Yeah, the OG term was Judenhasser, no points for guessing what that means. Marr wanted something that sounded "more scientific", coming the term Antisemitism.
Modern Hebrew isn't even the same language as the ancient Hebrew spoken long ago. Hebrew was a dead language for centuries. then they tried to bring it back last century, but they'd forgotten most of it. So they filled in the parts they didn't know with yiddish.
You might want to read up on virtually every language in the world.
BTW as a native Hebrew speaker, Yiddish is completely unintelligible to me. The closest language would be Arabic to my knowledge, and even that is very different.
How did you miss the part that old Hebrew was very well-preserved in texts and thought that Yiddish, a Germanic language, would be the primary vocabulary source in Hebrew language revival? Your take makes zero sense.
I agree it's stupid, that doesn't make it less true.
it includes characteristics derived from all periods of Hebrew language, as well as from the non-Hebrew languages used by the long-established European, North African, and Middle Eastern Jewish communities, with Yiddish being predominant.
Why am I, a modern Hebrew speaker, able to read and understand the dead sea scrolls?
Hebrew has never been a dead language. Every single Jew at some point in their lives learn to speak it to some capacity. It was mainly spoken in clerical and religious discussion as the "holy tongue" so it needed some updating when it was expanded to full modern day usage, like any other language.
Believe it or not, there's no words for car, or telephone in a 2000 year old language.
Now think about how Judaism just lifted traditions from the surrounding cultures of the time, Persian religion is prehistoric, and Judaism just randomly started saying they were special and chosen and the oldest tradition.
Egypt is a more likely source than Persia, but all religions come from earlier sources. Christianity and Islam are Judaism fan-fictions but nobody condemns them for that.
Hell, Mormonism is a fan fic of the Christian fan fic, which actual historical records of the events before, during, and after the creation and development of it.
spiritofporn@reddit
I miss the days when antisemitic jokes were edgy and limited to 4chan. Now it's just regurgitated reddit slop.
Trick-Caramel-6156@reddit
It's everywhere now, 4chan lost the edge now everyone wants to be a hitler wanna be
Biggu5Dicku5@reddit
Truly they chose wisely...
herb0026@reddit
Not exactly the Jews’ fault. It was coined by a German guy who didn’t like Jews in the 1880s and wanted it to sound more fancy.
I don’t think he considered how it would affect Arabs since there were effectively no arabs(yet) in Germany it that time.
226_Walker@reddit
Yeah, the OG term was Judenhasser, no points for guessing what that means. Marr wanted something that sounded "more scientific", coming the term Antisemitism.
uvero@reddit
So, blaming the jews to have been conspiring behind the scenes for something that wasn't their choice. I think there's a word for it
GorgeousGamer99@reddit
Accurate?
AnonymousZiZ@reddit
Modern Hebrew isn't even the same language as the ancient Hebrew spoken long ago. Hebrew was a dead language for centuries. then they tried to bring it back last century, but they'd forgotten most of it. So they filled in the parts they didn't know with yiddish.
spaniel_rage@reddit
It's true that there was no word for television in 300BC
MrGulo-gulo@reddit
Me when I have no idea what I'm talking about
AnonymousZiZ@reddit
Why do facts scare you people?
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Revival_of_the_Hebrew_language
MrGulo-gulo@reddit
I'm aware of that. I take umbrage with you saying it is completely unrelated and just Yiddish.
AnonymousZiZ@reddit
I never said it's completely unrelated and just Yiddish. I said they used Yiddish to fill in some parts they didn't have.
royi9729@reddit
You might want to read up on virtually every language in the world.
BTW as a native Hebrew speaker, Yiddish is completely unintelligible to me. The closest language would be Arabic to my knowledge, and even that is very different.
Limp-Temperature1783@reddit
How did you miss the part that old Hebrew was very well-preserved in texts and thought that Yiddish, a Germanic language, would be the primary vocabulary source in Hebrew language revival? Your take makes zero sense.
AnonymousZiZ@reddit
I agree it's stupid, that doesn't make it less true.
94_stones@reddit
So you’re saying that English is actually French?
Limp-Temperature1783@reddit
So what? Every language has borrowings.
spiritofporn@reddit
'You people'.
Lmao. Kosher is the new black.
_c0sm1c_@reddit
Why am I, a modern Hebrew speaker, able to read and understand the dead sea scrolls?
Hebrew has never been a dead language. Every single Jew at some point in their lives learn to speak it to some capacity. It was mainly spoken in clerical and religious discussion as the "holy tongue" so it needed some updating when it was expanded to full modern day usage, like any other language.
Believe it or not, there's no words for car, or telephone in a 2000 year old language.
WhiteSepulchre@reddit
Now think about how Judaism just lifted traditions from the surrounding cultures of the time, Persian religion is prehistoric, and Judaism just randomly started saying they were special and chosen and the oldest tradition.
spaniel_rage@reddit
Wait until you hear how Christianity and Islam got started......
PCmasterRACE187@reddit
every religion considers themselves special one way or another. well not every one, but practically all of them
SteveFrench12@reddit
Bros never heard of christianity
Snoutysensations@reddit
Egypt is a more likely source than Persia, but all religions come from earlier sources. Christianity and Islam are Judaism fan-fictions but nobody condemns them for that.
Tylos_Of_Attica@reddit
Hell, Mormonism is a fan fic of the Christian fan fic, which actual historical records of the events before, during, and after the creation and development of it.
_c0sm1c_@reddit
Etymological fallacy
Ionisation1934@reddit
Jews did not invent the rerm antisemite, it was antisemites themselves like wilhelm marr whodid.
barnacles_maize@reddit
Semitic Languages were promised to them 3000 years ago anon /s
itay162@reddit
Most original goy joke
spiritofporn@reddit
At this point I assume every 'promised 3000y' joke is just a bot posting. It was mildly amusing the first time.
Klutzy-Film8298@reddit
pack it up everyone, some random internet dipshit decided it’s not funny anymore.
spiritofporn@reddit
I was obviously wrong, you're very funny.
Triple96@reddit
You think its a reddit thing?
spiritofporn@reddit
Eh, social media. Reddit is just as bad as the others, except for niche subs.
HaeliXu@reddit
ngl agree with you, same with the “the painter was right” comments
Prestigious-Fig1172@reddit
Fun fact: Proto-Semetic is estimated to have existed 12000 years ago!
southwest_barfight@reddit
Low IQ OP lamenting on people incorrectly conflating semetism with Judaism while himself incorrectly conflating Zionism with Judaism.
roktoman@reddit
According to Islamic history, most of the Arabian Jewish tribes in Arabian peninsula either converted or subjugated into Islam.
The more mindblowing epiphanythen is that Likud killing arabs is actually antisemitism.
Evil-Fucking-Wizard@reddit
Actual truth nuke