TheaterFire

Was this terrifying to everyone else?

Posted by F3rus29@reddit | Xennials | View on Reddit | 43 comments

Was this terrifying to everyone else?

Reply to Post

43 Comments

EldrinSMP@reddit

Whatever it was, it's now gone... Unless you were talking about the perpetual or and circle of dits spinning around, and in that case it's absolutely terrifying. 🤣
View on Reddit #85445829

AllTh3Naps@reddit

Yes, but I found all of the puppets scary -- not just her.
View on Reddit #85444331

Specialist-Leek8645@reddit

I know old stuff from back then was scary by today's standards, like the Santa and Easter Bunny costumes, but I still wonder if she was supposed to be creepy because despite that I knew she was ok. Mr. Rogers trusted her so she HAD to be a good character. Even if she looked like a former witch, he told us to let people improve themselves, be gracious and forgiving. Even hospitality-- that was his house and all these neighbors were welcome there. Maybe she became a White Witch after meeting Fred. lol Nah, he was a pastor right? No witchcraft. :\[
View on Reddit #85444232

goldenscales@reddit

When I was very little she definitely weirded me out! I also thought the song Lay Lady Lay was saying Lady Elaine and I didn't understand why there was a song about her 😆
View on Reddit #85444192

olive_juse@reddit

All that's playing in my head is "🎶GET KNOCKED TF OUTTTTTT🎶"
View on Reddit #85443959

pimphand5000@reddit

Nah, loved it all
View on Reddit #85443383

blamberr@reddit

I’m from Pittsburgh and love every single thing about Mr. Rodgers 🥰
View on Reddit #85443811

SweatyPalmsSunday@reddit

I didn’t like that her face was burnt but I wasn’t terrified
View on Reddit #85443706

draculasbloodtype@reddit

Maybe not terrifying, but certainly ugly. Her cheeks and nose always looked burnt to me.
View on Reddit #85443108

1877KlownsForKids@reddit

Always reminded me of my uncle I wasn't allowed to be alone with. Ah, good times.
View on Reddit #85443554

Foxx983@reddit

She reminds me of my Aunt Margaret. There is no shade on either of them. She just looks like my Aunt and that amuses me. 😅
View on Reddit #85443810

catsoncrack420@reddit

Thank you. Glad I wasn't the only one.
View on Reddit #85443749

Affectionate_Ask_769@reddit

Yes. Hated it so much. Loved the muppets and Fraggle Rock tho
View on Reddit #85443727

SweetPrism@reddit

Not so much as sad; the woman was clearly a spinster with a drinking problem. My question, how did an alcoholic live in a rotating museum and still manage coherent speech?
View on Reddit #85443684

Ok_Shopping7204@reddit

It wasn’t then but it is now.
View on Reddit #85443669

jakechance@reddit

Yes! Also why did she live in a carousel?
View on Reddit #85443630

johnb300m@reddit

The Museum go Round was pretty dope. Especially when we got to go inside.
View on Reddit #85443605

nalninek@reddit

It would have been if it wasn’t presented by the kindest dude on television.
View on Reddit #85443587

scummins@reddit

No, because she’s always reminded me of a muppet version of my MeMom lol 💛
View on Reddit #85443569

cityfireguy@reddit

I was too busy listening to the words of a man who taught kids not to judge someone off looks alone.
View on Reddit #85443566

jimkurth81@reddit

always terrifying to me... even to this day.
View on Reddit #85443559

EmperorGrinnar@reddit

Turn it back to Eureka's Castle, please.
View on Reddit #85443544

johnb300m@reddit

Meow meow scary as fuck meow meow.
View on Reddit #85443531

Aragorn3223@reddit

Very much so
View on Reddit #85443528

likesblackcoffeebest@reddit

Baby's first nightmare fuel
View on Reddit #85443519

elektrik_noise@reddit

All great, but Lady Elaine was a bit of a saucy bitch. At the time I didn't realize she was my fav but I was fascinated by her like I was Cruella and Ursula.
View on Reddit #85443490

Deep-Interest9947@reddit

Honestly all of the puppet land in Mr rogers freaked me out. She might have been the cause but she wasn’t the only problem.
View on Reddit #85443476

epidemicsaints@reddit

Is it gin blossoms or is she a burn victim?
View on Reddit #85443035

NurseCait@reddit

I’m going with gin blossoms.
View on Reddit #85443473

gellshayngel@reddit

Rosacea
View on Reddit #85443275

Roland-Of-Eld-19@reddit

Not as much as a child but looking back on it she was definitely freaky lookin haha
View on Reddit #85443459

throwaway1102293384@reddit

Yeah old puppets are creepy af. Still loved that show
View on Reddit #85443435

NurseCait@reddit

Yeeeeeees. Darn Lady Elaine!
View on Reddit #85443429

Plutoniumburrito@reddit

No. It looked like one of our local city councilwomen. I always thought of it as her.
View on Reddit #85443415

Norwester77@reddit

Nightmare fuel
View on Reddit #85443350

blue_suavitel@reddit

Yes.
View on Reddit #85443313

CTMechE@reddit

Absolutely. The entire puppet village gave me the creeps.
View on Reddit #85443191

UnitedLink4545@reddit

Yes!!!!
View on Reddit #85443147

rangeghost@reddit

GAHHH!!!
View on Reddit #85443123

purpleteenageghost@reddit

https://preview.redd.it/jh1mlgbagrzg1.jpeg?width=3781&format=pjpg&auto=webp&s=56ee3ff16208a6c46d434f524c53738840277f8a She got a glow up on Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood.
View on Reddit #85443082

XennialQueen@reddit

Absolutely 😂
View on Reddit #85442955

Snargleface@reddit

Jesus, yes
View on Reddit #85442950

Texas_Kimchi@reddit

YES ALWAYS!!!!!!!!
View on Reddit #85442932