i5 13600k nightmare - should I go for 14600k?
Posted by Individual_College70@reddit | buildapc | View on Reddit | 11 comments
Recently I bought an used i5 13600k from a market place in my country for around 150 euro. Excited to get home and test, I paired with my Asus Prime B760M-A DDR4 motherboard and a 4 heatpipes 120mm DeepCool air cooler + using Artic MX-4 paste. In the first benchmarks and games the CPU hits around 85-90c in games and throttle in stress test. So I order a brand new Thermalright Phantom Spirit EVO 120 + contact frame from same brand for 40 euro. Installed and start the test the temps hit now 70-77c in games and around 85c in stress test.
Beeing socked about how bad is performing with one of the best air coolers in the markets (seeing the benchmarks on heavyer Ryzen or Intel cpus) and completly not satisfed, I searched for how to lower temps and I resumed to:
- Updated to last bios version as most of internet said Intel completly solved 13/14th gen thermal and power cosumption problem with this (even my last bios version was 1825 from couple of moths before) -> no improve
- Put the Intel Adaptive Boost to Intel Default not Asus Default, Asus multicore to disabled -> no improve
- VRM Core Voltage to Offset mode from -0.08000 to -0.13500 (as to not crash in apps) -> Slighly improve here but not satisfyed; temps between 68-75c. Didn't count the fps or benchmarks scores.
- CPU Power Manage - PL1 Long Term Pack to 125w and PL2 Short term Pack to 150w - no visible improve
- Performance and Efficent Core ration to sync by all cores and set to 1 value low (like 50 and 38) - slightly stable temps in game but not a much improve and higher idle temps.
- IA TDC power from mother board capability to Intel Default settings - no improve
- Auto Profile Lines from Auto (4th profile for OC) to Profile 3 and Profile 2 - not slightly improve and lower fps/scores
- Hyper threading Off - no improve
- Turbo Boost disable - huge improve temps no high >60c but runs at 3.5ghz but much lower scores/fps.
Tired already after trying a lot of unsuccessful visible methods, I kept reading on the net that the 13th generation has factory problems that can not be remedied with temperatures and consumption. That many users returned it or that others were burned after a few months of use.
Through other parts I saw that with weaker coolers they kept this processor in much lower temperatures than me with default settings.
Others said that generation 13/14 can be cooled only with at least one cooler per liquid of 240mm.
I also read that my B760M-A motherboard from Asus is one of the worst made and that VRMs do not cope for this processor (i saw several reviews with it) and to take another mobo or buy a Z690/Z790.
So I thought maybe the processor being bought second hand was broken over time or maybe it ran at high temperatures and had problems.
Finally I sold it for 200 euros (i even made a profit) and I ordered an i5 14400f tray at 150e that runs great so far (with this cooler Phantom Spirit 120 EVO) does not jump me 55c in games.
But still dissatisfied with the performance it brings out (compared to what I had before an i5 12400f) that offers only to say 10% extra, I would like to return it with 14 days right of return and buy a 14600k which is about 200euro (new without warranty) but I'm afraid to not get the same story as with 13600k.
I don't know what to do, this 14400f I don't see it last more than two years, it already makes me bottleneck with RTX 4070 in games (it stays at over 50% in some games and pulls the video card down) and I'll have to change again, and my best choice was 13 or 14600k.
RayDaug@reddit
Buying a used 13th or 14th gen Intel is a dicey proposition. The BIOS update helps, but older chips just have manufacturing defects.
I recently bought a new 14600k and it's been just fine with my air cooler. If you can get one new yourself for a reasonable price it wouldn't be a bad buy. At 1080p it's about 20% faster than the 14400f.
Individual_College70@reddit (OP)
Yep, I'm 50/50 to try a new adventure with 14600k
dxearner@reddit
A couple things:
With your new bios changes and contact frame, 70-77c while gaming and 85c during stress test is 100% fine for a modern CPU -- especially a 13/14th gen intel, which can run hot. Modern chips are designed to boost as much as they can, until they hit thermal limits. At 85c, you are still getting max performance of the chip (source)
While your cooler and paste do matter a lot for CPU temps, you also have to consider factors like your case, fan layout, and making sure you are not suffocating how your case intakes air.
Going with an AIO since you mentioned it, will bring down your temps. However, unless you are doing that because you want a quieter machine, do not think you need to do that based on what you have in the post. Your temps are not in any danger zone.
Individual_College70@reddit (OP)
Case is not a problem since I took down the glass window for test, and I have 5 fans with front mesh. So airflow is not a thing here.
TallComputerDude@reddit
Contact frame is potentially a good idea and they are cheap. 13600K can consume quite a bit of power when pushed, but the E cores are very powerful for shaders and multitasking.
Individual_College70@reddit (OP)
I mentioned I bought one, no much improvement
dask1@reddit
i would gamble that its the mobo fault, indeed a dog shit mobo that cannot even handle 12700 non K (!).
https://youtu.be/PEa0vcJ0lRY?si=ttB-JBAeLtgnEdLw&t=998
so upgrade to 14600k will probably give u same result.
btw i also have 13600kf working great with thermalright PA120, but ofc i regret getting this and not 7600/x back when i got it...
Individual_College70@reddit (OP)
I might think the same but I see other videos using same mobo + cpu and not getting struggle at all for temps and consume
Important_Sea_1136@reddit
Did you ever check what kind of voltages was your 13600k requesting? With default settings in my experience 14600k atleast has been a very cool chip.
Individual_College70@reddit (OP)
Hmm in HwInfo in stress test I would say I reaches up to max 1.4v Im not sure If I say something stupid
nivlark@reddit
Your temperatures were fine, and there was nothing wrong with your 13600K. The 14600K will have very similar thermal behaviour to it.
Your board's VRMs are adequate for running an i5 in gaming loads. They would struggle to run an i7 or i9 with more demanding workloads.