What's the best Toastie you've ever had?

[-]

Bksudbjdua@reddit

Cheese and beans.

Macaroni cheese with jalapenos

[-]

Arch-Com_Songster@reddit

A croquet madame is a classic for a reason. Wee bit of mustard between the fried egg and the topping you are in toastie nirvana.

[-]

Dramatic_Prior_9298@reddit

The guy who delivered my new fridge today told me that he had a beef brisket and cheese toasted sandwich yesterday. I bet that, with a little bit of mustard or onion chutney, would be immense.

[-]

RidgebackRogue@reddit

Bacon and banana with a sweet chili jam

[-]

craftyorca135@reddit

Cranberry and sausage? I think it was a christmas costa one. Very nice

[-]

CowRaptorCatLady@reddit

Caramelised onion, good cheese, post ham, mix up a little bowl of olive oil, mixed herbs and garlic spread it over the outside of the toasties prior to cooking. Beautiful.

[-]

nannyplum@reddit

Leftover lamb leg with mint and goats cheese. Didn't know what to do with leftovers from Sunday Dinner, and I bunged it in the breville. Very lush.

[-]

BoringGazelle1654@reddit

Very finely chopped mushrooms, cheddar and sriracha 🫠😍

[-]

Bloomfield95@reddit

Cheese and a big blob of Bovril is my favourite

[-]

RafRafRafRaf@reddit

Peanut butter and damson jam with a really strong mug of coffee. It probably helped that I was beyond exhausted at the time but it was at that moment the best thing I ever put in my mouth.

[-]

Oohyabassa@reddit

Dessert toasties for afters - white bread, mashed banana and chopped chocolate (either milk or dark are both good). My absolute favourite!

[-]

UndulatingUnderpants@reddit

Chicken snitzel, ham, mozzarella and tomato and basil sauce...basically a Parmo in a toastie.

[-]

Agitated-Honeydew-41@reddit

A little goats cheese, your fave kind of toms, a little red onion chutney or actual red onions and mozzarella for stringiness and rocket!!

[-]

Emmy182@reddit

I had an Indian inspired one at a cafe recently. Bombay potatoes, peas and corn, served with mango chutney on the side

[-]

Electrical-Injury-23@reddit

A friend of mine makes an Indian one with takeaway leftovers. Uses a nan bread instead of normal sliced. It's superb.

[-]

CensorTheologiae@reddit

Oh god yeah. A Dahi toastie (google dahi sandwich for recipes)

[-]

Londoner_999@reddit

I make Panini instead of toasties using part-baked baguettes, the type that sells in supermarkets for around £1 a pair. I don't bother baking them, they toast up nicely in my contact grill.

My favourite is to spread each side with ajvar, a sweet pepper paste from The Balkans, then add salami and some grated mozzarella.

[-]

Punyverse@reddit

Sourdough with mayo gochujang coating.

Cheese and kimchi inside

Rogue but delish

[-]

teacupisbigger@reddit

May I recommend my favourite: kimchi + blue cheese + sprunion. Killer grilled cheese

[-]

I’m trying that. I love that combo I may do butter instead of mayo but I’m. intrigued. I’ve never used Mayo on outside of a toastie. Matt do the mayo live for once. I might also add some shredded pork but just a little.
Thx

[-]

thatstoomuchsauce@reddit

The big sellers at my work are brie/bacon/cranberry and cheddar/ham/pineapple. I'm also partial to hummus/spinach/sundried tomato!

[-]

Mincey808@reddit

Chicken, stuffing, cheese, and cranberry sauce.

[-]

BeetleJude@reddit

Brie, bacon, and onion chutney

[-]

ringosam@reddit

Late 90s when my mum first got one of them toastie presses that makes it into the big triangles. White bread and cheddar with (or without) ham or whatever you fancy. Ketchup on the side. Been thinking about those toasties for 30 years...

[-]

thecatsothermother@reddit

I believe the one we had that did that was made by Breville, so we called the toasties Brevilles, and the machine the 'Breville maker'!

[-]

katalyna78@reddit

I used to valley ours "brevilly magic" (e.g its brevilly magic time!"

[-]

Tiny_Cauliflower_618@reddit

We got one as a wedding present - it has swappable plates, so you can also make waffles. And panini. But we do that a lot less 😂

[-]

Large_Reindeer_7328@reddit

We still murder those toasties. Love my toastie machine, it's the only kitchen thing (ok the air fryer too) that hasn't ended up relegated to a cupboard never to be seen again once the novelty wears off.

[-]

Purp1eMagpie@reddit

Honestly just good quality ham and cheese. Throw a sauce or chutney of choice in. Though if I don't want to eat lava, sometimes I leave the sauce out and dip it instead

[-]

katalyna78@reddit

I always add tomato so it takes the edge off how rich the melted cheese can be (I prefer mature cheddar with those little crystals in it)

[-]

lynkhart@reddit

Mango chutney with melted cheese is wonderful!

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

Dipping sauce is a great call

[-]

ultimateberk@reddit

I got fat on ham and cheese toasties dipped in truffle mayo. It was so moreish

[-]

Odd-Quail01@reddit

You glorious fat knacker

[-]

Spikyleaf69@reddit

Sweet chilli sauce is excellent with strong cheddar.

[-]

Phoenyx_wilson@reddit

Mango chutney goes well with cheese.

[-]

Spikyleaf69@reddit

Ooh yes that's nice, been ages since I've had that 😄

[-]

PrivateFrank@reddit

Leftover roast lamb with mint jelly

[-]

Prudent-Armadillo807@reddit

Cooked streaky bacon with honey glaze, your fav cheese, on vine tomatoes cooked on bottom, fine shallots and pesto or siratcha or what you like to top it off.

[-]

Prudent-Armadillo807@reddit

Put salad cream or mayo on the outside of the bread & butter inside.

[-]

miqqqq@reddit

Good ham, cheese and spring onions are one of the best combo I’ve ever had. Would love that as a birthday breakfast

[-]

Marvel--Jesus@reddit

Cheese, onion, baked beans, wooster sauce.

[-]

theamydoll@reddit

Pizza toasties! You just need pizza sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni.

[-]

kd819@reddit

Chorizo, mozzarella, roasted aubergine and basil, possibly with some kind of red onion jam

[-]

cwatt69@reddit

Cheddar cheese, ham and Branston pickle

[-]

81optimus@reddit

Cheddar cheese and Branston pickle

[-]

Appropriate_Trader@reddit

Sliced turkey, sausage and stuffing

[-]

BuggerFace@reddit

We used to have a place in my home town (Chester) which had the one and only Toastie Queen and she ran a place called Meltdown. Ohhh the toasties man. The bread, the cheese, the different options. Utter filth. Miss it.

[-]

Euphoric_Rough_5245@reddit

I like to make pizza toasties so either mozzarella or Monterey Jack with pepperoni and a smidge of tomato paste.

[-]

HauntingCicada2630@reddit

Sliced banana, cinnamon and brown sugar

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

Wow I hadn't even considered that I could do sweet ones definitely need to try this

[-]

Sygga@reddit

You can do thin slices of apple, too, if hot banana isn't your idea of a good time.

Possibly even cherries... I may need to dig out my toasties maker and get a can of cherry pie filling from Tesco

[-]

em_press@reddit

That is such a good idea!

[-]

cayosonia@reddit

Or chocolate/chocolate spread

[-]

Additional_Plant_539@reddit

Well buttered, and dust the outside with icing sugar

[-]

HauntingCicada2630@reddit

Use golden granulated sugar for the crunch! And watch your mouths, it's a scorcher and loves the roof of your mouth 😂😂

[-]

narnababy@reddit

Sweet napalm

[-]

HauntingCicada2630@reddit

I've got the scars to prove it 😂

[-]

BazzaSmith@reddit

If Sweet Ideas are something you're only just discovering...

My first adventure into sweet was Brioche, Nutella and Mini Marshmallows. It was very sweet, but some definitely liked it for the Smores vibe.

[-]

General-Bumblebee180@reddit

try using 2 sheets of flaky pastry cut to bread size. make delicious apple pies . don't take much longer than using bread

[-]

budleykun@reddit

Marshmallow fluff with Nutella on choc chip brioche bread if you like sweet

[-]

Sasspishus@reddit

Nutella and banana is a classic

[-]

Trick-Station8742@reddit

Do you put the brown sugar on the outside?

[-]

HauntingCicada2630@reddit

Inside!

[-]

Dr_Frankenstone@reddit

I’ve always mixed the brown sugar, honey or maple syrup with the peanut butter, and put it as a filling.

[-]

high_plains_grifter_@reddit

Brioche loaf 🙌

[-]

Defiant-Tackle-0728@reddit

Chocolate spread and banana too

[-]

captain_seadog@reddit

That sounds delicious. I'm a big fan of peanut butter and banana on toast, perhaps that would work too!

[-]

AzzTheMan@reddit

I was going to say peanut butter and banana. Add a bit of honey/maple syrup if you fancy it

[-]

ambergriswoldo@reddit

Mozzarella and Green Pesto

[-]

mrs_peep@reddit

Pork pie toasty. Thin slice of pork pie, optional wholegrain mustard.

[-]

FrankyFistalot@reddit

Sunday dinner….chicken/stuffing/roast potato/carrots/parsnips/gravy,etc….delicious.

[-]

nevynxxx@reddit

Gouda and corned beef. Maybe some onion.

[-]

Individual_Pass3933@reddit

Black pudding and beans. Oh my days.

Precook the black pudding. Chop it up and mix with the beans. Basin of tea.

[-]

Peachy_Witchy_Witch@reddit

I like black pudding & hash brown

[-]

behemuffin@reddit

Seconded black pudding. I had a jar of black pudding and ale pate left over from Christmas - big slab of that and some mature cheddar, serve with tabasco sauce.

[-]

Peachy_Witchy_Witch@reddit

Cream cheese, cheese, gherkin & salami.

Pineapple, tinned spaghetti, cheese and ham.

Chilli beans, cheese & egg. Hard to do without breaking the egg.

[-]

Boring_Benefit2172@reddit

Chorizo, mushroom, cheese and spinach!

[-]

seeyoujim@reddit

Strong cheddar and marmite. Umami heaven

[-]

Wonder_Shrimp@reddit

My mum has got a little cookbook of toasties ideas! Including some sweet ones

Apple, raisin, and cinnamon. Chicken, red pepper and pesto Baked beans and marmite

[-]

Kinelll@reddit

Butter and frosties

[-]

CarpeCyprinidae@reddit

I once made burritos with roast chicken, roast potato and roasted vegetables in, but thats a bit ambitious to fit inside a toastie

[-]

Voodoopulse@reddit

Pesto Parma ham and mozzarella is my go to

[-]

Woollen53@reddit

With some bechemel sauce

[-]

Cinnamon-Dream@reddit

Yeah, was going to suggest smoky bacon, pesto, and cream cheese! Used to be go to!

[-]

guiscardv@reddit

Or a twist, pistachio pesto, mortadella and provola (smoked mozzarella)

[-]

elchet@reddit

Mortadella is my kryptonite

[-]

CautiousAmount@reddit

Get thee to Bologna!!!

[-]

Henry-Black@reddit

Just to note, provola is a separate cheese. It’s not mozzarella and it’s not always smoked :)

[-]

PiskieW@reddit

Love this

[-]

nonsequitur__@reddit

Sun-dried tomatoes would go well in that too

[-]

EUskeptik@reddit

Oi! I was going to suggest that! 😂

-oo-

[-]

hedonism_bot_3012@reddit

Ah the "Tucci"

[-]

MyOverture@reddit

Cheddar, roasted red peppers (you can get these jarred), garlic, onion, and a bit of mustard

[-]

R0GM@reddit

Stilton and pear might not be the best, but it's nice and different if you are into it

[-]

ginfrared@reddit

I used to love scrambling an egg, adding it to my toastie bread with Cajun seasoning. Then close your bread up and it cooks the egg inside. You could add cheese and ham too. Then dip it in sweet chilli sauce 😍

[-]

Character-Bid-5089@reddit

I like pastrami, cheddar, opinion and English mustard.

[-]

xxxxxxxxxooxxxxxxxxx@reddit

The Aldi Christmas dinner toastie.

God I miss that.

[-]

qgwheurbwb1i@reddit

I've never felt so ashamed reading these comments. I read the post title and proudly thought "can't beat a bit of tuna mayo and some cheese" and then I read the wonderful concoctions that everyone else has made. Looks like I'm eating an array of toasties for tea for the next month!

[-]

Electronic-Stay-2369@reddit

Couple of years ago I had a toastie in a cafe in South Wales. It was "just" cheese and ham, but local cheese and local ham and I don't remember what type of bread but not a normal sliced anyway. It was A-mazing.

[-]

zero_glitch_cliche@reddit

Tinned Curry or egg

[-]

Deep_Banana_6521@reddit

The toastie rule is not too wet, and nothing that can slide out in one piece from the toastie.

My boyfriend told me my "roast dinner" toastie was amazing.

Basically chopped up roast chicken, chopped up stuffing, chopped up roast potatoes. Toss them in a bowl with mixed cheddar/mozzarella and make into a toastie with a gravy dip on' side.

[-]

Correct-Ad-6605@reddit

Two slices of toast,

Two squares/slices of dairylea cheese,

A full packet of 'Fries to go' (can't find them anymore now, sadly),

Fours rashers of smoked, streaky bacon, cooked so its crispy, but not completely dired out/burned,

HP sauce.

[-]

Character-Ad-3250@reddit

Jam. Cheese and kimchi.

[-]

Gornal-Annie6133@reddit

Corned beef and baked beans, absolutely delicious!

[-]

moth-on-ssri@reddit

Cheese and mushroom, but chop up the mushrooms and fry them in butter with onion and garlic.

Also mayo on the outside before toasting makes the best crust.

[-]

SM1955@reddit

Is a toastie a toasted sandwich? Or a panino? Or more like a pasty?

[-]

glasgowgeg@reddit

A toastie in my opinion is just bread and cheese. If it has fillings, it's a panini.

[-]

glasgowgeg@reddit

Toasties are just bread and cheese, if it has fillings it's a panini.

Best panini I'll say was the Firewalker Deluxe you used to get at Where the Monkey Sleeps in Glasgow, it was turkey, mature cheddar, sundried tomato, red onion, chillies, lemon juice, bacon, hot sauce, and cayenne pepper.

[-]

Purple_Committee_216@reddit

Red Leicester and apple.

[-]

jmabbz@reddit

3 cheese, garlic granuals, spring onions and lea n perrins sauce.

[-]

KellyMelany@reddit

You can't go wrong with the classic 'fridge raid,' but if you want to actually impress him, try Brie, bacon, and cranberry sauce. It's like Christmas in a crust, minus the awkward family arguments. Just warn him that the middle will be hotter than the surface of the sun—I once took a bite of a tuna melt too early and I'm pretty sure I lost my sense of taste for a week. There's a fine line between a delicious birthday tea and a medical emergncy—I mean emergency.

[-]

--BMO--@reddit

My grandparents used to run pubs, they had one around the corner from my school in the 90’s, 2/3 days a week my gran would pick me up from school and we’d go straight there for her to open up.

She used to make me a corned beef and onion toastie for tea in the old knackered press out the back, best thing in the world. Then I’d play pool until my dad came to pick me up after work.

I never really got on with my dads side of the family growing up but that’s a nice memory I’ve not thought about in a while, thank you.

[-]

buy_me_a_pint@reddit

I am pretty boring, and just go with a cheese and ham toastie

[-]

Funky_monkey2026@reddit

Halloumi and tomato. Might be biased as I'm Cypriot.

[-]

billybrew888@reddit

Nutella

[-]

miemcc@reddit

Just plain old cheddar and ham. If I want to fancy it up. I'll do that on the plate.

[-]

Time-Cucumber3961@reddit

Mature cheddar, lime pickle and crispy onions.

[-]

cayosonia@reddit

Banana a chocolate or Nutella is a surprising twist on a toastie

[-]

PKblaze@reddit

My gf makes great ones.
Cheddar, red onion, seasoned Quorn Fillet (Sub for chicken) red pepper, some chopped green olives, sour cream and chive and then some greens (like lettuce) popped in at the end.

[-]

syorks73@reddit

Ham salami cheese, and raspberry seedless jam. The sweetness of the jam compliments the savoury. No different to cranberry sauce with turkey tbh.

[-]

whodunnit20@reddit

My favourite is cheese, ham and baked beans.

[-]

secretrebel@reddit

Fig jam and blue cheese

[-]

Mundane_Pea4296@reddit

Nutella & marmalade for a warm jaffa cake vibe

[-]

Cathenry101@reddit

Red Leicester, good quality sausage (pre cooked and sliced) and English mustard

[-]

Acceptable-Yam8689@reddit

Nigella's brie, prosciutto and fig toastie is pretty awesome. Bougie for sure but tasty too.

[-]

spike31875@reddit

Cranberry brie and turkey.

[-]

asolarwhale@reddit

Extra strong cheddar and chilli jam is a winner. Extra strong cheddar with basically anything actually!

Some great suggestions in this thread, I’d do a spread of all of them! Or maybe more of a conveyer belt so they all arrive hot?

[-]

Tinkerbellfell@reddit

I am obsessed with truffle Cheese toasties.

You take Jason’s ciabattin, grate some of your favourite cheese (i use snowdonia truffle cheese), then slather on some truffle pesto (filippo berio truffle pesto is the best one hands down). It’s too good!!

[-]

Disastrous-Lynx-7962@reddit

Savoury cheese and onion

[-]

PM_ME_UR-DOGGO@reddit

I think stick to basics, ham cheese and mustard but push the boat out of the ingredients.

[-]

sharpied79@reddit

Peanut butter (smooth) and cheese 😉

[-]

Tattyhead4@reddit

Chicken, bacon and cheddar or tuna, red onion and cheddar. It’s got to be a vintage strong cheddar for the maximum taste.

[-]

Emmalulu2907@reddit

I had a lovely one yesterday - salt beef, lots of cheese and mustard

[-]

NextTomatillo2335@reddit

https://www.abc.net.au/news/2022-04-27/tasty-jaffle-maker-recipe-ideas/101016446

Masterchef has a toastie competition every now and again on the Aussie version a they do some epic creations!

[-]

Current_Mongoose_844@reddit

It was in Tonga.

Ham, cheese, tomato, and green onion. With mustard.

[-]

bluejeansseltzer@reddit

Extra mature cheddar and Branston small pickle, lightly buttered on the outside, is my go-to. The hot vinegariness of the Branston complements the cheddar even more deliciously than when cold in a sandwich.

[-]

goosiegander@reddit

A white toastie with brown toast as filling would be a surprise.

[-]

Timely_Egg_6827@reddit

Stilton and gherkins, mostly diced but some left whole for crunch.

Brie and cranberry sauce

Peanut butter and banana

[-]

filmdope@reddit

Avocado, red onion, lots of black pepper and the sharpest cheddar you can get your hands on.

[-]

Apprehensive_Ad4058@reddit

Aubergine chutney spread on the inside and then a mix of grated cheese, red chilli, coriander, spring onion and crispy onions inside

[-]

Gadget100@reddit

Mars bar.

It’ll make a mess, but it’s worth it.

[-]

Snorge_202@reddit

Cheddar, Tamarind sauce, potato curry (spices, garlic, onions & potatoes in about £1 sized slices, not too wet), coriander chutney.

[-]

Apart-Development-79@reddit

Minced Garlic paste, mozzarella, diced Bacon with a bit of honey

[-]

Apart-Development-79@reddit

Ham and cheese Ham, cheese and pineapple Spaghetti with minced garlic and mozzarella, Cooked mince with cheese

[-]

Kaurblimey@reddit

Kimchi and cheese 🤤

[-]

RegretEasy8846@reddit

I think it was croque monsieur; cheese, ham, mustard. Extremely nice.

[-]

Trivius@reddit

Bacon, Cranberry and Brie is one of my favourites

[-]

icebox_Lew@reddit

Pan fried chicken breast, sautéed red onions, brie and balsamic vinegar on pressed ciabatta.

[-]

TunedOutPlugDin@reddit

Corned beef and cheddar cheese.

[-]

N4t3ski@reddit

Chilli con carne and cheese.

[-]

Insomniacbychoice90@reddit

Smash (yes that Smash), cheddar and branstons pickle in a breville style triangle machine

[-]

CraigTheBrewer12@reddit

A simple cheese and bean, though ensure you leave it for 4-5 business days or the molten bean juice will destroy your mouth. Use a chilli cheese like mexicana or a flavoured cheddar to mix it up a little.

I’m ready for the downvotes, but I sometimes buy a cheapo tin of spaghetti Bolognese and have some of that and mozzarella in a toasty, it’s heavenly.

[-]

Maus_Sveti@reddit

Tinned spaghetti in a toasted sandwich is a kiwi classic. Mostly just a tomato sauce like you have with beans rather than a bolognaise sauce though. Bonus points if you can get the sort that comes with little mystery meat sausages (don’t know if you have that in the UK).

[-]

CraigTheBrewer12@reddit

Ohh I think you can spaghetti with mystery meat sausages here, though beans and sausages are more popular. Ohh I’m craving a toastie now

[-]

vikingneil81@reddit

Cheese and peanut butter....trust me

[-]

tearfulconfetti@reddit

I make mine in a frying pan and one of my best creations are:

- Garlic butter on the outside and grated mozz on the inside + grindy garlic

- tomato puree with seasonings, grated mozz, pepperoni (always butter the outside of any toasties i list btw)

- cheese and honestly a burger patty with onions and ketchup

- one i havent made but wish I had before I went gluten free, chilli with nacho sauce, cheese, guac, sour cream just a LOADED mexi mess. That would be good with garlic butter on the outside too i reckon

[-]

hellohowareyoudotcom@reddit

Ham, leerdammer and frenchies mustard, the cheese melts into the mustards it’s lovely!

[-]

Iwantedalbino@reddit

Ham and cheese for me nothing fancy just straight bat.

I used to make banana toasties as a kid with a shit load of butter.

[-]

ChiefKickAss500@reddit

Chicken Schnitzel, bacon, lettuce, ceasar mayonaise

[-]

Clear-Student-9607@reddit

Pesto and Parma ham is a classic combo, but adding some red onion chutney for a sweet kick would take it to the next level.

[-]

MrMatthewEx@reddit

When I was a student hanging with friends at the pool club there was a good looking bar maid that would make cheese toasties for like £2. Seemed a fair price and kept me playing pool and drinking with friends. That was a good toasty. Not sure if that’s real helpful but maybe try having some toasties with some friends and beer over some games.

[-]

Junior_Tradition7958@reddit

Prosciutto, machego and quince jam

[-]

Desperate-Cookie3373@reddit

I’m veggie. I had a posh smoked cheese and red onion one the other day that was absolutely banging! Love beans and cheese too…

[-]

MuserofMusic@reddit

Roast turkey and coleslaw.

[-]

tibiapartner@reddit

Pulled pork, kimchi and cheddar hits every time

[-]

PresterJonny@reddit

Cheese and beans.

[-]

EfficientTea3494@reddit

Add some Branston pickle and you’re golden!

[-]

Diligent_Explorer717@reddit

OP, anything but this.

[-]

MactionSnack@reddit

Add a little dash of worstershire sauce

[-]

Alive_Forever_9541@reddit

Special occasion: so use beans and mini sausages!

[-]

narnababy@reddit

This is my toddler’s favourite; he likes a beans and cheese toastie but if he discovers you’ve used the beans with the little sausages it’s like Christmas 😂

[-]

MamaMiaow@reddit

Or spaghetti hoops

[-]

minionoftheinternet@reddit

Yes one of the best fillings you can have.

[-]

eadipus@reddit

Chocolate spread, peanut butter and a few marshmallows in the middle.

For anything savoury replacing the butter on the outside with confit garlic mayonnaise is incredible.

[-]

pastapicture@reddit

Haggis, cheese and chilli jam

[-]

Public-Entrance8816@reddit

As much as I love a fancy toastie with interesting, fancy and flavourful ingredients, the mention of toasties unlocks the memory very close to my heart, clogging my arteries with love.

Cheap white thick sliced bread Proper butter on the outside (probably the inside too) Cheddar cheese (sold in corner shops now as "light cheese type substance")

It was the maiden voyage of the triangle toastie maker my nana won at the bingo in 1992. It was like a fried bread, greasy, cheesy heart attack. Eaten in front of a coal fire on a cold December afternoon after a swimming lesson with a cup of tea. I burned my chin on the molten cheese but I was too deep in food nirvana to care.

I inherited that bad boy and still have it. The only thing that stops me making them regularly is increased education on healthy eating, and it being a right bastard to clean.

If you want such a delightful beast for a birthday celebration, I understand that some of the classier, upmarket pubs have a breville out back.

[-]

Jezbod@reddit

I must say that I prefer the more mature cheeses when putting in to a toastie maker.

I trialled a strong mature Cheddar with peperoni in a George Forman, like a panini press, and it tasted just like pizza, but only took 3 mins.

[-]

not1or2@reddit

Ham, cheese and Timor’s

[-]

Inkblot7001@reddit

Truffle infused cheddar, chorizo, and sweet chilli jam.

[-]

Character_Arachnid65@reddit

Corned beef and beans.

[-]

Stefgrep66@reddit

Hi as he tried a croque Monsieur or Croque madame?

Or monte cristo which is just a variation on a theme.

I love a toastie but these Just add a little flair I find.

[-]

bonshui@reddit

You can't beat a simple tuna melt

[-]

Chunklett@reddit

Cheddar and mango chutney

[-]

Used_Platform_3114@reddit

Camembert, walnuts and hot honey!

[-]

Happily-Incorrect@reddit

If it's good on a pizza it'd be good in a toastie.

[-]

Dangerous-Web-1962@reddit

fried onions and hot dog sausages...

[-]

Trancer79@reddit

My mum used to make me sardines toasties when I was a kid, haven't had them for AGES but they were the bomb!

[-]

snarkmaiden5@reddit

Why dont you try cheese and chocolate...

[-]

djwillis1121@reddit

Brie, bacon and chili jam. Mozzarella, pesto and tomato.

[-]

ayamummyme@reddit

Cranberry Brie and bacon

[-]

djwillis1121@reddit

Replace the cranberry with chili jam and this is my choice

[-]

CEP64@reddit

Add in some chicken for perfection.

[-]

ayamummyme@reddit

Also cheese sauce on top and grill

[-]

sci-fi_hi-fi@reddit

Thin roast beef, red onion chutney and a good cheddar

[-]

hairychris88@reddit

This is what I do. With a big pot of gravy to dunk it in!

[-]

lodav22@reddit

Toastie and gravy? Hairy Chris, you are a genius!

[-]

Trancer79@reddit

Hairy Chris

LOL!

[-]

Ohtherewearethen@reddit

This is a good shout but I'd use stilton instead of cheddar.

[-]

sci-fi_hi-fi@reddit

Equally a good shout there

[-]

redqueensroses@reddit

Prosciutto, goats cheese and fig jam in a ciabatta.

[-]

X3TIT@reddit

Banana and chocolate. Milky way for extra points.

[-]

Interesting-Car8484@reddit

Chicken Mayo Cheese and biltong. Game changer.

[-]

after-my-blanket@reddit

My dad fed his mate a cat food toastie. Maybe not the best for your hubby mind

[-]

Clevergirluk@reddit

Cheese and cranberry!

[-]

KezzyKesKes@reddit

If you are anywhere near Nettlebed Creamery. Their toasties are the best I’ve ever had.

[-]

LAcasper@reddit

Stay with me -

Tuna mayo, red pepper, onion bhaji and cheese.

[-]

Remote-Pool7787@reddit

Chicken, bacon and bbq sauce

[-]

Diligent_Explorer717@reddit

Wow, this sounds delicious

[-]

narnababy@reddit

Add some red onion and cheese and you’ve got yourself a deal!

[-]

WrekTheHead@reddit

Add some cheese, and you have a Hunter's Chicken toastie.

[-]

EconomicsAfraid7880@reddit

I mean surely cheese is implied if it's a toastie? No one's out here having cheeseless toasties, right? Right??

[-]

WrekTheHead@reddit

Never had a toasted bacon sarnie?

[-]

MrBoggles123@reddit

Me!

I'm allergic to cheese. Or more accurately I have extreme sensitivity to some of the proteins and histamines in cheese so am intolerant. But it's not lactose intolerance so I can drink milk etc.

[-]

ArtificialPigeon@reddit

God I hope not

[-]

Ok-Explanation1990@reddit

Tuna, cheese and spring onion

[-]

Diligent_Explorer717@reddit

Horrible

[-]

Spoondoggydogg@reddit

Add some sliced green chilli 🤤

[-]

AudienceOpen2747@reddit

and some sweetcorn

[-]

Nightfuries2468@reddit

And in finely chopped red onion for a nice crunch too

[-]

stoodincrap@reddit

Could always add some olives and capers too!

[-]

Novando22@reddit

I do regular ham and cheese with some (lots of) garlic & herb Boursin added, total decadence!

[-]

Diligent_Explorer717@reddit

Salami and any kind of cheese

[-]

Starrryg@reddit

Pineapple, cheese & onion, Worcestershire sauce, black pepper

Sounds weird but absolutely BANGS

[-]

Ahleanna-D@reddit

Mediterranean grilled veg and goat cheese

[-]

Macky93@reddit

Used to be a place in Leicester city centre, on Loesby Lane opposite the O'Neills pub called Croques. They used to do the absolute best tuna brie toasties. Slightly spicy, gooey delicious mess

[-]

BernardBernouli@reddit

If you're using a deep toastie machine, you can crack an egg in and it cooks. I used to make egg, beans and cheese toasties. If you can fit it, bit of bacon/sausage/black pudding for the full English toastie experience 😅

[-]

Butterfish04@reddit

Chicken, pesto and mozzarella. I’d also give the Parma ham version, posted earlier, a try.

[-]

Admirable_Holiday653@reddit

I got this from instagram and it is expensive but literally worth every single penny: Roast some garlic, when it’s cooked squeeze it out of skin. Marinate some cherry tomatoes in olive oil with salt and pepper Toast or fry sourdough in butter. Squeeze the garlic on to the bread. Top with pesto if you want ( truffle for preference) Add pieces of burrata and Parma ham. Top with tomatoes although I also use figs. Drizzle some truffle oil if you have some. Elite.

[-]

3_box@reddit

Melted truffle cheddar is delish 😋

[-]

Low_Sodiium@reddit

Mashed potato, cheese & ham, white bread & an unhealthy amount of butter. Simple but the best

[-]

Greedy_Ad_812@reddit

Haggis, cheese, peppercorn sauce is great, or a cheese, ham and Jalapeños

[-]

Admirable_Holiday653@reddit

Haggis and peppercorn sauce is a beyond elite combination 🙌🏻 it’s also world beating on chips

[-]

Neddykins82@reddit

Sliced boiled egg, smoked cheddar, caramelised onion and sweetcorn

[-]

jackog420@reddit

Chorizo and mozzarella with a bit of hot sauce of choice 👌

[-]

Prestigious_Emu6039@reddit

Ham and cheese

[-]

OldManChino@reddit

Tuna, mayo, sweet chilli sauce, black pepper and cheese

[-]

bogyoofficial@reddit

There's a place near my mums that does an indomie toastie 🤤 🤤

[-]

ThinkIshatmyself@reddit

Chicken and cheese and a touch of BBQ sauce

[-]

buttersismantequilla@reddit

Emmental cheese and chopped ham. It’s so much more than a cheese and ham toastie

[-]

Reasonable_Sky9688@reddit

Corned beef, cheddar, onion, thin spread of brown sauce

[-]

No-Photograph3463@reddit

Corned Beef and Onion is a great combo.

And just Nutella inside for a good dessert Toastie.

[-]

Chordsy@reddit

Chilli con carne and cheese, even better if they're made in a toasties maker and are a molten pocket of meat, cheese, sauce and kidney beans.

Burnt my mouth on one of those mfers so many times at uni.

[-]

smoking-gnu@reddit

Haggis, chilli jam and cheese.

[-]

Time-Reindeer-7525@reddit

Marshmallow and Nutella. The Christian Union at uni always did a roaring trade in these around Rock Nite, especially around chucking out time and a bunch of us hungry goths appeared, looking like a hoard of particularly sweaty, hungry demons.

[-]

Arketan@reddit

Leftover bolognese and mozzarella

[-]

trin6948@reddit

Cheese and baked beans. Hotter than the sun inside but soooo good!

[-]

ellasfella68@reddit

Left over roast chicken (including skin) with some left over gravy, on white bread. Food of the gods.

[-]

Round_Grand_4716@reddit

Mars bar and banana

[-]

Daft-Count@reddit

fucking hell we love sandwiches don't we

[-]

strawberrypops@reddit

Not a filling but get crumpets in! Crumpet toasties are so good.

[-]

ding-wizzy@reddit

Corned beef and bean!

[-]

Snaggl3t00t4@reddit

Cheese and tuna.

Sounds wrong, tastes amazing.

[-]

darklinkuk@reddit

Pizza toasties

Pizza sauce, grated mozzarella and pepperoni

[-]

tellmymotherIloveher@reddit

This is what I come to Reddit for.

[-]

Kikitha1andonly@reddit

Philadelphia cream cheese and chunky blueberry+strawberry jam, dust of icing sugar over top with icy lime water....yes LORD😘

[-]

evb666@reddit

Using sliced brioche would be delicious with this!

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

Wowwww need to try this

[-]

Zahgurim65@reddit

Banana custard.

[-]

Jpeg-1@reddit

cheddar and spring onions, blob of tommy sauce on the side

[-]

uxkelby@reddit

Google 'on toast' Gloucester docks for inspiration, used to eat there all the time!

[-]

HashDefTrueFalse@reddit

Red Leicester cheese and bacon is my usual. I toast the bread in a pan with butter. Come to think of it I'm passing a shop on the way home...

[-]

grazzac@reddit

Nutella and raspberry jam - careful though cause it burns with the heat of a thousand suns if you bite into it too early.

Thick cut bacon, mature red Leicester and thick sliced tomato. Add a dallop of chilli jam smeared on top when it's cooked.

[-]

Beautiful_Spread7866@reddit

The best toastie I ever had was when I put leftover lasagne in one - it was incredible

[-]

vivaorangina@reddit

20 years ago, a cafe near us did chicken, bacon and Gruyère sandwiches that we still talk about to this day.

[-]

Sensitive-Housing495@reddit

Cheddar, ham and chipotle aioli

[-]

tiddlypuff@reddit

Tandoori chicken, red onion, and red Leicester cheese

[-]

No-Extension-2378@reddit

I like to add a layer of cream cheese, for extra, well, creaminess! Mature cheddar, cream cheese, a slice of processed plastic cheese, thin sliced pink pickled onions and any bits of ham or chicken I've got that need using up.

After reading everyone else's comments, the toastie maker is coming out the cupboard for the next 5-10 working days.

[-]

tsdesigns@reddit

Super noodles. Make them first, then put them in a toastie, excellent.

Nothing bad about a good quality cheese toastie though. Maybe some ham in there too.

Pesto and chicken is often one I make too.

[-]

Purple-Pie4283@reddit

Haggis. Not kidding. It’s the best toastie filling.

[-]

Accurate-Ad9790@reddit

Cheese and Onion, nice and simple.

[-]

kalendral_42@reddit

I do a decent Boxing Day/left over roast toastie 1. 2 slices of buttered bread (or I sometimes use large Yorkshires/yorkshire pudding wraps) 2. Sliced cheddar, left over roast meat (turkey/chicken/ham/etc), squashed roast potatoes, squashed left over roast veg (carrots/parsnips/brussrls/etc), any sides (stuffing/cranberry sauce/apple sauce/etc), slice of prosciutto, slice of Camembert, drizzle of gravy 3. Toast on both sides or fry on both sides for 5m each

Also some other toastie favourites: Black pudding macaroni cheese toastie - https://www.deliciousmagazine.co.uk/recipes/black-pudding-macaroni-cheese-toastie/

Bombay chilli cheese toastie - https://www.olivemagazine.com/recipes/vegetarian/bombay-chilli-cheese-toastie/

Brie, ham & fig jam toastie - https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/brie-ham-fig-jam-toastie

Mushroom Welsh rarebit toastie with fried egg - https://www.deliciousmagazine.co.uk/recipes/mushroom-welsh-rarebit-toastie-with-a-fried-egg/

Philly cheesesteak toastie - https://www.deliciousmagazine.co.uk/recipes/philly-cheesesteak-toastie/

Brie & bacon toasties - https://www.bbcgoodfood.com/recipes/brie-bacon-toasties

[-]

JBB2002902@reddit

Banana and chocolate spread is pretty banging.

[-]

warmslippers12345@reddit

You can't beat cheese and beans!

[-]

ermhagerd@reddit

the Cubano sandwich is my favorite sandwich of all time.

soft subway type roll, cooked pork, swiss cheese, sliced ham, a slice of gherkin, american mustard, buttered and grilled. so good. see the movie 'Chef'

[-]

jerzeibalowski84@reddit

Scrambled egg cheese and olives.

[-]

musicistabarista@reddit

Cheese and kimchi, cheese and brinjal pickle and tuna melt are my favourites. Cheese and thinly sliced pickled walnuts is also great.

[-]

Groffulon@reddit

Baked beans and cheese. Had this a lot as a treat when I was a kid. I now have a Teflon mouth. Good times.

[-]

sillydog80@reddit

Ham, Swiss cheese, gherkins, chilli jam

[-]

ErinClaymores@reddit

Still love a fish finger toastie - add some baked beans, or ketchup or tartare sauce 😋

[-]

narnababy@reddit

My other half’s favourite usually involves ham, cheese, chorizo, and Jalepenos

He’s also been known to put canned foods (like chili, curry, stuff like that) in a toastie

My BIL likes supernoodle toasties (has to be super noodles because they’re “drier” than pot noodles whatever the hell that means)

Beans and cheese is popular with my toddler, bonus if it’s beans with the little sausages in

I like a chicken, bacon, red onion, cheese BBQ sauce toastie myself

[-]

HPsauceOnCurry@reddit

Cheese, hashbrowns and gravy

[-]

Clive_Trotter75@reddit

Corned beef, extra mature cheddar, good splash of Hendo’s

[-]

ghostsnickets@reddit

This has unlocked a far away memory of student days and making toasties with tinned Heinz spaghetti. The filling goes absolutely thermonuclear, but really good especially with added cheese.

[-]

Top_rattata@reddit

Cheese, haggis and a little bit of Tabasco is my usual go to now

[-]

lildemonjodsx@reddit

Brie and cranberry sauce 🤤

[-]

BrainlessPackhorse@reddit

Bacon & stilton. Just don't expect to move afterwards...

[-]

RepulsiveGanache1609@reddit

Cheese, beans and Ham is my go too. I make my partner bbq chicken one’s. Sweet ones too - banana and syrup is nice Or peanut butter and chocolate 🍫

[-]

Foddley@reddit

I'll use a hot sandwich press. Butter both sides on each of the slices of bread to make them golden when they come out. I'd tear some sliced ham into shreds and then add your favourite cheese.

[-]

Realistic-Muffin-165@reddit

The previous nights leftovers.

[-]

Fool5Gold@reddit

Cheese, spinach and blue cheese on sourdough

[-]

mistat2000@reddit

Ham, Cheese, Red Onion Chutney
Ham, Cheese, Mustard
Tuna, Red Onion, Cheese
Cheese and Baked Beans
Curried Chicken, Cheese and Mango Chutney with some corriander
Pulled pork, BBQ sauce and mozzarella

[-]

c0tch@reddit

Ham, peanut butter, cheese.

[-]

ArtificialPigeon@reddit

That's 3 seperate toasties right? Right??

[-]

c0tch@reddit

Nope, it’s a toastie my mate created when we were drunk and named it a manwich and it genuinely is so good.

Cheese and peanut butter go well together, cheese and ham go well together, ham and peanut butter go well together.

All 3 go well together. Nice mix because sweet salty savoury and sweet etc.

Try it before you knock it, don’t overload it with peanut butter though.

It went from a drunk concoction to a legendary snack we would always have after a night out.

I’d happily eat one every day.

[-]

ArtificialPigeon@reddit

You've convinced me. Trying it tonight

[-]

c0tch@reddit

Please do let me know what you think! Just be mindful of the peanut butter too much can ruin it.

[-]

Competitive_Rub_9590@reddit

Ham and cheese at home plain Jane but they’re just class

[-]

CEP64@reddit

Crumbed ham and Mexicana cheese slice, some finely chopped onion.

[-]

ofgraveimportance@reddit

Bacon, Brie and apricot jam!

[-]

Nevynthal907@reddit

Cheese Chipotle Paprika and mayo i love it.

[-]

Competitive_Test6697@reddit

Do a breakfast toastie.

[-]

drivelhead@reddit

Frosties?

[-]

dodgrile@reddit

Instant coffee and a Marlborough light

[-]

rwinh@reddit

Look up "croque boem boem", is basically a croque monsieur (ham and cheese toastie) but with Bolognese sauce on top. It's Flemish and very delicious, and gives a boom of flavour. You could place a fried egg on top of you're looking to be extra saucy.

I would make that by serving some good quality croque monsieur, and the Bolognese on the side for everyone to serve themselves. It has to be a really good Bolognese though, with bacon lardons, properly broken down mince etc.

[-]

SrslyBadDad@reddit

Bacon, avocados and mayo. It’s out of this world.

[-]

aChocolateFireGuard@reddit

Chicken, cheese and jalapenos for me

[-]

snowdroptiger@reddit

My local cafe does a classic Reuben toasted and it’s verrrryy good.

I’m also a fan of a tuna melt.

And don’t overlook getting posh ingredients for a good version of a simple thing, some smoked ham and good cheese should make for an excellent ham and cheese toastie

[-]

edfosho1@reddit

Cajun chicken with cheese. I had it at a festival like 20 years ago, chilling in the sunset in front of some great music. Best. Ever.

[-]

Wrekh@reddit

I like mine with cheese, ham, some sliced peppers and pickles with some Italian herbs.

[-]

Dr_Frankenstone@reddit

Cheddar or Camembert and mushed avocado with Tajin sprinkled over the avocado!

[-]

FPRorNothing@reddit

Cheese, onion and chilli crisp 😋

[-]

PiskieW@reddit

I need to save this thread

[-]

Shams_the_only@reddit

honey and cheese.

Hear me out, this is the best transition from savoury to sweet. This is an Arab combination we had for dessert before chocolate became so widespread and is quite light.

It shoukd be a soft spreadable soft white cheese (at home we use Puck cheese or KIRI). UK equivalents are Philadelphia cheese, or cheese triangles (dairy lea or laughing cow).

A chocolate and marshmallow options is banging as well.

[-]

Dr_Frankenstone@reddit

I make this filling sometimes and spread it on tortilla wraps, fold it up and brown in a dry frying pan. The tortilla goes crispy, the honey and cheese are hot and sweet and slightly salty. It is an amazing combination! Great suggestion!

[-]

Not_Mushroom_@reddit

Sausage and peanut butter.

[-]

TurquoiseToaster@reddit

Cream cheese, jalapeños and cheddar

[-]

Ready_Perspective_95@reddit

Macaroni cheese.

[-]

bigyin1984@reddit

Honestly, a real strong cheddar with chunky Branston pickle.

[-]

lee379@reddit

Cream egg and Nutella...granted you won't be able to speak for a few minutes from all the hot claggy chocolate goodness 🤣

[-]

Foxalito@reddit

Leftover veggie pasta sauce, cheese, and ham, it's like a pizza toastie

[-]

SWITMCO@reddit

A Morrisons cafe cheese & bacon, like 15-20 years ago.

[-]

No_Vereniging328@reddit

Cheese and onion with jalapeños and bbq sauce

[-]

elmo298@reddit

Chicken in white sauce tin

[-]

pinpoint321@reddit

Ham, or cheese, or ham and cheese.

[-]

ddmf@reddit

My mum used to do apple and brown sugar with cinnamon, sometimes with raisins - was like a McDonald's apple pie in the breville.

[-]

Big-Tennis-4538@reddit

Cheese and (grilled) corned beef Chicken curry & cheese Cheese, beans & sausage

[-]

Cupid_Stunt17@reddit

Chunks of chicken breast, chorizo, cheese and sriracha

[-]

chartreuseranger@reddit

Cheddar, torn fresh spinach and sundried tomato pesto on sourdough.

[-]

NewtsReddit@reddit

Cheese and green chilli. Maybe add some chicken.

Use croissants as the bread with ham and cheese.

[-]

gone-in-a-spark@reddit

You need a desert toastie after a savoury one. Marshmallow, cinnamon and chocolate spread

[-]

DeirdreBarstool@reddit

Tomato puree, cheese and as many fresh chillies I can fit in it!

Also, corned beef, red onion and brown sauce

Bolognese and cheese

[-]

poppyedwardsPE@reddit

The best I have ever had was at Karma Bakery in Hampstead, a tuna melt with 3 types of onion and 3 types of cheese. Absolutely phenomenal. I dream about it

[-]

TheClnl@reddit

The 'Ch'.

Chicken, cheese, chorizo, chilli, chomato sauce

[-]

kungfumovielady@reddit

Bananas goldensyrup flaked almonds

[-]

Logical_Yogurt5146@reddit

Hot English mustard, creamed corn, cheese. Soo good, I haven’t had one for a while.

I haven’t been able to find cans of creamed corn over here but it wouldn’t be too difficult to mash up a can of corn kernels I guess….

But also onion, gherkin and tomato cut up very small, cheese on top, hot English mustard

[-]

Pedanticandiknowit@reddit

I had a Bolognese toastie once and it was the tits

[-]

IIgardener1II@reddit

Lightly fry halloumi, add to toastie with olive oil, and mixture of chopped mint,coriander and dill.

[-]

TheSecondiDare@reddit

Corned beef and tomato.

[-]

Enchanted_Whimsy7612@reddit

Chicken tikka and cheese

[-]

Dejahugh@reddit

Baked beans and cheese

[-]

charliegibbatron@reddit

Left over lamb, bit of mint sauce and then have a jug of gravy to dip in it. Unreal

[-]

-Po-Tay-Toes-@reddit

This one I made the other day was pretty good. Gouda with home made BBQ pulled chicken. Salt and pepper tiger bread. But, the most important thing is the mature cheddar on the outside, cripsed to form a crust.

[-]

drivelhead@reddit

Cheese.

[-]

Sea_Pomegranate8229@reddit

Chedda and Worcestershire sauce.

[-]

Disastrous_Style_477@reddit

Cheese, onion and ham. Haven't had a toastie in years though, might have to purchase a toastie maker

[-]

BRoberts93@reddit

Corned Beef, Branston pickle, and Cheese

[-]

Creepy-Albatross-588@reddit

Mashed potato, beans, sliced southern fried chicken breast and southern fried gravy to dip it in. Falafel, humous and mango chutney. Sliced steak, fried onions and a dipping sauce of your choice. Nutella and bananas. Favourite chocolate bar chopped up.

Basically anything you like.

[-]

Delicious-bakey-bake@reddit

I’ve said it before but too good not to again! Keema toasties dipped in ketchup.

[-]

smolpotato16@reddit

I had an amazing sandwich at a cafe recently that I normally would never choose but it surprised me.

It had inside: halloumi, peach, hot honey, cheddar(I think?) and was topped with hazelnuts

[-]

Hefty_Peanut@reddit

Bolognaise and cheese

[-]

BarryIslandIdiot@reddit

I watched a Heston Blumenthal episode once where he did toasties. He used a thin layer of filo patry on the outside for extra crisp.

[-]

Howthehelldoido@reddit

My mum used to make us ones filled with "Golden Syrup"

Dont do that...

[-]

UnderstandingFar6589@reddit

I make them like pizzas- so salami, pepperoni and mozzarella, or four cheeses, or I take inspiration from the dominos menu…

Also… Spinach and goats cheese is good too. Chicken tikka and roasted red peppers… so many great options!

[-]

Most_Kiwi3141@reddit

Tomato paste, dash of oregano, bit of sweetcorn, cheese. Toastie pizza.

[-]

Alive_Forever_9541@reddit

Taco Toastie! Pulled chicken (there's already lots of pork/ham variants), pickled pink onions (or chopped spring onion), chopped jalapeno and American squeezy "cheese"

[-]

No_Acanthaceae_362@reddit

Chilli con Carne with cheddar

Tikka chicken with red onion, mango chutney and cheddar

Ham, Dijon mustard and cheddar

Pepperoni and Jalapeno with tomato salsa and mozzarella

Cheddar and marmite

[-]

dereks63@reddit

Posh bread,cheese and ham, Branston

[-]

Acrobatic_Try5792@reddit

I love

tuna, sweetcorn, red onion, cheese and sriracha

Or

Cheddar and sweet chilli sauce

[-]

Novel-Structure-2359@reddit

If you can find it then Portuguese tomato jam united with a good cheddar is magical. On its own the jam is very odd as it is sweet and tomatoey. However when the sweetness collides with the savoury of the cheese then the angels cry.

Luckily for me I have Portuguese in-laws that hook me up, otherwise it can be hard to find.

[-]

DrZonino2022@reddit

Peanut butter and jam

[-]

obsessedwitheyes@reddit

Can’t beat a cheese and marmite toastie!

[-]

Altruistic-Nerve4180@reddit

Steak, brie and Lee and Perrins. Its gorgeous.

[-]

Eckmatarum@reddit

Smooth goats cheese, very finely chopped rosemary and honey.

[-]

Legitimate-Soil7109@reddit

Spam, Gruyere, Dijon

[-]

Scary_Application_70@reddit

Apple and cinnamon.

[-]

MahatmaAndhi@reddit

Chicken tikka & pesto

[-]

LagerBoi@reddit

Deeneys haggis and caramelised red onion

[-]

boondocks-888@reddit

Baked beans with Hp sauce and cheese 🧀 yummy make sure you fork it first avoid the burn 🔥

[-]

RoyceCoolidge@reddit

Brie and Bovril (and butter) in white sourdough.

[-]

Natural_Trick4934@reddit

Potato Carbonara, Pancetta, Pecorino, Black Pepper

[-]

rumham_123@reddit

Chicken, bacon, barbecue sauce, and cheese. Had it at a cafe at a wood near me and since then it is always sold out because everyone wants it

[-]

PurpleSquirrel811@reddit

A cafe I used to go to on Grey's Inn Road near Holborn used to do a roasted vegetable (peppers, onions, courgettes etc) and mozzarella panini that was sooo delicious. I miss that place! It did amazing omelettes as well if I had the time to sit in. Can't remember the name of it but this was about 20 years ago.

[-]

Helpful-Scientist-33@reddit

Grated cheese and kimchi is a great combo.

Also using crappy white sliced bread buttered on the outside for extra crunch.

[-]

brokenlandmine@reddit

Cheese and Peanut butter is my go to!

[-]

spik0rwill@reddit

Cheddar and raw onion, cheddar and ham and cheddar and bacon are my go to. Usually Mild cheddar as mature tastes a bit funny when its melted (imo)

[-]

chelseadaggerffm@reddit

Haggis, cheddar and sweet chili sauce.

I didn’t believe in this combo until I tried it. Now it’s my absolute favourite thing ever.

[-]

DIRTY_PINT@reddit

Cheesy leeks, mustard, black garlic paste, sourdough bread- I wake up thinking about it sometimes ...

[-]

Ring_Peace@reddit

This sounds awesome, will be making, out of ten, insert meme of choice here.

[-]

DIRTY_PINT@reddit

Tantalises all 9000 taste buds and that's a guarantee

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

Black garlic paste sounds like my new addiction never had that before but sounds unreal

[-]

DIRTY_PINT@reddit

It's unreal - use it as a smear on a sandwich/toastie, chuck a teaspoon kn a barbecue glaze or marinade, chuck it in a ramen paste its such a cheat code 🤤

[-]

Phoenyx_wilson@reddit

Smoked cheese and caramelised onion chutney. Chocolate spread and biscoff. Chicken tikka with a mango and chilli dipping sauce.

[-]

kingmickyb@reddit

Fishcake and mushy peas from the chippy.

[-]

LungHeadZ@reddit

May I suggest you do a mix of these. I think I'd love to get a smorgasbord of toastie varieties!

[-]

rainbow84uk@reddit

Smoked cheddar and kimchi.

[-]

Mysterious-Bee-8458@reddit

Chicken tikka. Cheese coriander and mr vikkis tamarind and Chipotle chutney.

[-]

BeautyAndTheDekes@reddit

Streaky bacon, cheddar cheese, provolone and hear me out with this, thinly sliced pear. Then just as it’s almost done, some sprinkled Parmesan on the outside of the bread and put it back on the heat so it turns into little Parmesan crisps.

[-]

Ulfgeirr88@reddit

Left over chilli with grated cheese

[-]

Marilliana@reddit

Feta cheese, good quality thin sliced ham, Branston pickle. It's sooo tasty!

[-]

CriticismHopeful4180@reddit

Beans, sausage and bacon (pre cook those last two). Make it a cooked breakfast toasite

[-]

helpmaboabjings@reddit

I did something like this once with a George foreman so it wasn't sealed...I still remember the burning hot beans and black pudding falling out into my bare foot. Lessons were learnt that day

[-]

Ok_Leadership_2967@reddit

Bacon, Brie and cranberry sauce

[-]

Scrunthorpe@reddit

Bolognaise and cheese is my number one

[-]

IP-Writing@reddit

Tinned sardines (in tomato sauce), jalapeños and cheese (cheddar)

[-]

EddieIzzardOnToast@reddit

The Birria beef toastie they serve at the Lounges is 10/10

[-]

unbelievablydull82@reddit

Rays BBQ sauce, BBQ chicken, jalapenos, spinach, cheese, pickled pink onions

[-]

helpmaboabjings@reddit

Sweet baby jesus...let the feasting commence

[-]

Least_Temperature_23@reddit

Smoked cheese & plum jam. The jam was home made and quite tart. Amazing!

[-]

MrsJBB@reddit

Bolognese sauce and lots of cheese!

[-]

lizzie_knits@reddit

Oooooooohhhhh

[-]

helpmaboabjings@reddit

Chilli con carne with maybe some yoghurt and guacamole? I did this once with salsa and found the salsa a bit sweet but I imagine guacamole and yoghurt or sour cream etc with a mix of cheddar and mozzarella would be great

[-]

TremorThief12@reddit

Bacon and peanut butter, bacon, brie and fig, cheese, tomato, onion and chutney.

[-]

Gogsgogford28@reddit

Savoury mince and cheese.

[-]

Eukonidor_Of_Arisia@reddit

Vintage cheddar & jalepenos
Beef & Brie
Tuna & Parma Violets

[-]

JocastaH-B@reddit

If he likes it, apple and mincemeat

[-]

bopeepsheep@reddit

Caramelised onion houmous and thinly sliced sharp cheddar. They merge into a really rich cheese and onion goop.

[-]

coraIinejones@reddit

Pesto, seasoned chicken and cheese!

[-]

Adept_Butterfly_6742@reddit

Watch the film Chef together and make the toastie they do. Basically ham and cheese but very delicious

[-]

Used-Let7134@reddit

Branston pickle and cheddar

Red onion and apple wood smoked

Cheese, mayo and ketchup (hot mayo is surprisingly tasty)

Worcester sauce and chedder

[-]

Shams_the_only@reddit

Came here to say Branston pickle and cheddar ( I prefer mine smooth)

[-]

Used-Let7134@reddit

The smooth one does spread a lot more evenly

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

Definitely on board with hot mayo

[-]

Katharinemaddison@reddit

Fruit pastels.

[-]

Even_Passenger_3685@reddit

Lived on toasties as a student in the 90s, there isn’t much you can’t put in them tbh. However the classics are always the best - savoury; cheese and ham or cheese and very finely diced onion, sweet; strawberry jam (but it’s like lava so be careful, so worth it tho)

[-]

Petcai@reddit

In construction form:-

Bread

Cheese

Bacon

Sliced jalapenos

Bacon

Cheese

Bread

[-]

Breaking-Dad-@reddit

As a kid my mum made them with tinned pilchards (in tomato sauce) and onion. It’s surprisingly good if you like pilchards although the onion slices turn it to burning strings of fire so wait a while before tucking in.

[-]

Instabanous@reddit

The post Christmas turkey, brie and cranberry. But I would say use that pattern to your taste- some meat, some cheese, and some kind of preserve.

[-]

ErmahgerdPerngwens@reddit

I love this, with some gravy for dipping.

[-]

Ironfields@reddit

Good, high quality ham, mozzarella and a bit of chilli jam. Keeping it simple is the best way when it comes to toasties.

[-]

euqi@reddit

Pastrami, cheddar, kimchi, gherkins, mustard mayo on good white sourdough.

[-]

luala@reddit

Get the M&S marmite cheddar, grate and mix with some regular cheddar. Very good with a tomato chutney or caramelised onion relish.

[-]

Jenpot@reddit

It's not fancy, but some decent bread, smoked sausage and the nicest cheddar you can find.

[-]

acedias-token@reddit

Salami, mature cheddar and viking pepper sauce or english mustard.

Something is special about salami, when you cook it the flavour changes. Even outside of the toastie filling spec, air fry salami for a few minutes until crispy and it'll serve well as a bacon alternative.

[-]

ecapapollag@reddit

Tomato puree on one slice (thin scraping) grated cheese with chopped spring onions and thin ribbons of ham. Change the cheese to experiment- cheddar, red Leicester, mozzarella, Gruyere etc.

[-]

Party-Werewolf-4888@reddit

I made a roast dinner toastie yesterday. Carrot & swede mash, parsnips, potato and sliced lamb (well, fake lamb coz im a vegan) plus a bit of gravy instead of butter. Cranberry sauce post toast. We toastie everything in our house 🤣

[-]

Green_List@reddit

Turkey, cheese, tabasco sriracha!

[-]

Zal_17@reddit

Thai 7/11s are famous for their toasties as a late night (or anytime really) snack.

Have a look at the below link see if you get any inspiration from theirs (I loved their cream cheese spinach)

Hawaiian pizza flavour may be a good shout. Carbonara in garlic bread too. Some ingredients will be too exotic to find easily but a lot will be doable!

https://www.cktravels.com/thailand-7-eleven-toasties-guide/.

[-]

Munchkinpea@reddit

Halloumi and sweet chilli chutney.

Brie and grapes. Maybe with bacon.

Cheese and Marmite.

[-]

Generally-Knackered@reddit

I top mine with bechamel sauce and do them in the airfryer

[-]

Pitiful_Shoulder9730@reddit

I once had a bite out of a £300+ toastie made by some private chef. Genuinely insane.

Been a few years so can remember the exact ingredients but it was a bunch of different high end cheeses topped with caviar and I think maybe truffle shavings. It was ridiculous, never worth £300 out of your own money but a damn good toastie.

[-]

Curly_Edi@reddit

Pesto chicken and ham hock

[-]

X2seraphim@reddit

I had a chicken Balti toastie last week it was really good.

[-]

Maentwrog@reddit

Ham, cheese, Nando's Piri Piri sauce

[-]

Sips_from_bottles@reddit

Look up toastie roulette. But also brie, bacon, and red onion chutney or chilli jam.

[-]

RollingKatamari@reddit

There's a girl on Instagram Star Holroyd who did a whole series on making toasties with the most insane ingredients, look up her toastie roulette videos! Some combos were banging...others not so much😂

[-]

ruddymarvellous@reddit

Savoury - very thin spread of tomato puree, sour cream, smoked salmon, dill

Sweet - apple and cinnamon

[-]

thehewguy1888@reddit

Mac and cheese toastie from the Cheesy toast shack in St Andrews

[-]

Bellatrixforqueen@reddit

Bolognase and cheese

[-]

Single_Classroom_448@reddit

shredded chicken, fresh bits of mozzarella, dried tomatoes and a dash of green pesto on one side is fucking lush

[-]

irv81@reddit

Corned beef and cheese is my favourite

[-]

Large_Reindeer_7328@reddit

Strawberry, banana, good chocolate spread. For savoury, I don't think you can beat ham with a couple types of cheese and a nice sauce, sweet chilli or something like that.

[-]

willp2003@reddit

We like salt and pepper chicken thighs (from Sainsbury’s) sliced up and some cheddar.

[-]

PaperShoesWontWork@reddit

Haggis and cheese with brown sauce

[-]

Electronic-Fennel828@reddit

Leftover bolognese and some mozzarella for a pizza toastie

[-]

Cockfield@reddit

Can't go wrong with a bacon and cheese toastie.

[-]

giraffe_cake@reddit

Crumbly Lancashire with pickled jalapeños slices.

Classic ham and cheese. Sometimes I put onion on if I fancy it.

Make sure you butter both sides of the bread!

[-]

InfiniteBaker6972@reddit

Do you have a Breville? Baked beans and cheese with a bit of marmite. You will have to wait 6 hours after toasting because it will be hotter than the inside of a nuclear reactor for a good while after.

[-]

soulsteela@reddit

Eggy bread n bacon.

[-]

Vespa_Alex@reddit

This toastie, from this cafe in Budapest. Perfection on a plate.

https://zileat.hu/en#menu

[-]

Illustrious-Bus-8862@reddit

Cheddar and horseraddish.

[-]

Intrepid_Bearz@reddit

Jaggery (palm sugar) - use the darker kind, not the light one that has poor flavour

[-]

CtrlShiftAaron@reddit

Chicken bacon cheese and mushroom

[-]

lucyuktv@reddit

Cheese and haggis.

[-]

Samuraisheep@reddit

Tuna cheese and sweet chilli sauce Obvs beans and cheese is superior

[-]

Disastrous_Dig4002@reddit

Cream cheese and mushroom- pan fry mush with a bit of veg stock then add cream cheese once cooked. Cheddar when filling and into toastie maker. The best.

[-]

Greedy_Investigator7@reddit

Cheese and marmite 🤤

[-]

davedinho@reddit

Chocolate spread and a thick slice of chocolate swiss roll.

[-]

ArtificialPigeon@reddit

Bacon, brie and Branston pickle.

Sausage, chestnut mushrooms, beans and cheese (sometimes with a splash of Lea & Perrins)

Prosciutto, spinach and Mozarella.

[-]

PengyLi@reddit

Some good quality ham, and a squidgy blue cheese like gorgonzola, add in onions and gherkins for a sharp crunch.

[-]

TraditionalScheme337@reddit

This is a bit christmassy but bacon, sausage, cranberry sauce and a strong cheddar.

[-]

HugsforCuddles@reddit

Crack an egg open, and a bit of chilli sauce and grated cheese - delicious!

[-]

Suffolkman2026@reddit

No question : baked beans and corned beef

[-]

ultimateberk@reddit

Ham and cheese. Its timeless. I do also enjoy a sliced beef and cheese toastie with dijon mustard

[-]

Pitiful_Land_3813@reddit

Macaroni

[-]

BandicootSecret8012@reddit

Fish paste doesn't work!..trust me 🥴😂😂😂

[-]

cockatilla87@reddit

Brie, bacon and cranberry sauce 🤤.

[-]

HopeTheresPudding@reddit

Sliced tomato, Mrs Balls chutney, mature cheddar, salt pepper and some fresh finely chopped basil. Delish!

[-]

ItsKingDx3@reddit

tuna and banana

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

[-]

ItsKingDx3@reddit

You know, fair. But you wanted a surprise.

[-]

potato2296@reddit (OP)

Fair point it definitely is surprising

[-]

When replying to submission/post please make genuine efforts to answer the question given. Please no jokes, judgements, etc. If a post is marked 'Serious Answers Only' you may receive a ban for violating this rule.
Don't be a dick to each other. If getting heated, just block and move on.
This is a strictly no-politics subreddit!

Please help us by reporting comments that break these rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.