HK USP vs. Glock 19 – Dealing with "buyer’s realization" after a range trip

Posted by Timely-Swordfish-330@reddit | Firearms | View on Reddit | 37 comments

My first gun was a gifted Springfield XDM elite, which is what I’ve mostly shot. But since I just turned 21, I finally picked up a USP. I tried CZs and Berettas, but they felt a bit clunky compared to the HK. As soon as I held the USP, I knew it was the one—looks great and feels amazing in the hand. I’ve put about 300 rounds through it so far with a TLR7-HLX installed.

Today I went to the range with my brother, who has a Glock 19 Gen 5 with the same light and a Holosun. After shooting them back-to-back, I’m actually feeling a bit of conflict. Even though the USP is a legend, the Glock honestly felt better in terms of weight balance and recoil management. The difference in the trigger pull was wild, and the Glock felt way less snappy, which caught me off guard.

Now I’m wondering how to proceed. I want to conceal carry, and while I don't mind the size of the USP, my brother's G19 would definitely be easier to lug around. If I commit to the USP, I’d probably send it to LTT for an optics cut and their trigger work to see if that bridges the gap. I’d also look into a custom holster from Kt mech.

Since I have some leftover budget, I’m debating if I should just keep the USP as a dedicated range/suppressor host and buy a G19 specifically for CCW. I also really want a Ruger Mark IV to suppress after shooting my Dad's today.

What would you guys do? Is the USP worth the extra investment for the LTT work to make it a primary, or is the flatter shooting of a striker-fired modern setup just hard to beat for a daily driver? The HK is a sick pistol, but the performance difference today really surprised me.

[-]

602geyser@reddit

That's life. I still love my CZ's but weirdly I shoot Glocks way better. Take it as a reason to learn and teach your self up on your matksmanship with the USP, and congrats.

[-]

Anonymusk@reddit

Curious: is it a USP in 9, 45, or 40? I've found my USP45 shoots worlds better than my g19.5, but I did upgrade the trigger, and I'm judging by accurate slow fire, not like uspsa style stuff. If you already have a USP, dont sell or especially trade it for a g19.5. Save for a modern striker fired gun (probably g19) and get it later, especially if you're already carrying the usp concealed, you'll be better prepared and feel the upgrade more with a compact. If not, still wait: if you sell or trade the usp for a dime-a-dozen g19 in your early 20s you'll 100% regret it later, and I bet you'll not get nearly as good roi for a usp if you want to sell or trade "quickly"

[-]

Timely-Swordfish-330@reddit (OP)

Yea I will probably not sell it as it right I could very well regret it, it is a 9mm. Thoughts on a Walther PDP C instead of the G19. If u know a lot about them how is the reliability as Glock is know as one of the tops for that?

[-]

Successful_Error9176@reddit

I have the PDP pro. I love it. It feels great in the hand like the HK, the trigger is the best or if all my polymer handguns, and the slide serrations are awesome for charging in any conditions. It does have a snappy harsher feeling recoil. But for me at least, it snaps back on target just as fast so I can still get good follow-up shots. I've heard the same thing about the C model.

[-]

chainmail97ws6@reddit

I just mentioned in another comment, change the recoil spring to 16lbs with a stainless guide rod. Shoots so much better and reduces recoil significantly.

[-]

chainmail97ws6@reddit

I just bought a PDP Pro and I agree about the recoil, so I did some research and swapped the guide rod to stainless with a lighter spring. It’s a world of difference.

[-]

norfizzle@reddit

I’m a fan of Walter over Glock and I disagree that it has more felt recoil. Rent both and shoot side by side. No wrong choice there.

[-]

Diligent-Parfait-236@reddit

If you think the HK is snappy you're going to love the Walther.

This is sarcasm.

[-]

Anonymusk@reddit

I would say the walther is definitely worth a try, as is probably the smith and wesson: I have a walther PPQ (very similar to the PDP) and it's been phenomenal--it sounds like recoil impulse and handling are priorities for you, and I've usually put more emphasis on trigger pull quality, but the Walther will likely have a significantly better (i.e. lighter and crisper) trigger than the Glock: the PPQ and PDP are "pre-cocked" striker pistols, so it's essentially more similar to a single action but with a long, light take up, while the Glock's striker is not fully cocked until the trigger is pulled, so it's almost akin a double or sort of one and half action trigger, because as you're pulling the trigger, you're also completing the striker "cocking" process.

Glock reliability is generally accepted as the gold standard (though I'd say the USP then would be platinum), and it's generally the biggest selling point for that platform in general, so I'd also suggest not going with a competitor's "almost glock" cheaper variant (saving another month or two to get the real thing will be better in the long run).

That said, it sounds like you're starting a collection journey that I've been on for a while, and your next step is a compact handgun for concealed carry, so I'll share my experience with CCWs:

I've CC'd a Walther PPQ M2 Navy SD (9mm), a basic RIA 1911 (45acp), Sig P365, and now currently a Glock 19 gen 5.

The main take I had heard about Glocks for years is that "everything about them is okay, but nothing stands out" --but something that made me come around to the Glock, especially the gen 5, is that I think the reverse is true and a bigger consideration for a EDC weapon: Nothing on a stock Glock NEEDS to be "upgraded" or swapped out for an optimal, reliable, consistent experience, and for a EDC.

For the gun that I'm training around as my "baseline," that I'm also trusting to work every time consistently, and that I know could potentially be used as evidence in court if I had to use deadly force to stop a threat, I want nothing changed or added after the factory except a light and optic.

[-]

Trailhawkfishnsh00t@reddit

The PDP has more felt recoil to most people. The Glock will shoot better with the lower bore axis.

Before you commit I’d try an MP compact and a Springfield echelon. Welcome to the beginning of your collecting haha

[-]

Timely-Swordfish-330@reddit (OP)

I’ll try an MP compact, would PSA have those to rent. My dad has an echelon that I have shot and I would rather go with a G19.

[-]

Trailhawkfishnsh00t@reddit

Most places will have the MP to try. For me I love my glocks but the MP is awesome. Feels better in hand and easy to shoot well.

[-]

Burnpowder_636@reddit

Welcome to the addiction of guns. Never sell, only buy, and always have your next purchase in mind. Drug addiction is probably cheaper but then you couldn’t pass a 4473 and buy that next gun you can’t quit thinking about.

[-]

Spydude84@reddit

Way too real.

[-]

sanmanc@reddit

Wait until you shoot a Canik Tatai or a Walther PDP Pro.

[-]

ratmanmedia@reddit

I present to you, the P30SK LEM.

[-]

Ok_Crab_3522@reddit

Ok... die hard hk fanboys aside, the USP, in 2026, isn't a great shooter, even by HK standards. The gun has remained unchanged through time mostly due to its iconic nature, and improvements to handgun platforms have left it behind. HK themselves have launched both newer hammer fired AND striker fired lines with modern features and ergos that they iterate upon occasionally. None of these generational changes touch the USP though, so you are, in fact, shooting a 1993 gun in 2026.... and shooter standards weren't particularly high in 1993.

Also, if you're gonna do business with LTT, do yourself a favor and get one of their beretta 92's... not an HK. Don't be one of those people who goes to Burger King and orders a salad.... or one of those guys who buys a Porsche mini van. LTT is known for their work on Berettas. Buy what they're known for.

[-]

ratmanmedia@reddit

LTT does solid work on HK’s too.

[-]

Additional_Dish_694@reddit

lol you are cooked! Welcome to collecting my brother

[-]

84074@reddit

Personally I've sold so many guns because I had an itch for another. I regret getting rid of about half of them, ok, maybe more than half. But what I've kept is what I shoot the best with. It's a package deal for me it's gotta feel good in the hand, holster, carrying first, then it's gotta shoot well, like recoil and such, then I gotta be able to hit the target best I can.

If I don't like the feel I'm not going to want to carry it, if I don't carry it it's just a hobby like bowling, if I can't hit what I'm aiming at it'll just get me in more trouble than it's supposed to get me out of.

At least that's my thought process.

It's great to have hobby guns, but damn a gun that "fits" you like your favorite shoes, one that you don't notice but never let's you down and you can do anything with it, that's priceless.

Good luck, stay safe and have fun!

[-]

sploader@reddit

You should keep the USP and save up for a G19. Selling the USP is something that you will absolutely regret later in life. Have you tried a CZ P-10 C? It's a great comparable gun to a G19. Also, if you're on the fence about getting an RXM, that might be the way to go. It's arguably the best value in all of firearms right now.

[-]

Vaultraq@reddit

Both for sure. I've carried the same gen 3 G19 for close to a decade and love it. Also the USP is a solid suppressor host!

[-]

Successful_Error9176@reddit

My buddies and I got together all of our pistol collections and shot them back to back. We had about 30 or 40 different pistols most of them compact and sub compact but a few full sized ones too.

At the end, we all agreed the Glock 19 just shot fantastic. It really stung because I've invested thousands into all kinds of pistols and my Glock 19 gen 3 was the oldest handgun out there. But we had a Gen 5 too, and it was fantastic as well.

Also HK to me, is one of the best feeling guns in the hand, but I can't stand shooting them. They just felt like crap to shoot for some reason.

[-]

I_L0ve_Hotcakes@reddit

FWIW, unless my LTT USP is a dud, the trigger work isn’t worth it. YMMV

[-]

MGB1013@reddit

If you’re just getting started in this you will probably end up with a Glock 19 anyway. I would go ahead and get one, get everything you want to carry it, then go nuts on the usp. Don’t have remorse about getting a gun you think is cool. One of my favorites is my sig p226 legion sao and I hardly ever shoot it. It’s a great gun but I just can’t run it as well as others I own. I don’t regret buying it because it still makes me happy when I shoot it.

[-]

Haunting-Broccoli-95@reddit

Why don't you just buy the Glock? You can't have too many guns

[-]

renegadeGDI@reddit

G19 can be great, USP can be great, you don't have to just pick one, it's mostly about which ergos and trigger b you prefer, me personally I'd take a P30 LEM over either one.

[-]

BarryHalls@reddit

The 19 is the gun absolutely every other handgun is compared to for good reason.

A bone stock 19 isn't a good comparison to an HK, as is reflected by their prices, but with some swaps like a Timney trigger, the Glock can match or exceed it in the same budget.

[-]

Averagecrabenjoyer69@reddit

Shiiiit I think you mean a 1911 is the platform that every other gun is compared to. The Glock 19 works definitely, but its like the Honda Covic of guns, it runs and meets the definition of "good enough" for its price.

[-]

BarryHalls@reddit

It's definitely the Honda Civic. Millions of hot rod options and it'll live until you get sick of it lol.

Nevertheless, even with the 1911/2011 revival, the advice for the last 20 years has been "just get a Glock 19."

[-]

BBQSauce61@reddit

The biggest difference for me is the grip angle. Not world ending, but retraining my natural point of aim just isn't worth it. Went from carrying a USPC 40 to P365s and PDP, with occasionally grabbing the wife's P238...

That said, don't sell the USP...

[-]

hindsighthaiku@reddit

you can snag an rxm for 400 from a lot of places and a holosun on PsA right now for 150.

[-]

Timely-Swordfish-330@reddit (OP)

What about a walther pdp C?

[-]

You know what to do

[-]

Sensitive_Box_@reddit

both 🤷‍♂️