How do I help to resolve an ongoing situation now they want RSPCA involved?
Posted by Common-Shine-8988@reddit | AskUK | View on Reddit | 30 comments
I hope this reddit thing is the right place to ask.
My friend had to recently move back in with his elderly father. He was going through a really bad time and his dad became severely unwell.
Anyway, there are 6 cats in the household, all outdoor cats. 3 of the cats were free roaming and would go quite far and be gone for days at a time.
You have mum, dad and their 4 babies.
I have been told that it's 2 babies and dad that go off.
From what i was told, for the last 5 years, they've taken off and found new homes. My friend's dad became unable to go out to search or call them back. My friend did know that they weren't around as much but he never seemed bothered by it.
When he moved back in Nov 2025, he said he realised how bad it was and he went out to look. He found all of the new homes and he struck up polite relationships with the people.
In March 2026, his dad became terminally ill and decided he wanted all the cats to be indoors.
My friend asked the people if the could return them.
One lady had outright refused. The cat came back of his own choice so my friend kept him locked inside.
This lady then came knocking and said she is going to report him to the RSPCA.
My friend said to her that his dad is the owner but she says she has concerns.
I have had cats before, never shut them in but I take my own personal feelings out of it. My friend says he's doing it to familiarise them back with the owner.
I am concerned about her report, i feel it would hurt the dad. I feel that they may take the cats away.
I'm concerned that the RSPCA may tell the lady information that isn't theirs to share.
My brother in law works for the local branch, he says they may act on the report but they shouldn't disclose anything to the lady.
I also worry that my friend may not be doing the right thing shutting them in. It may be harmful to all the cats as they may not want to be stuck together.
Thank you
Experiment328095@reddit
They don’t need to go outside, the RSPCA won’t be interested unless the cats are not being cared for.
constructuscorp@reddit
Not just not being cared for, not just being neglected, they need to be being actively, severely abused before they can intervene. I know a couple of people who've had severe cat hoarding situations where the poor things were all severely malnourished and living in their own shit, and they STILL weren't legally allowed to intervene properly. He'd need to be causing very specific and serious harm to the animals before they could do anything.
Experiment328095@reddit
It’s sad really, lack of funding and laws that view animals as property rather than sentient beings leaves a lot of room for abuse and neglect.
OkTadpole2920@reddit
I understand the emotions involved but leave the cats in their new homes. He couldn't look after them before and he really can't do it now. Have the cats visit him, it's the best way. Dreamies is a very desirable snack/treat for cats, cut them in half though!!!
dallaschickensh1t@reddit
Why cut them in half 😳
OkTadpole2920@reddit
They are like cocaine for cats!
dallaschickensh1t@reddit
Oh bloody hell! I give my cat 4-5 at a time ! I spread them round the house like a game to find them but no wonder she goes mental when she hears the packet! 😅
OkTadpole2920@reddit
😆 🤣 😂 I had a cat who broke into a neighbour's house to get a packet of Dreamies she had placed on the counter! I heard rustling and growling from a bush in my garden late at night and when I plucked up the courage to look, I saw him attempting to chew his way into the packet! It was a week or so later that I discovered what he had done. I didn't confess.
dallaschickensh1t@reddit
Haha that’s brilliant ! I didn’t know the crack addiction was that bad! 🤣 I had a cat that broke into a neighbours house and she found him on the kitchen counter pawing at her budgies cage 😅 luckily she found it funny 🙃
Dans77b@reddit
OK Newman...
OccidentalTouriste@reddit
Solomon is wise in the ways of felines.
Uhura-hoop@reddit
Brilliant 🥇👏🏻
Nitrogenflux@reddit
It's wild to me that some people think cats are indoor animals like hamsters and should be couped up inside a house their entire lives
constructuscorp@reddit
Oh god, never go near an american talking about cats then. I was called an abuser multiple times by a HOARD of americans after I mentioned that my cat had escaped out of a window. They're mental about it.
constructuscorp@reddit
Regardless of the context, it doesn't matter, because the RSPCA will not, and do not have the power to intervene in a situation like this. Unless the cats are actively being harmed or at risk of starvation or similar, they cannot get involved, and have SIGNIFICANTLY higher priorities than a dispute over which house a cat has wandered into.
C0nnectionTerminat3d@reddit
If the cats are microchipped with your dad’s details they’re legally his and RSPCA won’t entertain the custody side of things.
That being said, your dad needs to let them go. If he wasn’t paying for the upkeep of them he doesn’t/shouldnt have a right to ask for them back.
PurpleOctopus6789@reddit
This is not quite true. If they've been taken care by someone else for years and vet bills were paid, etc. It would be considered abandonment and there's a case
PurpleOctopus6789@reddit
How about hurting the cats? They have feelings and get attached. The dad din't care for the cats and now they're gone. let them live in their new homes. Ripping them out of them is cruelty. He abandonment them and now wants them back. That's not how it works. Domestic cats can't really survive alone when abandoned. They suffer.
Your friend and their dad are selfish and only think about themselves and not animal wellbeing. they're horrible pet owners. People who love their pets and are unable to take care of them make sure they end up in good homes.
He's doing it so they don't run away because they don't want to be there. If a cat loves their owner, they don't need to be familiarised with them, they will remember them even after years apart.
Common-Shine-8988@reddit (OP)
Thank you to all. I appreciate all that you have said.
I think, as a lot of you pointed out, the cats are better off within their new homes. The people who have cared for them, fed them and given them a safe place, are definitely the people that these cats deserve to stay with.
I will speak to my friend and give him a nudge in the right direction.
Adorable_Ad4328@reddit
It's difficult for most people to care for 6 cats, never mind someone with dementia. Are they insured? Who is going to be paying the (potentially significant) vet bills if they require treatment? The RSPCA would only act if there are welfare issues and even then it's likely to be verbal advice initially unless the situation is severe. The RSPCA will contact agencies like adult social services if they have concerns about your friend's Dad's welfare.
Be aware that person the cat has being living with might actually have a claim to ownership if she's been paying for the cats food and vet treatment for years, this applies even if the cat is micro chipped to your friend's Dad.
ambergriswoldo@reddit
While I sympathise with your friend wanting to do what makes his Dad happy it really sounds like the cats care hasn’t been a priority previously - so as much as he may want the cats at home now, they don’t want the same.
A pets home should be their safe space - the place they can rely on for food, care and peace - clearly some of the cats found this elsewhere instead.
Why force the cats to come back to a home they don’t want to be in? Plus, given your friends Dad dealing with worsening health problems - can he truly care for the cats any better now?
Let the cats go to their chosen homes - locking them in only risks further problems if the new owners can see that they’re being neglected. Absolutely there’s a risk of all of the cats being taken away.
Screaming_lambs@reddit
We've got one cat because of this. The house he came from is very noisy and busy, has little dogs and kids. When they went on holiday he'd hang out here and seemed a lot less stressed than when he was just visiting. A couple of years ago they'd been away in October half term then came back and had fireworks. That was it for him, he refused to go back. He's registered to us now.
Screaming_lambs@reddit
I'd leave the cats in their new homes. If they are chipped to that address there's not much you can do anyway. The rspca would do what is best for the cats, if they aren't looked after by your friends dad they are better off elsewhere.
whyaregeeselikethat@reddit
While technically they are the dad's cats and any organisation would side with him (outside of neglect situations), it doesn't sound an ideal situation for the animals involved and they have settled elsewhere. The cat in question has been taken in by someone who clearly cares for it and (likely) thought it was a stray/abandoned before bringing it into their home/family.
I'm going to put it bluntly, a terminally ill owner who allowed the cats to go so far astray that they found a new home probably isn't the best environment for them to return to, especially when they are being locked inside the home when they are used to free roaming.
As a pet owner you have to to what's best for the animal, not your own emotions and sometimes that means letting them go. They only have short lives, they deserve a good one and this doesn't sound like it is. We had a cat that ran away after we got a dog, it was already settled into a new home with an elderly owner with no pets or kids once we found it and while it was hard, we let her keep it since that was best for the cat (and it's what the cat chose).
Legally? Your friends dad is likely going to win that battle. Morally? Let the cat's be where they're happiest, even if it isn't with him.
Ok_Young1709@reddit
Cats will find their own homes if they want to. You can't control a cat. But RSPCA won't do anything either. Doesn't sound like the cats are being mistreated, they are fed and watered, they won't care. RSPCA hasn't cared for a long time about animals really, can report actual animal abuse and they say 'but they have food and water, must be ok'. 🙄
-XiaoSi-@reddit
So true, in fact there’s a whole sub dedicated to just that- r/catdistributionsysten
animalwitch@reddit
Your friend needs to give the cats back. It's not fair on the cats, or the new owners who have actually been looking after them. I appreciate your friend wants to do what his terminally ill father wants but it is not what's best for any one involved. When his/her father passes, your friend will have to deal with the cats anyway so make it easy while they can.
ExpatLou@reddit
Sorry but your goodwill is misplaced here. Dad cannot take care of 1 cat let alone 6, all have found safe homes that have fed and cared for them for YEARS. They are no longer his cats and he has no right to ask or take them back. On top of that, cats shouldn’t be allowed to free roam. It’s dangerous for the cats and for local bird populations.
I can tell you’re a really kind person and no one wants to see their friends in this kind of situation, but let the RSPCA do their jobs, investigate and come up with a solution that’s best for the animals.
MountainMuffin1980@reddit
Goddamn right cats shouldn't be outside.
Also it's wild that OPs friend is trying to force the cats back with a dude who hasn't cared for them, can't care for them and, sadly, is going to pass away soon anyway. His friend should be working to formally pass ownership on to people that give a fuck.
mixamatoosh@reddit
What’s best for the cats? Take emotions out of it.