Psephos.cc - an experiment in self-moderation
Posted by Nuaua@reddit | RedditAlternatives | View on Reddit | 7 comments
Yet another reddit clone... but with a couple of twists.
-> https://www.psephos.cc/
Psephos (Ancient Greek: ψῆφος, romanized: psêphos; plural: psephoi, ψῆφοι) was a ballot used by jurors (dikastai) in the law courts of ancient Athens to cast a secret ballot.
Decentralized moderation
Reddit and many clones have the issue that moderation is mainly handled by a couple of unpaid volunteers. This creates two problems: the mods have too much arbitrary power, but at the same time they have too much work.
With small power comes low responsibility
To address this issue we tried a decentralized, jury-based moderation system. The site has site-wide rules and board (subs) specific ones. When reporting content the rule that was infringed has to be selected, if enough (n=1 currently) reports are made a jury of users is randomly selected to judge the case. To handle egregious cases rapidly board's admins can fast-track moderation, but the user can contest which will result in a jury being selected as in the "slow" path. In theory this system should scale better and avoid some of the issues with the "mod-king" model of reddit, but whether this actually works in practice remains to be seen.
Media views
Another issue with reddit is that e.g. images often take over text content, due to their mass appeal to our weak-willed human brains. For example the r/photography allows only text posts, as it would otherwise be overrun by images. But isn't it a bit ironic for a photography sub not to allow photographs? To solve this we introduced different views of a board: all / text / images / videos. That way different types of posts can coexist without cannibalizing each other.
No BS?
No ads, no tracking, no google, no AI, open-source (eventually), global-first ("news" is not about the USA), etc.
Give it a try
https://www.psephos.cc/
I've disabled email verification, so making an account should be easy.
FAQ
- Federated ? No, I'm not sure how that would work with moderation.
- Mobile app ? No.
- Economic model? Donation-based / non-profit (eventually)
- Bots ? No magic solution besides standard practices, but I think it's a big problem that will need some institutional solution (some form of privacy-respecting ID system)
BillGhost85@reddit
not very populated, but it'll do ;)
Nuaua@reddit (OP)
Yeah, it's hard to attract people, specially now that it becomes trivial to boot up such a project. Maybe it lacks something fun or a bit of personality, unlike new projects like cyberspace.online or cozy.talk. Although I think their opiniated design is also a bit of a tradeoff (gets old quicker).
BillGhost85@reddit
And what have you been doing to attract more users? SEO or social media?
Nuaua@reddit (OP)
Just social media for now.
CoupleAnxious8858@reddit
You should read about our project veridonia.com - when it comes to self moderation we're like you, but a bit more radical. We actually pass all new posts through jury like reviews before they get into the feed, not after
Nuaua@reddit (OP)
I think something like this could be cool once you have a decent userbase, but I think the main issues for small sites is to attract enough activity, so you want to make contributing as frictionless as possible.
Tight_Heron1730@reddit
Good job! We need more of this. Keep up the good work