense of affinity to an identity that isn't yours or simply isn't connected to yours in a way.
Most Turks supported Kyrgyzistan against Tajikistan for example. Westerners, those who belong to the Western world will support Greece no matter what because Greece share a common root, a common identity with them.
This is basically human nature and there's no way to prevent it. The only solution is being ready to defend yourself in any cost.
chrstianelson@reddit
It is so depressing to read stuff like this and realize Turks don't actually know their own history.
It is absolutely bonkers to argue that Turkey belongs in the Islamic world. This would only make sense if your worldview is a simplistic division of Christianity vs Islam culture war and you have never opened a single history book about the Ottoman Empire or Turkey.
Even the Ottomans, despite relying more and more on the Caliphate and imposing Islamic policies for internal stability in their later years were never an Eastern facing country. The focus was always on Europe and European relations. Culturally the Ottomans adopted Roman cultural, bureaucratic, military and legal traditions. The infamous Turkish tradition of "The State" is actually modeled on Roman statehood. In later years, Ottoman as well as Turkish reform efforts were all modeled after Swiss and French legal and societal traditions. The longest alliance in Turkish history is with the French. There is a whole period in Turkish history between 19th and 20th centuries when Turkish high society were obsessed with French culture, adopted French as lingua franca, adopted its culture, fashion and traditions, opened up French schools and taught French. Even today French has the second most loan words in Turkish after Arabic, not Persian (and by a large margin too) and French schools are some of the most prestigious educational institutions in Turkey, fostering a signification portion of the intellectual, industrial and political elite in Turkey, who shape Turkish popular culture.
Politically, historically and culturally Turkey has always been an integral part of Europe and the European civilization. The Ottoman Empire was a part of the Concert of Europe, forming an integral part of European balance of power and forming crucial, strategic alliances with other European powers throughout history.
You literally cannot study the history of the European civilization, its development and evolution without Turks.
And yet some Turks somehow believe the bullshit Islamist propaganda that "Turkey is alien to European civilization".
Go read a goddamn book my dude.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Are you Turkish brother?
No_Tell5399@reddit
It's pretty natrual when you see maps like these tbh. Lots of younger folk get roped into conservative Islamic beliefs because they're convinced Europeans hate them.
The political right loves a "good vs. evil/us vs. them" story. Whish more ppl knew ab the Irish potato famine.
chrstianelson@reddit
Erdogan's policy of shitting on Europe through his media empire in order to consolidate his voter base in the last 15 years has done a lot of damage in how Turkish people view Europe, let me tell ya. 20 years ago Turks overwhelmingly supported being an EU member (at a peak of 73%). I remember those times. We were all about being pro-European, becoming a EU member. People were actually hopeful. Which feels unbelievable nowadays.
Then Erdogan started his term and that support started going down. Gezi Park happened, Erdogan openly started turning into a full fledged dictator, which European leaders spoke up against and suddenly Erdogan decided that Europe is the enemy and Erdogan is the hero for standing up against them. Almost every national TV channel in Turkey started pumping the narrative that Europe doesn't want us, they are working against us, that Turkey has no friends and voila. 15 years later people have actually started believing all that bullshit.
And it all started because Erdogan wanted to become a dictator and never give up power.
smh.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
"Europe doesn't want us, they are working against us, that Turkey has no friends and voila."
is it lie?
"at a peak of 73%"
peak is %60. now %20-25 😃
chrstianelson@reddit
Be a good neighbour, a reliable ally and don't try to scam people at every turn and we'll see whether they want us or not.
And the peak was 73% in 2004 according to Candidate Countries Eurobarometer 2004.1 study.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
if they could, they would wipe us out like medieval andalus. the real problem is historical. we have been an object of hatred for them ever since the western huns.
chrstianelson@reddit
Same story between France and England. Ireland and England. Scotland and England. Russia and Poland.
Historical enmities mean nothing.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
turks have different race, religion and relatively big population.
NidzoMadjija@reddit
"civilization"
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Yes, Buddhist culture that you see in Indochina is a Civilization with it's own values, structures, mindsets and ideas. West is a civilization. Islamic worlds also form a civilization. Civilization doesn't forcefully mean a "beautiful" thing as you can imagine. It is produced by people and vary according to the place that it was generated.
NidzoMadjija@reddit
Don't hide behind Buddhists, I was talking about turkics and turkey specifically
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
I never said Turkic Civilization
I said Turkey belongs to the Islamic Civilization.
"Turkey belongs to the Eastern Civilization, the Islamic Civilization that extends from Egypt to Malaysia. It is not an Islamic country, but it belongs to the Islamic World."
NidzoMadjija@reddit
Oh I understand you, no worries
But I also know what I said
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
If Erdogan stays more in power maybe. But Ataturk tried to build a new culture for the turks, one closer to the western civilization rather than east. Changing the alphabet changed alot, because nowadays the connection to arabic is low to nonexistent probably.
Maybe the turkish culture isnt yet one western, but for sure it isnt an eastern one anymore.
S0mber_@reddit
we are an eastern civilization. there is no need to feel ashamed of this. i am sick of trying to appeal to the west who frankly will never accept us as one of their own. we will be a democractic country that is respecting to the liberties of its people, but not a part of the west.
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
When I think about eastern culture I think about Arabs, Iranians and if we go further, indians, chinese and japanese. To me you don’t similar to them. Also appeal which west? The idiot french, british and germans which destroyed their countries?
S0mber_@reddit
we are turks, we are literally "the east" the average european pictured a few hundred years ago. geographically, it might look as if we're right between "the east" and "the west", but that is precisely because they made the cutoff based on us. typically, all the people you listed would be called "eastern", with chinese and japanese being "far eastern". but the ones who come up with these definitions are the westerners themselves, and clearly they don't see us with them.
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
Well i am not accepting this statement. Even DNA researches shows we are almost not have bound with Middle Asian Turks. If you are not genetically Turk, it means you are just using that identity. You can change your identity whatever you like anyways.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
lol
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
LoL
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
no
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
Site is not even working bro come on 😂
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
this wont change anything. https://x.com/yenidenturkmen https://x.com/oguzhantekden
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
LoL maps with 0 proof, 0 research, 0 papers.
S0mber_@reddit
races aren't genetical, they are cultural. there are certain patterns of DNA that can connect some people's lineage but they don't match 1:1 with the perception of race.
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
I understand your point, but I disagree. Culture and identity are not the same thing as ancestry.
A person can identify as Turkish culturally, speak Turkish and live in Turkish society. However, that does not automatically mean their ancestral origins are Turkic.
Modern genetic studies show that most people in Anatolia derive the majority of their ancestry from ancient Anatolian, Balkan, Caucasian and Iranian-related populations, while the Central Asian Turkic contribution is very low.
So when I say "Turk", I distinguish between cultural identity and biological ancestry. Someone may be culturally Turkish while having little genetic connection to the historical Turkic populations of Central Asia.
A tiger raised by lions may learn their habits, language, and culture, but it is still a tiger, not a lion.
S0mber_@reddit
this understanding of race is wrong. sure, you may call an entire population of turks "not turks" because their genetic contribution from central asia is low, but you'd still have an entire population you refuse to give a name. the thing is, genetic contribution hardly matters for a race to continue existing.
the thing is, there really were no "turkish people" with distinct genetic differences anywhere in the history for you to compare modern turks. any nomadic people living in central asia at some point were simply called turks and their genetic background were always mixed. the people of central asia of today may have different genetic backgrounds than people of turkey, but that is expected as they diverged a lot geographically. this does not mean turks are not turkic.
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
Well, DNA evidence shows that our biological ancestry is much closer to Greeks, Balkan peoples, Hittites, and Iranians than to Central Asian Turks. In that sense, I am making a similar point.
I understand that "Turk" is not a race but rather a community, culture, and identity formed through the mixing of different tribes that came from Central Asia. However, the Central Asian groups that entered Anatolia originated from a very different genetic, historical, and cultural background than the indigenous populations of the Balkans, Anatolia, and the Eastern Mediterranean. In that sense, they were not native to these regions but newcomers who became part of the local population over time.
So if someone identifies as Turkish, that is completely understandable.
However, on a personal level, why should I necessarily identify as Turk if my genetic ties are much stronger to the Aegean and Balkan regions? That is the part that does not seem logical to me.
Imagine that Brazil were conquered by African tribes, and after 1,000 years the population ended up with only 10-30% African ancestry while the majority of their genetics remained local. Would it make sense to say that those people must identify as African? To me, it would not.
That said, I have no problem with how anyone chooses to identify themselves. Everyone is free to define their own identity. But i am choosing to calling myself as Anatolian Local.
shiwonozomu_majochan@reddit
Turkish culture is more similar to Asian cultures such as Malaysian or Uyghur than it is to Romanian or Greek, let alone further western peoples like Germans or French. The presence of muhacirs with roots in Balkans doesn’t change that fact. You can’t talk about what Turkish culture entails if you haven’t ever been in deep corners of Anatolia, spoken to people from the villages of Tokat or Erzincan, observed the familial relations in Antep or Rize, or argued about the differences in mindset with people from Sivas or Konya.
Turkey is much more vast than you think. Its connection to Asian cultures is thousands of years old.
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
I lived half and year in Istanbul, people felt no different than the others in Europe. At least many of them
shiwonozomu_majochan@reddit
I suppose you didn’t stay in Ümraniye or Eyüp then, the districts of Istanbul tourists stay in only represent a tiny fraction of Turkish culture that can’t be extended to the vast majority of the country.
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
I stayed in Bey, bit I’ve walked in many neighborhoods. Even one far in the west of the city that felt more middle eastern
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
which bey? beylikdüzü, beyoğlu or beykoz?
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
Beyoglu
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
did you see kasımpaşa, okmeydanı, hasköy and sütlüce? they are average urban places for turkey standarts. only okmeydanı is more a bit dangerous(but not very). dolapdere is quite dangerous.
sutamburu@reddit
So what, we ignore the mühacir aspect and the deep Balkan/Aegean influence to embrace deepest corners of inland Anatolia and the South East? Why? So one is Turkish and the other isn’t, because saying we have more in common with Malaysia than Greece is simply not true.
Genuine question by the way, not ragebait… asking as a Gavur İzmirli with a mühacir family
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
It’s not supposed to be close to the “west” to be respected or considered and ally. You can build your own and solve your problems. Who cares about being a westerner
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
You basically write in a wastern alphabet, you copied western legal system and probably there are more examples. Learn your history, because this is what he wanted, to make the turkish culture more westerner
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
I know my history. He wanted to solve our problems, especially by getting rid of a milennia old backwards arabic influence. It doesnt necessarily mean everything had to be “western” no questions asked. You can solve your own problems. If you cant, if the answer is in europe, you can take an example. If it’s in china, you can take an example.
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
Who said everything has to be western? Western society proved to be a failure in many areas. Nobody should follow everything those idiots do
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Of course I don't say anything about it.
Cultures change, Russia before and after Petro is very different.
But tbh, I believe even if Turkey becomes an extremely democratic confederation like Switzerland, as pro-liberty like Netherlands with recognized gay marriages etc, I think even in this scenario 90% of Europeans would still not accept Turkey.
Again, it is just my opinion.
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
I dont fully agree. Because to some degree even western and eastern europeans don’t consider each other the same. For example I think western europeans are idiots. Probably eventually you will be considered eastern european like.
O_945@reddit
It's not an Europe map it's a world map,we can't focus on Europe every time, why on this world map most countries, including muslim countries pick greece that is the question
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Most of the Sunni Muslim countries won't pick Greece in this case.
The Anti-Arab people from Turkey generally use the Arab Revolt where 30K of Bedouins from Hejaz marched through Levant with British aid as an excuse for their racism while 300K of Arab soldiers fought side by side with the Ottomans at that time. In the other hand, many people in the West make assumptions by the commentaries that they read online and say "Hahaha! You see! Even the easterners don't like you!" to demoralize the counterpart. This really doesn't have a correspondence in reality.
Yes, it is right that the position of Turkey is disputed in the Muslim world by many countries. However, defending an unprovoked invasion is one different thing. There are some groups like Kurds or perhaps Egyptians who hold a grudge on us and has ancient ties with Greece, or Gulf Arabs that see us as rivals, but if you wanna look at the totality, Turkey's prestige in the Muslim world is pretty high. (Considering Arabs make 80% of the Muslims) Many Sunni Syrians are very thankful to Turkey, they already were pro-Turk before the civil war. Today in Netherlands, Turks are the group that the Moroccans marry most after their own community and we have Turkish grooms/brides in Turkey. I don't even have to think about Southeast Asian Muslims. The image of Turkey as a total in the Muslim world, is not sufficient for other Muslims to support the invasion and massacre of.
mirror__magic@reddit
I wouldnt be so sure
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
why?
mirror__magic@reddit
do you know what at arab peninsula happened in ww1
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Yes 30K of bedouins revolted under Hashemites. We had 300K Arab soldiers in the Army back then. This revolts didn't happen in Syria, Iraq or Palestine.
Rebels marched from Hejaz to Levant as you can see in this chart demonstration.
koltuklanmis_kargi@reddit
I've been to Jordan , which is ruled by the grandson of Shariff Hussein who started the Arab Revolt. The amount of love/respect you receive from the Arabs just for the sake of being a Turk and "a grandson of the Ottomans" is incredible.
gk98s@reddit
It's not as simple as that, as a Turk I would support the defender 100%. If Turkey attacks, then I'd support Greece but if Greece attacks I'd support Turkey
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Most people don't think like this.
As human beings we are tribalists, we support those we can identify as "We" and exclude those who are not "We".
Believe me, all the "non-racist" people in Europe that you see, they'd be celebrating if Greece invades Turkey and unalives Turkish civillians.
gk98s@reddit
I mean it's not the case with Gaza tho is it? Most people support Palestine eventho Palestine is as distant as you get from Western civilisation where gender equality, lgbtq rights, etc are in shambles. Whereas Israel is way closer to Western culture/values.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Bruh.
In Europe we are the Israel.
We took away the Anatolia, the cradle of Christian Civilization, we took away their capital.
plebbitchungus@reddit
Lol. Only dumb larpers think like this. Not saying there is any shortage of westoids like that, especially in the US, but like, chill my guy.
If anything, knowing my mere existence makes some dumbasses from some the other side of the planet butthurt gives me joy.
Alternative_Turn_470@reddit
You’re talking a lot of nonsense on here brother. And you have a massive victim complex. Literally nobody here I know in Ireland hates Turks. Saying all Europeans hate Turks and we cry for 'our capital' whatever that means.
Inner_Variety2826@reddit
Chill my guy. I don't think Europeans care that much for the fall of Constantinople and the end of the Byzantine/Roman empire in 1453, hell they played a big part on this happening. Most people that hold a grudge against Turkey it's because of how the government handles international matters that many times go against European intest (blocking countries for joining NATO for example). Plus the big rise of ultra nationalism that's becoming more and more vocal on denying some "shady" event's doesn't help either.
Available_Bus_9010@reddit
They can celebrate like you can celebrate 1453. What is the problem? They lost their land while defending and they want to took it back. It is natural response, you should expect that...
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
What's funny is that Kyrgyzstan is 2-to-1 for Greece here.
Obviously insignificant, but personally I wouldn't doubt a 25-30% favouring Greece in a neutral scenario.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
This kind of polls are not very reliable. Because there's no way to prevent you from lying about your country, number of participants are low and generally comes from 1 type of group from their countries (The Redditors).
However, it is true that Kazakhstan (despite being Turkic) would support Greece invading Turkey in the case of an invasion. Also Gulf Arabs, Kurds and Egyptians would side with Greeks.
If we exclude them, the overwhelming majority of Turkic countries, Syria, Palestinians, Afghans, Maghrebins and Southeast Asian Muslims would support Turkey in this case. We don't always get along, but in an invasion scenario, they wouldn't side with the invaders.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I know, it's basically the best we have right now and it's bad. I don't think any polling company would waste their time on that issue.
I get the latter, but Kazakhstan? I have seen some Kazakhs who post some vague anti-Turkish online, but I was guessing it wasn't that deep or anything. Mostly an online phenomenon.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Kazakhs are unfortunately extremely brainwashed and assimilated by the USSR to an extent that they left USSR after Russia. When it gained independence, a significant amount of the population (local Kazakhs) couldn't speak Turkic!
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
maybe partially 20 years ago. not now
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
"However, it is true that Kazakhstan (despite being Turkic) would support Greece invading Turkey in the case of an invasion."
what? there is no such world 😄
SoftMaintenance24@reddit
Truth nuke, finally.
lhookhaa@reddit
The only solution is to chill the f out, forget the past and live like brothers, we've got a lot in common. And I say this even as the sword of my ancestors lies in a museum in Istanbul.
Empty-Pace-4228@reddit
Bro, I said "defense" not attack.
lhookhaa@reddit
Yeah, I know, but if you "defense" too hard the other side will feel the need to "defense" harder! 🙂
And it seems on Reddit you guys are pretty civil, but on Facebook, for example, you're still going at each other.
Inner_Variety2826@reddit
I'm curious to know more about this if you're interested in sharing a bit more.
lhookhaa@reddit
Well, if you visit the Topkapi museum as a Romanian, among all those riches of the Ottoman empire, you will definitely notice the sword of Stefan cel Mare ("the Great"). He is one of the most venerable rulers in the history of Romania as he successfully defended lots of times against the ottomans and it is said he built a church after each one of his victories. There are also a few folklore tales about him, the typical "brave but vulnerable, fierce but fair" that some historical figures get.
LastHomeros@reddit
Many will try to argue against this but you are actually right. Turks, no matter what their ideology or political alignment is, are enemy in the eyes of many Westerners.
Atilla-The-Hon@reddit
Turks aren't even the friends of Turks
Sir_Potato2000@reddit
As an Uzbek, I support the Turks simply because I know that it is mutual on both sides. If, hypothetically, Russia were to attack my country, Türkiye would at least provide us with support and at most there would be Turkish volunteers on our side.
Lvl100Centrist@reddit
brother most Greeks don't even know where Uzbekistan is
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Most of your compatriots seem to agree, but I really doubt this "volunteer" stuff. I mean, what about Fergana?
OId_boy@reddit
You have to remember there are a LOT of russians or russified people in the ex-USSR Turkic countries. So even if this poll was genuine, and properly done, I wouldn't be surprised to see Kazakhstan/uzbekistan/kyrgyzstan in blue due to those people voting for their 'orthodox brothers.' No Kazakh would ever side against Turkey, we love Turkey and consume a fuckload of Turkish media. Never in my life have I seen a Kazakh express negative sentiment towards Turkey here. Just because we don't want some pan-Turkic state to exist doesn't mean we are anti-Turkey. And it's nothing personal, we just cherish our independence too much, after decades of USSR.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Not saying that you're necessarily wrong, but some of Kazakhs argue that Anatolian Turks steal Kazakh history and try to force them to Pan-Turkism. This meme was trending on Kazakh & Turkish twitter a few days ago. I don't agree with it obviously, but it was there.
OId_boy@reddit
I am talking about real life, I wouldn't know about twitter as I don't use it. But I can't take internet accounts seriously, anyone can make & write anything they want and there is no way to verify, much like the results of this poll where people can just make up their account's location, which is why I called the poll not genuine. Also I've never seen a Kazakh hate Anatolian Turks for 'stealing our history'. We all know 90% of Anatolian Turks couldn't even point to our country on the map, much less 'steal our history' lol. At most they will talk about early Turkic history like Xiongnu and Maodun as part of their history but that's shared history, we Kazakhs cannot solely claim them either.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Check some of the comments here. Some frustration is evident.
OId_boy@reddit
Yeah, against Pan-turkism there will always be frustration. It is a very touchy subject as I explained in the previous comments here, for many reasons. But on the whole people still see Turkey overwhelmingly positively. As with any country though there will be a small minority with more extreme opinions
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
lmao he is trying his best to make you guys hate us
OId_boy@reddit
It may seem weird but it's much better to be hated than loved. If you are hated, you will never get complacent, and you will always be ready to face whatever threat. If you are loved, you could get too comfortable, you could fall into the trap of relying on 'allies' that will actually just abandon you when things heat up. It's hatred that has made Turkey's defence industry into a monster.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
What I mean is the user you see above, No Idea 479. Pretty much the only thing he does is make posts about Turks in every subreddit he can and try to push propaganda and stir up hostility.
You can be sure that 90% of Turks in Turkey see Azerbaijan, Kyrgyzstan, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, and Turkmenistan as brotherly nations. I don't think it makes much sense to judge millions of people based on a few trolls you run into online.
Greetings from Turkey to Kazakhstan! :))
OId_boy@reddit
Greetings to you too my friend. I don't understand guys that try to spread discord amongst people. First and foremost, we are part of the same race, the human race! We all must get along otherwise we are doomed. Unfortunately, too many people are unable to let go of the past, even if it was many centuries ago. It's very sad and disheartening .(
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Painal comment, lmao
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
My Kazakh friends talk bs ab you all day, I'm not trying anything as I don't need to. I'm just acting as a messenger.
BornSpinach4444@reddit
Your kazach friend is a small minority, as a turk with kazach(kipchak) ancestry we have nothing against eachother, we like all turkic people. I would even support them if they hated me.
Michitake@reddit
Mate really we don’t want some pan turkic state either. However, I believe that Turkic countries should support each other in the international arena. I know that in the end, state interests and political majority decide to actions. But at least public opinion matters I think
OId_boy@reddit
I'd say we the public are in favor of improved relations between our states definitely. It's just pan-turkism that worries us because Turkey has a clear benefit, a pan-turkic state would be completely dominated by Turkey culturally, population-wise, power-wise, etc. It just doesn't make sense for us. But I'd love something like the EU for example, between Turkic countries
Michitake@reddit
My idea of unity is also in the style of the EU. But even that seems too idealistic for me. At the very least, a strong political and economic alliance and cultural exchange would be good
Falcao1905@reddit
Turks hate Turks more than anybody else does lmao
mutsuz_fuhrer@reddit
reddit is a leftist mossadfunded shithole dont believe this
Self-Bitter@reddit
The results are expected as the poll is about support if Greece is attacked from Turkey. Not in a general war (ofc a rational thinking would conclude that this is the only potential mechanism of war between the two countries).
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Check the next two slides.
Self-Bitter@reddit
Oh I missed them.
readyornotb@reddit
“Hypothetical attack by Turkey on Greece” Everyone should stand against that. It’s the question itself
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I agree. However, check the next two slides too.
readyornotb@reddit
Only last slide’s question is reliable and it got only 400 voters with a lot of countries don’t have a single voter.
But I do agree that Greece is likeable more than turkey, that would definitely change if they really attacked Turkey with no reason.
dontneedit000@reddit
Uzbekistan has always voted for Turks. I'm proud to be a Turk of Uzbek origin, lol. Jokes aside, it's a bit funny that other Turkic republics didn't support Türkiye much, while the Mongols did. It's obvious these results don't reflect reality.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Because it was like 1 vote for Mongolia and Kyrgyzstan.
Kazakhstan actually had over 10 votes in all polls combined though, lol. That was interesting.
Outside_Resist_8319@reddit
One question why you spread this in r/askgreece at first?
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Why would this be psoted in r/askgreece? It's probably irrelevant and something they already know.
Outside_Resist_8319@reddit
Or you tried to push votes from there just after you published this post first time.. Then why you did not post it in r/askturkey or anyother countries' sub?
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
This hasn't been posted on r/askgreece... I literally just crossposted it now. Are you hallucinating?
I tried posting it on r/askturkey but it got instaremoved, go argue with the mods.
Outside_Resist_8319@reddit
It was posted to ask Greece two days ago: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskGreece/s/5LLfw0dkGk
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Yeah this is not my poll mate, sorry to inform you.
Outside_Resist_8319@reddit
Oh Com'on, alt accounts.. Also that poll was never posted in r/askTurkey (maybe you tried but polls are not allowed that is why it was automatically removed even if you tried). You should try r/Turkey next time for that. You would get much more votes for Greece as we mostly do not support agression towards our neighbors as many Turks already stated herr as well.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I do not have alts... Just check my account and the other guy's account. Much different. Granted, seeing his poll inspired my own.
And I've been banned from r/Turkey so I can't post it. I've been banned for calling Osman Ghazi "Atatürk" lol.
Outside_Resist_8319@reddit
I paid attention that you were crossposting many thing that guys posts which gives hint that this account is an alt account of her. Ok. I maybe wrong but lol why you banned from r/Turkey from calling Osman Ghazi "Atatürk" is quite wierd as r/Turkey bans very rare if you keep discussion in Reddit rules limit. There were even people who called Turks as genociders before and even they did not get banned
GammaToastt@reddit
Shout out to Madagascar
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
That is Namibia. In all three polls there was that one guy from Namibia voting for Turkey, lol.
bokortuz@reddit
Thats why the world turns into a horrible place, i'd support the side that defends itself.
Impressive_Pin8761@reddit
small complaint: your "greece is the aggressor" chart is disorganized
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
What could have been done better? I added more options after popular demand in the second poll (people were fuming I didn't add more options).
Impressive_Pin8761@reddit
it's sorted like:
strongly greece - strongly turkey - slightly greece - slightly turkey - neutral
it should be sorted like
strongly greece - slightly greece - neutral - slightly turkey - strongly turkey
Same-Ad-6523@reddit
I mean, most countries would be against a Muslim-majority country for no reason, so I'm not surprised.
(this is the case for most muslim majority countries like Iran, Turkiye and Pakistan just a few examples)
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
I wont compare the islamicity of Turkey with the ones in Iran or Pakistan, Turkey is similar to how Albania is.
I was yesterday on the street and saw girls so underdressed that even many romanian women wont be, for example.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
"iran, pakistan, albania" "underdressed"
that isnt what is mentioned. but turkophobia is bigger than islamophobia. most non-muslims show less tolerance towards turks(muslim or irreligious) than they do towards non turkish muslims. and many muslims(i think %25-30 at least) show less tolerance towards turks than they do towards non-turks.
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
I always felt turks are the most accepted people from outside of Europe. I’m half turkish tatar and my family who is turkish tatar never faced any discrimination. I don’t think this sentiment is spread everywhere, at least in Romania I never felt it existed.
Baturing@reddit
Were you here for the Kanye concert? 😛
PomegranateOk2600@reddit
It was one in Istanbul?
Baturing@reddit
Hell yeah, 30th of May.
Surfer_Rick@reddit
"In a scenario where Turkey illegally invaded Europe"
You: "must hate Muslims, cause everyone loves illegal invasions!"
Same-Ad-6523@reddit
Well please research the bloody christmas from a non-biased pov and also read other sources than western only, there is a reason the event that happened in 1974 happened and not before or after
S0mber_@reddit
there are multiple pages in this post, the last one showing if greece were to attack turkey 44% of voters would still be with greece as opposed to 37% being with turkey
oops_all_memes@reddit
Even if we put aside the fact that all three countries mentioned have extremely problematic regimes, surprisingly many people support Iran in its war against the US. I think to people it is important how they view the other side and who attacked first
No-Heart3432@reddit
Türkiye isn't as Muslim as Pakistan or Iran. New generation are mostly nonbelievers.
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
Honey wake up another post about Turks dropped by No_Idea_479
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
This is how I've been moving recently:
Potential-Run-6540@reddit
fr tho don't you have a thing called "job"? how do you find so much time posting about Turks?
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Istituto Nazionale della Previdenza Sociale❤️🩹
Sury0005@reddit
Lol syria would never support greece why would we
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Who's "we" bro you're an immigrant in Sweden.
Sury0005@reddit
Am a student in “Sweden” also idk why ur so raty big nosey to go all the way in my profile
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Takes, like, five seconds. Not that nosey.
nile2@reddit
Who said so? Egyptian are strongly for Turkyia
Hot_Speech900@reddit
I'm Greek, but let's be serious here, if Greece were to hypothetically attack Turkey, the result would be similar.
bugog@reddit
But it is not similar. It says 44% would still support Greece even if Greece is the aggressor.
Truspace@reddit
Probably because no one in their right mind thinks that Greece would ever attack a country 8 times bigger.
xevoprime@reddit
A specific country in middle east is attacking other countries which are many times bigger so nothing is impossible
Truspace@reddit
I find the comparison insulting
Jamesanitie@reddit
You allied with them recently, no?
Truspace@reddit
It's a co-op for anti drone systems and cyber security. Not an alliance.
Jamesanitie@reddit
Forgive my ignorance then.
GrogmarktheRag@reddit
Israel was founded as a colonial project and has a colonial identity to its core. Greece is a homegrown nation that was founded by the same people that lived in that land without interruption. They are foundamentally different, and despite what our shitty government might make you think, most Greeks don't like Israel at all.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
StPauliPirate@reddit
Laughs in German
Satyriasis457@reddit
3 times less voters on the other example. Whatever that means
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Polling isn't done yet probably that's why.
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
Yeah, first question is the controversial one and what people will think happen. Others are ignored. They just need an enemy
Early-Show2886@reddit
A hypothetical war would surely be if the Greeks were to attack their Muslim minority in Western Thrace and expel them toward Türkiye.
Own_Worth_5929@reddit
Not true, some of my best friends are Bulgarian Turks.
Statakaka@reddit
You see, Greece has given a lot to the word thousands of years ago - mainly being gay.
Lucky_Ice5393@reddit
As an arab, this map looks so wrong based on the arab attitudes towards Turkey that I've observed throughout the years. Most arabs would be neutral or support Turkey.
The only arab nationality that would DEFINITELY be against Turkey is Saudi. They call erdogan "gerdogan" there which means "Monkey-gan". Lebanon would be divided as almost all Christians and Secularists would support Greece, while religious muslims would support Turkey.
Univer001@reddit
As a turk, i dont understand people who would support turkey if we decided to invade greece out of the blue.
Lumpy-Valuable-8050@reddit
UK being Greece? Lol
We have way more military cooperation with turkey
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Public opinion doesn't care. Even according to professional polling, 71% of the British view Greece positively, while only 2% view it negatively, making Greece one of the 10 most liked countries in the UK.
Lumpy-Valuable-8050@reddit
Turkey is mostly seen with a neutral view though which is already a win for them considering the fact that their leader is well uhh 💀💀💀
NoSwordfish1978@reddit
Because most Brits see Greece as a nice place to go on holiday and also because of ancient Greece as well. Of course many go on holiday to Turkey but its less common.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Turkey is much further down with 32% positive and 23% negative (rest neutral).
cicikusbabacik07@reddit
It wasn't the education system that pushed me into radical nationalism, it was you foreigners.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I think this should be a wake-up call to the opposite.
People don't like Turks because they're extremely nationalist and militarist. And this apparently causes Turks to be even more militaristic and nationalistic... You see the circle here right?
cicikusbabacik07@reddit
Yeah sure, it is totally not the bias of the West. You blame the Turks for killing Greeks and Armenians, and you get an applause. You blame the Greeks and Armenians for killing Turks and the only thing you get is "but.. but ottomn oppression!!". The wider "International Community" turns a blind eye to the Greeks what they would furiously lash out for if the Turks had done it.
Sadly, we didn't have lobbies that constantly advocated for the recognition of our misery in the US, and pushed any opposing narrative out of the academia.
DontCareHowICallMe@reddit
cicikusbabacik07@reddit
No need for it to be fictional. I see it all the time by the likes of you.
Suitable-Decision-26@reddit
What kind of a moronic circle jerk is this?
FuckTheCake@reddit
People just don’t fancy an Islamic dictatorship with a rich history of genocide denial
Skyaigrette@reddit
Though I don't think the results would change, Reddit usually doesn't reflect the real opinions of the real world. It's usually an echo chamber.
erelster@reddit
I think, even the Turk isn't friend of the Turk.
son_of_ur_son@reddit
I mean nobody likes the one qhobstarted the war first. If Greece attacked Turkey everyone, including those TURKİC BRETHREN🐺🐺🐺🐺🤘🤘🤘would be against Greek aggression. Btw, most of Central Asian in political level have already condemned the Turkish invasion/reclamation of Cyprus
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Check next two slides.
AnlamK@reddit
If you ask people to pick a side for when X attacks Y, regardless of the countries most will side with Y.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Check the other slides.
AnlamK@reddit
Oops sorry. Thanks.
Stalaagh@reddit
Nobody would support a Greek attack in Turkey, in fact people would be overwhelmingly against it.
If Turkey attacked first, which it has threatened to several times, people would gladly fight.
Early-Show2886@reddit
Op you have a big issue with your identiy. it seems to me.
matriyarka@reddit
Online surveys don't reflect reality. Because people in internet has heavy bias.
dagon_xdd@reddit
i think it's about Turkey being the attacking side. i'm Turkish and even i wouldn't support that kinda shit. just look back a few years ago and watch how many people LOATHED Russia for starting a war against Ukraine.
Waste-Restaurant-939@reddit
turkey and attacking side
when?
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I agree, but turn the slides.
dagon_xdd@reddit
oh my bad fam didn't see multiple slides.
yeah i kinda see the point in the other two.
InfernalVelocity@reddit
lol
Surfer_Rick@reddit
Genocidal authoritarian regimes illegally invading a European nation typically doesn't go over well in the polls.
many_zeros@reddit
Not being able to consider hypothetical scenarios is scientifically a sign of low intelligence, just saying.
Surfer_Rick@reddit
I am describing the reaction to the hypothetical scenario OP posted, by drawing on other contemporary examples. Such as Russia invading Ukraine or Israel invading Lebanon.
What hypothetical scenario am I neglecting?
O_945@reddit
Friend read the title of the post but failed to read the title of the map
Surfer_Rick@reddit
In a conflict between an authoritarian state and a democratic one, the result is the same. People rightly assume the warmongering authoritarian state is to blame.
Whether it's clear or unclear who began the conflict.
1384d4ra@reddit
"I can say i dislike my president, so I have a right to kill you" is quite an interesting approach, I have to say.
1384d4ra@reddit
There are multiple photos in the post my man, the next photos are for the other two scenarios.
many_zeros@reddit
The post has 3 different polls, first one says Turkey attacks Greece, second one says there is a conflict but the aggressor is unknown and the last one says Greece as the aggressor attacks Turkey
Surfer_Rick@reddit
Yes and currently Turkey is an authoritarian state.
If Russia and Estonia got in a conflict without it clear who started it. People will assume Russia started it.
The hypothetical scenario did not say a democratic secular controlled Turkey.
It said Turkey. As it is today.
many_zeros@reddit
back to square one
Several_Score_4278@reddit
You can't conduct surveys on social media. These results aren't realistic.
Apnanizor@reddit
What a shitshow the comment section is in this one
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Let it burn...
ZedIsDeadd@reddit
only what America says matters and america does what isreal says so only what israel says matters. and since isreal is buying all of cyprus and half of greece, israel would support greece
Kindly_Scientist@reddit
trust me all turks knew this already. thats why turkey is domestically developing their own drones, fighter jets, guided missiles, hypersonic/ballistic missiles. they literally announced a 6000km ICBM like 3 weeks ago and they are building a space agency base at somalia. you guys might call it “insanity” or “its reddit nobody cares this results” nah, entire world dont like us as we seen how EU handles us.
IcyRun6578@reddit
The amount of people drawing conclusions from these polls really shows the intelligence level of this sub
ATAKURT1453@reddit
muslims back turkey, everyone else backs greece. surprising? not really. only atheist kemalists would be shocked by this. the low support among muslims is just because the poll is on reddit.
YogurtclosetSad9472@reddit
Are we seeing another map?Only even a few Muslims would support Turkey, i mean why support in a scenario where Turkey is the agressor?
ATAKURT1453@reddit
attacking and committing war crimes are not the same thing.
also, the whole world backed greece when they tried to invade turkey in1919. In the real world, nobody cares who started the war when picking sides
YogurtclosetSad9472@reddit
You said "invade" Turkey in 1919.
First of all Turkey didn't exist in 1919, it was Ottoman Empire.
Secondly, movements that have an an aim to decolonise lands as indigenous out of the invaders aren't considered "indigenous people attacking poor innocent colonisers" , but liberation movements.
Last but not least, Greece intervening in Ionia and generally Asia Minor to protect it's population from full scale genocide that started the minute the colonisers decided that the farming cows weren't so beneficial anymore isn't "Greece invading Turkey" , but Greece rushing to protect it's people from genocide...
ATAKURT1453@reddit
as you can see, there’s always an excuse. who's right doesn't even matter. muslims support muslims, christians support christians. welcome to the real world
YogurtclosetSad9472@reddit
There is a basis to that, but the concepts of "just war" are different in the theologies of Christianity and Islam...
TheOnurobo@reddit
Well governments are not the same with reddit users, i dont necessarily believe that support for greece would be that high, it mostly relies on who proves or attacks first, while greece is a NATO member just like Turkey is, they are orthodox and they are not necessarily reliable in a Russian war as they were in serbian war, But Russia has been the biggest rival of Turkey throughout the history and Turkey is reliable in that regard so, EU might just even stay neutral, if Turkey attack first, Turkey attacking first means there is definetely an agreement going on with the US in background so its 3 dimensional chest in a sense
grkmmkrg@reddit
The sole result of these pointless polls is the recurring historical pattern of Greeks requiring foreign backing before taking any action against other nations.
Ildaiaa@reddit
The president who has been ruling for 20 years has incredibly poor understanding of international affairs and keeps pointing at all the countries and shouting THEY ARE THE ENEMY somehow made a reality where the country he's ruling has no friends and now he's people think it's a racism thing
Idk man, seems pretty weird such a country would exist and have poor relations with everyone except it's 20 year ruling opposition party ruler
Mention-Powerful@reddit
You know there is meme about Erdogan; "Rule 1 of geopolitics: Erdogan always wins"
You are fed with propaganda and it worked as it seems.
Ildaiaa@reddit
I am turkish my guy i just can see we keep losing
Candid_Awareness_585@reddit
I like having %13 with us 😍🥰
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
It's like 10-11% since many Turks took part in those polls too (much more than Greeks).
What's funny is that 3-4 Turks voted Greece in all three scenarios, lol.
IcyRun6578@reddit
I just checked, and some Greeks voted Turkey. We also have a penguin supporter from Antarctica
The European countries are probably true, but there's an immense amount of larping going on in Asia and Africa, and a lot of them have only 2-3 votes. You also made it so the polls can't be compared by adding extra options.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Check last poll.
chrstianelson@reddit
The poll is bullshit simply because it starts with a leading question. That alone disqualifies it as a serious attempt at gauging public opinion.
With that said, Turkey always sucked at international PR. Never had a politically powerful diaspora like Greece, Armenia or Israel who kept demonizing Turkey in western societies with state funded campaigns. The one powerful diaspora Turkey has is the one in Germany, but unlike Greek, Israelite or Armenian diaspora, those who emigrated to Germany (and to a lesser extent other European countries) weren't (relatively) educated, progressive, liberal, urbanites but highly conservative, uneducated, rural Turks from Central and Eastern Anatolia.
And the last 20 years of Erdogan regime and his policy of ruthless realpolitik at every turn even against long standing allies has eroded what little good will Turkey had internationally.
yns1899@reddit
Christian vs Muslım
SiofraRiver@reddit
Read the fucking question and drop your victim mentality.
Odio-gli-imbecilli@reddit
Most Muslim countries in this map would support Greece chief, the real reason is that Turkey has always kept an active stance on foreign politics and it's considered an aggressive power in the region, like Israel or Iran.
I mean, if Serbia attacked Kosovo most Europeans would defend Kosovo, we did it in the past, the issue isn't religious (and if anything it would be ethnic, not religious, but Turks are considered to be mediterranean, at least here in Italy, not Arabs or middle Eastern)
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
It’s true that we sometimes throw hands but we also find ourselves in a corner a lot. Current generation of europe is virtuous in what they werent tested with and they talk shit a lot
O_945@reddit
On this map (^(that I don't believe in at all)) 2/3 of the muslim countries are siding with Greece, so not really a "Christian vs Muslım " scenario.
yns1899@reddit
They are probably not Muslim, because in the survey asking 'what religion do you belong to,' atheism was the majority in Muslim-majority countries.
SiofraRiver@reddit
This is an insane question and an insane framing.
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
There's three questions.
YogurtclosetSad9472@reddit
No our Kazak friends with the beautiful flag will also supports us, as you know Turkey attacking Greece would be like Russia attacking Kazakhstan...
EL_ProfessionalHater@reddit
And who exactly voted this shit?... 😂
Russia, a predominantly christian-ortodox country siding with Turkey?... yeah sure man.
A realistic scenario would be:
North and South America sending us some supplies post-war.
Most of Europe will mainly support us with funds and ammunition and would fight by us through social media.
Most muslim countries will definitely aid Turkey, and most of Asia (besides Russia) will side by Turkey or won't get involved at all, maybe just get involved through social media.
radjPpP@reddit
Mhm OP what is the purpose of this post?
First I thought you only posted this information for the purpose of it being interesting but reading your comments I can’t help but feeling you are quite clearly having an agenda. Elevating Greece by calling them an ancient civilisation (which is true) while calling Turks famous for kebab, genocide and Kurds (which is also true but I feel there is more to be said).
Honestly disappointing to see people here trying to divide people instead of uniting.
Anyways…. hope for peace as always and better relations going into the future
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
I am not calling them anything. I am simply trying to rationalize what others might think to produce these results.
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
Brah the subtext of the post is obviously to generate a sentiment against Turkey, or amplify whatever is already ghetto
radjPpP@reddit
Oh my bad OP that makes sense and I think you are probably right in that regard.
PaymentAutomatic4831@reddit
How about the hypothetical attack of Greece on Turkey, though?
Olorin_90@reddit
I think we're putting a lot of weight on a sub Reddit voting post. These things are affected by various false factors, hypotheticals and do not represent outside reality.
Slow-Hawk4652@reddit
this is bs...
No_Idea_479@reddit (OP)
Reddit-skewed results.
Still, not that far from reality.
Stverghame@reddit
Serbs would support Greece, but Serbian dictator would probably go with Turkish dictator. He kinda likes going against the will of the people.
Early-Show2886@reddit
The outcome was to be expected, after all. As a Turk, you simply stand no chance against the Greek lobby—not with all the anti-Turkish smear campaigns currently being waged.
Character-Pirate1297@reddit
FFS with that same old question.
Flat-Employment-4165@reddit
When I visited Greece, I didn’t feel like I was in a typical Balkan country; instead, I felt like I was in a European state, more in the style of Slovenia or Southern Italy. It is, without a doubt, a strong cultural part of Europe. I understand the dynamics of Europe and their 'all for one' motivation. However, wars are unfortunately fought with weapons, not just rhetoric. For instance, France might stand firmly behind Greece today in political terms, but a mother in Normandy would not easily send her child to die in a war against the Turks just to defend the Greeks.
In such a conflict, Greece would suffer immense loss of life and territorial damage. Furthermore, the European Union would be the biggest loser in such a scenario. They heavily underestimate Turkey’s role as a fortress, guarding the gates of Europe. Neither the Bulgarians nor the Greeks are strong enough to hold those gates. If Turkey were to open its borders for even a month, it would bring Europe to its knees.
Beyond the strategic side, the idea of killing and taking lives for the sake of politicians and those obsessed with mapping games is absurd. Why should we get amputated, die, or commit atrocities just for the sake of wealthy elites? We only have 60-70 years to live; why spend it trying to destroy one another? These 'old men' in power should be the ones solving these issues so that people don't have to die. Bureaucracy should exist to resolve problems through dialogue, not to create them.
Downtown-Figure6434@reddit
It’s eurocentricism. Ofc no matter what Greece can do no wrong and Turkey can do no right
Even their stance on Ukraine war is not all “white” as they like to think. They are just happily turning Ukraine to a meat grinder for the Russian army by letting the war drag out instead of helping them with a decisive blow and kick the Russians out. Ukraine wont be accepted into nato or eu either. They will be discarded just as soon as they think Russia is weak enough