[s2e01] Troi's son Ian didn't need to die.
Posted by Mostly_Ponies@reddit | TNG | View on Reddit | 13 comments
Troi has it the worst throughout the show. I just rewatched season 2's "The Child" and Ian didn't need to die. Since they were going to separate the saucer section anyway he could've stayed in his room and things would've been fine. Or take a shuttle; those have warp drives. But the writers needed to wrap up the episode. Ian was an interesting character and I wish he stuck around, he could've been a kindred spirit to Data, not a redundancy.
Granted, at his rate of growth he would've died of old age in over a month, so the writers would've had to slow that down if they kept him. Not that there's any consistency with kids' ages. Was Alexander an energy being too? That kid aged 9 years in 1 year.
MovieFan1984@reddit
It's easy to forget that Troi had THREE children.
Ian in this episode, along with Thaddeus and Kestra between Nemesis & Picard.
I-am-not-Herbert@reddit
Wasn't that episode hampered by the writer's strike?
NewLife_21@reddit
Yes. A lot of that season was.
dinosaurkiller@reddit
Zhymantas@reddit
He wasn't her son per se, just alien who forced itself to be Troi's son
Mostly_Ponies@reddit (OP)
To her he was her son. The grief of losing a son so soon, despite what he really was, is a valuable story that was sadly never explored.
Electronic-Country63@reddit
You’re being downvoted because the Reddit hive mind says “baaaah, story bad, it’s about Troi’s rape”. And it is, but you’re also right. Women are raped and sometimes choose (or are compelled) to keep that child and have to navigate the conflict between what happened to them, what the child represents and the fact it is their child who is ultimately innocent.
If they had approached the story from that angle more rather than have Troi passively accept “well, I have a kid now” it would be a much more interesting, narratively complex and nuanced story.
Torlek1@reddit
In the original Phase II script, the child doesn't "die" before leaving.
ads1031@reddit
What does happen in the original Phase II script?
Torlek1@reddit
The child beams over to the alien ship, as the latter does the ending of Galaxy's Child.
ravynwave@reddit
I was so confused about Alexander, then just decided that Klingons grew twice as fast than humans during adolescence since he was a young adult in DS9.
farmallnoobies@reddit
They have twice the critical organs, so there's probably a lot more growth hormone.
Sea-Quality4726@reddit
He was on an undercover away mission like several we seen Riker undertake. You could just as well ask why those personas had to cease when the research objective was met.