Colorado River Basin Users are Cooked.
Posted by nostoneunturned0479@reddit | collapse | View on Reddit | 61 comments
9 Days ago, Cody Moser with the Colorado Basin River Forecast Center stated that only an additional 800,000 acre feet, only 13% of average, is projected to flow downstream in the Colorado River through July, after this abysmal Water Year's snowpack has finished melting and running off.
For years now, the reservoir that everyone was paying attention to was Mead, while Lake Powell has fallen to the wayside. It seems no one of importance has completed a meaningful seepage and evaporative loss study of Lake Powell since the 1980s. USU's assessment stated that the data for both Mead and Powell was too old to be reliable. In fact, USU found in 2022, that the Bureau of Reclamation's 24 Month Outlooks for the Colorado River, "in most cases, future reservoir elevation was overestimated."
Unfortunately, at this point, deadpool seems both inevitable and fast, at not one, but both major reservoirs.
Today, Lake Powell's elevation is 3,527.15. It is at just 23.31% of full pool (24,323,000 AF). That translates out to be roughly a bank of 5.67MAF. Assuming only 800KAF of water will be coming downstream from the runoff, coupled with up to an additional 1MAF to be released from Flaming Gorge to help prop it up... that means this year's annual bank only adds up to 7.47MAF. The math here, simply does not math.
Per the Colorado River Compact, Lake Powell is obligated to release 7.5MAF annually, less any reductions as mandated by more recent Contingency Plans agreed to by the lower basin states, or orders passed down from the Fed. Because the Contingency Plan (which expires at the end of this year, by the way), is based on shortage conditions at Lake Mead, and not Powell... Per the Contingency Plan, the Colorado River is simply at a Tier One Shortage Condition, which does nothing to the mandated releases for Lake Powell, it only has to do with the mandated releases for Lake Mead, and even then, it only amounts to a 590KAF flow reduction from Lake Mead. Despite the flow reductions from Lake Mead, it's water levels are continuing to drop. Lake Mead currently is at a elevation of 1052.68ft, and dropping like a rock.
Mead is down 13.46ft from the high of the year, and just in the last two weeks has lost 2.86ft. It is in complete freefall, and we aren't even in the hottest part of the summer yet, where evaporative losses mount. We are currently following a curve pattern similar to 2022, and from May 17th 2022-July 27th 2022 (the water year low), it had lost 9.81ft. For perspective... during the hottest time period prior to the monsoon picking up steam, Lake Mead was only losing 1.96ft on average every two weeks. If it continues to lose water at the same rate we are currently at now, it will lose a cumulative 14.3ft by the time July 27th hits this year, bringing Mead to an elevation of 1038.
Now, to get to the good part. While the minimum power pool at Mead is 950ft, that does not mean we have time before ultimate destruction. "Aging hydroelectric turbines are at risk of cavitation (damage caused by expanding and collapsing air bubbles in the water) when levels drop below 1,035 feet. At that elevated threshold, federal operators may be forced to shut down most of the older turbines even before the absolute minimum power pool is reached. Despite that problem, the Fed is now stuck between a rock and a hard place, and must decide whether to continue to prop Mead, or to prop Powell up. Powell is projected to possibly fall below minimum power pool (elevation 3,490) by August this year.
The Fed is talking about possibly reducing Powell's releases down to 6MAF this year to prevent the loss of hydroelectric power, and reliance of the lower penstocks to pass water through the dam, but in doing so, it may create another issue: it will likely reduce Mead's power production by 40%. Mead is mandated to release 9MAF annually, less the current Tier One shortage reduction of 590KAF. The Lower Basin States have offered up an additional 1.25MAF voluntary reduction for the next two years, but that has not yet been approved by the Fed. There is one problem. Mead currently only has 7.88MAF left in it. Even with the voluntary cuts, from Mead downward, that means 7.15MAF in deliveries, and if Powell cuts down to 6MAF in deliveries going forward... the deficit increased exponentially, and deadpool becomes all but assured, and within the next 18 months.
What happens next?
At deadpool for Mead, it means no further water delivery for California, Arizona and Mexico. It means the loss of Hydroelectric power from Lake Mead, Lake Mohave, Lake Havasu, the loss of water to cool the Nuclear Reactors at Palo Verde Nuclear Power Plant near Phoenix. Technically speaking, Palo Verde uses treated wastewater from Phoenix area to cool the reactors, but with water not being assured, Phoenix area customers will have to cut consumption, which will result in less waste water to use.
Can you imagine the repercussions of the loss of 2,080 megawatts from Hoover Dam, 240 megawatts from Davis Dam (Lake Mohave), 120 megawatts from Parker Dam (Lake Havasu), 4,000 to 4,200 megawatts from Palo Verde Nuclear Power Plant? A cumulative loss of approxumately 6500 megawatts, means about 6.5 million households will go without power, in the hottest desert areas of the US, where temperatures regularly are in excess of 100 degrees for 60-90 days of the year.
A few years ago I came on this sub begging for awareness and action, and had several people question the direness of the situation. The day has finally come.
Mike-Banachek@reddit
I am writing a paper on the Salton Sea. California wants to save it, but it’s not happening with the Colorado being so screwed.
Fragrant_Tailor9609@reddit
Hasn’t it been dried up for many years?
Nervous-Locksmith484@reddit
My heart breaks for the animals.
Dapper_Succotash9826@reddit
People are animals too
Diligent-Square8492@reddit
I mean, animals have feelings too, including humans. We can feel bad for both animals and humans. Also, I think humans should feel at least a bit sad for the environmental destruction humanity overall has caused. Not saying all humans share the same blame for the environmental destruction.
Dapper_Succotash9826@reddit
Agreed, thanks for understanding my comment
ochute@reddit
Yeah but people have caused this problem. It's not like the horses and dogs terraformed and polluted the planet. Homo Sapiens are the worst... and I can say that, cus most of my friends are humans.
Pap3rStreetSoapCo@reddit
Just so we are clear that the culture is the problem, not the species…
BrotherBear0998@reddit
It can be both
Pap3rStreetSoapCo@reddit
It isn’t. Quit with this “original sin” bullshit; it’s ridiculous.
Purple_Puffer@reddit
Most of them are fucking animals
Reasonable-Teach7155@reddit
AnOnlineHandle@reddit
It's inconsequential compared to the wasteful massive energy and water usage of the meat industry, which is a ridiculously cruel luxury.
You can tell if somebody actually cares about the environment or is just pretending based on whether they care about the unnecessary big users or the tiny users which are currently fashionable to hate and which requires no change from them to hate.
genomixx-redux@reddit
For now. But the techno-capitalists are all in on hyperscaling generative AI -- which means plenty more datacenters in the future.
Strategically, then, it makes a good deal of sense to make an effort to nip this in the bud before its usage approaches the same level as that of the meat industry.
Gyirin@reddit
Agreed tbh. People who really care prob already went vegan by now.
RadiantRole266@reddit
Sure. But this isn’t about relative waste, it’s about cumulative waste. AI demands are significant because they are coming on top of the everything else — including drinking water or flows for animals.
Johndough99999@reddit
El Nino typically brings extra moisture to the SW. This year expected to be a Super El Nino.
Anyone have forecasts for what would happen to these reservoirs in the SW if that happens?
filmguy36@reddit
Too bad there wasn’t someway to generate electricity from the sun. Oh well
nostoneunturned0479@reddit (OP)
Solve one problem, but cooling yourself will mean next to nothing without both food, and water.
filmguy36@reddit
You think solar is only good for cooling yourself? Okay then🙄
nostoneunturned0479@reddit (OP)
Nope. But its certainly a high priority if you will live somewhere where highs are 95+ for 120 days of the year, friend.
But also, solar won't make water, and you need water to drink, and make food. Can you be so for real.
filmguy36@reddit
Solar won’t make water but it can power pumps, desalination plants and machines that pull water from humid air.
nostoneunturned0479@reddit (OP)
10% relative humidity is not nearly humid enough.
bernpfenn@reddit
how long can Las Vegas survive without water and electricity?
Jukka_Sarasti@reddit
I dunno, but I think we might know the answer to that question sooner than expected...
Laatikkopilvia@reddit
By Tuesday you say?
GardenRafters@reddit
Meatrocket_Wargasm@reddit
Paradoxically, I believe Las Vegas gets most of it's power from natural gas power plants. So they'll keep running for the foreseeable future. The remaining water will be given to the mega-wealthy tourists while the Vegas residents will be forced to fight in Hunger Games type of pay-per-view events for their ration of water. Parking will still cost 40 dollars to park at the casinos.
nostoneunturned0479@reddit (OP)
Ahem. You need water for a natural gas power plant. The natural gas burns, and heats water, and the energy is created from the steam.
mem2100@reddit
It totally sucks that we've switched so casually from coal to natural gas power plants given the high warming potential of natural gas. That said, bad as they are for warming, a natural gas plant only uses about 700 gallons per mWh. A typical couple in the US directly consumes about 5,000 gallons of water/month. And uses about 1 mWh of power, about 40% of which comes from natural gas - so the natural gas power for an average person only adds about 300 gallons per month to their 5,000 gallons of direct consumption.
Nat gas is a modest consumer of water in the overall scheme of things.
lordraglansorders@reddit
The good news is everyone who lives in phoenix has a massive ~20,000 gallon rainwater harvesting basin right in the middle of their back yard. They also have plenty of solar power to run a small pump through a natural bog filter. At ~7" per year and a ~2000 sq ft roof that should be enough to fill that thing up and last at least until the next monsoon season starts in August (assuming you don't have a lawn, wash your car, etc...)
Confident-Tea-9763@reddit
I don't think it's 7" per year anymore. It hardly ever rains.
koryjon@reddit
Quality satire! Lol 3,000sf roof average
errie_tholluxe@reddit
Ah yes all those HUGE storms that drop the flooding waters that never evaporates....
lowrads@reddit
Dams, like any storage option, are really only optimal for grid balancing.
The outcome of the basin is largely a product of the economics of it, which are bizarrely still tied to the antiquated allocation system based on the classic, and time tested principle of dibs.
Final_boss_1040@reddit
I remember going to Lake Powell in May 2021 and realizing just how cooked the southwest was. It was a big part of the reason I relocated my family from California to Canada
darkmeowl25@reddit
I used to dream about living in the desert. It was my backup plan if I ever got the urge to run away and never look back.
As i learned more about the water situation, I realuzed it would be so insanely selfish to export my suffering to another place without the resources to sustain the people, plants, and animals who live there currently.
Now, I'm even older. Now, I've realized there's no where I can run away from what's coming.
Meatrocket_Wargasm@reddit
I adore Las Vegas and the surrounding areas in southern Nevada. I lived there for more than a decade and considered it home. I had to leave for family reasons. I'd love to go back but the almost inevitable outcome for cities and farms built in the middle of deserts with little concern for the future stops me.
I still daydream about moving back to the desert while I drag the snowblower out, but at least I still have water.
modernwinglish@reddit
Relocated to Wisconsin in 2011 for work and am still here. I do not like the cold, gray weather, but I find solace in our proximity to fresh water. Then the data centers came along and now I’m worried again.
reddolfo@reddit
Me too. Minnesotan here. The other assured threat is drought. We do have water, but we don't have sprinklers in the forest, which means fires. Persistent drought over time also harms the soils and the water lands. Feels dire.
QueasyPerformance221@reddit
But climate change is a hoax, right? 🤣🤣🤣
hiddendrugs@reddit
funny to me that this trope gets so widely spread, in US media especially, while one of the biggest advocates for adaptation & energy security is the US military
Alarming-Art-3577@reddit
Does the US military still support that or is it too woke?
reggionh@reddit
tbf the trope is more like “man-made climate change is a hoax”. US military will still be concerned of its security implications whether its natural or man-made.
HolyMoleyGuacamoly@reddit
well, when you put it that way OP…. fuckin he’ll
Lailokos@reddit
The water rights fight, with the 3 lower states getting something like 3 to 4 MAF water cuts, is going to be wild. What do they do? Stop approving new homes in Pheonix? It's one of the biggest metros and that would just play havoc with the whole region. Cut local growers of alfafa (well and of course Saudia Arabian operations)? If they do that beef prices go up throughout the US. Cut vegetables growers, and that's the winter crop for the US too. And the wild thing is they have to do ALL of those, and still not enough. All that lost power too - wonder how much will be new gas turbines somewhere? Which of course are production booked for years ahead of time at this point.
Jessintheend@reddit
I vote stop growing a water intensive crop that’s not even used here
bizobimba@reddit
Like all that alfalfa grown in imperial valley shipped to Middle East to feed Arabian stallions?
Jessintheend@reddit
Yeah that stuff
merikariu@reddit
Great observations. Regarding the gas turbines, I have heard that there is a 5+ year wait for those. I expect that major infrastructure items like that have such a tremendous lead time. What will the SW USA look like in twenty year? Solarpunk Mad Max?
JuracichPark@reddit
Cut the golf courses, the Saudi alfalfa growers, the rich people's lush green lawns. Cut everything and anything that is not a NECESSITY to life. The wastage of water is ridiculous, and the price is about to get paid.
How_Do_You_Crash@reddit
Any sane plan would cut cut cut regular water releases to preserve electricity generation as long as possible. While spinning up contingency plans for down stream water and electrical customers. We would also force pretty draconian usage reductions on all river users, and sacrifice a ton of agricultural production to do it.
This is America in 2026, so we won't be doing any of that. That requires a level of national coordination and priorities/goals setting that just isn't likely to happen. Instead we will have different political and physical geographies fighting until the water runs out and the knock on effects take hold.
Agreeablepeeable@reddit
The golf courses use recycled water. Spreading fake news is something we should not do on the left
ribald_jester@reddit
Don't worry - that moribund souless fuck of an EPA director "Lee Zeldin" is busy destroying decades of environmental regulations so the oligarchs can have one last orgy of profiteering, before descending into their bunkers!
mistegirl@reddit
The first time I saw Hoover Dam was in 2000. The water was pouring over the spillways, it was something to see.
I don't know the exact numbers, but seeing the lake now, compared to just 26 years ago is alarming as hell. I have to imagine it'll be about gone completely in the next 25.
NkhukuWaMadzi@reddit
The only hope for the coming food-apocalypse is Jim Bakker's buckets! (Oh wait, you need water though)!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IMbZp2P7wn4
NyriasNeo@reddit
"deadpool seems both inevitable and fast"
Time to leave.
digital@reddit
Another one of the hundred to get off oil and stop burning shit. We are not going to have an environment or anywhere to grow crops if this continuous.
HappyAnimalCracker@reddit
Every time someone posts a warning there are people who pile on and say it’s alarmist, fear mongering, etc. I suppose there must be a few times where this is actually the case, but much of the time they sound like uninformed ostriches to me. Sorry OP. This kind of “told ya so” is never fun.
The loss of power in the southwest will likely affect the entire western interconnect, if I understand the situation correctly.
Hang on to your bippy, folks.
TheHistorian2@reddit
Perhaps literally.
sneedoisis@reddit
Pop pppppp