Can americans tell the difference between spoken spanish and portuguese?
Posted by Zygoatscythe@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 1174 comments
Posted by Zygoatscythe@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 1174 comments
ToastetteEgg@reddit
I can. Not sure if the flyover states could.
Ok-Walk-8040@reddit
Yeah, Spanish sounds like Spanish and Portuguese sounds like a Russian guy trying to speak Spanish.
Permanenceisall@reddit
Portuguese sounds like you’re speaking Spanish with a bouncy ball in you mouth
Rhombusofrecipes@reddit
That's great😂
RobertMosesHater@reddit
Portugal Portuguese sounds more Russian. Brazilian Portuguese more French in my opinion
poisonedkiwi@reddit
I agree. Used to date a Brazilian, I always thought Brazilian Portuguese sounded like Spanish & French had a baby lmao
JustAutreWaterBender@reddit
Same ancestor language!
LightedAirway@reddit
If I’m listening and it sounds like Spanish but then I realize I’m not recognizing any of the words and they actually sound more like French… except I don’t recognize any of the words as French either… I’ll go back and forth like that a couple times before I finally conclude/ realize that I’m listening to Portuguese.
Altruistic-Dig-2507@reddit
Same
Snoo_16677@reddit
That happened to me once when watching a movie in another language. The language sounded familiar, but I couldn't place it. I finally looked it up and discovered it was from Brazil.
LightedAirway@reddit
The first time I heard Romanian spoken in a film, my brain kept trying to squish it into the “sounds French!” box!!
Snoo_16677@reddit
My grandfather was born in Romania, but he and his siblings moved to the US in ~1913, so I never got to hear Romanian spoken.
spleenboggler@reddit
This is me trying to understand Italian.
LightedAirway@reddit
There’s a rhythm to Italian that I usually pick up pretty quickly - though I do get your point!
Ok_Watercress_7801@reddit
Fvcking bossa nova 😒
The_Ref17@reddit
Which is pretty much what it is, if you look at the history of the language
Cyphierre@reddit
Splain please? How are those three languages connected historically?
heart_blossom@reddit
They were talking about Brazilian Portuguese sounding like both French and Spanish.
This is likely because France, Spain and Portugal all colonized SOOOOO much of the Americas that the languages blended together a lot more over here than they have in Portugal.
Aside from that, all the New World languages sound similar yet obviously different to the Old World languages simply because it's in a different place so the evolution of the pronunciation has gone a different route.
Responsible_Side8131@reddit
They all descended from Latin
TrueStoriesIpromise@reddit
Latin produced French, Spanish, Portuguese, etc. they are called “Romance languages, after Rome.
tumunu@reddit
+ Italian and Romanian.
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
It’s not really. French and Spanish aren’t like the mother of Portuguese. Portuguese, Spanish, and French are all like sisters with Latin as the mother.
TheBotchedLobotomy@reddit
here is a pretty good explanation
Atlas7-k@reddit
Besides being descended from Latin?
ClinkyDink@reddit
Before I started learning Portuguese I thought it sounded like a mix of Spanish and Italian with some nasal vowels thrown in.
spam__likely@reddit
That would be Catalan.
JulesCT@reddit
French and Spanish did have a baby. Twins, in fact.
Catalan & Valenciano.
Myfourcats1@reddit
That’s how I imagine Occitan
CAGrilling@reddit
I actually always thought that of Catalan.
Radar1980@reddit
That’s Basque
mrpointyhorns@reddit
Basque language isnt related to either of those languages
Spirited_Ingenuity89@reddit
Or any other language in Europe for that matter.
Willing_Ad_699@reddit
Yeah we’re like I think this Mexican dude is an Indian or something.
Arderis1@reddit
This is exactly how I describe Portuguese too!
Sylent09@reddit
Omg you've dated a Brazilian?!?! THAT'S SO MANY!!!
*I'm sorry, if I didn't say it then the 'tism would make it feel like I'm getting poked in the brain with a sharp toothpick until it got what it wanted.
JimLeader@reddit
Glad you’ve got it out of your system.
No-Anteater1688@reddit
That's what I've always said about Brazilian Portuguese!
diversalarums@reddit
I was married into a partially Portuguese family and that's exactly how it sounded to me.
Cblasley@reddit
I always say that Portuguese is like reading Spanish while trying to pronounce French.
wiserTyou@reddit
Yep. I had a bunch of Brazilians working at my site and my Portuguese coworker could barely understand them.
Myis@reddit
Not surprised. My Mexican husband can’t understand Bad Bunny
dangerousdave2244@reddit
Puerto Rican Spanish is quite unique.
grandma-activities@reddit
My Puerto Rican aunt refused to teach me Spanish because she said she wanted people to understand me. So I learned from a Colombian and a Peruvian, and with my latent French accent... no one can understand me.
dangerousdave2244@reddit
To be fair, Peruvian Spanish is REAfast compared to say Mexican Spanish. My mom is Peruvian
grandma-activities@reddit
It's so fast, but it's so pretty!
badtux99@reddit
Wow. My impression entirely upon first hearing Brazillian Portuguese. I was like, did the French conquer them at some point in the past or something? Glad to hear it's not just me.
DankBlunderwood@reddit
I never heard Portuguese until I went to Brazil and my first thought was how it sounded like Russian because of the zh sounds and many y diphthongs and weak vowel sounds.
justbreathe5678@reddit
I always thought it sounded like it has an Italian accent
FilthyMindz69@reddit
Brazilian Portuguese sounds like French, Spanish, and a little Italian to me.
Where Brazilians really seem more Italian to me is in their mannerisms, use of hands, body language, volume.
ClinkyDink@reddit
You’re probably thinking of Brazilian Portuguese then. They say Brazilians speak with their mouths open and the Portuguese speak with their mouths closed lol. The gap between a Brazilian accent and a Portuguese accent is pretty wide.
DrKittyKevorkian@reddit
Moçambican Portuguese is pretty easy to follow as a Spanish speaker if you review a pronunciation guide. Kinda lispy Spanish.
bendingoutward@reddit
We share that opinion, but for some reason I have trouble articulating, it also reminds me a lot of what little Mandarin I've heard.
Like, more than just not understanding it.
kitesurfr@reddit
Nah, I speak French and Spanish fluently.. Portuguese sounds like unintelligible danger. Something i should be able to understand, and yet, when it's translated back into English for me I realize I understood non of it.
Successful-Clock-224@reddit
The Brazilian-American kids I grew up around sounded like Helen Keller trying to speak Spanish when they spoke Portuguese.
Affectionate_Data936@reddit
Living in Florida, my mind went immediately to Brazilian Portuguese and forgot that people in Portugal speak it too lol.
opheliainwaders@reddit
Agreed (and as an American who speaks French, it's kind of like a fever dream to be in Brazil and allllmost understand what's being said).
soggyballsack@reddit
Baseline Portuguese sounds like a whining Portuguese.
mhook52@reddit
My buddies wife is Brazilian, always sounds Italian to me.
MuchDevelopment7084@reddit
Agreed. I was hearing a lot of French and Italian words during my visits to Brazil.
basszameg@reddit
Yeah, Brazilian Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a French accent to me. Must be all those nasal vowels.
FlyByPC@reddit
I speak French reasonably well, and Brazilian Portuguese sounds like a Spanish person who had way too much to drink, to me.
Bashira42@reddit
Yep. Portuguese is one of those languages I feel I should recognize when spoken, and most of the time I go "oh no, my French has gotten so bad! I don't understand any of that!" when I overhear it
katarh@reddit
"Looks like Spanish, sounds like French" is how Portuguese was sold to me in college.
RockShowSparky@reddit
yes, bom gia sounds like bonjour.
currymuttonpizza@reddit
Agreed. I also knew a Russian guy who said his ears perk up if he hears Portugal Portuguese because even to him it sounds like it should be Russian, because there are so many shared phonemes, but it sounds like gibberish.
KnotUndone@reddit
That would make sense that I here it as more French as all of the Portuguese speakers I have met were Brazilian.
edparadox@reddit
Definitely not French.
dh1971@reddit
I used to live in South Florida near a large Brazilian population and this is exactly what Portuguese sounded like to me.
Arkhamina@reddit
Efb. I can read Portuguese ok with my Shitty Spanish, but spoken (in Lisbon). Next to nothing. Sounds Slavic.
Theomnipresential@reddit
I grew up with family from the Azores, so got used to hearing Portuguese.
I always describe it as Spanish is softer while Portuguese is Spanish except you're getting punched in the ear
weggaan_weggaat@reddit
Perfect description.
NortonBurns@reddit
I'm a Brit with a vague smattering of German, French, & restaurant level Spanish & Italian.
I went to Portugal for the first time last year - and that's what I thought. I could kind of make out some of the signage written, in restaurants etc for its similarity to Spanish/'latin', but the spoken word I'd have mistaken for something Russian or Slavic.
I was absolutely stunned by how it sounded. Couldn't understand a single word.
Rambocat1@reddit
I speak a little Portuguese, and was trying to listen in on a conversation that I assumed was Portuguese. I was confused to why I couldn’t make out any words they were saying, then realized it was Eastern European
ExasperatedManatee@reddit
If this happens BUT you end up understanding words, it is probably Romanian!
KnotUndone@reddit
I always thought it sounded like Spanish spoken with a French accent.
greyshem@reddit
Wild. I've always thought of it as Italian with a Spanish accent. We all agree that there's some Spanish ingredients, tho.
SovietStar1@reddit
Spanish, French, Italian, Romanian and Portuguese all came from Roman Latin language that’s why there’s a hint of each, Italian is the closest to the original Latin
Express-Stop7830@reddit
Don't forget Catalán!
throwawayatxaway@reddit
And Galician!
CD84@reddit
And Occitan!
Curmudgy@reddit
And Ladino! (with some Hebrew mixed in).
ExasperatedManatee@reddit
And Aranés and Valencian and (gulp) Mirandés!
Accomplished_Water34@reddit
And my ax !
CD84@reddit
THERE IT IS!!!
Cthulwutang@reddit
i also choose this guy’s wife.
macoafi@reddit
Spanish with an Italian accent is just Argentine Spanish.
spam__likely@reddit
lol
audioaddict321@reddit
Ha! I met Argentinians while travelling in Croatia and absolutely thought they were speaking Italian at first. We connected on something and we were doing the stilted communication thing until I said something in Spanish; it broke the ice and we talked about my mistaking them for Italians.
Push_the_button_Max@reddit
Yep- Can verify! - grew up speaking some Spanish as a young child, then forgot it.
Studied Italian in College….now whenever I try to speak Spanish everyone tells me I sound Argentinian.
Consistent-Ad-6506@reddit
This is how I feel bout Portuguese too. Like someone is speaking both French and Spanish really badly.
Remote-Wafer3321@reddit
Funny, French is my second language from a young age and for some reason I cannot say any words in another language other than English without unintentionally using a French accent. I wonder what the Spaniards thought of me when I was there speaking broken Spanish sounding like that 😅
ForestOranges@reddit
Spanish is my second language. I was in France trying to order food and the guy could tell I was a Spanish speaker by how I was pronouncing my words and he just took my order in Spanish.
Remote-Wafer3321@reddit
That's very accommodating! I didn't get that opportunity in Madrid haha
ForestOranges@reddit
I’m pretty sure the guy was Moroccan. Many Moroccans are bilingual with French and Arabic, plus a sizable minority, especially in the North, speak Spanish too. Spaniards have some of the lowest levels of English in Western Europe, so I imagine not a ton of them are diving into French.
Jackasaurous_Rex@reddit
Yeah when I was in Portugal I’d describe it as Spanish but with twangs of French and Italian pronunciation.
wonderlustVA@reddit
I thought Spanish, but smooshes their words together like French, with the gusto of Italian. I know a decent amount of French and Spanish, started trying to learn Portuguese for a trip and gave up because it was so hard.
Express-Stop7830@reddit
And a sprinkling of the sound "ow".
MetzgerBoys@reddit
I think it sounds like the illegitimate child of Spanish and French with a touch of Italian
djninjacat11649@reddit
Yeah it sounds like French Spanish, like Portuguese is to Spanish as French is to English, if that makes sense
SnooChipmunks2079@reddit
I think that's Catalan.
Riker_Omega_Three@reddit
Or Spanish being spoken by an alien pretending to be a human speaking spanish
MyUsername2459@reddit
That's reminding me of that Portuguese guy on YouTube that everyone thought was Russian because of his accent.
Drew707@reddit
There are a few Portuguese YouTube people I watch that I initially thought were eastern Europeans based on their English accent.
ExasperatedManatee@reddit
European Portuguese sounds like Sean Connery trying to speak Spanish.
mercerclone@reddit
r/PORTUGALCYKABLYAT
a subreddit dedicated to statistical instances of portugal fitting closer to eastern europe than western
Drew707@reddit
Whoa.
jibaro1953@reddit
The guy traveling the US with his wife eating B B Q and shooting guns? His stuff just popped up on my feed and I sure thought he was Russian.
virgo_fake_ocd@reddit
I worked with a a Brazilian lady, and initially thought she was from that region because of her accent.
Zealousideal_Lab_427@reddit
This happened recently! My husband was watching some IG video and showed it to me. The woman was speaking, and I asked him where this took place and he said “Portugal”. I was like “really? It sounds like Russian!” So I wasn’t imagining it.
AuntRobin@reddit
Exactly my first thought.
Eskimodo_Dragon@reddit
For real. Was in Lisbon for the first time and I always like to see what's on TV in new places so I was watching some news and was very confused cause the anchors sounded eastern European.
HaleEnd@reddit
Nah it’s Japanese Italian
absolut696@reddit
Portuguese sounds like someone speaking Spanish with an egg in their mouth.
airmantharp@reddit
Portuguese is to Spanish what French is to Latin lol
violet_wings@reddit
Yeah, it's fascinating to me how much Portuguese sounds like Russian.
MeowMeow_77@reddit
🤣🤣🤣
Heykurat@reddit
That's such a good description of how it sounds.
spiniton85@reddit
100%. My husband speaks Portuguese (European) but I add "drunken" to the Russian guy. Brazilian Portuguese, I'm not as sure how to describe.
IcyMathematician2668@reddit
I work cusromer service i speak both spanish and english. Once in a while i get a portugese speaker and they tell me they “also” speak spanish.
It usually sounds like someone speaking spanish underwater and its usually barely understandable
Youare-Beautiful3329@reddit
A drunk Russian guy trying to speak Spanish.
Whybaby16154@reddit
First time I heard Portuguese I said “somebody is speaking German- style Spanish in that spot”.
ParchedZombie@reddit
I was driving from Spain to Portugal and was so confused when the radio station announcers started speaking Russian. That’s when I found out Portuguese speakers are Latin Russians.
PromiseThomas@reddit
I always think spoken Portuguese is Korean at first until I hear a random word that sounds Spanish and need to reassess my assumption. And no, looking at the person speaking and realizing they are not Korean does not clue me in. I’m like “wow that person who isn’t ethnically Korean sure is fluent in Korean.”
KamtzaBarKamtza@reddit
I had two Portuguese women clean my house. The first time they came my wife said to me "They said that they are Portuguese so I can't understand why they're speaking some Slavic sounding language"
Winter-Warlock8954@reddit
Love this ❤️
Yes-Ifeedthemice@reddit
This is how I always describe Portugese!
No-Ship-6214@reddit
Oh my god, I thought I was the only one who thought they sounded Russian.
Reasonable_Bid3311@reddit
yes, which is why I think Portuguese sounds like Romanian.
ipsum629@reddit
r/portugalcykablyat
P00PooKitty@reddit
That’s European Portuguese.
-impossiblethings-@reddit
Exactly! I know its Portuguese if I think it’s Spanish, then think it’s Russian, then think its Spanish again.
b0ingy@reddit
Brazilian PG sounds oddly like yiddish
Fluffy-Mine-6659@reddit
🤣
-GenghisJohn-@reddit
Da
ramblintrovert@reddit
I just snorted. That is hands down the best description I have ever heard of the difference!!!
Important-Trifle-411@reddit
YES!!! I always tell my husband that Portuguese sounds Russian!!!!
wwbbqq@reddit
That is hilarious because it is true!
And at least as for this American, yes, I can tell the difference.
Building_a_life@reddit
Perfect!
DisneyBrat83@reddit
I’m trying to learn some Portuguese and I swear it sounds like Spanish with a mouth full of food. Some words are completely different from any Spanish I know (family comes from Mexico) but some words are very similar. Just like Italian too.
ancientastronaut2@reddit
🤣
zandyman@reddit
I thought it sounded like Spanish with an Italian accident.
Dotsmom@reddit
This is the perfect explanation!
phenomenomnom@reddit
This is amazing! Great comparison. I have often thought --
-- Now, I am going to say this in the interest of fun science, okay, and I want you to understand that I am (1) a huge Star Wars nerd and (2) an actor who has had a little bit of formal training in reproducing dialects for performance.
So, you know that character Greedo, the green bounty hunter who catches up to Han Solo in the cantina scene and gets himself merc'd? So ... he is speaking the made-up, fictional language "Huttese."
Well, as a kid I heard Greedo speaking Huttese long before I knew what Portuguese was,
but when as a teenager, I finally heard a recording of the Gilbertos singing bossa nova, I was so charmed by the sound of the language, and it sounded to me like they were singing the formal, elegant version of Huttese.
That's what Portuguese sounds like to me.
... And I need y'all to understand that this is a compliment.
... And the cooler part of this story is that the sound of Huttese is loosely based on the sound of Quechua, an indigenous language from the Andes mountains.
Which are obviously not in Brazil.
But I have since learned that while Quechua is not indigenous to Brazil, it is still spoken in some regions bordering Brazil, and I wonder whether some of the music of that language possibly osmosed into Brazilian Portuguese, and if that was what I was picking up on, just vastly diluted by time, space, and culture, and three times removed.
It's all just really r/showerthoughts and speculation, but I find it interesting to consider.
justdisa@reddit
Which he learned from a native Italian speaker.
anyunusednames@reddit
What I came here to say! First time in Portugal I thought we accidentally landed in Russia
Positive_Bug978@reddit
Or pirates!
Raelf64@reddit
As an English speaking American - hahahaha--- apt description.
allaboutmojitos@reddit
Exactly! If I can’t quite place the language, the answer is always Portuguese
Blue_Star_Child@reddit
As someone who does not hear Portuguese often and only through media, if I start to hear Spanish but then it sounds odd, I automatically think its Portuguese.
Bcatfan08@reddit
I've thought Portuguese sounds like drunken Spanish.
jackof47trades@reddit
I think Portuguese sounds like drunk Spanish
Anthrodiva@reddit
HA! I always say Dutch, but yes.
RTBSUM@reddit
When I was walking around in Lisbon for the first time (very jet lagged, in my defense) I commented to my girlfriend about how many Russian tourists I was hearing. I realized shortly after that I was an idiot and I was hearing Portuguese people speaking Portuguese.
Unsolven@reddit
Growing up I went to a friend’s house. His mother was born in Portugal and spoke little English, he’d grown up in the US and I had no idea what his heritage was. Later I asked him, do can you speak Russian too? He was like “what?”
Dr_Watson349@reddit
Jajajajajajajaja
bansidhecry@reddit
more like a Romanian
Prestigious-Web4824@reddit
I thought it sounded like Spanish with a German accent
Crying_in_99Ranch@reddit
To me Portuguese is like a drunk Russian with a lisp trying to speak Spanish. At least the kind spoken in Portugal. Brazilian Portuguese is easier on the ears.
Crying_in_99Ranch@reddit
The average American? Probably not. But many can and it's not that hard if you've ever tried to learn one of the languages.
_Caveat_@reddit
I think this every time I hear Portuguese.
I'm not a native Spanish speaker but I can hold my own and manage 30 days or so immersed with no issue.
I understand very little of spoken Portuguese. Written I think I can get the gist more often than not.
trekkiegamer359@reddit
No. Romanian is Spanish mixed with Russian. Portuguese is Spanish spoken with a hint of French and Italian.
ElKaoss@reddit
:D :D
TiFist@reddit
I'm dead, but this is 100% correct.
Physical-Compote4594@reddit
This is so true! I used Duolingo to "learn" Portuguese, not knowing that what it really taught me was Brazilian. When I arrived in Lisbon I wondered why there were so many Russian visitors, and when I mentioned this to my Portuguese colleagues they were all somewhat miffed.
this_curain_buzzez@reddit
r/PORTUGALCYKABLYAT
rsvihla@reddit
Portuguese sounds like a combination of Italian and Polish because of the nasal vowels.
Vesper2000@reddit
LOL accurate
elviswasmurdered@reddit
This is so funny. I had a lot of Brazilian coworkers and there's one in particular who sounds exactly like that.
xadriancalim@reddit
Came here to say the same thing. I have a LEGO friend in Portugal and always thought that.
im_gonna_hug_you@reddit
I’ve always thought this as well! 😂
rainy-brain@reddit
yes. maybe it comes from having Portuguese speaking friends but there are telling sounds that happen in one language but not the other.
JustAutreWaterBender@reddit
Yes but I studied them - and French and Italian.
Cryptidly@reddit
Yes, I can vaguely understand Spanish. Portuguese makes me feel as though I’m having a stroke.
Groundbreaking-Duck@reddit
Puerto Ricans probably can
N2Shooter@reddit
I can, and I don't speak either language. Portuguese sounds much thicker and heavier than Spanish, if you know what I mean.
Color_Odd_Numbers@reddit
Pretty much. Might take a few minutes but yeah. I live in an area where there’s a lot of spanish speakers and if the Spanish sounds a little off center I always assume it’s Portuguese.
West_Guidance2167@reddit
I don’t think I could. Maybe a little
br0kendr3ams@reddit
If they aren't complete morons, then yes.
stillwatersrunfast@reddit
Yup. One makes sense and one sounds like someone having a stroke.
Nice-Fail-6202@reddit
The US is the second largest Spanish speaking country in the world after Mexico
stangAce20@reddit
A little bit, Portuguese sounds a bit more like French to me then it does Spanish.
kawaqueen@reddit
Before I went to Brazil I wouldn’t have been able to identify Portuguese at all, but I definitely would have known that it wasn’t Spanish. Now that I know what Portuguese sounds like it is so so easy to pick out in a crowd. I always get excited “they’re speaking Portuguese!” As if I’ve cracked some sort of code. Still have no idea what they’re saying though.
Rudyjax@reddit
Yes. Especially Americans that can speak either language.
InannasPocket@reddit
Yes for me. Personally I can tell the difference between Portugal Portuguese and Brazilian Portuguese, and those are both very distinct from Spanish - I know a decent bit of Spanish and I can read Portuguese but can only speak/understand a limited amount.
But I wouldn't be surprised if many Americans could not, even though they sound very different.
thisgenXer@reddit
I live in California, and for us non Spanish speakers, we do know the difference between Spanish and not Spanish.
droopy615@reddit
Americans can’t even differentiate spoken English accents, let alone another language.
LoooongFurb@reddit
I can't speak for all Americans, but I had a Brazilian roommate one year in college and I can definitely tell the difference.
RudyMama0212@reddit
Educated people do.
ConfidentPin2914@reddit
portugues sounds more round with ow sounds ?
Significant_Alps_399@reddit
🤷🏼♀️ To me Brasilian Portuguese sounds like Puerto Rican Spanish with a sinus infection.
Ok-Tutor8961@reddit
Yes
carrie90210@reddit
I can
itsjudemydude_@reddit
Yes, because they seem so similar written down and sound nothing alike spoken aloud. Like to me they are as different as French is from Italian, you can hear the difference in sounds plain as day.
alltexanalllday@reddit
Watching the Rio Olympics opening ceremonies, I was so confused why the Spanish was ‘off’. Then it finally dawned on me that it was Portuguese. So yeah
raindorpsonroses@reddit
Yes. Not because I understand a lick of Portuguese, but I do have a basic level of Spanish and if I can’t understand a darn word they’re saying but it’s obviously a romance language that isn’t Spanish, French, or Italian, it’s Portuguese by process of elimination?
shriekingintothevoid@reddit
Spanish sounds like Spanish, and Portuguese sounds like if French was Spanish lol
TraditionalEvent6102@reddit
Portuguese words sound more slurred together and Spanish words sound more staccato.
Icy_Huckleberry_8049@reddit
some yes, most no
it all depends on where they live
morganproctor_19@reddit
Anecdotal data: As someone from Southern California who lived in Brazil -- yes. But I would say many who have never heard Portuguese would call it funny-sounding Spanish (BR PT) or funny-sounding Russian (PT PT).
bjbigplayer@reddit
We had Portuguese folks calling our Spanish lines today so I guess while Americans can tell the difference Portuguese folks can't.
SirTheRealist@reddit
I think most Americans are familiar with what Spanish sounds like, so it should be easy to distinguish it from Portuguese. I don’t think the two languages even sound that much alike
JadeHarley0@reddit
I can, but also I have studied Spanish heavily and speak it semi-fluently
deadlyhausfrau@reddit
Usually because we have a lot of Spanish speakers here.
Forlorn_Cyborg@reddit
For sure. I use google translate, but the phonetics of Brazilian Portuguese skews A LOT from its romanized alphabet.
12468097531@reddit
Yes
Mamapalooza@reddit
Spanish sounds like Spanish.
Portuguese sounds like someone trying to fake that they know Spanish.
ExasperatedManatee@reddit
Almost half of us speak Spanish, so yes, we can tell.
Repulsive_Brief6589@reddit
I can, but I would guess that my husband couldn't. A lot of people I know speak Spanish, so they could obviously tell.
Odd_Negotiation_159@reddit
Yeah, most can. 1 in 5 people in the US speak Spanish. Basically everyone has heard it spoken pretty often
iswhyouhavenofriends@reddit
Yes
Miserable-Yak-8041@reddit
Shit, most Americans I k ow can’t tell the difference between Chinese and Spanish
LadoBlanco@reddit
If you have any experience with either language it is pretty easy to tell, that being said not everyone has experience. But anyone who lives in a city with a significant number of Spanish speakers, I believe, would be able to tell.
Clydelaz@reddit
Yes we can. I live in Newark which has the largest Portuguese speaking population in the U.S. and also a large Spanish speaking population
oatmealparty@reddit
There are actually several towns in MA and RI that have a larger or equivalent Portuguese speaking population than Newark. I was pretty surprised. .
episcoqueer37@reddit
Fisheries. All about that sweet cod.
eirinne@reddit
In cod we trust
SolidApple733@reddit
There’s a cod hanging in the statehouse!
dotDeeka@reddit
I think you mean, All about that salt cod
Interesting-Fish6065@reddit
I once can across lasagna made with bacalhau at a little grocery store in Newark. Not a combination I had previously imagined possible!
Square_Band9870@reddit
Cape Cod too.
Amockdfw89@reddit
Yea I was in Rhode Island on vacation and they even had Portuguese news station on tv
ohamel98@reddit
The Braga Bridge is the longest bridge in the world. It takes you from Somerset to Portugal.
The joke is the bridge goes to Fall River which has a huge Portuguese population not just in that city but many cities/towns in that area.
LittleLemonSqueezer@reddit
Fall River MA
No_Owl_7380@reddit
Can confirm, lived and worked in Newark for 15 years. I miss the food!
Nyx_Shadowspawn@reddit
Or a significant number of Portuguese speakers. Brazilian Portuguese is much more common than Spanish where I am.
gregrph@reddit
I can't
Aggravating_Finish_6@reddit
I can only tell the difference now because I spent time studying both and travelled to countries that speak them. Before that, not a chance.
mst3k_42@reddit
I can’t say I’ve heard a lot of Portuguese speakers, but if I’m reading something (usually a warning sign in public in several languages) and I start out understanding the Spanish and then I feel like I’m having a stroke, ah! That’s Portuguese.
Square_Band9870@reddit
This.
DeepRok@reddit
Yeah I live in Miami, and even my gringo friends can tell when someone is speaking Spanish or Portuguese
Kellzy1212@reddit
I lived in Miami for a while and everyone i knew could pick out most languages spoke around town.
PrimaryHighlight5617@reddit
True. Simply from working restaurants and watching shows like Dora as a kid I know enough Spanish to understand the topic of surface level conversations. South American Portuguese is way different and EU spanish sounds goofy AF
shelwood46@reddit
I watch a lot of UK shows and sometimes they will have a character that is supposed to be from a South American country but then have them speak EU Spanish and it makes me giggle every time.
PrimaryHighlight5617@reddit
Omg!!!!
That's crazy because in the US it's like we go out of our way to poke fun at their silly little lisp
1heart1totaleclipse@reddit
I don’t know. My dad is a Spanish speaker and once had a conversation with a lady from Brazil and just thought that she had a weird accent lol.
GandalfTheGrey46@reddit
Or listen to music with those languages.
Repulsive-Debt5492@reddit
Completely agree. Where I live in central Texas, Spanish is SUPER common, and people would definitely be able to tell the two languages apart. Probably at least once a week I run into someone who basically only speaks Spanish.
Rural Minnesota though? Idk.... I shouldn't talk shit though as I haven't actually lived there
Quiet-Reflection5366@reddit
LOL I work with a Brazilian and several Mexicans. It's funny because the Brazilian speaks Portuguese and Spanish, English, Italian and Latin. The Mexicans speak English and Spanish, but struggle to speak Portuguese. And from what I have been told that is common, Spanish speakers struggle with Portuguese but Portuguese speakers get Spanish.
All of them outclass me, I can barely speak English and it's my mother tongue.
rickontherange@reddit
Do we need to? But yes we can they are different in cadence and sound.
Parking_Champion_740@reddit
Yes, I can. I suppose wouldn’t be able to
Cyoarp@reddit
Yes but it sounds similar enough that we wonder why a spaniard cant understand portugies and vis. Versa.
GryffindorGal96@reddit
Ngl, I would have to hear both before I made any promises lol.
But I feel like I'm familiar enough with Spanish that Portuguese always makes me go, "that's not Spanish," so I think a lot of people would, but some would not.
Blonde_Vampire_1984@reddit
I confidently can. I majored in Spanish, and there are some phrases that I use basically daily. I can competently carry on a conversation most of the time.
I was able to have a conversation with a Brazilian Portuguese speaker some months back. She understands, but does not speak Spanish, and I can understand but not speak Portuguese. We made it work.
boodler88@reddit
Yes. I can tell the difference between new and old world Spanish. And to my uneducated monolingual ears, Portuguese sounds like Spain Spanish but spoken with a French accent.
I sincerely hope it’s not offensive or anything. It’s just how my brain recognizes it, I’m not remotely claiming this is accurate linguistically!
pah2000@reddit
Yes!
Turdulator@reddit
Sure, I speak some Spanish - I essentially understand like half of what people are saying… while Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a French accent and I can’t understand any of it.
TechnicalDot9@reddit
I can because I have taken Spanish. I can’t understand Portuguese.
I’m not an amazing Spanish speaker, just the basics.
MalleableBee1@reddit
Im going to does on this hill. The average American Cannot tell the difference.
thisismyhumansuit@reddit
I don’t know a single word in Portuguese but the sounds are so distinct I’m relatively confident that I know when I’m hearing it. I think it sounds incredibly complicated and also really pretty.
shadowmib@reddit
I may not know that it's Portuguese but I would know it's definitely not Spanish because I live in Texas and hear Spanish all the time
Unusual_Entrance7354@reddit
Not really. Americans hate speaking a second language so I doubt they can even tell.
madqueen100@reddit
Not really. Most Americans dont even know that Brazilians speak Portuguese. I havent heard the kind of Portuguese spoken in Portugal, but Brazilian Portuguese sounds quite different to me — those Rs pronounced as H, those S those s sounds softened to sh, and a distinctive, different rhythm to speech. Spanish — all the different dialects or accents, and if you’re only thinking of basic vocabulary - is its own thing.
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
I think a lot of Americans would be able to identify Spanish and Not Spanish. Whether they can positively identify Portuguese is another story.
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
This is the best answer. I answered the same way but apparently it offended folks.
ButtSexington3rd@reddit
I think a lot of non-Americans don't realize that on the whole, we speak English from coast to coast. Like, the width of a whole ass continent. There are many other languages here, by far the next popular being Spanish, but if you speak English you're fine everywhere. Somehow, the same criticism isn't aimed at Latin America, where the mass majority of people speak Spanish or Portuguese and maybe a bit of English. English and Spanish are global languages, if you speak one or the other you're good to go in a LOT of places.
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
I don't think the offended folks were non-Americans, but rather Americans who were I offended that I assumed most people wouldn't know what Portuguese sounded like.
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
With Reddit, it's luck of the draw. For the same comment, you can either be lambasted for being a racist or hailed as a comedic genius. The fun part is you'll never know until it's too late.
Puzzleheaded_Door399@reddit
Exactly. A lot of Americans speak Spanish.
OptimistSometimes@reddit
This is true for me. I can identify Spanish consistently because it is more familiar to me - I took it in high school/college, and it is fairly common where I live.
I can identify almost no other languages. My partner has made fun of me for not being able to tell if someone is speaking Russian or French. It's just not a skill I have.
GreenBeanTM@reddit
Tbh I think I’d just assume it was a different Spanish dialect, like Mexico Spanish vs Spain Spanish.
strum-and-dang@reddit
I worked with a lady who was very proud of her Italian heritage. A new pizza place opened up down the street, and she was raving about how good it was, because the guys running it were from Italy. I went in there to pick up lunch and was listening to them talking while I was waiting. When I was paying, I asked them if they were Portuguese, they said yes. I told them my coworker thought they were Italian, and they said yeah, a lot of people think that, it's good for business! (They did make very good pizza)
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
LOL that's amazing. A lot of Americans out there bragging about their heritage while knowing nothing about it.
Suppafly@reddit
I'm not sure I'd recognize the difference, but I suspect I would. The thought process being "hmm that sounds like Spanish, but also not, I bet it's Portuguese."
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
That's exactly the thought process that I think Americans would have. At least those that are a little more in tune with different languages.
TrashPandaNotACat@reddit
Makes me wonder if she calls a taco, a meat snack on a tortilla.
aculady@reddit
No, because that would require saying "tortilla".
TrashPandaNotACat@reddit
Ha! Good catch! 🤣
beenoc@reddit
"One of them there little Mexican calzones." Wait, calzones are Italian, which is still 'foreign' food to old Southern grandmas (I have one, I know.)
aculady@reddit
"Mexican Sloppy Joe"
TrashPandaNotACat@reddit
🤣
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
I'd be surprised if she's ever eaten a taco. Probably too ethnic.
Suppafly@reddit
That's super weird of her.
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
Yeah. It's a pretty common joke around my house.
But to be fair, she has a very strong southern accent and can barely pronounce English words.
katarh@reddit
One of my older sisters was born in South Carolina and lived in Georgia most of her teenaged years (had a brief stint in Montana from ages 3-8 iirc. Yay military family.)
She was also a Spanish major back in college.
She never could quite get rid of the southern US twang in her Spanish. Was always super funny to listen to her practice.
Amockdfw89@reddit
Yea but the thing is spoken Portuguese REALLY doesn’t sound like Spanish unless you are in tune to it.
Hell I have had Spanish speaking friends not even realize what they were watching on YouTube was Portuguese. Then once I mentioned it then they had a lightbulb moment and started realizing it was similar to Spanish.
Unless you love languages or have exposure I don’t think the average person will just magically know what language is spoken, even if it’s a similar language
0116316@reddit
There would be a lot of us that would think they are Puerto Rican. Portuguese is distinct. I hear it as Spanish and French but it could just be the people I've been around.
badwithnames123456@reddit
The number of Americans who grew up in a Spanish-speaking homes is only surpassed by the number who took Spanish in high school
MikeExMachina@reddit
I’m tempted to say this, but then I think about the accent differences between an actual Spaniard, someone from the Caribbean, and someone from southern South America, and I question weather an average non Spanish speaking American would actually realize that all of those accents were the same language.
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
I can't speak for everyone and I think I'm a little better with accents than the average bear, but I can tell the difference between Central American Spanish and South American Spanish. I have a client that I'm sure is from Argentina because he's so animated and practically rolls every R for about 3 seconds each. Hard as hell to understand him sometimes but it's so damn entertaining to hear him speak. Like every conversation is an auditory show. At least I think I can. I don't know too many people from Spain so I'm not sure about that one.
MikeExMachina@reddit
Yeah the “southern South America” accent I talking about is actually called the “Rioplatense” accent, mostly used in Argentina and Uruguay. Its iconic feature is that sound made by ‘y’ and ‘ll’ shifts to more of a ‘sh’ sound, e.g. “yo” sounds like “sho”.
CaptainAwesome06@reddit
TIL, thanks!
FilthyMindz69@reddit
Yes, I speak Mexican, Brazilian Portuguese, and Engrish.
Budsygus@reddit
I can tell the difference, but I also speak Spanish as my second language.
My wife who is learning Spanish doesn't easily recognize Portuguese, I think because so much of Spanish is still hard for her to understand and, if I'm being honest, she doesn't have much of a gift for or interest in languages in general.
biancocigno@reddit
Obviously?? Spanish is beautiful and Portuguese is so ugly to listen to
Rough-Trainer-8833@reddit
Brazilian Portuguese has a very unique sound, like Italian/ French and Spanish had a threeway.
I have not heard much Portuguese from Portugal.
As for Spanish there are many dialects I can discern. Mexican Spanish sounds very different than Puerto Rican Spanish.
Distinct_Chair3047@reddit
I can, but thats because, for some unknown, god forsaken reason, we had a huge Portuguese population boom in my hometown when I was growing up. Came out of nowhere. No idea why or how it happened. But it was very substantial. Still confuses me to this day.
PoolSnark@reddit
Yes
Sweaty-Move-5396@reddit
"Spanish" and "Portuguese" are not singular things. I'm sure you could find a dialect within each language that I would have trouble distinguishing.
FormalConcern4862@reddit
Yes
xristosdomini@reddit
I usually can. Partially because I have taken a couple years of Spanish in school, and partly because Portugese sounds like Spanish and French had a baby that got dropped.
Patient_Meaning_2751@reddit
I can tell Portuguese is not Spanish, Italian, or French but is a Romance language and would take the leap of faith to guess Portuguese
New-Cicada7014@reddit
We have a pretty large Hispanic population here, especially in the South, so people here are pretty familiar with Mexican Spanish. Portuguese sounds like if Spanish moved to France then got dizzy. At least to me.
Gaeilgeoir215@reddit
Yup
hatkinson1000@reddit
Most of us can pick out Spanish easily. Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a cold and extra shushing noises. Not hard to tell apart honestly.
Ninjaher0@reddit
I can, but I’m trilingual, so it’s pretty obvious to me that theres a difference between Latin American Spanish and Portuguese.
ApprehensivePie1195@reddit
Yes
Sans_Seriphim@reddit
Easily. I can usually tell if someone is Mexican or not, too
jpiggzz@reddit
I'm assuming you mean you can pinpoint their nationality by their accent?
Sans_Seriphim@reddit
Indeed. In English and Spanish, though my spoken Spanish is crap. I could tell my Chilean coworker had an accent I had never heard before, which made her week. Everybody else just assumed she was Mexican.
Zygoatscythe@reddit (OP)
Are you hispanic?
LaLaLandLiving@reddit
80 million Americans live in a border state with Mexico. Even for those that aren’t Hispanic, they hear people speaking Mexican Spanish literally every single day (and this applies to every major city in the US that is nowhere near Mexico too, like NYC). I live in LA (though am ironically Tejana), and hear Spanish from multiple countries everyday, though the vast majority of it is Mexican Spanish. Outside of Americans in rural areas in the Deep South or Midwest, I’d think most would be able to discern the difference between Mexican Spanish and say EU Spanish. It gets a little harder with like Guatemalan, because it borders Mexico. But that’s like asking if people who listen to British English speakers everyday could tell of someone had an American accent instead. The answer is likely, yes.
Sans_Seriphim@reddit
Nope. But I live in Colorado.
devushkablondinkaya@reddit
I was stationed in the Azores. To me, Portuguese looked like Spanish and sounded like French. I took both French and Spanish in high school in the South, so the accents were probably way off.
ZenA1ien@reddit
I don’t know about all Americans but I can
Glad-Intern2655@reddit
Yes.
h3rs3lf_atl@reddit
Yes, we can tell.
CoachedEgg@reddit
Yes. Because I speak some Spanish
DeFiClark@reddit
Yes. As my dad (who spoke both) would say, Portuguese is Spanish after the second bottle of wine
FeelTheWrath79@reddit
I can, but mainly because i speak Spanish.
MartyPhelps@reddit
Yes.
MattieShoes@reddit
I can in the sense that I have, but I'm not at all confident if you gave me a quick clip of somebody speaking one sentence.
DruncleMuncle@reddit
Personally, yes. I took Spanish through high school and can muddle together a conversation. Portuguese confuses me.
Godisdeadbutimnot@reddit
Yea. Most americans are pretty familiar with spanish, and portuguese sounds a lot more “russian” and nasal-y. So while an american might not realize that someone is speaking portuguese, they would probably know it at least isn’t spanish.
Elivagara@reddit
I can. Portuguese sounds like Spanish if it was spoken by cats.
Current_Coconut_5778@reddit
Yes and no.
Some can tell based on pronunciation, certain words, etc.
Others can’t. This is usually because they’re in an area that isn’t very diverse. These people just tend to assume the person is from Mexico and speaking Spanish.
Defiant_Ingenuity_55@reddit
Yes
soda-pops@reddit
MEXICAN-AMERICAN MOMENT 🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽🇲🇽 VIVAAAAAAAA
Buncai41@reddit
Yes. I hear Spanish all the time. I can recognize it even if I'm not fluent. I pick out words I know to help me communicate with the growing Spanish speaking population. I love exercising my brain with these moments. Then someone will come up to me from Brazil and starts speaking. It's like my brain wants to identify words, but can't actually grasp at anything. It takes me a good minute to realize it's not Spanish or a different dialect of French. It's a whole other language that I'm not used to hearing and have no way to communicate in.
Yeah_Mr_Jesus@reddit
For me, yes. I'm familiar with Spanish. I'm not quite conversational, but with some practice I could be. My wife is from Puerto Rico. I hear her speak with her family all the time. She's trying to teach our daughter. I understand a good bit of Spanish, but for me, speaking it is hard.
Portuguese sounds, to me, like an amalgamation of Spanish, French, and Italian with some extra pizzazz thrown in. I don't want to say Portuguese sounds ugly or anything, but I think Spanish sounds absolutely beautiful and Portuguese doesn't sound as pretty
KilroyFSU@reddit
Generally, yes. Portuguese has a certain sound that Spanish lacks, even if you don't understand the words, you can usually pick up on it.
Wadsworth_McStumpy@reddit
Spanish sounds like a Mexican speaking Spanish.
South American Portuguese sounds like a Frenchman speaking Spanish that he learned in an American high school.
European Portuguese sounds like a Russian speaking Spanish that he learned in an English high school.
Aquarius_K@reddit
On the TV with captions yes because I know a moderate amount of Spanish lol. But there's still enough I don't know that I'm like are they speaking Portuguese or is that a Spanish word I don't know? I'm also relatively familiar with what regions commonly speak Spanish vs Portuguese. However I would wager the average American isn't interested.
doctorate_denied@reddit
Probably about as well as Europeans can tell the difference between Iroquois and Navajo lol
Kimba26@reddit
I can. Portuguese has a lot of sounds in it that are clearly different from Spanish even if some of the words sound similar.
CB_Chuckles@reddit
Over time I can usually tell the difference. Based on a single sentence, usually not.
Cak3Wa1k@reddit
I think I can because I speak enough Spanish to know when I don't understand it.
No-Possible6108@reddit
Living in Texas means I've heard Spanish, Spanglish, and Tex-Mex my whole life. My introduction to Portuguese was the Brazilian version.
MesopotamiaSong@reddit
yes, spanish sounds like spanish, and portuguese makes no sense. that being said, i’d be suprised if i ever saw someone speaking portuguese on the street
getdownheavy@reddit
Some, yes.
R_A_H@reddit
If they're familiar with one or both languages, probably. A lot of people just hear "not English" and put zero effort in trying to tell which language it is.
Engelgrafik@reddit
Yes by the consonants. Portuguese consonants seem to have a lot of very soft and spongy sounds. There seems to be a lot of "sh" and "j" and "dj" and what I can only describe as the way you pronounce the classic actress Za Za Gabor's first name. Spanish doesn't seem to do this as much.
Also, Portuguese seems to stress words in a way that sounds "slower" than Spanish. It sounds more "expressive"? I don't know if that's the word.
Quick_Sherbet5874@reddit
exactly. portuguese has a lot of a russian sound to it. i live in florida and most everyone experiences or speaks spanish daily
srslytho1979@reddit
I can. 🤷🏻♀️
Araxanna@reddit
Well, I understand about 80% of Spanish, so if I don’t understand it and it sounds like Spanish, it’s Portuguese.
pluck-the-bunny@reddit
some can, some can't.....probably like in most countries
RemarkableBeach1603@reddit
From years of watching MMA and soccer, I can pick up on certain sounds that seem to be more prolific in Portuguese over Spanish.
If I hear a lot of "ao" (ow) sounds, like in the name Joao, I automatically assume Portuguese.
Key_Hat_5721@reddit
Yes - they are completely different languages that sound (American or not) like two different languages
Limp-Plantain3824@reddit
Spoken by who?
92TilInfinityMM@reddit
Prolly, enough Americans know at least broken Spanish so they would know it’s not Spanish although they may not know it’s Portuguese
skipperoniandcheese@reddit
quite a few americans speak spanish, so yes
GraceXGalaxy@reddit
I can. I went to school with an exchange student who spoke Portuguese, and took Spanish in middle school, so I have a little advantage here lol.
ManateeFlamingo@reddit
Most definitely
CloudedLeopardDaemon@reddit
Of course. Granted I live in Southeastern Massachusetts, so I've been hearing Portuguese all my life, with mainland, insular, and Brazilian dialects all represented, plus Cape Verdean Creole. Most Americans can't even pronounce chouriço in my experience.
Wildwilly54@reddit
I speak pretty bad Spanish, so I can. After about 20 seconds I realize it’s Portuguese.
QsXfYjMlP@reddit
If it makes you feel any better, I speak pretty good Spanish and I'm still on a ~10 second delay. Its close enough, and so infrequent that I hear Portuguese, my brain panics and I assume that I somehow forgot Spanish lol
Wildwilly54@reddit
Haha I know the feeling. Lot of Dominicans, Puerto Ricans, and Cubans live near me which I struggle to understand, so I’m usually sitting there trying to figure out if it’s some slang I don’t know.
popdivtweet@reddit
I once heard someone say that Portuguese is just Spanish but with a speech impediment. That was kinda mean but I pffft! my soda at the time.
Substantial_Meal_530@reddit
I can tell the written languages apart, but haven't heard enough Portuguese to know what it sounds like. I know they share a lot of words.
Living-Night4476@reddit
I personally cannot tell the differences of the different latin based languages. That includes separation of Italian from Spanish. I know that’s bad but I just never could
kalelopaka@reddit
Yeah, Spanish, Portuguese and Italian sound very similar and share a few similarities, but I can tell the difference. Likely because my grandfather was born on Madeira island Portugal, and my grandmother was Portuguese/Hawaiian.
SkittleCar1@reddit
Both sound cursive.
LazyOldCat@reddit
Yes.
jibaro1953@reddit
As an American who speaks decent Spanish as a second language, I can tell the difference. I usually get a lot of Spanish around me, but I can barely understand a word of Portuguese.
The written languages are quite similar, but the spoken languages are quite different.
FireHammer09@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Spanish but something's wrong, like they're pretending to sound Spanish but have no idea and are super committed to the bit.
Recent-Celebration86@reddit
I can tell but only because I speak decent Spanish and then I hear Portuguese and I have no clue what's happening lol
PuppySnuggleTime@reddit
Yeah. I can.
r2d3x9@reddit
It’s all Greek to me
Shantotto11@reddit
I can barely tell the difference between US English and stroke noises…
Rhapdodic_Wax11235@reddit
God yes.
CanIEatAPC@reddit
Yes if it's a Mexican Spanish speaker and a Portgual Portuguese speaker. Not from other countries, the languages sound too different for me.
knitter_boi420@reddit
I’ve noticed Portuguese has a lot more sh and j sounds than Spanish.is
DesertWanderlust@reddit
When I hear the "ao" sound, I assume it's Portuguese, because it's rare for Spanish speakers (especially in the US) to talk about Bilbao. There are also a lot "sh" sounds in Portuguese it seems, so that's an indicator.
reluctantmugglewrite@reddit
I have never met a Portuguese speaker in person and every time ive heard it sounds dramatically foreign to me. I know some spanish from school and it feels like a puzzle to match words like corazon to corazao. Very similar but has such a different vibe to the sounds.
Alycion@reddit
Yes, but I follow a lot of Brazilian born athletes.
drewster321@reddit
I think most Americans readily recognize Spanish because it is so widely spoken here, and thus we also recognize that Portuguese is NOT Spanish. They sound VERY different, even to foreign ears.
juliaakatrinaa0507@reddit
Yes, but I know Spanish. Even before learning though, I could tell the difference in the nasal sounds. Now if you were to ask me to tell the difference between Japanese, Chinese, and Korean, or something like Russian, Hungarian and Polish…… heck no
Inspi@reddit
I'm in south Florida. I can tell the difference between Portugal Portuguese, Brazilian, etc. I can tell the difference between Spain Spanish, and many of the the LATAM countries too. I can also tell the difference between France French, and that sh!t the Quebecois speak.
Individual-Schemes@reddit
Lots of Americans speak Spanish, so I would think so.
wizzard419@reddit
Depends on where in the US I suppose. Here in socal it sometimes is reference (same for Mexico vs Spain Spanish) as the euro version sounds like someone talking with their mouth full.
If you live somewhere where you hear a lot of Mexican Spanish and you hear Portuguese or other regional versions of Spanish, you perk up and go "That sounded... different".
LettuceInfamous5030@reddit
Yes. It sounds extremely different. Many Americans take Spanish in school so they would be able to tell the difference.
My Brazilian friend sounds like he’s speaking French, Italian and Spanish when he’s speaking Portuguese. Which makes sense historically.
Unlikely_Film_955@reddit
Not everyone, but if you have some passing familiarity with the languages then yes. My very white, very English only boyfriend, however, was surprised one day when I was able to tell I was hearing Portuguese on the TV, so I don't think the differences stand out to him the same way
Ok-Department-2405@reddit
Yes.
RianThe666th@reddit
Depends on the conversation for me, I've worked with mostly Spanish and Portuguese speakers for a while and some conversations are immediately apparent and others it takes a bit, most words are pretty Spanish sounding to me but a lot of common sounds are replaced so it depends on if they're using words with tells I've clued in on. I've definitely gotten a lot better at it but I knew enough(not much) Spanish already that I could usually pick it up if it went long enough.
Ginge_fail@reddit
Yes. Portuguese and Spanish sound completely different.
Fingersmith30@reddit
Yes, because I speak Spanish. I can only read a little Portuguese. A lot of the words are extremely similarly spelled, but the pronunciation is very different so I have no fucking clue what someone speaking Portuguese is saying to me.
lakeswimmmer@reddit
I can't say whether Americans in general can tell the difference, but I can. There are more soft j sounds in Portuguese.
Rimurooooo@reddit
The first time I heard Brazilian Portuguese I thought it was Italian. We very scarcely ever interact with it. We know Spanish, though
biancanevenc@reddit
Yes. Spanish sounds like Spanish, and Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a French accent. And Italian sounds like French with a Spanish accent.
Years ago I studied both Spanish and French in high school and university, and added Italian at university. I picked up Italian very quickly and could speak Italian fairly fluently after two years of classes. I never took a Portuguese class but I could understand a fair amount when I heard it. And when I traveled in Europe, it always astounded me that French/Spanish/Portuguese/Italians couldn't understand each other. They're all practically speaking the same language!
RichardAboutTown@reddit
Maybe. Brazilian Portuguese sounds more like Spanish than it sounds like European Portuguese. It also depends on the American's familiarity with either language. If they don't really know either language well, it might all be just so much jibber jabber to them.
Donald_J_Duck65@reddit
Some do, some dont.
waitingforgandalf@reddit
I'm part Puerto Rican and I married someone with dual American and Brazilian citizenship, so I can have a conversation in both Spanish and Portuguese. Even before I learned to speak Portuguese I could easily tell the languages apart.
Irohuro@reddit
Spanish is very rapid and crisp. Portuguese is very slow and nasally, and very emphasized
blooobolt@reddit
Yes. Portuguese sounds like a drunk Frenchman and a Spaniard made up a language. Spanish does not.
Per_sephone_@reddit
Yes of course. I took four years of Spanish in school and understand it.
TumpanyTuna@reddit
I can. Others I don't know
midzo@reddit
A comic once said “Portuguese is like Spanish spoken by a gay Englishman with a head cold.”
I can easily tell the difference, but I speak Spanish. I doubt many monolingual Americans could distinguish them.
Hell, I was speaking Thai to a waiter in a Thai restaurant in Alabama and a fellow diner asked how long I had been studying Spanish.
jeffeb3@reddit
There are some Spanish speakers that sound pretty Portuguese. But I can understand Spanish. So Portuguese mostly sounds like a Spanish speaker speaking gibberish.
keithrc@reddit
I can sometimes. To a casual non-speaker of both languages, it can be subtle.
Fernwhatnow@reddit
Yes
technoangel@reddit
I can but most Americans? Maybe not
mando_ad@reddit
I can. My grandfather was a native Spanish speaker, and my grandmother, mother, and bio-aunts and -uncles are all pretty fluent.
The first time I heard someone speak Portuguese, I genuinely questioned if the man was possessed.
mozzieandmaestro@reddit
yes, portuguese sounds like a russian trying to speak spanish
soupy2112@reddit
Kind of an odd question, but if you are not American I guess I can see why you might wonder.
Spanish speakers in the US are such a huge part of the population that a lot of non-Spanish speakers still have some sort of regular contact with the Spanish language even if they don’t speak it. We have little to no contact with Portuguese. A lot of Americans that hear Portuguese may automatically assume they are hearing Spanish just because when they hear a “foreign” language unknown to them the balance of probability means Spanish is the safest assumption. Non-Spanish speaking people who have some decent exposure to the Spanish language (and I’d say there is a decent amount of people that fall into that category) will likely know pretty quickly that when they hear Portuguese, they are hearing something other than what they are used to.
Oomlotte99@reddit
I can. Can’t speak for everyone but most people in the US are at least familiar with hearing Spanish if not familiar enough with Spanish words to be able to tell when they are being spoken or not.
Affable_Pineapple@reddit
Took 6 years of Spanish in school. Either I understand it or it's Portuguese.
ginger_princess2009@reddit
Yep! I grew up around a lot of Spanish speakers, I can tell Spanish and Portuguese apart very easily
benz58@reddit
Easily.
Jagg811@reddit
Yes. Portuguese has a lot of swishy sounds. It is a very pretty language.
SmilingHappyLaughing@reddit
Yes. Portuguese sounds very strange. Every time I hear it I can’t figure out which language is being spoken. At times it sounds like a mix of Russian, French, Spanish or something else like Italian.
BasicAppointment9063@reddit
Americans that speak Spanish can tell the difference. /s
broipy2@reddit
Portuguese does not sound like Spanish... it's weird, pleasant but odd.
Iwentforalongwalk@reddit
Yes. I can understand Spanish but not Portuguese
earmares@reddit
Yes.
Pfizermyocarditis@reddit
Thats a no for me dawg. I don't hear either of these languages. I really only hear English 🤷♂️
UCFknight2016@reddit
I can. I live in a city with a large hispanic population and now a growing Brazilian population. Portuguese sounds more nasal than Spanish. It sounds almost like French to me. More like a drunk Frenchman trying to speak spanish.
Square_Band9870@reddit
Yes. They don’t sound that similar.
Adventurous_Button63@reddit
It sounds like Spanish with funny vowels to me
BitPoet@reddit
We had a cat who could distinguish Portuguese spoken by Brazilians and by Portuguese. We had the siding on our house redone by a couple of Brazilian guys, and after awhile our cat would growl at them.
He’d growl at random guys (women were ok) speaking Portuguese walking by when the window was open. Eventually we figured it out.
Realreelred@reddit
Yes
ThimbleBluff@reddit
In my area of the US (Great Lakes region) I probably hear 20 or 30 Spanish speakers for every 1 Portuguese speaker, so I would never get the two confused.
Donkey_Balls5150@reddit
The reasonably intelligent ones can
cats-n-cafe@reddit
I grew up in a town with a ton of people from the Azores. My high school and college boyfriend was from Azores. Spanish sounds nothing like Portuguese.
WhereTheSkyBegan@reddit
I can tell the difference after a few seconds of listening. Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a generous dash of French mixed in.
xGeorgieGirlx@reddit
You’re going to ignore the fact that a large portion of the population speaks Spanish.
KellyBlack1111@reddit
I can! Growing up around the different dialects in MA. I also agree with the Brazilian Portuguese sounding more French.
Strange_Specific655@reddit
The problem with this thread is that someone who lives in Florida and someone who lives in Washington state are going to tell you very different things. Different parts of the USA have very different cultures once you rip off the cover
Strange_Specific655@reddit
Like take the UK for example, those that live in London vs Edinburgh are very different even though it’s under the same state
Thedaniel4999@reddit
American here that is a Portuguese speaker due to family being from Portugal. Americans will pretty quickly realize that you aren’t speaking Spanish. They won’t know exactly what you’re speaking (assumption is usually Russian/polish)
PlentyPossibility505@reddit
Which Americans?
auntlynnie@reddit
Anyone who can speak Spanish with any amount of fluency should be able to tell the difference.
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
Yes. How are there so many people saying no?
ParryLimeade@reddit
I never took any Spanish and don’t live near any Spanish speaking people. I took French in high school.
Moist_Rule9623@reddit
I can, because I understand like 1 word in 4 when people speak Spanish around me but about 1 word in 10 of Portuguese 😂
ParryLimeade@reddit
No. I don’t speak either.
YOUTUBEFREEKYOYO@reddit
I can, but thats probably because a friend growing up was Portuguese
PenHouston@reddit
I kinda understand Spanish, I do speak TexMex and restaurant Spanish, aka 3rd grade Spanish. Formal Spanish is very different than border Mexico, CDMX, or South American Spanish. Puerto Ricans speak like they are in a race, super fast. As a South Texan or a South Florida citizen we would never confuse Portuguese with Spanish. Still mad when I went to Spain, they spoke Catalan. I was all confused.
Thunderplant@reddit
I speak Spanish so I obviously can, but more than once I've had someone ask me what a Brazilian person was saying so there are definitely people who can't tell. European Portuguese is really different though and I don't think anyone would confuse them
Shoshawi@reddit
I can.
If it sounds like Spanish for a moment but I have no clue what is being said, and it’s not extremely fast Mexican Spanish with a lot of slang, then it’s Portuguese.
beccahas@reddit
Lots of us can, yes. There's a lot of people here to generalize, though. Many divergent regions.
Cool_Log_4514@reddit
I would be able to tell bc Portuguese has this vowel sound no other language seems to have that kinda sounds like “wow”
cb630@reddit
Some of us can
Luckypenny4683@reddit
Absolutely. This wouldn’t be a difficult task for most people.
They may not know it’s Portuguese, but they’ll definitely know it’s not Spanish.
cannonspectacle@reddit
Depends on the American. To some, every language is either "English" or "not English."
Bexar1986@reddit
I know enough Spanish to get by. I don't know a thing about Portuguese, so if it doesn't sound TOO familiar, I just assume it's Portuguese.
devilscabinet@reddit
I can, because I speak a little Spanish and hear it all the time. I can only pick out a few words here and there when I hear someone speak Portuguese.
roughlyround@reddit
yes
ionmoon@reddit
I can, but only because I know a bit of Spanish and when I hear Portuguese, I don't understand it lol.
I would say most americans don't know that portugal, etc are not in mexico and so to them it is all "sapanish" and they can't be bothered to learn more than taco and tequila.
Lie-Pretend@reddit
Yes. Romanian is the language that always gets people looking at me with a lot of questions.
FnordRanger_5@reddit
Sounds like funny Spanish
deltagma@reddit
Yeah most likely. We know what Spanish sounds like, and we know Portuguese sounds like weird Spanish.
lovelylinguist@reddit
I can, but I speak both.
HotCode4423@reddit
Now that I work with both Spanish and Portuguese speaking folks I can definitely tell the difference.
Key-Bodybuilder-343@reddit
Yes
vicsanbarajas@reddit
Brazilian Portuguese or Portugal Portuguese?
Phoenix_Court@reddit
I can, but I need a second to listen. Portuguese sounds like Spanish being spoken with a very heavy French accent.
cpkuske@reddit
easily. I know some Spanish and some Japanese.
Portuguese and Chinese hurt my little brain.
Castillian Spanish I can distinguish. South African English I can never tell.
Mike_in_San_Pedro@reddit
Yes.
OJSimpsons@reddit
Yeah, I know some Spanish
Difference_Last@reddit
Absolutely. Portuguese is like extra bouncy Spanish, I adore it.
coppergoldhair@reddit
Sometimes
Mission_Breakfast548@reddit
Absolutely. I’m in California so lots of Spanish speakers. And btw, Spanish spoken by all the Latin American countries absolutely sounds different than those from Spain. And Portuguese sounds nothing like either. Very different words and accents. Just visited Lisbon and Porto recently and it’s a far cry from the Spanish I hear in So Cal,
SkyPork@reddit
Not really, but I'm terrible at accents or languages. Portuguese sounds like something from Eastern Europe sometimes.
bbii511@reddit
Yes.
underscore197@reddit
Yes. They sound nothing alike.
Hairy_Debate6448@reddit
Yeah, you have to remember outside of literally Spain and countries in South America there’s probably not another country that hears as much Spanish. Most Americans can understand a little bit of Spanish and know basic greetings or at the very least are fairly familiar with what it sounds like. I think the description of “a Russian person speaking spanish” is apt, it’s pretty guttural when compared to Spanish but is fairly unique sounding overall. Its usually easy for me to pick out because it sounds completely different than most other languages.
02meepmeep@reddit
Yes. Portuguese sounds like you put Spanish, French, & Italian in a bowl and mixed it up really hard. I understand some words but not many.
Prestigious-Toe9381@reddit
They really don’t sound alike at all in my opinion. But I’m an American that can speak Spanish, albeit poorly.
Puzzled-Bench2805@reddit
I can, but I speak Spanish so..
JimBones31@reddit
There are plenty of Americans where Spanish or Portuguese or Brazil Portuguese are their native languages.
cans-of-swine@reddit
I wouldn't be able to.
HarlequinKOTF@reddit
Good rule of thumb at least in writing.
If you see ã and õ it's Portuguese
If you see ñ it's probably Spanish
Lower_Neck_1432@reddit
Portuguese - Spanish with a head cold.
cans-of-swine@reddit
I wont remember that.
HarlequinKOTF@reddit
I mean how often do you realistically encounter either language lol. If it's daily life in the USA it's probably Spanish.
Cerulean_IsFancyBlue@reddit
I encounter Spanish every day in the United States — in my city. I’ve seen demographic maps and I know that there’s places in the USA were the only Spanish they’re gonna encounter is Taco Bell but, it’s a very common language here. It’s so common that when people make interesting maps about what no -English languages are spoken in given US regions or states, they usually exclude Spanish because otherwise it’s just Spanish across the map.
I encounter Portuguese rarely. We have Brazilian neighbors so maybe one or two days of the week I have access to a Portuguese speaker, but we don’t speak Portuguese.
Honestly, though, remembering that simple idea for telling the two apart? That doesn’t require daily exposure. I can tell Japanese, Chinese, and Korean writing apart, even though I see way less of those. If it looks entirely like Chinese, it’s probably Chinese. If it looks like Chinese with a couple simplified bits, it’s Japanese. If it looks like somebody made it up from little blocks to be easier to learn, that’s Hangul and that’s how they made it and that’s Korean.
Weaponized incompetence. Let’s not support it.
HarlequinKOTF@reddit
Look, I get what you're trying to say, but realistically most americans are just not exposed to non English or Spanish that regularly to be able to do too much distinguishing. Locally important languages you should probably know. I lived in Madison and Hmong is a big language there, I could recognize signs in Hmong. When I was in AZ though I did not live by a res so I didn't get a lot of exposure to native american languages and probably couldn't tell them apart. Is that a failing on my part? No, just never proved to be needed.
Just food for thought before we jump to assumptions.
Cerulean_IsFancyBlue@reddit
I hear you, but the numbers are overwhelming. Spanish is a big language in many areas, including nearly all the biggest metro areas. Even Atlanta is over 10% now.
It’s also a bit off the original argument. The hint that was offered to somebody was, if you see these two letters it’s probably Portuguese. And they said that was too hard. At that point, it’s nothing to do with exposure.
Important-Trifle-411@reddit
Depends where you live. I live next to Fall River Mass. Tons of Portuguese
HarlequinKOTF@reddit
For the vast majority of americans though we can recognize that if it sounds like spanish, it is probably spanish.
cans-of-swine@reddit
Not very often, thats why I won't remember that.
lanikuikawa@reddit
work on your memory brother
No_Report_4781@reddit
Bought a new Ram.
thatonebitchL@reddit
In this economy!
No_Report_4781@reddit
I’m saving up for the Ewe!
cans-of-swine@reddit
My memory is almost full. I try to just keep the things i need to remember...
crosscountrycoder@reddit
Also, if you see ç, vowels with circumflexes (âêîôû), the sequences lh, nh, eiro or eira it's probably Portuguese.
If you see sequences like ll, ero, era, or ción it's probably Spanish.
These are other ways I recognize the difference.
WestWillow@reddit
To me Portuguese sounds like Spanish if I didn’t understand any of it at all. My brain is trying to hear Spanish. When I realize I don’t know any of it, I assume it is Portuguese.
bananakegs@reddit
I feel the same way about Italian too. I’m not completely fluent but I I understand Spanish pretty well- but I need to concentrate. If I start focusing and nothing makes sense still- it’s not Spanish
Happy_Confection90@reddit
Portuguese, or at least the version spoken in Massachusetts, is similar enough to Spanish for me to get the gist of what's being said, but I realize within quickly that it's not Spanish. Even when words are quite similar (say in a phrase like "grapes for sale"), they're often not in the same place within sentences as they are in Spanish.
VinceP312@reddit
They sound nothing alike to me.
bass679@reddit
i'm decent at Spanish. I can use it at work and to get around Mexico fine. The first time I heard Portuguese I thought the speaker had a lisp or some kind of speech impediment. In the years since I find Portuguese in a weird place where I feel like I SHOULD understanding it but I definitely cannot.
Several of my colleagues are Brazillian and I absolutely cannot follow beyond the basic greetings when they swap to portuguese.
norecordofwrong@reddit
I’ve always described it as drunk Spanish.
ElDopio69@reddit
There's way more "sh" sounds in Portuguese
HarlequinKOTF@reddit
Yeah it sounds like Dutch does to me since I know german pretty well.
Temporary-Row-2992@reddit
Thank you. Always wondered.
Inside-Try-394@reddit
They pronounce things pretty differently.
Lower_Neck_1432@reddit
I can, Portuguese uses far more nasalized vowels.
bananapanqueques@reddit
Yes, especially considering 59 million of us speak Spanish.
ITrCool@reddit
A friend of mine grew up in Brazil as a missionary's kid and taught me a few Portuguese phrases and words. From what I've learned there, and studying Spanish I can see the differences and the tones are definitely different in how the words sound out.
obtusewisdom@reddit
Depends on the Americans. If someone lives in a place where they never hear either, they might not. If they're like me living in a more diverse area, we can.
Relative_Average522@reddit
I can because I speak Spanish but not Portuguese.
atierney14@reddit
Every time I hear Portuguese for just a few seconds, I think, “that persons speaking Spanish.”
Every time I hear someone speaking Portuguese for a few minutes, I think, “oh, that’s not Spanish, must be Portuguese.”
randomwellwisher@reddit
Yes. And between specific Spanish accents. Portuguese is harder - I can’t really differentiate between Lusophone accents. But I think most people can certainly tell the difference between spoken Spanish and spoken Portuguese.
Exact-Truck-5248@reddit
Portuguese is highly palatalized. lots of ch's and sh's
Technical-Pack5891@reddit
Yes - quite easy.
somecow@reddit
Yeah. Sounds kinda like spanish at the start, but then you’re like “whoa”.
oneislandgirl@reddit
I don't hear Portuguese often enough to know the difference but I'm sure if you heard it regularly you could tell.
maimou1@reddit
I can but I had years of Spanish in high school and spoke it with my Greek dad at home. He was trilingual; English, Spanish and Greek.
GrannyTurtle@reddit
No. They barely know the difference between French and German.
Tommy_Wisseau_burner@reddit
I can. Portuguese sounds like someone tried to speak French, Italian and Spanish at the same time
Saltwater_Heart@reddit
Yes. Spanish sounds like Spanish. Portuguese to me sounds like almost Spanish.
Constellation-88@reddit
There are millions of Spanish-speaking Americans, and we can definitely tell. Idk about monolingual Americans tho.
jexxie3@reddit
I have been learning Spanish. Prior to this, I could pretty confidently tell you when someone is definitely speaking Spanish. But I had no idea what Portuguese sounded like.
But now, I think Portuguese sounds like Slavic Spanish
WhompTrucker@reddit
I can but I'm an English language tutor who works with a lot of Brazilian students so I can detect that kind of Portuguese
Jjackx@reddit
I couldn’t at first… but listening closer now I can.
uReallyShouldTrustMe@reddit
Yeah but Im Latino american.
Soundtracklover72@reddit
Probably not a lot of Americans. They’ll assuming the person speaking Portuguese is speaking Spanish. It’s sad.
I’ve been doing Duolingo Spanish for several years and I can tell the difference because I’ll be like “only 2 of those words sounded remotely familiar.” 😜
A_SleepyHed@reddit
Well, considering everyone from Canada to Chile is "American," I would venture that a majority of "Americans" can definitely tell the difference.
_MadSuburbanDad_@reddit
If you grow up in areas where Portuguese is spoken, you can definitely tell the difference.
Also….There have been Portuguese-speaking communities in the US since the 1700s
navylast@reddit
If they listen they can. Quite different.
Owlthirtynow@reddit
I know I can. They sound completely different.
baggiecurls@reddit
I can
Calm_Pollution7649@reddit
Most Americans take at least a little Spanish in school and interact with it more, seeing as how we have plenty of Hispanic immigrants in the country. I’d assume most can tell the difference
questionably_human7@reddit
for certain, Portuguese is Slavic Spanish, sounds very different!
mb46204@reddit
Only if they know one or the other
heyitslola@reddit
Spanish sounds like Spanish and Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a mouthful of mashed potatoes.
anneofgraygardens@reddit
I'd say yes? Spanish is extremely common in the US and Portuguese isn't (unless you live in Massachusetts), so people are very familiar with the sound of Spanish. And they sound pretty different.
But obviously some people aren't good at languages and might be confused.
TheMarshmallowFairy@reddit
Oh that’s interesting! My great grandmother was a Portuguese immigrant and she settled in Massachusetts when moving to the US, where she met my great grandfather and where my grandmother and most of her siblings were born. I’ve never been anywhere near there, I had no idea it had a strong Portuguese community but now that makes sense why she settled there first. Super cool to know that! It makes me want to visit, since it’s probably the closest I could ever get to Portugal. My grandmother spoke some Portuguese and made some of the food, but my mother and I never learned either and now I miss my grandmother’s cooking. Her linguica soup is something I have been missing lately, it’s been over 20 years 😭
Sorry for my random emotional tangent 😅
Wyoungv01@reddit
There is a lot of Portuguese in Mass?
pmonichols@reddit
Oh yeah... I think Portuguese is probably about as popular as Spanish here
Cookies_2@reddit
My hometown has several Portuguese festivals each year and three Portuguese clubs. The festivals are incredible, the food is amazing!
ohamel98@reddit
Feast of the Holy Ghost might shut down the city depending where you are 😂
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
Third most spoken language in the state. Large Brazilian community AND large Portuguese community AND large Cabo Verdedan community.
norecordofwrong@reddit
And it also swings down into RI. I think Portuguese is the most common non English language. If you live around Cabo Verdeans as well you can pick up on how their Portuguese sounds different than South American or mainland European Portuguese.
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
Oh yeah, tons of Portuguese speakers in RI too, but outnumbered by Spanish speakers (like in MA). Lots of Colombians, Dominicans, Bolivians and Guatemalans in the Providence area.
norecordofwrong@reddit
Yeah my first neighborhood was more established Portuguese immigrants and my second one was a whole shit ton of Dominicans.
They speak Spanish fast and have a ton of slang I don’t know.
Murderhornet212@reddit
What’s the second? French?
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
Spanish.
Murderhornet212@reddit
Huh. The part of MA I lived in, Portuguese was by far the second language. Most of the Spanish speakers I worked with lived in RI, mostly Guatemalans.
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
There are more Spanish-speakers total because they are spread out throughout the state. Places like Springfield and Holyoke have minimal Portuguese speakers but huge Spanish-speaking communities. Same with Worcester and certain parts of the Boston area. Portuguese speakers are clustered in SE MA, Framingham and surrounding towns, Milford/Franklin area and Boston/Cambridge/Somerville/Everett....though there are plenty of Spanish speakers in Boston and immediate environs too.
Murderhornet212@reddit
Makes sense. I was in Taunton.
ZaphodG@reddit
Southeastern Massachusetts is heavily populated with Portuguese-Azores Islands immigrants. They originally came as crew with the New Bedford whaling fleet when New Bedford was one of the wealthiest cities in the world. In the 1890s, large amounts of immigration were for the textile mills in New Bedford and Fall River.
I can buy things like Pasteis de Nata at the Portuguese bakeries. Lots of places sell bolinhos de bacalhau / cod cakes. The Azores version of linguica and chourico sausage are ubiquitous. Morcela / blood sausage. It was just Easter so folar de pascoa / sweet bread with hard boiled eggs is common.
My town just had an election. The four candidates for select board were named Silva, Melo, Nunes, and Olivera.
LandofRy@reddit
Yeah, Mass and Rhode Island have huge Portuguese populations
Durham1988@reddit
Also in Rhode Island. Most Portuguese immigrants to the US were sailors or fishers or whalers.
Murderhornet212@reddit
Yup. Originally it was because of the whaling industry in coastal MA, then over the years other Portuguese speaking people came over. I think it’s just easier to settle somewhere where they speak your language. There’s Portuguese people, mainly from the Azores, a large Cape Verdean population, some Brazilians. I used to work with somebody from Angola.
nathanwilson26@reddit
You are correct that the original Portuguese immigrants to Massachusetts were in the whaling and fishing industries. Then the mill towns of Fall River and New Bedford (formerly whaling and fishing towns) were attractive because of factory jobs through the 60s and 70s.
ginger_bird@reddit
Fall River Massachusetts is considered the 10th island of the Azores.
Happy_Confection90@reddit
That's funny because one of my parents was Portuguese by way of the Azores and Bermuda, and it surprisingly wasn't the parent who grew up in Fall River 😄
h0lych4in@reddit
yes
Eat_Locals@reddit
Mass and Rhode Island both. A couple of Portuguese people moved there, then a few more moved to where there were already Portuguese. Similar thing happened with Cape Verdeans, who also speak Portuguese.
ShiftyShaymin@reddit
Yep. Especially the southern coast of the state (Fall River, Taunton and New Bedford area).
anneofgraygardens@reddit
Yes.
Murderhornet212@reddit
I was going to say yes because I lived in MA for 20+ years lol
OneAndDone169@reddit
Heavy Portuguese population in NJ as well
Murderhornet212@reddit
We used to go to a Portuguese restaurant in like Harrison or Kearney back in the day.
OneAndDone169@reddit
Harrison, Kearny, Newark that whole area plus a lot more of Hudson and parts of Essex county. The Portuguese festival in Iron Bound is one of my favorite events that happens in NJ, The food is an 11 out of 10.
shelwood46@reddit
The food is incredible.
mwhite5990@reddit
Yeah I think a lot of people would think Portuguese is just Spanish with an accent they are unfamiliar with.
MikeExMachina@reddit
Plenty of Brazilians in South Florida as well
WhirledPeas2703@reddit
Lots of Portuguese in California too. The difference in the two languages is pretty easy for us to hear.
spintool1995@reddit
The farmers went to CA, the fishermen mostly stayed in MA. My great grandfather was a fisherman in the Azores and came to MA, fished at first, then worked in a factory. His brother had married into a farming family so when he came he went to Sacramento where his in-laws had already acquired a farm.
anneofgraygardens@reddit
There are a lot of people of Portuguese descent here but I never hear Portuguese spoken - they're mostly third/fourth generation Americans and monolingual English speakers at this point. I had a coworker who spoke Portuguese as her first language (born in the US to immigrants) so I know they exist, but the Portuguese speaking community is tiny compared to the Spanish speaking community.
WhirledPeas2703@reddit
Well our experience is different then, isn’t it.
Goats_for_president@reddit
Or South Florida, I’m just guessing it’s pretty common there tho
MrsSnuffleupagus764@reddit
I too live in MA and can quite easily tell the difference.
Permanenceisall@reddit
San Diego also has a fairly large Portuguese community, and with our proximity to Mexico it’s very easy to tell the difference
Cookies_2@reddit
I was just going to comment I can tell the difference because where I grew up. That is Massachusetts lol.
rsvihla@reddit
Or Mystic, Conn.
fsmpastafarian@reddit
Yeah Spanish and Portuguese sound very different and Spanish is commonly spoken throughout the US. I would think most people with a passing familiarity at how Spanish sounds would be able to tell the difference.
Grand-South9060@reddit
Yes. Portuguese sounds like very drunk Spanish with a rock in the speakers mouth.
min_mus@reddit
Yes, they sound very different.
mustang6172@reddit
No puedo entender portugués.
dunncrew@reddit
Portuguese (Brazilian) is very Mellifluous. Very different from Spanish.
neuralpathweighs@reddit
Yes. American living in Florida. Portuguese sounds like Italian French Spanish, if that makes sense.
John_M_L@reddit
Yes, of course. If I can understand what they're saying, that's Spanish. If I can almost understand most of the words but what was that at the end? That's Portuguese. But I speak Spanish so 🤷🏻
SpaceFroggy1031@reddit
Yes. One I can understandish. The other is this weird Italian hybrid.
addictedtotext@reddit
Spanish sounds familiar and Portuguese sounds like someone trying to speak Spanish. Or what I think people who don't know what Spanish sounds like, sounds like.
I can recognize the sounds and a few words in Spanish so I know if its Spanish. Portuguese sounds like Spanish to me but I can't make out any words. Like they're just saying fake words. But also it sounds rounder(?) Hard to explain fully.
What___Do@reddit
I can. I hear someone speaking Spanish and say to myself, “why can’t I understand this guy’s Spanish? …oh, it’s Portuguese.” So, it’s a two-step process, but I still get there. It’s easier to tell when it’s written.
Charming-Pack-5979@reddit
I can barely differentiate Italian and Spanish 😂
TheOnlyJimEver@reddit
Well, I speak Spanish, so, yes...
Relative_Roof4085@reddit
I can tell Mexican Spanish from Caribbean Spanish from Portuguese.
hannahroseb@reddit
Yes. One I can understand and the other sounds like someone speaking French with marbles in their mouth.
tiny_purple_Alfador@reddit
I can recognize Spanish when I hear it, the first time I heard Portuguese I spent several minutes trying to work out what I was hearing, and ended up asking the people what language they were speaking (I worked in a souvenir shop, asking people questions about where they were from was encouraged.). So.... Sort of? I don't think I'd necessarily recognize Portuguese if I heard it again, but I wouldn't think it was Spanish.
tetrasodium@reddit
South Florida here kinda yea but I don't speak enough of either to be sure
codenameajax67@reddit
Of course.
Spoken Spanish is a language and Portuguese are birds sitting on the porch
TieDyeSocks77@reddit
Yes.
Shivs_baby@reddit
I can always tell. I have a friend from Brazil and another from Portugal and I’ve heard them speak Portuguese enough times to be able to easily tell the difference.
Mysterious_Green7904@reddit
Spanish sounds like Spanish just different speeds and tones due to dialects. To me the only way I can describe hearing Portuguese is imagine a French person with a super thick accent trying to speak Spanish.
joanmcq@reddit
Yes, I just went to both Spain and Portugal. Spanish is gracias and Portuguese is abrigado. lol, I don’t really speak either. But definitely a difference.
pimpletwist@reddit
Yes
notthegoatseguy@reddit
The likelihood of 95% of Americans even hearing Portugese is very low. Its not a widely spoken language. with only two major nations in the world speaking it.
pmonichols@reddit
It's a regional thing... in the northeast it is a major second language. It's a strong contender to Spanish actually.
CommandAlternative10@reddit
Portuguese here is mostly the fancy coffee shop playing bossa nova.
Emergency-Machine-55@reddit
Don't forget Brazilian BBQs.
hurtingheart4me@reddit
Absolutely
InvestigatorJaded261@reddit
Aurally? Absolutely.
UnderaZiaSun@reddit
Si! I mean Sim!
kjc-01@reddit
I speak high-school level Spanish (SoCal) and heard Portuguese for the first time in Boston at the end of a late night out. I thought I had a stroke, as it sounded familiar but did not make any sense.
Weird_Squirrel_8382@reddit
I'm such a dumb American that I was in my thirties before I found out Brazilians speak Portuguese. I remember flipping channels on vacation and thinking "Brazilian Spanish is so different than Mexican Spanish." My SIL had to break the news to me.
BrieBelle00@reddit
Probably the same number who can hear the difference between Arabic and Farsi
K_N0RRIS@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a sinus infection
7GrenciaMars@reddit
For me it's easy, but my household was close friends with the neighbors who were from Brazil and still spoke their native language a lot. When I was first getting to know them I knew a little Spanish and didn't know where they were from but could immediately tell that they weren't speaking Spanish.
skittlesriddles44@reddit
yes
Winter-Warlock8954@reddit
We hear Spanish often, being north of Mexico and having a massive immigrant population of multigenerational Spanish speaking residents. So yes, most Americans know the difference between Spanish and Portuguese.
Portuguese and Italian though, that's another story.
Olliecat27@reddit
I can. But a lot of us learn at least a bit of Spanish as a second language in school. I took it for 6yrs myself. (Only at around B1 level though)
Lingo2009@reddit
I’m an American who speaks Spanish. Yes I can tell the difference.
Interesting_Yak8052@reddit
Yes
BayAreaPupMom@reddit
💯 Even the accent alone is so different.
Only_Presentation758@reddit
I’d say many can, some can’t
Yggdrssil0018@reddit
Yes.
James-robinsontj@reddit
Spanish is the 2nd most spoken language in the US. Some areas like Southern California, you need to speak a little Spanish, from time to time.
If you work in restaurants, Spanish is required.
_that_dude_J@reddit
Yes. Though not all. Those of us watching Portuguese language programming. Netflix The Circle and then dating shows got me hooked.
TacoBMMonster@reddit
Yes. If it sounds vaguely like Spanish but I can't understand it, that's Portuguese.
Potential-Current-62@reddit
We can’t even agree on English lol
Rolthox@reddit
Oh absolutely! Spanish sound like Spanish, but Portuguese sounds like if Spanish was also French with a hint of something else. I think they're both lovely languages
bibliahebraica@reddit
Many Americans speak one or both languages, so some of us certainly can. (I’m about to spend a few days with my extended family, which will include several people who are fluent in one or the other).
On the other hand, plenty of Americans are native English speakers who really don’t speak English, let alone any other language. So no, they wouldn’t know Spanish from Mandarin.
Fabulous-South-9551@reddit
I can but my dads side of the family is Mexican and Spanish speaking (no he didn’t teach me) and I had a lot of Portuguese friends in high school. I grew up in the Bay Area. Way more “sh” sounds in Portuguese.
North-Country-5204@reddit
To me the two are very distinct from each other and easy to differentiate.
RatonhnhaketonK@reddit
I can, because I have been exposed to both enough times to know
Famous-Hunt-6461@reddit
Yes. I don’t speak Spanish fluently but I know enough Spanish to know the difference. I took 7 years of French and Portuguese sounds like a mix of Spanish and French to me.
jessper17@reddit
Yes. They’re pretty different to my ear.
DevilPixelation@reddit
If they’ve had some form of exposure to Spanish, then I think after a while it would click. Highly dependent on the individual tho
Southern-Usual4211@reddit
Easily my part of the US Spanish is spoken as frequently as English if not motey
Your-Fellow-Man@reddit
Me? Yes. But I have had lots of contact with Spanish and know a good bit. Nearly everyone else I know? Probably not.
SaltPrestigious5923@reddit
Yes 💯
Lumpy-Magician-9832@reddit
Yes, for sure. But I’m an American from New Mexico with a huge Spanish speaking population. I’m not near fluent but the difference is immediately obvious.
mikegalos@reddit
I certainly can
theresuscitator@reddit
Yes
Jaygon1963@reddit
Yes. Next silly question.
Zygoatscythe@reddit (OP)
"Yes. Next silly question" 💅
Imaginary-Duck1333@reddit
I speak Spanish, so not quite your target, but I used to get Portuguese all the time on the Spanish line at work. We could usually understand each other if we both spoke slowly. The person who transferred the call would then a lecture on the history of Spanish vs Portuguese. Rarely had the same person twice but there are always new hires.
Rundiggity@reddit
I speak Spanish well and French fairly well. When I hear Portuguese, my initial thought is that for some reason I’m not hearing the Spanish correctly. Then confusion. After a few seconds I realize it’s Portuguese. I hear it so rarely that I’m surprised every time.
TexanGoblin@reddit
No, unless we speak one of them decently well, they sound the exact same to us.
Reasonable_Bid3311@reddit
Portuguese sounds faintly like Romanian to me.
IvyLestrange@reddit
Depends how much that person has heard Spanish. As others have said, if they can tell the difference it is still pretty likely they won’t necessarily realize it is Portuguese.
mountednoble99@reddit
I took 3 years of Spanish classes. I might be able to!
Playful-Spinach-4040@reddit
We can’t tell the difference between Spain Spanish and Mexico Spanish
Alternative-Law4626@reddit
Yes, Spanish sounds like Spanish and Portuguese sounds like Russian. To me anyway.
Amockdfw89@reddit
Some can some can’t. Most people though aren’t familiar with what Portuguese sounds like so if they hear it they are like “huh”
Hell I know plenty of Spanish speakers who couldn’t recognize it was Portuguese spoken. Unless your really in love with languages it isn’t usual to know what is being spoken
Lwadrian06@reddit
If its written out I can 100% tell. Spoken im not sure, not many people in the US speak Portuguese
Temporary-Library597@reddit
All of them? No. Some of them? Well yeah they're different languages that have some similarities.
soul_separately_recs@reddit
only people living within 100 m from🇲🇽
(the ‘m’ = meters)
Carinyosa99@reddit
I can, but then again, I'm also fluent in Spanish.
40pukeko@reddit
Yes, I've worked with Brazilians enough. Portuguese sounds like mushy Spanish. I cannot tell the difference between Brazilian Portuguese and Portuguese from Portugal.
lexicon951@reddit
Yup. Portuguese has suffixes like -em and -ao. It’s like Spanish with aegyo
Minimum_Boat6028@reddit
I live in Rhode Island and can clearly tell the difference.. it’s the shhh sound. But US is huge.. my cousin lives in Missouri and his wife had never met anyone Portugese until she came here
Vast-Combination4046@reddit
I can understand Spanish. I can't understand Portuguese
Vast-Combination4046@reddit
I can read Spanish better than I can hear it. Portuguese looks absolutely absurd on paper
iLiveInAHologram94@reddit
Yeah it sounds different to me
silverbatwing@reddit
Shoot, most Americans can’t even understand English half the time if it has an accent
Elnathi@reddit
I'm an American who speaks Spanish as a second language.
One time I had someone talk to me in Portuguese and I asked them to repeat themself like 3 times before I realized it was Portuguese and not some Spanish accent I was unfamiliar with
But I am also kind of stupid 🤷
Historical_Bath_9854@reddit
I can. It sounds like Spanish with a French accent 🤷
LHCThor@reddit
Yes. Almost all Americans have heard Spanish, very few folks know what Portuguese sounds like.
Maleficent_Button_58@reddit
Since Spanish is such a commonly spoken language here in the states, I feel like most can probably tell if someone is speaking Spanish or not.
FirstPersonWinner@reddit
I mean, many Americans are at least familiar with Spanish and like 15% of all Americans speak Spanish. The US has the world's second largest Spanish speaking population, only behind Mexico.
patawpha@reddit
Yes. Maybe not immediately but after hearing a few sentences I can definitely tell.
Maleficent_Button_58@reddit
Sure, if they know what the languages sound like or can speak them themselves.
P00PooKitty@reddit
I live in Massachusetts and specifically a city with. Lot of both speakers. Yes. It’s incredibly easy to decipher Brazilian Portuguese from Latin American Spanish. The former is legato, sign-singly, and almost tonal. The latter is staccato, faster, and has a totally Different rhythm to it.
Pittypatkittycat@reddit
Portuguese is the "Spanish" I can't pick out any words. My grandparents were Eastern European German. So Dutch and Yiddish are the German I can't pick any words out.
Francescothechill@reddit
These comments are making me feel dumb lol. I speak Spanish and it still takes me a solid couple of seconds to realize the other person is speaking Portuguese. To me there's a lot of similarities
eyeshitunot@reddit
I speak a little Spanish. When I was preparing to go to Portugal I tried to learn a little Portuguese. It looked pretty OK in writing, not to different from Spanish and other romance languages. Once I got there, I could not understand a word anyone said.
Ok-Possibility-9826@reddit
I can kinda tell, but only because I speak (some) Spanish. I’m by no means fluent, though.
Senior_Performer_387@reddit
I don't know that I've ever paid attention but I probably could if i actually paid attention to how they sound.
Reasonable_Guess_175@reddit
I know it’s Portuguese if it kind of sounds like Spanish but I can’t understand it (I can usually understand Spanish at least a little).
DoctorFunktopus@reddit
Portuguese has a lot more of those (not sure how to type this ) “jush” soft J sounds. Between that and if it sounds like Spanish but I recognize none of the words I can tell you’re speaking Portuguese.
Crash0020@reddit
Most Americans can’t tell the difference between Spanish and German. Source? I’m an American.
Romaine2k@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Spanish spoken by someone with a speech impediment.
Intermountain-Gal@reddit
I can. Though I can’t speak Portuguese to save my life! My Spanish is about like a 4 year old.
bazoos@reddit
Yeah, Portuguese sounds like someone speaking Spanish wrong.
Most_Time8900@reddit
Yes, of course.
let-it-rain-sunshine@reddit
It’s all Greek to majority of Americans
Spazyk@reddit
They do not sound the same.
potlizard@reddit
Yes. Portuguese sounds like a cross between French and Spanish to me. Spanish sounds more like Italian to me than Portuguese.
TNSoccerGuy@reddit
Yes, easily
JacobDCRoss@reddit
Sim
Throwaway-ish123a@reddit
Me yes, but I hear both nearly every day. Generally, however, no.
ohamel98@reddit
Yes. I speak decent Spanish and live in an area with a substantial Portuguese population. The “zh” sound (I don’t know how else to describe it - like the J in João) is an instant tell.
zsava002@reddit
I would say its sorta difficult. But im notoriously bad even figuring out english accents. For me portuguese, at least brazilian portuguese, is kinda sing songy compared to spanish. But idk if that holds any water 🤷♂️
jkmhawk@reddit
At least the 45-60 million Spanish speakers probably could.
Bfan72@reddit
Only if you are one or the other.
MeteorMann@reddit
Yes.
Spanish is instantly identifiable. Portuguese sounds like an Italian pretending to speak Spanish.
Gwtheyrn@reddit
If they're familiar with the languages, sure. I've only ever heard Brazillian Portuguese, and that had a more lilying quality than Mexican Spanish.
Enough-Tap-6329@reddit
Spanish sounds like Spanish except Spain Spanish which thounds like thpanith.
Portuguese sounds like shushushush ush ush shush
Ponchyan@reddit
This American can.
Lance-Boyle-666@reddit
To me, Portuguese sounds sort of like Italian, but it looks kind of like Spanish, and Spanish sounds like Spanish.
Free_Ad_4_U@reddit
Portuguese sounds like someone who doesn’t know Spanish pretending to speak Spanish.
Successful_Deal9334@reddit
Do you mean the Americans who dont speak Spanish? Its a very common language here and we dont have an official language.
Quirky-Attitude1456@reddit
I used to be better at it
RockShowSparky@reddit
Yes. I’m in Brazil right now and it sounds nothing like spanish.
SkullLeader@reddit
I don't really hear Portuguese spoken here though. I'm sure it happens but Spanish is far more common (or maybe I can't tell the difference? LOL) In any case I've listened to enough music in Portuguese that I'd be able to tell, I think.
pinksparkleberry@reddit
Yes.
Regular_Boot_3540@reddit
Oh, absolutely! The first time I heard portuguese I guessed it was some African language (I was in high school). It sounds really different to me!
DidelphisGinny@reddit
They sound NOTHING alike
HeyPurityItsMeAgain@reddit
I can identify Spanish and poorly speak a few words.
SnooPies5378@reddit
with everyone taking Brazilian Jiu Jitsu and MMA in America i’m guessing a lot can tell the difference when it’s Spanish or Portuguese
Patient-Ad-7939@reddit
I can tell them apart, since I’ve spent a good amount of time around speakers of both languages. But Portugal Portuguese always throws me off because I’m more used to Brazilian Portuguese. But the occasional Portuguese from other countries throws me off even more. I have a coworker from Mozambique. It’s much more like Portugal Portuguese, but still different.
DocTeeBee@reddit
Yes. Understanding is a different matter. I can sort of understand slowly spoken Spanish. But Portuguese is a nope. It sounds like Spanish with a French accent, but not quite French.
maestra612@reddit
I think Portuguese sounds like a cross between Spanish and German.
Virtual_Job9303@reddit
Not me. Except for French, all Romance languages and accents sound the same.
MoriKitsune@reddit
Yes. To me, Portuguese sounds kind of like Spanish and French mixed together. It sounds very "round" in comparison.
mattcmoore@reddit
I can but I speak spanish. About 14% of Americans speak Spanish.
tcspears@reddit
Yes, they sound completely different.
pubesinourteeth@reddit
Most Americans have heard fluent Spanish. If someone hasn't heard Portuguese before they probably wouldn't immediately deduce that it's Portuguese, but they would know it's not Spanish lol.
AtheneSchmidt@reddit
I'm decently familiar with Spanish, as it is the second most spoken language in my area. I have only heard Portuguese a handful of times, and I think it has always been Brazilian Portuguese, which in my experience is melodic and beautiful. I'm not sure if I would be able to spot Portuguese from Portugal.
NoIncrease299@reddit
I dated a gal from Brazil for several years. When she'd call her mom; they'd speak Portuguese.
First time I heard it; I was like "You ok?" "Yeah, why?" "Sounded like you and your mom were arguing." "Oh no, that's just what Portuguese sounds like."
parker9832@reddit
Absolutely! PBS taught me enough Spanish that I can recognize it. I can recognize most Western European languages. I have a hard time parsing between Nordic languages.
Mr_Noms@reddit
Yes.
Many Americans speak Spanish. Those who don’t have at least heard enough that they can tell Portuguese is different.
Maurice_Foot@reddit
Depends. My wife used to work a a large bank in Florida and got called in after a younger Cuban American was sent to translate for some Brazilian customers. Hearing the confusion, my wife (Anglo, grew up in Japan) stepped in and worked with the customers, who spoke English and didn’t know why a Spanish speaker who didn’t understand (or know about?) Portuguese had been had been sent to desl with them.
For myself, my mom (Chicana) had picked up an antique bottle and when I was 10 or 11, I tried to read the script on it but after I asked my mom why I couldnkt figure out the words, she explained about Portuguese and got me a dictionary.
NoMSaboutit@reddit
Yes! Portuguese is very hard for me to pronounce and I always try to pronounce Portuguese words like Spanish words.
Fluffy-Mine-6659@reddit
Not really. Around 20% of USA Americans can definitively understand that Spanish is being spoken.
Given that 24% of Americans are functionally illiterate, most of the rest couldn’t tell the difference between Spanish and Finnish.
Highly educated Americans, or Americans who live in cities with a lot of Spanish speakers - like LA or NY or Miami, chances are fair that they could discern it.
I spent a month each in Portugal and Spain and have taken Spanish classes. It would probably take me hearing an “abrogado” or “gracias” or “bom dia” or “buenas dias” to definitively clock it.
Narrow_Roof_112@reddit
No
ihatethesidebar@reddit
My girlfriend is Brazilian so yes, a lot more “yo” sounds at the end.
Broke_Pigeon_Sales@reddit
Yes. They sound pretty different. Portuguese uses some sounds that Spanish doesn't that, in my experience, makes my brain initially think it sounds more Eastern European. However, the only way we can probably really differentiate is to have experience with both cultures, and at that point they definitely sound different.
Moist_Ordinary6457@reddit
a lot of Xs or ao sounds tip me off
Broke_Pigeon_Sales@reddit
Yes. That’s it. That harsher X sound.
Duque_de_Osuna@reddit
Depends on the American. I can, but I learned Spanish as a second language. I have also been to PortugalBrazil and spent quite a bit of time in Spain.
There are probably a lot of Americans who cannot.
Rex_Lee@reddit
Yes Spanish sounds like Spanish and Portuguese sounds like Spanish spoken with a mouthful of marbles
Ilikedunkin@reddit
Yes
No_Ladder_9818@reddit
I am an American who speaks Spanish, so yes, I can distinguish the two.
tinytacomuncher@reddit
Yes
xRVAx@reddit
Portuguese has more zh sounds
shessocold1969@reddit
Yes. They are two different languages.
Technical-Tear5841@reddit
I can, I understand some Spanish, Portuguese has no words I recognize.
SusanLFlores@reddit
I’m sure many Americans can tell the difference between spoken Spanish and Portuguese. We have a lot of people here who speak Spanish and we have a fair amount of people who speak Portuguese.
thelastcoconut7@reddit
Of course
mister_drgn@reddit
What a bizarre question. The language skills and indeed the spoken languages of Americans vary wildly.
linkxrust@reddit
Bro, A lot of people speak spanish here in America.
RX3000@reddit
I can. But I speak Spanish 🤣 So it goes from understanding like 100% of Spanish to just catching words & phrases here & there in Portuguese. Im pretty sure if I tried I could learn Portuguese fairly quickly.
mwhite5990@reddit
I can, but I speak a bit of both languages.
txlady100@reddit
Yes
Aggressive_Power_471@reddit
Honestly I think it depends where you live. In Massachusetts, growing up we had a large population of Portuguese immigrants, so there will be some people there that can tell the difference. Likely same with NYC. In Arizona, I think people that do not speak Spanish might not know the difference. People that speak Spanish will know it is not Spanish, but may not know it is Portuguese.
AdelleDeWitt@reddit
Of course. Many of us speak Spanish or Portuguese. To me, Portuguese sounds like Spanish got all mooshy.
revocer@reddit
100%. Spanish is used in many parts of the US. So it is relatively easy to hear the difference.
With that said, if you mean Spanish from Spain. That is a little different. The accent in Spanish from Spain is totally different, and harder for me to decipher than the Spanish spoken in the Americas.
Although closer in sound, I can still tell Spain Spanish apart from Portuguese though. I might not understand it fully, but there is a distinction.
Hey-Bud-Lets-Party@reddit
Yes because Portuguese is very distinct sounding in the same way that French is.
Only-Candy1092@reddit
Ish? Like i can usually pick up that its different from spanish, but i have a hard time ID'ing it as portugese.
This is coming from someone who only speaks english, as a reference
1Negative_Person@reddit
“That person is speaking Spanish”
“That Spanish sounds really weird; it must be Portuguese.”
Mean-Anybody-134@reddit
The 2 languages surprisingly sound very different. Spanish is soft sounding. And I agree with the reference to a Russian guy when listening to Portuguese.
CarolinCLH@reddit
To me, Portuguese sounds a lot like Spanish, but I can't understand any of the words.
dirtygutshot@reddit
Yes, most of us can. I can, but my husband is terrible as discerning languages and even accents, so he wouldn’t be able to tell the difference.
BakedBrie1993@reddit
Do you mean the Americans who don't know any Spanish?
A lot of us at least know a little from school, community, or race/ethnicity, and would notice that it isn't Spanish, yes.
Buffalo24601@reddit
Yes. At least, I can, though I speak Spanish. Not sure about people who speak neither Spanish nor Portuguese.
samosamancer@reddit
The “sh” sounds in Portuguese give it away for me.
mothsuicides@reddit
I can tell the difference if I hear enough of it. I know Spanish well but Portuguese sounds like Spanish and French mushed together.
Leather-Sky8583@reddit
I can. My family heritage is Puerto Rican and so while I am not fluent, I can pick my way through Spanish relatively well.
When I was going to school for aircraft maintenance, I had a part-time job at a local McDonald’s after class. This particular McDonald’s was staffed almost entirely by Brazilian immigrants, although one of the supervisors was actually from Cape Verde. I was positioned on the register upfront since the entire kitchen. Staff spoke fluent Portuguese and some of them spoke little or no English.
There was a sizable Brazilian population in the area and so needless to say I was exposed to a lot of Portuguese. More than a few times I would have customers walk up to me and start making their order in Portuguese and when it was clear that I wasn’t entirely following them, they would become very apologetic when they realize I didn’t speak. Portuguese fluently myself and switched over to English.
I was quite flattered actually when one customer did the same thing and when I let him know that I didn’t speak Portuguese, he said he didn’t realize because I looked Portuguese myself. I will never complain about someone thinking that I look Brazilian lol.😆 Though I don’t see it myself😊
While I was able to occasionally pull out words, particularly when a team lead jokingly said to me “¡Ah, cala a boca!” it was close enough to “¡Oh, cállate la boca!” That I was able to quickly respond much to the intense amusement of my coworkers.
To my ear Portuguese sounds like the flourished accents of Italian with a Spanish sounding familiarity. But it is definitely very distinct to me from Spanish. (This is literally just my attempt to describe how it sounds to my ear, this is a very subjective description of the difference to me of Portuguese and Spanish.)
I do wanna say that the Brazilian team members I worked with were some of the kindest and most fun people I’ve ever worked with in my life. The same team lead I mentioned above cheerfully told me that they would have me speaking, fluent Portuguese by the end of the year.
Of all the jobs I’ve had in my life I have never been made to feel more at ease and welcome than I did at that McDonald’s with a crew that mostly spoke a language that I didn’t speak at all. Sadly, I graduated school and left that job, I would’ve loved to have stayed longer and learned the language myself.
Maronita2025@reddit
If we don't speak either then it is all GREEK to us.
Morphecto_Solrac@reddit
As a Spanish speaker from Mexico, Portuguese sounds like a word salad of Spanish and French to me. I’m curious what it sounds like to other native Spanish speakers.
NetFu@reddit
Most Americans won't.
Any American, like me, who took years of Spanish will realize you must be speaking Portuguese after a minute of my trying and failing to understand you.
But, middle America where most people never meet a foreigner just know you aren't speaking American. I grew up there, moved to California 36 years ago, and people were surprised I couldn't look at a person and tell the difference between Japanese, Chinese, Filipino, and Korean. I can now, but it took years.
So, without exposure to at least one language, it's unlikely you'll know the difference between two of them.
Able-Seaworthiness15@reddit
I don't know about every American since I haven't met everyone. I can tell the difference. Portuguese is more, I guess I'd say lilting, while Spanish is more staccato. At least to me.
loud-tortoise-plant@reddit
Why is Portuguese just French sounding Spanish?
piscina05346@reddit
I can, but I speak Portuguese.
wonderlustVA@reddit
They are recognizably very different.
Grouchy-Stand-4570@reddit
I can
OhWhyNotMarie@reddit
Yep. Mostly met Brazilians tho
GraceJamaicanKetchup@reddit
It depends on where the individual is from but I think if you presented it as like a question on a test or something most could tell the difference. If someone just heard someone speaking Portuguese on the street, I think more than a few would assume it's Spanish though.
I can tell the difference in any context but I've lived in an area where it's common to hear both languages. Plus I've done Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, which as you can guess has a lot of Portuguese speakers involved in it. Even if you can't understand what they're saying the accents are pretty distinct.
RedLegGI@reddit
Yes, Portuguese doesn’t sound ‘quite right’ when you hear it.
skyHawk3613@reddit
As an American born to Portuguese parents…yes I can
BroCanWeGetLROTNOG@reddit
They sound a lot more different than they look.
Defiant_Network7916@reddit
Hmm these comments are the opposite of my experience, most people cannot tell the difference unless they have above average familiarity with one or both languages. Most Americans, in my experience, assume spoken Portuguese is Spanish.
fadedtimes@reddit
I assume it is Portuguese because I can’t understand anything. In Spanish I at least know some of the words
Vivid-Explanation951@reddit
Im very familiar with Brazilian Portuguese and can distinguish it from Spanish. Im not sure i hear many speakers from Portugal, but I would realize they weren't speaking Spanish. I think I've mistaken it for Russian before.
TrillyMike@reddit
“Hmm this kinda sound like Spanish but I’m not catchin any word I recognize, prolly Portuguese”
pvrkr@reddit
The United States is the 2nd largest Spanish speaking country in the world, so I would argue yes.
El-Mas-Vetado@reddit
I am a Gringo who learned Spanish in school.
After that, I worked for a company that did business in Brazil.
Eu hablo muito bien el portunol.
Mysterious-Lab974@reddit
Yes
420catloveredm@reddit
Pretty sure I could. We hear Spanish a lot in the U.S. if I couldn’t recognize any of the words I would assume it is not Spanish.
SirMixSalah@reddit
As an American,I don't think Americans can tell the difference with simple English
bellegroves@reddit
Some Americans can. Others can't tell the difference between spoken British English and spoken Australian English.
Equilibrate321@reddit
Yes. Eastern Massachusetts has significant numbers of people who speak Spanish (Central America, Dominican) and Portuguese (Portugal, Azores, Brazil, and Cape Verde).
I know a little Spanish by osmosis and can pick up words and sometimes get the gist. I can often figure out written Spanish.
Portuguese sounds different. Distinct "sh", "zh", and nasal sounds like "aowm". The intonation and cadence are different. I can see why people are saying it's like French because those sounds are common in French. I understand very little spoken Portuguese. Some written but not as much as Spanish. I can't tell the difference between Portugal, Brazil, and Cape Verdi Creole though.
severencir@reddit
You mean mexican and Brazilian? /s
Shoddy-Secretary-712@reddit
I might not know it is Portuguese. I recently heard a video in Portuguese, the sounds quality was very poor. I could tell it wasn't Spanish, but it felt familiar.
Zapitago@reddit
No. I played an MMO when I was young (and still do) that is primarily played by Brazilians. I can tell the difference between written Portuguese and Spanish, but would need to listen very closely to realize it’s not Spanish when spoken.
goat20202020@reddit
I can hear the difference right away. But I went to high school with a lot of Spanish and Portuguese kids.
glitterlok@reddit
Depends on the Spanish.
Original-Platform577@reddit
My Portuguese grandmother could easily communicate with Spanish folks and vice versa. As a non-speaker of both of those languages, a notable difference for me is the pronunciation of "s". Portuguese "s" sounds more like "zh).
Elevenyearstoomany@reddit
Yes. I can understand most Spanish but Portuguese, despite the similarities, trips me up more. I’m conversational in Spanish.
Petrifalcon3@reddit
Depends on the American
archonpericles@reddit
Yes. Easily.
NorwegianSteam@reddit
Rhode Island has the only Portuguese radio station in the US. I found it once and thought it was pissed off Romanian or Hungarian, two languages that I do not know. Take from that what you will.
ifoldsocksatmidnight@reddit
As an American, who didn’t learn Spanish until later in life, for me, it would be a no. But now that I am nearly fluent in Spanish I can clearly tell the difference.
mmarkmc@reddit
I’ve lived in California my entire life and majored in Latin American History and minored in Spanish and was closed to fluent many years ago. I still have a pretty strong grasp of Spanish and tried to learn Portuguese through a language app and was surprised at how different it was from Spanish. I definitely would have known the difference before that but it really drove it home.
thatmaneeee@reddit
The roughly 45 million Americans who speak one or the other natively sure can
Sabertooth767@reddit
I would think I'm better than a coinflip but not 100%
notapoliticalalt@reddit
I’m in the same boat. I don’t speak either, and of course, part of this is going to depend on the speaker and the exact things being sad. But I will say there are a few tells.
The first thing for me is cadence and rhythm. Portuguese in particular tends to have a more irregular cadence at least to my ears. If you are familiar with music, it almost kind of “swings” in a way and is a bit more legato (ie more connected sounds), while typically Spanish, to my ear, is more “straight” (ie the beat is more regular) and staccato. I’m sure there are other and better ways to describe this, but this to me tend to be the biggest give away.
Next, you have the sound. Portuguese has a lot more nasal vowels (eg when you get “ão” sounds). Portuguese also has what to the causal ear might be described as the the “g/j” sound like in the English “jello” or “gee” (or sometimes a lot in between this sound and “ch”; linguistics nerds feel free to add and tell me how this is wrong but I’m speaking without a high level knowledge of linguistics so…) which is at the very least rare in Spanish but is all over Portuguese (eg in Portuguese good afternoon, “boa tarde” the “de” makes more of a “gee” sound). To me, these are the biggest sound give always.
Lastly, depending on how much you are around Spanish or Portuguese speakers, you may pick up words and phrases that you know specifically are one or the other. For most Americans, Spanish is probably more common so listening for those can help….sometimes.
Anyway, these are sweeping generalities. You results may vary.
hasanicecrunch@reddit
Obviously. I think you meant English speakers. There are Spanish and Portuguese speakers everywhere here. 🙄 ofc we know
intheether323@reddit
Yes. I speak Spanish but I most definitely do not speak Portuguese 🤣
auldnate@reddit
Nope.
panic_bread@reddit
I can, but I've been studying Spanish and Italian for many years.
Gloomy-Ask-9437@reddit
Everyone I know who has studied at least a couple years of Spanish can tell the difference, even if they can't understand what's being said
petersemm@reddit
Yes. Spanish is very prevalent. Maybe the majority wouldn't be able to identify Portugese but would certainly be able to distinguish btw the two.
burns_before_reading@reddit
I speak Spanish so yea, I can tell the difference.
WellWellWellthennow@reddit
Yes, most of us know enough of what Spanish sounds like so that we know when something doesn't sound like it.
94grampaw@reddit
Some can
Thin-Bat4202@reddit
Very different sounding languages. I'm from California and mostly hear Mexican Spanish, though I only know a bit myself. But just did a video tour of Castillan, Cuban, Argentinian, Puerto Rican Spanish, others. Portuguese sounds very distinct from all of them.
otetrapodqueen@reddit
I can, but my family on my mom's side is from Mexico, idk if other people can or not.
rawbface@reddit
Yes absolutely. They sound extremely different to me, just in the accent and the consonant sounds they use.
Is there somewhere where it's supposed to sound indistinguishable? You might as well be telling me that French and Italian sound the same to you.
Mayor__Defacto@reddit
Dunno about ‘white people’ but I sure can. Portuguese sounds more like French with a bit of German to me.
joshdrumsforfun@reddit
To me Portuguese sounds like someone speaking Spanish but I can’t recognize any of the words.
It almost feels like having a stroke or something.
Any-Worldliness-679@reddit
Yeah. Some can. Some can't. It's a massive country with every demographic you can imagine. It's a silly question.
BossDjGamer@reddit
I could count on one hand amount of times I’ve knowingly heard somebody speak Portuguese
No_Owl_7380@reddit
I can but I lived and worked a long time in a city with large Latino, Brazilian, and Portuguese populations.
I can generally differentiate which country/community someone who speaks Spanish is from.
smugbox@reddit
I definitely can. I don’t speak Spanish but I took classes for like 11 years as a kid and can definitely tell if a language is Spanish or not
DoubleResponsible276@reddit
Americans who have been around Spanish probably will understand, but of course you’ll have those that will see a brown person not speaking English and assume it’s Spanish.
into_outdoors@reddit
Most Americans couldn't even find Portugal on a map, let alone tell dialect differences from anywhere outside of the US.
skilletjlc4@reddit
I can, but I also live in Florida where Spanish is extremely common.
Hardpo@reddit
There's a difference? /S
Least_Bat1259@reddit
Certain ways things are pronounced yes. But I’m not a fluent Spanish or Portuguese speaker.
Otherwise-Soft-6712@reddit
As a Brazilian with dual citizenship from the US I’m loving the answers. I had a waiter in Denver ask me and my friends if we were speaking French. I also had someone asking if me and a friend from Rio were speaking an Eastern European language.
Worried-Artichoke-13@reddit
Si, inmediatamente.
McFreezerBurn@reddit
I’m American and learned Spanish in school so I can understand it very well. Therefore Portuguese sounds very different to me. If I didn’t understand Spanish, however, I think I would still hear a variation between the 2, even if I didn’t understand what was being said.
TokyoDrifblim@reddit
Yes by fact that we all know what Spanish sounds like. If it sounds kind of Spanish but it's not then it's probably Portuguese.
exquisite_conundrum@reddit
100% I live in south florida. Spanish makes sense in my non Spanish speaking brain. Portuguese is another world of language. A Spanish speaking friend of mine once compared Portuguese to klingon. There really is a big difference between the two.
BenAfleckIsAnOkActor@reddit
The average American who have no interactions with anyone who speaks Spanish would just think Portuguese is a different kind of Spanish
english_mike69@reddit
Americans can’t tell the difference between Alaska and Egypt, how do you expect them to understand that Portuguese isn’t just Spanish spoken by someone with a bigly nasal infection and the betteristist vowels?
atheologist@reddit
They sound very different to me, but I grew up outside Boston (where there are several towns with large Portuguese speaking communities) and learned Spanish in school.
yellowdaisycoffee@reddit
I can, yes.
Slothnazi@reddit
Yes, Spanish is spoken more on the tip-of-the-tongue with a consistent cadence.
Portuguese is more gutteral and has a different spoken cadence than Spanish.
DizzyLead@reddit
Yes. In one of my earlier jobs, this was something we did regularly--we also had to distinguish between "Castilian" (from Spain) Spanish and Latin American Spanish, and while we had to classify Portuguese (POR) and Brazilian Portuguese (BPT), we didn't have to distinguish between them.
jackjackj8ck@reddit
Yeah Spanish sounds like this and Portuguese sounds like tHiS
Triscuitmeniscus@reddit
Lots of us can. I don't speak Spanish but I know a tiny bit and hear it often enough that Portuguese sounds like Spanish but not quite right, almost like if a French person was trying to imitate Spanish. If someone passed me on the street speaking Portuguese I probably wouldn't notice but if I was actually listening to them it would be apparent.
I think a lot of Americans would think Portuguese sounds like weird Spanish, just because we hear Spanish so much more and because many of us took at least some Spanish in school.
Radar1980@reddit
Yes but I grew up in an area that spoke Portuguese so I knew that before Spanish.
Time-Decision@reddit
If they are from an area with a decent enough Spanish speaking population yes. Pick a random person from Dallas or Tampa then likely yes. Denver or Salt Lake,? Less likely.
Perfect-Librarian895@reddit
Yes. Even though I don’t speak or understand more than a few words of Spanish, Portuguese has sounds that are very different.
evergreengoth@reddit
I'd imagine it depends on the American, but it's imagine the vast majority would know. A huge percentage of Americans speak Spanish. Also worth noting that not all Americans are white.
Massive_Dirt1577@reddit
Definitely.
I run into a lot of different Spanish accents but none of them remotely sound like Brazilian or continental Portuguese.
Portuguese sounds very “sing-song” to me for lack of a better description. Very pretty language.
FoxglovePattycakes@reddit
Such a weird question to me, as my dad's side are Spanish speakers, and my mom's side are Portuguese speakers. How could you possibly mistake the two?!
I feel like the vast majority of Americans have sufficient experience hearing Spanish that they'd immediately recognize it. Portuguese would clearly be not that, even if they recognized a word or two.
FormicaDinette33@reddit
I can, but I speak a decent amount of Spanish.
Ok-Neighborhood8855@reddit
We have a lot of Brazilian students where I work and they sound more Spanish but I can almost always tell them apart from the Central American crowd. In Portugal they definitely sound like they have a Russian accent, it was super surprising but also very cool.
Particular_Bet_5466@reddit
Yeah I mean I can but I know a lot have no idea what the difference is. There’s a difference in inflection when speaking and certain “sounds” although idk how else to describe it.
ChanFry@reddit
Many of us can, yes. I've lived in Texas for many years, so I hear Spanish regularly and have long been familiar with many Spanish words (note: usually with a Mexican accent, not Spain).
The first time I heard Portuguese, it was in a movie and I was an adult. It sounded like Spanish, but clearly was something else.
AncientGuy1950@reddit
Those US Citizens who speak either Spanish or Portuguese can.
band-of-horses@reddit
The main way I recognize protuguese is that it sounds like spanish but I cannot decipher more than 1 or 2 words, compared to deciphering 80% or so of spanish.
MuppetManiac@reddit
People who are unfamiliar with either language might not be able to, but anyone who has any familiarity with either can.
Atlas7993@reddit
I can only understand Spanish, and no Portugese. That's usually how I can tell.
Odd-Bullfrog7763@reddit
I can but im married to a Mexican woman.
AlmeMore@reddit
Yes.
MonkeyVine7@reddit
I probably couldnt
queerkidxx@reddit
In many parts of the US, Spanish is ever present. Where I live it’s rare to see signs that don’t also have Spanish translations. I hear Spanish constantly, just going about my life. Life is extremely bilingual here.
As such, it’s easy to recognize the difference. They have a really different rhythm and I’d never mistake Portuguese for Spanish. But I wouldn’t be able to tell Portuguese from, idk, any random European language I have little experience with.
But I imagine if you have less experience with Spanish you might not be able to tell the difference. I suspect though that’s a shrinking group of Americans.
xSparkShark@reddit
Barely
Icy-Whale-2253@reddit
I can
DogsBikesAndMovies@reddit
The USA is a very large and diverse nation. There's no correct answer to this question. Can I, a white American who speaks Spanish quite well, tell the difference between Spanish and Portuguese? Yes, it's quite easy for me, especially because I spent almost a decade working in a churrascaria where every single one of our gauchos spoke Portuguese as their native language.
But is the same true of all Americans? Of course not. All Americans haven't shared my life experiences. It's especially complicated because of the similarities between Spanish and Portuguese. At the workplace I mentioned, all of our gauchos spoke Portuguese natively, and English as their 2nd language. All of our bussers spoke Spanish as their first language, English as their 2nd. In spite of the fact that both our gauchos and bussers had English in common, they chose to communicate with each other in their native language. One of them speaking Spanish and the other speaking Portuguese, but they understood each other, for the most part. Every now and then they had to stop the conversation to ask for a clarification, but mostly they understood each other.
No_Entertainment1931@reddit
💯
Augen76@reddit
Yes.
I hear Spanish semi frequently, Portuguese is rare. I can spot Spanish within a couple of words even if I am by no means fluent.
Regular-Tell-108@reddit
I can tell the difference, but I have spent my entire life living in parts of the US that used to be Mexico (Texas, Arizona, California). I don't know if someone from the midwest would know for sure, for example. I can also pretty easily tell the difference between European and American versions of both of them.
tryptanfelle@reddit
The [ʒ] “zh” gives it away.
spontaneous-potato@reddit
My Mexican friend (Mexican-American) said that Portuguese sounds a lot like Spanish after downing 5 shots of tequila in one go. Our Portuguese friend (From Portugal) said he definitely agrees with that.
I’m Filipino-American and shared my experience with Tagalog and it basically just turned into a really poorly done Abbott and Costello “Who’s on First” skit when we were out drinking together at the bar.
bigoldgeek@reddit
If you don't throw an ao in there, no.
NightDragon8002@reddit
Yes but I don’t hear Portuguese that often so I didn’t know I could tell the difference until I watched The Secret Agent and I was like "this sounds like it should be Spanish but also I’m pretty sure it isn’t? What’s going on??“ and then I learned it’s a Portuguese movie lol
Ok_Arachnid1089@reddit
I can but I’m not your typical American
felixthecat59@reddit
The language spoken in the Azores sounds more guttral, kinda like Russian with an attitude. My dad's father was from San Miguel in the Azores, and his mom was born on the island of Maui, of Potguese parents.
Zebras-R-Evil@reddit
If it sounds like Spanish, but I don’t understand it, I know it’s Portuguese.
Last_Stand28@reddit
I cant really tell which is which but I can tell that they are different. Maybe thats just because tons of Portuguese immigrants have been showing up in my town over the past year or two and I have been hearing a lot of Portuguese.
Southern_Blue@reddit
I don't know if I could tell if someone is speaking Potugese or not. I could label it as 'not Spanish '.
OmightyOmo@reddit
The average American? No. It’s like speaking in tongues 😂
BigBlueMountainStar@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Sean Connery speaking Spanish.
Fejj1997@reddit
Yes, but I'm cheating as I grew up in a largely Spanish-speaking community, and have been to Europe multiple times including Portugal and Spain.
Portuguese sounds like me drunkenly practicing the 17 words of Spanish I know, lol
moekow415@reddit
Some of us.
ElefanteAmor@reddit
Only because I lived in the Azores and would be really confused by mainland Portuguese—let alone sounding fluent. At first I thought knowing a bit of Spanish would help but oh BOY was I wrong.
floopdyboop@reddit
Yeah
salbrown@reddit
They sound like very different languages to me personally, but I also grew up in a community that’s about 50/50 white and Latino and speak some Spanish myself. I’d imagine Americans who grew up hearing Spanish around them can probably tell the difference, but those who didn’t would have a harder time.
Appropriate-Food1757@reddit
Yes
possums101@reddit
Probably not the average American
PaleontologistNo2625@reddit
They don't even sound similar lol
CamiJay@reddit
I can tell the difference but only speak enough Spanish to survive. So most of the time I have no clue what they may be saying. But yes, I feel like most Americans would be able to tell the difference based on how the language sounds.
corrosivecanine@reddit
I’ve been to Brazil and it sounds nothing like the Mexican Spanish I hear in the US. European Portuguese also sounds distinct from both Spanish and Brazilian Portuguese from what I’ve heard of it. If someone were speaking Portuguese in a Mexican accent it might take me a while to catch on and I wouldn’t be surprised if monolingual english speakers familiar with Spanish couldn’t tell the difference, but just from the accents alone I can tell it’s not Spanish really quickly.
Smorgas-board@reddit
Yes
Ix_fromBetelgeuse7@reddit
When it's written I can definitely tell but I'm not positive if it was just spoken.
monkeypickle8@reddit
Depending on where you live, if you live in the middle of nowhere you probably can't tell the difference between Spanish and Mandarin, if you live in a diverse area you probably differentiate many different languages pretty easily. The NYC metro is one of the most diverse places in the world, meanwhile there are towns that literally only have white people.
Critical_Purple_8600@reddit
This one can’t. No experience with languages other than English
KJHagen@reddit
Many of us can, many others cannot. We're a very big and diverse country.
In my case, I grew up in an area of California that had a lot of Portuguese speakers. We even had a Portuguese radio station. I didn't learn to speak it, but I can usually identify it.
certifiablegeek@reddit
Sim, si...
Darkdragoon324@reddit
I can tell that they’re different. I’m not sure I’ve heard enough Portuguese to be able to recognize it as Portuguese if I just heard out in the wild though.
DazzleMeAlready@reddit
Yes, but that’s probably because I’ve lived in an area with a large population of Hispanics all my life.
Ryan_TX_85@reddit
I can't tell Spanish from Portuguese or Italian.
Unsolven@reddit
Americans are extremely familiar with Spanish. Even if they speak very little they know how it sounds, it’s not a strange language. Portuguese sounds straight up bizarre the first time you hear it.
Pfinnalicious@reddit
Even though the languages are fairly similar the cadence of Portuguese is sooo different.
I assume anyone who has even the slightest amount of exposure to either language can tell right away.
cjdstreet@reddit
Yes bit only cause Portugal is full of brazilians
jdmiller82@reddit
Yes, partly due to the fact that I've lived in Spanish-speaking and Portuguese-speaking countries.
___HeyGFY___@reddit
I can because I've been studying Spanish off and on for 40 years. I can also pretty much tell the difference between a Spanish accent and a Portuguese accent if someone's speaking English.
Historical-State-275@reddit
Like most people, some can, some can’t. There are 360m+ of us, and we live in a country larger than Europe. Not much we’re all alike in.
Louisiana_sitar_club@reddit
If it sounds like Spanish, but I don’t know any of the words it’s Portuguese
redjessa@reddit
I mean, I can. I don't know about all Americans, but Portuguese and Spanish sound very different to me.
Pale_Space_4144@reddit
Nope. Not unless they are familiar with one of those languages. But I'm sure the same could be said for anyone, not just Americans.
Misterarthuragain@reddit
Yes.
StOnEy333@reddit
They don’t sound a lot alike to me.
macoafi@reddit
I speak Spanish, so yeah. Telling Portuguese apart from Polish or Russian, though, that's the trick.
eugenesbluegenes@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Spanish that I can't understand.
Rays-R-Us@reddit
Spanish and Portuguese to me look similar but the sound of the spoken language is much different.
skeptical_phoenix@reddit
No. People here are severely overestimating the capability of the average American to decipher this. - signed, average American
GOTaSMALL1@reddit
Maybe it’s the two years of Spanish in High School (Peudo ir al bano por favor)… but I can tell the difference between a Spanish Spanish speaker and a Mexican Spanish speaker. Portuguese isn’t even in the ballpark.
No_Owl_8576@reddit
Yes. Eventually
Kraken0915@reddit
No.
collin-h@reddit
I took 2 years of Spanish in high school and I can usually tell when it's Portuguese because it sounds enough like Spanish that I should sorta know what's going on, but I don't and also it sounds like random French words thrown in there every now and then.
phydaux4242@reddit
Americans can barely understand English
cbizzle85@reddit
Yes, thank you is not the same in those languages. To me Portuguese sounds like Spanish mixed with French and Romanian. Different vibe for sure.
furie1335@reddit
yes
redmambo_no6@reddit
My GF must be one of the few Brazilians who can’t speak Portuguese (she’s from Ohio).
InevitableRhubarb232@reddit
Yes absolutely.
rollerfedora@reddit
When we hear other languages, we can tell if something is “off” between them. Accents? No clue. We think anyone speaking English without an Americanized accent is lumped into “Brit” territory.
FinsFan305@reddit
Yes, I live in South Florida.
Forsythia77@reddit
Portuguese is what happens when Spanish French and Italian have an orgy baby.
jambajuiceofficial@reddit
Yes
Certain-Monitor5304@reddit
Que?
WhichWitch9402@reddit
Many Americans cannot tell the difference between proper English (correct grammar, verb tense, etc.) and bad English.
I don’t think as a whole they’d be able to tell the difference.
Princessformidable@reddit
My partner and I were very drunk at a music festival and got asked to be interviewed by a Portuguese influencer. My partner decided Spanish was close enough. I'm not shocked it didn't get posted but I would have loved to see it lol.
bansidhecry@reddit
Yes. At least I can. They do not sound anything alike.
EllieIsDone@reddit
Spanish is not my native language (same with majority of u.s citizens) but Spanish and Portuguese look very very similar when reading. It’s like reading an article in Scot’s.
Speaking is a whole nother story.
Pizzarocco@reddit
Easy! Portuguese sounds like Spanish spoken by a Russian dude.
Bulky_Employ_4259@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Spanish but weird.
Walksuphills@reddit
I'd like to think I understand enough Spanish to tell the difference, but it might depend on the speed and accent. I've heard Brazilians and Portuguese people speak to each other, and they sound very different to me.
ElephantCares@reddit
I can, but I learned most of my Spanish in Spain and spent time in Portugal. I'm not sure most would.
CanIOpenMyEyesYet@reddit
Every time I don't recognize the language being spoken it's almost always Portuguese.
Fantastic-Bit7657@reddit
Growing up in Massachusetts and working in restaurants, I can absolutely tell the difference. I’d like to think most Americans could tell the difference but I bet there’s a good amount that cannot.
humble-meercat@reddit
Every time I hear Portuguese I always wonder what the heck I’m hearing and it takes me a few minutes to realize. Then I always kicking myself for wondering why I didn’t realize it. It sounds almost Eastern European to me in a way.
Spanish I recognize right away even though I only know a few words. I can even pick out accents, like I think Chileans and Colombians have the most beautiful spanish accents…
MollyOMalley99@reddit
Because I can speak Spanish (poorly), yes.
Can you tell the difference between two similar-sounding languages that you do not speak? Russian/Ukrainian? Mandarin/Cantonese?
Psyko_sissy23@reddit
I guess it depends on how much a person interacts with each group. I live in the southwest, I understand a lot of Spanish, but don't speak it very well anymore. I used to know a Brazilian family when I was younger. Depending on what they are saying, I would realize it's not Spanish.
djninjacat11649@reddit
On average? Maybe? I speak Spanish and even then sometimes it can take me a bit to realize it is Portuguese and not just me failing to understand an accent
frisky_husky@reddit
I used to live in Massachusetts, which has both a large Hispanic population and the largest Lusophone population in the US. It is very easy to tell the difference.
abhainn13@reddit
Any time I hear a language, and I can tell it’s a Romance language, but I have NO IDEA what it is, it’s Portuguese.
ThreeRacoonz@reddit
I speak someone Spanish, so if I hear something that I can almost understand, it is Portuguese.
GurProfessional9534@reddit
The average American probably doesn’t even know Portuguese is a language.
Altruistic_Error_832@reddit
Many probably would, being conversational in Spanish is pretty common, particularly in the southwestern US. As someone from Minnesota who has never studied Spanish beyond extreme basics I'd be relying more on identifying the Brazilian accent than necessarily being able to tell the difference between Portuguese and Spanish.
ElBosque91@reddit
I can, but I also live in South Texas and I’ve heard people speaking Spanish almost daily for my entire life. So the difference is pretty clear when I hear Portuguese
faifai1337@reddit
Spanish is all spiky and Portuguese sounds like mushy Italian.
Dapper_Cantaloupe_34@reddit
I dated a guy from Brazil and whenever he spoke Portuguese it honestly sounded more like Russian than Spanish.
SnooPineapples280@reddit
Many of us, yes
DeliciousMoments@reddit
I'm going to make an assumption that since Spanish is very widely spoken in the US, a large number of people would be able to identify Spanish, but would maybe not know the other language is Portuguese. They'd probably just know it's not Spanish.
Khajiit_Has_Upvotes@reddit
It's this. I know some Spanish. I can't identify exactly which language Portuguese is when I hear it spoken, but I know it's not-spanish.
DonJovar@reddit
Some can, but I'll bet most can't.
Rattlingplates@reddit
I can only because I understand Spanish and Portuguese. Sounds crazy as fuck to me.
UncomfyPerspective@reddit
I can understand Spanish well enough, but I played World of Warcraft in 2007 and my entire guild aside from me spoke Brazilian Portuguese.
They'd go over all the fight strategies in Portuguese, then run it back for me in English.
I can tell you for certain that even though I understand Spanish to a level that gets me by, I had no clue what they were saying in Portuguese.
So for that alone I would say yes, I can tell the difference when spoken.
(Side note, occasionally someone would get disconnected, and then all of our Brazilian members would get the boot too. We joked many times that we had to cancel raid night because "Brazil is offline".)
No_Sorbet1634@reddit
I would say yes, they sound kinda similar and share many words or some that are close enough but not enough to be mistaken. That said I’ve been around Spanish pretty much all my life so the first time I heard Portuguese it sounded like a Spanish version of pig Latin, in a vastly distinct accent.
Pitiful_Bunch_2290@reddit
Personally? Nope.
ReeMayRe@reddit
I can but I come from a big diverse city
Trypt2k@reddit
Instantly.
pikkdogs@reddit
Depends. MOst people in North Dakota? Nope. Most people in California? Probably.
resiyun@reddit
If they speak either of them then yes
Grounds4TheSubstain@reddit
Between Spanish and what now?
Early_Clerk7900@reddit
Americans in general is a lot of different people. Millions of us speak Spanish so yes.
PrimaryHighlight5617@reddit
I can. Portuguese sounds like a Canadian Frenchman trying to speak Spanish.
shootingstar527@reddit
I had a college roommate who spoke Portuguese to her parents on the phone all the time and it sounds like Russian to me. I don’t really speak Spanish but I can understand a fair amount. I understand zero Portuguese.
CockroachNo2540@reddit
I can, but it somewhat depends on how much/what is said because certain words/phrases are pretty much identical sounding (but usually very different written).
BasedTaco_69@reddit
Some can. Weird question
sailorsonia@reddit
A lot of Americans speak Spanish, so I hope so.
hairball45@reddit
Some of us can, especially if we have a bit of experience with one or the other. I'd guess for most the answer is NO. Unfortunately there's also a pretty good portion of the population who can't recognize either one nor tell them from any other language, believing just about anything is "Mexican".
xxxfashionfreakxxx@reddit
Yes. Grew up around Spanish speakers and know a little. Can definitely tell the difference between Portuguese. Also have know a few Brazilians.
Glittering-Silver402@reddit
Well I speak Spanish so si, obrigada.
AnitaIvanaMartini@reddit
Yes, they sound like two different languages. They both sound like Romance languages, but Portuguese is less staccato and has gentler “sh” sounds. It can sometimes sound a bit like French, except I can’t understand it. I speak French.
Consistent-Ad-6506@reddit
Yes
Lurkalope@reddit
20% of the US population is Latino. Most of them are citizens. Americans. Don't just say "Americans" when you really mean non-hispanic Americans.
I rarely hear Portuguese, but I know enough Spanish words and phrases to deduce that I'm hearing a different but pretty similar romance language, presumably Portuguese.
imzadi111@reddit
Most likely. In the US Spanish is the second most spoken language. I speak Spanish and French and Italian passably. While I can pick up some spoken Portuguese and read some, it is quite different to my ear than the others.
LandofRy@reddit
Yeah to me they sound very different. Portuguese sounds more "vowel-y" I guess? Spanish sounds closer to Italian pronunciation and cadence.
Most of my exposure comes from North/South American dialects of both languages though
TeamTurnus@reddit
Im sure lots of Americans can, notably those who either speak Spanish as a first or secondary language, or who just have exposure to it. There's at least 45 million (low estimate) people who can speak Spanish in America, so Id imagine they'd know when it was in fact Portuguese
I personally would struggle cause I dont speak any Spanish, even if I hear it from time to time.
SmoovCatto@reddit
in big cities of course
willtag70@reddit
I've been to Brazil, Portugal, Spain, and have heard lots of Spanish spoken. It's easy to tell the difference. I'd actually been to Brazil before Portugal and was quite surprised at how different Portuguese sounds, which is much more Slavic sounding than spoken in Brazil.
TheLonelySnail@reddit
Yes, but I live in SoCal and get exposed to more Spanish than most
shrlzi@reddit
Hahaha most us people don’t even know there is a difference
SassyMoron@reddit
Whenever I hear someone speaking a language and I can't figure out what the hell it is it turns out it's portuges
Algae_Mission@reddit
I lived in Florida for a while so I can. Most Americans who don’t know some Spanish or Portuguese? Probably not right away.
msbshow@reddit
I can bc I speak Spanish
alwaysboopthesnoot@reddit
I can. Lots of Brazilians and Puerto Rucans around here. There’s a difference and it’s a big one.
I think Portuguese sounds more like Romanian and Puerto Rican Spanish sounds like Mexican Spanish—only it is much faster and much more staccato. I can tell Cuban Spanish from Colombian, too.
Erdos_Helia@reddit
Well I speak Spanish...so yes.
notapunk@reddit
If I was just randomly walking/standing by a group speaking - probably not, but if I took a moment to listen a bit most likely yeah.
They are similar enough that my Brazilian friends learned the hard way that cussing out people under your breath in Portuguese isn't safe in a place where Spanish is common
GemarD00f@reddit
nope, ive never heard portugese
YardSardonyx@reddit
Yes, but I live in a city with an astronomical amount of Puerto Ricans and Brazilians. I would assume the average American who does not hear them a lot cannot differentiate.
DepthPuzzleheaded494@reddit
Yes
jk_pens@reddit
I can for sure, but I speak a bit of Spanish and live in an area with a lot of Spanish speakers and have known a few Brazilians.
John_Tacos@reddit
I can’t tell if someone is speaking Spanish I don’t know or Portuguese, but I know enough Spanish to identify it in most cases.
sleepypossumster@reddit
I always think Portuguese sounds a little like a cross between Spanish and Italian, so, in other words, like Spanish, but also not like Spanish...
Sad-Attitude8453@reddit
I grew up on the West Coast hearing only Spanish being spoken. Then I moved to the East Coast and the first time I heard someone speaking Portuguese I thought I was hearing alien gibberish. I had to stop and eavesdrop for a bit, trying to figure out what language it was.
MassConsumer1984@reddit
Yes, yes we can.
ProfessionalBat8843@reddit
When I first heard Portuguese I thought it sounded like a combination of Spanish, French, and Italian.
VinceP312@reddit
Yes. Because I understand some Spanish and no Portuguese.
Starfoxmarioidiot@reddit
Most of the time. Sometimes someone has a regional accent that blurs the line.
koboldkiller@reddit
I can, but only because I speak a bit of Spanish and understand enough Italian to know it's neither of those. I haven't studied Italian, but it's considerably easier for me to understand that than Portuguese by hearing it or reading.
paka96819@reddit
Yes. Portuguese is more French to me.
Autisticspidermann@reddit
I can. I may not be able to tell its Portuguese immediately, but i would know its not Spanish
SeaBass1690@reddit
A fair amount of Americans know at least a few words in Spanish from school, especially in the southwest, Texas, California or in big cities where there are lots of Spanish speakers will know. But in areas with fewer Spanish speakers may not.
Poster_Nutbag207@reddit
Portuguese sounds like an injured cat speaking Spanish
johnnysauce78@reddit
Not fluent in either but I think I can tell the difference
Spanish sounds crispier? Portuguese more nasally, like Spanish speaker eating peanut butter
TumbleFairbottom@reddit
Yes
Can you tell the difference between French and Spanish?
Mirabeaux1789@reddit
Brazilian Portuguese sounded like “off” Spanish to me the first times I encountered it irl. Portuguese Portuguese is very hard to place if you have no experience with it. It sounds like Polish but also Russian but doubtfully romance?
sneezyailurophile@reddit
This American can. But I speak both and my Portuguese has a pronounced Spanish accent.
Riri004@reddit
lol. Yes.
steely_92@reddit
Yes, I think they sound pretty different.
The ones I have a hard time differentiating are a lot of the Balkin languages. They all sound really similar to me.
Outrageous_Garden586@reddit
I absolutely can. I don’t know about anyone else.
admseven@reddit
Only in that I understand a little Spanish and no Portuguese. So if it sounds like Spanish but I can’t even pick out any familiar words, it’s Portuguese.
Fragrant-Top2962@reddit
I can, but that is because i live in an area that has both Spanish and Portuguese speakers. Ironically, I had a high school Spanish teacher who was a native Portuguese speaker.
La_Rata_de_Pizza@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Spanish gibberish with “ao” and “dzo” sounds
killingourbraincells@reddit
If the portuguese is coming from someone form Portugal, yes. If it's from a Brazillian, makes it a little harder. I'll try conversing in Spanish and then I get hit with the "Brasil!!!". I worked in the Florida Mall when I was a teen, you could always tell the Brazilians tho. They carry around like 10 suitcases.
No_Appearance4463@reddit
It takes me a minute to hear the difference.
rsvihla@reddit
I can.
Rj924@reddit
I studied Spanish for 6 years, 17 years ago, am out of practice, and was never fluent. I can tell.
MrsBeauregardless@reddit
Yes. The Portuguese accent sounds almost Russian, and “-os” is pronounced “oosh” as opposed to “ose”, which is how that letter combination is pronounced in Spanish.
Flimsy_Equal8841@reddit
Yes. We hear plenty of Spanish so we can tell.
PositiveChi@reddit
No (español)
No_name_Johnson@reddit
Não (Portuguese)
fierce_turtle_duck@reddit
Typically but I've certainly been bamboozled by Brazilians speaking Portuguese and my brain just wondering why the Spanish sounds 'wrong' 😂
likeschemistry@reddit
I can, but even though I haven’t spoken Spanish in 20 years I still remember a good chunk of normal convo, verbs, etc and I’m somewhat familiar with Portuguese due to having a Brazilian foreign exchange student and visiting Brazil twice for a total of 9 weeks.
freddbare@reddit
Big Brazilian population near me. A little Spanish and some German help some but as long as you get "I'm Brazil we drink much tequila" and "here we drink much tequila" you are good to go for a fun night
Bookworm1254@reddit
This American can.
ThePunLexicon@reddit
Yesnt? Spanish is identifiable to me because I understand it at a very simple level. Portuguese sounds LIKE spanish but not quite and I dont understand a word of it and that's the giveaway. Or it also sounds a bit like french and spanish had a baby to me too.
Jorost@reddit
Definitely. They sound very different. Portuguese almost sounds like a Slavic language if you aren't used to it.
Avery_Thorn@reddit
I think a lot of Americans would realize that it's Portuguese after trying to figure out why they can't understand any of it and confirming that they are not having a stroke.
(I suppose there are some Americans who would go about it opposite, but there are a LOT more Americans who speak at least a little bit of Spanish than Portuguese.)
Norwester77@reddit
Yes, they sound very different. Brazilian and European Portuguese sound pretty different, too.
machagogo@reddit
Can't speak for all but I can. Spanish speaking wife, lot's or Portuguese and Brazilian people in my relative area.
gutclutterminor@reddit
Portuguese is like Spanish with a French flair. Being from the southwest, it clearly stands out from Spanish.
Patient-Hovercraft48@reddit
This answer is going to vary widely depending on a number of factors- including location. The US is a big place. Lots of folks in the US live over 1000 miles from anywhere where another language is the primary one used. In those places fewer folks will know the difference.
In places in the southwest near Mexico (for example) spansh is often more commonly spoken, and folks will be more likely to notice a difference
pastrymom@reddit
Yes. Many of us speak Spanish in my area, myself included.
HectorsMascara@reddit
Yeah, I actually studied Spanish from 4th through 12th grade in the '80s and '90s (in the northeastern US). Doesn't seem like kids do that anymore, especially in the states closest to Mexico. Ridiculous.
animalisticneeds@reddit
Well I'm first generation American from a Cuban immigrant, so I can definitely tell the difference. I can also tell the difference when people speak English but have an accent whether they speak Portuguese or Spanish as their native tongue.
Administrative_Elk66@reddit
Americans who have familiarity with Spanish will recognize Portuguese as something different. I have a good ear for languages, but I have to listen longer before I recognize something as Portuguese vs Russian
Responsible-Fun4303@reddit
I studied Spanish in middle school, high school and throughout college. I found once I could read Portuguese (thought it was Spanish with horrible grammar lol) only to find it was Portuguese. My professor told me I would never be able to understand it if it was spoken though. So I probably could? But it’s because I studied one of the languages for years not everyone studies Spanish.
OdinNW@reddit
Yes, as someone that grew up in Southern California, Spanish was/is super common. Although I don’t know if I could tell you if someone was speaking Portuguese that it was Portuguese. But I could tell you it wasn’t Spanish.
DoTheRightThing1953@reddit
I can. I don't speak Spanish but I know enough and I've heard enough to recognize it but Portuguese is very different.
SabresBills69@reddit
I see Spanish and Italian has much more closer than Portuguese and Spanish
Dunnoaboutu@reddit
I’m not sure I’ve heard anyone speak Portuguese in person, so I would assume my answer would be no.
Bake_knit_plant@reddit
I sure can - but I speak semi fluent Spanish so that might have something to do with it. I was just in Argentina and Uruguay for a month and ran into quite a few people who spoke portuguese. It was obvious from the time they opened their mouth.
CommitteeofMountains@reddit
Portuguese accents can sound very Russian to American ears.
jtfjtf@reddit
Yes, Portuguese sounds distinct whether it's Portugal Portuguese or Brazilian Portuguese.
gilana@reddit
I speak a very little bit of Spanish, and I can usually recognize Portuguese because it sounds like I should be able to understand it but I can't. Also it sounds a lot more liquid than any other languages I understand -- not sure how to explain that but that's how it sounds to me!
Significant-Dance-43@reddit
Yes. Easily.
HegemonNYC@reddit
Americans are more likely than most other nations to have studied Spanish at least a little, to hear it often, or even to have family who speaks fluently. So in gonna say yes, more so than almost any other non-Spanish or Romance language speaking country.
whatafuckinusername@reddit
They may not be able to tell which is which, but they absolutely should be able to tell them apart.
nsnyder@reddit
Yes. Spanish and Italian is harder, Portuguese sounds very different, with way more vowel sounds, and sometimes almost kinda Slavic.
norecordofwrong@reddit
Yup. It sounds like drunk Spanish at a distance and then as you get closer you realize it isn’t.
Frenchitwist@reddit
Yes. I’m proficient, but not fluent, in Spanish so hearing Portuguese fucks me up. Listening to Portuguese makes me think I’ve somehow lost all my spanish, and then I remember “no, wait. That’s just that language that sounds like a bunch of really drunk Colombians and Mexicans got together and partied”
Wendora15@reddit
I can. 🤔 I would assume most can, but I’d probably be assuming wrong. For reference, I speak English and Italian and just a little Spanish and French.
elviswasmurdered@reddit
Yes. But I took 3 years of Spanish classes and also worked part time in high school at a restaurant with Brazilian and Mexican coworkers so I heard a lot of both. While I don't understand Portuguese (only a few words here and there) and I have lost 90% of my Spanish skills, I can hear the difference. That being said, sometimes there are people who speak Spanish who speak a regional slang or dialect or have a strong accent and I would probably not be able to tell what language they're speaking lol.
lyralady@reddit
Approximately 45 million Americans speak Spanish at home, and estimates for broader categories (native, heritage, and second-language speakers) are more like 59 million. So about 14-18% of all Americans definitively know that Portuguese isn't Spanish.
MarsupialPresent7700@reddit
I can, but that’s because I speak Spanish.
Hailsabrina@reddit
I can only because my friend from France spoke French and Portuguese. I can tell Spanish and Portuguese apart.
mothramydear@reddit
I usually can, but my great grandparents were Portuguese immigrants and my grandpa was fluent.
Many_Inevitable_6803@reddit
I can tell it’s not quite Spanish
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit
Almost all the time. But I am in California where the Spanish normally spoken is from Mexico. There’s immigrants here from both Mexico and Brazil; the two languages, to my ears, are very different.
Xitztlacayotl@reddit
I don't know, can Norwegians tell the difference between Spanish and Portuguese?
Yes if they familiarized themselves beforehand. If not then I guess not. Same works for any language and ethnicity.
islandurp@reddit
I grew up in the Miami area so I hear Spanish everyday but don't speak a lot of it. I can't really explain how, but I can tell the difference between Portuguese (Brazilian) and Spanish pretty easily.
mish_munasiba@reddit
I can, but I'm kind of a language nerd. Portuguese sounds like Spanish with a heavy Russian accent to me for some reason.
IJustWorkHere000c@reddit
This American can. Portuguese sounds almost Russian.
Hillbillygeek1981@reddit
I've known quite a few of my countrymen that hear either and immediately ask "You speak Mexican?" so I have my doubts. Outside a few large communities of people of Brazilian origin it's odd for your average American to encounter Portuguese in the wild anyway.
Arievan@reddit
It will be like I am watching something with subtitles and I'll be like wait why does their Spanish sound weird??? I don't recognize any of these words? And my husband will be like "I think they are speaking Portuguese" and it makes a lot more sense after that lol. But really I only speak English and I can tell mexican accent (dialect?) and Spanish from Europe apart easier than I can tell Portuguese and Spanish apart.
JonMatrix@reddit
Yeah kind of. For me it’s more like I can tell a language isn’t Spanish more I can instantly recognize Portuguese.
Desertswampfrog-99@reddit
It sounds like Spanish speakers speaking French or Italian.
charlieq46@reddit
I hear Spanish a lot, but I usually have to wait for something to sound "weird" to realize it's Portuguese which doesn't always happen.
Informal_Persimmon7@reddit
I can tell the difference but I also understand a little Spanish. I can also tell the difference between them and Romanian but it's because there's an occasional Russian word in there ..like "da."
bigsphinxofquartz@reddit
I know varying amounts of both, so yes. A common sentiment that I hear among Americans is that Portuguese "sounds like Spanish with a Russian accent" and I don't know enough about linguistics to understand why, but I'm sure that the answer has nothing to do with Russia or Slavic language families.
watchandsee13@reddit
Absolutely
My boss is married to a Brazilian lady and she and her friends speak Portuguese regularly
I have a small idea what they are saying because I can keep up with verbal communication in Spanish, but Portuguese is a lot different and I can’t keep up
She speaks five languages and prefers Portuguese over English, French, Spanish and Italian
WillDupage@reddit
Portuguese has always sounded to me like Spanish being spoken by a Russian.
zignut66@reddit
I’m willing to bet most Americans are more familiar with Brazilian Portuguese, which bears a greater phonetic resemblance to most Spanish dialects heard around the States.
I speak decent Spanish and when I visited Portugal years ago, for literally hours in Lisboa I wondered, “Why are there so many Russians everywhere??” The dialect was that different to my ear (and sounded nothing like Spanish).
twineandtwig@reddit
Yes. At least in most parts of the country.
Some people may not know it’s specifically Portuguese but many people would.
Portuguese has a different cadence and rhythm. As well, Spanish is more phonetic than Portuguese.
Automatic-Arm-532@reddit
Smart ones can. So very few.
peachywthasideofkeen@reddit
I can but I'm fluent in Spanish lol they sound very different to me.
Esmar_Renacette@reddit
About 50 million Americans speak Spanish fluently, so at least they would be able to.
I don’t, but cousin does. I’d probably just ask her.
jordynbebus8@reddit
I definity can. But the average person probably not.
FixergirlAK@reddit
I absolutely can, but I speak Spanish. I understand Portuguese to some extent, but no matter how hard I try I can't speak it. My brain flips over to Spanish.
hungaryboii@reddit
I worked with some Portuguese guys a while back, only knew they were speaking it because I used to live in Europe and had Portuguese friends
Silgad_@reddit
Yes, but only during the most recent two decades because of MMA and Brazilian jiujitsu.
Coidzor@reddit
Depends on the region and the individual's level of exposure to Spanish.
GoodDecision@reddit
Yes. It sounds like speaking spanish while holding a small potato in your mouth. Very distinct.
CornyOne@reddit
I can, but I have studied BJJ under Brasilians for 18 years, typical Americans who don't know either language probably could not
Living_Fig_6386@reddit
A little over 20% of Americans speak at least some Spanish and they will typically be able to tell if they listen. For what it is worth, Spanish is very common in the US, and Portuguese much less so. I you live in Rhode Island, parts of Newark NJ, the San Joaquin Valley or San Jose in CA, the Fall River / New Bedford area of MA, folks probably hear a lot of Brazilian Portuguese and can fairly easily differentiate it from Spanish if they made an effort.
Minute-Frame-8060@reddit
Yes.
uglytruthshurts@reddit
Only the ones who care to understand languages. Like I can tell the difference for example because I study languages. However, a lot of people don't study languages and take their mandatory classes in high school or college and never use it.
ArkansasTravelier@reddit
Very much so, especially Brazilian Portuguese and Mexican Spanish (the kind id run into the most)
I might struggle more with original European Portuguese and Spanish but that’s not something id run into.
Portuguese almost has the roughness and hard sounds of a Slavic language to my ears when Spanish very much does not, depending on accents I’d be more likely to confuse Spanish and Italian tbh
lanikuikawa@reddit
as a californian who hears spanish all the time, yes. portugese sounds very unique and unusual to me because i never hear it.
kinnikinnick321@reddit
Probably 50/50. I would bet a higher percentage in the perimeter coastal states would be able to identify purely based on general immigration and exposure.
claudiatiedemann@reddit
Yes, but this might not be true for Americans who don’t live in areas where Spanish is common and who didn’t study Spanish in school.
Cerulean_IsFancyBlue@reddit
Spoken? Not very likely. I’m not that great in Spanish in the first place, and I sometimes get befuddled by unfamiliar dialects of Spanish. I could probably be fooled by Italian at least for a little bit, although the prosody is usually a giveaway.
Written, 100% given a paragraph.
Important-Trifle-411@reddit
I can, but I grew up next to Little Portugal.
cornfarm96@reddit
Yes. I can’t speak either, but I’ve worked alongside both Spanish speakers and Portuguese speakers, and they sound very different to me, so I’d assume other people who’ve heard both would be able to tell the difference.
LadybuggingLB@reddit
Yes. But I’m one of many, many Americans who speak Spanish.
EagleEyezzzzz@reddit
I can, but I speak Spanish.
I have heard Portuguese described as a drunk Italian trying to speak Spanish, and that's always what I think of when I hear it lmao.
ShootinTheBreez@reddit
Yes. Spanish is a commonly used language in the US. Portuguese is not.
h0lych4in@reddit
they sound very different to me and portuguese uses a bit of a different accent that is more nasally
chelseyrotic@reddit
Yes, but I like to think I'm well-versed in languages and accents.
cmcrich@reddit
I can, but I heard both when I lived in Massachusetts.
Ordinary_Map_5000@reddit
Sadly, the last time someone spoke Portuguese to me I thought it was Spanish. I’ve hardly been exposed to Portuguese and to be fair there are a lot of different Spanish dialects and accents. Still, I was embarrassed I mistook it
Maddad_666@reddit
Yes
IHaveBoxerDogs@reddit
Yes, but I’ve taken a lot of Spanish, grew up in SoCal, and have traveled in Spain and Latin America. Portuguese sounds completely different to me.
NotTheMariner@reddit
Only if it’s continental Portuguese
Tippacanoe@reddit
There’s a gigantic amount of Spanish speakers in the US so they would.
curlyhairweirdo@reddit
Not if they don't speak Spanish or Portuguese
AndreaTwerk@reddit
I teach in a high school with a lot of students from Brazil, Cape Verde, Dominican Republic and Central America. I can almost never tell the difference between Portuguese and Spanish - though Cape Verdean Creole does have a distinctive sound to it that is noticeably different.
The languages are close enough that the students learn to understand each other faster than they learn English and will have full conversations where one is speaking Spanish, the other responds in Portuguese and is understood.
Silkyiniquity@reddit
Yes
ToeLimbaugh@reddit
I've heard some Portuguese speakers who somehow have a Spanish accent when they speak it, but most people sound QUITE different.
My guess
Older folks mostly can't tell
But Most younger folks can tell(most or close to a majority)
ArsenalinAlabama3428@reddit
Yes, 100%. Most Portuguese sounds closer to Russian when it's spoken. Nothing like Spanish at all.
peterpeterllini@reddit
I would, but I've been studying spanish for years and recently started picking up on portuguese.
AffectionateWay5783@reddit
Where I live, yes. Large Brazilian population so I’ve worked with enough Portuguese speaker to be able to tell. Bom dia!
OpposumMyPossum@reddit
Absolutely. Portuguese (in Portugal) has some gutteral German sounds.
ginger_bird@reddit
Spoken Portuguese, yes. Written Portuguese, not so much. Portuguese sounds vaguely Russian to me.
seau_de_beurre@reddit
Yeah. A lot of us speak Spanish. I wouldn’t have recognized Portuguese vs another language until I visited Portugal though.
natttgeo@reddit
Yes. I grew up in Philadelphia, plenty of folks here who speak Portuguese.
alottanamesweretaken@reddit
I can’t. My uncle would say that if they’re wearing construction gear, it’s Spanish, and if they’re wearing cooking gear, it’s Portuguese. My uncle is a little funny and a lot shitty.
Ok_Concentrate4461@reddit
I have a deep familiarity with Spanish, having studied it all through high school and some in college. And while I can’t speak very well anymore, I’m familiar enough with it that I can tell if something is not Spanish.
Tight_Steak_232@reddit
Most Americans cannot speak a second language let alone discern between two similar sounding languages. Our nation is not concerned about educating us. We are the new third world.
jessek@reddit
I can because I can’t understand Portuguese.
hello_sweetie_@reddit
To me, only knowing very very basic Spanish and absolutely zero Portuguese, Portuguese sounds a lot more...smushy? Like speaking in cursive with stuff in your mouth? than Spanish does, and I can recognize when a word/sentence/phrase ends in Spanish a lot easier. Probably part of that is just more familiarity, though.
sportzanimal@reddit
I don't think I've ever heard Portuguese spoken, but I'd guess they would sound essentially the same to me... (have a tiny bit of Spanish knowledge but not really).
sandbagger45@reddit
Yes I speak Spanish. However I think there will be some of us who don’t know what Portuguese sounds like.
siestarrific@reddit
I can but not every single American could lol
jguerrer@reddit
Most people who live in big cities in the US have at least a passing understanding of Spanish--so yes they could tell the difference. So could pretty much anyone in Texas, Cali, Arizona, Florida, or New York.
A rural resident of, say, Idaho? Probably not.
cyvaquero@reddit
This one can but I’m a white guy who happened to be stationed in Spain for a few years, was married to a Colombian, and has lived in border states for almost twenty years.
Even if you don’t speak either, if you are around it you’ll recognize the similarly latin rooted words with different pronunciations.
No_Report_4781@reddit
Yes
Sorry-Ad-1169@reddit
Kinda? I can't explain it. Its like an accent over the Spanish. Maybe like slang?
gnartothecore@reddit
I can, but I also live in south Florida and I'm used to hearing both languages spoken regularly.
Mushroom-2906@reddit
This American can, certainly. The sounds are quite different.
ramblingMess@reddit
I’m usually not able to tell for the first few words or sentences, but I know enough Spanish to know what not-Spanish sounds like and can figure it out before too long.
houdini31@reddit
Not even close
AToastedRavioli@reddit
I’d guess the majority cannot
ForestWayfarer@reddit
Yes, absolutely. They have a similar vocabulary, but sound completely different to me. If anything, Portuguese sometimes sounds almost-Russian (I do speak Russian), despite being a vastly different language
apcb4@reddit
I doubt I could, but most Americans speak at least some Spanish (whether because they are Hispanic/live in a heavily Hispanic area or because they took it in high school) so I’m sure they could figure out pretty quickly that it’s not Spanish. Unfortunately I thought French would be more glamorous when I was in high school, so I’m pretty useless with Spanish.
MarketEconomist@reddit
Not really an American thing.
Very few people who don't speak either Spanish or Portuguese can tell the difference. Especially in spoken form.
yyythoo@reddit
I would be able to tell. But I’m from South Florida and can speak a decent amount of Spanish
pgm123@reddit
In my experience, Americans recognize Spanish is being spoken and can't always identify Portuguese. Spanish is much more commonly heard.
Electronic-Clock5867@reddit
No hablo espanol. Soy UN inodoro.
SassyGirl0202@reddit
Yes different dialects
IsThisDecent@reddit
Yes definitely.
AlarmingAttention151@reddit
I can. I think most could tell that they’re different languages. They’d know that Spanish is Spanish, but probably not recognize Portuguese. We don’t hear a lot of it here.
blurrysasquatch@reddit
Absolutely, I speak conversational Spanish and Portuguese is different sounding to me. It's a lot of hollow noises on the phs and the a sound, there's also the R sound which gets swallowed and turned into an H. If I didn't already know how to speak Spanish then it would be much harder
CantCreateUsernames@reddit
Americans who have taken Spanish classes (and paid attention in them) and/or live in areas where a plurality or majority of the population is Spanish speakers (e.g., Los Angeles) may be able to. However, if I were to guess, most probably would not be able to tell the difference at first. Maybe after hearing it for a while, but not at first.
Helpful-Winner-8300@reddit
Spanish is not uncommon to encounter in American, even if you don't speak a word of it. Portuguese rarely. Especially Brazilian Portuguese sounds quite unfamiliar to me - it often takes me a moment to even realize it's a romance language being spoken.
d3ut1tta@reddit
I think for some of us that particularly live in more Spanish-speaking dense areas (which is a lot of parts of the US), you can sort of pick up on the nuance that when someone speaking Portuguese is speaking something different, but we can't always quite put our finger quite on what it is.
I grew up (not natively Spanish speaking) in California where there's a lot of Mexican and South American Spanish spoken and had a coworker that spoke Portuguese (from Portugal, not Brazil). There's definitely an intonation difference of Portuguese.
Sad-Bunch-9937@reddit
lol no.
17Girl4Life@reddit
Yes, but just because I watch an awful lot of European football and have heard enough interviews in each to be able to hear the difference
Ok-Tackle-5128@reddit
No, not really. Most would just think that Portuguese is a Spanish dialogue.
toomanyracistshere@reddit
I certainly can, but Spanish is pretty commonly spoken here in California. Portuguese is very hard for me to place when I hear it. It looks a lot like Spanish written down, but sounds to me like French, Spanish and a little bit of something Slavic all mixed together.
Impressive_Ad8715@reddit
I think if you have any basic knowledge of Spanish (which a lot of American do because many take it in school, even if a very basic level) or have any exposure to hearing Spanish being spoken, you can definitely tell. They sound very different…
blueeyedbrainiac@reddit
Probably those that can speak Spanish or are around a lot of Spanish. But not every American for sure
mckenzie_keith@reddit
Where I live a lot of people (way more than 50 percent) speak some spanish. So if they heard someone speaking portuguese, they would know it was not spanish.
Pitiful_Ad2397@reddit
Definitely, though I grew up in MA with a lot of Spanish & Portuguese speakers
plutoniumwhisky@reddit
I can, but only because my boyfriend is Portuguese so I know what it sounds like.
kooboomz@reddit
I can. Non-spaish and non-portuguese speaker here btw.
vanchica@reddit
Portuguese and Latin-American Americans can.
spice_weasel@reddit
Depends on the American, and how fluent they are in either of those languages.
I typically figure it out via “…wow, my Spanish is a lot worse than I thought. Oh wait, no, that’s Portuguese.”
iswintercomingornot_@reddit
I know I can. Portuguese sounds like it has French mixed in.
kabekew@reddit
Yes
JosieZee@reddit
Yes. Portuguese has a zsh kind of sound in place of a "s" sound.
I used to work in a job where I interviewed many, many people who needed an interpreter, so I probably am unusual.
Tomagander@reddit
Probably only those of us with some knowledge of one or the other.
I can, I speak some limited Spanish and have been exposed to Portuguese enough to pick up the difference, usually.
largos7289@reddit
i'm going with no. You're all Mexican to us LOL.
Healthy-Meet-8373@reddit
If you live in an area of the states and interact with a lot of Spanish speakers you certainly can. I personally can, but I'm Hispanic and can understand Spanish.
I think it'll depend heavily on the demographics of where you live.
You know, big ol' country.
MrShake4@reddit
Well about 20% of the US are Spanish speakers so I imagine they can.
Impedimentita@reddit
I can, some others probably can’t. There’s 350 million of us.
Alert-Algae-6674@reddit
I think they’re pretty distinguishable. I haven’t heard European Portuguese in person but Brazilian Portuguese sounds very different to Spanish for me.
warp10barrier@reddit
I would assume not for the most part. A great deal of Americans probably don’t even know that Portuguese is a language, period. There are a LOT of stupid people here.
himtnboy@reddit
Only because I speak some Spanish. I have to listen until I hear unknown words or verb tenses. Right off the bat, they sound similar and share a lot of words.
bunchofclowns@reddit
I can but I'm surrounded by Spanish speakers and can speak conversationally.
ancj9418@reddit
Yes, but I’ve studied both. I think many Americans would be able to if they listened to the sounds enough. I also think many Americans wouldn’t be able to.
WarrenMulaney@reddit
Yes. Born and raised in California.
My step-mom is half-Portuguese so I grew up hearing some of her older relatives speaking it.
garden__gate@reddit
I can, but I have Brazilian family.
mykepagan@reddit
No, and I live in an area with a decent sized Brazilian and Portuguese community.
Sorry.
iwantawaffle99@reddit
It will entirely depend on where someone is from and how much they've been exposed to Spanish. People along the coasts and in big cities will have a higher chance. People in rural areas are more likely to not be familiar with either.
This-Performance-241@reddit
It depends on the American. Pretty sure the 15% of Americans who speak Spanish at home will be able to. For someone who has less experience with the language it would be like trying to tell Ukrainian and Russian apart
cmcglinchy@reddit
The average American, probably not, but some of us can (especially if the sample is long enough).
sociapathictendences@reddit
Kinda
I was recently in an elevator with some people speaking what I thought was the weirdest Spanish accent I had ever heard. Turns out they were Brazilian.
SGDFish@reddit
It may take me a moment or two, but I can usually clock Portuguese pretty fast
RikkiLostMyNumber@reddit
Yes
HarlequinKOTF@reddit
Most americans probably would struggle. Maybe 50% could.
I would guess I can do so reliably both in conversation and in writing.
sickostrich244@reddit
I can since but I think most average Americans probably wouldn't be able to
Crafty_Ish1973@reddit
Yes, I can tell the difference.
crunchyfoliage@reddit
Those of us who speak some Spanish generally can. I wouldn't be surprised if people who've never taken a Spanish class don't notice a difference
Far-Lecture-4905@reddit
Most Americans haven't heard Portuguese. Most Americans have heard Spanish. Spanish and Portuguese sound pretty different so they might not be able to tell the difference, but they would know that Portuguese isn't Spanish, even if they don't know what language it is.
Gullible_Key1382@reddit
Can anyone not exposed to them? Not an American thing I wouldn't imagine.
Anon-John-Silver@reddit
I can, but only because I randomly happen to have a few Portuguese speakers in my life and I’ve grown up around a lot of Latin immigrants. They sound pretty different.
CouldntBeMeTho@reddit
Considering they have different words and accents a lot of us can..
Can Brazilian or Colombian people tell the difference between Farsi and Arabic?
kidthorazine@reddit
I can, but I also spent a lot of time working at a company with a bunch of offices in Brazil.
Johnny_Burrito@reddit
I can, but I’m cultured.
143019@reddit
I can but I work with a lot of Spanish speakers and Portuguese speakers. I also speak a little of both languages.
Daddysheremyluv@reddit
No. I have tried to study both. At a very low level.
Genius-Imbecile@reddit
Qué?
unknowingbiped@reddit
The ones that know Spanish would?
brittneyacook@reddit
They sound similar but after a while of listening I can tell the difference even though I cannot understand.
WinterRevolutionary6@reddit
Portuguese sounds like Italian Spanish. Like it sounds like Spanish with an Italian accent. Depending on the accent or dialect, I could easily muddle the differences since I only know a bit of Spanish
Rare_Refraction@reddit
100% yes I can tell the difference.
They sound very different to me
cluttrdmind@reddit
I can, but only because I took a lot of Spanish in high school
1200multistrada@reddit
No, unless the American speaks one of those languages.
PhantomJackalope@reddit
Unless they are bilingual and know one of those languages (which there are many but certainly not most), no.
tonightbeyoncerides@reddit
Not 100% but often.
TooManyHobbies6969@reddit
Only Americans that speak spanish
GSilky@reddit
I can, but I grew up in an area knowing Spanish helps, and I know what most of the vocabulary sounds like. However, I am pretty sure people on the other side of my state would confuse Arabic and Spanish, as well as Portuguese.
boopbaboop@reddit
Depends on the American.
Sapphfire0@reddit
Most people know some basic Spanish words so sometimes yes
Calliope719@reddit
Probably not, unless they already speak Spanish
MrLongWalk@reddit
Most probably could
1200multistrada@reddit
no
FunImprovement166@reddit
No