Are churchs in the south really as wild as movies and shows depict?
Posted by True-Blackberry-3080@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 228 comments
I've never actually attended church. But i have always wondered if things I've seen depicted are based in reality in any way.
For example in fried green tomatoes the pastor talks about idgie attending a revival that is days long and last all day and night (when do they eat? When do they sleep??)
I've also seen scenes where people are fainting in the aisles and jumping over pews, or being "healed" by a preacher grabbing their head.
I have friend that said growing up she used to attend church on Sunday morning and Sunday night and Wednesday and Saturday. She said she was penecostal (?)
Is this normal?
FranceBrun@reddit
I had a neighbor in New York who used to brag about how long she spent in church, until one day I told her that we Catholics were able to do everything in about an hour and I was sorry it took her so long.
She stopped bragging after that.
DokterZ@reddit
Some Catholic services are 45 minutes. Lutheran weddings can be even shorter though.
Jewish-Mom-123@reddit
I went to an afternoon Catholic wedding once, it was three hours long. How can some masses be shorter than an hour and some take three hours? The wedding part was only ten or fifteen minutes.
apgtimbough@reddit
Our local church has a 7:30am mass with no music or singing. You were often in and out in 30 minutes. It was the mass we went to more often then not.
IShouldBeHikingNow@reddit
If God can create the universe in 7 days, he should be able to manage a church service in under an hour.
bonzai113@reddit
That does sound Pentecostal. This is how I was originally raised.
BeeinCV@reddit
As a child (raised Catholic) I went to my Grandmother’s Baptist service one Sunday, the singing was wonderful! Then came the preaching, all hellfire and brimstone, it was very off putting. Then some woman in the front row started having a seizure and no one cared or even called an ambulance, I found out later it was just the Holy Spirit. I could not get out of there fast enough.
Technical-Bath9108@reddit
Before going, always ask if you're expected to bring your own rattlesnakes or if rattlesnakes will be provided by the church. Luckily for me, I always have a couple lying around.
alwaysboopthesnoot@reddit
Some are, some aren’t.
There are strip mall churches held in little-used shopping malls or repurposed warehouses and barns in some places up North, that are like that too. Tent revivals, open air churches.
It’s the denomination or sect or leader, not the region, that determines what that looks like.
You can find some pretty wild services and charismatic cults in Ohio, or rural Pennsylvania.
Pentecostal, evangelical, apostolic Protestant churches can sometimes be like that, as well as some African Methodist Episcopal or some newly-founded Hispanic Catholic and breakaway “Catholic in name only” churches.
milkandsugar@reddit
I was raised Catholic in the south and the wildest we ever got was "Guitar Mass."
sultrie@reddit
Some are. Most arent. Pentecostals are essentially the white church version of a black church.
Diligent-Variation51@reddit
Not quite. Black churches can be very energetic, for example dancing with the singing. Pentecostal churches are energetic in a way that looks like people drugged/possessed. As someone who escaped Pentecostal upbringing, I would not attend a (deranged) service there again, but some good spiritual music and dancing at a black church could be appealing
sultrie@reddit
Thats exactly how black deep south southern baptists or cogic churches are. ive seen full on excorsims in black catholic churches in louisiana. speaking in tongues, yelling, screaming, crying. etc.
21stNow@reddit
It's OK to say that some are like that, but it's far from all, especially today.
sultrie@reddit
Well yes. thats what i said. I also stated very clearly that what i said wasnt a blanket fact.
21stNow@reddit
Your first statement indicated that it wasn't all, but the comment that I responded to made it seem like all Black deep south churches are like that.
sultrie@reddit
did you read the other comments? i said it wasnt unheard of that pentecostals do this and its very common to black churches. one of the largest black church denominations in the south is COGIC. Literally black pentecostals that operate under the name “Church of God In Christ” and they 100% do get wild. so it makes sense white pentecostals would do similar things.
Diligent-Variation51@reddit
That’s not typical for Southern Baptist. They definitely have a Pentecostal/ Charismatic Christian element. Though, sadly, we’ve been seeing a lot more of that in the US lately
sultrie@reddit
its not typical for white southern baptists no. for black southern baptists or any black church of any denomination in the south, it will be more common.
ThatVoodooThatIDo@reddit
Sighs in American accent
sultrie@reddit
Sighs in black southern american accent. problem?
ThatVoodooThatIDo@reddit
Nope, I am sighing in the same black southern American accent because I grew up as southern as it gets and I’ve never been to churches with all that going on. Can’t say I have the monopoly on going to a helluva lotta churches, but I went to a helluva lot of churches. Just on Sundays and during revival week in the summer. I just happen to live a bit higher right now
Maybe all that mysteriously happened when I wasn’t there. I guess lucky me…ignore my Reddit username
sultrie@reddit
So that makes you the expert on every southern black church? Did you astral project into every black church in the south on sunday or were you just born with this omnipotent knowledge? Also, you arent the only practitioner here 😂. xxx
FewRecognition1788@reddit
They exist, but are few and far between, and tend to be in small towns or rural areas (or if they are near a city, they get a lot of side eye).
Most churches are very orderly and everyone follows along with a written order of worship when it's time to sing, read responsively, stand, sit, or kneel (if they do that).
GabbyWic@reddit
North Point Church streams online, and has a global initiative. You can check it out yourself. (Georgia/metro Atlanta based). It is not like what is in those movies, but you can judge for yourself.
I’ve been to other churches that are more “boring”, and another that was a lot of yell-preaching. It’s a mixed bag. It’s common knowledge that people “shop for a church” to find one that meets their needs.
Dramatic-Blueberry98@reddit
Depends on the denomination. Not all of them are like that.
edelmav@reddit
charismatic churches, sure. but the rest of us (i was raised in the Norwegian Evangelical Free church, husband raised Southern Baptist, now i'm Orthodox and he's Catholic) don't want to make a big fuss and distract from the message
scarletwitchmoon@reddit
Watch the documentary "Jesus Camp" and you'll get the gist.
Smolmanth@reddit
Pentecostals and evangelicals tend to experience collective religious psychosis due to their belief in the holy spirt ‘moving through you.’
HooksNHaunts@reddit
There are a handful of local churches that are insane with people flopping on the floor everywhere.
normiepitbullmom@reddit
Yes, these churches are very real. The speaking in tongues thing is also…sadly, real.
Sabertooth767@reddit
I would associate that with Pentecostalism (and Charismatic churches at large) and particularly with Black churches. Faith healing and religious ecstasy don't have much of a presence in Mainline Protestant churches.
somePig_buckeye@reddit
I’m Methodist. I went to a few Emmaus gatherings with a friend. Every time they sang at least 4 verses of How Great Thou Art where everyone held hands and kept them in the air. If I have to keep my arms up it needs to be a two verse max.
LifeApprehensive2818@reddit
Episcopalian here, and we have the opposite problem. All right verses of "Oh come, oh come Emanuel" at about 0.75x speed. I think the assistant rector fell asleep one year between verses six and seven.
Former-Fig-9686@reddit
I’m Episcopalian, too. I feel your pain. My wife is RC. We went to her church for two or three Sundays in a row during Lent. They sang “Were you there when they crucified my Lord” during communion as slowly as is humanly possible. If I ever hear that song again, I will run screaming from the church.
QnsConcrete@reddit
I’m RC too and I can’t stand that song.
Former-Fig-9686@reddit
At my wife’s church the organist sat behind the organ looking out at the congregation. He would croon that song sort of like Bing Crosby or Frank Sinatra. I always thought he should have had an empty brandy snifter on the organ for tips.
IShouldBeHikingNow@reddit
I grew up Methodist too. We were very pragmatic. Our church had to end services at 11:50 am so people could beat holly rollers to the restaurant for Sunday lunch.
Wastedgent@reddit
Baptist here. Whenever our service ran past noon the preacher would tell everyone not to worry it'll give the Methodists time to eat and leave the restaurant.
eyetracker@reddit
Don't even have to go to the south, COGIC is around and quite a bit out there.
ZedisonSamZ@reddit
I’ve attended a Pentecostal church with a friend before. They were practically leaping into crowds and dancing on top of their chairs. But most churches I’ve ever attended have been fairly subdued.
ScoutB@reddit
Charismatic pentacostal churches can get wild, like mania level.
Butimthedudeman@reddit
Snakesssss
ITrCool@reddit
Holy cow, the mountain churches that practice snake handling are really weird, not gonna lie. That’s definitely the crazy side of Christendom.
WhiskyStandard@reddit
My wife went to a divinity school that was mostly aspiring mainline Protestant clergy and academic religious studies types who had likely never been to a church like this. When a professor got to the passage that this practice is based on they said “I know there are a bunch of you thinking about how you’re going to write a thesis about this, but just so you know: that means you’re going end up in a room where someone’s throwing venomous snakes around.”
Also, most of the primary sources you’d want to interview are dead. Of what? Well, in a lot of cases, snakebites.
ITrCool@reddit
I'm a Christian myself and honestly, that sect/practice never made sense to me at all. There's literally nothing in the Bible that supports it and nothing spiritually to gain from it.
Cynewulfunraed@reddit
My dad, who was raised Baptist, told me that as a kid he watched a documentary about snake handlers, and the thing that shocked him was people dancing in church
DokterZ@reddit
Baptists don’t have sex standing up because if someone walks in on them they might think they’re dancing.
4LOLz4Me@reddit
🤣🤣 live around to many baptists and never heard this joke before 😆
PuppySnuggleTime@reddit
lol I was raised Baptist, and we all danced. We had dances at the church!
CalmRip@reddit
My mom's folks were Baptists from rural Kentucky. The running joke was that Baptists can't dance, play cards, or go to the movies. That left them stuck with whiskey, women, and fast horses.
Butimthedudeman@reddit
All done in the shadows 😂
Nightmare_Gerbil@reddit
It’s also why Southern Baptists don’t drink alcohol. If they stagger when they stand up, people might think they’re dancing.
Butimthedudeman@reddit
Baptists will drive 12 miles out the way to buy beer on the way home from Wednesday night prayer meeting 😂
Butimthedudeman@reddit
You definitely got the full experience 😂😂😂😂
Cynewulfunraed@reddit
This is the way. You know the difference between Jews, Anglicans and Baptists?
Jews dint recognize Jesus of Nazareth as the messiah, Anglicans don't recognize the authority of the pope, and Baptists don't recognize each other at the liquor store
Frosty_Employment171@reddit
Yeah. I've seen that. But it's the 'laying on of hands' that's a whole other world.
Coldfyre_Dusty@reddit
Snake handling, speaking in tongues, they got all sorts.
FreeRange0929@reddit
Told my story about this.
Growing up, my mother was…out there. Her family was from rural North Carolina, very familiar with Pentacosts. The string she was familiar with though was the snake handlers, a bit of speaking in tongues.
We went to a pentacost church one time when I was growing up that embarrassed even her. Basically, throughout the sermon, you’re supposed to get overtaken by the spirit. People will pop up and start speaking in tongues, shaking, and then the spirit eventually has everyone drop to the floor at some (varying) point. So randomly throughout the service, these people would start shouting then convulsing (holy rollers) and by the time we hurried out of there most of the church was laying on the ground
Butimthedudeman@reddit
I went to my grandma's church one time. It was Pentecostal but mild. Still, being about 6 or 7 and learning that in church you sit still and "every head bowed, every eye closed" and then watching old ladies run up and down the aisle my little confused self was like 😳😳😳😳😮
Healthy-Attitude-743@reddit
That sounds so fun!
blackhawk905@reddit
Protestantdom
lowercasenameofmine@reddit
What about the ones who deny blasphemy outright? That's crazy too
panicnarwhal@reddit
here’s a really wild documentary about a snake handling church - Holy Ghost People (1967)
i think it’s also on Tubi
Elegant-Pineapple-56@reddit
Yeah, my Appalachian ancestors did the snake thing.
Frosty_Employment171@reddit
Laying on of hands gets very scary.
Duck_Diddler@reddit
My dad was born into that insanity. Up in WNC. He’s still a fire and brim stone dude but they can’t have snakes no more. They still do weird stuff by drinking antifreeze and shit
Zellakate@reddit
We had a guy drink bleach here. 😬😬😬 People still talk about it. Not in a good way.
Duck_Diddler@reddit
Yeah bleach was another one they’d drink. Vile practice
she-dont-use-jellyyy@reddit
And they're not just in the south
SignificantTransient@reddit
They're in the north too. I seent it
PuppySnuggleTime@reddit
Southerner here. Yes, all of that happens. The Fried Green Tomatoes thing is a bit exaggerated. People can leave to sleep and whatnot.
LastCookie3448@reddit
Some, yes. There is a sect where I used to live that holds tent revivals that last all weekend, they speak in tongues and handle snakes. They also go door to door seeking new members and are known to throw snakes at people who decline the invite. There are some that speak in tongues and get themselves worked into an almost hysterical state at their Sunday services, and the priests will call people up front to 'lay hands'. Some are huge audio/visual productions with lasers, fog machines, multiple cameras, etc., that cost a small fortune to fund. Then there are the live nativity events with carriage rides, bonfires, and cocoa, to draw in the crowds. It's all so performative.
CD84@reddit
Where is this that they carry the snakes door-to-door and throw them at people?
LastCookie3448@reddit
NC.
alwayslate187@reddit
I would expect that there would have been some documented lawsuits resulting from that
LastCookie3448@reddit
1a, and before doorbell cams, they’d claim innocence. They sent the little Stepford teens, trusted people would open the door for a bunch of innocent looking kids. They were superfun.
FreeRange0929@reddit
In dudes fantasy
Pentacosts don’t see snakes as a punishment. The ones that practice snake handling/healing see it as a blessing/test of faith.
They will absolutely try to evangelize to someone, but they’ll keep that good venom for themselves
Adventurous_Button63@reddit
So what you see in movies, specifically comedic presentations such as you mentioned, is played for comedic effect. That being said, there is some wild shit that goes down in Pentecostal/charismatic churches. (Charismatic describes practices which include “speaking in tongues,” people “falling out” or being “slain in the spirit,” dancing, running, shouting, and other ecstatic expressions)
When I was a kid in the 90s we had “revivals” that would last 3-5 days. Sunday morning, Sunday evening, and Wednesday evening were already church days/nights. Revival made Monday, Tuesday, and sometimes Thursday and Friday church nights too. The longest I’ve personally experienced was 2.5 months, I know of one church that went for like 3+ years. In both of those longest cases, there were some significantly fishy things happening they just kept having services regardless of anything driving it. There would be some retired folks or stay at home moms that would come in to pray during the day on occasion but it was mostly just church at night. Historically, this is how tent revivals ran too. The air was cooler, people were done working, cleaned up and went to hear the preacher who traveled the country. This is what they were talking about in Steel Magnolias. It’s not as common now, but it still happens in older more traditional Pentecostal churches.
Now, as to how common it is and where you’ll find it, there are some rules of thumb. If you’re going to a predominantly white church, there are a few denominations that trend toward charismatic practices: the church of god, church of god of prophecy, assemblies of god, and some seventh day adventists are the major pentecostal denominations. You’ll also find plenty of nondenominational churches that are pentecostal/charismatic and they’re mostly clones of the major denominations but split off into an independent church; same theology, different organization. Outside of these parameters, white people don’t tend to get very charismatic in church. When it comes to predominantly Black churches, it’s a little more common to see charismatic practices across denominations and may or may not be rooted in Pentecostal practices and theologies. A white Methodist church is unlikely to be charismatic while an African Methodist Episcopal (A.M.E.) church is more theologically aligned with the Methodists than their evangelical counterparts, you’re more likely to see charismatic practices at an AME. Other race-dominated congregations tend to be similar to white folks (but this isn’t a hard and fast rule). I have my opinions on why this is…but this comment is long enough already.
I can regale you with plenty more first-hand experiences, history, theology, and stories if you’re interested lol. I have a degree in ministry from a Pentecostal university, worked as a children’s pastor, and have become an empirical atheist later in life.
alwayslate187@reddit
I would be interested to hear more about your theories about why that is so if you have time to explain
Adventurous_Button63@reddit
Basically it comes down to the roots of Pentecostal practices. Pretty much everything Pentecostal is rooted in African traditions and practices, including hoodoo. Black congregations are more closely tied to these practices handed down through generations and so they tend to permeate through different theologies as a shared racial tradition. For non-Black churches, theology and denomination tend to take priority. There is a unique relationship between Blackness and Christianity so it tends to be the outlier when it comes to the practices that Black Christians originated.
alwayslate187@reddit
Interesting, thanks
Apprehensive-Pop-201@reddit
I grew up Methodist in the South. Very boring, not exciting at all.
Pure-Economist9928@reddit
For me it was like that. Raised fundie pentecostal. Hollering, running the aisle, shouting/dancing in the spirit, speaking in tongues, laying hands on people, prophesy, and casting out demons. We didn't handle snakes. But we were wilder than most churches you see on tv. It was never normal it was just our normal. We had a six week revival once with church every night. We didn't rest and my school work suffered. You eat when yuou can, some big services had a meal after. You could pay for a plate of tacos or spaghetti the women cooked. At campmeeting they gave about 175 ppl food poisoning at a midday meal. For many reasons, I'm now a throughly traumatized adult now. So I got the hell out of there.
alwayslate187@reddit
Thank you for this very real comment
pastrymom@reddit
I went to a revival once. There was so much food all over the place. We had breaks for food.
I’ve also done several conferences and retreats. They always had bathroom breaks and food breaks. There was also areas for snacks.
visitor987@reddit
Many revival last a few days; why would that be crazy.
GlobalTapeHead@reddit
Hollywood likes to show the extremes. There are a few churches like that, but as someone who grew up in the south and attended many different types of churches, I’ve only been to one that was actually like that.
hornbuckle56@reddit
Depends, lots of different denominations and churches in Deep South.
Street-Length9871@reddit
My Mom is a birthright Quaker and my Dad was raised in The Church Of God in the rural South. When we went to church with my Dad's parents I was afraid as a child. Tounges, healing, crying etc. Very different churches!
devilscabinet@reddit
You mostly see that sort of thing in Pentecostal churches or other specific denominations. It isn't the norm across the United States, but you can pretty easily find a church like that if you go looking for one. As others have said, a number of "non-denominational" mega churches are like that, too.
marchmay@reddit
Yes, I grew up in what are called charismatic churches. Spoke tongues and everything.
abrahamguo@reddit
I've also seen scenes where people are fainting in the aisles and jumping over pews, or being "healed" by a preacher grabbing their head.
church on Sunday morning and Sunday night and Wednesday and Saturday
I'm sure there are a tiny number of churches where things like this happen, but almost all churches are not like this.
Butimthedudeman@reddit
Those are typically Pentecostal. Pew jumpers and snake handlers lol
GateDeep3282@reddit
I really want to see one, but would they allow a casual observer or would I have to fake it?
Diligent-Variation51@reddit
Be careful. They will make every effort to convince you that joining them will solve all your problems and bring happiness you cannot imagine. Yes, it’s not a coincidence that sounds like cult behavior
Proud-Delivery-621@reddit
They used to hang around the cafeteria at my university and try to proselitize to the people who looked like outcasts (sitting alone or whatever). A friend of my dad's fell into it and they literally made her give a schedule to the pastor showing everything she did at every hour of the day. Eventually he lost contact with her because the pastor forbade her from talking to any outsiders.
aharbingerofdoom@reddit
I think you would be welcome to observe, but they will try to convert you. I was invited to a Pentecostal church by a school friend when I was in my early teens, and my mom told me I was welcome to go, but warned me that it might be different, and not to freak out of they start speaking in tongues or acting like they're having a seizure. I thought she was joking or exaggerating, but nope, it was just as wild as it looks on TV. They would probably put on an extra good show for you if you seem interested and respectful because it's actually part of their faith to spread the word and preach to others.
t_huddleston@reddit
They would LOVE for you to come visit. Seriously. That’s why they’re called “evangelical,” they want to evangelize you.
Diligent-Variation51@reddit
In the 70s/80s, they were called holy rollers. Is that still true? I’m having flashbacks to all the revival weeks of nightly services, with young kids sleeping on blankets under pews while people were dancing, running, shouting, singing, crying. It was exhausting and we didn’t get much homework done those weeks
BeholdBarrenFields@reddit
Don’t forget speaking in tongues!
donnacus@reddit
I remember attending tent revivals as a child. They put up a large tent in the field beside a church. I do think that there were breaks. As I recall we went after lunch then went home for dinner and came back for the evening service. The only true memory I have was a story about a boy/young man who ran away from home. He climbed a tree to spend the night and was stuck by lightning. “So all you young people mind your parents”
Chicago_Avocado@reddit
Some of the evangelical mega churches are wild in their own way. Some cone off very greedy and scammy.
ChiSchatze@reddit
Some Australians I know went to the Abyssinian Church in Harlem - it’s a black Baptist church with a lot of choirs, singing & dancing. They said, “If church was like this in Australia, we would go!”
dobbydisneyfan@reddit
Pentecostal churches (which are everywhere) or ‘nondenominational’ churches (which are either Pentecostal lite or Baptist lite) are.
Bluestarkittycat@reddit
I was raised in a Methodist household here in the south. Church was by far the most boring thing ive ever sat through.
No-You5550@reddit
No not all churches but enough of them that it is something lots of us recognize it as being real. I will let you in on something else it is common for churches to only have only one, two or three main families going to the church. For example my friends husband is a preacher at a church and his father is a preacher at another church. Because father and son do not get along. The family is divided with part going to one church the other half going to the sons church. That is how you get little family churches all over the place.
TeacherOfFew@reddit
Like most of life, most church services would not make for entertaining cinema.
Patient-Hovercraft48@reddit
This is indeed a thing that happens. I would not describe it as normal.
Frosty_Employment171@reddit
Southern Baptist Sunday meetings last all day with meal breaks. But you can walk in and out, folks do. Yes there is a lot of singing and calling out.
Pentecostal is another matter. It will often involved a lot of 'laying on of hands' and screaming for the Lord. And that's when I leave as that's enuff for me.
SouthCotton1979@reddit
20 years ago multi day hours long revivals was very common. But these days not so much. Some revivals are one day now
HermioneMarch@reddit
That is what some denominations do. (Mostly Pentecostal.) Black churches also tend to have a more call and response, interactive worship that is just part of their tradition. But mainline churches follow a fairly traditional, staid service.
Also consider the movie’s time period. Week long revivals and snake handling etc wss a lot more prevalent in rural communities a century ago. Life revolved around church in these communities. At a revival you would sleep in tents or with neighbors who lived nearby. The ladies would all bring dishes and the community ate together.
You also had less seminarians. A man could just claim to have been touched by the Holy Spirit and start up his own church, using charisma to lure people in. That still happens but not as often.
El-Viking@reddit
Normal? No. Do stereotypes exist for a reason? Yes.
Infamous-Phone-1973@reddit
You are looking for a little white pentecostal church out in b.f.e. in the south. The kind you have to cross a creek to get to from the main road.
Reader124-Logan@reddit
My childhood Southern Baptist Church had revivals that lasted several days. It wasn’t round the clock, but you went every night for several hours, and they culminated with an extra long weekend event that included a meal.
Our church didn’t have bands or dancing, but there was a lot of singing and multiple altar calls, often to Just As I Am
And yes, some of them were focused on the End Times.
New-Process-52@reddit
Yeah hungover people at church on sundays
AnybodySeeMyKeys@reddit
I'm in Alabama and an Episcopalian, a member of the 'frozen chosen.'
I've heard rumors of such things, but actually attended? No.
ThroatFun478@reddit
I've only ever gone to united methodist, united church of Christ, and high church Episcopalian (my preferred) services. All are traditions that require a high level of formal education from ministers and an ordination process. There is no holy roller stuff.
I got dragged to one of my aunt's pentecostal services as a snarky teen and was promptly installed in the back pew due to all my laughing at the charlatanry from the pastor and the falling down and speaking in tongues. It was nothing like hearing a sermon from a a PhD in divinity about well translated scripture and reciting the apostles creed like we always had. 😂
They exist I guess, but are a curiosity to most of us.
slpybeartx@reddit
As a kid that grew up in a Pentecostal denomination I have personally seen people jabbering “speaking in tongues”, others “interpreting” what they think they were saying, people shaking, running around the church aisles, people “fainting in the spirit”, and dancing. All during church services.
And I’ve had to go to revivals that lasted every night of the week. I’ve went to four different services on a Sunday. Vacation Bible schools over different weeks in the summer.
I’ve heard Preachers tell us that the following would send us to Hell: movies, dancing, any non-Christian music, most tv shows, mixed swimming, becoming a catholic, curse words and words that aren’t but sound like them, cartoons with magic or fantasy characters, all alcohol, any and ALL sexual acts outside of marriage-solo or as a couple, tobacco, wishing or thinking about any sinful act, and the list went on.
We were taught that Jesus would rapture us at any minute and if we had any sin that wasn’t confessed and forgiving we were screwed. As little kids we spent hours waiting for a parent to get home wondering if it happened and we were “left behind”.
I’ve been to church camps in my youth, went to Christian concerts, and many other events. I’ve had to go to a church out of town when on vacation with my parents.
It was a super strange part of my childhood. And I have zero interest in any of that denomination or similar.
HavBoWilTrvl@reddit
Ray Stevens wrote a song about it.
FreeRange0929@reddit
I wore those tapes out growing up
Doobadah doobadah
Maurice_Foot@reddit
Chicago Churches are cool as well.
The0wl0ne@reddit
Depends on the denomination. I grew up in the Baptist church and it was a “sit down and shut up” thing. You dressed in your Sunday best and just listened to the pastor.
Pentecostal churches though are definitely a stereotype. I went to one for a few years cause of parents and it was exactly like you describe. People standing on pews, speaking in tongues, getting healed
FreeRange0929@reddit
My fathers side are Disciples of Christ. Pretty mild, conservative, go in read a few passages and a few hymns.
My mother’s side…well we went to a lot of churches. Baptist, Pentecost, she took us to a holy roller church one time (I think that was technically pentacost, but much different)
The Southern Baptist are what you often see depicted. Fiery sermons, lots of singing, often black churches in movies will be SB.
The pentacostals, we went to 2 types. The ones from the area of North Carolina my grandmother were from were the infamous snake worshippers. My wife is Catholic, the first time I went to their mass I joked “where’s the snake boxes”? I never partook of that, the idea is to have enough faith that the snake simply cannot harm you.
The other was a bit more than what you’re describing. I remember we went when I was young, throughout the service, the “spirit” would get into everyone and they’d start dancing or talking in tongues. As the “spirit” overtook them, they’d eventually fall to the floor (“holy rollers” as I said) and flop around. By the time we left, even my mother (who’s….out there) was a bit embarrassed by the whole thing.
Revivals, you’re overthinking it. The ones we went to were like weekend (maybe week) long camping trips complete with cookouts, some bible study, swimming all at a campground with most of the church in attendance. You eat and sleep as normal, just kind of communalized
CycadelicSparkles@reddit
I grew up in pretty religious circles that had revivals and stuff but we never had the faith healings or snake handling or all day and night services. There's degrees to that stuff and what you're describing is definitely the rare, extreme end.
TRDOffRoadGuy@reddit
I grew up in a Southern Baptist church and it was insane. The preacher would scream at you that you were going to burn in hell for all this stupid shit that didn't make sense. As soon as i turned 16 i never went back.
Kaakoii@reddit
Eh, being raised southern Baptist, some of the stereotypes are pretty close to fact. We sang all the time, held hands for the final song, but as a child growing up in that small rural church, I always saw love from my perspective. Did Awana club, vacation bible school, Sunday school, and Wednesday night church. But at the same time, I started learning at to be wary of lgbt+ and judge certain people, which made it very confusing coming into my own sexuality as a queer person growing up.
Fast forward to early teen years, we’re smoking black and milds waiting for the church van. I was taken advantage of by an older guy there when I was 13. My high school years, the new bigger Baptist church I went to in a bigger town, the youth minister ended up being convicted of being a pedophile and was found guilty of having inappropriate relationships with 2 underage girls at the church. Mind you, his wife and two children also go to this church.
What I got from all my experiences from then till now at 29 and also all I have to say truly about it is this: I don’t go to church anymore. I feel like a hypocrite there and I feel like most people around me are to some extent. I believe that you are supposed to be kind to people, love your neighbor to the best of your abilities, and try your best to be as a good of a human as you can be. For me, my relationship with God at this point is that he’s exactly what I need him to be for me. Consider me a bad Christian or whatever, but I feel closer this way than I did pretending to be someone I’m not in a church pew.
botulizard@reddit
It would depend on the denomination. Some churches are like that, but not all of them, and usually those same denominations have churches outside of the south that are basically similar.
BananaMapleIceCream@reddit
Yes and no. I’d say the weirdest was a service where they brought in live rattlesnakes (Georgia).
17Girl4Life@reddit
There are some churches that are charismatic, high camp churches. There are plenty that are quite sedate. The funniest one I heard about was a new pastor at First West in West Monroe, LA giving a sermon while riding a mechanical bull he had brought in to replace the pulpit. It divided the membership lol
somecow@reddit
Revival doesn’t last for days, just several long hours. The “faith healing” is absolutely fake.
But every church I’ve been to (and definitely not often) will feed you after. That’s part of community.
Chewiedozier567@reddit
I grew up in a rural Southern Baptist church, so some of the things you mentioned did happen in the past but not as much today. Also you must remember most movies are using an exaggeration of what occurs, mostly to look down upon people of faith,particularly poor people.
The revival services we had growing up started on Sunday, but we would also have dinner after the morning service. They generally lasted until Wednesday, but services were only at night.
The shouting in the aisles, dancing and fainting are usually attributed to the more charismatic congregations such as Apostolic or the Church of God. Most Baptists, at least the ones I knew and grew up with tend to be more reserved. There’s not much difference between Baptists and Methodists, except the consumption of alcohol is more common among Methodists. Do Baptists drink alcohol? Yeah, but it’s generally frowned upon, hence the joke of why you must invite two Baptists when you go fishing so they won’t drink all your beer.
As far as handling snakes and drinking strychnine, that’s more common in the Appalachian area, I’ve heard stories about it but have never experienced it myself.
boopbaboop@reddit
"Normal" as in "that's what everybody does"? No.
Is it a thing that happens in some very specific churches? Yes.
BusinessWarthog6@reddit
This. It depends on the denomination and the type of church within that denomination. I’ve been to Southern Baptist services (not a fan at all) where the service felt traditional like a Methodist service and i’ve been to others where they bring the snakes out
FolsgaardSE@reddit
Reminds me of this scene.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9k260wEclC8
Not sure why but can't stand why some preachers talk and act like that.
FolsgaardSE@reddit
Sadly yes and not even the South but anywhere rural.
Look up WV snake handlers.
HobsHere@reddit
Some are. Some are very solemn and orderly. Some are enthusiastic, but not wild. It varies both by denomination and the particular congregation.
BHobson13@reddit
It should also be noted that not everyone who lives in or are from the South are Christian. Many of us shook that off as we grew up.
Ok_Orchid1004@reddit
There’s also “speaking in tongues”
Former-Fig-9686@reddit
There are thousands of churches in the South. Which ones are you talking about? If you go to a Catholic, Episcopal, Greek Orthodox, Methodist, Presbyterian, or the vast majority of Baptist churches, you will definitely NOT see anything “wild.” If I were you, I’d search other venues if you want to see bizarre behavior.
Emkems@reddit
It’s real but it isn’t every church in the south. There are churches where the spirit possesses them and they speak in tongues. I also had a coworker who was a mime for jesus, and a dancer for jesus. Yes, there were pictures.
FriendWinter9674@reddit
Those churches do exist. Not very common, but not unheard of either. Also, I don't think they are a southern specific occurrence, either.
Curmudgy@reddit
Some of the comments here have convinced me that The Righteous Gemstones is an accurate documentary.
RaineMist@reddit
My mom goes to 2 churches and it's like that sometimes.
straycatwrangler@reddit
It depends on the type of church. I went to a mostly white Baptist church, so there was basically no action there. You wouldn't even catch people swaying to the singing or the music. No speaking in tongues, no dancing, no screaming, yelling, running, jumping, fainting, falling or healing.
We would have potlucks pretty often, which I guess plays into a commonly known Baptist stereotype. Maybe it's a southern Baptist stereotype. I grew up hearing, "Baptists know how to eat."
Sunday morning, night and Wednesday services are common. When my family was more involved in the church, we attended all of the services, plus any holiday/special occasion potlucks, get-togethers, celebrations, etc. which all involved food.
However, some are like what you mentioned. It really depends on the denomination of the church being shown though.
jvc1011@reddit
In Fried Green Tomatoes, it was a Baptist church. But also 80-100 years ago.
straycatwrangler@reddit
Ohhh cool. I haven’t seen it or read it. However, long revivals like that do sound about right. Especially considering the time period.
thats-gold-jerry@reddit
Yeah they’re pretty crazy. Can’t say I’d recommend.
Traditional_Trust418@reddit
My grandparents are Southern Baptist. It can get pretty crazy
emmie-claire@reddit
This is a real thing but it's less than 1% of churches. If your friend was Pentecostal everything in their story checks out.
tcrhs@reddit
There are many different types of churches in the South. What you’ve seen in movies isn’t a very good depiction of Southern churches.
Pitiful_Lion7082@reddit
This type of behavior is common in Pentecostal congregations, but it's absolutely NOT representative of traditional (and by that I mean historically traditional, not just conservative) Christianity.
DeiaMatias@reddit
Most churches? No. Some churches? Yes.
A friend of mine was raised Pentecostal Holiness. When he came out as gay, his parents literally beat him with a Bible and threw him out of the house. He was under 18 at the time. Don't worry, the story gets better.
I met him a year or two later. Helped him get his GED, helped him get a job, gave him a place to crash when things went wrong with his boyfriend, and now he's living his best life. We still grab dinner from time to time.
Anyway, at some point while he was sleeping on my couch, his parents realized they really fucked it all up and reached out to reconnect.
For that first meeting, he didn't want to go alone and asked me to come with him. Okay. Church and lunch afterwards. Big home-cooked meal.
Omg. I was raised in the church. I swear to you, I had never seen anything like this in my life.
There was faith healing, there was speaking in tongues. Have you ever heard the phrase "holy roller?" I learned the origin of the word that day. People were LITERALLY rolling down the aisles. It was loud, it was chaotic. Stuff that I really only thought happened in movies.
Afterwards, his mother asked me, "so, what did you think?"
The real answer was, "That shit is insane."
However, I was raised to be polite and she was my host, so I took a second and sheepishly replied, "I was raised Presbyterian."
She laughed and patted my hand. "Bit different, eh? Well, we sure do appreciate you sticking it out!"
Anyway, they ended up being okay folks in the end, they mended fences with their son, and they all have a pretty good relationship now.
So, yes, crazy churches like that do exisit, but they're rare.
Ok-Race-1677@reddit
You know Europe has churches too right?
yourlittlebirdie@reddit
Do they have Pentecostal churches there?
CobandCoffee@reddit
There's a fairly sizable Ukrainian Pentecostal church near where I live in KY so unless they all suddenly decided to convent after moving here I'd assume so.
yourlittlebirdie@reddit
Interesting! I’ve attended a couple of times (which was….interesting) but I know very little about the history or reach of the church itself.
Ok-Race-1677@reddit
Yes
Zygoatscythe@reddit
Rarely as crazy
bangbangracer@reddit
Oh, those snake handling Pentecostals.
Most churches aren't crazy. But then you might bump into some variety of snake handler.
jvc1011@reddit
Tent revivals were more common in the 19th and early 20th centuries, and not limited to the Southeast. They’re not even limited to Pentecostals, but they are a very specific Evangelical Protestant thing. Not universal among Evangelicals!
They weren’t and aren’t 24/7 for the whole week. Mostly in the evenings on weekdays, more on weekends.
Lilylake_55@reddit
Go to YouTube and watch Mississippi Squirrel Revival. 😂
🎶 The day the squirrel went berserk in the First Self-Righteous Church 🎶
Apprehensive-Ant2141@reddit
Oh, they CAN be but not the norm.
geekycurvyanddorky@reddit
Yeahhh, the Protestants are pretty wild. Lots of fighting between the branches, speaking in tongues, sending kids to torture camps, telling each other that Catholics are satanists and wiccans, and that every kids in a Catholic Church has been raped by a priest, and that being a POC is the the mark of the devil/evil/sin, etc. They also created the kkk, and there are still churches that are segregated and only one shade of people attends them.
✨There are absolutely good Protestants out there that aren’t into any of that stuff though, and are brotherly/sisterly with all peoples of every belief 💖 Pointing out the bad parts of some beliefs and churches is not an attack on all of the people within that religion✨
Fangsong_37@reddit
Some of them do. I grew up Lutheran and had to attend a church with a live band during college, and I never got comfortable with it. I was used to a pipe organ as the only instrument in the church. I also visited a "worship center" for a special event, and they had people shouting and yelling "AMEN" during the sermon, and I wanted to leave. It just wasn't my style of worship service.
NegotiationLow2783@reddit
Wait until you find out about snake handlers.
jkmhawk@reddit
The one time my wife came to my parent's church in Florida, the priest put on a giant cat head.
GiraffesCantSwim@reddit
That sounds amazing. Why did he do that?
overlord_cow@reddit
Maybe it’s because I’m in a heavily Catholic area but no. Though the catholic community ranges from lax feel-good churches to very traditional “don’t you dare bring an acoustic guitar” churches.
At least for Catholic Churches down here (southern Louisiana) the craziest ceremony I can think of is the Easter vigil where you sit in silence until midnight when Easter comes around. Nothing manic and crazy, usually serious and at worst kinda overbearing.
Sparky-Malarky@reddit
Southerners and Protestants please correct me if I’m wrong.
I believe that revivals were more common, and more popular during the depression? People were poor and hard up for hope. Also for entertainment.
As for "a revival that is days long and lasts all day and night" how would this be different from a music festival? Like Woodstock, except with preaching instead of hippies.
GiraffesCantSwim@reddit
I was raised in the Southern Baptist Church, and went to revivals all the way up through the late 80s when I went to college. They were strictly an evening event, because people had work and school during the day. Sometimes there'd be "a singing" on one of the nights, where a couple-few gospel groups from out of town would come and perform, and the congregation would sing some hymns. I liked those. Way more fun than listening to some preacher I've never seen and will probably never see again.
They were usually in a tent next to the church and people from other churches would come too. We were always home by 10 pm or so. Not all night.
holymacaroley@reddit
Most churches are not at all like that, no. But it does exist.
And because my friend who went to college in Ohio's friends thought it was made up for the movie, the tag line for the Winn Dixie grocery store really is "The Beef People", yes.
Asparagus9000@reddit
That's specifically a "revival" rather than a regular church service. The point is to get really hyped about it.
But yeah, there are churches where that kind of thing happens.
LastOfTheAsparagus@reddit
Depends on the denomination.
rcowie@reddit
My now wife and I got locked into a church sermon. I was still smoking at the time and i dont care to be locked up. I tried to step out for a smoke and found the door locked i found my way out eventually. All the doors had padlocks but they weren't locked, just through the latch. I locked them all together and then tossed them in the dumpster. Finished my cig and went and got my wife and told her we were leaving.
GiraffesCantSwim@reddit
Everybody is mentioning snake handling, so I have to point out that it's not nearly as much of a thing as it used to be. I think it's technically illegal in my state (health and safety hazard), but I wouldn't be surprised if somewhere in the mountains and hollers, a few little churches still get up to it. They were always small rural churches anyway.
I heard from a documentary that there's one snake handling church left in Alabama, but I can't confirm that since I forgot what the doc was called.
Video rec: look up "Rattlesnake Preacher" by Ashley McBryde on YouTube.
pinniped90@reddit
The usually de-venom the snakes, except for the church in West Virginia that didn't. Turns out Big J was tending to other matters when the pastor got bit.
pawsplay36@reddit
Pentecostals are like this. Mormons, too, but not when anyone's looking. Baptists mostly more just sing and sometimes faint, but are probably the sect most likely to have a week-long revival in the modern. Modern Protestant mainlines? It's hard to get people to sing loud. :)
Leather_Rate_9785@reddit
I grew up one flavor of pentacostal. What you are describing is fairly common in pentacostal churchs, not common for churches as a whole. I have many memories sleeping in the pews as a small child during late night revivals. I never specifically knew of one that lasted overnight, but I know they've happened.
Yes, people would fall in the aisles (This was called being 'slain in the spirit.')
Yes, I had evangelists pray for me by smacking me in the forehead. (Some are more aggressive than others.)
Yes, people speak 'in tongues.' (This is a bit too complicated to describe here, but it's likely what you would have seen as people saying or shouting strange things.)
Going to church Sunday morning, Sunday night, and Wednesday was the norm for most churches of Christian Denomination untill 10-20 years ago. Less common now, but not super uncommon either.
SignificanceHead9957@reddit
There is pentecostal church where I am, in Scotland, where the congregation will start speaking in tongues and rolling around 'in ecstacy'.
Friggin loonies shame us all.
doonerthesooner@reddit
Some of them are much weirder.
Pentecostal churches are legit insane. Snakes and speaking in tounges
notarealperson319@reddit
I had to go to a eastern Tennessee youth group meeting when I went to visit my cousins in the late 90s. Wildest shit I'd seen til that point. 12 to 15 year old talking in tongues, collapsing and having what looked like a seizure etc...
It's not just the south tho, my grandma in northern Illinois went to a similarly crazy born again church.
meenadu@reddit
I’m catholic. 60 minutes from start to finish.
tabby90@reddit
Also a revival is an event. Believers come in from surrounding areas to attend. It's to 'revive' or reawaken the faithful. So it will be wilder than even the craziest church service.
CommercialWorried319@reddit
More normal in certain areas but not overall normal, wait until you find out about snake handler churches 😆
And the word she was using was "Pentecostal" who believe in speaking in tongues and some of the wilder things in some of them.
Revivals can vary from just having some extra services and guest speakers all the way to days long marathon sessions, I've never attended one that was 24 hours, usually they'd break in the early afternoon so you can go eat or whatever then be back in the evening, sometimes there'd be a fellowship where everyone would eat together potluck style and then back to preaching.
Wednesday, Sunday morning and Sunday evening are standard in the Baptist churches I attended, Wednesday was typically a class, sometimes broken down by gender or age, Sunday morning would be Sunday School followed by a service and then another service at night.
Some areas are more religious than others, where I lived in Indiana we had a few big churches and that was basically it.
Where I currently live in Texas there's big churches and tons of smaller churches, some only have membership in the teens and 20s and a handful actually attend services regularly.
aldmonisen_osrs@reddit
Pentecostal? Yeah that tracks
RickySlayer9@reddit
Some are, some aren’t.
The problem is evangelical Baptist churches
Aggravating-Key-8867@reddit
OP, you should look up the Pentecostal movement, the Assemblies of God, and the Charismatic Movement. There are specific strains of Christianity that emphasis baptism by the Holy Spirit and gifts of the spirit (including prophecy and speaking in tongues). In these churches, people become very expressive in their worship.
These movements have roots going back to the Second Great Awakening in the early days of the Republic in which itinerant (traveling) preachers would go from place to place setting up a tent and leading worship for several days before packing up and moving to the next place.
AdamoMeFecit@reddit
There are SO many denominations and congregations. A few of them in the Pentecostal tradition tend to dance and sing a good bit. Other niche traditions lay on hands as a form of spiritual healing, speak in tongues during possession by the Spirit, or even handle venomous snakes as a way to demonstrate their trust that god will protect them. (Spoiler: the kill rate is unusually high in those churches).
Conversely you also will find Quaker congregations that are completely silent during worship unless a member is moved to speak.
Full gamut of worship practices. By far the bulk of the Bell Curve is mainline congregations who sit, kneel, stand politely and on cue. Pray when it’s time to pray, sing when it’s time to sing. Go drink coffee afterward and spend the afternoon mowing the yard.
Aquarius_K@reddit
My family church often has week long revivals but you go home lol you just return the next evening. The more energetic preaching is often associated with Pentecostal or Holiness churches. When I was a kid some lady in front of me got the "holy ghost" and she flopped and shook so hard her hair clip flew off and hit me in the face lol. Every night the preacher is usually red faced and exhausted at the end of service. It's common for some random person to start speaking in tongues or some other outburst. I'm not really religious anymore but I still go sometimes to see my family or just get the general support of "Hey how are you?" from 100 people. Anyway churches and places of worship in America are as diverse as the people.
NoCaterpillar2051@reddit
I don’t think it’s normal at all. But it happens all the time.
Yeahboyeah@reddit
In reality, Church and State merge and it's usually pro-tRump rhetoric. My neighbors inherited a home of his dad's and are from FL. They said the churches in Oregon are too liberal. They are Southern Baptists. I told them Jesus is too"woke" in these parts and believes in feeding the poor and healing the sick.
tranquilrage73@reddit
Those would be Petacostal churches. My grandma called them "Holy Rollers."
I used to go to church with my grandma at one of those churches. It scared the shit out of me with the speaking and tongues and such. Although my grandmother attended, thankfully she sat quietly in her seat and fed me hard candy throughout the service.
SphericalCrawfish@reddit
There are like 70 million churches in the south. Most of them a guy reads a book, people sing, everyone has a sip of wine, everyone goes home. But if one in a million is crazy fire and brimstone psycho that's still a fair number of churches.
NintendogsWithGuns@reddit
It’s very specifically a charismatic Pentecostal thing. Assemblies of God and Church of God being the two largest Pentecostal sub-denominations, although a lot of “non-denominational” churches in the south are essentially Pentecostal churches that don’t want to pay dues to a governing body. There are also some “Baptist” churches that do this, but they’re not as common. I was raised in such a church, so I’m quite familiar with the movement.
But no, the majority of churches in the South are not Pentecostal. If anything, the majority are Baptist or Church of Christ, which are fairly boring little denominations. Catholicism is pretty big in parts of the South as well.
Delicious_Oil9902@reddit
Protestants have always been a little peculiar with their tambourines and such
dildozer10@reddit
Some yes, and some no. I had a great uncle who jumped, yelled, and screamed during his sermons, and tent revivals last for days, dusk till dawn. He preached at the oldest church in our small town, and he vehemently opposed mega churches. The guy was very fun to be around outside of church, he told great jokes.
The church I grew up going to was much more laid back and chill. The preacher was a hellfire preacher and would raise his voice, but rarely got excited. It was easy to fall asleep during his sermons.
One time at my great uncle’s church, he hosted a couple of snake handlers from West Virginia, and he asked them not to bring snakes into the church. Instead they yelled, streamed, danced all over the floor, and at the end, brought out jars full of spiders, and covered themselves in spiders. 8 year old me was absolutely scared shitless, and this is a lot of the reason why I stopped going to church. My uncle kindly asked these men to never step foot in his church again.
duckfruits@reddit
Some of them, yes.
ixiterum@reddit
Part of the thing about the south and churches is that there are a ton of denominations and you’re bound to see in every town a thousand different churches, some of them only slightly different from another. Churches are also fairly racially segregated, even in diverse areas. I grew up in a super diverse metro area but ethnic and racial groups tended to go to their own churches. Some more charismatic and Pentecostal groups do things like speaking in tongues, laying of hands, etc but it varies a lot from church to church. Non-denominational and mega churches can also get up to some wacky stuff, but in a different way. Pyrotechnics, huge stages, giant bands playing pop worship music, that sort of thing. Some churches are really boring, though. My grandmother was a Methodist and of the few times I stepped in that church (almost exclusively for funerals, albeit) it was very mundane. Lots of non-denominational kids I went to school with went to churches that were more plain but went constantly. Youth group, Wednesday services, etc.
Elegant-Pineapple-56@reddit
The American religious spectrum is wide and varied. As a former christian involved in ecumenical ministry, I had opportunity to visit and worship in many different southern churches. At a cajun Pentacostal church, the service ran 3+ hours and people "ran in the spirit" around the room, some falling and taking out folding chairs. Other churches had a tight schedule, everything done orderly and precisely to get out in 60 minutes.
In more conservative denominations, I think it's still expected members attend most services, but evening and Wednesday services (in addition to Sunday morning) are not nearly as common as they used to be. Revivals and special services can last longer than a standard Sunday morning service.
Leading-Occasion-428@reddit
They can be. I'll speak from personal experience. I few years ago, my mom and I went to this small church. Apparently the holy spirit "broke out" and there was no sermon. People were shaking, crying, kneeling down, speaking in tongues. The pastor was just screaming into the mic over and over again. It was super intense, dramatic and I was so scared that the holy spirit was gonna hit me (at the time I was still a christian, and even then I was scared of the holy spirit because I was afraid I was gonna act like a maniac like the ones in the video when I caught it). But nothing happened to me.
After church we all just sat down and ate dinner together like it never happened. Weird asf.
eternal_casserole@reddit
Oh, they get weird no matter where you go, at least in a lot of evangelical circles. I was a pastor's kid and grew up in churches in about six different states from Florida to Maine, and there are equal levels of being absolutely bananas in every region.
jezreelite@reddit
Pentecostal churches specifically do have a reputation for being rather strange. Aside from the faith healing, they are also known to speak in tongues and a few isolated churches engage in snake handling, despite it being illegal in many states.
Revival meetings, though, are not specific to Pentecostals. Baptists, Methodists, and general Evangelicals also do that.
Piper-Bob@reddit
A pejorative for Pentecostals is holy rollers, on account of the falling over in the aisles.
Ohhmegawd@reddit
Sounds pentecostal
armadilloantics@reddit
Its generally a very specific church (Southern Baptist or Church of Christ) and even then it isn't every congregation. This depiction is also a bit old timey and would not expect to find it in the same in modern times.
ITrCool@reddit
That’s not really an SBC thing. You’re thinking more of Pentecostal churches. If an SBC church is doing that, it’s definitely against the SBC denominational distinctives and could land that church in hot water with the denominational authorities.
NintendogsWithGuns@reddit
Church of Christ doesn’t even believe in music, so I think you’re mixing up your denominations.
whipla5her@reddit
Spent a lot of years in the church growing up (went to a pentecostal church and they aren't the only ones that go twice on sunday and once on wednesday), and then as a musician as an adult, so I got to travel to other churches. I've seen the people losing thier shit and running around screaming, I've seen pastors "faith heal" people, etc. I've also seen pastors spend an hour and a half of a two hour sermon, harrassing people to bring money up to the stage to prove their faith. There's some crazy churches out there. On the other hand, I've seen some incredible kindness and compassion as well and most of my longest friendships are people I met at church. Funny, none of us go anymore though.
TheLonelySnail@reddit
This isn’t a ‘southern’ thing. I can find you a few churches here in Southern California that are like this
DrBlankslate@reddit
This is normal for very extremist, fundamentalist churches. Most churches don't fit into that category.
Cacafuego@reddit
It's real, but I wouldn't say it's normal. I'm not even in the south, but we have churches like that in rural Ohio.
I went to church youth camp in my teens (for a girl, of course), and it was essentially a multi-day revival. There were sermons during the day and then people broke up into smaller groups for more religious and social activities (and food and sleep) in the evenings. The sermons were fiery and hateful. I had to listen to them talk about how my friends were destined to hell for being gay or engaging in premarital sex. Since it wasn't the south, we didn't even get the good music or fancy hats.
I've also been to a small church that my grandmother-in-law attends, and that was fairly eye-opening. The minister yelling about Christ needing Christian soldiers to man the walls, people in the audience standing up, yelling "amen!" and lifting their hands to the sky. Nobody passed out, but some of the older members were sucking down their oxygen pretty hard.
But that's nothing compared to some of the churches we have that I steer well clear of Pentecostals, Charismatics, and even more exotic denominations. Speaking in tongues and snake handling.
CatoTheElder2024@reddit
No
ticktack@reddit
I attended a church exactly like that. Our revivals were a week long, and several hours in the evenings but not all day (people do work, after all). We also had church potlucks for meals. The youth also took a week off of school to attend full-day, week-long regional events held in stadiums. And I also attended a church-affiliated sleep-away summer camp. The other commenters saying Pentecostal are spot-on. “Charismatic” is a newer term. The church across the street from ours also had a snake handler- now those people were weird 😆
snuffleupagus7@reddit
It is a real thing, but it is uncommon. You might see it at some Pentecostal and charismatic type churches in the south and appalachia, but not frequently, even if you went to a Pentecostal church you would not necessarily see it. I have been to churches (Baptist and 'non-denominational' which basically have baptist theology) where there is a lot of hands waving in the air, dancing, coming up to have hands laid on you to pray, people coming up to confess various things publically, etc; that sort of thing is more common.
Revivals last for days but people would not stay the whole time. Most of them have events (sermons and music) scheduled and don't last all night. I have heard of one that lasted all night but I think people still came and went and didn't stay 24/7.
Minimalistmacrophage@reddit
Honestly people even going to church regularly is the minority.
Most churches are not like that. But some are even crazier.
Meekanado@reddit
It happens in churches all over the US. Some churches are crazier than others. I went to one once where people were running up and down the aisles and the stage looked like a game show setup. It was in Ohio. Weird shit. People can be conditioned to accept anything and it’s scary.
Self-Comprehensive@reddit
What you are describing are Pentecostal churches and revivals, for the most part. And yes, they do exist all , all over the US, not just in the South. It is not the majority or even the norm, however. Most religious folks just go to church once or twice a week, sing some hymns and listen to the sermon and then go on about their week.
beamerpook@reddit
The one in my husband's hometown was. They have revivals where people speak in tongues and dance and do crazy shit
OrthodoxAnarchoMom@reddit
Wilder.
The 24/7 stuff the church is open 24/7. Any given person isn’t there 24/7.
shammy_dammy@reddit
The earliest flashbacks are to 1927, so they're portraying the south a century ago. Yes, there were revivals and snake handling (still are, but not to the same degree) and all of that stuff. Does it still happen back in the hollers and gaps. Sure. And yes, this is Pentecostal.
Openly_Unknown7858@reddit
No. And I only know of people going to them Sunday morning and sometimes Wednesday evening.
SirFelsenAxt@reddit
I have known people who went to churches who were exactly like that.
When I was a kid we went to church on Sunday, had youth group on Saturday, and D-group on Wednesday.
But there wasn't any hooping or hollering.
This_is_fine0_0@reddit
That is not something you would see in most churches but you could find one like that.
Wolf482@reddit
Why don't you try going to a church and finding out?
LiveMarionberry3694@reddit
As a guy who attended many churches in the south growing up, some are like that, but not most.
Mysterious-Web-8788@reddit
Some of them, yes. Most of them no,
BananaJelloXlii@reddit
Pentacostal ones for sure, but they are like that everywhere. We call them the "pew jumpers"