Get into groups of four and discuss these results
Posted by Meteorstar101@reddit | greentext | View on Reddit | 704 comments
Posted by Meteorstar101@reddit | greentext | View on Reddit | 704 comments
Lot_a_bay@reddit
What is therapy gonna do for someone who is just ugly.
bustermagnus@reddit
Ugly people find love all the time. Self-pitying misogynists do not. Thinking that having sex will make you healthy is putting the cart before the horse.
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
misogynists are famously single yes as shown by any marriage IRL
Funnyboyman69@reddit
There’s a difference between black pill misogyny and “I hate my wife” boomer misogyny.
slayerx1779@reddit
This is a gut feeling based on experience, but I think those "I hate my wife" boomer jokes are more often than not, playful ribbing between two people who definitely still love each other.
Any man who's best friends with a man knows that if you truly know someone, then you know what jokes you can make at their expense without actually hurting their feelings.
There's a reason we save our most savage roasts for our best friends.
Uniquely-Bee@reddit
Is there? I just think that the old school wife-slap misogyny just doesn't fly nowadays with young women who aren't dependent on a husband for survival
peanutist@reddit
There is, one just thinks women should be subservient to men and the other thinks all women are literal psycopathic hellspawn meant to seduce men and suck all the money out of them (both are wrong just so people don’t think I agree with that).
Uniquely-Bee@reddit
The point is that if you took a "I hate my wife" boomer misogynist and made them 20 yo, they would probably have no success finding a wife this time around. And then they would turn into a blackpilled incel who rationalizes their loneliness with roastie memes
chriszenpaok@reddit
Would depend on how they look
KebabLife2@reddit
Still happens way too much among younger
bustermagnus@reddit
You can be an attractive misogynist or ugly and healthy, but you have to pick
eldryanyy@reddit
I think ugly misogynists do way better lol, let’s be real
drwicksy@reddit
Confident ugly mysoginists do better than u confident people generally.
Confidence is usually the main factor as it not only opens you up to more possible matches by, you know, actually talking to women, and it also doesnt come off as desperate and pathetic like being unconfident does.
2836382929@reddit
An unconfident attractive misogynist will do better than a confident ugly one. Attractiveness is the most important factor.
FunnyP-aradox@reddit
Depends on HOW MUCH he's attractive/ungly and confident or not, but no overall confidence is more useful than attractiveness - signed, an attractive (at least what i'm been told) VERY unconfident person
2836382929@reddit
If you have the view that confidence is more useful than attractiveness, you probably aren’t truly attractive 😭 “just be confident bro”
drwicksy@reddit
If you think a kid who had to google how to talk to a girl was showing any kind of actual confidence during that conversation I have a fee Bridges to sell you
2836382929@reddit
If he was 6’5 and attractive no one would gaf what he was doing, that’s the entire point I’m making
drwicksy@reddit
The image you posted has no mention of if he is attractive or not, only that a clearly unconfident guy got rejected, proving MY point
2836382929@reddit
You can look up the article, there’s a picture of him attached.
drwicksy@reddit
Ok... so you have proven neither of our points then. Because he was both unattractive and unconfident.
Attractiveness absolutely plays a part, anyone who claims otherwise is high on copium, but my argument is that confidence plays a BIGGER part. Because I have seen and heard of plenty of unattractive guys who get WAY more women than I do as a semi attractive guy, because they are more confident than me. And even as someone who is apparently quite attractive to some women I had very little success with women (read none) until I finally came put of my shell and gained some confidence.
2836382929@reddit
Attractive people literally get out of jail for grand theft purely for being attractive and you think it’s far fetched that they still get romantic success despite “not being confident”.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jeremy_Meeks
If this guy was attractive and did the exact same things he did, he would be perceived as confident. Learn what the halo effect is.
If they’re getting more women, then how are you so sure you’re semi attractive?
drwicksy@reddit
You are fighting a whole ass strawman here my dude. I never said attractiveness isnt an advantage, I never said it doesnt make you more successful in things that you might not be if you are ugly. I simply said that confidence is MORE important. An ugly guy with confidence is likely to have more success romantically than an attractive person who is a confidence black hole. If nothing else simply because of the fact that a confident person will interact more with people, including women, and therefore have more opportunities.
Women dont just appear in front of you you have to go our and find them, and some 6"4 hot guy who shuts himself inside all day and doesnt go out to meet women is unlikely to easily get with them, whereas the ugly guy who goes out to bars every night, talks to women, and is generally pleasant to talk to, will get with women simply by process of elimination.
I gauge my own attractiveness on what others have told me, and from that I gauge i am kind of attractive. I am not super handsome but I do ok. And until I was about 27-28 I had basically zero self confidence. And because of that I had very little romantic success. I didn't lose my virginity until I was 21 and that was mostly a fluke of finding the right girl at the right time. I just didnt know how to talk to women, and when i did I was so full of self pity and social anxiety that I just wasnt pleasant to be around, and so women didnt stick around me and I didnt have the opportunity to gain more confidence in speaking to them, it was a vicious cycle.
But after a specific event in my life I gained a lot of confidence and at that point I noticed I got significantly more attention from women, simply from exuding social confidence which is a very attractive trait.
I also knew guys all throughout university who were objectively worse looking than me, some even i would say were "ugly", and even when we would go out as a group the women would go home with them and not me because they had confidence and I didnt, it was that simple.
But the biggest factor, and I cant stress this enough, is that women, are human. They have preferences, desires, likes and dislikes just like anyone else. Some woman's ugly might be another womans attractive, some women are really into specific races, some women are really not into specific races. Some women want a short fat guy, some want a tall skinny guy. My first real girlfriend's type was tall skinny nerdy guys and she was way more conventionally attractive than me.
Yes there are some traits that are more statistically likely to be seen as attractive but the incel mindset seems to place women as a hivemind that will literally never date someone who doesnt have those traits.
2836382929@reddit
And that's where you're wrong. An attractive person who's "unconfident" will be considered "quiet and sensitive" rather than unconfident. The lack of confidence will be seen as endearing rather than as a negative attribute, that's what the halo effect is.
Being short is commonly viewed as unattractive for men. When a short man is "confident", it's seen as "short man syndrome" or a "napoleon complex", simply because they are unattractive. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Napoleon_complex
Compare this to if a tall man (as being tall is viewed as more attractive for men) acting the same way. There's no such thing as "tall man syndrome", because these traits are simply viewed as attractive BECAUSE the person is attractive.
Your anecdotal evidence really means nothing unless you can provide actual sources back up your claims.
The below source demonstrates how both men and women value attractiveness over confidence when it comes to finding a partner.
https://ink.library.smu.edu.sg/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1717&context=soss_research
drwicksy@reddit
But that goes against your point though... he was attractive but not confident so wasnt successful. So surely that means confidence IS the important part
No_Adhesiveness_5727@reddit
Wait till you are called misogynist while on a wiretap or a phone or computer or god knows what and you will regret it...
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
makes for a diverse meta I guess
SapirWhorfHypothesis@reddit
I just really enjoy seeing all the different builds people come up with.
Mackejuice@reddit
Some people mask their actual emotions better then others.
I have seen so many people get charmed just to later find out how abusive the person who wooed them actually were.
It is just another form of "masking", hiding away your actual self to make yourself nore presentable.
At the point where they reveal their destructive tendencies emotional reliance and bond is already complete, which explains how so many sticks around in abusive relationships.
Competitive_Sky8182@reddit
Also, pregnancy, mortgage and isolation
WintersbaneGDX@reddit
Instead, try putting your cock before the horseface.
SonTyp_OhneNamen@reddit
Be aware that horses eat baby carrots. There is hope.
saketho@reddit
Eric Cartman does this in an episode right?
miluielmclovin@reddit
He feeds them sausages - it’s the episode when he kills that guys parents
plarah@reddit
I like that each comment is more unhinged than the last. Damn Cartman
miluielmclovin@reddit
That episode made me realise how ruthless and calculating Cartman can actually be sometimes, easily my top 3 characters of the show
Beowulf33232@reddit
I only catch the occasional but when someone leaves the breakroom tv on the right channel.
What made me see him for who he is in modern episodes is when the therapist made fun of him for being fat to test his temper and he just typed away on his phone. The therapist decided he didn't have a temper, then the therapists wife called him accusing him of cheating, and ended her life during the phone call. Cartman just looked at him and said "I'm not fat." and the scene ended.
What made me realize it back when the show was new was people talking about how he was a bad person and the show creators saying "Yeah, we hate him, he's horrible, that's the point. Nobody is supposed to like him."
ThisUsernameis21Char@reddit
With a minor, specifically
miluielmclovin@reddit
Yeah that’s a prime example of him being a horrible person, I forgot about that ep until you’ve just mentioned it
saketho@reddit
Its a fantastic episode. every moment of it is genius. Even the money exchange joke where they go back and forth is so fucking funny i remember pausing and rewinding that bit like 100 times.
PotatoDominatrix@reddit
Not just killed them.
He killed them, turned them into chili, then fed them to their child because the kid sold Cartman his pubes.
enjaysm@reddit
10/10, the right horseface will garge balls right to the taint 10/10 times.
thereoncewasahat@reddit
I don't mind horsefaced girls because I associate them with the aristocracy; and the cut glass enlgish accent turns me on bigly.
DistributistChakat@reddit
Something something inbreeding for the sake of the lineage
imhere2downvote@reddit
when i heard 'a little bit of the in and out' one time that shit was immediately fried into my smooth brain forever. let me tell you i immediately forget my next action entering different rooms
Kaikeno@reddit
Sounds like a surefire way to become a eunuch
JackFuckCockBag@reddit
Amen bro! I'm busted as hell but still found an attractive wife.
Chonboy@reddit
Self pitying people not so much but misogynists get laid all the time if you are pretty enough to look at and can lie well enough your personality is irrelevant women ignore crazy red flags for dudes they want to fuck genuine rapists abusers any form of hate they dig it as long as they are attracted to you
If you are ugly like truly ugly and full of self hatred with no confidence and no ability to manipulate them yes women won't like you but let's not pretend misogyny has ever come into play lol
bustermagnus@reddit
The way you talk about women it sounds like you don't recognize them as humans. They have thoughts and preferences and interiority just like you do. Yes they can act illogical and be manipulated, also just like you. Your perception of women as this alien stereotype is both a failure of empathy and an indication of being terminally online.
Chonboy@reddit
Why should I feel empathy for things they themselves put themselves into repeatedly you can't make repeat mistakes and expect everyone else to feel for you
There is also no empathy for men from their end no empathy or sympathy for male victims nothing but shame and mockery
Why is my side expected to be the bigger person when women as a whole are incapable of it why are men held accountable for their actions but not women lol just food for thought
bustermagnus@reddit
You are holding an entire gender accountable for individual failings that aren't even unique to women. The calumnies you believe about women are based on your own biases, not any actual trait inherent in or exclusive to the female sex. You have invented a villain in order to reframe your own prejudice as self defense. There is no my side or their side, there is only you making up excuses to attack people you don't even know.
Chonboy@reddit
The day women are capable of feeling responsibility or hell accountability for any of their actions will be the day I give a fuck until then they can keep any of their privileged bullshit to themselves
bustermagnus@reddit
That caricature of women is a figment of your ignorance that exists only inside your own head. Nowhere does anything having to do with actual women factor in. It's that same level of irrational as blaming somebody for something that happened in a dream you had.
Chonboy@reddit
As I said they don't take accountability
bustermagnus@reddit
A person can do things and have agency and take accountability. A gender cannot. You may as well see a criminal wearing glasses and blame everybody else who also happens to wear glasses.
Chonboy@reddit
There is a difference between one gender or the other on the expectation of accountability that is the problem lol
Women are not held responsible for their actions by any metric that's the problem
Men are responsible for their choices and immediately held accountable it's just two different worlds there isn't much else to be said
bustermagnus@reddit
The woman you are imagining when you say that women do this or that is a part of your imagination. You invented her, you attributed your prejudices to her, and you use her to justify your hatred of actual living people. Women cannot be described using personality traits because in real life there is more than one women and they are all different from one another. Things like responsibility and accountability are concepts that apply to people, not genders.
popmyhotdog@reddit
This is pathetic cope we have studies showcasing this as true. You just cannot admit it because then it would be a criticisms of women which is not allowed at any cost. Study after study show women get arrested less for committing the same crime as men and charged less for being found guilty of the same crime. This is quite literally a direct way in which people are given accountability and across a gender there is a continuous tilt for one side having less as shown again and again than another. You can lie and try and play semantics but given the same situation and circumstances and outcome a woman is punished less frequently and less harshly than a man for the same action I.e. they are not held accountable to the same degree
bustermagnus@reddit
I am talking about personal prejudice and discrimination against women. You are talking about external societal forces that affect women. It's two different conversations
something-somone@reddit
"You do it too!"
Has never been a good retort to anything ever.
Aromatic_Oil9698@reddit
crippling self-confidence issues -> no pussy -> crippling self-confidence issues -> no pussy -> etc.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
The biggest bullshit I heard this week. How someone can even formulate such words and don't understand how idiotic they are?
SolidPrysm@reddit
I know plenty of married people that are what many would consider to be ugly. You need to go outside.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
What's the connexion? I never said that "ugly people don't get married". What I tried to said it that's extremely idiotic to think that only good people have good life, and all people that have it bad they deserve it. So, by your logic, domestic violance doesn't exist? Do you know how offensive and arrogant it is for ANYONE who experienced this? Or maybe you think that anyone who experienced domestic violance deserved it? You really have such primitive, crude sense of morality? Also, you REALLY do believe that there is ABSOLUTELY no difference in quality of life of very attractive people and very unattractive ones?
SolidPrysm@reddit
Did you mean to respond to a different comment or is there a gas leak in your house somewhere?
Kaszalot1352@reddit
No, this comment was for you, and everyone else in this conversation
new_KRIEG@reddit
By saying the truth? Like, are you fucking blind or just never left your home for more than 5 minutes? You'll see some fucking abhorrent looking dudes in relationships all the time.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Can you fucking read with understanding? Where did I wrote that ugly people can't be in relationships? It was only about your primitive, tribalistic sense of morality and justice, that all good people are rewarded and all bad people are punished. Do you know that by your logic domestic violance doesn't exist and everyone who experienced this is propably a bad person and deserves it? Also, even a monkey could understand that good looking people have on average easier lifes compared to ugly people
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
Ugly people do find love and have sex all the time.
Hell, day time TV is full of drama chat shows where some of the ugliest people in the world are fighting over a paternity test.
If you don't wanna trust me, trust your eyes
Kaszalot1352@reddit
You're playing dumb or can't read? Where did I said that ugly people can't be in relationships or have sex?
I__o___o___I@reddit
Blud is straight up wrong, keep malding
bustermagnus@reddit
Your fuck-ass dad had you despite looking like a decayed corpse because he loved your mother. You are single because you are incapable of empathizing with women.
Jakefiz@reddit
Ugliness is on the inside. Sometimes you are dealt a bad hand physically but theres so much you can do hygiene and health wise to improve yourself, but at the end of the day you can be an Adonis and if you have a black pilled bigoted shit personality you still wont find love.
Turbulent-Armadillo9@reddit
Also one more thing. Therapy did helped with dating (I’m average looking). Therapist told me not to try to date someone who totally lights me up. He told me to go on dates with people who just turn up the dimmers dial on me a little. Basically said “it’s not worth the pressure and puts you on an in-level playing field in the relationship”. I think that advice really worked for me. I want to be with people who love me not someone I worship and and anxiety ridden over keeping them around.
Turbulent-Armadillo9@reddit
Good point. I have 3 lonely, sad, male coworkers. All they do to get a gf is swipe on tinder and they will swipe left on 8s. Like bros, you are all 5s or less, and factoring in your personalities don’t help…. but if you keep swiping on a fucking app one of these days youll bag a hip, smart 9?
I even tried to explain this nicely to one of them. He said something like “if I’m not totally physically attracted to someone there is no point in going on a date”. Alrighty then you will most likely stay single don’t know what to tell you.
ZachF8119@reddit
Nah, tons of ugly women still think they’re 10s
I called myself a 3 recently because I’m fat, and in ozembic days it’s even more of a bad thing opposed to when I was 8 and being put on a “fat free” sugar replaced in foods diet.
It’s hard to find a fellow 3 thats like yeah this is us.
Res_Novae17@reddit
It happens, but not "all the time." And they need to MAJORLY bring something else to the table. They need to have exceptional social standing, like being a famous podcaster, or make serious money, or be unbelievably charming and funny.
Sultahid@reddit
Brother, stop worrying about Internet people and just go outside and look around. Plenty of ugly people in happy relationships because its not actually that deep if youre not stuck in incel echo chambers.
Res_Novae17@reddit
Me? No I'm not worried. I'm married with a kid. But I know what I see.
It's frustrating that you can't notice how much harder it is in the dating market to be an average guy than an average girl without people calling you a bitter incel. I did the work to climb out of the crab bucket, but that doesn't mean the work didn't have to be done.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Nah, just old couples. Very rare to see actual young men outside with girlfriends.
f0rm4n@reddit
I've know plenty of plumbers/truck drivers/electricians/unemployed guys who get laid like crazy despite being ugly af. One of the dudes who I know for a fact constantly gets laid(because he boasts about it a ton in the boys' chat, lucky bastard) is a bald fat guy, who's been bald and fat literally since his early 20's, his bodycount is probably around 50 at this point lol
I also know some guys who are objectively attractive but don't put themselves out there, so they don't have a social life despite their looks. Some of them actually don't give a shit about dating in general and are perfectly content with sitting at home, playing Steins Gate, watching anime or some shit.
A lot of dudes get by on being confident despite their looks or being passionate about stuff, or being helpful, or being funny. There's nothing unbelievable about those interpersonal skills either, it's just a thing that guys had to develop to be competitive on the dating market since the dawn of time.
I know for a fact that I don't possess none of those skills(yet?), but I know enough people who are worse looking then me who started families and found success in dating in general to know that the problem isn't with my looks(it's with literally everything else lmao)
TopptrentHamster@reddit
You're probably not going to bag an 8/10, but that doesn't mean you can't find love.
Satisfying_Fog17@reddit
Reducing the problem of inceldom in its very integrity to a mass of men being 'self-pitying' misogynists' is a dangerous generalization. A few screenshots carefully picked to portray the absolute worst of forums and threads dedicated to involuntary celibate men most certainly will give you the wrong idea of what an 'incel' truly is. No man is prone to be hateful for no reason; the hatred you see derives from years of constant solitude and rejection, from women and often society. Not everyone is able to endure such loneliness.
EquivalentSnap@reddit
Exactly. If you don’t love yourself you shouldn’t expect someone else to. Especially if you hate women and want to use them for sex. Sex doesn’t change you shit opinions or your mindset. There’s people who have sex and still lonely
Therapy doesn’t work if you don’t put the effort in yourself. They give you advice doesn’t work if you don’t follow it
LesserValkyrie@reddit
"Ugly people find love all the time"
Says the 9/10 person who consider "ugly" a tall man with a squared jaw but an ugly scar and whose brain is programmed to totally make disappear from its perception the 95% of the uglier men they see lol
frb26@reddit
Have you ever been outside ? There is no shortage of partnered ugly people
KortFulBlatte@reddit
There absolutely is if you don't count old couples. Young ugly guys aren't getting laid.
thegr8cthulhu@reddit
Mfs on here would have people think that when I go to the grocery store it’s just Calvin Klein model couples walking around. It’s a self tell they don’t go outside or get any social interaction lmao.
coworker@reddit
Ugly people find love with other ugly people. Incels don't want another ugly person
Carbonatite@reddit
Sounds like a them problem.
chriszenpaok@reddit
But thinking jaded single men are misogynists defo isn't putting the cart before the horse!
Foxy552@reddit
"Jarvis, I'm low on karma"
Ada_Pearce@reddit
Yeah but they have to be willing to date other ugly people and many incels only want women out of their league
kol6Figueiras@reddit
You can be misogynistic as shit and still lay pipe lol. Self-pity is way worse for dating than seeing women as sub-humans.
Interstate-8-@reddit
Big difference between normal ugly and incel level ugly
Mar3czek@reddit
A lot of incels are slightly below mid if not straight up average.
Unfunnycommenter_@reddit
Autism detracts your attractiveness by lile 4 points tho
heresjolly@reddit
This is true, I'd be a 7 or 8 easily if I wasn't socially r-slurred by autism.
Petabik@reddit
Thinking that autism is killing your attractiveness is the same kind of incel mentality as "my genes suck I'm forever ugly". Then you look at people who say that shit and notice they don't follow basic hygiene, dress like they never leave their room, and never met a barber. Fucking Chris-chan managed to pull off decent looks when they dressed in something else than crap from Salvation Army or Goodwill.
I have an autistic friend who managed to get a girlfriend through fucking Danganronpa and Resident Evil, so much so that it turned into a monkey's paw when she wouldn't stop fantasizing about getting Leon pregnant. Autism can get you HELLA rizz if you get through the difficulties of learning social skills. I'm not saying it's easy, I'm just saying have a little faith
Interstate-8-@reddit
those people may call themselves incels but they aren't incels
mbmiller94@reddit
Or maybe it's their attitude, personality and lack of self awareness that makes them incels. And they usually don't call themselves as incels, they just out themselves by ranting.
Mar3czek@reddit
I'm not taking about people who a) can't get laid b) are misogynists. No matter which definition you choose, they're incels. I believe these truly ugly ones are called "trucells" and "subhumans" in the jargon.
kaninkanon@reddit
Just b urself
Nezikim@reddit
I even have a daughter. Luckily she isn't ugly.
For real though I'm just fat.
gabetoloco2@reddit
I was trying to win the throne to save the kingdom when I was supposed to save the kingdom to win the throne
arbiter12@reddit
I'm sensing a lot of anger in you that is somewhat parallel to the incels' one. This weird obsession with mental health, misogyny, sex, etc is raising some concerns.
In my experience the "incels" and the "ravenous anti-incels" are basically the same sort of insufferable people, just on the other end of the horseshoe.
bustermagnus@reddit
6/10 bait, I did do the eyebrow thing
mbmiller94@reddit
This one?
SnakeOilPlagueDoctor@reddit
Cope
SmoothPimp85@reddit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jon_Brower_Minnoch
Yes, morbidly obese people are very ugly (sexually repulsive, among the least suitable candidates for coupling).
ayriuss@reddit
You only get that fat by finding someone to emotionally abuse, to be fair.
PointOfTheJoke@reddit
Imagine if they were 5'11"
zombieGenm_0x68@reddit
no way, its OP's mom
thereoncewasahat@reddit
The problem is, nobody in the system is going to tell them that, yes, you're ugly and you're going to have to make the best of it.
Because then they're in trouble; and/or they don't want to admit to themselves that this is the truth.
'Ye, you're fucked, mate' isn't going to be said.
tobitobiguacamole@reddit
Most of human society is about not saying the quiet part out loud
ayriuss@reddit
Or outright dishonest denial of the quiet parts and demonizing anyone who has a different opinion as hurting society.
arbiter12@reddit
Is it really this bad though?
I see a lot of dudes confusing "attractive" and "good looking" (mostly because we're attracted to looks). Attraction is situational, good looks are genetic. The girls banging the drummer of a group that has 50 fans are clearly finding him attractive from his "status", not because he's a 10.
Chicks seem to be quite forgiving of looks, considering the hotties i see, dating truly mediocre-looking dudes. Not particularly rich dudes either. Charming and attractive, but not rich or hot.
You can be ugly or boring or no-passion, but you can't be all three at once.
SUDDENLY_VIRGIN@reddit
Dudes just think they "deserve" a 10/10 banging hottie wife without putting in the amount of work required to even pull a 7/10 cutie.
Oh, you're unemployed, don't take care of yourself physically or mentally, and have no sense of humor about your flaws? Wowee I can't wait to see you Anon, I'm so excited to hang out! 🙄
ArchmageIlmryn@reddit
Plus a lot of these guys think said 10/10 hottie will magically fix their problems, because they've blamed all their problems on not getting laid.
I guarantee you that the average incel would go back to being depressed after a month even if they got the perfect 10/10 subservient bangmaid dropped in their lap.
Competitive_Sky8182@reddit
And would blame the woman for all his problems, too.
Glonos@reddit
Tons of 4chan posts where incel does get laid and tells nothing changed if not got worse as now they need to interact with the woman they are getting laid.
Some people think they are miserable being a weeb, when in fact, that is the exact place they want to be, parent’s basement eating chicken tendies and complaining on the internet.
wsdpii@reddit
Why should I put in the work to find someone? They should be putting in the work to find me because I'm such a catch. /s
Mostly a joke but I haven't put in any effort to finding a partner (mostly out of disinterest) and I'm (surprise) still single.
WEASELexe@reddit
I don't think you realize how ugly some of these dudes are. Like at some point it doesn't matter how confident you are or how much money you have because if you're ugly you're ugly, but let's be honest most of these guys don't have money or confidence either.
frb26@reddit
Yeah in most couple in 99% of couples i ever met the guy is considerably less attractive than the girl, women just aren't as focused on visual as males are
Neither-Signature-81@reddit
Do you realize how stupid that sounds??? Just by definition that would be impossible.
TheBraveToast@reddit
This right here. I see so many weird looking dudes married to genuinely cute girls just because they're interesting and dedicated people. Women DO NOT care about looks like men do. Sure, some are super shallow, but it's not like guys who base their partner 90 percent on how fuckable they are.
inspectoroverthemine@reddit
This is an understatement imo. Its insane how much ugly guys can pull if they have skills. I'm more jealous of charisma and genuine charm than looks. When I hit the gym and in shape I'm well above average, but I still have more problems than a lot of guys I know who are less good looking.
Looks put you at a disadvantage- and many women will straight ignore you without engaging, but being good at personal interaction is the make or break.
WaveDash16@reddit
Hitting the gym helps you pull dudes more than women
8696David@reddit
Ehhhh, really depends on what you’re doing in the gym, and what you looked like before. If you started at 115# or 315#, hitting the gym will probably help your prospects quite a bit. But if your goal is just to get jacked as hell, that’s not for women.
liquidmccartney8@reddit
IMO incels becoming a thing is a symptom of much bigger issues in society and we would all do better to take a hard look at why so many young men started to suddenly start viewing themselves as having no chance of measuring up or being happy rather than just telling them that their beliefs are a self fulfilling prophecy. If everyone is conditioned to be obsessed with comparing themselves to others and competing to be better than everyone else, but everyone can't win, what else would you expect to happen?
KingBileygr993@reddit
Thank you. This is great analysis
BannedfromFrontPage@reddit
Fuck man, this is just wrong. Ugly people have excellent standards of life. I know tons of ugly people who are happy. And there are plenty incels who aren’t ugly.
It’s incels’ framing of life which is the cause of the poor standard of life. A lot worship misery and victimhood. If they’re the victim/underdog, then they’re the hero in their narrative and they don’t need to change.
Being alone sucks, don’t get me wrong, but basing your entire life and happiness on one aspect of life is what robs Incels of happiness and, ironically, is the thing that keeps them involuntarily celibate.
Ball_Of_Meat@reddit
Is it fair to say those ugly people who are happy have embraced that they’re just not good looking and made the most of it?
I feel like that’s the big difference. Being in denial and bitter at the world vs. accepting it and making the most of your life regardless.
BannedfromFrontPage@reddit
Maybe? I think some don’t consider themselves ugly because they just don’t look at the world that way or place importance on it. Anecdotally, I know that’s the case for a few people I’ve worked with or am friends with. Most commonly, it’s not that they accept that they’re ugly, but they accept that they aren’t attractive to most people and that someone will find them attractive.
I know that’s sounds like semantics, but I think that’s the healthy was to accept it. If you want to say, “they accept that they’re ugly,” then fine, but the point is the worldview. It isn’t personal and it’s just one characteristic of many.
It’s a viscous cycle though. Having a complex about your attractiveness and the attractiveness of others is a huge turn off. Having low confidence is a huge turn off. Getting rejected or ignored or just the perception that others don’t like you (whether true or not) just feeds that cycle.
frb26@reddit
Vicious*,sorry but i have seen way too many people messing that up lately
BannedfromFrontPage@reddit
Fuckkkkkk, it hurts.
twotokers@reddit
Literally anyone can be a 7/10 if they just put in effort. The real issue is that these people let their “ugliness” on the outside turn into real ugliness on the inside, which is much harder to fix.
MisterGoo@reddit
No, the problem is that psychotherapy is not there to give you the social skills that make you the kind of person that can get a girlfriend. And if your attitude is « it’s women fault anyway », therapy ain’t gonna do shit cause your brain is lost. This is the situation where the flat earthers use a NASA instrument, find that the Earth is round and conclude that the measurements of the instrument must be wrong.
Mishi_Mujago@reddit
Loads of ugly people get laid. Inceldom is at its core, an expression of victim mentality. They blame their dissatisfaction with their lives on external factors as a way of avoiding having to take responsibility for their choices and perceived failures. Therapy wouldn’t work for these people or anyone with a victim mentality because therapy is about giving an individual the opportunity to lay their own thoughts out in front of them and reorganise them. Therapy doesn’t “fix” you, therapy gives you the time and space to “fix” yourself. People in the throes of a victim mentality don’t want to do this, their whole life is structured around not doing this. So of course therapy wouldn’t work for them. Concurrently, the worst thing that could happen to an incel is they get laid coz then what are they going to blame all their problems on?
It’s a stupid story that didn’t need to be done (one thing my psychology lecturer taught me was that just because a study was conducted doesn’t mean it was worth doing, like in anything, some scientists are just shit at their job). But even though the study is silly, it doesn’t invalidate the obvious underlying issues with incels.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Loads of young ugly guys aren't getting laid. The rest of your drivel is just you operating out of the just-world fallacy.
"You MUST be doing something wrong, bro!"
Nope, just being an ugly guy is enough to not get laid nowadays.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Because they spend all their spare time at home, online, gaming. No shit they aren't getting any.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Because they've given up due to being constantly rejected. No young heterosexual guy would rather stay at home wasting time online if they had the opportunity to go out and get laid.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Sure it's hard, staying in and gaming is safe and easy. People prefer the path of least resistance.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Not only is it hard, it's basically impossible for unattractive guys nowadays. They realize that there's no point in trying anymore.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
I see unattractive people together all the time, every single day, everywhere. The difference is they are living life, not wallowing in self pity on reddit.
Mishi_Mujago@reddit
Bullshit. Complete bullshit. Your thinly-veiled anger reeks of fear.
A lot of the frustration expressed towards incels is annoyance that so many young men are standing by in their own way! An you’re so confident in your obviously flawed, illogical misunderstandings. You’re so wrapped up in bitterness and fear and your life is passing you by! And it’s not about getting laid.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Fear of what? You're rambling.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Fear that the problem is you and your own actions/attitudes.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
The problem is my looks, yes. The actions/attitudes that you think are the issue have not been the issue for the millions of attractive men who have 0 problem attracting women.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
That's the cowards way out. Oh it's not my fault. It's easy to blame something out of your control. Like some feminist whinging about the patriarchy holding her down instead of taking responsibility for her own life. It's cringe.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
I just don’t get why you people have such a hard time accepting that some things are outside of one’s control.
If a guy born without legs blames that as why he can’t run a marathon, that’s valid. But if an ugly guy blames his looks for why he’s undesirable to women, you get pissed.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
If you wanna hold on to that toxicity and let it poison your life, that's on you. Take it from a married ugly dude, you can't let your insecurities run your life.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
It's not even about insecurities. I'm simply undesirable to women due to my looks. It's that simple.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
lol ok mate, you can keep being miserable, I'm done wasting time on this
Impassable_Banana@reddit
So how did I get married? Lmao. Cope, stop blaming others and get off the internet.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
So how did I win the lottery and become a billionare? Lmao, cope.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
You're only shooting yourself in the foot.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
My face and height did that.
La_Trousse@reddit
this is the victim mentality they were talking about
Guglielmowhisper@reddit
How do I reduce the difficulty settings on Tinder? Indeed.
_Haza-@reddit
A large majority of people who think they’re ugly, just aren’t. I thought I was. Then I lost weight and I’m working out. I realise now I’m relatively good looking. 9/10 times it’ll be the same for whoever believes they’re ugly.
LordPeebis@reddit
Every guy can be a 7
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Yeah, no.
Faust_the_Faustinian@reddit
Keep self pitying yourself, I'm sure It'll do wonders for you.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Won't make any difference but whatever.
_Haza-@reddit
It literally will though. Physical attraction can be built. Sure things like height, bone structure, skull shape can’t be influenced, but chances are you don’t suffer the tail end of all three.
If you think about it this way, how many people in day to day life do you think are a 9 or a 10? I’d bet it’s probably around 1 in 10. Now count how many people you think would look more attractive if they took care of themselves. Worked out, ate better, slept better (where possible)? I’d suggest at least half of the people you see day to day would benefit from all of those things.
Just because you think only 9s and 10s get female attention, I tell you you’re being force fed the red pill and it’s actively hindering your chances even more. Go out and actually learn what women want (spoiler alert, it’s caregivers, not big macho scary men. Why do you think so many women LOVE putting makeup on men?)
KortFulBlatte@reddit
I actually do suffer from all three, and more.
You can't "build" physical attraction unless you become more attractive through surgery. If she can't even imagine herself sleeping with you after meeting you based on physical attraction, you'll always be second-choice option until a truly attractive guy comes along.
Sure, but unless they're fat, it isn't likely to bring them up significantly in terms of attractiveness. Like a 5 might become a 6 at best. I've already maxed everything out. Still sub5.
They want tall, facially attractive and preferably white men.
_Haza-@reddit
Oh boy, your profile is literally full of this. You can keep being a sad little muppet on the internet the rest of your life, you’ll accomplish a hell of a lot doing that.
And the idea you can’t build physical attractiveness is fundamentally flawed and I’m sorry but you’re an idiot for believing it so.
EquivalentSnap@reddit
Improves your self worth because you’re not ugly. Your state of mind. You’re just average. Changes are you’re not deformed or burnt or facial disfigurement. Even if you do they still find love.
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Your minsdstate is irrelevant, its other people that treat you bad for being ugly
EquivalentSnap@reddit
Then cut those people out your life and have positive friends
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Not about friends, its walking down the street and having people cross the street to avoid you, its getting weird looks on the bus. Things that normal looking people would never think of.
EquivalentSnap@reddit
No one is crossing the street cos of you or giving you weird looks unless you’re staring at them. You’re not the centre of the universe. No one cares about you
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Bro what are you talking about?
EquivalentSnap@reddit
Talking that it’s in your head. No one is crossing the road cos your ugly or giving you looks
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Man youre a bad person, youre just gonna say that people arent prejudiced and its all in peoples heads looool.
EquivalentSnap@reddit
No but it is when they cross the road or on a bus. People have places to be 🙄 idc about other people on a bus unless they’re bothering me. Not all about you
JustifiedCroissant@reddit
Being ugly isn't the problem, being a nihilistic piece of shit who whines all the time is the problem
LesserValkyrie@reddit
Which is the logical result of being ugly
It's like blaming a black person after suffering racism for 20 years that he is angry against society. Of course he can be wiser and decide to make peace with the world and evolve further. Some people do that.
Or he can be angry, which is a very natural way for the brain to work. Which is something that happens.
Can't blame him, and doing so is being part of the problem, you can only help him, but never blame, you have no clue about what he lived and why he is like that now to judge
JustifiedCroissant@reddit
I was an ugly kid and an ugly teen, no amount of bullying brought it into me to cry like a little bitch about my life. Self-pity is incredibly unattractive.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
You're so tough.
JustifiedCroissant@reddit
Act like a cuck all your life and you'll stay a cuck thats it, literally shower and wear clothes that fit you.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
NPC reply. No shower or clothes for your face and height.
Little_Whippie@reddit
You are not oppressed for being ugly, don’t even try to compare that to racism
thegr8cthulhu@reddit
Comparing someone facing actual oppression to a loser who can’t get laid cause they’re a loser is wild. Ugly people aren’t oppressed, it usually just someone who has too much self pity and refuses to work on themselves.
Lot_a_bay@reddit
They are what people tell them they are, ugly monsters.
They get bullied their whole lives. Its only natural that you end up being an asshole.
thr33beggars@reddit
Hormone therapy to make them a pretty girl
ocajsuirotsap@reddit
Body positivity for women : "You're perfect the way you are and should never make any form of effort. "
Body positivity for men : "Haha you will never be a real man you should just castrate yourself lmao. Why don’t you laugh? It’s just a joke bro lmao but you should become a femboy.
EquivalentSnap@reddit
That’s bullshit and you know it. That’s just some incel misinformation. You see it on 4chan and posts all the time about how overweight women are “whales” and sluts if they sleep around and whores .
No one is telling men to castrate themselves wtf are you talkin about? Get off 4chan and make some real friends not online ones. No one is telling you to be a femboy ffs
SagaSolejma@reddit
Who's holding you chained and keeping you from starting your own male body positivity movement lol
ocajsuirotsap@reddit
Israel.
SagaSolejma@reddit
LMAO
RedSander_Br@reddit
Honestly, the feminist movement.
Men actually tried to start a male movement, there is a whole documentary about this.
The feminist movement at the time labeled them radicals and misogenists, and the media agreed for a quick buck.
What they were asking? Better treatment for men's psycological issues, equal rights in terms of the draft, male parental leave should be the same as the female one, the same with retirement and jail time.
Women get less jail time then the men for the same crime for example.
Anyway, they asked for a bunch of things like this, because these ARE female privilleges.
Anyway, there was a feminist who decided to do a documentary about them, after actually sympatizing with them, she was called a movement traitor by the feminists, and bullied.
The male movement name at the time? It was called the redpill movement.
The name like in matrix meant, "the hard truth to believe, is that men also have disadvantages."
After being branded by radicals by the feminist movement and the media, the normal guys left, leaving only the radicals inside, and the normal guys started a new movement, MGTOW, that basically says to ignore women and work on yourself.
Guess what is happening again?
Its both a money issue and a radical one.
Female rights groups have been getting donation money for ages, a new "rights" group would compete with them, in fact, this is the same reason why the black movement was absorbed into the lgbtq movement with mixed results, just look at the "new flag".
There is a term for this, its called pink money.
This is not a conspiracy, i am just telling you the two incentives. Money, and radical members of a group.
WilliamBurrito@reddit
These men were/are trying to fight for and strengthen the patriarchal system that they themselves hate living under.
ocajsuirotsap@reddit
On a more serious note, you can criticize something without having to build a better alternative all by yourself.
"-Man it’s terrible to see that we don’t have a cure for cancer yet.
-Then why don’t you make one?"
Few-Requirement-3544@reddit
Poorly disguised fetish
TrueGootsBerzook@reddit
Lol, lmao, haha even
thr33beggars@reddit
Any girl with a cock and balls is a pretty girl in my eyes. Even better if they have no feminine features. As Johnny Bravo once said, anyone that gets my dick hard is a girl.
sleezy_potatoo@reddit
Johny Bravo did not say all that
thereoncewasahat@reddit
DefinitelyNotDonny@reddit
I think i missed that episode
TGWsharky@reddit
Literally reason number 1 given for why incels fail in therapy was your exact incorrect line of thinking lol
If ugly people never found love, we'd all be tall and beautiful by this point.
Altruistic-Ad-6593@reddit
Don't wanna be a devil's advocate but compared to like 200 years ago we all are more beautiful and significantly taller
Carbonatite@reddit
We're taller because malnutrition is less of an issue, that's all.
pacard@reddit
Teach them to get over it and make the best of the only life they'll have. Or maybe at least not to double down on being ugly by having an ugly personality too.
dessertforbrunch@reddit
Dumbest take ever. Ugly people fuck all the time. These guys just suck at being people and treating others like them.
chriszenpaok@reddit
Lazy take
Jonesy1348@reddit
Women are attracted to confidence bucko, there are plenty of ugly dudes getting laid, they just aren’t so pitiful.
Real-Ad-1728@reddit
Help them derive their sense of self-worth from things that aren’t their physical appearance?
Lot_a_bay@reddit
You say that but, things like your career and your social life is largely dependant on your looks.
widdifullilac@reddit
Give them confidence?
Lot_a_bay@reddit
If you are confident, but people treat you like dirt and you have to swipe over 2 million times to get a date, then isnt that just delusion?
Little_Whippie@reddit
You kinda have to be good looking for online dating because your personality doesn’t come through with a couple pictures and a few short sentences. I know it’s scary but try meeting women in person
thegr8cthulhu@reddit
I’d like to ask this guy to see the rest of the profile, and how much he goes and socializes irl. Cause this is not enough evidence to make a call. For all we know his profile could say :”looking for trad wife must stay home and cook”
peanutist@reddit
Dawg I literally see dozens of people like you walking around with their partners every day
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Thats not me, and wow bro dozens? out of the thousands of people you see every day? nice odds.
peanutist@reddit
I see 2 million people every day
inspectoroverthemine@reddit
If thats you, you're not ugly, but you're literally on a platform where you're competing with 9 and 10s based solely on looks. I don't have any modern dating tips, but I struggle to meet with connect with people IRL, so if I was still dating I'm sure I'd have a hell of a bad time.
My only comment would be: interacting and connecting with people is a skill. If it doesn't come naturally, you have to force yourself to do it all the time. Its can be exhausting, but it does get easier with practice. Join clubs, volunteer- don't go in with the mind set of finding a date, all connections with people, can lead towards finding a partner. Having a large group of acquaintances/friends greatly increases the chances you'll come in contact with someone compatible. Its might also be easier to work out any personal issues the above difficult- and that will make 1 on 1 connections easier in the future.
I'm sure this is all the usual advice which I'm sure you've heard before. Its just sadly correct, and if it doesn't come naturally its difficult.
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Yeah and you train it by talking to people, but nobody wants to talk to ugly people.
inspectoroverthemine@reddit
Train it by talking to all people with your only agenda being: improving your skills and meeting people. Make acquaintances (or friends) with everyone- men, women, everyone.
You're going to have a really hard time finding a romantic interest if you can't make connections without that extra level of pressure.
chatshitgetpegged@reddit
most incels arent that way bc they’re extraordinarily ugly look at any irl incel meetup
esssssto@reddit
Even like that, they don't need looksmaxing, just a haircut and some styling tips, most of the times. Their negativity is so hard that even if women are interested in them, they will soon lose interest because of the toxicity. Nobody wants to be with a loser committed to being a loser.
lichtblaufuchs@reddit
Help them be happy and functional, just like with attractive people
noeagle77@reddit
This hopefully.
LocusRothschild@reddit
Is that what he calls it?
mucharuchakaralucha@reddit
It's not like women give much fuck about looks anyway. Dudes obsess about millimeters of bone structure while women when asked about what attracts them in their current partner say shit like "his kind eyes", "his crooked smile", "his hands", "his sexy voice", "he makes me feel safe" or "he's literally the funniest guy". Men just can't comprehend attraction that doesn't rely on looks, with women it's a full package of sensory experience. You look like a neanderthal but have nice eyes, strong, veiny hands, passable hygiene and a nice voice? Congrats, slap a decent personality on top of it, decent hygiene and employment, your looks will never be a barrier. If you don't believe me - go ahead and read women's erotica.
Lot_a_bay@reddit
Sorry bro, but all they care about is looks
SyntheticDuckFlavour@reddit
You can do a lot of simple things to improve your physical appearance, assuming you did not fall face first into a blender. You won't be Prince Charming, but better than looking like a cellar dweller troglodyte.
8123619744@reddit
You realize you could be an actual downy that children and people look at with fear and disdain, but you could be the happiest adult at the park. Everything is just how it’s perceived. Incels try to be “realistic” and see reality “for what it is.” “I’m just ugly.”
Actual reality is that to avoid one type of internal bias they just over corrected for another. They hate themselves because they must. Because anything else wouldn’t feel genuine. Being ugly is the least of their concerns.
thereoncewasahat@reddit
SolisArgentum@reddit
To help them develop a healthy ability to cope.
Therapy isn't people asking shrinks to fix their mental health issues, it's about assisting in helping dissect your thoughts and by extensions your feelings to certain stimuli and what made someone to that level of thinking and emotional output.
All a therapist does is help you un jumble that so you can sort that shit out for yourself
JoniVanZandt@reddit
Therapy isn't the answer to everything, i hate the way it's been built into this foundational aspect of a healthy life by Hollywood and self-help culture.
AdorableDonkey@reddit
i've gone through idk how many therapists in my whole life and none really helped
Any-Cricket-2370@reddit
I tried in person and it was too much of a hassle, i tried doing it over phone and that way it was effortless.
It feels good to get things off your chest.
thatscucktastic@reddit
Bro just talk to an LLM, it cares as much as the therapist does and might even be better at pretending to care lmao. Imagine paying another person to pretend to give a shit about you lmao
Any-Cricket-2370@reddit
I have a good job with ample health benefits. Try talking to an LLM for a while and see how stimulating it is.
thatscucktastic@reddit
More stimulating than a mentally ill w*myn in my experience lmao
Q_dawgg@reddit
LLM’s will just give you the recycled “it’ll get better lmao” spiel that you see on Facebook posts.
For the most part it just recommends cognitive behavioral therapy techniques. Which I know have worked for some people, but I just find to be lying to yourself until you feel better.
thatscucktastic@reddit
Nah an LLM will let you vent and it will just repeat back to you what you've said, exactly like a therapist. If it tries self help shit or mental health hotlines you just tell it to fuck off lol.
Sample_text108@reddit
Did you manage to improve your situation by now? And if yes, what did you manage to do that therapy failed you at?
haojifu@reddit
Speaking for myself I don't know I would say therapy "failed" because it at least gave me an outlet to discuss my issues and at least get some feedback, but it didn't really help solve any of those problems.
What genuinely has worked has been meditation. 15 minutes a day is all it takes. Of course it isn't a magic bullet but it lays a foundation for other positive change.
dajoos4kin@reddit
Do you think that you would have figured out that meditation does work for you if you never went to therapy?
gbmaulin@reddit
It’s very mainstream knowledge at this point
IKnowUselessThings@reddit
So is reducing your calorific intake to lose weight, many people still require some kind of external source to teach them that before it sinks in. A lot of people love under the assumption of "yeah I'm sure it helps people that need it, I'm not one of them though".
gbmaulin@reddit
Fat people are fully aware they need to reduce their caloric intake, they’re incapable or unwilling. Fuck are you on about?
OmNomSandvich@reddit
mindfulness, healthy diet, regular sleep hours, regular exercise is like table stakes advice that even a primary care doctor will hand out.
TESTlCLE@reddit
Therapy was beneficial for me when I was playing the dating game. It helped me identify signs of codependency and work to avoid falling into bad habits related to it.
Ultimately my helpful therapist switched networks, I stopped going, and then I fell right back into bad habits lol. But it all worked out eventually—getting married in June!
roblox_baller@reddit
The good ending
Sample_text108@reddit
Glad to hear it ended well. Wish you both all the best.
sofaking181@reddit
Found the therapist
dance_rattle_shake@reddit
Ironically (on this post) it's a LOT like dating. Can be hard to find a good match. But when you find one you click with, it's incredibly helpful.
thatscucktastic@reddit
Lmao just expend your life savings on a therapist game of chairs, bro
SergenteA@reddit
Universal Mental Healthcare is necessary yes
thatscucktastic@reddit
I'm not paying taxes to the government to fund mentally ill women to prostrate men
dance_rattle_shake@reddit
Access is a problem, for sure. It's $5/session for me, which I could afford 10 times over, but I know many aren't as fortunate.
thatscucktastic@reddit
5 dollars a session? Fucking how? Where?
dance_rattle_shake@reddit
Good insurance + tele health is way cheaper
ThatOneCloneTrooper@reddit
Had a friend who went to therapy for like 4 years and I asked "at what point do you think it might not be the solution?" and they looked at me like I shit in their tea.
Mental_Jeweler_3191@reddit
Yeah, I've had the same experience.
I've never encountered a therapist who could tell me something I didn't already know.
PGSylphir@reddit
Because therapy is really not much more than talking to someone who can make pointed questions.
You're supposed to arrive at the right answers by yourself, the therapist is there just to point out the way, which to an objective party is usually obvious but not as much to the subject party
beige-@reddit
unfortunately, therapy is very much a "try, try, and try again" sort of thing. The healthcare system in America doesn't really allow for that either, given how inaccessible mental health treatment is. I've had absolutely terrible therapists, but once one sticks? Actually life changing. Can really help with a positive outlook. Going into therapy with specific, actuable goals in mind can also be helpful; ultimately, its not your fault finding a therapist sucks, but it doesn't mean there isn't one out there for you either
TimeGlitches@reddit
At some point you have to initiate change in your own life. Therapy helps you figure out the why and the how but you have to actually DO the things.
iameveryoneelse@reddit
I’ve used them a few times and it did make things better but, honestly, it wasn’t the therapy that helped…it was having someone I was paying not to judge me so I could just unload a couple decades of suppressed garbage. Pretty sure if I was religious a confessional would have worked just as well.
SuckerpunchJazzhands@reddit
I've had two and am seeing a third. I understand the frustration people feel when talking with therapists they feel don't understand them. Therapy isn't a one-size-fits-all solution and needs to be molded to the individual and I think there's an unfortunately low-amount of therapists that possess the level of objective empathy needed to properly help people.
I'm a really angry person. I don't want to be, but I am. My therapist now is one of the only people that has said, "That's okay. You're allowed to be angry." That alone helped me so much and finally let me start looking inward as to why I'm angry and it turns out, I'm really not all that mad. I just needed to find better ways to channel my stress and worry.
I think the issue we see with not only incels, but a lot of guys in therapy, is that no one just tells them they aren't in the wrong for how they feel. They ways in which they act on those feelings and affect them may be wrong and even harmful, but I think a lot of them just want to hear that it's okay that they're sad and upset.
maggiemayfish@reddit
Hell I've had therapists that made things worse
The-Thot-Eviscerator@reddit
I mean tbf, of those who seek therapy, around 75% report benefits in their lives, it definitely helped me. It can’t help everyone but it objectively does help a ton of people and many who don’t have it would benefit heavily from it.
vitringur@reddit
OP was posting a study that contradicted the statistics you are claiming.
Let us assume that 100% of women report benefits and that 75% of those who seek therapy are women.
Using your data to suggest to a man that he should go to therapy would be ridiculous.
Lying with statistics is quite common.
The-Thot-Eviscerator@reddit
Wuh
vitringur@reddit
Of those who wear tampons, 95% report increased comfort.
That does not mean you would recommend it for some 22 year old incel or at any point think it would actually benefit him in any way, shape or form.
Martijnbmt@reddit
Therapy only works if you let it. But people like incels are afraid to admit being wrong, amongst many, many other things. Someone who cannot admit to making a mistake cannot be helped.
akmarksman@reddit
Man, I wonder what group of people runs those...
I think Dave Chappelle mentioned something about it..
Dry_Blueberry6806@reddit
Whenever someone complains about a personal problem people will just say two things like they're silver bullets: 1) Go to therapy. 2) Get off social media.
Both can work, maybe, but people greatly overestimate what they can do.
Puzzled_Nail_1962@reddit
Because then you don't really have to do anything. People just really don't like it when you actually have to do something on your own and take responsibility. It's always something or someone external who has to fix them.
Bupod@reddit
Well it’s because it’s easier than asking a couple questions to dust off the actual answer.
If you dig and find someone’s root problems all come back to not enough money and they have a wellspring of problems all connecting back to that?
Yeah, therapy isn’t going to do jack shit. In fact it’ll make it worse because now they’ll have to fork over even more money for therapy.
Ozzy-@reddit
Then the solution is "make more money". But if you say that then most people will just come back with a bunch of excuses for why they can't. At the end it boils down to "it's hard and I don't wanna".
Life is suffering. To suffer is to live. Embrace suffering instead of running away from it. This is universal truth
Bupod@reddit
It is possible to enter in to a poverty trap which is procedurally very difficult to escape.
I won’t say it describes all situations, but it can absolutely be the case that “just make more money” isn’t a realistically feasible option. It’s better advised to try and avoid the pitfall in the first place except that, at least in the U.S., sudden medical problems can trigger that trap pretty easily (you need to work to make more money, but your medical problems limit your ability to work. You need more money to take care of your medical problems, but you need to work to make more money. You are now in a catch-22). It’s not an uncommon scenario.
Ozzy-@reddit
Of course, the system is deeply flawed. My point is that when faced with this situation, each path forward leads to suffering. The choice is how to respond. I don't fault anyone for giving up when faced with struggles like this. That too is a form of acceptance of suffering
Hongkongjai@reddit
9/10 times people will not give actionable and meaningful advice. They won’t even really process your problem. After all, whenever they say, if you don’t manage to improve, it isn’t their problem and they will take no responsibility for it.
Brilliant_Sweet_6848@reddit
It can help,but this is not panacea.
Especially when big part of problems is coming outwards, from imperfect systems.
Zarbibilbitruk@reddit
There's also the issue that therapy that does not acknowledge what capitalism is doing to the psyche is not therapy to help you get better. It's therapy that helps you be a good worker
SageoftheForlornPath@reddit
When done right with a good therapist (and good medication), I believe it can definitely help.
Pocketfullofbugs@reddit
I think a lot of people use it to replace church.
PlsDntPMme@reddit
You’re delusional. Your god killed so many people and is so evil. Hell is the most evil concept that exists. Church doesn’t fix people. In my experience it usually just makes them more insecure and judgemental.
Pocketfullofbugs@reddit
I dont go to church. I do think people are saying "go to therapy" in the same empty way people say "go to church"
Its an easy way to feel helpful.
Objective-Lawyer5428@reddit
Thing is, if you break your bone in an accident or need a dental treatment, there is visible progress an at a given point you're "cured" - with therapy, that is a lot more vague.
You don't wake up one morning, brush your teeth, it hurts and you suddenly have the epiphany that you nned to get treated for clinical depression. The way towards diagnosis can be long, arduous and even filled with several doctors not even identifiying the source.
Now, if your are correctly diagnosed, there is no "on shoe fits all" treatment - there are various approaches, sometimes even ideological warfare between "we need to talk" and "take that pill twice a day" and as a patient who a) doesn't know what exactly is wrong, b) doesn't know all pros and cons of every treatment option and c) doesn't even know if these treatments will help, how do you act?
Someone said with therapists it's like a relationship - it needs to click on a personal level, you will nned to be able to open up in order to share and to accept their advice. Same with medication, your body might respond differently than others' so it takes time to find the right level - not too much so you feel emotionally numb and not too little so you constantly fear an episode. It's complicated.
And now, within this hard to grasp medical fiels with lots of subjectivity, through in an industry that feeds on insecurities - people want to look better, so sell them training plans, diet plans, plastic surgery and instill that they won't necessarily feel better.
For the latter, sell them ongoing therapy, regardless of their actual need - the problem is, Hollywwod markets what sells and vague advice and therapy can be sold ad inifnitum. So they will sell it.
Doesn't mean everybody needs therapy, also doesn't mean every advice for therapy is wrong or ill-intentioned.
chriszenpaok@reddit
Scam for 90% of people
TotemBro@reddit
Therapy don’t solve your problem, I think that’s pretty obvious. What it does is help you to move through the emotional distress that your problems create. The bonus is if your therapist is competent, they can also help you be more tactical about solving the problems.
Boring-Original-2968@reddit
Therapy needs to be approached as part of a full spectrum treatment including booze, illegal drugs, access to legal prostitution, and some sort of physical exercise. This must also be done in concert with a strong, supportive social group of people in similar positions progressing at similar rates. Actually, just having an expanded freind group and social structure eliminates the nedd for the other stuff most of the time. Get a hobby.
XbdudeX@reddit
You ever notice how most of the people that tell you that you need therapy are usually pretty deranged themselves?
JimmyReagan@reddit
Yup, it's useful to certain people with certain issues, but I get annoyed at how many times I'm told "maybe you should see a therapist" for every little thing. People can be sad or mad or whatever and work through it themselves, it is possible.
BitesTheDust55@reddit
It's a daycare job for mostly women where they get paid obscene amounts of money to do nothing of value
micahamey@reddit
had a therapist when I was a kid for my anger issues. Gotta be real. She talked more than I did about her own anger issues when she was a kid. Tried to relate them to me in these weird ways. I was resistant not because I didn't want help, but because she was yapping at me for 3 straight sessions. I didn't get a word in. Told my mother I'd rather go into the woods again than let that lady yap at me for another 45 minute session.
WintersbaneGDX@reddit
Are you one of the 100 reflected in the study results?
JoniVanZandt@reddit
WintersbaneGDX@reddit
Fascinating
koknesis@reddit
wait, that was a serious question from you?
WintersbaneGDX@reddit
Nothing I do on reddit is serious, my friend
koknesis@reddit
then why are you mocking him for not answering the "question"?
WintersbaneGDX@reddit
because both my initial reply and the follow-up are shitposts?
koknesis@reddit
obviously you should work on that then.
arbiter12@reddit
I think "casually destroying you" was his response. I doubt he's one of the 100, but I don't doubt you got ground to a fine powder.
WintersbaneGDX@reddit
I would love to engage further, but he blocked me. Oh well.
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
There is a great video from healthy gamer GG about how therapy is actually "female-biased" in the sense of therapy developped itselfs a lot through women, so a lot of method used by most therapist were build to cater a little bit more to women and a lot of men when face with such therapy method can actually feel frustrated, confused or blind-sinded and when they do not respond well to this method that were not made for them they are shamed and criticized.
SamTheGill42@reddit
Therapy is mostly talking about your emotions, which is the exact opposite most men have been taught to do.
Tilting_Gambit@reddit
It just seems hugely gendered to me. In years of management, it seems like women want me to listen and validate their concerns. Their main issue is what has happened and gone wrong. They want to unpack that.
With guys, I've found that its more "here's what you did wrong, here's how you fix it up, if you do that it won't be an issue anymore." How we move forward, what the path is, what reconciliation looks like.
I think therapy is very good at the first version. You're getting one side of the story ("my husband did this thing on the weekend") but very bad at the second type of thing. Good therapists will say "it's not your husband's role to make sure you get to the wedding on time. Why didn't you get up earlier?" But simultaneously, there's an explicit understanding that the business model requires the client to feel like they're not being judged. And professionally, the therapist knows they "can't help somebody if they stop coming." So they need to carefully work the session around trying to make sure a client figures out what went wrong themselves. Through careful questioning and guided conversations, the idea that all people are somewhat introspective and will eventually realise they shouldn't have changed their outfit 3 times if they wanted to show up on time. Again, this seems extremely gendered. Men are more direct, which is exemplified by the complaints of mansplaining and being cut off in meetings. Everybody knows the negative side effects of men being direct, but they resist all other acknowledgement of it. This directness is some of what makes therapy bad for men.
In practice I think therapy ends up mostly being softball questions, where problematic millennial women show up to air their grievances. They voice their non problems in an environment where they are essentially paying for companionship, a confidante, who will not say "you are a narcissistic person, your family are fine. You think you deserve more but you don't. You have exactly what you earned, this is it, and you need to accept it and move on." They will instead entertain the deluge of first world problems, pretend that whatever fake work from home job they're talking about is the hardest job in the world, and nod understandingly when hearing about how a husband would rather watch sports instead of listen to this garbage himself.
Men don't have the requisite patience or introspection to need a paid companion. Most men have an issue, go and watch a movie with their best friend, briefly mention this "fucked situation at work" and eat another handful of chips. At worst, they need to be told not to buy their wife a gift card for their anniversary. Something that is a concrete problem, that needs a concrete solution.
The most frustrating thing about all this is that women really do think that their preferred methods of problem solving and conflict resolution are the best approach. Therapy is the default, why aren't all these silly men just going and doing it? Some men do, and some men love it. But on the aggregate, it's an extraordinarily feminine approach to go pay a stranger to listen to you yap. Yes, if you've watched your best friend die in a blackhawk crash, maybe you will get a guy who needs to work out why they're waking up screaming at night. But for the vast majority of white collar workers who make up the clientele of therapists, this is not the case. The biggest adversity these people have encountered is generally being asked to actually do the job they're getting paid to do.
Nearly all the people I know who go to therapy have zero real world adversity. Cushy jobs (or totally fake jobs) and upper middle class lives. Most of them are paying a proxy friend (totally captive audience) listen to them talk about some fake or basically fake trauma. This just isn't something most men are interested in.
I was recently robbed on the street near my house. I've had therapy suggested multiple times, all by women. They think it's weird, totally weird, that I'm totally fine and not traumatised. They cannot for a second imagine that some men are not the exact, mirror image, of them. They don't realise that this has impacted my life in no actual way, because they visualise it and think they'd take 3 months off work and check themselves into a psych unit before going out at night again. And this is the problem. Most women have deluded themselves into thinking there are no differences between men and women. And that any differences that are existant need to be stamped out and men need to become more like them.
Anyway yeah, therapy seems gendered because it definitely is.
F-Lambda@reddit
Yeah. I went to therapy for a bit, and while it did solve a few things (which I honestly mostly figured out outside of therapy), it was mostly just a prerequisite to meeting with a prescriber.
raich3588@reddit
I love organically coming across something this stupid expressed so confidently
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
I love systemic bullies trying to be smart and failing
raich3588@reddit
Says the guy learning psychology from a video game YouTuber
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
Yhea video game youtube who actually is a Harvard graduate and a therapist. Nice try bully but you fit the cliche perfectly you're as dumb as a rock.
Baddyshack@reddit
This is categorically untrue. Counseling and psychology have been historically developed, largely, by men.
Aluminum_Tarkus@reddit
The foundations of modern psychiatry were developed largely by men, but the clinical practice of therapy was mostly catered for women as the recipients. That's because therapy has historically had an overwhelmingly greater number of female patients than male patients. Part of that was due to how quick women used to be, and still are, labeled as crazy. But nowadays, it has more to do with the effectiveness of modern therapy between genders. Even in recent years, where the overall percentage of the population has had therapy at some point, we still see women being around 2-3x more represented.
If you see one gender overrepresented among patients of a clinical practice, does it not make sense that the methods found to be most effective in the practice might also have a bias towards the majority group? That's what Dr. K's video is about, and I think the Harvard psychiatrist with loads of experience might have a point there, especially when therapy is largely more effective for women than men. At the very least, that discrepancy is worth looking into.
SapirWhorfHypothesis@reddit
Is that last claim backed up by anything? I would have guessed lower ratio of women in employment and higher likelihood for social and personal introspection as drivers over actually efficacy.
Objective-Lawyer5428@reddit
It's the exact opposite with most medial practices - for most medicine, the dosage for wmoen and children is calculated as a fraction of the average male's dosag, disregadring hormonal differences between a grown man and growing men or a grown man and a woman.
Any empirical science derives its principles from observation - if the observation is skewed in one direction, so will the results/ rules/ treatments be.
sadacal@reddit
Women use healthcare services more in general than men.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10718692/
Yet healthcare is obviously not geared towards women, with many female specific problems and concerns ignored or dismissed by doctors.
https://www.ucl.ac.uk/news/2021/apr/analysis-womens-pain-routinely-underestimated-and-gender-stereotypes-are-blame
https://www.northwell.edu/katz-institute-for-womens-health/articles/gaslighting-in-womens-health
Divine_ruler@reddit
Developed by men isn’t exclusive with developed for women
InquisitorMeow@reddit
So... These men were just really good at emphasizing with women and making programs perfectly catered too them? Bruh women were being diagnosed with "hysteria" and lobotomized and shit. Dunno why you're acting like a bunch of dudes back then were woke or something.
Divine_ruler@reddit
Not what I said at all
bisky12@reddit
op never said it was developed for women they said by women read both comments again
Divine_ruler@reddit
No, they said developed through women. To me, that reads as “therapists/psychologists developed therapy through female patients”
wirelessfingers@reddit
But they weren't developed for women, though. It's still wrong. You could make the argument that Humanist/Person-Centered therapy is tailored more for women because of its focus on emotions and lack of direction, but therapy isn't one thing. There are multiple modalities. To say that behavioral therapy or psychodynamic therapy or cognitive behavioral therapy are 'female-leaning' is just plainly wrong to anyone with any knowledge of the field itself.
Divine_ruler@reddit
K, but Humanist/Person-Centered “talk therapy” is the most common and well known form of therapy
Coronel_Flokill@reddit
Yes and no, it depends on the country. Latin america we tend to mix CBT with Psychodynamic approaches.
wirelessfingers@reddit
No it isn't. CBT (Cognitive Behavioral Therapy) is.
PetsArentChildren@reddit
keep your facts away from my dogma
Slinto69@reddit
Modern gynecology was historically developed by men also. Who is it for though?
Little_Whippie@reddit
Developed by men, for women
farlon636@reddit
Do you not understand the difference between "by" and "for"?
majesticle@reddit
literally i mean cmon now? sigmund freud? every modern modality was either inspired by his teaching or inspired to remix his teachings
HulaguIncarnate@reddit
Would you like to guess the gender of Shlomo's earlier patients?
CaptainHindsight92@reddit
But my blackpill youtube video says it’s designed by jews to make me gay. Is it a coincidence that I started fantasising about dominating fem boys right after I was dropped by my therapist? Check mate atheists.
majesticle@reddit
gamerGG himself is extremely biased towards his religion which is fine but thats only in theory of what will help someone. therapy is based on theories of what people believe will help someone, its okay to look at him and take stuff from him but hes not end all be all
how-unfortunate@reddit
I'm glad to see a balanced take on the guy. I think some guys online have found positive results from concepts they picked up from the guy, but in viewing his stuff, he does seem to work from a couple of themes that strike me more as right leaning traditionalism than traditional therapy. And maybe the thought there is that men need the "toughen up and just start doing something" angle, but maybe, if men do require that, it's actually because we need to make societal changes to how we socialize boys and treat young men. Maybe "examine your feelings" doesn't work on someone raised their whole lives with "shut off the evidence of your feelings and get results," but the fault there isn't really in therapy methods, but cultural conditioning. In the meantime, maybe leaning into the unhealthy mentality/worldview could start to be moved away from, so that over time men, women, and others could benefit from a more robust, holistic approach.
Marvosta@reddit
Dr.k seems pretty consistent with his message of, yes society definitely could improve on its societal condition of men, but for the individual you wont be fixed by waiting for society to change, and even if it does you would still personally need to work on undoing the conditioning, i would say its a little unfair to categorize it as "toughen up" since hes quite vocal about examining and feeling feelings
how-unfortunate@reddit
Yo I am definitely biased, as a result of my own (and I hate to use this word, as therapy speak has been co-opted by horrible people) trauma.
All I needed is what would be considered moderate, slightly strict leaning parenting. I got something very different.
I'm a little knee-jerky in my reaction to some stuff, as I know you just have to do things, but often I need help figuring out how to trick myself into doing the thing, so "just do the thing" hits wrong for me, even if the messenger doesn't mean it in the "bootstraps, suck it up" way.
So, take that into account, and my statements with a grain of salt. I try to be open, but we all have our biases that shape the message when we receive it. We just need to be aware of it.
I'm out here tryin'.
Cuboidhamson@reddit
The fault there still very much is with the methods, or at least with the psychologist for choosing to employ that method with that patient.
majesticle@reddit
I agree with everything you said. Someone from a traditional background is less likely to be open to talking about emotions. A good therapist would take this into consideration
And GamerGG seems to be a good guy who means well. He’s not for me, though I can imagine he’s likely helped lots of other people
scrotalobliteration@reddit
There's also the fact that men are generally less socialized to share and talk about their emotions, and are often more distrustful of situations like that. So it requires getting past that before they get to the same level of comfort and insight that women are more likely to start at.
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
Yhea and instead of actually recognizing that they just shame men and then when men have a normal response to being shamed, to them it's the proof m'en are the problem, nice healthiness guys really.
Mental_Jeweler_3191@reddit
Yeah, it's not a conspiracy theory.
Much psychotherapy is built around ideas and values about emotions and expressing them is constitutionally alien to a significant proportion of men.
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
not it's a conspiracy theory what you said is true and instead of therapist working to try and work with said men to find way to work on emotions and expressing they are just shamed when they can't .
onepromaster69@reddit
Less shamed and more pressured
I had colleagues and friends who practiced therapy that sort of left everything to be filled in by their patients instead of being a holding hand to guide them into questions they can answer for themselves.
I remember one case shared to us that one therapist who had a patient who transferred from plenty of psychologists shared that he felt that he was being shamed like he was stripped naked by his last psychologist because of how he was pressured into answering questions due to how impatient they looked at him and that they would not stfu when the patient was taking time to think.
TGWsharky@reddit
There is not single field of modern science that was built on a foundation of studying women. Certainly not psychology or therapy. Men do worse in therapy because it goes against a lot of things we were taught growing up about "complaining" or voicing our feelings.
Add to that how many people believe what you just said and refuse to even engage properly. And you end up with a self fulfilling prophecy.
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
literaly go watch the video I talked about, guy is from harvard btw.
TGWsharky@reddit
Didn't realize people from Harvard couldn't be grifters or misinformed. My bad, dog.
LonelyPermit2306@reddit
As opposed to your stunning credentials
TGWsharky@reddit
I didn't make an appeal to my credentials.
If you comb through early therapy and psych papers, it's either 100% men or a 50/50 split. Anyone claiming that modern therapy was built to be woman-centric is not speaking truthfully.
People just say this now, because a bunch of terrible women have started abusing therapy terms (without actually going) to try and excuse shitty behavior.
LonelyPermit2306@reddit
Written by men, but is it about men or women? That's what the other guy said
TGWsharky@reddit
No, not written by men (well, they were, but not what I was referring to). The studied populations were those splits. Not the authors.
Keep in mind that a lot of early therapy work was on soldiers with shellshock, PTSD, and other service related mental issues. Almost exclusively men were studied for those.
Matikso@reddit
It's not a great video if the premise is just wrong. Every medical field (also psychiatry) is heavily based on male. It was studied by men, on men and for men. In recent years (I don't mean 5 or so but more like 30-40) women get to be more represented.
You know that a lot of testing and examination were performed solely on males (human or rats) because females are too hard to test - it's because of their hormonal cycle that is monthly, which skews the test week by week.
Not even medical field but basically everything is catering to men. For example: car safety. The cars are designed based on male models, just like crashtest dummies. Women bodies differ so they are not as safe as males are in the cars we are driving. Just to name a one example
RobotTrexNinja@reddit
it's just untrue therapy do not catter to men at all, it's all women's stuff and most mens are often shamed just because the hterapist refuse to try and understand how they function. You're just a bully dude, you just want to shame people who do not fit your critteria instead of actually trying.
NickFromNewGirl@reddit
Well he sounds brain dead.
AdorableDonkey@reddit
This explains why it never worked on me
TropicalBatman@reddit
It's because these dipshits view "therapy" as girly. They think that men don't have traditional feelings and "feelings" are "gay and girly" so therapy is inherently girl based and that therapy in itself is inherently girl based and because of that the deck is already stacked against them. They're actively fighting the therapy because they think it's women telling them how to think and act so of course it won't work, because they don't want it to.
BlueLizardSpaceship@reddit
For therapy to work, the incel would first have to admit to theirself that the problem is their attitude, ideas, and the behaviour resulting thereof.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
You're just typing shit that sounds good. It's just-world fallacy drivel, nothing more.
"It has got to be your personality, bro!". Nope, might just be ugly.
BlueLizardSpaceship@reddit
I know personally a guy who looks like tall redheaded gollum. He's had a kid with his girlfriend, broke up with her, married the next one, divorced her, married yet another woman...
It's not looks.
something-somone@reddit
"I have a singular personal anecdote that no one aside from me can verify.. this obviously entirely refutes your claim and makes you 100% wrong!!!"
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Have you never been outside? Ugly people get together all the fucking time when they live their life instead of being terminally online.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
And? What does it change? They still have it harder than normal people, let alone attractive ones
Impassable_Banana@reddit
So what? Life's not fair, but if you let that hold you back then you'll just be unhappy and unfulfilled.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
You can't be real
Impassable_Banana@reddit
I am real, and I'm right. Incels wallow in self pity online and wonder why they're miserable all the time.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
"just be confident bro"
Impassable_Banana@reddit
If they alternative is whinging for validation on incel subs? then yes lmao.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Sorry, but how does it affects you personaly? If you don't like these forums, then why do you waist your time for them? I promise you, there are many, many other grups that are hundreds of times worse, and it's really pointless to waste that much time on them. Of course, some of them are really weird, hateful and deserve everything that happens to them, but most are just normal, unlucky guys that are just short, ugly, neurodivergent
something-somone@reddit
"Someone who is miserable complains about being miserable all the time"
No shit Sherlock, you want a noble prize with that?
Not complaining will not automatically fix everything, it honestly won’t even fix a little bit.
Again more shitty just world fallacy, lack of empathy for human beings, and victim blaming.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
If people spend all their spare time on reddit in incel subs it's going to completely poison their mental wellbeing. It's not victim blaming, it's just common sense. They are the only people that can do something about their lives.
something-somone@reddit
They can’t do something. That’s the entire point of being incel.
You’re rejecting the basic fact of life that some people just genuinely can’t do something about their situation.
Do you go to the kids in Gaza and say like "bro whining about it won’t make it better??" No right cuz that’s fucking stupid.
You seriously have me repeating myself here but the only thing you do is commit just world fallacy. You don’t think about how our societal systems play into it, you don’t think about how different people are affected differently by the same thing, you just don’t think. You think everything can just be hand waved by saying "lmao your fault bruh" but we know this isn’t the case cuz the fact of the universe: You can do everything right and still fail.
something-somone@reddit
You recognize the problem yet still continue to victim blame and accept the poor state of society. Holy fuck you’re stupid..
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Cope.
something-somone@reddit
Nothing can change that’s like half the point.
There is no self fulfilling prophecy because the prophecy was set in motion by the time the person was born.
You’re too stupid to see that someone can do all the right things in life and still fail.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
It's totally a self fulfilling prophecy. The person feels insecure and hopeless and that they will be forever alone, so they do nothing to try and put themselves out there and better themselves and what's the only outcome possible in that situation? Forever alone. A completely self fulfilling prophecy.
Sitting on reddit moping in incel subs is not going to do anyone any ounce of good. Excuses. Whinging. Moping. Blaming others, and everything but themselves. Never getting off their arse to do anything about it. Too afraid to try and fail.
something-somone@reddit
"This just in: Man creates completely fictional scenario then gets mad about it!!!" Never seen that one before. No seriously it just doesn’t happen as you say it does. Different people have different paths but the bottom line between all incels is that they’ve already continuously tried to put themselves out there, problem is they failed.
For the second paragraph just look at my other response. I think it fits nicely for that.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
It's rare for ugly young guys to have success with girls nowadays.
-Caberman@reddit
Brother if you just log off for a second and go to any country or city where people are actually walking around, open your eyes and you will see unattractive, short men walking around with women out of their league. It's not a single anecdote, it's just real life.
BlueLizardSpaceship@reddit
Or walking around with women in their league. And somehow old people manage to stay in relationships. Imo the other big problem with incels is they're shallow af and assume everyone else is like them. They come up on a "feemale" with an incredibly toxic attitude, she detects this and nopes out, they promptly missattribute the rejection and carry on making themselves miserable.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
I genuinely DO NOT see short unattractive young men walking around with women out of their league. Even seeing them walk around with women at all is extremely rare.
Old guys, sometimes. Young men? Basically never.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
It's pointless bro, they are brainless NPCs that can't comprehend such things
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Sure buddy, whatever you want reality to be
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Yeah but people want an excuse as to why it's not their fault. I have a feeling a lot of incels are narcissists.
KortFulBlatte@reddit
And you want an excuse as to why everyone gets what they deserve. It's the just-world fallacy.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Yeah, sure, and I know a green tiger with wings that speaks mandarine, and what real value does it bring to this conversation? How does your example prove that everyone else is wrong? By your logic, if a certain sniper (or bowman, if you like) hits the target nine out of ten times, but fails one out of ten times, then he aren't accurate at all?
KortFulBlatte@reddit
Ah, the classic "I know a guy". I swear you people are actual NPCs.
popmyhotdog@reddit
So youre saying that therapy works for women because they all go in there and decided that their attitude ideas and behavior are all the problem and that the woman is the issue and she just needs to change herself to not be a sad piece of shit???
Cause that doesn’t sound like any women I knows experience with therapy that sounds like shit you just made up cause you’ve decided that that’s what you think incels need to do cause you hate the version of them you’ve imagined in your head
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
love how in the case of therapy the treatment failing is actually the fault of the patient
willthefreeman@reddit
Doctor recommends obese person eat less food, person doesn’t want to eat less food, treatment failing is the fault of the patient.
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
that would be refusing to take therapy no? the person here was willing to undergo the treatment but it did not work
Kaszalot1352@reddit
I think it's pointless to argue with them, their toxic positivity don't want to see world and it's problem how they are not because they don't want others to suffer, but to fulfill their egoistic desire
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
it's interesting to see how the people arguing against me just agree it ends up really confusing from my side
I say therapy doesn't work unless you are a specific type of mentally ill
they counter by saying therapy doesn't work unless you are a specific type of mentally ill (/pos)
idk
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Man, someone stated that looks don't matter in therapy, I started a discussion that it indeed does, and they ended it with something like "Well, life isn't fair, duh", so they literally used my words as a counter point
mrjackj2@reddit
Therapy isn't really a "treatment." they aren't rearranging your brain for you.
It's more like... Talking to someone helps you sort out your shit naturally, but you still got to put forth the effort require to make changes for the better.
If you don't do that second part, you won't have improvement.
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
you can't at the same time disagree with people saying therapy doesn't work and then affirm that it only works for the good mentally ill people
Little_Whippie@reddit
Actually you can. You cannot expect to go into therapy and be “cured” of your problems, get upset when that doesn’t work, and then say therapy doesn’t work. You fundamentally misunderstand what therapy actually does
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
just sounds to me like you are affirming the point against therapy
this is just stating that if you aren't a specific approved kind of mentally ill there is no hope left for you
Bupod@reddit
“Going to therapy” is like going to the doctor. Physically going.
You can physically go to the doctor but if you refuse doctors orders, you will get worse. You have to take your medication, you have to adjust your lifestyle, you have to follow the diets and recommended practices.
Likewise, going to the therapist is meaningless if you don’t genuinely examine your own thoughts, if you don’t write them out in a journal, if you don’t practice the mindfulness exercises they show you. If you walk in saying “this is all bullshit” and convince yourself you’re not going to do it, then yeah, YOU will fail. The therapist isn’t going to sit in your shoulder every night convincing you that you’re actually wrong about how you feel about yourself and others, the same way your doctor isn’t going to chain you to a treadmill and crack a whip on your back to make you exercise and follow a diet. That’s on you.
Hugo_Spaps@reddit
Sometimes, yeah. Therapy only works if the patient is receptive to personal change. Incel Ideology promotes that idea that it’s never the incel’s fault that they can’t find someone. This conflict generally nukes the chance of successful therapy.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Sure, whatever lets you wear rose tinted glasses and keep your naive worldview
new_KRIEG@reddit
Great way to provide an example to that person's comment!
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Yeah buddy, alienating other people and claiming that their experiences are wrong because you think otherwise is surely a great idea
EquivalentSnap@reddit
Exactly. They won’t they blame women. Look at point 3
whan_a_nibba@reddit
TD;DR: Incels need to touch grass
Because therapy is only part of a healthy mental equilibrium. Beyond meds and shrinks, a health lifestyle involves physical exercise (and that doesn’t just mean going full gym-bro and ending up with and entirely different form of insecurity and depression, just doing an activity that elevates your heart rate and triggers endorphin release, even if it is only on a weekly basis), a solid diet and sleep cycle (it doesn’t have to be perfect, but it should at least be as consistent as possible to ensure you’re actually getting the full benefits of both) and most importantly, a small but steady social circle of people close to you that you can rely on. All of these factors can help build the foundations of a persons ability to interact and thrive in a larger social context (whether it be simple day-to-day conversations or a larger gathering).
The problem for a lot of incels is that they are mentally-ill, terminally online weirdo’s trapped in echo chambers with other terminally online freaks. And that’s not to say there’s anything wrong with being ‘weird’ or not really fitting, but if that’s the case and yours struggling to connect with people (for any number of reasons), then the answer is not to spend all your free time with other miserable, angry, disenfranchised loners projecting your failings and problems back to you but to get out into the real world (or barring that, looking for more positive digital spaces) and finding a way to positively and more importantly, authentically engage in shared hobbies or interests with other people, from all walks of life, of all ages, sexes, colours and creeds. It doesn’t matter if it’s not perfect the first time or not absolutely everything you imagined. It’s a big fucking world, eventually you’ll find your people and that makes the difference. And if you have a mentality that said world has insanely high expectations for you or men in general, then why cave or submit these unrealistic expectations simply to feel shitty you’ll never reach them.
A lot of it is, unironically, all either made-up or in your own fucking head. And that’s why therapy alone doesn’t work on incels. Because they don’t really want help, so to speak. They, like many an immature, mentally disturbed person, only want to be helped THEIR way, under THEIR conditions, and that any other kind of assistance is either unwanted or unfair. Because again, they are depressed man children. All of which leads to nothing really getting done, because the particular incel in question will go to such lengths NOT to fulfil their own impossibly high standards and unrealistic self-imposed agenda, just so they can eventually throw up their hands and say: “See, I am right, everything is hopeless and there’s no point to any of this, may as well give up!”
The reason that none of the fairly simple, easily achievable solutions seem possible, or reasonable is because they require a level of personal effort, self-discipline and self-awareness that somebody carrying the black dog or such may not be able to comprehend themselves (or believe themselves capable of bearing alone). Hence the need for the smaller community mentioned earlier to help share those loads and act as emotional safe harbours to stop and look for support in.
Therapy is a tool for wellness. It can help you find, explain and understand these issues along with helping create structures and systems to manage and achieve results. But at the end of the day, unless the person attending is not only willing to open up, but to learn, think about and take onboard the advice and any personal revelations they may have, then it won’t do anything. Unless you make an active effort not to have a closed mindset, to be curious, to try new things and experiences, to not make premature judgments or assumptions based off your own fears and anxiety’s, to not defeat yourself before even starting, then no amount of time spent on a couch whinging about how fucked up the is universe will fix anything. There’s a saying about horses and water but I digress, because this is Reddit and neither you or I really give enough of a fuck to keep going.
But on a last note, to anyone that may have got this far. If you need help, reach out to someone, anyone. Try and make a few positive changes in your life. They don’t have to be big, just things you can personally feel good about, that offer a sense of pride and self achievement. And most importantly, keep going. It’s going to be hard. It’s going to be tiring. It’s going to be emotionally exhausting, and occasionally leave you bawling in a way you haven’t done since you were a kid. And that’s ok. Cause at the end of the day, as along as you keep going, as long as you reach the top of the mountain, then you’ll feel better then you would have if you quit. And if you get to the top, and see even more mountains, that’s ok too. Because you’ve already climbed one. You know the risks, you know the safe paths, you know who can help you, and how. You know the tools and skills you’ll need, and from the top the mountain you just climbed, you’ll have a much better view to access and breakdown the stages before you start. And therefore, when you’re ready, you can start the next climb, knowing that each time it’ll get a bit easier, that your now stronger and more experienced then you were, and that the obstacles that once stopped you in your tracks now barely phase you.
Goodnight everyone, I hope this fever-induced rant answers a few questions and offers a few solutions to any that may need them. Cheers, and keep you chin up
Ullixes@reddit
The black pill is very effective and, if we are to believe this research, almost impossible to reverse.
It;s an ideology that has inoculated itself to being persuaded to think differently. That does of course not mean it's true, just that it's a very stubborn ideology.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
They are reminiscent of cringey tumblr feminists crying about the patriarchy for every imagined problem in their life and taking no accountability for themselves.
Ullixes@reddit
They are definetely negative images of each other, jeah. I would say thet there is genuine adversity and reason to be angry about unfairness in life, but in both groups. they just chose the wrong way to adress these adversities.
I am against the blanket "you are responsible for your own life and problems" ideological take. Many unfair things in life can and should be changed. recompense for being born with a dumb face is sadly not something society owes you. Accesible healthcare, a job that pays the rent or decent education we can and should demand.
CEO_of_IDK@reddit
That makes sense. The post states exactly why it doesn't work, doesn't it? "Barriers to engagement?" It's not gonna do shit if you don't let it.
NotRandomseer@reddit
If the study is out of 100 incels why are the percentages not whole numbers?
technoteapot@reddit
My issue with this is 100 is way too small of a pool to draw firm conclusions from, with stark contrasts like this it can bring about good guesses but anything strong you’d need a much larger pool
vitringur@reddit
To be fair, 100 subjects is way larger than many exercise science, psychology or economic studies that are published.
PJ_2005_01@reddit
In the defense of whoever made the study, it’s damn hard to get incels out of the basement
Jozef_Baca@reddit
As you notice those decimal points
Some of those incels had to be sawed into bits.
rhen_var@reddit
How does the sawing work with percentages? Is it based on total body mass lost or the usefulness of the lost body part? Would someone who’s lost a hand be considered less of a person than someone who had a hand-sized chunk of their leg sawed off?
ZDuskFP@reddit
Because those under 6" don't count as full men
ahamel13@reddit
My guess is that the outcomes were not a singular post-survey but milestone surveys conducted at different points during the study.
Or the study isn't real and OP is just bsing
Jetstream-Sam@reddit
As with all studies, some will quit
majesticle@reddit
a study on 100 incels in supposed to be conclusive?
also “therapy” is extremely broad term and when it comes to seeking help there are way too many modalities for them to have tried all of them. I personally did DBT after several years of different modalities didn’t work.
I call extreme BS on this study. It doesn’t stand up to much scrutiny
Source: major in psychology, pursing master in counseling concentration in higher ed.
popmyhotdog@reddit
I call extreme bs on you being a major or pursuing a masters. No study ever claims to be “conclusive” that’s literally antithetical to the scientific method and it never claimed that you just made up a strawman that it did which makes me question your literacy and bias. They claim to have some finding of what the data represents and then say if they think there should be further study and if so what. Studies show an outcome with a related statistical significance of what you have a range of having it be true extrapolated across populations based on sample size and findings. This is a normal small study used to try and demonstrate points to then get larger studies with greater samples sizes that require more budget because obviously it’s a lot harder and riskier to go study 100k or 10mil people based off of just a hypothesis- which again should have been literally stuff you learned your freshman year.
I think your issue with the study is that you didn’t like the results so you’ve just decided to arbitrarily call it invalid because you don’t “feel” the sample size is enough and “therapy” isn’t well defined(actual papers define these things and split them into categories). This is a normal study done under normal conditions and this is the kind of work you would be doing in a masters if you were actually doing it. Go ahead and study a thousand incels you think it’s gonna come up different? Or are you gonna say those results are suddenly wrong to- but not you. No it could never be your personal opinion that is wrong it’s the study and data that is wrong
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
I mean, this is pretty obvious.
Therapy doesn't work on anyone who's hostile or combative with it.
Incels aren't special in this regard. The post outright states why it wouldn't work.
ArcticLeopard@reddit
It also doesn't work on people who want actionable things to change. If someone is in therapy for X but there is literally nothing that can be done to make X better, they're gonna report an unfavorable outcome
Adduly@reddit
This is absolutely untrue. Therapy can absolutely help with this. It can help you change how you relate and deal to the unchangeable issue.
For example, someone suffering from PTSD, there's nothing a therapist can do to make the trauma go away. But it can help you let go of some of the pain, move your life past it, teach techniques to ride out panic attacks and rebuild your life after it.
ArcticLeopard@reddit
It can, but that also implies the patient is open to change. If a patient isn't, then they won't find therapy helpful
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
That's not how therapy works.
You have to be able to determine an issue before you can address it.
People who go into it, expecting to be told "You need to do X to address Y" aren't being open to it.
ArcticLeopard@reddit
Yes, you and I are aware of that. But that's not what everyone thinks. Some people think therapy is the magic end all be all where you go and get a solution and things improve without considering the work that goes in or the required introspection and desire for change.
WazuufTheKrusher@reddit
lmao tf are you talking about
ArcticLeopard@reddit
Some people go to therapy with the expectation that the therapist will give them a step by step list of how to improve whatever it is that's bothering them.
If the therapist cannot do that, for whatever reason, the person will see therapy as unhelpful.
For example, if a person went in for a broken leg and kept being asked "and how does that male you feel?" Then they would get really fed up because what they are looking for (how to set the bone) is not something the therapist can provide.
The same thing with an incel. If an incel is in therapy to work on confidence but the source for lack of confidence is something that the incel believes is outside of his control, then he will get angry
VicisSubsisto@reddit
Okay, that explains the 25.8% who were forced into therapy. What about the 45% who voluntarily sought therapy and reported negative outcomes?
Adduly@reddit
Depends how they mean forced.
Some might not be "forced" but try it expecting it to fail and so not be in the right headspace to benefit from it. Others might even go into it to prove that it doesn't work.
Others might not be "forced" but Badgered into it.
Even if someone isn't ordered to therapy doesn't mean they won't be combative and deeply skeptical about it.
Im_Sure_Thats_a_Lie@reddit
Some people reported it as a conspiracy to sedate and control, some stated practical concerns like cost and hospitalization. Sounds like those reasons could come from either one of those groups.
To reiterate : "The post outright states why it wouldn't work."
Adduly@reddit
Precisely. Therapy doesn't fix you. It helps you to fix yourself. You have to want to change and grow. If you'd rather wallow in self pity than put the effort in it won't help at all.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Yeah, vitamin C won't fix a broken arm? It's probably the victim's fault.
Jozef_Baca@reddit
Surgeon wont fix my broken arm because I start swinging whenever he tries to touch me.
I guess surgery can't fix a broken arm.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
That's how pseudoscientific foil hat men works, the first thing they do after seeing the result of scientific research is denial
Jozef_Baca@reddit
Brother are you a bot?
Kaszalot1352@reddit
No, I just don't believe in pseudoscience and witchcraft
Mishi_Mujago@reddit
Case and point.
I have no time to listen to opinions on therapy from someone who has never gone to therapy. It’s like how incels getting zero coochie claim to know everything about women.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Those people went to therapy and it didn't help any of them. Would you spend your time listening their opinions or are you too afraid that your view on therapy (and propably also on world) isn't true and it's not some wonderful cure against all problems?
Mishi_Mujago@reddit
It didn’t help them coz they didn’t want to be helped. Therapy is literally just vocalising your inner thoughts outwardly. The therapist can’t fix you, they don’t know your inner mind. The therapist is there to ask questions and guide you through your own mind. You might think “how can saying things out loud help?” But it absolutely does. Therapy is just talking to someone. If you don’t want to change and improve your life, therapy won’t work. That point was made by the original study.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
You don't even know them, you just saw the result of scientific research and the first thing you did was to deny it because you definitely know better than them
Little_Whippie@reddit
If you go into the doctor’s office expecting vitamin C to cure your broken arm then yeah it is your fault
Kaszalot1352@reddit
That's literally my point, theres no miraculous omne remedium that will fix all of someones problems
Little_Whippie@reddit
Nobody ever said there was
Kaszalot1352@reddit
You treat therapy like cure for everything and whine at other people when it don't work for them
Little_Whippie@reddit
This just in: Incel makes some bullshit up, more at 11
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Awww, you don't have any arguments, so you just insulted me.
Little_Whippie@reddit
Yeah I’m not engaging in good faith when you aren’t, massive own bro
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
If the victim genuinely thinks they can fix a broken arm with vitamin C, then yeah... That's on them.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
That's my point
jvken@reddit
A doctor can give you pills but if you believe the doctor to be working against your best intrests, you won't take them (poperly)
Kaszalot1352@reddit
Yeaaah sure, pills won't work because you don't believe they will work, that's how medicine works
Nvenom8@reddit
Exactly.
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
"It's your fault that you're suffering!"
Goes to therapy. Doesn't work.
"It's still your fault that you're suffering!"
That's why you don't give these people even an inch, bros.
Kaszalot1352@reddit
I don't think that reddit NPCs have enough critical thinking to stop their toxic positivity and to try to understand someone from outside their circlejerk
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
Who are these people assigning blame and are they in the thread with us right now?
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
Yeah, it's better to believe in this so-called cure where the only success stories are from people who were already predisposed to convince themselves that it's working. Try anything similar in a medical department; they'll laugh at you.
JohnnyXorron@reddit
It’s not about convincing yourself that it’s working it’s about even being open to it working. The subjects of the study went in completely shut off from the idea of it even being able to work.
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
The pill will work whether you believe it will or not. Something very basic that you learn in pharmacology is that, when developing a drug, you have to test it against the placebo effect.
JohnnyXorron@reddit
It’s not about the pill itself, though. It’s about if you are even willing to take it.
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
No, it's not. That's a fallacy. The equivalent of not taking the medication is not going to therapy, not "not being open," whatever that means. Besides, if the person doesn't feel comfortable opening up to the therapist, isn't the therapist not doing their job properly? And even if the person opens up, you can't say whether the cure came from the method or from a placebo.
Sudden_Pie5641@reddit
Unfortunately when it comes to psychology, would that be behaviour change or accepting something about yourself whether that you need help or that you can try different solutions - all that comes from your own readiness to try new things. Sometimes it’s despair, sometimes hope that pushes you to try other things. The difference with more « material » problems is that you normally see results of your actions immediately, while therapy or own behavioural changes are normally not giving any immediate results. Why I am writing this: most likely getting satisfaction and results from talking through the things with some specialist can come only if you come there at least neutral about possible outcomes. We are wiring ourselves all the time. Anything I am against of doesn’t have any meaning for me even if it’s factual - I just prefer not to agree with it. Therapy has taken a lot of political context and people wired themselves to hate it so they would never get any outcome of it. Even if they change their view on it it may not help them either - but at least they get a chance for a non-negative outcome.
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
There are non-negative outcomes outside of therapy too. Besides, sometimes the problem isn't you, but the hands you're given.
Therapy-talk is also a way of holding the individual responsible for psychological problems created mostly by material circumstances. They don't want to have to deal with a state of social anomie all over again.
Sudden_Pie5641@reddit
We didn’t talk about anything outside of therapy in this thread. It’s like replying to a message with « there are trees in the forest ». Of course there are things outside in the world, but we spoke about why people have difficult time working with a professional on their issues, and I tried to explain to the extent of my vocabulary and knowledge what usually holds people in these sessions from getting a chance of positive outcome. I hope this perspective will help someone who has a difficult time accepting changes to look differently on their challenges.
JohnnyXorron@reddit
Just because I go to the therapist’s office and sit in the room with them doesn’t mean I’m taking the pill. The therapist’s job isn’t to make you want to change. When I say you have to “be open” I mean that you need to actually trust that therapy could help you and not, to quote the article, that it is “designed to sedate and control” you. You need to believe that the person sitting across from you is working in your interest, which is clearly not the case with the subjects of the study.
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
Brother, that's bearly an answer to the question.
Sounds more like you're trying to convince yourself of something
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
Nah bro, you give me a half-hearted joke and I explain to you what I've meant in my first comment. There's no "convince myself" here, I already know what I think.
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
It wasn't a half-hearted joke though. It was highlighting that you're already coming at the topic in bad faith.
Like I said at the start, it only works if people are open to it and your response boil down to "See, it only works if you're pre-disposed to agree with it".
Like, yeah... that's my point. Why are you tryna convince yourself it's a bad thing?
Little_Whippie@reddit
You can’t read. If you go into therapy with a combative attitude or expecting it to not work then it will never work for you. You have to be actually willing to go through the process and be open to it
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
"You can't read", says the person that didn't read my other comments.
Little_Whippie@reddit
I actually did, they don’t change anything
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
You can't read.
Little_Whippie@reddit
See the thing is I can read, and I can read loud and clearly that you have a hostile attitude towards therapy. Obviously it’s not going to work like that dumbass
Slinto69@reddit
No hes right you cant read
Thedudeinabox@reddit
Precicely; as the black pill/ incell movement specifically demonized therapy, these people are now specifically hostile to it as a concept.
It’s not that these people can’t be cured, but now it has to happen by other means, typically meaning naturally.
Res_Novae17@reddit
This implies that therapy will be effective to anyone who is receptive to it, and this simply isn't the case. I've met with therapists and given them every opportunity to help me and all they do is ask questions and speak in vagaries and provide nothing actionable. The only thing that has ever helped me feel better has been to relentlessly do whatever it took to actually fix my situation.
Okay_Ocean_Flower@reddit
Bro is out here denying the antecedent
ILookAfterThePigs@reddit
You probably tried psychoanalysis when you were expecting cognitive-behavioral therapy
TheMcBrizzle@reddit
How did the original comment, imply this?
the_marxman@reddit
We live in a world of absolutes, Batman. If therapy doesn't work for those who don't want it to work then the inverse must hold that therapy works for anyone who wants it to work. Checkmate ♟️.
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
No, it doesn't. There is no absolute cure-all, but if you go into any form of support from a combative POV, it's never gonna work
hagamablabla@reddit
You really attracted the illiterate with this comment.
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
The responses are wild but I wouldn't insult them like that.
No one understands everything from the jump, I'm just hoping I can help shine some light or point them in some general direction.
ChoiceFudge3662@reddit
I mean what is therapy supposed to do for me, I’m short and fat, my time is better spent high on factorio
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Sounds like the gym would be better 😂
The_salty_swab@reddit
Does therapy genuinely provide positive outcomes for anybody? All that ever seems to spawn from therapy is more therapy
ver_bene@reddit
I dealt with severe PTSD after getting out of the military, and therapy taught me better coping strategies. Now I only have a bad day every once in a while, but I recognize that not everyone has good outcomes that
lifetimeoflaughter@reddit
Did you factor in the time that passed? Time is the best medicine after all.
Adduly@reddit
Time can both help and hurt.
If you have time and you weren't so badly hurt that you can continue with your life with plenty to occupy yourself then time can help heal psychological wounds.
If you're so badly hurt that your whole life changes and grinds to a stop (as often is with severe PTSD, losing friends and/or can't hold down a job or do the hobbies you love) then more time is just more time to ruminate over the painful thoughts into an ever deeper groove, fall further out of sync with life and fall ever deeper into a vicious spiral of pain and depression
dadsuki2@reddit
Not for PTSD it isn't. You hear stories all the time of people who never get past that shit
ver_bene@reddit
It certainly helped. But I was expecting time to fix it all, and things only got worse. Believe it or not actually trying to improve your life, does in fact work
T_Ijonen@reddit
You are absolutely correct. But you're also casting pearls before swine, these people have made being miserable their whole personality, they won't change, because then they would completely lose themselves.
majesticle@reddit
thank you for sharing, i did some PTSD based therapy program and it changed my life. wishing you the best
SuckerpunchJazzhands@reddit
I'm currently in therapy for PTSD and it's been incredibly rewarding. Hope all is well for you.
Nvenom8@reddit
Yes, it’s very helpful if you’re engaging with it seriously and your therapist isn’t terrible at their job. Doubly helpful if they’re a psychiatrist and can prescribe you medication if you need it.
KonamiKing@reddit
“I diagnose you with needing more of my services!”
WilliamBurrito@reddit
Do you think you could fix an incel in one session?
EquivalentSnap@reddit
A lot of the reason it failed is they told them what they don’t want to hear. They wanted someone to be an echo camber like 4chan threads. Wanted someone to affirm their beliefs and refused help. That it was just feminism way to control men
No you can’t fix someone in one session. Needs to come from them and positive role models
nnog@reddit
Yeah, just offer them sex.
will_xo@reddit
Yes, finding the right therapist and allowing myself to be completely honest with her - and trust what she says - helped me immensely with depression and anxiety. It did take a couple tries before finding the right one.
EquivalentSnap@reddit
It’s nice to talk to someone about things I bottle up and keep private. They don’t judge you. Theroaht doesn’t solve your problems and I don’t follow their advice as best I could but you need to follow through it as sessions alone won’t change your life
Shawer@reddit
There’s good therapists and bad therapists out there. There’s also good patients and bad patients. Quite ironically, the people who would benefit the most from therapy are generally people who are capable of the introspection and identification of cognitive dissonance and problems in their mindset or environment that means they don’t need therapy.
The people who would benefit most from therapy are people unwilling to actually do the extremely difficult work involved in therapy. But if they were willing to, it would improve their lives and the lives of their families immensely.
Throw bad therapists into the mix, which I’m inclined to think is quite a lot of them, and you have recipes for disaster.
For reference, I’m doing a psychology degree part-time. Some of these people are going to pass that are themselves either super mal-adjusted or worse just not intelligent - and you need psychologists to actually be smart.
Not that I have my shit together or am the sharpest tool in the shed myself. But what I see still alarms me. Some of these people aren’t capable of questioning themselves at all, and at some point they’ll essentially be in charge of regulating other people’s mindsets.
Coronel_Flokill@reddit
Not sure I agree with the best patience thing, being able to identify what is wrong with you isn't the same as fixing the issue. Therapy works by investigating with the patient not the only cause of the issue, but what is stopping this person from dealing with the issue. If I can spot my cognitive dissonance, have enough introspection to name my feelings, but I am still suffering, then therapy would work on that roadblock and identifying why I'm still in this state. This is the reason why therapy styles where the therapist has a more active role during the healing process and works with the client are usually more effective (take CBT for example, in comparasion with a more humanist approach). Just knowing what's wrong usually isn't enough.
talllongblackhair@reddit
The problem is that most people expect therapy to have slow, steady progress but it doesn’t always work that way. I found that you can go for months without any progress at all and wonder wtf you’re doing this, but then one session you have a major, life changing realization. When you get that session you have to be willing to change and take action however.
Slinto69@reddit
Its kinda like believing in Santa. If youre not seeing results its because you dont believe enough and suggests you might be a bad person.
Little_Whippie@reddit
My therapist gives me a space to talk about what’s bothering me without judgement and helps me orient my thinking to be more positive and productive. Because of her I haven’t been suicidal in over a year
mighty_bandersnatch@reddit
For all the flak psychologists take from "real" scientists, yes, talk therapy does seem to work. Nobody really knows why, unless you count speculation, which always just winds up being tautological description of human psychology, but outcomes are improved. My source is someone who graduated with a psych degree before switching to medicine out of frustration over this fact.
I think, with the total confidence of someone who has no idea what he is talking about, that a problem that needs to be addressed is that some therapists may be quacks, and because success in the system is based on whether people come back to pay for more therapy rather than on outcomes, they continue to treat people ineffectively.
GreenNukE@reddit
It can, but the details are very important to its effectiveness. There are different types of therapy that are suited to different patients. Some patients are not well suited to what's available (availability being a serious issue). Patients also need to engage with the right mindset for anything to work. Medication can also be an essential part of treatment that therapy cannot replace.
Psychiatry has advanced a lot, but our medical understanding of the mind and brain are still limited. We've identified many treatments than can work, but the mechanisms remain murky.
Wawrzyniec_@reddit
For those who are not forced into it and actively partake into it, instead of resisting the concept with every fiber of their body, it usually works.
(Obviously depends on which kind of therapy for which kind of problem)
EinMuffin@reddit
Yeah, it genuinely turned my life around. I had a lot of self destructive ways of thinking, ideas and coping mechanisms, often stemming from childhood experiences and "wrong" lessons I learned during that time.
Therapy helped me unravel a lot of these things and helped me to actually understand and feel my own emotions, which is kind of essential if you want to live a happy life.
But a lot had to go right for that. My therapy was free due to public health insurance, I was lucky to get a spot (there is a massive shortage of therapists in my country), I was lucky to get a good therapist on my second try and I was willing to do the work, open up to her and give everything she suggested a chance, even if it seemed weird or unhelpful.
Shawer@reddit
That’s a big one. Sometimes your problems are just problems you have to solve. Sometimes the problem is your actual cognitive processes. Therapy works for one of these, but not the other.
EinMuffin@reddit
exactly. My case was the latter so it helped immensely. Right now I am struggling with the former though lol.
And this is also why I am not surprised it is not helping. From the study it sounds that a lot of the participants didn't want therapy, so they didn't open up and do the work. Of course nothing changes in that case.
On top of that, I think for a lot of incels the problem goes further than just cognitive processes. A lot of them lack the necessary social skills to find someone (among other stuff). Therapy isn't going to build those skills either. And if loneliness is your biggest source of pain therapy can't really change that either. It can only help you cope.
MrCattsDad@reddit
I had a great therapist when I was younger and I think her work with me really did help me become a much more functional person.
Saying that, I am still very skeptical of therepy and think I just got very very lucky getting someone who actually cared beyond just seeing me as a money bag, which I think is the experience most people get.
Vespasian79@reddit
And a reliance on drugs!
Idk I have friends who talk to therapists and it helps for sure
Shawer@reddit
A psychologist worth their salt won’t recommend drugs as anything more than an extremely desperate and short-term stopgap. A psychiatrist may be more inclined to do so, as they’re first and foremost doctors, leading to a generally different mindset.
Settleforthep0p@reddit
bruh don’t be a mental treadmill friend
Vespasian79@reddit
Settleforthep0p@reddit
I mean lots of people. 75% according to APA but it’s probably inflated. Still, incels are not just mentally unhealthy, they are probably more aptly classified as being part of a cult.
Therapy won’t make an unwilling person change, especially not at the cost of their entire social network. It’s also a question of completely disrupting someones perceived experience of how the world works, which isn’t exactly comparable to ”normal” therapy, again probably has more in common with cult deprogramming.
Impressive-Door-2581@reddit
Stopped me from being borderline suicidal everday. So theres that.
Life still kinda sucks, but not at much. Therapy is a slow-burn treatment. Its going to take a few years for most, like me. That and as another person said, you must be willing to make change in the first place.
OfficialSandwichMan@reddit
Yes, but one has to be willing to change to make use of therapy
Samurai123lol@reddit
If you actually went to read the study, its an almost meme level study. I think there are some of the problems:
A) if you are an incel and went to therapy AND it worked, would you post about it on a incel forum
B) Much of that dataset was analyzed by Nvivo, no idea how they uploaded the threads into it so it could have hallucinated stuff if it wasnt inserted correctly, havent personally used it so no idea how amazing it is.
C) If you are an incel, how much does that factor into your emotional intelligence, being able to describe why something feels the way it does etc.
D) to point C, the study does go through "the blackpill" how potent it is but thats probably a core issue why therapy isnt effective, having a very potent and "hardcoded" belief is going to require tens to hundreds of hours to get rid of.
Probably too much effort into a comment on a reddit shitpost about 4chan about a study on a incel forum (the quad whammy)
Babylon_Burning@reddit
Can you link it? I can’t seem to find it.
Samurai123lol@reddit
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10503307.2025.2600546
Lemak0@reddit
It really depends on the patient's mindset though. If you don't want to change and turn your life around and believe therapy will do that for you, nothing good can come from this.
For therapy to work you have to realize that it's you who has the power and responsibility to change your life and therapy only gives you a toolkit to help accomplish that.
EthernalForADay@reddit
Therapy is essentially you paying someone to help YOU help YOURSELF.
Fundamentally, if incel revels in their own misery and is unwilling to change, due to how conveniently their belief system absolves them of any responsibility for their romantical/sexual life, no therapy or treatment outside of a lobotomy will help them.
There are of course wrong therapists for the job, but in most cases most therapists are able to provide a necessary basis for at least some gradual improvement, granted this is what you came for.
When your worldview is of concern, there will be no magic pill or power sentence that will help you. Only yourself slowly and painstakingly working out your issues and fallacies, finding ways to move forward.
And while at it, antidepressants are there when your psyche is pushed down so hard, it is likely physically impossible for you to work your issues out by yourself or with verbal therapy. It's about suppressing parts of your brain actively shutting you out of being able to help yourself, not solving the actual issue, it's valid and important, just not the point of the the treatment, only part of one.
Nvenom8@reddit
ugottagetschwiftyyy@reddit
You can lead the donkey to the water, but you can't make it drink.
Therapy doesn't work if you don't want it to work.
Wanting to get better is probably the biggest indication if therapy will work. Beeing honest with yourself and realising you are your biggest roadblock.
Hit_It_N_Quidditch@reddit
Like 80-90% of the indicator of therapy working is
I doubt any of them want help, nor do they think a therapists "stupid" words are going to change anything... so yea, not going to work. Therapy isn't an injection that just works. Just like physical therapy, you have to work, do the work at home, and stay engaged.
ManifestingCrab@reddit
Most incels I unfortunately run into are also narcissistic so it's not surprising.
Educational-Coat-922@reddit
Therapy dont do shit for those who dont want it
Lev--@reddit
In cells don't need therapy they need Society to fucking change some what
Outis918@reddit
Therapy doesn’t solve issues that require cultural shifts. Nor do they create coping skills without destroying male identity. Fuck therapy.
RevenantCommunity@reddit
Therapy is a two way street that requires self-awareness and accountability.
Which incels infamously have none of
EatAllTheShiny@reddit
IMO 80% of modern therapy has just figured out that most people don't really want to change, and they just want validation. Or, if you're high enough IQ, you can usually just run your talk therapist around in perpetual circles (for people who are *put into* therapy and don't really want to be there). "Oh, I can just sit here and make $200 an hour validating people's feelings about how badly they exercise their moral free agency? Cool."
Results based therapy that works with the body is the only way, if you really want things to change.
And willingness to change.
ThePassiveGamer@reddit
Le reddit bait
dark_holes@reddit
I know two girls who are therapists and they’re both dumb as a bag of rocks and I couldn’t possibly fathom taking mental health advice from them. I know it’s a small sample size and obviously not reflective of the entire industry but it really gave me some confirmation bias in thinking it’s not exactly the most legitimate practice.
DoggyMcDogDog@reddit
Then "it" enters the room
Btw what the hell is a "lolly"?
There you go
Meowza_V2@reddit
You can't get help if you don't want it.
AdorableDonkey@reddit
Incels need pussy, not therapy
Therapy may help after getting pussy
new_KRIEG@reddit
Incels need to not be incels to get pussy. So far, the best option we have for unshittfying someone is therapy.
BackseatCowwatcher@reddit
Yah, problem is that Therapy won't help a 4'5 300lb man with an unfortunate face that makes you assume his family tree was stealing notes from the Habsburg's.
a lot of them aren't 'involuntary' just because their personalities are shit, their personalities being shit is in fact a result of finding out the hard way that even equally deformed women aren't interested in them.
Impassable_Banana@reddit
Well they can sure as shit start by losing weight.
amidoes@reddit
Are the women not interested, or are their standards unreasonably high? It's obvious a guy like that isn't gonna bag a 10/10 baddie, but some won't "settle" for anything less than that while offering nothing noteworthy in return
Mahajangasuchus@reddit
The women are not interested. You don’t have to be a misogynist incel to recognize the reality that the bottom percentiles of men are basically never going to get attention or interest from women.
new_KRIEG@reddit
Yeah, but have you ever gone to the incel forums to see their pics? I lurked in those a lot, and most dudes there just need the classic trifecta of normie advice: "take a shower, go to a barber, and learn to dress", that, and to stop being cunts.
The 4ft5 300 lb man is the absolute fucking exception, not the rule. Most dudes just have some shitty canthal tilt, are balding, and have a weak jawline, which is absolutely not on par with being an overweight midget.
AdorableDonkey@reddit
As if shitty people never got pussy 🙄
bustermagnus@reddit
Any kind of self destructive ideology is a sickness of the mind, not the body. Having sex would not make an incel less misanthropic or self-obsessed.
creator-the-hater@reddit
Hence
brotherofgurnip@reddit
We need therapussy
LebrahnJahmes@reddit
Same reason rehab doesnt work for all addicts they dont want to change
Hogzor@reddit
Bro look like you hit randomize in Oblivion character creation.
poopcockshit@reddit
Something something horses and water
UnsavouryFibrosis@reddit
Honestly, I think it’s an addiction. There’s company in misery. It’s hard to escape the environment when it’s online, you can’t just move like other addictions. Plus, doomerism can be comforting especially when you share it with others.
stormspirit97@reddit
Therapy can't resolve you genuinely living a shitty meaningless life as low value societal trash with little ability to get out of that even with effort.
DeckJesta@reddit
Breaking News: Treatment that requires the ability to self-reflect doesn't work on people who can't self-reflect.
sk_arch@reddit
In therapy, you have to have some type of self awareness for any positive effect to occur, isn’t the whole concept to incels nowadays is that it’s the women’s fault, not theirs?
400asa@reddit
Therapy is a social technology developped to extract money from the nineteenth century bourgeoisie.
If it doesn't work on the 21st century low-life, it's not a mystery.
CorbinNZ@reddit
Why is picrel always the poster child of incels? Poor guy.
thataintapipe@reddit
“Do you agree with the authors conclusions” is part of the problem.
Here’s some research, how do you, an emotionally stunted dipshit feel about the results?
LukeJaywalker0@reddit
Therapy doesn't work on men because have men have objective problems like being ugly and poor that you can't talk your way out of. Women have subjective problems like how they feel about being molested. Obviously both are real problems, but the latter can't actually be fixed in the real world so all she can do is talk until she feels better. The man actually has to change the objective reality of his situation, therefore, therapy is counterproductive because it consumes time and resources and encourages rumination instead of action.
This is a flippant summary of my thoughts on the matter you can nitpick if you want.
Secludedmean4@reddit
My only gripe with therapy is the cost, it’s just paying people to vent. Most of what I had experienced in therapy was just self help stuff I already had learned on my own and was just an outlet for me to bitch. I don’t need to spend 100+ to bitch to a therapist when I have online outlets anonymously or friends who will listen (to a smaller extent)
EquivalentSnap@reddit
Those online outlets will listen sure but if can give you bad advice or make your problems worst. You pay money to have someone who trained and will help. Your online friends could tell you women are the problem and agree with conspiracy theories
Coronel_Flokill@reddit
If you are paying only to vent, then there is something wrong with the therapist. Therapy is a collaborative work, the therapist is supposed to work with you in order to investigate your problems, not just listen to you vent. Even the more classical approaches, where we have this classic view of "you talk I listen", the therapist still has some level of activity to where you aren't just talking to a wall.
Treadmillrunner@reddit
I get that it is painfully expensive but it sounds like you haven’t found a good one.
It shouldn’t feel like either venting or self help books. A good therapist will be listening to you and the way you speak about things to determine what you need to be taught or to notice so that you can help rewire your brain.
The way that I see it, every problem is either external (something you have to fix in your life) or internal (you need to determine what it is and how you can deal with it) or both. Therapy can be incredible for the internal stuff if you have a good teacher.
Secludedmean4@reddit
My biggest problem is external (money/ cost of living and how fucked the house market is) by going to therapy I am actively pushing myself further away from affordability by spending money on things.
But yes after 3 separate therapists (different cultural backgrounds / genders even) I got a very similar experience and a lot of it was just along the lines of “well you’re self aware but you can’t really fix this” so the therapy did not really help make me less depressed about this world or give me a more positive outlook unfortunately.
Ok_Elk_4333@reddit
There are different forms of therapy.
Most therapists:
1) Specialise in a specific kind 2) Also offer accessory stuff shared by most therapist, like letting you vent, offering basic self-help advice, ect
Sounds like your therapist was simply under qualified
Katastrofa2@reddit
The only value I find in therapy is my therapist calling out my bullshit and telling me, in a nice way, to stop being a little bitch. Still not sure this is helpful or worth the money...
42Ubiquitous@reddit
That's the only way I think therapy would work for me. I don't want to just complain; I want someone to attack my excuses and the underlying reasoning. I've known a couple of people who were exceptionally good at that, but they weren't therapists.
PrepperBoi@reddit
I can call you a bitch for free
Danny-Fr@reddit
Well for that kind of service it's either ah therapists or an escort, I guess the therapist is marginally cheaper?
AdorableDonkey@reddit
Also some therapists want to use you as a guinea pig for expensive medications
"Use this one, if it doesn't work we'll try another"
Homunkulus@reddit
Psychiatrists aren't the same thing as therapists.
WilliamBurrito@reddit
That’s not using you as a guinea pig, that’s trying to find a medicine that will actually work for you because everyone responds to drugs differently, that’s why there are so many different options. Jfc…
PGSylphir@reddit
Forced into therapy wont work for anyone, incel or not.
Therapy wont ever work on someone who's not willing to do the work and get better. Which is the majority of incels.
It's an obvious conclusion dictated by simple logic, no scientific research is needed for this.
JeaniousSpelur@reddit
The issue is that they’re being forced into therapy. It’s like forcing an alcoholic to quit. Incels receive tons of advice all the time but prefer to wallow in their misery - it’s no different with a therapist.
Uncle_Yoba@reddit
I'm a volcel, and it doesn't help me either.
Must have something to do with sex, I recon.
PoshDiggory@reddit
Many incels would probably find sex underwhelming. I know I did, now I don't care about it.
PoshDiggory@reddit
Grooming, dressing well/more fashionable, and working on your charisma goes a long way.
Bistro_Clancy@reddit
Link to the article: https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10503307.2025.2600546#d1e360
This post is misleading, it wasn't studying 100 incels, it was 89 users who "unambiguously reported attending mental health therapy (i.e., psychiatry, psychotherapy, group therapy, or mental health hospitalization)". the 100 is the amount of discussion threads they analysed to find the users. They didn't recruit any participants, it was all analyses of posts.
It is not a "woah, they studied 100 incels who went to therapy and IT ONLY WORKED FOR 7.9%", it is a "they found 89 people complaining about therapy and weirdly enough 7 of them said they had a good time."
Idk read it for yourself, it's not that surprising when given proper context. The goal of the study sounds more explicitly about "how can we better help people who are almost specifically resistant to therapy." Also I don't think anyone is going to have a good experience with therapy if they are forced into it or forced to attend.
Theta291@reddit
You have to believe and put effort into therapy for it to work.
MassRedemption@reddit
You have to actively participate and care about therapy for it to improve you. If you just go because you have to, it's not going to do anything. You still have to be willing to change.
Incels/plackpill are set in their ways. They are stubborn and only see the world through their own view.
Hlinanas@reddit
Sadly you need to have a certain mindset and a little bit of skill for therapy to work.
Alex014@reddit
Wow youre telling me therapy doesn't work on people who won't engage with it in good faith and dont believe it could actually help them?
In order for therapy to work you have to eventually acknowledge you could use some improvement/change and only you can improve/change it. Its usually a conversation you have with someone who causally points out flaws in your own world view. It won't ever work if you blame your situation on external issues that may not even be real.
SageoftheForlornPath@reddit
The problem is that it's too late. They needed that help before they took the black pill.
LazarusPizza@reddit
Therapy can't work on someone unwilling to engage with it. The study concluded that incels are too entrenched and stuck in their own way to consider any alternatives, or the possibility of working on themselves.
It's not that therapy doesn't work. It's that they refuse to engage in it. The 8% that did seemed to report satisfaction.
MariusCatalin@reddit
many therapists ignore the concerns the regular man has, thats the sad truth, they simply dont consider how deep some beliefs are entrenched
9lazy9tumbleweed@reddit
Therapy doesnt work on people that are unwilling to work on themselves, self reflect and blame everything and everyone else for their problems.
Maybe you cant fix everything about yourself but you dont have to in order to succeed.
A therapist also doesnt work you like a project, you use them and their knowledge to help you, the only place where they actually work you is with medication if needed.
Spiritual_Parking_70@reddit
The way it seems to me a therapist helps point out the dots and it's up to you to draw the lines to connect them and understand your problems. The most important bit of therapy is the introspection between sessions and taking accountability for your situation. This is impossible if you believe the tenants of inceldom to be true.
aj_thenoob2@reddit
But who makes that decision? Does the therapist know that this person is unsaveable and will end the relationship? Doubtful.
9lazy9tumbleweed@reddit
Sometimes therapists do cut of patients for various reasons, if a patient refuses teatment and is actively self destructing a therapist can and will cut you off since you arent responding to it.
Its not about being unsaveable, its about wether someone is willing to cooperate and work together with them or if they arent.
Blashmir@reddit
"Forced into Therapy". Theres your answer there. If someone doesnt want to change they arent going to.
idlickherbootyhole@reddit
Hold onto your asses, anon is onto something big here.
Jumper2002@reddit
In my experience therapy was a scam and was just them trying to shovel me pills to get me to leave them alone
duva_@reddit
Therapy MAY work if you want to attend, if you already identified that you need help or have the will to change. It's not magic
foxinabathtub@reddit
Therapy only works if you want to be there and actively work on yourself. It doesn't fix you, it gives you tools so that you can then go and work on yourself.
You would have a bad time with any type of doctor if you constantly fight them and don't take anything they prescribe you.
AngusLynch09@reddit
Because they're arrogant and therapy only works if you honestly and sincerely engage with it.
chriszenpaok@reddit
This just sounds like describing a scam
AngusLynch09@reddit
Case in point.
Ok-Lynx3444@reddit
I did do that i told them everything and detailed how i was aware of what needed to be done to improve my quality of life but was to unmotivated to do so and all he did was pull “yah parents definitely had a play in making you like this” with no solution for anything and then plainly said he was stumped offering to fill the remaining 20 minutes playing chess
Objective-Lawyer5428@reddit
With a sample size of 100 people, you only get decimal percentages, if your measuring is already fucked up - fake.
Also, wanting to intimately talk to other guys - gay
After "Fake & Gay" is proven, 'what if true':
1) What kind of therapy are we even talking about?
Court ordered treatment for anti-social/ violent behaviour? Therapy for drug addiction?
Or did they jump in because "family and friends staged an intervention"?
In those cases, a lot of metastudies have proven, that a baseline (changing and depending on circumstances, average age and sex or participants) considers any given therapy as "useless" or "designed to repress" them - wouldn't call that a consiracy theory but an inherent adversion to comply.
If - on the other hand - the participant wanted the therapy for themselves, what were their expectations/ prior experiences? Again, with any given medical profession, there are patients who simplex expect doctors/ nurses/ therapists to fix their problems for them.
You can go to a physiologst and explain pain in your knees but if you're 200lbs overweight, maybe contribute a little to the healing instead fo leaving a scathing google review?
And if you are a toxic person blaming others for your shortcomings, maybe a therapist is not the kind of help you actually need? They won't explain to you, why the world has it in for you - of course any manosphere influencer will gladly take the same money off your hands and agree with you or even add more reasons why you are not to blame for your behaviour and others' reaction to it.
2) What is the "incel" qualifier? Did they talk to 100 people, who had no sexual/ intimate contact for 5 years? 10 Years?
Assuming ANON did not omit facts, the "study" was carried out on the basis of self-reports, so how did they make sure there was a suffciently large group on incels and a "neutral group" of non-incels to verify the statistic efficacy of the reported results? Especially number 4 seems a fitting result of any given medical treatment which is not covered by health insurance, even here in Europe. Especially psychotherapy and most of dental treatments are not covered so the primary concern is not "will it help?" but "can I even afford that?" - privacy is a general concern, especially when you are suddenly part of a study you did not sign up for. Hospilization for "being an asshole" therapy? Really? This point alone makes me question whether (given the premise that there actually was such a study with too small a sample and "7.9 out of 100 people" results) the questionnaire was even probed with a pre-test group. Did the therapy even adress "incelism" or did they just ask people (100 of which were qualified as incels) random questions about their divere experiences with any therapy they ever had?
3darkdragons@reddit
To any in cells here, looking for constructive advice I would probably look elsewhere the Internet’s not a great place for that kind of advice and this place is kind of like an Isis execution ground
Moonwatcher_2001@reddit
St. Black Ops 2... it's been a long time since I've been blessed with his presence.
TenMillionEnchiladas@reddit
I forget where I heard it but I never heard a more true statement: That's where therapy is flawed, you have to believe in it for it to work.
And it seriously is true though, if you go into therapy not expecting it to work and think it's a bunch of bullshit then it doesn't matter how good the advice is your brains gonna subconsciously reject all of it, in a kind of fucked up way, it's like a placebo.
Slinto69@reddit
Therapy and faith healing are the same thing then.
Altruistic-Ad-6593@reddit
Sir, you just described religion
albinorhino215@reddit
Therapy works when you want to change/improve yourself.
If you see it as the world is mistreating you or that you are in the right and everyone else is wrong nothing is gonna change that
Additional-Finish-89@reddit
i only believe a sample size 10k plus
Ok_Elk_4333@reddit
If sample size is your main determinant of whether something is statistically significant, then you know nothing about statistics or study design
If you could rule out confounding variables or reporting bias would that still be your threshold?
If 4,000 cancer patients with a placebo died, and all 4,000 who took the pill recovered completely within a week, would that not be statistically significant enough for you?
majesticle@reddit
this guys stats
whiteco11artrash@reddit
There are actually mathematical functions for statistical significance.
If you disagree with how that works, then you actually disagree with how math works, which means you in fact know very little about stats.
To put this in perspective, 1 in 1 of your posts that I have read are stupid. I consider that pretty telling even with the small sample size.
Additional-Finish-89@reddit
Its indicative sure but not definitive. I do believe the results tbf just not off face value off this 'survey'
PrepperBoi@reddit
It’s pretty hard to get 100 incels to leave the house much less 10k
LarKanon@reddit
Are we talking psychology therapy? Because if so, there is already a low chance to work to begin with.
Mahajangasuchus@reddit
Therapy can only address the internal mindset of a person. It does nothing to cure someone’s height, face, ethnicity, looks, or other unchangeable things. Wanting a girlfriend and being unable to get one is an external problem beyond a certain point. The meme advice of “hit the gym” doesn’t hurt but it also only goes so far for someone with other immutable features.
The “best” therapy could do is trick someone into thinking that they can or should be happy being unloved and alone.
psinguine@reddit
I love how they put arguably the biggest issue (the cost as a barrier to entry) as the last thing on the list.
Autumn_Fire@reddit
The other issue is that a lot of therapists are shockingly bad. I've been in therapy for a while and my god the amount of therapists who honestly should not be therapists is rather staggering.
When you get a great therapist and you're receptive to healing, the progress can be immense (and I can attest to this personally) but great therapists are far too difficult to come by, unfortunately. I'm not surprised the satisfaction rate is so low when one of the most popular therapy strategies (CBT) is essentially just gaslighting yourself into being ok with overly academic talk to make you think it's smart.
yaangyiing_@reddit
forced into therapy? that literally sounds like torture
Dry-Tower1544@reddit
the study was on 100 incels how do they get parts of a percentage point
RatOgryn@reddit
Therapy only works for those who want to be helped. Hateful, bitter incels don't want to be helped. They want to wallow with likeminded individuals.
UpbeatRegister@reddit
Isn't that true though?
Little_Whippie@reddit
I don’t know what kind of therapists you’ve had but mine have never been hostile towards me or masculinity. My therapist basically gives me a judgement free zone to talk about what’s bothering me with a mental health professional
mighty_bandersnatch@reddit
The feminist equivalent of incels say it's biased against women, so somebody must be wrong.
I briefly went to a couples therapist who turned out to be religious and he certainly wasn't female-biased lol
Fearless_Occasion989@reddit
Both are true. It was developed to treat "hyterical" women who could not behave and act as good wives. But that was like in the first half of the 20th century. It's just one more case of feminists complaining about a problem that has been solved decades ago.
majesticle@reddit
no.
UpbeatRegister@reddit
The_Billy_Dee@reddit
Good. We don't need ugly, stupid assholes breeding.
mrhaluko23@reddit
Men like practical solutions to things. From personal experience, talking-therapy has been the least helpful. CBT is so much better and practical.
Limp-Temperature1783@reddit
Because incels don't want help. You can't save someone who doesn't want to be saved. Incels aren't insane either. They live in shit because they think the whole world is shit and of course their opinion is the only correct opinion on the planet. No matter what they do or what they hear, unless they stop assuming that everyone and everything is against them, they won't stop being incels. Simple as.
Even if you present an incel with an argument that 100% proven by lots of people and science, they will still continue to believe in their bullshit. It's like talking to a wall. There is not much to expect. The problem is real, unfortunately, but not many people can deal with someone delusional and there aren't many ways to prevent delusions from resurfacing again.
Vertex138@reddit
Outed himself as fake so quickly
NecessaryCockroach85@reddit
How can the study be on 100 people and 25.8% were forced into therapy?
the_marxman@reddit
You can't help someone who doesn't want help.
UpsetPhilosopher4661@reddit
as incel i find therapy to be a very "cotton candy world" to seeing things. yes, it can and will help some people, but for most their problems will simply never go away, and "learning to accept them" feels like a cop out.
i've found that accepting that romantic love is simply not a thing for me will bring me more peace in the long run than trying to change for someone who would nor will stay with me at my lowest
mrbigglesworth95@reddit
This shouldn't be surprising. The problem incels face is the cel part and therapy isn't going to change that. Therapy is just paying for someone to listen to you share your hardships with them. Occasionally they might offer some advice, but they seldom tell you to do this or that.
The problem I think is that what these people likely need are not therapists but life coaches. People who can lay out to them: step 1 do this, step 2 do this, etc. You don't get that with therapy.
esssssto@reddit
To be fair, they are right in one thing, therapy (Behavioural, Gestalt, psychosnalysis) is mostly based on female studies, since during the 1900's most patients were female.
That doesn't mean It can't work on men, but men, specially incels, requiere more than talking and reasoning.
Physical therapy, sports, gym, socializing activities, should be the basis of therapy for these kinds of cases. Their negativity can be very hard to deal with reasoning, they first need rewiring.
8696David@reddit
How can you have 70.8% of 100 people
evilandregarded@reddit
I'm learning that people get really fucking mad whenever therapy doesn't work for someone
Subpar_diabetic@reddit
Therapy isn’t the end all be all of mental health. It certainly wouldn’t be for people determined to be as miserable as humanly possible like the inkwells
NiceGuya@reddit
Imagine not having a leg. Going to the therapy aint gonna work, is it
jack-whitman@reddit
If you're not willing to learn or change w therapy then TJ's absolutely wasted money.
I've been in therapy for 5 years, my progress is only as good as the work I actually do on it when not in therapy
Real-Ad-1728@reddit
Not surprising that it didn’t dont work for the people forced into it.
LordJanas@reddit
Can't help people who don't want to be helped.
Hugo_Spaps@reddit
Therapy with incels doesn’t work because incel ideology is extremely fatalistic. Incels generally believe that none of their problems are their fault, which is a problem since, for therapy to work, patients need to be receptive to acknowledging their own faults and working to change them. Incels won’t because it goes against their worldview.
Few-Requirement-3544@reddit
I mean, 2 and 3 are guarantees that it won't help. If you perceive that you are in some sort of enemy territory being brainwashed, then your internal narrative will be that you are a heroic main character in a story, like Picard and the lights; it's not only a duty, but a gratifying one, to resist and come out unscathed.
MattTheGuy2@reddit
Therapy doesn’t help incels because they simply do not want to be helped. That is why they are incels
A__Whisper@reddit
To be fair, something like 92% of therapists are now female. I'd call that a bias, but yeah the echo chamber makes you miserable.
One-Bad-4274@reddit
You cant help someone who wont help themselves
LesserValkyrie@reddit
A psychiatrist explains why therapy sucks for men and it's very interesting because it really highlights how men and women's brains are wired differently when handling these kinds of subjects
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uf8bt6fGQyA
Okamitoutcourt@reddit
*why doesn't therapy help" my brother in Christ you are actively trying not to make it work
Pelon01@reddit
I mean half of those points are valid. Therapy ain't all that
eruizb_@reddit
ShortBrownAndUgly@reddit
Therapy will not work on someone who doesn’t want to change or get better. If someone doesn’t think they even have a problem, getting that buy in will be difficult and may just result in them pushing back harder
allnameshadbeentaken@reddit
I think it might be less effective because the therapist is going against an entire ideology that's embedded in the incel's mind. Just a few sessions a month is nothing compared to constant validation of your beliefs from Instagram accounts and incel grifters through social media all day every day. There's a chance some individuals spent more time monthly looking at Andrew Tate's face than their therapist's
ATF8643@reddit
Therapy no, coaching/counseling might help more
Zelcki@reddit
Why do the procentaged have decimals if the study was conducted on 100 incels?
BannedfromFrontPage@reddit
I am also willing to bet that a lot of incels lack success in therapy because it would break their reality. Being an incel makes them feel like heroes within their community. They get to share their story and receive validation while reading the stories of others which echoes their experience. This feels good much in the same way candy tastes good but isn’t a filling meal.
Therapy isn’t about forcing opinions or ideology down throats. 99% of therapy is just being listened to by an impartial 3rd party. It’s about identifying specific unhealthy behaviors that cause unhappiness and dysfunction and, metaphorically, leading people to water.
Ultimately, it’s the patient that has to take actions and make changes to improve their lives. Similarly, a nutritionist can look at your diet, health, behaviors and recommend improvements, but the patient is the one who has to do the work.
PleasantVanilla@reddit
Celibacy can easily be solved by paying for sex - probably more cheaply than a therapists visit. Escorts, massage parlours, strippers.
Now, many incels feel that this isn't good enough. Why should they pay for sex while others get it for free?
Well, that's just not a very interesting topic. Why wasn't I born rich? How come my cock isn't more girthy? Why is my hairline receding? Why do innocent children die of cancer on the daily?
There's no shortage of tragedy and unfairness in this world, large and small. The only thing you can do in this life is to try and better yourself and play the best hand with whatever cards you've been dealt. Most incels to refuse to do even that.
Do-it-for-you@reddit
No, inceldom comes from the mindset that they think nobody will ever love them.
Paying for sex to get laid… kinda proves to them that the only way they’ll ever get laid is if they paid for sex.
It’ll make things much worse for him.
PleasantVanilla@reddit
Prostitution is a solution to celibacy, and thus inceldom.
There's no arguing this - according to the very definition of the words. Like, this is just baseline reality.
Incels struggling to come to grips with this just proves their inability to accept reality for what it is.
TheDwiin@reddit
Therapy is a good thing, but some people see it as a magic bullet. It is not. You need to work on improving yourself, a therapist is only giving you the tools and guiding you on how to do it, but it is still you doing it.
Now a psychiatrist, not a therapist, can diagnose you with certain illnesses and conditions and match you with a therapist who specializes in those conditions which can help you further than just going to a normal therapist.
But there is one slight pitfall that a lot of people fall into when it comes to therapy... It has to be willing... Forcing someone to see a mental health person who is not a danger to themselves or others is not going to be productive.
mustafaaosman339@reddit
Incels have a mindset that they can't be helped. It's built in to being an incel
You aren't going to be helped if your natural reaction is to fight against it and use it as a reason to be worse.
Xeon5568@reddit
Therapy helps promote change but but you also have to want to change.
ComissionerClown@reddit
If y'all have watched Shy Boys, a documentary about incels, some of them are very miserable towards women and some others are not. None of them i'd call expressly ugly but their attitudes towards life all suck to high heaven and if they just cleaned themselves up, both physically and mentally, they'd find someone.
Vlad_The_Great_2@reddit
How is therapy going to help you when you are sad you don’t have a girlfriend? It seems like an open and shut case. This issue comes when that person thinks a relationship will magically change every aspect of their life instead of just having one more person to talk to or be intimate with.
CBSmartCA@reddit
Well, seeing women as individuals with their own desires and preferences is contradictory to their world view. Changing from that requires a ton of self reflection which I doubt most of them are willing to do.
Enlils-Reincarnation@reddit
Of course, The CIA agent posts a thread claiming that the Incel Archetype views therapy as bad, in order to attract trend-seekers who might then ironically engage with it.
We're living in 1984
Devitostitos@reddit
They don’t want help. They want to be handed what they want with little to no effort. Any decent therapist is most likely going to tell an incel to “focus on what they can’t control” or “work on self improvement/branching out”.
Platycryptus238@reddit
Why would a group that feels like it has been left out by society and the system accept help by either? Who‘da thunk it!?
Aside from the barriers 1&2 which are absolutly outlandish, barrier 3&4 are absolutly vaild. Just as medicine is biased in favour of men (i.e. the whole heart attack symtomatic example), psychology is biased in favour of women.
Mishi_Mujago@reddit
The key words you used there were “feels like”. You’ve hit the nail on the head, that’s the crux of the issue.
N9neFing3rs@reddit
How are they defining incense? What they just pulled guys from a Warhammer tournament at random?
Res_Novae17@reddit
All four of these are incontrovertibly true. Therapy will make you accept that you will never get laid. It will not help you get laid. You cannot be honest with therapists, ever, if you are having even the slightest "dark" thought. They will put a button under their desk and police will come and section you.
Therapy is utterly useless for a significant portion of the population.
captain_lampshade@reddit
“Therapy doesn’t work for people who have already convinced themselves that it won’t”
Yea right. Next you’ll be telling me the sky is blue
Enlils-Reincarnation@reddit
Another CIA- infiltrated thread framing "Therapy is bad" concept with the Incel archetype.
Fucking 1984 all over here yet no one bats an eye
miggleb@reddit
Therapy just boils down to a fancy "suck it up"
Darkling971@reddit
ITT: incels
OcelotSlight7892@reddit
Better company than Redditors tbh
SPZ_Ireland@reddit
Brother, if you're on this site, you're a redditor.
OcelotSlight7892@reddit
Sounds like something a redditor would say
drak0ni@reddit
If someone is still calling themself an incel, therapy probably didn’t work. Therefore, if you look for incels that have tried therapy, your results are going to be very skewed.
StobbstheTiger@reddit
Therapy isn't going to make the incels not 5'2". It's like expecting education to overcome racial differences in intelligence.
lifetimeoflaughter@reddit
A woman is the only thing that can save an incel but it’s a big ask for most of them
Homunkulus@reddit
It depends on the incel, I think the OGs were more accurate in their assessments of their place in the world, lots of the modern ones are awkward dudes who are just picking up prepackaged ideas as an excuse for their lack of success.
lifetimeoflaughter@reddit
Yeah that’s what’s so sad. They are only cooked really cooked if they become convinced it’s over and stop trying. And they pull others down with them and convince each other it’s over for them.
HerrVonMosh@reddit
If you're too stupid for therapy it won't work. It's not like a magic charm which will make you healthy or what evs
OnionTaster@reddit
Therapy ain't gonna get you pussy
Comfortable_Survey18@reddit
Where they get these results from lmao
JetLag413@reddit
So basically theyve already decided theres no way to make anything better and refuse to try, and this is womens fault somehow.
Yeah that tracks for incels
zzzfoifa@reddit
How a research conducted on 100 participants found .8% results?
Mouthfullofcrabss@reddit
You can therapy someone out of being mentally challenged.
T_Ijonen@reddit
Do you understand the difference between "can" and "can't", or do you need therapy?
Strong-Hovercraft702@reddit
I think therapy is designed to get humans back into line. It is also used for that purpose. Nobody might be doing it to subdue the populace, but that is a second order effect.
Therapy only became needed after people started working 9 to 5 without anything to show for it but debt and loneliness. The issue is not why therapy is not working.
Chairfighter@reddit
You have to want help and be willing to change for therapy to work. Otherwise you're just wasting your time.
TranSpyre@reddit
Therapy helps to find your issues and to try and come up with coping methods, but rarely actually solves your issues.
No amount of CBT can fix a chemical imbalance in the brain.
It comes to a point where you get severely diminishing returns, at which point you're just paying someone to listen to you vent.
Avarice241@reddit
Therapy only works on people with enough emotional intelligence that allows them to change. Hence the incel failure.
Vary-Vary@reddit
Therapy requires the will to do something. Inceldom requires the attitude that all is doomed.
Very much surprising, so wow that the population subset that believes everything is set in stone does not benefit from therapy
TheyCallMeCool1@reddit
A long time ago I was a conservative incel, was depressed, no self esteem, tried therapy to fix myself. It didnt work because I couldnt comprehend that all of that was bad. I surrounded myself with good and diverse people that are accepting of others and over time ive slowly become a good person. I've even got a date next week. Friends the best advice i can give you is to surround yourself with diverse friends and teach yourself that everybody really is the same. Regardless of race, gender, sexuality, or otherwise, everybody deserves to be treated fairly. Don't take the news at face value, do your own research into topics and stay far away from sources that are known to skew in one direction.
CaseClosedEmail@reddit
The link works, read more here:
https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/10503307.2025.2600546#d1e681
ErasmosNA@reddit
Therapy helps when the patient actually wants to change. The most important factor is whether the therapist believes that change can happen. I doubt any of those incels had the right mindset.
Icy_Cupcake_8076@reddit
Because therapy isn't meant to help. It's only meant to extract money.
Tortoise_Knight@reddit
Therapy is indeed biased towards women
He-She-We_Wumbo@reddit
Man, Black Ops II was great
ParsleyBagel@reddit
incels hate women. they're not gonna respond well to having that belief challenged.
CaterpillarLoud8071@reddit
Because the psychs couldn't understand the incels' problems or mindsets, probably. Same reason they couldn't help a racist.
Flimsy-Guarantee1497@reddit
idk plenty of normies are helped by it and most people are pretty racist it seems more like an issue with "incel" pre selecting for aspies and shit
Ocarina-0f-Thyme@reddit
I just never felt that therapy gave me any answers that were helpful to me personally, considering I've had therapists since early childhood i wasn't exactly surprised. Half the time they seem... idk, unprepared for my questions? Or maybe the questions don't really have solid answers. Idfk
PhantomCruze@reddit
You can't fix weaponised autism... You harness it
Don_Sebastian_I@reddit
Now incels will find themselves related to Tony Soprano
F1R3Starter83@reddit
They are helpless. Euthanasia would be the most humane thing to do