If by the 1947 plan you mean the UN partition of Palestine, Israel violated that immediately and repeatedly. They wiped their ass with it. It was illegal anyway so who cares.

The Arabs literally threw a hissy fit, rejected it and started a war. How the hell did Israel violate it when they said yes and Arabs not only said "no" but started a war over it ?

Also it came from the UN. How tf was it illegal ? Nowadays if someone breaks the slightest UN law everyone is up in arms about it as if they sinned against God but when Arabs do it it's "Illegal" ? What the hell kinda logic is this

And they only gave the Sinai back because they seized it after they simultaneously attacked all their neighbors before the 6 Day War.

You conviniently leave out that said neighbors imposed a blockade on Israel (AKA an act of war) and were massing troops at the border like Russia did with Ukraine.

And again, regardless of what happened Israel still gave that back to Egypt when they could have just kept it since it was very strategically important.

And they haven’t withdrawn from Gaza, they’re still actively committing genocide there.

First of all they widrew 20 years ago. Forcefully evacuated all Jews and destroyed every settlement only to wake up with a hail of missiles from Hamas. They only came back after October 7th.

Levantine Jews had a much better time of it under the Arabs than European Jews had it under the various European despots that spent the previous 2,000 years pogroming them from Spain to Russia.

That's like saying people had a much better time under the Soviet Union than under Nazi Germany. Just because the Europeans were worse doesn't mean that life under Arab rule was a Utopia.

Just do any basic research into Jewish-Muslim relations pre 1900 and you’ll see that there isn’t some ancient hatred between the two groups, that under the different caliphates and states that came after the Jews were more protected than they were in Europe. They even had more economic opportunities and weren’t forced into ghettos. It wasn’t until England and France divided up the region at the end of WW1 that things began to move in the current direction. There was a legitimate chance for a multi-cultural, multi-religious Levantine state but Sykes-Picot killed that in its crib.

Bullshit! Jews (just like all non-Muslims) were literally 2nd class citizens who needed to pay protection tax for existing. It was like America under Jim Crow. Hell even the Quran has some rather anti-semitic bullshit in it.

Also "multi-cultural, multi-religious state" LMAO ! Arabs can barely tolerate each other if they worship a different denomination of Islam let alone another religion. Just look at all the ethno-religious groups Sykes-Picot stitched together Willy-Nilly and all the civil wars and discrimination it caused.

You're calling me naive when you come up with this bullshit, unrealistic hippie feverdreams ? LOL!

And yes absolutely, the state of Israel is a genocidal entity. You can give them whatever excuse you want, they are a nation built on ethnosupremacism and religious intolerance. They have been since Ben-Gurion too so we can’t just act like it’s Bibi.

Literally 20% of it's population is Arab and they have better rights than any minority in any Arab state. They can be Muslim or Christian or Druze and speak their language no problem, they have cities and towns with Arab majority, bilingual signs in Hebrew & Arabic, they can serve in the army voluntarely instead of being forced to like the Jews and there are even IDF army officers. Not to mention Arab politicians, MPs, judges etc.

Compare that to all their Arab Muslim ethnostates surrounding them where very few people are not Arab or not follow Islam and if they do they're discriminated or straight up murdered.