Why does every British conversation sound mildly sarcastic?

[-]

thricedice88@reddit

Because yanks don't understand the concept of sarcasm, or how to use or perceive it correctly, for the most part.

[-]

Proud_Grapefruit63@reddit

Some of us confuse sarcasm with irony (and irony with coincidence.)

[-]

AshtonBlack@reddit

Sarcastic, me? An older British man steeped in centuries in a society that lauds "clever" comedy, word-play and puns?

I've never been so insulted in all my life. How very dare you! Sarcasm? Perish the thought.

[-]

I moved here 10 years ago and the sarcasm is one of my most favourite things 😂 there is an art and finesse to it and it’s amazing when someone has quick wits and manage to respond with a clever sarcastic response.

[-]

Efficient_Hyena_7476@reddit

Visit Liverpool. Nobody is sarcastic, there.

[-]

JungleyD@reddit

Yep - famous for the lack of sarcasm, Liverpool is.

[-]

caughtunaware@reddit

I don't know but honestly I feel we perhaps all don't sound sarcastic. I am Scottish and while we do love a bit of banter and sarcasm my ears don't hear all Brits as being the same.

For example to me the Welsh just sound so happy. Even when they're upset and kicking off (I used to work in a customer focused role). Some parts of Northern England just sound so warm and welcoming. I could go on. I love the variety out small island has.

[-]

JungleyD@reddit

The Highland lilt is so gentle they can say the most viciously appalling things and still sound like they're lovingly reassuring a toddler who has woken in the night from a bad dream.

[-]

Outside-Parfait-8935@reddit

It's in our blood. We basically can't converse without some sarcasm creeping in. Most of us find being genuine extremely difficult.

[-]

Adorable_Past9114@reddit

Really? You don't say

[-]

Fantastic-Cat-5252@reddit

I hope you have a VERY happy cake day

[-]

Adorable_Past9114@reddit

Ooh, so kind

[-]

n7shepard1987@reddit

Agreed, if i say say summat nice and sincere to my daughter she has to ask if I'm being sarcastic lol.

[-]

RNEngHyp@reddit

We are genuine though. Genuinely sarcastic!

But it does come from a place of being... well... erm... genuine.

Honest.

[-]

ResponsibleBend2195@reddit

What's genuine?

[-]

smartfellerayi@reddit

As a proud sarcastic Brit, you are getting my genuine self if I can be sarcastic with you.

If I can't, you're getting the mask.

[-]

Witty_Ad_2098@reddit

Because it is. It always makes me laugh when Americans feel the need to explain when they are being sarcastic. Sarcasm is cultural for us Brits.

[-]

JungleyD@reddit

/s 🙄

[-]

eatseveryth1ng@reddit

I cringe so hard when someone comments on Reddit in the most obviously sarcastic/facetious way and ends the comment with ‘ /s’

[-]

Gullible_Fan4427@reddit

But we have to because if not, we get people questioning our sarcasm.. and that’s sad 😔

[-]

alphahydra@reddit

The joy of sarcasm, and lots of other types of humour, depends on the recipient piecing together the right interpretation in their own mind (or it flying right over their head).

/s is like immediately explaining a joke. You might as well just not use sarcasm if you're going to label it, because it defeats the purpose.

[-]

FuzzyBreak5678@reddit

I think it should be actually illegal to use it in any British based subreddit.

[-]

hepheastus_87@reddit

Because that'll help.

[-]

NeilDeWheel@reddit

Somebody ought to invent a sarcasm detector.

[-]

SatiricalScrotum@reddit

Oh wow, a sarcasm detector. That’s a really useful invention.

[-]

Idonthinksom8@reddit

Oh do you now

[-]

JungleyD@reddit

I love it. It’s my absolute fave.

[-]

ArcherApprehensive18@reddit

Sometimes I feel like it must be an insult. Like "you're so dumb I need to signpost this for you".

[-]

AuroraDF@reddit

I recently got down voted massively in a thread which has people from across the world but is mostly Americans, because I made a sarcastic comment and didn't tag it with /s or whatever you're meant to do. The day Im required to start explaining whenever I'm being sarcastic is the day I stop speaking.

[-]

IntrepidMaybe8579@reddit

Whats weird is as a brit in America i can hardly tell when their being sarcastic and i dont get it… i think we have entirely different ways or maybe we just naturally recognize it more in eachother i think americans dont change their tone when they are maybe thats what trips me up

[-]

MisabelWearsNikes@reddit

Exactly. Americans are so literal that they need to have sarcasm explained, which defies the point of being sarcastic.

[-]

Kudosnotkang@reddit

Americans: I’m being sarcastic btw ^_^

Brit: Eurgh I think you just made me dumber hearing that obvious disclaimer

[-]

polkadotska@reddit

Americans value earnestness. Brits generally find that cringe. Speaking with sarcasm, archness, irony - these are playful ways of speaking that not only negate earnestness, but also allows you to show off wordplay/antiphrasis/litotes/self-deprecation/tone/a wide vocabulary.

[-]

Lanky-Big4705@reddit

Good word choice. In many situations here even the word ‘earnest’ is pejorative. We distrust overly straight people.

[-]

neverendum@reddit

What a great post, I need to look up some of these terms. Never heard of antiphrasis and litotes before.

[-]

AppearanceAwkward364@reddit

Earnestness itself is a form of sarcasm in the right context. It's a great weapon when used on certain people.

[-]

keepgoingguy@reddit

Hmmm, sure.

[-]

Status-Mousse5700@reddit

Surely not…

[-]

DeniseGunn@reddit

Have you ever watched Blackadder?

[-]

Background-Cap-9047@reddit

Usually because it is

[-]

BastardsCryinInnit@reddit

Does it.

[-]

StillJustJones@reddit

Hmm… you think so do you?

[-]

HelloRV3991@reddit

Da fuq you replying. Did it sound like a question.

[-]

Mammoth_logfarm@reddit

Found the non-Brit.

whoosh

[-]

Background-Cap-9047@reddit

r/whoosh

[-]

Virtual_Opinion_8630@reddit

Really?

[-]

OkGreen3481@reddit

Are you sure?

[-]

Background-Cap-9047@reddit

Really?

[-]

Maskedmarxist@reddit

What gave you that idea?

[-]

HelloRV3991@reddit

Got Sherlock Holmes in the house lads.

[-]

ConsciousBother4047@reddit

No flies on them

[-]

ConsciousBother4047@reddit

No flies on them

[-]

SherlockScones3@reddit

You rang?

[-]

pm_me_your_amphibian@reddit

Sherlock Homms

[-]

G7VFY@reddit

hmm. Sarcasm does require intelligence and character study,

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8k2AbqTBxao

[-]

SkepticalBelieverr@reddit

We’re so depressed we have to try put humour in everything

[-]

Artificial-Brain@reddit

Oh aye...

[-]

Incantanto@reddit

Genetic reflex. Culturally we don't like earnestness or sincerity, its seen as awkward and gauche, so sarcasm is our mother tongue

[-]

Fine-Night-243@reddit

It's this isn't it. Not so much sarcasm as a layer of irony so people don't think we are taking ourselves too seriously. I swear it's the reason people dislike Keir Starmer so much.

[-]

Incantanto@reddit

Theres a great pop anthropology book called watching the English and the two things I remember from it about conversations was that humor is very important to us and we really fo not like earnestness.

[-]

Xenyme@reddit

Another day in paradise

[-]

irish_horse_thief@reddit

This Big, if true..

[-]

Visual-Leadership446@reddit

Of course it does.

[-]

Marvel--Jesus@reddit

Because it is ?

[-]

Individual-Web-2547@reddit

Just another of the many services we offer, you’re welcome.

[-]

user_error101@reddit

Hmm,I wonder...

[-]

Shitelark@reddit

There is actually a British island called Sark.

[-]

NaturalTruth1374@reddit

It's the only way I know.

[-]

drquakers@reddit

Oh, I don't know, have you tried asking?

[-]

AkihabaraWasteland@reddit

Why does every Australian conversation sound drunk

[-]

MrsTheBo@reddit

Sarcasm is a British expression of affection

[-]

bondinchas@reddit

Brits being sarcastic? I don't think so!

[-]

Left-Ad-3412@reddit

Fascinating that you have been a part of every British conversation so you know what they sound like mate. Must be really hard to keep on top of mate

[-]

Veenkoira00@reddit

Because it is.

[-]

freebiscuit2002@reddit

Because it is mildly sarcastic.

[-]

Jaybee021967@reddit

Do you think we are sarcastic? Thought so

[-]

Citroen_CX@reddit

Oooh, I just don’t _know_

[-]

AuroraDF@reddit

Because most are.

[-]

terryjuicelawson@reddit

It is part of being a bit humble at times. You can't be too gushing or positive as it sounds fake. Then if something really does need praise, you know it is sincere.

[-]

Mikon_Youji@reddit

Because we are sarcastic fuckers.

[-]

Aware_Ad_431@reddit

Why would you think that?

[-]

PrettyNobody2342@reddit

Because it is?

[-]

HRHKarlFranz@reddit

I dunno why DOES every British conversation sound sarcastic.

[-]

evelynsmee@reddit

Only mildly?

[-]

MeghanSOS@reddit

Do we lmao

[-]

MisabelWearsNikes@reddit

'Mildly' is putting it mildly.

[-]

dwair@reddit

British conversation sounds sarcastic because, for the most part, it is. Sarcasm is our default.

[-]

Whosentyounow@reddit

Come on give us an example?

[-]

JimmieSavsscumsock@reddit

Just the one?

[-]

Whosentyounow@reddit

Yes 😂

[-]

MixPlus@reddit

Because it is

[-]

No-Ask2117@reddit

Because it does

[-]

EitherChannel4874@reddit

It's our 2nd language. That's why so many of us don't learn other languages when travelling. We already speak 2 fluently.

[-]

EasternCut8716@reddit

When I lived in California, my friend found a conversation very hard to follow. There was me, a Brit, and a young valley girl.

Everything the valley girl said sounded sarcastic but was sincere, meanwhile everytime I was sincere it sounded sarcastic. She decided not to converse with the two of us together ever again.

[-]

MapOfIllHealth@reddit

I live overseas and I’ve just stopped bothering being sincere because all the my Aussie friends accuse me of being sarcastic

[-]

Ghotay@reddit

Yep. One of my friends is a middle-aged Scottish man. He once said something to me like “You’re a really great friend to me and I appreciate the time we spend together”. Except in his voice it just sounds like he’s taking the piss. I couldn’t stop laughing at his genuine attempt at sincerity, poor bloke. Must be genetic

[-]

Fanny_Flapps@reddit

Did ye aye

[-]

emmacappa@reddit

Yeah, I had an Aussie mate and he would say "Yeah, right" and every time he did I had to check and remind myself that he was not saying this sarcastically.

[-]

MisabelWearsNikes@reddit

"Mildly" is putting it mildly, old chap.

[-]

Waste_Locksmith_4299@reddit

It enables us to assess where we stand with the listener. If they get it, they're on the level.

[-]

ohnoitshimagain10@reddit

What an absolutely fascinating question

[-]

Sxn747Strangers@reddit

Only mildly?

[-]

Square_Quarter_229@reddit

Sure about that, are you?

[-]

SmashingK@reddit

Great Sarcastic Britain.

It's literally there in the middle of the name I typed out.

[-]

NoMortgage3467@reddit

Hmm how interesting.

[-]

NotoriousREV@reddit

I’m never sarcastic, I don’t know how you could ever reach such a conclusion.

[-]

CanidPsychopomp@reddit

Because they are?

[-]

Booboodelafalaise@reddit

We don’t just “sound sarcastic”, we ARE sarcastic.

[-]

JimmieSavsscumsock@reddit

Aren't we.

[-]

Even_Video7549@reddit

Because it is!

[-]

Goldf_sh4@reddit

Because it is. That's how we roll.

[-]

Dangerous_Hippo_6902@reddit

Something to do with history, wars, losing an empire… etc etc etc

[-]

Diddleymaz@reddit

We’re built that way

[-]

Uncle_Zardoz@reddit

No idea what you're talking about, frankly. Never been sarcastic in my life.

[-]

_Cridders_@reddit

Sure

[-]

MinaretofJam@reddit

Really? How interesting.

[-]

Elfynnn84@reddit

No idea what you’re talking about.

[-]

Time-Mode-9@reddit

Probably because every British conversation is mildly sarcastic.

[-]

ginger-tiger108@reddit

Because they are! especially if it's a conversation being had with a American but ironically if someone is being playfully sarcastic it means they quite like you and it's when they aren't mildly taking the p!ss that you know they absolutely loath your guts

[-]

SpaceJkr@reddit

It might be the people you are around. The I moved from a industrial manual workplace into a corporate office in a completely unrelated field.

The constant sarcasm in the social chat from the people in the office wore me down. It was eye opening the way some people chose to navigate the world.

[-]

vastaril@reddit

Couldn't be because we're all being sarcastic, all the time. Obviously

[-]

TheLastHotstepper@reddit

Because it probably is

[-]

kebabby72@reddit

Fuckin hell.

[-]

Extreme-Dream-2759@reddit

Really ......

[-]

Alfredthegiraffe20@reddit

Because it is. I take exception to the 'mildly' bit to be honest.

[-]

JungleyD@reddit

Yes mate. Every single conversation is entirely sarcastic. Brilliant observation 👏

[-]

EUskeptik@reddit

It’s to ward off foreign types. A defence mechanism.

We no longer have a viable navy so sarcasm has become our main weapon.

-##-

[-]

snarkmaiden5@reddit

Probably because it is 😅. We are so fluent in it we genuinely dont realise everything we say sounds a little sarky

[-]

slinkimalinki@reddit

Someone once told me that when I say “thank you very much” sincerely, it sounds sarcastic.

[-]

radiantr4y@reddit

No way it’s actually that obvious. Never realised myself

[-]

Lympwing2@reddit

you're having a laugh

[-]

Sapiopath@reddit

Because it is.

[-]

Extreme_Objective984@reddit

Mildly?

[-]

Extreme_Objective984@reddit

Oddly, I watched a video on just this subject, this morning Americans don't understand British sarcasm. here's why.

[-]

healeyd@reddit

It’s because we are so amazing, mate.

[-]

weetattyscone@reddit

Nooooooooo

[-]

Broad-Raspberry1805@reddit

Right.

[-]

DemonicHedgehogs@reddit

I lived in Canada for a couple of years and was constantly being accused of being sarcastic in meetings when I was actually being sincere. The problem is that we’re generally less effusive and demonstrative, so that may be seen as not being genuine. In reality we’re just not pretending that complimenting someone for doing their job well is deserving of a great deal of excitement.

[-]

Labyrinth2_718@reddit

"Sarcasm is the lowest form of wit, but the highest form of intelligence"(Possibly, Oscar Wilde )

[-]

Bipolar03@reddit

We're not sarcastic. There's a difference between our sarcastic and people thinking we're being sarcastic

[-]

theavocadolady@reddit

Because they are?

[-]

Only_Tip9560@reddit

I disagree, some conversations clearly sound very sarcastic.

[-]

Ok-Direction-8257@reddit

Brilliant... 👍

[-]

Evening-Cold-4547@reddit

If you spent all day talking to Brits you'd develop a coping mechanism as well

[-]

PopularDisplay7007@reddit

OP, you absolutely walked into that one.

[-]

Less_Local_1727@reddit

Is that right

[-]

BuncleCar@reddit

It's irony mate, not sarcasm

[-]

SuburbanBushwacker@reddit

i’ll give you one guess

[-]

Evolutionary_u-turn@reddit

It's not every conversation, just the ones that you have.

The rest of us are being nice and open with each other, no obfuscation at all.

[-]

Purp1eMagpie@reddit

Are they though

[-]

ohdoyoucomeonthen@reddit

Not seeing it, myself.

[-]

Impressive_Ad2794@reddit

Well maybe that's just how conversations with you go, yeah?

[-]

kreemy_kurds@reddit

Think that's a you problem

[-]

parkchanwookiee@reddit

I dunno Jake, why do YOU think?

[-]

wildflower12345678@reddit

Nothing really matters 🎶

[-]

Kiki-sunflower@reddit

Mmm surely not, we’re a perfectly delightful bunch

[-]

bearbfc@reddit

It's to see if you actually have working braincells in your head or not so we know whether to bother wasting our time carrying on the conversarion.

[-]

the_ninjahippy@reddit

Because we are!

[-]

flashdonut@reddit

Great question mate.

[-]

Ashamed_Caregiver_22@reddit

Do tell me more. Sounds really interesting

[-]

pandabearrose@reddit

Because we are British?.....

[-]

Boring-Print9058@reddit

Of course they do, you've obviously heard every one, pal.

[-]

Limp_Mix5958@reddit

I have a half-sarcastic voice. Its a defence mechanism mainly so that if I say something stupid I can pretend it is sarcasm.

And if I accidentally say something clever when i'm trying to be sarcastic i can still take the credit.

[-]

Emotional-Shallot674@reddit

Do they? 🤣 I think there's a combination of our humour and our overly polite manner (compared to some cultures) that comes over as sarcasm, and sometimes performative politeness, which can come across as sarcasm. I'm Scottish, so insincerity is absolutely part of our banter. "did ye, aye" is a prime example.

[-]