Is there really a common cake flavor that apparently comes in a box and the flavor is “yellow”?
Posted by IMicrowaveSteak@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 357 comments
TiFist@reddit
Yes.
It's basically vanilla + butter and eggs.
nietheo@reddit
With yolks= yellow cake, without yolks = white cake
Holden1104@reddit
Well I’ve learned something new today. 🫶🏻
bloobityblu@reddit
... and flour.
Freyr_Tuck@reddit
When you combine milk and flour, you get glue. And then you add sugar and eggs and you get cake. Where does the glue go?
charcoalhibiscus@reddit
I know this is a bit but the answer is actually interesting. The glue doesn’t go away! Its toughness is important. The leaveners (baking powder, and egg to some extent) create fluffy pockets within the glue. So you have something more like a sponge. Then the sugar and fats act as tenderizers, so in total you end up with something that has enough stability to keep itself together, but is fluffy and tender (and tasty). Pretty cool, huh?
flortny@reddit
Or....just squeeze some elmers in your mouth and a packet of sugar.....yum...sticky cake
amyn2511@reddit
Idk why someone downvoted this, I thought it was funny lol
Wodentoad@reddit
Science! Woo! I love the chemistry of the kitchen!
diversalarums@reddit
I wish I had an award to give you. Best real answer to a joke I've heard!
rawbface@reddit
Wait whats the joke
Winter-Warlock8954@reddit
Fryer said "When you combine milk and flour, you get glue. And then you add sugar and eggs and you get cake."
With the punchline "Where does the glue go?"
rawbface@reddit
The punchline? What is funny about this? It seems like an anti joke.
Winter-Warlock8954@reddit
What can I say except that explaining a joke take the funny out of it 🤷♂️
Dazzling-Climate-318@reddit
Maybe the joke wasn’t funny to begin with. In this case it’s dependent on the huh, I don’t understand the nature of reality kind of thinking many people exhibit. It’s funny, but sad because it’s making fun of a person, supposedly the comic is making fun of themselves, but they are also making fun of others and making the person that understands reality feel smug and superior to those that don’t understand how things work.
And it could get quite awkward if the person you are with says something about it in the manner of yeah, how does that happen, I don’t understand and you realize they don’t understand chemistry nor baking. Could be a mood killer and definitely a red flag.
Tempest_in_a_TARDIS@reddit
In the version of the joke I've heard, Where does the glue go? is part of the setup, and the punchline is: That's what makes it stick to your thighs.
Sl1z@reddit
The “where does the glue go” bit was was originally said by Rita rudner in one of her standup routines
BlueSkyMourning@reddit
Is that why so many call these sponge cakes? I'd never heard the term before listening to these baking shows.
Catcollector503@reddit
Professional pastry chefs refer to the baked cake as sponge because that is what it looks like when you cut into it. The textures will vary from quite dense, as with a pound cake, to very light such as an angel food cake. The term ”angel food” gets used interchangeably with sponge cake, though I think the ingredients are a bit different. It all depends on the type of flour, the amount and type of leavening, and the amount of air that is incorporated into the cake batter. The more mixing you do, the denser the cake. An overmixed batter will produce a tough cake. There is quite a bit of science and precision to baking which is why many chefs do not like desserts. 😱
sjd208@reddit
In the US, a sponge cake is a specific style of cake leavened with whipped egg whites and a very light texture. A yellow cake usually is creamed butter and sugar and baking powder and has a richer and denser texture.
Curmudgy@reddit
I'll add that a sponge cake is related to an angel food cake, with the difference being that the egg yolks are added back into the batter of a sponge cake while you need to find some other use for the yolks with an angel food cake.
BlueSkyMourning@reddit
I have a vague memory of sponge cakes from family reunions as a kid, but we were raised on yellow cake so thanks.
MissFabulina@reddit
Yep, it is because the texture of the cake is just like a sponge.
Dapper-Condition6041@reddit
Science! Imagine that!
stevzon@reddit
Love me a good tender glue sponge.
Alycion@reddit
Ty. Got my learn something new today out of the way. It is pretty cool.
TrailsNstuff@reddit
Well that's what stops the cake from falling apart
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
What do you think holds the cake together!?
AnitaIvanaMartini@reddit
I always assumed it was held together by the sides of the pan
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
In all honesty. It is the "glue". The leavening agents blow bubbles into the "glue" matrix and that's what creates the sponge. Cakes like angel food cake actually do rely on the pan glue combo more since you want that batter to stick to the sides nice and strong to help it maintain its sponge as it sets upside down
AnitaIvanaMartini@reddit
I once got a non-stick angel food cake pan for Christmas. I keep it for occasional giggles. It’s the most useless pan I have.
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
Lmao 🤣
alady12@reddit
That's why it always sticks to my hips and thighs.
fgsgeneg@reddit
Baking is the most chemistry like activity you can do in the kitchen.
NoGuarantee3961@reddit
Yeah, it is a sticky situation...
WonderfulProtection9@reddit
Isn’t that a George Carlin bit?
Freyr_Tuck@reddit
Rita Rudner, actually.
psu256@reddit
That’s a name I haven’t heard in a long time. One of my favorite comics growing up.
Scavgraphics@reddit
wow me too... i loved her delivery.
SummitJunkie7@reddit
Into the cake! It's what holds it together.
BigBlaisanGirl@reddit
The eggs do magic.
PurplishPlatypus@reddit
It holds the cake together
AnitaIvanaMartini@reddit
… and sugar
GodsGoodGrace@reddit
The box is an integral part of the product
pyramidalembargo@reddit
Don't forget the baking powder!
PAXICHEN@reddit
And my axe.
OpenRecover6769@reddit
Those are the yellow things, not just cake ingredients.
Simple_Praline_7275@reddit
so just vanilla, butter and eggs are pretty necessary
AnitaIvanaMartini@reddit
Baking powder makes it fluff up
dantemortemalizar@reddit
Yellow is not a flavor, it’s just the color of the cake.
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
no?
Popular-Local8354@reddit
Yes. It’s a thing, have you not seen it?
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
Never
Popular-Local8354@reddit
Huh.
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
I've honestly never heard of that before. I've only ever made cakes from scratch or bought them from a bakery.
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
When I call my local bakery to order my favorite cake, I ask for yellow cake with chocolate buttercream. It’s objectively a thing. Not sure how you missed it.
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
The bakeries I go to either don't have that flavor, or don't call it that. I always go in person and look at the menu.
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
I’d say the fancier the bakery, the less likely to use that name. They probably call it something pretentious like “vanilla bean cake” or “golden butter cake” or something.
My favorite (non-homemade) cake is from a local grocery store chain bakery. They just call it “yellow cake.”
I also don’t know how you have missed this info in your life. I’d say it’s pretty common/well-known.
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
'Gold butter cake' is one I've seen a lot. Is yellow cake something that's exclusively sold as cake mix or in grocery stores?
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
I don’t think so. When I googled “yellow cake” after first seeing this post, I found a bunch of from-scratch recipes. Since there are 2 very common vanilla cakes in the US, the easiest way to differentiate them is by the color (white vs yellow). IMO, white is vastly inferior to yellow.
Either way, the boxed mixes are so common as to be universal. Even if you just go in the baking aisle of your grocery store to get ingredients for your own bakes, you’ve almost definitely passed a myriad of “yellow cake” boxes.
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
IDK, I've just never heard of it, and I'm not used to seeing that shade of yellow in baked goods. The few times I've baked anything, I've just asked my mom for a recipe, and I don't pay attention to cake mixes in the store.
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
King Arthur did a comparison, and while the box mix is decidedly more yellow (likely artificially enhanced), the homemade recipes are still distinctly yellow, especially compared to a white cake recipe.
I guess I’m saying that your lack of awareness of it doesn’t lessen the ubiquity of yellow cake.
ZozicGaming@reddit
So when you buy your baking supplies you just ignore the half or more of the baking aisle that's just boxed mixes of various baked goods?
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
Yea, I've never had any reason to look closely at them. I'm rarely in that aisle anyway.
AuraCrash78@reddit
Yellow cakes can easily be made from scratch. It's white cake with whole eggs (rather than just the whites). Are you really gonna claim you've never had white cake either?
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
I've had cakes that were white, but I've never heard it referred to as 'white cake'.
AuraCrash78@reddit
Then what the hell do you call white cake? You seem very limited...tbh.
manicpixidreamgirl04@reddit
The white cakes I've seen in bakeries are labeled as vanilla.
Popular-Local8354@reddit
Fair enough
burghfan@reddit
Yes, yellow cake is made with full eggs, giving it a richer flavor and hue. White cake uses only egg whites, making it lighter and fluffier. Both are common in boxed cake mixes along with chocolate, red velvet, lemon, etc
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
Exactly. And it’s “yellow” vanilla, to differentiate it from “white” vanilla. As a baker, I never questioned it because it was clear why it was called that and what it is meant to be compared to, but looking from the outside in, I can see why it seems odd, though.
It’s not entirely as unsophisticated as it seems based on OP’s question.
amphigory_error@reddit
White cake is often almond rather than vanilla - "wedding cake" flavor versus "birthday cake" flavor
No-Author-2358@reddit
Yellow cake with chocolate frosting has been my favorite since childhood. It was also my father's favorite.
pineapples_are_evil@reddit
Set a cup of yellow batter aside, add a few tablespoons of cocoa powder to the cup... mix, blob on and swirl through rest of cake batter the then we have even better. MARBLED with Chocolate icing!!
Yellow or Marble cake are so good. I love a super rich fudge chocolate cake (extra egg and butter, or mayo) with a fudge or ganache like frosting for my birthday though... with French Vanilla ice cream
That would hit the spot right now. A good piece of yellow, marble or cocoa cake with chocolate frosting and ice cream.
jlsteiner728@reddit
Favorite in my family, too. In fact, I have one in the oven as we speak.
Impatient_Orca@reddit
Yellow with chocolate frosting is the best, hands down no question
quaid4@reddit
Every year for my birthday I make a strawberry cake with chocolate frosting. I suggest giving it a go :) cake based chocolate covered strawberries!
Dr_mombie@reddit
Make strawberry cake with brownie egg water and butter ratio. Then top it with hot fudge.
MissFabulina@reddit
I hope there is a typo here, because 'brownie egg water' doesn't sound appetizing. 😁
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
I think they mean to use the ratios for egg, oil, and water from a brownie mix, and bake a strawberry cake mix into dense, chewy strawberry cookie bars.
Because I also cannot get behind “brownie egg water” if they mean anything else.
MissFabulina@reddit
They fixed it. Thankfully! Apparently it was a pre-coffee comment. Brownie egg water does not sound appetizing!
Dr_mombie@reddit
Typo. I haven't had my coffee yet lol
lalacourtney@reddit
This is THE birthday cake. I am craving now. Birthday is in two months 🤩
Scavgraphics@reddit
Did you know that as an adult, you can have birthday cake whenever you want? And no one can stop you...or even check your ID!!!
randomname5478@reddit
I bought a cake at the local place and took it home. The cashier asked whose birthday. I said no one. I was surprising the wife with a cake. She looked like she had never thought about just buying a sheet cake for a random day.
Justin__D@reddit
As someone who is now craving cake thanks to this thread, but does not have a wife to use as an excuse... Note to self: Self-checkout.
Scavgraphics@reddit
But what if the cashier is a single woman who likes cake and offers to share with you?
Outrageous_Cow8409@reddit
If you go to the cashier and they ask what it's for, answer is always "work party."
MayoManCity@reddit
do you think the cashier is gonna call you out as maidenless
giraflor@reddit
Yes! My mom was not a baker, but she’d buy one from Berger’s (famous for their cookies).
I’m always happy to meet other people whose favorite birthday cake isn’t white icing with sprinkles.
Anthrodiva@reddit
Berger cookies... Homer drooling dot gif
Impatient_Orca@reddit
Right? My birthday is in a week and I think I'll buy myself a little one as a treat 🎂
stiletto929@reddit
Chocolate cake with chocolate frosting is the best, and I will die on this hill. ;)
StrawberriKiwi22@reddit
My husband’s birthday is today. This is what he has requested, yellow cake with chocolate frosting.
model563@reddit
Yall should try a Smith Island cake if you can.
DMfortinyplayers@reddit
Try using Nutella instead of frosting.
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
Nutella doesn’t exactly spread the way you want frosting to. What about a chocolate hazelnut French buttercream?
Will_White@reddit
Whip the Nutella into an American buttercream.
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
That might be a touch too far on the sweetness scale for me, as I am already not a huge American buttercream fan, but I’ll bet that would work like a charm for someone with a sweeter palate than mine.
Will_White@reddit
Yeah it's very sweet. I do it with banana cake, straight Nutella for the filling and the Nutella Buttercream for the frosting.
DMfortinyplayers@reddit
I put the Nutella in a bowl and warm it gently in the microwave.
That being said, chocolate hazelnut French buttercream sounds divine.
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
That is probably amazing, especially if we’re talking a classic 9x13” cake-in-a-pan. Perfect for a weeknight treat! (I’m gonna do it, and my Nutella-loving kids will think it’s amazing. So thanks!)
I’m envisioning trying to frost a layer cake with Nutella and the meltdown of rage that would trigger in me, which led me to immediately recalculate that journey to one that doesn’t end in an explosion off the side of a cliff.
Cheers! But with cake! Cake-cheers!
shelwood46@reddit
I often half-ass that by using Nutella on (store bought) pound cake.
mcsangel2@reddit
Oh yeahhhhh
EmilyAnneBonny@reddit
It's yellow cake with chocolate pudding in my family. Divine.
Danibelle903@reddit
This is, by far, the best box cake combo
seanodnnll@reddit
My favorite as well.
HeyItsReallyME@reddit
That’s what Harriet the Spy ate every day after school!
oldladylikesflowers@reddit
Yes! My dad didn’t ever cook, but he always made the chocolate frosting for our yellow cake. It was sooo good. I miss it and I miss him!
Linzabee@reddit
It’s my favorite too!
Anthrodiva@reddit
Same, it's elite.
DopeyDame@reddit
Yellow cake with chocolate frosting is to cake what chocolate chip cookies are to cookies: simply the best and ubiquitous for a reason.
marvsup@reddit
Specifically, buttercream chocolate, IMO.
draculinaaa@reddit
okay, but have you ever made this cake into ice cream cone cupcakes? top tier.
fueelin@reddit
Oh my god I haven't thought of those in like 30 years! I'm definitely doing this soon!
Remarkable-Rush-9085@reddit
I just recently had a bad week and made up a yellow cake with chocolate buttercream frosting and put it in a bundt pan to feel a little extra. It was honestly the best pick me up, I highly recommend.
Mondschatten78@reddit
Ooo, never thought to try it in a bundt pan!
Mondschatten78@reddit
Also mine, especially if home made!
unripe_mangosteen@reddit
My family always did boxed lemon with chocolate frosting
chaosisapony@reddit
This combo makes the best birthday cake. It's always been my favorite.
librarianjenn@reddit
Same! It’s just such a great combination
WonderingLost8993@reddit
Omg yes! I woke up this morning craving this exact cake which is unusual. Then this shows up on my reddit feed.
Intelligent-Invite79@reddit
Same here, such a great combo.
Loganpowered@reddit
My dad just turned 80, per request we are made him a yellow cake with chocolate frosting!!
Fit-Distribution2303@reddit
Omg yes. On the rare occasion I make a cake those flavors transport me to childhood.
RipeMangoDevourer@reddit
Me too! It's the best
kerrykcb@reddit
Yes!!!
MollyOMalley99@reddit
It's my husband's favorite.
NCLAXMOM26@reddit
This is the best !!
Stock_Difference_346@reddit
White often has almond flavoring as well.
Which_Loss6887@reddit
Could be misremembering some of this, but I believe this all stems from the “homemaker” culture of the 50s-60s, and that culture’s eventual downfall. Time was when the average middle class American SAHM knew the “proper” names for a dozen or more different types/flavors of cake and more or less understood the technical differences between them. As the 60s fell into the 70s and 80s, many of those women’s children never learned those names, but they knew that white vanilla cake tastes different enough from yellow vanilla cake as to not really be the same flavor, and for whatever reasons we ended up shortening this into calling the white one “vanilla” and the yellow one “yellow.”
Amardella@reddit
Well, your dates are wrong, to start with. Our family was eating yellow cake mix and white cake mix in the 1960s. No such thing as vanilla cake mix. And we knew the difference is egg yolks in yellow, no egg yolks in white.
My mom (born 1934) loved cake mixes, because she grew up with a coal stove to heat with and cook on. No thermostat. You just cooked stuff "till it's done" according to how hot your fire was, and you learned how to build the fire to cook "slow" or "fast", hence you see those terms in old recipes. Grandma was still cooking that way in the 1980s.
They usually just made spiders (cakes baked in a skillet on top of the stove, like pineapple upside down cake) because it was hard to bake a cake in the actual fire chamber. Same for cornbread and biscuits. Did you know you can make lovely flaky biscuits in a skillet on the stovetop? You need a lid, but they are incredible.
The fluffy, light, perfect cakes that issued from those cake mixes baked in an oven with a thermostat were a miracle to Mother. She still made her red velvet from scratch, though. Vinegar, soda and cocoa with cooked flour (ermine) frosting. No red food coloring or cream cheese in sight.
Which_Loss6887@reddit
I guess the thing I heard was a buncha bullshit, then. Thanks for correcting!
Amardella@reddit
Nah, maybe just off on the dates.
No-Gas5342@reddit
I agree with your assessment! It’s a bit of a rustic way to describe but not like yellow is the flavor.
burghfan@reddit
Cake mixes are weird. Especially when you learn about their history (to sell molasses) and their role in food/grocery marketing.
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
Ooh, interesting! That sounds like it would make a good episode of Weird History Food or something.
silkywhitemarble@reddit
There's an episode from the series "(The?)Foods That Build America" on The History Channel that talks about the history of Betty Crocker and boxed cake mixes.
ZozicGaming@reddit
Its not some grand conspiracy. Cake mix came about because back in the olden days baking a cake was basically the ultimate house wife skill. Since back before standardized measurements and modern temperature controlled oven it was a really hard thing to do. Boxed cake mix helped solve many of the problems with baking a cake.
princessglitterbutt@reddit
And the history about adding/not adding eggs
burghfan@reddit
The whole "bad housewife" theory has actually been debunked. It seems it was more about overall quality, but still only discovered because of focus groups
RichInBunlyGoodness@reddit
Actually, it is more unsophisticated than it seems.
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
How do you mean?
Alfredthegiraffe20@reddit
Til the USA have something called white cake and it's common enough to have a box mix version. I also learned that yellow cake is bog standard vanilla sponge. Why can't it be called that?
Candid-Effective7347@reddit
Because American cake is different than the British equivalent. Most American cakes are airier, moister, and sweeter. They use oil, cake flour, and higher sugar content and are typically covered in frosting. Typically used for celebratory purposes i.e. birthday, promotion, graduation, etc.
British sponge cakes are drier, denser, and less sweet. They rely on creaming butter and self-rising flour for structure.
White cake is literally just vanilla flavored cake made with egg whites to give it to white appearance. The alternative would be yellow vanilla which is made with whole egg which makes it look yellow. It is not as airy and a littler denser. We have box mix versions of both as well as many other flavors such as carrot, lemon, chocolate, red velvet, etc.
The closest American equivalent to a British sponge cake would be an Angel Food Cake or a pound cake but it's denser and richer.
MissFabulina@reddit
Sponge sounds unappetizing, don't you think? I don't want to eat a sponge (it is that dirty, squishy, slimy thing that your mom leaves on the bottom of the sink...just soaking up the germs). But you do you. We won't judge.
Different countries call the same things different names - all...the...time. just look at all the different parts of a car. Boot & bonnet in the UK vs. trunk & hood in the US.
But, the texture of an American yellow cake is different than a Victoria sponge. The yellow cake has a much more tender crumb (super soft and fluffy) than the sponge. You guys seem to like to be able to pick up a slice of cake in your hands (at least if I go by all the British movies and shows that I watch). The cake has to be pretty sturdy (i.e. less tender) to be able to do that.
Now I want some yellow cake with chocolate icing, darn it! It is sooooo good.
qrysdonnell@reddit
Also uranium.
Cant-Take-Jokes@reddit
Yeah and it’s delicious
FunDivertissement@reddit
Yes and its delicious
nippleflick1@reddit
Yellow not a flavor, if that's what you're saying, but vanilla, lemon are two yellow colored cake mix flavors.
jackfaire@reddit
Yeah I got some Yellow Cake but what ingredient is Ura Nium?
HeyPurityItsMeAgain@reddit
Yellow cake is a specific kind of layer cake with butter and egg yolks. The crumb is yellow as opposed to white. Goes great with chocolate frosting... There's a box mix for those who don't bake.
PrettyBaby000@reddit
yes
WafflesFriendsWork99@reddit
Yes and it is my favorite flavor! Yellow cake with chocolate frosting is the best.
annagph@reddit
As others have said it’s common but what they’ve failed to mention how delicious it is! Definitely try to get your hands on some if you can :) it’s normally paired with chocolate frosting.
Sarnewy@reddit
"Yellow Cake" is made with whole egg, vanilla extract, and shortening and/or oil.
"White "Cake" is made with egg whites, vanilla and almond extracts, and shortening and/or oil.
Using butter (rather than shortening and/or oil) gives you a "Butter Cake".
Personally, I like Yellow Cake better than Butter Cake as I feel shortening makes a better texture than butter.
quietlywatching6@reddit
Yep, its just a plain cake that uses full eggs or extra yolks. It's less vanilla-y than a vanilla cake.
A white cake uses egg whites only, and often results in a fluffy but less mouthful cake. So is less appealing to most American palates.
astrologicaldreams@reddit
yeah, i've got some in my pantry right now lmao
SideEyeFeminism@reddit
Yes. And it is best served with thick chocolate icing
rocky8u@reddit
America loves color flavored cake. There is also white cake, rainbow cake, red velvet cake, marbled cake, pink cake, all sorts of colors.
GreenBeanTM@reddit
1) yellow cake is vanilla flavored. Yellow cake is the type of cake.
2) same with white cake.
3) no one says “rainbow cake” in reference to flavor or type.
4) red velvet cake is a specific type of chocolate cake (it’s also called that in other countries)
5) also not referring to the flavor, but referring to half mixing 2 flavors together.
6) again, not flavor or type of cake. If someone asks for a pink cake they just mean the color.
TomDestry@reddit
Don't ask about the flavour of their coffee cake.
GreenBeanTM@reddit
Don’t ask the flavor of your tea cake.
MortimerDongle@reddit
Yes, it's just vanilla cake with extra egg but I'd guess the boxed kind is just dyed
criesatpixarmovies@reddit
White and yellow cake mix vary in their preparation. For white cake you use egg whites only and for yellow you use whole eggs.
I accidentally make yellow cake from white cake mix by not separating the eggs when I was a kid.
ground__contro1@reddit
Did it taste any different?
criesatpixarmovies@reddit
More… rich I guess? Also the vanilla flavoring was slightly different from actual yellow cake mix, but I couldn’t guess as to why that would be.
The3rdBert@reddit
They just use powdered eggs in the mixes that require water only.
Theoiscool@reddit
MJ
Regular_Boot_3540@reddit
Yes! But you can also make yellow cake from scratch. It's not just a product on supermarket shelves.
_purse@reddit
Haha yes, it’s very good. It’s like a richer vanilla flavor.
DogDelicious9212@reddit
There’s no yellow flavor duh.
avicia@reddit
in contrast bakers who want VERY white cake and buttercream, like for weddings sometimes use clear vanilla extract or particular brands of butter than are paler in color and sometimes a little white or purple food coloring to neutralize any yellow tones. Instead of going to all that effort, you can use whatever butter, whatever vanilla, and the whole egg, and have yellow cake.
cdev12399@reddit
Yellow cake flavor can be a bit spicy.
MetroBS@reddit
Yellow is not a flavor. This particular cake has been called “yellow cake” in the English language for as long as it has existed
Mr_BillyB@reddit
Not to be confused with yellow cake uranium.
ProbablyDrunkOK@reddit
Do not drop that shit
Leather_Rate_9785@reddit
There is an excellent episode of Good Eats on yellow cake.
hakumiogin@reddit
That's mostly true. The flavor isn't yellow. The flavor is vanilla. Yellow cake is a type of cake, like pound cake or angel food cake. It's basically just a little richer than a standard vanilla cake (aka white cake), usually due to extra egg yolks. It's not dense like a pound cake, but it's essentially a very fluffy pound cake.
Vegetable-Shirt-4319@reddit
Yes and because its a pretty consistant mix of ingredients, it forms the base of many store biugh professional cakes. Similar to buying all purpose flour instead of milling amd hulling your own wheat and adding trace other ingredients. Bakeries buy it in bulk. OP has likely eaten it without knowing.
MissFabulina@reddit
It is a softer, fluffier Victoria sponge...to put it in the OP's parlance.
G17Gen3@reddit
You appear to be from the DC metro area. Have you never been in a grocery before? Or are you just bullshitting?
ChaosTorpedo@reddit
Yes and it’s my favorite
MamaMimosa@reddit
It's my dad's favorite. Specifically "yellow cake with chocolate icing."
RanjuMaric@reddit
"yellow" is not the flavor, it's the descriptor
Ok-Cap-204@reddit
The eggs yolks will make the cake a yellow color in homemade cakes. I would bet the boxed cake mixes contain some type of dye or coloring. American food producers love to dye our food.
ConscientiousDissntr@reddit
Yes, it is a little denser and more buttery, like 3/4 regular cake and 1/4 pound cake.
R3ddit_N0ob@reddit
Yes, and it's fucking delicious 😋
2PlasticLobsters@reddit
It's delicious, and works with any kind of frosting. My favorite, in fact, by a wide margin.
Hmm, come to think about it, I have a box of yellow cake mix in the cupboard right now.
brinns_way@reddit
Yes and with chocolate frosting on top, it is fantastic.
OranginaOOO@reddit
Yellow cake uranium is named after yellow cake.
WrongJohnSilver@reddit
Ah, the delicious difference between yellow cake and yellowcake!
Charlesinrichmond@reddit
Yes, but it's a national embarrassment. Can we please not talk about it?
indifferentunicorn@reddit
Yes yellow cake to accompany yellow corn, yellow mac n chz and yellow chicken tendies.
The color of sunshine.
BrotherNatureNOLA@reddit
Yellow is the type, not the flavor. The flavor is butter and vanilla.
IJustWorkHere000c@reddit
All I know is, you better not drop that shit.
mayhem14@reddit
Best answer on the thread. 😁
citizen-salty@reddit
That’s why we wrap it in the special CIA napkin.
criesatpixarmovies@reddit
And eggs with yolks.
phridoo@reddit
Yes, and it is by far the best cake mix you can get.
lewisae0@reddit
Everyone mad about this- what flavor is red velvet???
Right it refers to a type of cake.
SoStarstruckk@reddit
Kind of, it’s usually vanilla.
Ok_Preference6999@reddit
Yellow cake was my dad's favorite. With chocolate frosting. He never wanted anything else. ❤️ I'll never have to make one again 💔
Top_Bluejay_5323@reddit
Betty Crocker lemon cake. How hard is that?
AuraCrash78@reddit
Yellow cake as not the same as lemon cake.
AuraCrash78@reddit
Hey OP....still waiting to hear what your issue is.......
ZenNihilism@reddit
OP is a troll. Comment history shows they're in MD/DC area. They know what the fuck yellow cake is.
Edithasburglar@reddit
FFS- people stop and think about it for a second, to someone who did not grow up with this variety of cake, they’re thinking yellow is a color not a flavor. For the smart aleck who decides to mention orange beverages, come on, you know that orange is a fruit as well as a color, while yellow is not.
ZenNihilism@reddit
Bro lives in Maryland/DC. This is not a good faith question.
shadehiker@reddit
Yes and it is delicious!
explosive-diorama@reddit
White cake tends to have less egg, or at least less egg yolk, and is lighter in texture. Yellow cake has egg yolk and tends to be more moist and a bit richer.
getElephantById@reddit
Do they not have yellow cake in Maryland?
zoppaTheDim@reddit
Yes
Tastes different than “white.”
Extreme-Green-9652@reddit
Yellow cake is a vanilla cake made with whole eggs (the batter is yellow). White cake is vanilla cake made with egg whites (the batter is white).
Capable_Suit_7335@reddit
White = egg whites
Yellow = full eggs
Google = answers
codenameajax67@reddit
Yes it's a light butter cake.
Traditional_Entry183@reddit
Its essentially the default cheap cake. The base model. White is always nicer.
caryn1477@reddit
Yes
bizoticallyyours83@reddit
Yeah, it's just a sweet, kinda boring cake flavor.
bmaasse@reddit
Its my favorite. With chocolate frosting.
RCoaster42@reddit
FYI. YellowCake is very much a thing, and it should not be eaten. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yellowcake.
Rustmutt@reddit
Yellow cake. I had it for my birthday this week it’s my favorite when covered in chocolate icing and sprinkles. Just a box yellow cake, nothing fancy, no special name.
iteachag5@reddit
Yes. It’s just vanilla
ajcm1125@reddit
Sadly. Yes.
oswin13@reddit
Yes, and it is delicious
Reader124-Logan@reddit
Less of a flavor than a recipe.
Homemade “yellow cake” includes: granulated sugar, butter, whole eggs, flour, baking powder, salt, milk and vanilla extract.
The box mix is just a convenience.
whitecollarredneck@reddit
Yeah. I bake a lot of cakes. If I make a vanilla cake with just egg whites and clear vanilla, it ends up white (like a wedding cake). If I make a vanilla cake with whole eggs (and a couple extra yolks) and regular vanilla, it comes out yellow.
EdgeCityRed@reddit
I think I'm going to try this with clear almond extract.
LeopoldTheSnail@reddit
I made my wedding cake with egg whites, clear vanilla, and clear almond extract, with an almond flavored cream cheese buttercream ish frosting.
Put raspberry jam between the layers, I promise you it's the best cake ever.
EdgeCityRed@reddit
OMG that is so similar to my wedding cake! The baker did an almond amaretto white cake flavoring with raspberry filling. It was so, so good!
LeopoldTheSnail@reddit
That's so cool! Great minds think alike or something. My husband always asks me to make a tiny version for our anniversary every year lol which is nice because we didn't need to save a layer in the freezer or anything like that. Half the time now I just doctor up a white cake mix to taste the same and save myself 90% of the effort.
EdgeCityRed@reddit
Married 30 years here, so it was a lucky and effective wedding cake!!
I really need to perfect the cake flavoring and make it sometimes. :)
Weird-Response-1722@reddit
I feel like “white” cake is more like a chiffon cake and “yellow” is closer to pound cake, richer and heavier on the vanilla-butter notes.
balthisar@reddit
It's not a flavor, anymore than "white" is a flavor. It's a style or variety.
Flimsy_Equal8841@reddit
The difference is you use whole eggs in yellow cake and only the whites in white. It tastes the same to me.
AdEastern9303@reddit
Yes, and we have a drinks with a flavor called “orange”.
LeopoldTheSnail@reddit
Well, I mean, orange is a flavor as well as a color. We named the color after the fruit, if I recall correctly.
Dinastar13@reddit
Yes! It's my favorite flavor!
Lumpy_Paint_3766@reddit
I used boxed yellow cake yesterday as a base to make an almond sheet cake with coconut buttercream 😏
Mummifiedsu@reddit
Yer if you are from the uk it’s like a weak Victoria sponge. It’s not as rich because it’s lacking the butter (oil is used instead) but you get the colour from the egg yolks.
SaoirseMayes@reddit
It's not a flavor, it's just a type of cake. It's yellow because it uses whole eggs, white cake only uses egg whites.
one-off-one@reddit
Oh come on, next you’re going to have me omit strips of velvet from my grandma’s red velvet cake recipe
Baby_In_A-Trenchcoat@reddit
Yes
SuspiciousJuice5825@reddit
It's just vanilla. And the butter you add gives it a butter flavor too.
TheMrsH1124@reddit
Wait, other countries don't have yellow cake?!?!!!
limbodog@reddit
Dick Cheney reportedly had a thing for it for years and was searching for it all over Iraq.
Comprehensive-Tea-69@reddit
Yes it’s delicious with chocolate frosting especially
idkman1768@reddit
Yes
HarlotHistory@reddit
Yeah! Yellow cake is very very common. It’s like white vanilla cake, but white cake is made with egg whites and yellow cake uses whole eggs. Yellow cake is usually richer than white cake but they are both flavored with vanilla usually
There are a ton of flavors of boxed cake mixes. They’re just like home made cake mix, but minus the wet ingredients
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
I feel like there is a register difference between white and yellow cake, too. White cake feels more front-door, and yellow cake feels more kitchen-door to me. Like, you make a white cake to show off that you can beat egg whites and fold them into a batter, but you make yellow cake for people you actually love because it tastes better.
BreadPuddding@reddit
I wouldn’t say yellow cake necessarily tastes better. It’s different, and has different uses. There’s a recipe for white buttermilk cake in The Joy of Cooking that is melt-in-your-mouth delicious while still light and fluffy.
CalculatedWhisk@reddit
You’re right, white cake can absolutely be delicious, and buttermilk (or sour cream, or yogurt, or whatever) does a lot of the legwork there. I often make white cake, especially for orders. But there’s something about the richer and more unfussy nature of yellow cake that feels more homey and comforting.
MissFabulina@reddit
You are absolutely right. But when I was a kid, I never understood it, because the yellow cake is better than the white cake in every way. More tender, moister, more flavorful, etc.
The white cake is more sturdy, though. So, if you were making a multi-tiered, heavily decorated cake, you did a white cake. Wedding cakes tend to be white cakes because of this. I don't think it is because it looks "pure", but I guess I could be wrong!
krittyyyyy@reddit
Yeah yellow cake is common but weirdly when it’s used in cupcakes it’s referred to by its frosting flavor, like a vanilla cupcake vs a yellow cupcake.
justanameform@reddit
Based on the OP's post history, I don't believe this is asked in good faith.
sierra-echo-november@reddit
Yes, and there are many other flavors that also come in boxes
MissFabulina@reddit
You can make a yellow cake from scratch, as well. The "yellow" color is from the egg yolks. We also have white cake, which is only made with the whites of the eggs. They are both vanilla flavored cakes, though some people add almond extract to white cakes. I don't know why they want to ruin their cake with fake almond (the extract is made from cherry pits, I believe), but there is no accounting for taste.
I love yellow cake, with a super chocolatey icing. Mmm mmm good.
SteampunkExplorer@reddit
No. There's a common type of cake that, like most cakes, can be made from scratch but also has a boxed mix available, and the type of cake is called "yellow cake". The color comes from egg yolks.
HootingSloth@reddit
Although this is an extremely common cake and of course it says "yellow" on the box, I don't ever really hear people refer to it as "yellow" cake. If someone said "yellow cake" to me without context, I would probably think of uranium before Betty Crocker. I most often here people refer to this as "birthday cake" or "vanilla cake," as leaving the egg yolks in seems more like the default option with a white vanilla cake being reserved for something with more elaborate decoration.
Judgy-Introvert@reddit
Not really only because the flavor isn’t yellow. That’s just the color of the cake. The flavor is vanilla.
Judgy-Introvert@reddit
Not really only because the favor isn’t yellow. That’s just the color of the cake. The flavor is vanilla.
HackDaddy85@reddit
It’s the best cake flavor. And then you add chocolate frosting to it.
languagelover17@reddit
Yes, I use it all the time.
Ok_Neighborhood_470@reddit
I made a yellow cake from scratch once. 6 whole eggs. It's a very rich cake.
Gustav55@reddit
Yellow cake mix is great, it's the base for how my mom made her chocolate chip cookies, id have to look but I think it was the same recipe as the box but only using one egg and maybe less oil.
orcas-@reddit
Yep it’s my favorite!
Aside-Flimsy@reddit
Mine, too! It’s the best with chocolate frosting.
KnowOneHere@reddit
Yellow cake 🤤
I lived near a hostess factory and would detour just to drive by it to smell that yummy yellow goodness.
Murderhornet212@reddit
Yes. It’s my favorite!
machagogo@reddit
That's not meant to be the flavor... the cake is vanilla , the color is yellow as opposed to white as one has full egg, and the other only egg whites
radandsadgal@reddit
If you want it in Australia the brand Greens has a ‘butter cake’ which is basically the same thing, other countries probably have butter cake too
TallCommission7139@reddit
Yeah, and if you're Iranian the guy at the check out counter will always have a smartass remark ready just for you.
jojokangaroo1969@reddit
Yes absolutely and my favorite cake of all time is yellow cake with chocolate frosting.
friedpotato93@reddit
It’s basically just normal white cake but you don’t separate out the egg yolks
Hurdlelocker@reddit
It’s so common, it’s also an occasional ice cream flavor! (Which I had a scoop of from a local shop this weekend and it was delicious)
TheJokersChild@reddit
Yes there is. A lot of "homemade" cake is made this way.
oneislandgirl@reddit
Yes. Yellow cake mix. It is kind of like plain maybe with a hint of vanilla.
User_Anon_0001@reddit
It’s why we went into Iraq the second time
AcceptableLoquat@reddit
Tbf I would absolutely go to war to get my hands on some yellow cake (with chocolate frosting, obvs)
headshotdoublekill@reddit
Don’t drop that shit!
Ok_Story_3454@reddit
Too late, we already down-winded St. George!
El_Kameleon@reddit
I got it here in this special CIA napkin
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
Lol yes. I think it's technically vanilla
Raibean@reddit
Yeah, it’s basic vanilla cake. White cake is made with just egg whites iirc and yellow is with the entire egg.
Bright_Ices@reddit
Yellow cake is what you make when you make a cake with whole eggs. White cake is cake made with only the egg whites. They have a different taste and people have preferences.
GingerTea69@reddit
Yes and I also think it's weird that we have that. Purple is a very distinct flavor too. Not grapes. Purple. And blue raspberry. That's another flavor. But yeah yellow cake? Exists here.
Playful_Question538@reddit
I think so. I believe it tastes like vanilla but I don't really eat cake.
NecessaryPopular1@reddit
Also, pound cake is golden-yellow with a caramelized golden-brown crust. It’s delicious.
BrazilianButtCheeks@reddit
Yes .. it’s like butter flavored lol
No_Thought_7776@reddit
Yellow is the color of this vanilla flavored cake, as opposed to a white colored cake, which does not have egg yolks added.
Hope this clears things up. Now that you point it out, it does sound very odd. I guess it becomes so ingrained that it's perceived as normal.
Good question ⁉️
EMAW2008@reddit
Jiffy?
RectorAequus@reddit
Yes, and it's the best boxed cake.
It's a buttery vanilla sponge cake and when you make it from scratch the yellow color comes from the egg yolks.
Best served with chocolate buttercream.
Rimurooooo@reddit
Yep it’s my favorite boxed cake. Tastes so spongy and yummy
YoshiandAims@reddit
Yep! Yellow cake with chocolate frosting is a common sight in the region where I grew up. A very simple crowd pleaser, lol.
pyramidalembargo@reddit
OP, yellow cakes have been a thing in the US since at least the Victorian era.
It's basically a white cake that uses the whole egg instead of just the whites.
rkb70@reddit
Yes. White cake is vanilla flavored cake that only has egg whites. Yellow cake has egg yolks, also.
caseygwenstacy@reddit
Mmmm, Uranium… tasty
Fireguy9641@reddit
Yes, and it's the best cake, esp when paired with vanilla icing.
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
CHOCOLATE ICING!!!!
Shelisheli1@reddit
Yep
Boba_Fett_is_Senpai@reddit
My sister once made a yellow cake that tasted like scrambled eggs, still not sure how because the crumb was normal
PreciousLoveAndTruth@reddit
Yep.
linkxrust@reddit
yellow, white, chocolate
pepperw2@reddit
Mmmm. Yep, and it is delicious.
coldequation@reddit
It's actually uranium flavored, but we're not supposed to talk about it.
szayl@reddit
Yes
Bluemonogi@reddit
It is called “yellow cake” because of the color but the flavor is kind of buttery vanilla. It has egg yolks in it.
It is a type of cake. It was originally called butter cake but came to be known as yellow cake. It is still yellow cake even if you make it from scratch. It is classic to pair it with chocolate frosting.
tsukiii@reddit
Yep
houdini31@reddit
It is just vanilla cake with yellow food coloring
Beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeess-@reddit
no, it’s yellow because of the eggs. if you make it at home homemade then it will also be yellow.
AuraCrash78@reddit
No.....just no.
husky_whisperer@reddit
<< dave-chappelle-yellow-cake.gif >>
Beeeeeeeeeeeeeeeess-@reddit
the flavor is vanilla
Terrible-Image9368@reddit
Yes
PabloPicasshooole@reddit
Yellowcake is the bomb
lexicon951@reddit
Yellow cake is my FAVORITE. I’m not sure flavor-wise the exact difference between yellow cake and white cake, but yellow cake tastes so much better. IMO white cake tastes trashy like either plain or chemically idk but it doesn’t taste as moist and delectable as yellow cake does
manderifffic@reddit
Yes and it's fucking delicious. I think it's supposed to be butter cake.
Remote_Hour_841@reddit
Add some sherry, a box of vanilla pudding mix and a tsp of nutmeg to yellow cake mix—that’s my family’s recipe for “wine cake”. I always make it for my mom’s and my birthdays.
Ziegelmarkt@reddit
LOL! The way you word it makes it sound like a culinary abortion. It’s basically vanilla flavored and yellow is the color. Now why it isn’t called that compared to its blacker cousin chocolate; I do not know.
Chocolate tends to be drier and “yellow” more moist. Skilled bakers can blend the two in a “swirl” but it’s more common to bake one yellow and one chocolate (see how hard it is to interchange?) shove them together side by side and hide the seam with icing. That way fans of both flavors can get what they like at a party,
CowboysFTWs@reddit
It is also the best
malachite_13@reddit
Yeah …yellow cake ….it’s good you should try it
jesusmansuperpowers@reddit
Not just uranium anymore
brunetteblonde46@reddit
Yes, usually with chocolate frosting.
turkeyisdelicious@reddit
Was looking for this comment!
WoodwifeGreen@reddit
There's also 'white cake'. It has egg whites, no yolks. Vanilla flavor.
White cake for pale color for subtle decorations, like a wedding cake, or high contrast, like a kid's birthday cake.
Yellow cake for more rustic type cakes, like a classic yellow cake with chocolate frosting.
Intelligent-Invite79@reddit
Yellow cake with chocolate icing is up there for me. Such a classic combo!
LastandLeast@reddit
Yes. If you throw some butter in and mix until it's like damp sand you can put it on top of fruit and bake it to create a delicious crumble. That's all I've ever used yellow cake mix for anyway.
Zaidswith@reddit
It's what the cake is called. Yellow is not the flavor. It's yellow because of the yolk in the eggs.
AuraCrash78@reddit
What exactly is your issue/concern?
obtusewisdom@reddit
It doesn’t have to come in a box. There are homemade yellow cake recipes.
AmazingRefrigerator4@reddit
Yellow cake with chocolate frosting slaps.
Efficient-Ball4360@reddit
I actually pretty much never have yellow cake
Ok-Office6837@reddit
As many others have said, it’s very common. I find it disgusting and will usually turn it down if it’s offered to me. It’s just vanilla with whole eggs but something about it throws it off for me.
Warmasterwinter@reddit
Yep. It tastes like yellow cake.
nedshammer@reddit
Wait till you hear about purple flavor
Nottacod@reddit
It has whole eggs as opposed to a white cake which has egg whites. It's a color not a flavor.
Less-Load-8856@reddit
Of course. Flour + Eggs make it yellow.
Familiar-Debate-6786@reddit
Yes and it's the best one
Prestigious-Talk1112@reddit
Yes. Yellow cake is one of the most common cakes to bake at home. People even make yellow cake from scratch. It's just your basic cake.
iowaman79@reddit
As others have said, yellow is the color, not the actual flavor. It’s a vanilla cake mix that’s really easy for someone to make at home, it’s mostly used as a carrying device for whatever flavor icing you (or the person you’re making it for) like.
angrymurderhornet@reddit
Yes. It’s like white cake, but with whole eggs in the batter. Quite good, actually, especially with chocolate frosting!
StupidLemonEater@reddit
Yellow cake is an entirely traditional type of cake, the color comes from egg yolks and butter.
Yes, you can get it in a boxed cake mix, but you can make it from scratch too.
Cudi_buddy@reddit
Yea and it’s god damned delicious
microcorpsman@reddit
Yeah. It ain't vanilla and it ain't chocolate. Just plain cake.
rozzingit@reddit
yellow (and white) cake is absolutely vanilla cake. it's just differentiated as yellow and white cake to indicate the other ingredients (primarily the eggs used).
stringstringing@reddit
Yellow cake is vanilla
Azulaatlantica@reddit
I have no idea what yiu are talking about
sleepygrumpydoc@reddit
You’ve never heard of yellow cake? I feel like it’s a pretty common “flavor” for boxed cake mixes.
Popular-Local8354@reddit
Yellow cake
enchiridic@reddit
The flavor isn’t yellow, it’s describing the color (as opposed to white cake). The color difference is largely due to the use of whole eggs including yolks in yellow cake vs just egg whites in white cake
RedditWidow@reddit
This is something you could easily google by searching "US yellow cake mix"
But yes, we have yellow cake mix, it's flavored with vanilla but uses whole eggs, the whites and yolks, so it turns a yellow color
TressoftheEmeraldTea@reddit
Yes.
It’s just a vanilla flavored cake made with whole eggs (not just the whites), so it’s more yellow in color and has a richer taste.
You can buy the dry ingredients for the cake pre-mixed, so all you have to do is add the wet ingredients to make the batter. It’s in a bag that’s inside of a box. So it’s called box cake mix.
xAkumu@reddit
I'm pretty sure it's just vanilla with extra egg yolk + butter
GenFatAss@reddit
yup multiple brands has something similar https://www.pillsburybaking.com/products/moist-supreme/classic-yellow
msmovies12@reddit
Yes (never considered how dumb that is until now. lol)
theCynicalChicken@reddit
Lol, yes. The sort of standard boxed cake mix flavor is labeled as just "yellow"
CorpT@reddit
https://www.bettycrocker.com/products/betty-crocker-baking-and-cake-mixes/yellow
Incredibly common.