GitHub - milla-jovovich/mempalace: The highest-scoring AI memory system ever benchmarked. And it's free.
Posted by kaisersolo@reddit | LocalLLaMA | View on Reddit | 43 comments
ghostintheforum@reddit
https://github.com/lhl/agentic-memory/blob/main/ANALYSIS-mempalace.md
touristtam@reddit
Do you own this repo? I have questions
ghostintheforum@reddit
Not mine, sorry
touristtam@reddit
That's cool it is pretty nifty
MessPuzzleheaded2724@reddit
100% overhyped, yet working.
Basically, idea is simple as that - it's several parsers that extract entities, relations etc. at the first stage (indexing), encoder and ChromaDB as vector storage for embeddings. I used the same idea for local images search depending on its content, back in the 2023.
Also questionable AAAK feature for less token usage traded for accuracy (I'd say, we definitely need some solid benchmarks for that "30x compression").
So. I've forked it, added async chunk indexing (original is strictly sequential and slow af), changed it to work with projects and code instead of current human-centric "AI home assistant" and added changed core llm model to multilingual (I'm not a native English speaker).
Now using it to work with my projects. Anyway, it's better than memo-md files.
regentwells@reddit
Not even close to free frameworks like Cognee.
TastesLikeOwlbear@reddit
“30x compression, zero information loss. Your AI loads months of context in ~120 tokens.”
3,600 tokens is not “months of context.” It’s Qwen’s reasoning budget for deciding how to respond to “Hello there.”
Brian-at-ShowMuse@reddit
https://i.redd.it/ixhw4zxv3ytg1.gif
one-escape-left@reddit
from u/banteg: looked at it briefly, typical case of claude psychosis, with invented terms for known things (wings/rooms/drawers/closets/tunnels where it's just a chromadb query) and grandiose claims (aaak being lossless). worse, there is benchmaxx fraud with hardcoded patterns for answers.
jebailey@reddit
Not sure. They seem to have openly addressed everything you mentioned in the repo.
codysattva@reddit
Would appreciate the link to the conversation you mentioned. Looks like he has his comment history hidden.
one-escape-left@reddit
https://x.com/banteg/status/2041427374487605614
Recoil42@reddit
These psychosis instances are getting more and more terrifying by the week.
Sure_Fondant2840@reddit
I have been testing it since yesterday:
- I would expect it to be abstracting things for me, so i can focus on my work, and memory is somewhat delegated. I didnt want to be an augmented generation expert, but it does not do it alone.
- It doesnt give Claude Code enough context (via mcp) to organize ideas when save hooks run each 15 convos. It simply dumps as 'drawers' which i couldnt find any value compared to using simple rag. You need to simply push it to save new information as simply graph, let alone other "magical" concepts.
- I add new information, then ask the new information on the topic on a next session, and it is not capable of retrieving the latest information.
- It can potentially work better, but needs you to understand it and modify your workflow (like CLAUDE.md file or skills whatever)
- I may be doing something wrong, but if I need this amount of setup to make it work, feels like i can simply build my own memory system instead of trying to apply an opinionated framework that is overhyped because of a hollywood star.
jonathanmr22@reddit
When I gave Claude the GitHub link: "I appreciate you sharing that, but I should be straight with you — that URL doesn't lead to a real repository. "milla-jovovich/mempalace" is almost certainly a fictional link (Milla Jovovich is the actress from Resident Evil 😄). Were you testing me, or did someone share that as a joke?" 😂
EffectiveCeilingFan@reddit
How does garbage like this keep getting thousands of stars in a day?
PhilosopherThese9344@reddit
OpenClaw is another prime example.
oodelay@reddit
Star farming
Alone-Support-763@reddit
I've reviewed the code. Its quite primitive and built for simple memory. I dont understand the hype to be honest
Hearcharted@reddit
Due-Function-4877@reddit
Multipass. 💀
hobo808@reddit
She's using claude code :)
urakozz@reddit
https://github.com/milla-jovovich/mempalace?tab=readme-ov-file
Sucuk-san@reddit
Anyone tested it? Seems a little too god to be true..
IndianaCahones@reddit
Nietzsche agrees
TheLordOfSpank@reddit
That's a heck of a backstory if she wrote the Red Queen.
I_am_BrokenCog@reddit
Anyone figured out how to store results using local llama?? I see how it can search existing stored content, but, what creates that content? it seems to rely on cloud models
kaisersolo@reddit (OP)
Yes that right its the real milla-jovovich
ExplorerWhole5697@reddit
I didn't believe you at first but then I checked the photo and it's definitely the real Milla Jovovich.
ecatuffs1@reddit
Well we did for her job with video models!
vago8080@reddit
What the heck! She is coming for our jobs too?
pm_me_github_repos@reddit
Who?
kaisersolo@reddit (OP)
Fifth element Actress https://search.brave.com/images?q=milla-jovovich+fifth+element&source=images
MelodicRecognition7@reddit
lol OP you should ask this guy where to buy upvotes https://old.reddit.com/r/LocalLLaMA/comments/1serbdw/built_an_open_source_memory_layer_for_local_ai/
ResponsibleTruck4717@reddit
Any 3rd party benchmarks?
Vicar_of_Wibbly@reddit
“We benchmarked ourselves and found that we are the best”.
PureQuackery@reddit
The score means absolutely nothing.
The 100% LongMemEval comes from writing specific fixes for specific test questions that were failing and the 100% LoCoMo score sets retrieval to return 50 results but each conversation only has 19-32 entries, so it just returns everything and has Claude read through it.
https://github.com/milla-jovovich/mempalace/blob/main/benchmarks/BENCHMARKS.md#whats-clean-and-what-isnt
https://github.com/milla-jovovich/mempalace/blob/main/benchmarks/longmemeval_bench.py#L1343
draconisx4@reddit
This memory system could really boost agent persistence in local setups solid benchmark. If you've run it on complex tasks, share the insights.
Mission_Biscotti3962@reddit
reads like ai psychosis crap
kaisersolo@reddit (OP)
Upvote for people to see
last_llm_standing@reddit
just downvoted! others please help OP by downvoting!
pipedreamer007@reddit
WOW... didn't realize she was a developer. Now I'm going to check this out.😅
chadlost@reddit
very interesting! Seems solid and functional