What are the most typical American and most favorite sandwich topping combinations in the USA?
Posted by mayermail1977@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 286 comments
Is Subway's toppings and offerings would be considered the most typical? Which one is your favorite and the most typical in your household and your friends and family's household?
SympleTin_Ox@reddit
Turkey, Roast Beef, Bacon is the holy trinity with Sharp Chedar. Mayo. Lettuce, tomato. cherry peppers Pretty much bootlegger club from Jimmy Johns. Jersey mikes has similar version.
Britt030@reddit
Peanut butter and jelly, grilled cheese, BLT, bologna sandwich, sloppy joes (I’ve never even tried this sandwich though), fried egg (the breakfast style type) and just interchangeable deli meat style sandwiches (ie. roast beef/ham/turkey/etc with a slice of any cheese and a condiment like mayonnaise/mustard/miracle whip/etc) are very popular.
I see a lot of Reuben, fried chicken, BBQ brisket, pulled pork, Italian and melt style sandwiches on menus here also and am personally a huge fan of a French dip but they seem to be less popular in restaurants here for some reason 👎🏻. Also a big fan of egg salad sandwiches but I’ve only ever really found them publicly sold while in Japan sadly. I’m sure they’re around, just not really popular in my state.
Growing up I ate a ton of grilled cheese and peanut butter and jelly sandwiches and I’d say that’s pretty common for a lot of kids. I don’t like bologna but I think a lot of kids grew up eating those also. These days I still eat grilled cheese sandwiches (but on sourdough bread and add guacamole now) and it MUST be eaten with red pepper tomato soup. Also still eat PB & J sandwiches occasionally when camping or going out into the mountains for any activity where a lunch needs to be packed where we’re not bringing a cooler.
At our home these days we most commonly make: grilled cheese with guacamole, reuben, egg salad, fried egg (breakfast), Italian, pulled pork and interchangeable deli meat sandwiches.
Great, now I want a sandwich
Collins4816@reddit
I’ve seen some really weird combos at Subway. I saw a guy get a meatball sub and put green bell peppers, extra pickles and mayo on it. I almost had to leave the store because I was about to puke.
Zealousideal_Crow737@reddit
A childhood staple in New England was fluffernutters - peanutbutter and fluff (marshmallow spread).
Budsygus@reddit
I'd never had one before I read a book series where they were the protagonist's favorite thing ever. I tried one and honestly I get the hype. They're pretty dang good. Not gonna replace my PB and Apricot jam anytime soon, but I definitely indulge from time to time.
makestuff24-7@reddit
Apricot is the best j for pb&j, very underrated.
Budsygus@reddit
Spread the word. People need to know.
Numerous-Surprise875@reddit
Trust the awesomeness.
Budsygus@reddit
Might have to plow through those books again. Filthy monkeys!
lowtdi850@reddit
I’m in Florida and have ate them my whole life
Zealousideal_Crow737@reddit
It's more common in New England since fluff is MA based
aintjoan@reddit
I gotta say, as someone who grew up not in Massachusetts and then lived in Massachusetts for a while, this was one of the weirdest fucking things I ever saw. I can't believe this was served in schools. I was even there during the fluffernutter festival one year and could not believe it with my own eyes. Lol
ljculver64@reddit
I haven't had one of those since I was a kid. Probably one of the best sandwiches I ever had
Zealousideal_Crow737@reddit
It's fucking awesome! I'm a 31F and I'm thinking of making one for myself tonight lol
aintjoan@reddit
The beauty of the USA - such a wild variety of experiences and opinions that much of the rest of us are confused and/or horrified by but at the same time I love and appreciate the fact that this is something delicious to you. Haha
TheSaltyDog73@reddit
Think about it: the vast majority (definitely not all) of Americans are immigrants! Many bring their favorite foods!!!
aintjoan@reddit
Yes. Though I'm pretty sure fluffernutter is one thing that literally nobody else in the world would try to lay claim to, lol
Mindless_Rush5002@reddit
I've never liked marshmallows, but for some reason I love fluffernutters.
Pard22@reddit
Scrolled down for this. The almighty Fluffernutter!
jade420420@reddit
i swear those fluff containers would fly away they felt so light
OhThrowed@reddit
Ain't nothin more American than peanut butter and jelly.
FoolhardyBastard@reddit
100%. If you grill the PB and J as you would a grilled cheese, it’s next fucking level
Slight_Manufacturer6@reddit
🤯
wolfmann99@reddit
I prefer the Duane Purvis https://indyburgerguy.wordpress.com/2018/10/08/duane-purvis-triple-xxx/
Cerulean_IsFancyBlue@reddit
I know people love it, but I just prefer my peanut butter and jelly to be cold.
Ideally, the strawberry jam is straight out of the refrigerator, and the peanut butter is room temperature, spread onto freshly toasted bread.
keener_lightnings@reddit
I once had my freshman comp class write short essays where they explained how to do something, and when one said he was going to write about how to make a peanut butter and banana sandwich, I wondered if he'd be able to get enough material out of that. Then I sit down to read his very thorough, well-written essay on how to make a grilled PB & banana with brown sugar sprinkled inside and I was like "...oh damn, that sounds amazing"
Standard_Mongoose_35@reddit
I’ve been making this combo for YEARS. PB on both sides of the bread, even layer of brown sugar, sliced bananas corner to corner, griddled as with a grilled cheese.
Soooo good.
Patient_Parsley7760@reddit
Oh. My. Gawd. Please stop. I just got back from dinner. You're making me NEED to go to the kitchen to make more food now! I seem to remember my mom doing fried bananas in a pan with butter and brown sugar, and serving it over vanilla ice cream. The second you mentioned brown sugar and bananas, I started drooling.
Patient_Parsley7760@reddit
Ok, I need to try this now.
USNCCitizen@reddit
I’ve cooked peanut butter and jelly French toast for myself many a times. Delicious imo.
ju5tjame5@reddit
Oof. You really had to say this on Good Friday when I'm fasting.
sjedinjenoStanje@reddit
Except the PB liquefies and drips out 😠
Madreese@reddit
I just toast the bread first, then make the sandwich. It's good. The PB gets a little melty on the hot toast, but the jelly cools it off. It's not so drippy.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
My favorite sandwich with a slice of American cheese added
Madreese@reddit
I sort of like adding BBQ potato chips on it. But then I have to skip the chocolate milk because eww.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
My wife puts potato chips in her sandwiches sometimes and I guess its a British thing to do.
sjedinjenoStanje@reddit
I wasn't aware it was British tradition. I've loved putting in chips (potato, tortilla or corn) in my sandwiches since I was a kid too.
Madreese@reddit
I've read that, but I'm from the USA.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
I am too
sjedinjenoStanje@reddit
Good advice - my kid loves PB&J and she prefers the bread toasted, so I'll try that.
Madreese@reddit
So good!
TheMrsH1124@reddit
Mmmm I need this now with a glass of cold milk
Lovemybee@reddit
I like to pour the glass of milk and put it in the freezer while making the sandwich. It gets a crust of frozen milk around the edge and across the top... mmmmmm! 🥛🤤😋
SgtDoakesSurprise@reddit
Ice cold baby!
Sallyfifth@reddit
I occasionally give a pb&j the french-toast treatment. It's good.
ljculver64@reddit
I ran out of syrup once and used jam.Peanut butter naturally followed. Big fan.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
I've done that
Midmodstar@reddit
Grilled Nutella sandwich. Perfection.
lyricoloratura@reddit
Add a schmear of cream cheese to that Nutella sandwich before you grill it. You’ll thank me later.
PraetorianHawke@reddit
Making me hungry...dammit haha
likemy10thaccount@reddit
The great debate: grape or strawberry? I'm going strawberry 🍓
7empestSpiralout@reddit
Always grape.
Madreese@reddit
Grape. And jelly not jam. LOL
TheSaltyDog73@reddit
⬆️This is the answer. Strawberry is a remote second acceptable addition. Apple is awful for some reason.
No-Switch-851@reddit
Im a peach guy myself
Amarastargazer@reddit
Peach and blackberry are tied at first for me.
CatPurrsonNo1@reddit
You had me until “Apple is awful”! Apple jelly practically ties with grape for me!
7empestSpiralout@reddit
Yeah idk about Apple jelly. Not sure I’ve tried it
TheFlyingSaucers2@reddit
Jam is glorious brother
bouquetofashes@reddit
Personally I prefer preserves. Usually make em myself. An older lady I worked with said they were just like her grandmother used to make and that'll always make me inordinately happy to remember.
Honestly some pear, apple, fig, onion and/or bacon jam, or preserves goes real nice on a grilled cheese, too.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
Nope, jam
Stop_Already@reddit
I call the chunks in strawberry jam blood clots and I just…can’t.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
My mom made grape jelly from grapes from my grandma's vines. After that I can't eat store bought grape. I like strawberry preserves.
honorthecrones@reddit
You can make your own grape jelly from grape juice. Get good grape juice and it will taste as good as you remember
ProveISaidIt@reddit
Good idea. Thanks.
bouquetofashes@reddit
I've never made jelly because I prefer preserves but preserves are very easy to make yourself and they are imo preferable to any of the store bought. Pretty sure you just strain em to get jelly.
I like homemade nut butters, too. I'm not crazy about peanut butter so I do walnut, white chocolate macadamia, and pecan spiced and sweetened to be a lil like pecan pie. Hell of a lot cheaper than store bought specialty nut butters, too.
ProveISaidIt@reddit
I misspoke. It would have been grape jam that my mom made. I have made strawberry preserves and am planning on doing so again shortly.
bouquetofashes@reddit
Not a problem, I think jam is probably easier. I've honestly never made my own grape anything because I don't prefer it but I bet you could get the grape jam recipe passed down easily. What kind of grapes does she grow/use?
ProveISaidIt@reddit
Concord
7empestSpiralout@reddit
I bet that was amazing
ProveISaidIt@reddit
Itv was so good. It ruined me.
kms582@reddit
Red plum was always a family favorite
bouquetofashes@reddit
Damson plum preserves are real nice, too.
dontforgettowriteme@reddit
Blackberry!
relikter@reddit
I once accidentally bought blackberry instead of grape and never looked back. And yes to jam > jelly.
dontforgettowriteme@reddit
Blackberry jam is the superior experience and I'm so glad you had that revelation!
I didn't realize that people even ate grape jelly with their PB&Js until much, much later in my childhood, I was so used to blackberry lol
theRealHobbes2@reddit
Strawberry. And jam not jelly.
renegrape@reddit
Raspberry. And preserves, not jam.
ljculver64@reddit
Jam....always
Standard_Mongoose_35@reddit
Yes! Jam actually is spreadable. Jelly just gets chased around, and I end up cutting and mashing it just to cover the slice of bread.
SherLovesCats@reddit
Nope. BlackBerry jelly is the best.
calimiss@reddit
Black raspberry or raspberry or boysenberry. With bbq potatoe chips on the side.
Stop_Already@reddit
Kirkland organic strawberry jam.
I’m a grape jelly convert.
NeverEnoughGalbi@reddit
Strawberry jam
SgtDoakesSurprise@reddit
I say strawberry jam or preserves.
A surprisingly good one is blueberry 🫐
ProveISaidIt@reddit
Strawberry preserves
OfflineGameEnjoyer@reddit
I’d go with this or ham and cheese, hot or cold.
Rare_Independent_814@reddit
I never realized this was an American thing til we had au pairs from other countries. At first they were like, you feed your kids what? Then it became their new fav thing.
corvidae_666@reddit
that is the sandwich, not the toppings.
Mr_Kittlesworth@reddit
I don’t know how I’d test this, but I’d be pretty damn confident this is the single most common sandwich made
Wink527@reddit
Peanut Butter, Butter, and Jelly on toast (chef's kiss).
MarqiMichelle@reddit
Just had one
rottenindenmark37@reddit
Counterpoint: fried bologna
Slight_Manufacturer6@reddit
Roast Beef
Maybeitsmeraving@reddit
Lettuce, tomatoes, pickles, mayo and yellow mustard are probably the "across all types" most common sandwich toppings. But there are a lot of regional american sandwiches that include various other ingredients. America has a pretty strong sandwich culture, from the cheesesteak to the po' boy, the hoagie to the reuben, that each have their distinct toppings and frequent variations.
Odd-Tell-5702@reddit
I feel like BLTs are pretty popular.
Genius-Imbecile@reddit
My favorite. My cardiologist on the other hand says I shouldn't enjoy them. Some people just have to be negative.
Patient_Parsley7760@reddit
Turkey bacon. I get that a lot of people don't like it, but I enjoy it because it holds up in a sandwich. It doesn't crumble and fall out of the sandwich if you look at it wrong. I also learned to like it when my family lived in a country where we couldn't get pork.
kat_storm13@reddit
When I was a vegetarian ages ago I made Bacon bits, lettuce & tomato sandwiches. The turkey bacon probably would have been kinder to the roof of my mouth, but I only needed a sprinkle of bacon bits to be a decent (painful) sandwich. Turkey bacon didn't fit in my budget
Fit_Bath2219@reddit
Isn’t that not vegetarian
makestuff24-7@reddit
Bacon Bits are made of TVP. https://www.mccormick.com/products/mccormick-r-imitation-bacon-bits-4-4-oz?view=sl-DC677ED4
kat_storm13@reddit
Oops for some reason I conflated turkey bacon with vegetarian bacon. I haven't tried either of those that I've liked, but whatever bottle of imitation bacon topping I had in the 90s tasted close enough to the real thing for sandwiches
TenMoon@reddit
Have fun storming the castle!
MasonStonewall@reddit
What's wrong with turkey bacon 🥓
ThumbsUp2323@reddit
Negative for coronary artery disease 11
Stop_Already@reddit
If you live near a Trader Joe’s, go buy their green dragon hot sauce. Put it on your BLT. Mix with the mayo, if that’s your thing.
It’s fantastic.
itds@reddit
Sriracha mayo on BLTs are the way to go.
wmposl70@reddit
I prefer MLTs.
spookybatshoes@reddit
Mutton?
wmposl70@reddit
Yes. It's from the princess Bride movie.
Somhairle77@reddit
Have you ever had a Vimes BLT? The kind Lady Sybil doesn't think are good for him?
wantonseedstitch@reddit
Pratchett FTW! Personally, I think in the summer when the tomatoes are ripe from the garden, such a thing is a travesty. Also, I want mayo on my BLT, not brown sauce.
Somhairle77@reddit
Tomatoes are one of my strongest food aversions because someone did a slipshod job wiring up my brain. My mom has always worked really hard on our garden to keep seven kids fed and always made me eat them.
wantonseedstitch@reddit
It took me until I was in my 20s to start liking raw tomatoes. Even now in my 40s, I am very picky about them.
HotCommission7325@reddit
Peanut butter and jelly, to my surprise, seems to be a primarily American thing.
TheSaltyDog73@reddit
Really? To be sure, PB in all other countries I’ve visited (75+) that sell peanut butter, it never tastes the same or as good (to me, an American), as the American version.
We take American peanut butter, “Tony Chachere’s Cajun Seasoning”, and seasoned peanuts to our friends in Germany 🇩🇪 and 🇦🇹 as hostess gifts.
kaki024@reddit
Apparently we’re the only ones who use roasted and salted peanuts to make peanut butter. No wonder ours is so much better.
doctorsnarly@reddit
Well, and the horrifying amounts of sugar, because that's what Americans are expecting.
I had a friend who was moving back home to Brazil, and she had packed a massive suitcase full of nothing but iPhones and Peanut butter.
iPhones are way cheaper here, and our peanut butter "is like candy" according to her.
holymacaroley@reddit
I lived in the UK late 90s- early 2000s and peanut butter there at the time was not good. When I'd go home to visit every so often, I brought back peanut butter, ziploc bags (don't know if they have those there yet in 2026), grits (I'm from the South), hot sauce, and I'm not sure what else.
Icy_Air7727@reddit
My personal fav is rotisserie chicken and provolone cheese, toasted, with lettuce tomato red onion and pickle, topped with garlic aioli and salt and pepper. Delicioso
Swimming-Book-1296@reddit
PB&J, Ham and Cheese, Burger patty and cheese, fried chicken breast (boneless skinless), and pickles,
mostlygray@reddit
I like to make Rueben sandwiches. I do roast beef with sauerkraut, provolone, and thousand island dressing. On quality rye bread. I bake the sandwiches between 2 sheet pans with a weight on top. It works nicely.
My wife's family makes regular cold cut sandwiches with tomatoes, onions, your choice of cheese and Dorothy Lynch dressing. Dorothy Lynch is important to people from Nebraska.
At a restaurant, when in doubt, it's Roast Beef Aus Jus for me. Get it with prime rib if they offer it.
nippleflick1@reddit
On most of my sandwiches, I have at least one of these. Mayo or mustard, lettuce, tomato, onions, dill pickles.
BlowFish-w-o-Hootie@reddit
Nothing is typical. That’s why we have a variety of choices on menus.
Other than that, Ham and cheese with tomato, lettuce, mayo and mustard.
jcoigny@reddit
Whatever meat, all the veg and extra jalapeno peppers
doonerthesooner@reddit
Philly cheesesteak is probably the most American sandwich.
Stupidlysudden@reddit
And 99% of the country doesn't know how to make one.
doonerthesooner@reddit
Agreed, the best cheesesteaks come from places you can get fresh jalapeños
Stupidlysudden@reddit
Weak rage bait haha. The crunchy green bell peppers being mandatory in cheesesteaks is still something that irks me to no end. Same with stupid fucking cheese like swiss.
doonerthesooner@reddit
If not Swiss what you even use?
Blew my mind when I found out that in Philly it’s common to use cheese whiz
Stupidlysudden@reddit
People outside of the Philly area always think cheese whiz is the shit in the can. It comes in a jar! Think of it more like velvetta cheese rather than the shit that the one kid in the goofy movie kept eating. Also, deli american is NOT a kraft fucking single.
Also, whiz is one of three acceptable cheese families, deli american, provolone, or whiz. Whiz is just super fake super bad for you, but good as fuck. The original is provolone. Cooper sharp is gaining a lot of popularity but it is just another version of deli american.
If you put fucking swiss or some shit on your cheesesteak that's a violation.
Boba_Fett_is_Senpai@reddit
I worked at a mom & pop cheesesteak place down here and they made a point to not include the 'Philly' but experts from NJ usually had good things to say. The roll is more important than the cheese imo
Stupidlysudden@reddit
The roll is typically the most important because the other items do not change. Rib eye for the meat, white/yellow onions, and the three acceptable cheeses. The only real agency is the bread. You could argue how fine you chop the meat is also some agency I guess.
Real hoagie shops or cheesesteak spots use fresh bread made locally or in house and if they run out of bread the day is done. And Amoroso is NOT the best bread in Philly, it is just the ubiquitous decent fresh bread in the area.
Responsible_Side8131@reddit
Meat (usually Turkey or ham) plus cheese, lettuce, tomato and Mayo is probably the most standard deli sandwich ever.
JulesInIllinois@reddit
We have many types of sandwiches. The toppings depend on the sandwich type.
I don't eat at Subway. But, for a sub sandwich, most shops put shredded lettuce, tomato, onion, cheese and mayonaise.
TipsyBaker_@reddit
I've never had someone turn down a grilled cheese. Especially if I add a fried egg.
One of my favorite though is honey ham, grilled onion, arugala, Swiss cheese, and stone ground mustard, on a pretzel bun.
Nobody leaves hungry or unhappy in my house
vabeachkevin@reddit
Lettuce, tomato, mayo, paired with some kind of meat
Dank-Retard@reddit
A Philly Cheesesteak is incredibly popular throughout the US. If you live in the should you’ll be very familiar with Publix’s chicken tender subs.
If we’re talking about sandwiches in general, then a grilled cheese is definitely the quintessentially American sandwich.
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
Incredibly terrible in most of the country.
Meowmeowmeow31@reddit
I am not opposed to green bell peppers on a cheesesteak, but I am so confused about why they’re standard on cheesesteaks outside of the Philly metro area.
snailballoon@reddit
Wow, you're right, they are SO ubiquitous that this is the first time I'm hearing they aren't supposed to be there?? I thought that was part of the definition lol
Meowmeowmeow31@reddit
People are downvoting me for telling the truth! It’s not a thing here where they were invented!
Dank-Retard@reddit
Can't argue with that lol.
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
I have heard that some locals have moved down to Florida though and make some legit stuff so you might be in luck.
MastiffOnyx@reddit
Midwest: Pork fritter sandwiches. Some so big it looks like it's on a cheeze-it sized bun.
Princess_Parabellum@reddit
Publix chicken tender subs are one of the few things I miss about my time in south Florida!
TheMrsH1124@reddit
Ah, but you have burgers with green chile!!!!! The burgers at El Parasol in Los Alamos are what I miss!!!!
angrypuggle@reddit
Muffaletta!
mayermail1977@reddit (OP)
What is that?
angrypuggle@reddit
https://www.seriouseats.com/classic-new-orleans-muffuletta-recipe
wieldymouse@reddit
I would say typical for a sandwich shop. I don't usually put all that stuff on sandwiches at home. The only toppings at home are usually cheese and condiments (mayo, mustard, pesto, or some combination of them).
MsPooka@reddit
For specifically a subway sandwich? I'd say typical toppings would be lettuce, tomato, onion, with either mayo or oil and vinegar depending on the type of sandwich. Beyond that it's more personal.
DogsBikesAndMovies@reddit
Onions, tomatoes, green peppers and jalepenos.
Ok_Orchid1004@reddit
I think subway is garbage.
state_issued_femboy@reddit
Bacon, like everyone loves bacon here
LetterheadClassic306@reddit
subway is fine but not really what most people make at home. the classic american sandwich is turkey with american cheese lettuce tomato and mayo on white bread. for a heartier option people do roast beef with horseradish sauce and provolone. peanut butter and grape jelly is huge for kids and adults too honestly. subway's offerings are broader than what most pantries have. we keep it simpler at home.
sfdsquid@reddit
I haven't gone to a Subway in like a decade and even back then I didn't want to.
There are about 340 million people in the US. I have no idea what the most favorite sandwich is.
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
I last went about 15 years ago and it was awful. NJ and PA and filled with local sandwich shops and chains though, not even counting Wawa.
corvidae_666@reddit
NJ and PA are smack dab in the middle of the deli belt. We have great options.
subway is not one of those.
shelwood46@reddit
I am also in Eastern PA (and currently NJ), I think I have been to Subway twice in my entire life, because I was on a road trip. It was...not good.
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
And it's not like there still aren't a ton of them around here. Like who is going there? I have 10 local places just within like 2-3 miles I can get a hoagie, plus 2 additional Wawas.
Patient_Parsley7760@reddit
In my household the favorites are, in no particular order
PB&J
Grilled cheese (In the UK they'd call it a cheese toastie) Or grilled cheese with ham.
Sliced ham, turkey, or chicken with lettuce, tomato, and a little bit of mayonnaise on the bread.
Sliced ham or turkey and thick sliced cheddar or Swiss cheese. Nothing else, except possibly a little bit of stone ground mustard on the bread.
I like to make egg salad, tuna salad, or chicken salad, but I'm the only one in my household who eats those so I make them in small amounts. I love putting sliced cucumber on my tuna salad sandwiches and will sometimes add diced apples to my chicken salad sandwich filling.
We will also make sloppy joes or picadillo sandwiches on pita bread for dinner some nights, or homemade burgers on kaiser rolls.
Middle-Wealth-6755@reddit
Peanut butter and jelly. Grape jelly, JIF cream peanut butter.
Kitchen_Coast2802@reddit
-pbj -blt -fluffernutter -peanut butter and banana -club sandwich -grilled cheese & tomato soup -chicken Caesar wrap -some sort of turkey southwest situation -ham & cheese -Reuben
You wouldn’t see these peanut butter ones on a menu (maybe a kids menu) at most delis, but people will sure make them at home!
Fit-Rip-4550@reddit
Whatever people want.
ju5tjame5@reddit
I would say all of the most common sandwich toppings are in Subway's lineup, but not every sandwich topping in Subway's lineup is a common sandwich topping.
Connect_Bee5338@reddit
I like prosciutto with fresh mozzerella. Toppings like tomato, onion, spinach, basil are good.
Also balsamic vingearette is a good splash of flavor.
jennyx20@reddit
Philly Cheesesteak Deli Sub - salami, ham, pepperoni, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, red onions, Italian dressing, mayo,
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
What about that is supposed to be a cheesesteak?
jennyx20@reddit
Two different things
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
It sounded like 1 sandwich lol
jennyx20@reddit
I forget that they don’t do the return button 🤣
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
Add a couple spaces after each line.
Libertyprime8397@reddit
Obviously it’s peanut butter and tuna fish.
ohmygotchi@reddit
Ketchup and mustard.
trynworkharder@reddit
Bacon egg and cheese might actually be the answer, since there is a lot less competition for breakfast sandwiches than rest-of-day sandwiches
Only_Presentation758@reddit
Peanut butter & jelly, thin sliced ham (or turkey) & cheese, grilled cheese (made in a pan), bacon/lettuce/tomato, & canned tuna mixed with mayo are the sandwiches I grew up with at home and very common for most American kids & teens
tcspears@reddit
Food is very regional in the US - it will depend on the state's culture and traditions, which European country owned the state, and also the various bands of immigration since.
I don't think there are any more Subways by me, but we have a ton of Italian sandwich shops within walking distance of my house, we call them grinders or subs (other parts of the country call them different things), and they generally come with some veggies, oil, vinegar, et cetera.
If you were to go to Chicago, New Orleans, NYC, LA, and others you'll see very different types of sandwiches, and different toppings.
Friendly_Side3258@reddit
White bread with ham or turkey, cheddar cheese, mayo, mustard, and potato chips! I call it the poolside sandwich cause we always had the same type of sandwich during summer days by the pool growing up😂 can use any chip! I like hot Cheetos or Doritos
MadHats3@reddit
Lately I've been going for corned beef with sauteed onions and horseradish mayo. An Italian or American combo would be pretty standard orders around the country. Chicken cutlet with swiss, bacon and mayo pretty classic too. Anyone that has a chicken cutlet sub would likely have buffalo chicken as well since all you need is buffalo sauce and blue cheese or ranch dressing.
craftyrunner@reddit
We don’t eat at subway (Togo’s bread is so much better imo). We also love independent sandeuch shops. Among my friends and family the favorites are:
Turkey and avocado
Italian combo
Meatball
Chicken salad
Turkey and cheese
I also have a tendency to order any sort of house special, I love trying new things. Of course sometimes this means something that’s oddly bad but edible.
Avbitten@reddit
the most "american" sandwhich is a pb and j.
shelwood46@reddit
I live in the Northeast so I have no idea what Subway offers for toppings. If I don't go to a local place, I hit Wawa or Primo. How I top it depends on the filling, but personally I like raw tomatoes and any version of onions (Wawa has raw, crispy or caramelized, I will also take grilled). I don't like condiments, and mostly not cheese though I do like provolone for cheesesteaks.
SPCsooprlolz@reddit
PBJ or a grilled cheese, probably
Extension_Abroad6713@reddit
Sandwiches from Subway or other chains are not the same kind of sandwiches we make at home usually. At home it’s usually sliced deli meat, cheese, mayo, and mustard
Living-Night4476@reddit
If asking my husband his favorite is salami pepperoni and ham with American cheese on white bread with mayo and pepper. Never the butt ends though, heaven forbid. If asking me I switch around. There is raspberry preserves with provolone cheese, roast beef with caramelized onions and garlic aioli, blt with basil pepper and salt added, grilled cheese of any cheese variety (seriously I like even cream cheese to Limburger cheese), peanut butter and apple butter, Nutella and orange marmalade, and don’t forget egg salad or tuna salad or chicken salad with some romaine and tomato.
But seriously isn’t a cheeseburger just a hot sandwich? I think that is overall the most popular sandwich in USA 🇺🇸
Awdayshus@reddit
Lately, I've been making a quick sandwich spread by mushing up a tin of fish with a few dollops of Miracle Whip. Today I did this with tuna, so most people would call it tuna salad. A few days ago, I used herring. You could call that herring salad, but mostly people use tuna or salmon for this.
I have no idea how typical this is.
Ok-Growth4613@reddit
Fried bologna is as American as it gets.
MangoSalsa89@reddit
Processed meats and cheese are pretty much offered at any place that sells sandwiches.
PM_Me_UrRightNipple@reddit
Italian Hoagie
Meat:Genoa salami, capicola, ham
Cheese:Provolone
oil and vinegar on the roll
Toppings: lettuce, tomato, onion, salt, pepper, oregano - a lot of people also add pickles, hot, and sweet peppers as well.
Jhooper20@reddit
Although they do have the more common sandwich meats and toppings, they don't have all of them. Probably won't see pastrami, corned beef, or egg salad unless its actually a special they're doing.
Also, on the topic of Subway, here's a video that digs into the downward spiral they went into both in quality and legally (got sued and sued a lot, one occasion being over people actually getting hepatitis)
oneshadeoff@reddit
A double bacon cheeseburger with grilled cheeses for buns
wantonseedstitch@reddit
Very typical:
Peanut butter and jelly (grape is probably most common, followed by strawberry)
Ham (usually a lightly smoked and brined city ham, rather than a dry-cured one) and cheese (American cheese, a processed "cheese food" often sold in individually wrapped slices but also available sliced from a brick at the deli)
Tuna salad--tuna mayo to the Brits and others
Chicken salad--basically cooked chicken cut and mashed up with mayo
Other lunch meats are also common, with roast beef, turkey breast, salami, and bologna probably being the most universally available.
Other cheeses you might often see are Swiss (Emmentaler), provolone (usually a mild one, not too aged), and cheddar (ditto mild)
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
Toppings on like a cold sub/hoagie? The standard is something like this. Lettuce, tomato, onion. Possibly pickles or pickled/sweet/hot peppers. Mayo and/or mustard.
My favorite hot sandwiches would probably be cheesesteak, reuben, and cuban.
But there's hundreds of cold and hot sandwiches/subs/hoagies/clubs/paninis.
sundial11sxm@reddit
Look up Jersey Mike's instead.
professorfunkenpunk@reddit
Subway sandwiches aren’t very good but their toppings are the kind of thing that would be typical for American subs and just sandwiches in general.
DruncleMuncle@reddit
Subway is trash, I wouldn't use them as any sort of standard.
I would say lettuce and tomato at minimum, then condiments.
GreenBeanTM@reddit
I really wanna try subway outside of NE cause in my experience here it’s always just a good sandwich
TooManyDraculas@reddit
Having had Subway in NE, no it isn't.
ninjette847@reddit
It's extremely hit or miss because it's franchised, not a chain. Where I live the bad ones are really bad and the good ones are fine.
GreenBeanTM@reddit
That makes a lot of sense
Chimpbot@reddit
Yeah, I can't say I've ever really had a bad sandwich from a Subway. There are certainly better options out there, but it's not something that I'd call "trash".
TooManyDraculas@reddit
They are however an ersatz version of an actual sandwich shop.
They don't have anything you wouldn't find anywhere else. So the answer to OP's question on whether their topping selection is standard is "yes".
They really just do some of the shittiest versions of stock hoagies.
PinkRoseCarousel@reddit
Subway is trash in quality and taste, but I would say their general offerings are pretty typical of American sandwiches. A variety of deli meats, cheese, lettuce, tomato.
Appropriate-Food1757@reddit
Agree, not the best quality but the standard fare is representative of the basics.
yourgrandmasgrandma@reddit
Subway is trash, but the specific toppings they offer absolutely are the most standard American sandwich toppings. There are definitely regional favorites, like pickled cherry peppers are big where I live, but the subway offerings are the most typical of the US as a whole.
CreepinJesusMalone@reddit
I think they were just saying are the toppings and meats available at Subway the standard.
Which, yes lol. Subway may use shitty ingredients and taste bland, but LTO, pickles, bread, cheese, and the meats to choose from are standard at pretty much every sandwich restaurant. The baseline condiments of mayo and a selection of mustard and dressings are also standard.
Tasty-Possibility627@reddit
Subway’s range of options are the typical American deli sandwich types. At home though, more Americans use square-shaped sliced bread to construct their sandwiches.
There are many beloved regional sandwich types, but with the exception of PB&J, Subway pretty much covers it.
Defiant_Network7916@reddit
My favorite was always pastrami or mortadella.
TexasGiantTen05@reddit
I guess you could say that. However, most of the “sub” bread we get would be at the bakery of a grocery store or local & would spoil fast. Square sandwich bread is a household staple. Ham, American cheese, sliced turkey are staple.
johannaishere@reddit
I love a good roast beef with horseradish sauce and cheddar and lettuce on good crusty bread.
min6char@reddit
Subway is relatively typical, but also, I don't know what Subway offers in your country, maybe they've tuned things towards local tastes there. But if you go to an independent sandwich shop in the US, that's pretty much the selection of breads meats cheeses and vegetables that will be available -- they'll just be better at the indie place because Subway makes a lot of quality compromises to distribute so widely and you don't need to make those compromises if you just have the one store and you just need to contract with one local bakery etc.
lanikuikawa@reddit
PB&J, grilled cheese, and BLT
Somhairle77@reddit
In Butte, MT, Pork Chop sandwiches are the local favorite. I haven't looked into the sandwich's history, specifically, but Butte is the most Irish city in America because Marcus Daly encouraged his countrymen who needed better incomes than they could make at home to come work in his mines.
Reasonable_Wasabi124@reddit
Tuna melt
Silkies4life@reddit
Do you mean topping as in what we would add on to a turkey and ham? Or the type of sandwich itself?
TheSaltyDog73@reddit
The question is really about TOPPINGS, not the sandwiches. I think three of the most common would be ketchup, mustard, and mayonnaise.
Saltpork545@reddit
Hi, food nerd here. Honestly sandwiches are too broad of a category for any one store to really have them all.
What Subway mostly sells are what we call cold cut or deli meat sandwiches. Think sliced deli meats, sometimes cheese, some veggies, on horizontally cut bread. That's most of it.
There's several national/large chains that do this as well. Jersey Mikes and Jimmy Johns are just a couple.
Now as for the bigger sandwich conversation, there's burgers, which are their own subset of sandwiches, and stuff that doesn't always neatly fit into definitions. The patty melt, for example, existed before the burger bun did by a couple of decades. So it is a proto-burger that's served on sliced bread.
There's also hot sandwiches, which are sandwiches served with cooked components that are typically made at the time of ordering. Philly cheesesteak, club sandwich, chopped cheese, and so on.
Then there's loose meat sandwiches like the sloppy joe and Maid rite.
This still is lacking as I've not discussed open faced sandwiches, American sandwich staples like PB&J, Mayo mixture sandwiches like egg or tuna salad, and the weirder, often forgotten sandwiches that aren't made anymore.
On that note, one of the coolest channels to show just how insanely huge this topic is would be Sandwiches of History.
https://www.youtube.com/@SandwichesofHistory
There are thousands of sandwiches. Thousands.
If I'm getting a cold cut sandwich I tend to like roast beef with horseradish and cheddar and topped with onions, pickles and tomatoes.
like_shae_buttah@reddit
I love me a vegan BLT
shammy_dammy@reddit
My favorite? Roast beef and swiss cheese
Appropriate-Food1757@reddit
Yeah Subway is pretty standard for what’s typical.
Budsygus@reddit
I grew up growing tomatoes in our back yard. I've never liked tomatoes all that much, but in the summer time there's nothing better than toast, mayo, tomatoes, and salt/pepper. Tastes SO GOOD even though I'm otherwise not a fan of tomatoes.
My wife had never had them before we got married. She's now in love with them just as much as I am.
Madreese@reddit
I grew up with tomato sandwiches. Especially if you can find giant beefsteak tomatoes. Yum!
yellowrose04@reddit
I usually get the club, the one with bacon. Sometimes just turkey or just pepperoni. Like lettuce, tomato, green peppers, pickles, onions and mayo.
momof4beasts@reddit
In the NY/NJ area I'm from, we like Bacon,egg and cheese with salt/pepper/ketchup for breakfast and a cold cut hero or Italian hero with lettuce / tomato/ mayo/ oil&vinegar. We also love breaded fried chicken cutlet with lettuce and mayo.
Icy-Mammoth3821@reddit
Mayonnaise and regular yellow mustard.
HorrorAlarming1163@reddit
This isn’t a normal one in all of America but I love a pimento cheese sandwich
RoundandRoundon99@reddit
PB&J. BLTs. Grilled Cheese.
smokervoice@reddit
Turkey and swiss cheese.
baalroo@reddit
The club, the BLT, the "Italian," and the reuben are all on basically every sandwich shop menu around here.
Ham, turkey, chicken, bologna, roast beef, salami, pepperoni, and bacon are all staples and can be had in basically any combination and seen as entirely standard/normal.
Dai-The-Flu-@reddit
Fast food breakfast sandwich, extra points if the bread is something like French toast or waffles or something similar to the McGriddle.
moonmoonboog@reddit
I’m a sucker for a BLT. Mostly normal. Bacon, lettuce, tomato, mayo with banana peppers.
moonmoonboog@reddit
Crispy bacon is a must for me. I hate a weird chewy bite.
Tchemgrrl@reddit
Subway is fairly representative. Things that subway doesn’t have that I think are pretty common at other sandwich places are egg salad and hummus. (I’m vegetarian so those are my personal go-to.) Some places have different veggie toppings, including things like grated carrot or roasted veggies. But lettuce, tomato, onion, pickled cucumber, and mayo and mustard are pretty universal, along with the sliced cheeses and meats.
superkt3@reddit
If forced to order at subway, (the only way I'd eat it) I'd probably get turkey American cheese and pickles, because their ingredients are so low quality. At a good sub shop, Italian subs with hots, steak and cheese, and steak tip subs are very popular in my part of MA.
A top tier sandwich for me is fresh fried chicken cutlet, fresh mozzarella tomato and basil with a little oil and balsamic drizzle. Hard to beat when done well.
Inside-Run785@reddit
PB&J or possibly a Dagwood.
tetrasodium@reddit
Pb&j is pretty common. I prefer strawberry jam grape jelly is for kids. I prefer to toast the bread
Peanut butter and marshmallow fluff might be even more American but probably less common. There are two major brands fluff and jet puff, afaik they are identical but pretty sure they hail from different regions. I haven't made this in years but prefer to toast the bread
Ham and cheese to roast beef and cheese turkey and cheese or tunafish are also super common but might not be specifically American. Mayo mustard tomato pickles let and or onion are common additions those.
If you are talking about a sub sandwich Italian Cuban and tuna salad are probably among the most common but meatball sub is common too. Cuban is kind of a sweeter modified Italian with banana-peppers and pickles
geekycurvyanddorky@reddit
This is going to be a very regional thing… overall I think peanut butter and jam or jelly, or grilled cheese are the most popular sammiches. But ham, cheese, lettuce, and mayonnaise sammiches are very popular too, and would be at subway and other delis nationwide (unlike pb&j or grilled cheese). Lobster rolls, Philly cheese steak, hamburgers, and chicken sammiches are all extremely popular as well and won’t be at most delis. Wraps and burritos and tacos are extremely popular as well, and again, aren’t in most delis. A less popular sammich that I personally really enjoy is a peanut butter and Nutella sammich, with banana between the spreads (especially when it’s lightly pan fried). It’s a very rare, once a year kind of treat because it’s not very heathy. Just yummy and fun.
The variety of traditional and fusion foods enjoyed here is one of my favorite things about America.
DickLips5000@reddit
The most common toppings you will see is lettuce, tomato and onion.
Mayonnaise and Mustard are common condiments.
Some other toppings are pickles, avocado, sprouts etc.
Subway is not a great representation of American sandwiches.
forgotwhatisaid2you@reddit
Subway is pretty representative of toppings Americans put on sandwiches which is what the question was. At least for deli meat sandwiches.
DickLips5000@reddit
Ya, true, I guess I should have been more specific about the quality of the subway toppings compared to other sandwich shops in America.
425565@reddit
Cheeseburger with pickles and raw onions.
IthurielSpear@reddit
Grilled onion for the win!
lordofpersia69420@reddit
Both!!!
r/onionlovers
VeteranYoungGuy@reddit
I use multiple different kinds. For a few examples I use dijon mustard for turkey, oil and vinegar for an Italian sandwich, horseradish for roast beef, and mayo for a BLT.
bloopidupe@reddit
Meat lettuce tomato mayo mustard
nsbsalt@reddit
Like most things I’d say very regional. Overall subway has standard items and toppings. My personal favorite sandwich which more of a Florida thing is a Cuban Sandwich. Very simple with pressed Cuban bread, ham, roast pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard.
BasicallyADetective@reddit
I think of a club sandwich as the classic American sandwich. Lettuce, tomato, and mayo. Chicken and ham although some prefer turkey. Two layers with three slices of thin toasted bread. Maybe some Swiss or provolone. Cut into triangles. French fries on the side or potato salad. Chef’s kiss.
ruggerbear@reddit
Since a hamburger is technically a sandwich, it would definitely fall into the top 3, if not the very top spot, of common sandwiches in the USA. typical toppings for a hamburger are cheese, lettuce, and tomato. mustard, ketchup, and mayo are the most common condiments. other slightly less common toppings would be pickles, onions, and bacon.
ToastMate2000@reddit
My favorite is a toastie with extra sharp cheddar cheese and sautéed minced mushrooms, zucchini, and red bell pepper, griddled with butter on the outside. This is not a standard thing you can just buy, though.
_iusuallydont_@reddit
Most common sandwiches in my house are Pb&j, BLT (with turkey bacon), and Roasted Turkey sandwich with provolone, lettuce, tomato, onion and garlic aioli.
Agamemnon66@reddit
Stopped reading at Subway. If you think that's the standard then your hopelessly lost.
Icy_Consideration409@reddit
This sub is “ask an American”.
Good possibility the OP is from another country.
If Subway is the only U.S. sandwich chain they know, then that’s their point of reference. Can’t imagine Jersey Mike’s is well known in Hungary or Moldova or wherever.
GrammarCriminal_@reddit
He meant that the condiments at subway(regardless of quality) are usually toppings put on American sandwiches. He’s not wrong
ToastMate2000@reddit
The combinations of bread types and toppings are very very common, even if theirs is substandard quality.
kamasutures@reddit
I think they meant more the spread of veg, proteins, dressings/condiments, spices/seasonings than the quality of subway.
Chad71313@reddit
Pickles
crappymedium@reddit
BEC/SPK
RestRare3056@reddit
PBJ is our unique thing. Subway is trash but the sandwiches are pretty typical. If you get any sandwich, you’re going to be given lettuce, tomato, and onion almost without a doubt. Mayo or mustard are the most common condiments, and oil/vinegar is also popular depending on what part of the country. Turkey and ham are probably the most common meats but I’d say what makes American food American is that we will do just about anything.
French dips are my favorite sandwich. My husband loves a Reuben. My kids love a pizza sub.
WatermelonRindPickle@reddit
If you are in the South, and close to farms that sell terrific tomatoes, or grow your own, a tomato sandwich in summer from a ripe tomato is terrific! White bread, Duke's mayonnaise, thick slice of a fresh beefsteak tomato. I put Kraft Miracle Whip on mine, the husband will have nothing but Dukes mayonnaise!
oklahomadokey@reddit
For any sandwich or burger anywhere in America, the standard is lettuce, tomato, and mayo. There are plenty of other options and local variations, of course. But you can safely assume lettuce, tomato, and mayo.
pbmadman@reddit
If you went to a restaurant and got a generic sandwich you’d probably expect lettuce, onion, tomato, maybe pickle, mayo, and mustard.
Outside of that, basically anything you can imagine.
Onyx_Lat@reddit
PB&J or tuna or grilled cheese sandwiches are more likely to be eaten at home. It's also common to have some kind of lunch meat sandwiches, with or without cheese. Most people don't go to the effort of putting lettuce and tomato on sandwiches at home. If you're getting a burger with "all the fixins" it will probably have lettuce, tomato, onion (usually raw), dill pickle slices, and cheese on it, also bacon if desired. Though the cheaper burgers will just have meat and cheese on them along with condiments. If you're making burgers at home, you're more likely to put all the toppings on if you're grilling and have guests.
ideletedyourfacebook@reddit
Deli meat + cheese (especially cheddar, swiss, provolone, or "American" cheese) + lettuce + tomato + onion, with mayo and yellow mustard is your basic American lunch sandwich. Then massive variation according to preference, mood, and creativity.
donuttrackme@reddit
There are too many sandwiches in the US to have "one" favorite topping of combo of toppings.
The two biggest nationwide ones are PBJ and a grilled cheese though.
TessOfLesJoueurs@reddit
Check out Jersey Mike's for typical American sub sandwiches
Emergency_Ad_1834@reddit
BLT, meatball sub, chicken parm, hot dog
SnooBananas7203@reddit
Trying to start the "is a hot dog a sandwich" argument, aren't ya?
Emergency_Ad_1834@reddit
Not particularly, but i don’t know what else it would be and is very American
LittleSubject9904@reddit
I like red onion, lettuce, mayo and some kind of mustard, unless it’s a BLT, then no mustard. Tomatoes only when they are great quality, preferably grown by me!
AgreeableCommission7@reddit
Subway is the bottom of the barrel.
This is a very regional question and can greatly depend on the type of sandwich. I can only speak for my area(New Mexico), the favorite topping is cheese + Green Chile can be fresh and chopped or roasted/peeled/chopped.
CheeseburgerSmoothy@reddit
Lately I feel that I have been eating a lot of shit sandwiches.
makinbankbitches@reddit
Peanut butter and jelly, grilled cheese, BLT, ham/turkey/roast beef and cheese
kamasutures@reddit
It can be pretty regional and seasonal too. Pimento sandwiches and Hanover tomato sandwiches are summer common in my neck o the Mid-Atlantic along with your ham and cheese or turkey and cheese.
Duke's only. (I cheat with Kewpie)
randypupjake@reddit
For Subway toppings, I would probably say avocado. I miss having an avocado tree
JonMatrix@reddit
Since the question is about typical sandwich toppings, not sandwich types, I would say lettuce, tomato, and onion (LTO) are the most common and found on all sorts of sandwiches.
Proud_Huckleberry_42@reddit
Love my pastrami sandwich on rye and a little mustard.
WritPositWrit@reddit
Ham & cheese
IthurielSpear@reddit
Pulled pork with Cole slaw where I’m from. Or a BLT.
Subway? GROSS
KillBologna@reddit
BLT, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and whatever condiments you want. You don’t need a national identity to eat anything.
Educational_Impact93@reddit
Typical is a peanut butter and jelly.
IMO, the best American sandwich is the simple BLT. When you can get a good tomato, nothing beats it.
tsukiii@reddit
Ham and swiss, turkey and provolone… I mostly buy turkey and pepper jack cheese for my sandwiches at home. With avocado if I’m feeling fancy.
OneNerdyLesbian@reddit
PB&J and grilled cheeses are probably the most common types of sandwiches here that you can't get at Subway, but the stuff available at Subway (at least in the US) is all common sandwich toppings as well.
Personally, turkey sandwiches and BLTs are my favorite. But when it comes to BLTs, I'd prefer them to be on sliced bread rather than subs like from Subway.
Traditional_Trust418@reddit
Ham/turkey and cheese or peanut butter and jelly are the most popular for lunches, I'd say
SuspiciousZombie788@reddit
Peanut butter & Jelly or grilled cheese are probably the most common sandwiches.
Asparagus9000@reddit
We have too many different popular options to easily name a specific one.
Deli meat and cheese is up there, but so is peanut butter and jelly.