I’m building CounterSwipe because one-on-one disagreement is better than getting dogpiled
Posted by paijim@reddit | RedditAlternatives | View on Reddit | 4 comments
Hi. I’m the founder building CounterSwipe.
The basic idea came from a frustration I have with Reddit and most discussion platforms.
A lot of the time, the problem is not that people disagree. Disagreement is good. The problem is the format.
If you post something outside of the dominant view in a subreddit, you are not really entering a conversation. You are often getting hit by 20, 30, or 40 people making some version of the same point at once.
At that point, it stops feeling like dialogue and starts feeling like ideological dogpiling. Even a moderate opinion can get flattened into “you must be on the extreme other side” because the crowd has already decided what box you belong in.
CounterSwipe is my attempt at a different format.
You swipe on a prompt card, pick a side, then get matched with one person who picked the opposite side.
Not a comment section.
Not a pile-on.
Not a popularity contest.
Just a one-on-one conversation where both people actually have room to explain themselves.
A few things we are building around:
- Prompt cards with two clear sides
- One-on-one debates with people who disagree
- Debate modes for cleaner or more intense conversations
- Scores for things like logic, persuasion, and civility
- AI practice if you want to test your argument before talking to someone real
The goal is not to create another echo chamber. It is to make disagreement feel more balanced, more direct, and more human.
I’d really appreciate feedback from people who are also frustrated with the way Reddit-style discussions usually go.
Would you use something like this? What would make one-on-one debate actually work?
https://thinklavender.com/counterswipe
Thanks for reading.
Gearjerk@reddit
This is written by AI. Look, I can appreciate the intent behind a project like this, but if you can't even be bothered to write in your own words about this idea, how can you expect anyone to have any faith in your willingness and ability to execute?
Tight_Heron1730@reddit
Often unseen point and nice way to encourage real discourse and bring different views
paijim@reddit (OP)
thank you ! do you see this as something you would self would use or does it feel like its a little too niche ?
Tight_Heron1730@reddit
too niche, i am building in that space too https://terribic.com reddit shaped, phpbb/mail groups, privacy led. Niche only means it's not for everyone and finding market would be challenging.
I see it as piggybacking option on top of existing ones, I do believe some people would appreciate/like to argue and have a discourse but often hiding not wanting to be judged or misunderstood