Consumers urged to ‘completely avoid’ UK-caught cod as population plunges | Fishing
Posted by Same_Bug5069@reddit | collapse | View on Reddit | 46 comments
Submission Statement: UK cod stock is essentially gone and now they’re telling people to stop eating it entirely. Not cut back. Stop entirely.
They’ve been warned about this for years. Scientists said stocks were collapsing, said to slash quotas, to stop fishing. Didn’t matter. Quotas stayed high, profits came first, and here we are.
Same pattern every time. Drain it, ignore the warnings, act surprised when it’s gone.
retrosenescent@reddit
Like non-vegans would ever do anything to inconvenience themselves for the sake of the planet
jbond23@reddit
Just switch to Haddock, Hake, Basa, Halibut, Turbot, farmed salmon, fish fingers, fishcakes and so on.
Oh. Wait.
Fried Cod in batter & chips is THE national dish. Wat are we going to do?
Admirable_Advice8831@reddit
Replace cod w/ cauliflower about the same texture and colo(u)r and Brits have no taste anyway >:p
Inner-Leopard7871@reddit
The idea of telling consumers to reduce eating it, rather than governmental laws, is exactly what’s wrong with neoliberalism (among a long list).
It was only 100 years ago that the majority of humanity was illiterate. We cannot trust the lowest common denominator to work with long term interests. Especially when it’s financially beneficial for corporations to continue fishing and selling cod.
This shit makes me want to get trigger happy
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
I agree that it needs to be policy driven
mushykindofbrick@reddit
ok, done
oldsch0olsurvivor@reddit
I’ve seen photos of my deceased grandad with so many cod caught of our coast and these days they are more like unicorns. I mean how does this surprise anyone? We literally hoover the seabed and destroy everything in sight. It’s disgusting
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Those drag net operations are insane. Apparently mackerel stocks are also crashing.
HansProleman@reddit
Damn, and mackerel is actually good 😢
oldsch0olsurvivor@reddit
I was watching a docu on tuna fishing and how they catch them using vast funnel nets. They just scoop everything up it’s insane. How do people think this is sustainable?? Of course everything will crash.
Slamtilt_Windmills@reddit
They scoop up everything and dump the less- then-maximally-profitable fish, now dead, back in the water
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
It's insame and not even remotely sustainable.
Sarah_Cenia@reddit
I read about this 20 years ago. I guess nobody cared enough to protect the poor fish from extinction.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
I doubt if even our own mass die off wakes us up
PM_me_your_trialcode@reddit
Covid was the dry run, laying bare before the world our fragile and corrupt healthcare, poverty, food, and commodity systems, resulting in no changes.
All it did was convince the owning class to loot while they can, because it’s all coming down soon and there’s no accountability.
Cultural-Answer-321@reddit
Yep.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Completely agree
Sarah_Cenia@reddit
You have a point there.
HomoExtinctisus@reddit
We Care A Lot
Barbarake@reddit
For anyone who's interested in the subject, I recently read an great book called 'Cod: a Biography of the Fish that Changed the World' by Mark Kurlansky.
Highly recommended.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Added to my list, thanks.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Submission Statement: UK cod stock is essentially gone and now they’re telling people to stop eating it entirely. Not cut back. Stop entirely.
They’ve been warned about this for years. Scientists said stocks were collapsing, said to slash quotas, to stop fishing. Didn’t matter. Quotas stayed high, profits came first, and here we are.
Same pattern every time. Drain it, ignore the warnings, act surprised when it’s gone.
freexe@reddit
Apparently we would just need to stop eating fish for 7 years for the stocks to return. But that's just not possible apparently.
Konradleijon@reddit
Why not have people go vegan
NyriasNeo@reddit
Because meat tastes good.
PatrolMan2129@reddit
The irony in that is humans can't really taste protein since we're not traditionally carnivores until relatively recently. If you don't believe me, try boiled egg white without seasoning, salt, or butter. Or unflavored protein powder.
What people like on meat is the fat and the texture they associated with it eating it growing up.
I know this, because people around here would hunt deer and not like it too much since it was very lean. They'd have to put it in stews or made ground meat with it, mixing it with bought fatty cuts of beef.
Talking of which, the supermarket meat people like is very far off the mark from average hunting meat in other ways. Animal is never old which adds it's own shitty flavor. Isn't on a wild diet, which adds it's own distinct flavor. Etc.
When I hunted or fished, it wasn't unusual for me to dip the cut of meat I wanted to cook into buttermilk for a day or two, to make it taste less "gamey".
So much for meat just tasting good.
Bavarian_Raven@reddit
Because it’s hard changing diets dramatically. And hard to be healthy as a vegan without taking certain vitamins etc to make up for the shortfalls in the diet. That being said we do need to cut back on meat in our diets asap.
PatrolMan2129@reddit
>And hard to be healthy as a vegan without taking certain vitamins etc to make up for the shortfalls in the diet.
How long have you been on the diet? I've been on it for 10 years and my "hard to be healthy" routine is some b12 drops once a week. I went from super obese/prediabetes in my late 30s to one of the healthiest in my age cohort a decade later:
https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/1sehf48/comment/oex4wi0/
I have read studies that seem to show while all eating groups have members with low numbers in some nutrient or other, it's often the standard western diet omnivore that gets hit with the most deficiencies. Yet people often worry about a vegan diet, for whatever reason.
Ok_Main3273@reddit
The only supplements I take are B12 and iron. I would not call that very hard. And I've been perfectly fine for the last ten years.
However, you are correct that it is a dramatic change in diet, unless you've been vegetarian already for quite some time prior.
ShyElf@reddit
I wouldn't count on that. It's been mostly shut off in Canada with relatively little response for decades. Sure, having what little fishing they had with stocks that low was stupid, because you're delaying any rebound for little return, but they ought to have seen more of a response if fishing was the only issue. The correct temperature zone also moved north, increased stability cut the nutrient supply in deeper waters, and what nutrients come up are increasingly being biologically pumped back down where there used to be sea ice.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Just one more Truffula tree
NyriasNeo@reddit
"urged to ‘completely avoid’ UK-caught cod"
Is anyone gullible enough to believe that this will happen?
"a zero-catch policy for 2026 in the North Sea and adjacent waters."
We will eat them all, then move to pacific cods.
PatrolMan2129@reddit
While I would like to see Consumer responsibility, it's an industry tactic to stop the government from regulating anything and allowing them to sell it.
It would be the same if megatrucks and SUVs had no lower safety requirements like no mandate for lower bumpers and bad vision, so they can run over cars and smaller cars --- and then say it's up to consumers to drive safely. Which is great for assholes that want to buy the biggest automotive male genitalia enhancement vehicle but bad for everyone else. And we call that country the USA.
The_Weekend_Baker@reddit
And just yesterday, one of the Guardian's opinion writers was encouraging Americans to turn their appetite for animals from the land to the sea.
https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2026/apr/08/to-convince-americans-to-eat-fish-disguise-it-as-meat
Barnacle_B0b@reddit
Article headline:
"How do you convince Americans to eat fish? Disguise it as meat, of course"
Oof. This has got to he the dumbest thing written I've read in a while. Unfortunate given The Guardian typically seems to be on top of reporting sensible takes on Climate Change and ecological collapse. Just have to remember it's an opinion piece I suppose.
TenderLA@reddit
This is why I’m hauling pacific cod 350 mile from catcher to processor. The market for Alaska caught cod has been the strongest in many years.
HolymakinawJoe@reddit
Yeah, this also happened in Newfoundland, Canada many years ago. They over-fished the hell out of their waters and decimated the cod population. The government had to freeze all cod fishing.........the life blood of the Newfoundland economy........and that freeze lasted 30 years and finally ended in 2024. Over 30,000 people lost their jobs.
The good news? The people found a way to survive without cod fishing.
The even better news? The cod are back and there are lots & lots of them again and people are fishing again(many disagree with this decision but here we are).
I sure hope they take it MUCH easier this time around.
England should pay attention to this. Stop NOW.
IntoTheCommonestAsh@reddit
Surely doesn't help that newfoundland lifted its cod moratorium that was in place 1992-2024 (a purely populist move made against all scientific advice)
Glittering_Secret_99@reddit
As a Newfoundlander, I was looking for this comment.. & I couldn't agree more! I personally don't think the moratorium should have been lifted. Unfortunately, I think the majority of Newfoundlanders would disagree with me.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Surely not. We're so fucking stupid and greedy.
1erRPIMA-fiesta@reddit
downgraded all UK-caught cod to the worst possible rating, recommending consumers choose European hake as a flaky white fish alternative.
"Should we eat less fish? No. The eco friendly thing to do is to deplete other people's stocks instead"
PartyPoison98@reddit
Tbf, the vast majority of UK fishing waters has permits issued to other countries. So while overfishing is a broader problem, this specific issue is mostly down to the fact that the UK barely had any fishing waters to work with.
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
Same old pattern. Deplete and move on.
flriverlivin@reddit
Little late when they have already been caught. Perhaps the smarter move would be to stop harvesting cod?
Same_Bug5069@reddit (OP)
We're so completely fucking hopeless
StatementBot@reddit
The following submission statement was provided by /u/Same_Bug5069:
Submission Statement: UK cod stock is essentially gone and now they’re telling people to stop eating it entirely. Not cut back. Stop entirely.
They’ve been warned about this for years. Scientists said stocks were collapsing, said to slash quotas, to stop fishing. Didn’t matter. Quotas stayed high, profits came first, and here we are.
Same pattern every time. Drain it, ignore the warnings, act surprised when it’s gone.
Please reply to OP's comment here: https://old.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/1sgmu02/consumers_urged_to_completely_avoid_ukcaught_cod/of629br/