Which car would you pick for 35k?

Have you driven one at the limit? The consensus and through experience, it’s one of the best drivers car around that price range. Front mid engine, double wishbone, very very lively motor, and engaging gearbox. Even stock it’s great. Once you set one up properly it’s very hard to beat for the money.

[-]

PrometheanEngineer@reddit

Yeah, and it was totally "fine"

It was the fastest autocross car I've had, but it wasn't nearly as fun as a bunch of other cars I've owned

My C5 Z06, blob eye STI, and even my MS3 were all more actual fun.

[-]

SAHairyFun@reddit

The newest one is 17 years old

[-]

Khoanigsegg@reddit

And?

[-]

SAHairyFun@reddit

And it's a little long in the tooth for a reliable reliable daily driver

[-]

GPW-S2k@reddit

S2000 will be my choice also, such a good car for the money.

But from his list I will pick the New Z in performance for the rear LSD or the C6 Corvette in manual 08+ for the LS3, those are fun cars but the harmonic balancer has to be replace no matter the mileage, the factory ones wobble after not many miles.

[-]

Khoanigsegg@reddit

S2000 best car

[-]

Temporary-Chest-3111@reddit

Doesn’t look like there are convertibles on OP’s list at all.

[-]

AdvertisingLittle954@reddit

Honda accord Hybrid ?

[-]

Tresaki@reddit

Not a fan of BMW or Mercedes but this is a pretty solid list. EERIELY similar to the cars I was cross shopping before I got the GR86. If you can head to a CARMAX if available in your area and try test driving some of these. But for me it came down to the GR86, Focus RS, Jaguar F Type and Lexus RC F. And the only reason I didn't get the other 3 is because used they all costed more than a brand new GR86. And Toyota offered me a unheard of interest rate in this economy so I couldn't say no to that.

[-]

CardiologistFun8398@reddit

My brother has an elentra n and it’s sick af. Got me interested in cars

[-]

Thick-Paper1595@reddit

Ats v or mustang gt.

[-]

Winax2449@reddit

I'd take the 5.0 GT. Preferably with manual and convertible. Not the fastest or most unique or whatever but I just love a good, simple V8 to go vroom vroom in.

[-]

Super_Mario_DMD@reddit

Toyota GR Corolla. The cars is very fun to drive and has enough power to keep you happy

[-]

grammer70@reddit

Honda Accord. I have owned two over the last 30 years. Each extremely easy to maintain and drove over 250k miles on each, they are rock solid. On my 3rd now.

[-]

MakkNero@reddit

The depreciation sweet spot really doesn’t exist anymore.

Go get a new warrantied GR86/BRZ and call it a day. Your insurance will be high as hell, but the car will hold up.

[-]

Expert-Platypus-3136@reddit

Toyota gr86!!

[-]

Astronaut-2025@reddit

New Mazda cx~5

[-]

Amazing_Tangerine569@reddit

None.. i’d pick xiaomi, Huaweii or Chery Chinese cars over these bunch of overpriced dinosaur cars

[-]

No-Extent-8897@reddit

Genesis for me.

[-]

Ok-Carpenter-362@reddit

Find a Chevy SS. Criminally underrated car.

[-]

Arthurelwooda@reddit

X3 m40i

[-]

not-a-toad@reddit

Dont know your financial status, but i recently was in the same boat. Had the same budget and considered/test drove a lot of the same cars that are on your list. Is it gonna be your only car? Don’t forget to also factor in mpg, practicality, insurance cost, repair cost, etc. I ended up picking up an older brz for way under my budget, only 10k.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

Out of what you listed, the cars that will be the most fun while having the least repair bills and, most importantly, not get you killed are

370z, Elantra N, brz/86 (I think they fixed the oiling issue)

[-]

undarant@reddit

A friend of mine recently sold his Elantra N and bought a 981 Cayman S. He's a proper driver, did quite a few track days in his EN. And he said that one of the biggest things he retrospectively learned after getting the Porsche was just how good the Elantra N actually is. After he had the reference point of daily-ing a car that's better in every way, he said it was shocking how solid the EN would perform in hindsight.

OP, do with that information what you will.

[-]

Ghost_with_no_name@reddit

I have a year left on my lease and I’ve been reading so much about the Elantra N that I can’t wait to at least test drive one, let alone buy one

[-]

undarant@reddit

They're pretty amazing cars. I think too many people get hung up on the "but it's still a Hyundai" thing. I think the Elantra N is Hyundai's serious first step in kind of restoring their name. It's not perfect, but it's a car that changes the landscape of cars at its price point.

[-]

JMPhotographik@reddit

Oiling issue doesn't appear to be fixed, but I just picked up a new GR86, so I guess I'll find out in a few thousand miles. I'm still 100% planning to pull the pan at 5k miles at least to check.

[-]

drpepperfan69420@reddit

the oiling issue is mostly about people who tracked their cars. If you're daily driving your GR86 like a civilized human being, it'll be fine

[-]

sssozi@reddit

Not an issue. I drove mine for 40k in 1.5 years. No issue.

[-]

Indication5151@reddit

It’s not an issue I assure you. Just half quart overfill and call it a day.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

If you must continuously add oil to your brand new car to keep it alive, you have a problem.

[-]

Ancient_Manner_2650@reddit

They don’t burn oil…the oiling issue is just mitigated a little by overfilling the engine with oil, something that is very common on track cars.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

I thought the new ones had an issue with oil consumption not the same oil starvation in corners the old one had? Am I mistaken?

[-]

Ancient_Manner_2650@reddit

I didn’t even know the first generation had that issue

But no, no oil consumption issues just oil pressure from taking hard turns on one side, forgot if it’s left or right lol.

[-]

fcwolfey@reddit

The first gen issue was people putting R compounds on for track days without upgrading their oiling system with baffles and they would drop pressure in high G corners. For normal street driving it wasn’t a real problem

[-]

JMPhotographik@reddit

Nope. No consumption, but starvation and the "RTV issue" are still a thing.

[-]

kStefano@reddit

Trash, SS and 5.0 are BOTH reliable. That’s ridiculous.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

and most importantly, not get you killed

[-]

windmill09@reddit

100% the 370z. Some antisway bars is all it needs for the canyons.

[-]

morganlandt@reddit

If you’re suggesting the Ecoboost Mustang why not the RS? Same power plant with AWD and a manual. Plus the limited run of them lowers depreciation.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

Because of the many issues they had, including lifting the head. There are quite a few things a seller can hide, just not a really safe buy.

The EcoBoost mustang he wants is a newer one and doesn't have the same issues. Totally different revision of the engine.

[-]

Pinkys_Revenge@reddit

As an ex-370Z owner, if you want to get serious with it, make sure there are good solutions for camber adjustments and the shitty rear differential. When I had mine (when they were new) there weren’t any good aftermarket solutions yet and it kinda sucked.

[-]

DoloSteadyCruising@reddit

I'd second this motion.

[-]

cheeky_LAMB_7@reddit

Gr86 sound's fun

[-]

TheRoley02@reddit

On the list you provided the Gen 2 CTS-V is probably one of the best options. I have 1 (2012 sedan) with full bolt ons, + E85 since 35k miles. 680 HP at the wheel. 120k miles now and only thing I ever have to do is change spark plugs, and fluids (includes diff fluid).

My friend also has one that he did the same full bolt ons + a cam + E85 and his is close to 200k miles now and he has had zero major issues as well. Pretty much same maintenance items as me but he has had to change some worn out suspension parts by this mileage point in his.

Find a stock one with good maintenance records and you should be golden.

[-]

banannassandwich@reddit

2025 Mazda Miata

[-]

Extreme-Machine3162@reddit

Get the baby GTR. Red Sport 400

[-]

laylowlazlo@reddit

Lotus Elise will bring more smiles per gallon than any car on this list

[-]

laylowlazlo@reddit

I’ll give you a breakdown of your list from my perspective having sold most of these cars.

Infiniti Red Sport 400 - Pass due to turbo issues with those motors amongst other things

Camaro LT1/SS - Cool to get the Corvette motor, I would not settle for LT1 over SS. I would pass though due to very high theft rate, you just hear about it less because the Mopar community is much more vocal and larger

GR86/BRZ - Compared to most other cars on this list you are getting half the car for twice the price. The GR86 experience really isn’t so far off what an original Scion FRS provides for $12K

Mustang GT - Good bang for your buck but not special and will depreciate. I see GT’s as regular traffic, especially when GT350’s exist for not a whole lot more

M2/3/440i range - The motors are known to be reliable, and this is being told by their values which have spiked once this became known. However, you will wish you got the true M experience VS M-lite. You are in F80 territory, get the M3/M4

Genesis G70 3.3T - Quick but numb. Still wary of engines past 50K miles. Will depreciate hard like any other Korean car, they are not immune

Stinger GT - Same complaint as G70, quick but numb. Still has Kia issues and Kia depreciation

Elantra N - Just no, not in the same vain as the other cars on your list. Replace with Civic Si or better yet Civic Type R.

370Z Nismo - Cool car with good platform that will hold its value. Does suffer from high theft rates

Porsche Cayman Base - Good car but not worth getting over the S

Cadillac CT4-V - America’s latest answer to the M3 is pretty cool from what I hear, but I can only judge off the ATS-V sedan’s I have driven. Theft can be a concern just like it is for Camaros

X3 M40i - This car only makes sense if you are looking for a compromise. Judging by the other cars on this list, this doesn’t seem to be the case so I don’t understand why you would want to consider this over an M340i, in which case the same complaints still apply

Camaro SS 5th Gen - See earlier Camaro notes

Jaguar F-Type - Not the car if you don’t like dealing with reliability issues. With the way Jaguar was/is setup, think of them as basically Land Rover Coupes and Sedans. They use the same engines, transmissions, and a lot more components. Suffers from the same depreciation as Land Rover cars as well

Mercedes SLC 43 AMG - Like my notes on M340i, I am against lite versions of cars. AMG means V8, you know it does

Mustang EcoBoost - You will wish you got the V8. Do not consider, this is the Mustang for people who don’t care about cars

GR Corolla - Cool car, interesting motor, only time will tell how they hold up. Good depreciation curve being a Toyota, but at the end of the day you are still in a Corolla

Cadillac CTS- V, ATS-V - Yes and Yes, 2 distinctly different engines that live up to the V name. Be wary of high theft rates

Ford Focus RS - can have reliability issues, hard to find not thrashed

Nissan Z base - not a special car in my eyes

I would highly consider a Lotus Elise. They can be very reliable with the Toyota 2ZZ setup and you will have a truly special car. I speak from experience!

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

Wow #1 comment, thank you for this

[-]

KoenigseggAgera@reddit

Since you’re considering its competitors, you may consider an Acura TLX A-Spec.

[-]

norwegiangreen@reddit

I was going to suggest the Acura TLX! I’m in my mid-20s similar to OP. I’ve first learned to drive in a 2017 Honda CRV. I also had a 2021 Passport for 2 years. I really loved the Honda experience and the reliability, but being young I wanted a sporty, sexy car. The CRV is the opposite of that. The Passport is just so excessive for a single guy.

I looked into Acura as it’s the luxury/performance wing of Honda. I loved the TLX higher refinement and quality interior and exterior, in addition to the same reliability as Honda. Personally, I find Acuras to be more sporty looking and better for a younger person than Lexus (I think the stereotype is Lexus = older person car). The 2021+ Acura TLX in any trim has a undeniably sexy exterior.

I just got a 2021 Acura TLX Advance with 41k miles. I had to pounce on it quickly because the Advance seems to be a very rare trim and I liked the extra luxury touches over anything extra sporty.

Coming from a compact and midsize crossover, I don’t mind the size of the TLX at all. Really the TLX is a midsize sedan. It has serious road presence, despite being a sedan. I don’t feel unsafe driving it, as it’s around 4,000lbs. Trunk is a very good size and fit my CRV trunk weather mat perfectly. The rear seats are extremely comfortable and plush, but legroom might be tight for people over 6 feet tall. The second row is absolutely useable, despite what some things I saw online. The front row is extremely comfortable and spacious, I actually enjoy the touchpad because fingerprints on my previous touchscreens used to bother me a lot.

[-]

Vcapeph@reddit

The new car with a full warranty that fits your bill is a 2026 Honda Civic Hybrid Hatchback Sport Touring Over half of the other stuff on your list are going to be money suckers sooner or later

[-]

Dry_Diet9916@reddit

4runner

[-]

midyearqueen@reddit

Camaro as

[-]

sfo2@reddit

86, corvette, and Miata (which I assume you just forgot to add) are the only cars on this list I’d really be interested in owning personally. Light weight, short wheelbase cars are where it’s at. Reliable, cheap and easy to repair, cheap consumables.

[-]

Ancient_Work4758@reddit

25 mustang eco. It's the newest on your list. Ive been driving a 15 eco since I bought it new. It's been solid and that's 10 years of improvements to that 2.3

[-]

Longjumping_Song_134@reddit

Before reading your list I thought brand new honda civic hybrid. After reading your list I believe most of them seem like another nightmare waiting to happen, probably gr86…

[-]

Brave-Captain-7596@reddit

So the world does not work that way, at your age first look for insurance prices, then average fuel consumption, tire prices.... you make an Excel. you discard 15 models (the highest in price to maintain) you choose from the 5 that you have based on a mixture 50% logical and 50% passion for cars.

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

I did that to reach these 20.

[-]

Brave-Captain-7596@reddit

Doit again, till you only have 5 options max.... if not, its like hunting 4 polar bears at florida.

[-]

JORGEiSDEAD@reddit

2026 civic si new, used corvette, used bmw e30 in good condition

[-]

Horror_Direction2150@reddit

A BMW that’s slight newer with the Gen 2 B58. I’d go for a G20 in your budget

[-]

ChampNR@reddit

I'm biased towards Kia, Hyundai and Genesis. After I bought my first Genesis all my friends and family went out and bought one. They all agree they are great cars.

[-]

GlitteringPen3949@reddit

Can get a brand new Miata for 35k the RF is a hardtop. Will have a warranty

[-]

Competitive_Day6307@reddit

V9 chalenger shaker

[-]

LongjumpingRespect96@reddit

You said your budget is $35k - what’s your budget for repairs and maintenance, cause every euro car you mentioned is going to take big bucks to keep on the road?

[-]

HalfLegend@reddit

My G why don’t I see a 981 cayman S?

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

Not in budget, unless it has 100k+ miles

[-]

HalfLegend@reddit

Just got a fresh and shockingly clean 90k mile base model for 30k, well optioned. You’d be surprised how many baby’d stock models still pop up.

[-]

enderbird87@reddit

Get a RF Miata. You won't regret it!

[-]

Kanye_Z-143@reddit

Camaro all the way. Sould be able to get a 2ss for that price.

[-]

Palannos@reddit

I can't believe nobody has recommended a 2021-2023 Lexus IS 350 F sport with that sweet red interior. Best bang for your buck. No questions asked.

[-]

MemerDude34@reddit

Nowhere near the best bang for your buck for what it sounds like OP is looking for. They’re ultra-reliable and very solid daily drivers, but not exactly enthusiast friendly.

[-]

-DeuceDeuce-@reddit

Super slow and dated interior. Might as well get a Camry and save 30 grand. Does look nice tho.

[-]

Consistent_List_6279@reddit

honda civic dont get to flashy

[-]

RidiculousTakeAbove@reddit

C6 corvette, c63 amg

[-]

meabyter@reddit

No Subaru WRX? I've had 2 and they were great cars, super reliable (if you don't mod the hell out of them) and great cars for street or track use.

[-]

Fun-Bathroom8103@reddit

r/GRCorolla is beckoning…. Join us….

[-]

HuntGundown@reddit

I'd get a fiesta st, 300whp that bitch and have 15k left

[-]

drpepperfan69420@reddit

GR86, although I can really see an argument for the Z-car if you can find a stick

[-]

Bitter-Chicken-3773@reddit

g70 3.3 all day

[-]

Inevitable_Grab_9338@reddit

Awd rav4 hybrid

[-]

Ragnar-Wave9002@reddit

Dude, get a rav4 hybrid brand new. Or 3 years old to save money.

[-]

Technical_Jello3055@reddit

GR corolla because wagon

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

What universe do you live in that makes a compact hatch a wagon???

[-]

Technical_Jello3055@reddit

It’s slim pickings in the US for wagons today so I’ve expanded my wagon love

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

I quite literally could not think of a dumber answer than this. You like hatchbacks and you like wagons. Wagons are rare and that's fine, the definition does not need to be expanded simply because you don't find them very often.

[-]

bruh_the_person@reddit

u/DJScaryTerry is allergic to fun and whimsy apparently

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

I love fun and whimsy, calling hatchbacks a wagon because it's hard to find wagons is like calling a wrist watch a pocket watch because it's hard to find pocket watches. It's dumb.

[-]

Lower_Kick268@reddit

Not a wagon, that's a hatchback

[-]

Pinkys_Revenge@reddit

Agreed, other than it not being a wagon.

[-]

Technical_Jello3055@reddit

I know it’s in the hot hatch segment, but it def feels much more wagon than my mk8 egg

[-]

PhotographLess6194@reddit

GRC is so small, hardly consider it a wagon. Can barely fit any luggage and has super small back seats only good for kids.

[-]

bruh_the_person@reddit

that’s a hatchback

[-]

Ill-Nectarine592@reddit

I drive a 22 BRZ.

First car I’ve owned outright and bought myself once I got my first real job. 1000% recommend for a fun daily driver and a good fun car. Power issues with the second gen aren’t a problem especially in this price range. More room than a Miata and a bit newer and with a hardtop roof vs the S2000

I highly recommend you look at the platform and get a lightly used example. Definitely worth a test drive

Check out the whip on ig: djsbrz

[-]

pbrown6@reddit

Used Camry

[-]

PossibilityTotal191@reddit

C7 corvette stingray for an extra 5

[-]

pieindaface@reddit

C7 base in manual really is the whole package. What’s great car. If I wasn’t a sucker for MR2’s I’d be saving for one.

[-]

PossibilityTotal191@reddit

Mr2s are nice and yes manual is the way, sadly because of how much i drive for work plus how much traffic im always in and because of the 2 options i found when i get my c7 z06 it will be auto :/ sad but at least its still a z06

[-]

pieindaface@reddit

Idk man. There are worse places for traffic, but driving in the DC area in a manual is not bad at all.

Even then, I found there is practicality of having a cheap reliable automatic car. I drive my MR2 whenever I want. Work, grocery run, date night, whatever. If I don’t want to, I just drive the Camry. It gets better gas mileage and is quiet and easy to drive. Don’t compromise on your 10% car just so it can be your 99% car. Unless you only live in the city and only have space for 1 car, you won’t want to drive it everyday anyway.

[-]

PossibilityTotal191@reddit

Eh my 10% car is already my 99% car haha, 500whp stinger gtline ive put 100k miles on it the past 3/4years Itll be at about 150k miles when ill be in a good place to trade it for the z06 so itll be about at retirement miles, but yeah im mainly in the city. Luckily all the z06’s around me have less than 5000 miles on them

[-]

titanium_bruno@reddit

Corvette C6 but with Z51.

[-]

prn006@reddit

Toyota GR86.

[-]

3dl33@reddit

New Elantra N or GTI

[-]

biohackenthusiast@reddit

infiniti. where’s lexus tho?

[-]

editoratcharge@reddit

No Golf R? Mk7.5 is in that price range. Out of your list though I would go with a M240 or m340.

[-]

oilers411@reddit

M240i / C6 grand sport / bmw z4M coupe / miata / nismo 350z / E90 M3. All manuals.

[-]

editoratcharge@reddit

I’m with you on the first two. Third or maybe even second would be the mustang. I’ve always wanted to drive a Miata to see what all the hype was about. I think that would be one high mileage E90.

[-]

derkfisch13@reddit

x3 m40, new z, gr, or ecoboost for me personally

[-]

WikipediaBurntSienna@reddit

I would be aware of insurance in your early 20s.
On that list, what I'd honestly look at the Nissan Z or Cayman. But if cost of ownership is too high, then the Elantra N would probably be much better.

[-]

street_talent@reddit

Gr86. Reliable and fun

[-]

Thin_Ad_2182@reddit

Probably the BRZ

[-]

JennaLeighWeddings@reddit

You could probably swing a C6 GS for that coin...

[-]

WiizKlafka@reddit

I own an Elantra N. It's a super fun daily driver and it will have the longest warranty on this list.

It's not the fastest/most powerful if that's your goal, but it'll have the best peace of mind and is great for tracking AND long road trips.

[-]

Emergency_Fun_2853@reddit

Love my N so much

[-]

FindingAlignment@reddit

M240i or the Genesis

[-]

PolybiusChampion@reddit

2022–2024 Toyota GR86 / Subaru BRZ - newest, lowest mileage one you can find and never look back.

Shockingly my 2nd choice from your list is the ‘14 -‘18 Jag F Type. The driveline on these is pretty robust and all the other stuff is reasonable solid. Great motor, still turns heads and not too hard to maintain. Plus lots of these were/are owned by old guys who never really drive them hard. Again, find a low mileage example from a 1st or 2nd owner and enjoy.

[-]

evilr2@reddit

I went with a G70 3.3T a few years ago and happy with it. But I'm in my early 40s so interior luxury is more important to me. If I were younger I'd probably go with a Camaro.

[-]

Green_Tradition9925@reddit

Not on your list but I’d get a C7 corvette!

[-]

DaishiGD@reddit

F-type

[-]

dwarfpike@reddit

If we are being honest, it is the most fun car on the list.

[-]

CC7015@reddit

GTI or Golf R would be on my list

[-]

Galromir@reddit

Buy a Miata or a GR86/BRZ. I think you could maybe swing a new one of any of those? or at least near new? not an expert on US prices.

Don't buy anything American or German.

[-]

BruinBound22@reddit

A new GR86

[-]

FitEstablishment4627@reddit

Lexus ISF, BMW E9X,

[-]

streamerjunkie_0909@reddit

I bought a 25 GTI, they get some hate but i never get tired of driving it. Next car will be a Porsche or Golf R.

[-]

AndresRAyala@reddit

Nissan Z base.

[-]

maxnormaltv@reddit

F-type

[-]

Fydron@reddit

I would choose my old Vito and keep the 32k

[-]

dutchman76@reddit

BMW M240 all day long. I've had 0 issues putting over 100k miles on mine. Just needed tires and oil.

[-]

jckwlzn@reddit

Same here 106k miles. Best daily and has a fuck ton of power

[-]

gdiddy1324@reddit

Low mileage 2018 Audi A7

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

2011 a6 was my nightmare Audi haha

[-]

yeawrongperson@reddit

What even happened brother?

I had a 2007 S4 but the 4.2 v8 motors where trash, absolute hell hole I got myself into. Young and dumb. 15k in debt and needed a new 5k motor. I learned how to put a motor in a car tho at 18 🤣

Now I’m onto a 2021 A4 45 Premium Plus, it’s using the tried and true EA888gen4 motor, same EA888 platform as what’s in the Golf R’s, and I’ve been seeing nothing but praise as the only weak spot is the water pump around 60k going out. Other than that, some 2019 and 2020 A4’s I’ve seen it 250k already surprisingly. Fingers crossed for myself hahaha

[-]

DarthVaderRPh@reddit

I was going to recommend a golf R/Audi S3. The gen 3+ EA888 is a solid motor. You’re right about the water pump issue though. I have a 105k mile S3 that’s been tuned since 20k miles and it’s been an absolute gem with no issues at all.

[-]

jckwlzn@reddit

M240i

[-]

ShapePlastic3874@reddit

Ct4-V no question

[-]

YouShitMyPants@reddit

You could get a used m2 for around that price range. But raw performance and in a manual nothing really comes close to a corvette or Camaro.

[-]

_THX_1138_@reddit

Buick Roadmaster Estate

[-]

FitFormal7363@reddit

I don't think anyone here knows what that is 😂

[-]

Ancient_Manner_2650@reddit

Car guy in their 30s here, no idea what that is

[-]

10footjesus@reddit

I'm not a huge Regular Car Reviews watcher, but this videos is one of my favorites ever and it gives a good overview while it's at it:

https://youtu.be/ooFWD5w6pXA?si=ah6CfL2slquyFHjB

[-]

FitFormal7363@reddit

They had what seems to be creative names for pretty much all the big 3, some survivors for sure, but that was a boat station wagon the was supposed to make you feel like you were an estate owner cruising around checking on things with 12 kids in the back and standard luggage racks that would come in handy for going on vacation at your other estate properties. Could also handle a couple of Coffins in the back by collapsing the seats if you were leaving your estate for the other side. Then we got mini vans and that's pretty much what got us where we are today with the invention of the SUV that covers a lot of what the wagons and vans did, but not quite the same flair in there names. Country Squire really makes you connect with the theme. Ok I will STFU now.

[-]

beforesunsetearth@reddit

They ought to.

[-]

floridamaannn@reddit

He’s in his early 20s not early 70s 😂

[-]

90_CRX_si@reddit

Maybe get some VIN numbers of these cars you are looking at and see what the insurance is gonna be

[-]

Kuniyoshi99@reddit

E39 M5

[-]

Jolly_Cicada380@reddit

Mach e

[-]

Optimassacre@reddit

GR Corolla. Fast and fun. Probably won't catch fire. Basic maintenance should last a lifetime.

[-]

AJRoadpounder@reddit

22-24 Mazda 3 Turbo AWD. Just bought a ‘25 with 10k miles for just over 35k. No CVT transmission.

[-]

comment0freshmaker@reddit

Gen 5 Prelude.

[-]

New_Breadfruit8692@reddit

I bought a 2019 740i that was $32k with only 30,100 miles on it and now has 43,300 in 2024. They are out there and I have found it to be one of the most reliable cars I have owned in my 54 years of driving.

[-]

u700MHz@reddit

Lexus RC 2015-2018

[-]

Wisco777787@reddit

I bought a new Elantra N in 2022 for $33,500. 100k 10 year powertrain warranty. $0 in repairs. Even free oil changes. I love the car. I’d look at trying to find a deal on a new one

[-]

howrunowgoodnyou@reddit

I have lots of fun cars that don’t need repairs all the time that were under 5k

any 88-01 Honda w a 5spd. Absolute blast to drive; slow yeah but handling is full regard and it feels fast af because you’re so low and there isn’t much car
miat
vw w 1.8t and chip tuning. You can go from 180/180 to 235hp/275ftlbs w just software

I think spending 35k on a depreciating asset in your early twenties is fully regarded

[-]

Cute-Percentage-837@reddit

The only vehicle on that list that might be trouble free is the corolla.

[-]

bharding81@reddit

Craziest part of this list is how old you’ve gotta go on a lot of these models to get them down to $35k….. seems like yesterday some of these were $35k new. Nice list tho. Good luck choosing!

[-]

DrPhilMustacheRide@reddit

Id probably get a GTI

[-]

LuckInternational336@reddit

F Type

[-]

Bamram91@reddit

C6 corvette

[-]

muchgass@reddit

Mustang, Q50 or C6. Or look at an IS350

[-]

PoopSmith87@reddit

None of these. They are all either unreliable, impractical, expensive to maintain, or just not cool.

I would be looking for like a 2015-2020 Mazda MX-5 (retractable hard top), Toyota GR86, Subaru WRX, etc. Any of those with a manual transmission.

[-]

Nerb49311@reddit

996 carrera

[-]

DropGearStayHere@reddit

What do you want though? These are so different. Also, you missed the right answer: S2000.

[-]

Jiggaloudpax@reddit

probably a very clean 80's series Toyota LC

[-]

Milking-Camels@reddit

BMW E46 M3 AND ITS NOT EVEN CLOSE.

[-]

darbykp@reddit

CTR

[-]

MattDinOC@reddit

Assuming you want a manual :)

6th gen Camaro SS or 86/BRZ, depending on how much juice you’re after!

[-]

ShoeFree5756@reddit

These are my favorite on the list as well.

[-]

SeminoleVictory@reddit

The GR86 / BRZ

Japanese + RWD should give you very few problems

The Z is both of those as well

[-]

crankin_muh_hog@reddit

This list needs to be shorter.

Do you want AWD, RWD or FWD? Do you want a manual? Do you want a driver's car or a muscle car? How important is the exhaust note? Is this a daily or a weekend car? Are you going to maintain it yourself?;

Out of your choices I'm getting an SS or a GR Corolla

[-]

Main_Paramedic_292@reddit

A $9000 Camry.

[-]

SolarWind77@reddit

Golf R

[-]

Medcuza2@reddit

Laughs and cries as a Singaporean. I wish. It's usd$150k for a mazda 3 here.

[-]

Ancient_Manner_2650@reddit

How do you guys even afford to drive there. Are you guys getting paid significantly more or are you just rich lol

[-]

Medcuza2@reddit

Car loans :( the CoE (car tax) just to get a car is killer.

[-]

meisum123x@reddit

Have you considered a Lexus 👀?

[-]

Fadedfaith451@reddit

You know, I test drove most of these minus the Porsche, jaguar and Mercedes benz. The 3 BMWs I test drove was the 2021 540i, 2023 M340i, and a 2024 X340i. I really hate to say it but the BMW X340i was my favorite and I was really close in purchasing one.

[-]

Small-Studio@reddit

Early twenties and few repairs I’d definitely pick the Corolla or gt86

[-]

Tasty_Cod_7354@reddit

Bmw m340i or x3 m40i are the best all rounders without a doubt

[-]

Lower_Kick268@reddit

Me personally the Kia Stinger or Nismo Z

[-]

Vegetable-Giraffe-79@reddit

Gr86

[-]

Tylighter12@reddit

I'm literally in your exact situation. Got a 2020 Mustang GT premium(with PP1 and 400a). It's a blast. Powerful, reliable, loud, just all around fun. Love the interior too, plenty comfy and nice.

Just don't floor it on turns and become part of mustang crash compilations

[-]

Local-Wing-8080@reddit

Fifth gen Camaro is the answer. Great looks, great power, reliable, and even has a backseat. Don’t even bother with the Toyota 86/BRZ…a civic si would smoke you.

[-]

Temporary-Chest-3111@reddit

Having just bought a 3.0si, I’d suggest a Z4M Coupe if you’re not a roadster person. Hydraulic steering, S54, manual transmission and quite a bit of traditional BMW character.

Also, if it’s a weekend car are first gen Lotus Elises available where you are? They’re hitting just about 35k USD here these days.

[-]

K_Linkmaster@reddit

2025 Ecoboost mustang. It is more than enough and come with a warranty.

[-]

Ancient_Manner_2650@reddit

I’ve been seeing dealers drop the price on them heavy, down to like $5k off. Makes me wonder what they’ll be in the used market in like 2-3years, probably a crazy value

[-]

K_Linkmaster@reddit

Because we are 1/3 of the way thru 2026, 2025 should be heavily discounted.

[-]

DapperCadaver2021@reddit

Lexus RC350

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

New gen gr86 is better

[-]

Ancient_Manner_2650@reddit

Depends what you want

The gr86 is going to feel like a shitbox compared to a 10 year old rc350 for commuting.

I think you need to test drive all the cars in your list and you’ll be very surprised what you like and don’t, compared to what the internet hypes up.

[-]

Acceptable-Room985@reddit

Good car but they made the same car for almost 10 years. I've driven a 2015, even with 150K miles it drove beautiful

[-]

lard-tits@reddit

The c6 corvette is a stout choice. Probably one of the most raw drivers car on your list. They’re old cars now so they will have things that need fixing. Worth it though if you are willing to deal with that.

[-]

El_mochilero@reddit

I own a 2007 C6 base.

I love it so much. Favorite car I’ve ever owned. There’s nothing like it for the combo of price, performance, ownership cost and ownership experience.

[-]

carcaliguy@reddit

That's C7 budget, I daily drove c5, c6, c7. All great mpg when you light on the foot.

[-]

Pinkys_Revenge@reddit

I love a c6, but I don’t think it’s a good choice for a reliable car in your 20’s

[-]

zinten789@reddit

Corvettes are reliable and your 20s is the best time to own one.

[-]

lard-tits@reddit

They can be if you keep it mostly stock. Reliable is relative here though.

[-]

Dinismo@reddit

I got a z51 corvette. Don’t regret it at all. It’s still as fun as it was when I bought it in 2018.

[-]

Crotch_RockIt@reddit

If you get a C6, go ahead and pony up for a Grand Sport.

[-]

lard-tits@reddit

I agree on this.

[-]

Hoovie_Doovie@reddit

C6 electrical... yikes.

[-]

lard-tits@reddit

Never had electrical issues with the z06 i had.

[-]

Kdoglol@reddit

I’ve driven a Cadillac CTS-V and that is my choice. Chevy reliability and parts availability, corvette sound and performance but with a back seat and a trunk.

Next I may be tempted with the Genesis if you want more luxury day to day that torque.

[-]

_Mezuka_@reddit

If you want a fun to drive manual sport car thats got modern features and some (but not much) utility: brz hands down

If you need something with more practicality: GR Corolla or Elantra N (depending if you want a hatchback or not)

If you want a convertible or dont need the extra space:, Miata, s2000, c6/c7 corvette

[-]

Previous_Feature_200@reddit

None of the above. Buy a two year old Camry and drive it for 20 years. Save like crazy while you’re young and retire at 60 with not a worry or care in the world.

[-]

BCJ_Eng_Consulting@reddit

Brand New VB WRX base.

[-]

TheTortise@reddit

You can buy an 86 brand new for that budget, and probably get Subaru to give you a discount on a BRZ to that price range as well

[-]

Weinerdogwhisperer@reddit

Cayman. Live A little.

[-]

Grand_Moose_6890@reddit

Gr or s2000

[-]

HowDoYouLikeMeNowB@reddit

I have owned a 5th gen camaro SS for 12 years and it has outlasted everything while being the most hard driven vehicle. I have, and still, autocross it every month and take it to track days where my husband also drives it, so it's out on track all day long. We have owned so many cars and the Camaro Just. Keeps. Going. I have spent more on tires than I spent on the car at this point. I service it myself and everything is so easy, parts are easy to find and cheap. Off the top of my head, other cars we have owned to compare against: 1999 subraru impreza, 2002 impreza, 1991 miata, 2001 sonoma, 2004 crown vic P71, 1986 toyota supra, 2008 C6 Z06, 2011 Cayenne Turbo, 2016 2 series, 3 series E36, Pontiac G6, 2015 dodge charger SRT8, 318 E30, many street and dirt bikes.

[-]

BartesianDrunk@reddit

2023+ Ford Mustang Mach-e Premium or GT. Test Drive one, OK?

[-]

artemiswins@reddit

Get a focus ST, super fun and a morale engine in the focus RS, torque steer and front wheel drive is super fun and just switch out the winter tires and no problem at all. You don’t even need the big turbo, but that can up the game, but the stock turbo is so small that it spools up almost instant instantly and makes coming out of corners just a riot.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

The focus ST and rs both have the same engine problems, most people I know with one have replaced the engine.

[-]

morganlandt@reddit

I’m at 157k on my ST. I hear the horror stories but I just baby it until it’s up to temp on everything and enjoy.

[-]

DJScaryTerry@reddit

Occasionally you hear about the owners with nothing but luck of the platform. Unfortunately they are not common.

It's kinda like DSM's, some people can swear by them, most can't

[-]

Sweet_Common_55@reddit

Miata

[-]

unpolire@reddit

Tesla Model S or any AMG model.

[-]

0peRightBehindYa@reddit

Personally I'd go with a CTS-V, Chevy SS, or a built Caprice or G8....but I've developed strong feelings for Aussie Chevies.

[-]

morganlandt@reddit

SS will be hard to find for a good example of OP wants a manual for 35k, I’d personally love a CTS-V wagon with the 6 speed but I’ve wanted one since they came out. I really like the SS too, talk about a sleeper.

[-]

K_Linkmaster@reddit

Don't you dare buy that red sport for 35k. It is not worth 35k. I can sell mine to CarMax for 25k which means it's only worth 20.

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

I’ll buy yours for 26k

[-]

K_Linkmaster@reddit

I replied somewhere else. The Ecoboost with a warranty

[-]

helpmefixer@reddit

2026 Honda Civic SI

[-]

Kamalethar@reddit

I'd probably buy an MX-30 so the Wife gets her oh so necessary AWD and spend the savings putting it on a lift kit so she can sit higher than everyone else. She just wants to look down into their eyes as she slams into 'em...I'm pretty sure at least.

[-]

PK808370@reddit

X3 M40i is useful and drives well. M240i great car

Mustang, but the pre 2018 look better.

[-]

Unique_Mix9060@reddit

2024 Volve S60 T8, severely underrated car and the ultimate sleeper, 455hp plug in hybrid 4.3sec 0-60

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

Interesting pull

[-]

Unique_Mix9060@reddit

Yeah and you can get really low mileage examples for around $35k

[-]

Cynyr36@reddit

I'd love one of these, but even 35k is too rich for me.

[-]

Gmod-Racer-Overdrive@reddit

If it was me, I would probably pick a 2007 to 2009 GT500.

[-]

Aioka1@reddit

Honestly id look at a couple year old Tesla Model 3 Performance. You'll get a lot of hate from old school car guys but really close to 0 maintenance really. Maintenance is Tires and washer fluid for the most part. Its a super fast and very fun car to drive.

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

👎

[-]

Mysterious-Guide8593@reddit

C6 is a solid choice, the Camaro SS is also a good possibility, but that AMG seems hard to pass up if its really in the same price point?

[-]

AskThis7790@reddit

GR Corolla

[-]

CattywampusOG@reddit

Elantra N

[-]

floridamaannn@reddit

Early twenties I’m assuming no kids? Get the corvette or cayman, if you need a practical one get it later in life when and if you need the extra back seats

[-]

Sacred_B@reddit

Don't skip a test drive in a mk 7 GLI. More power than you expect.

[-]

lunchbox651@reddit

Those all look horrifically boring to me.
The Cayman might be fun but Porsche parts can be pricey if you break something. Easy to get, just not cheap.

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

What would you buy hot shot

[-]

lunchbox651@reddit

I don't really like newer cars as my "fun" cars. Sure they can be fast and I can view 378 cameras around the car but I find the act of driving the vast majority, boring.

As close to your requirements, I'd look at something like a VW Scirocco, Audi S1 but what you think is very fun may be wildly different to myself. What are you looking for when it comes to fun? Straight line power, something that looks cool, something you can modify a heap, something that's slow with brilliant handling, AWD/FWD/RWD?

[-]

ClapClapFlapSlap@reddit

Manual Transmission 2nd Gen Acura TL

[-]

renispresley@reddit

I would get a just off lease used EV - many great options fall under your price target.

[-]

MeesterCHRIS@reddit

6th gen Camaro SS with a manual. Because I’ve missed mine every day since I traded it.

[-]

garkerfatbitch@reddit

440i. The b58 engine and ZF8 transmission are some of the most reliable machines out there. That’s going to be the most bang for your buck car on this list

[-]

Cloakedbug@reddit

Anything under 3,000lbs, if you actually care to experience the drive.

[-]

Emotional-Buddy-2219@reddit

I’m a fan of the Infiniti, G70, GR 86, or 23 Z base.

[-]

N1njagoph3r2@reddit

Ct4-v if you can find it for sure. Then probably a m240i or a g70. Just the best cars on the list imo.

[-]

GenericallyCorrect@reddit

No GTI? I get that Audi did you wrong but the eggs have the best bang for your buck. Running 300+ hp with less than 3 g’s into it.

[-]

SaoirseMayes@reddit

GR86 all the way, you can get it for under 35k brand new with options.

[-]

wuhanbatcave@reddit

7 ford focus

[-]

SopranoCrew@reddit

Camaro SS is probably the best bang for your buck on the market

[-]

Head_Photograph9572@reddit

2006-09 Porsche Cayman S. You'll find plenty with less than 60K miles. Just get the engine scoped and a PPI inspection.

[-]

PM_Me_A_High-Five@reddit

I got a low miles 2020 bmw 440i for a little less than that and I like it

[-]

porta-potty-bus@reddit

Get one that has a manual transmission and have fun

[-]

kh04@reddit

I got my facelift G70 3.3t Sport Prestige (top trim) RWD at 14k miles for $35k, cross-shopped against a lot of these options and found it to be the most comfy with low maintenance and just enough performance.

However your experience will be highly dependent on your local Genesis dealer for recall/warranty and indy shop for maintenance. Maintenance is cheaper than my B9.5 A4 so far and only 1 recall (turbo hose) + 1 minor coolant hose leak covered by warranty.

[-]

Thin-Tax7836@reddit

Fk8

[-]

FitFormal7363@reddit

2018–2022 Ford Mustang GT

[-]

Zealousideal-Tax1344@reddit

Infinity nice looking holds its value

[-]

dRedPirateRoberts9@reddit

I mean I got a 24 EV9 GT for $37k.

[-]

Careless-Internet-63@reddit

GR Corolla but get it inspected thoroughly, reliability is really not bad if they're taken care of but they're also cars that tend to be abused

[-]

amibeingtrolled@reddit

Brand new Miata Club.

[-]

TheBobInSonoma@reddit

Not an expensive European car. You should have learned your lesson. Should probably try driving different types of vehicles from your list to narrow it down.

[-]

TrvthReloaded@reddit

Get like 3 ford rangers with plans to lift one, slam one and keep one stock. And buy yourself a sandwich and a movie ticket with the change

[-]

IAteTonysLoMein@reddit

My older brother had a dream of buying two identical trucks. Lift one and put 'Up Above It' across the hood. Slam the other and put 'Down In It' across the hood. He passed a couple years ago, but maybe one day I'll have the idle money to do that in memoriam

[-]

jango-lionheart@reddit

Wrong sub, pal

[-]

timmmarkIII@reddit

Mustang GT convertible 2022 or so

[-]

ApatureSilence@reddit

You could probably get a 21 or 22 IS350 with like 50k miles.

[-]

Annual-Duty-6468@reddit

For 35 you can get a brand new VW Jetta GLI and have a full factory warranty. Depending on where you live you might be able to get one with a full maintenance package as well.

[-]

Hot_Plastic_@reddit

Extremely biased but my vote is a Mustang gt

[-]

YouWillHaveThat@reddit

2011-12 Shelby GT500.

[-]

kmacpt33@reddit

2016 ATS-V. You can find one in your price range easy. Criminally under rated. Fantastic car stock, but with around 5 grand in mods and tuning you'll have a 650+ rwhp rocket that will embarrass a long list of other high performance cars.

[-]

deanmass@reddit

Get insurance quotes and this field will narrow...

[-]

KM964@reddit

You can find a current 4 Series coupe or convertible at that price. I did. Though it likely will be the 430 with the B48. I enjoy driving mine.

[-]

Wild-Range5433@reddit

Get a Bolt and a level 2 charger. You will love life.

Real life convert.

[-]

ProfessorApex@reddit

From this list:

Lose the X3. Crossovers are lemmingmobiles.

See if you can stretch to a Corvette Grand Sport.

No convertibles?

If it was me and my $35K I’d be looking at interesting older stuff in very good shape. Vintage is extremely cool and enjoyable/gratifying even if it doesn’t return the computer-generated numbers of modern performance cars.

[-]

FinStop@reddit

CPO Macan S

[-]

Heinz_Legend@reddit

Used Corolla

[-]

Pinkys_Revenge@reddit

Automatic or manual?

I’d probably go with the newest Camaro SS you can afford, or a GR Carola, depending on whether you prefer RWD or AWD. I think RWD is more fun unless you have lots of access to loose surface driving.

[-]

sc-rider@reddit

GR86 but no Miata? M I A T A

[-]

Miller335@reddit

Early 20's? Something cheap and reliable. Start saving for an emergency fund/house/retirement.

Your list is insane.

[-]

Flylo_Lotus@reddit

No fun allowed

[-]

Miller335@reddit

Don't be dense. It is once you got other things covered and you know this.

[-]

MarchTop6194@reddit (OP)

Don’t worry, Jane street is paying

[-]

Southern-Usual4211@reddit

The 18-22 Mustang GT fairly inexpensive huge aftermarket support and a large community of onwers. Great car for the money

[-]

bp3dots@reddit

M340 fo' sho.

[-]

Hoovie_Doovie@reddit

You'd be hard pressed to find an M340i in OP's budget. When he typed 340 he didn't make a mistake. He's looking older. For that budget.

[-]

bp3dots@reddit

Ah, I just carried it down from the 2. Good catch.

[-]

Hoovie_Doovie@reddit

340i is still a good, fun car. Just morr wear and heat put into those plastic engine parts and I don't like the look as much.

[-]

ElPresidente714@reddit

Good lord that’s a lot of different cars. You’re in your 20’s. Every car need repairs. Some more than others. Think about maintenance budget. If budget is restricted, then eliminate all the German cars. I have several BMWs and work on them myself. If I didn’t, I couldn’t afford ownership.

If ownership budget is an issue, then stick with Honda/Toyota. Most reliable and parts are easily accessible and generally easy to replace/repair.

[-]

metamodern-mess@reddit

Had a similar search but with higher budget and still got an 86.

[-]

Ok-Front8255@reddit

F-type