What exactly is American culture?
Posted by No_Beautiful_8647@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 104 comments
What would you tell someone who’s about to come to America for college?
What are the pillars of American culture? Language? Religion? The Constitution? What distinguishes us?
the_real_JFK_killer@reddit
This is absurdly open ended and varies by location and subculture.
What exactly do you mean by a pillar?
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
Well, most cultures have language and religion as “pillars”. For instance, Thailand it’s definitely Buddhism and the Thai language, along with the royal family and one’s own family.
So what are the American equivalents?
Peytonhawk@reddit
The dominant language an religion in the USA are English and Christianity. Not a ton of people would call either of those culture of the USA though.
xXJLNINJAXx@reddit
He said "most" ffs, and that was an example 🤦♂️
the_real_JFK_killer@reddit
But what does that mean? Im not thai, I have no idea what the equivalent would be because I dont know what those things mean to the thai.
What do you mean by a pillar?
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
A foundation of the culture. For instance, most of the holidays in America are based on Christianity. Thus, at least on the surface, Christianity is or was a pillar of the culture.
Certain-Monitor5304@reddit
They used to call America the "melting pot." If you can imagine a huge pot filled with different "ingredients"from different cultures, culminating into something uniquely American.
https://share.google/aimode/EV4TT9vzTqB0sorUQ
Pillars would be the US constitution and the bill of rights.
Curmudgy@reddit
Only Xmas and Easter are based on Christianity. New Year’s Day, President’s Day, Memorial Day, Fourth of July, Labor Day, Columbus Day, Halloween, Thanksgiving aren’t.
webbess1@reddit
Well, technically it is. Jews celebrate their New Year on Rosh Hashanah.
Curmudgy@reddit
There are actually four new years in Judaism. But they have nothing to do with Christianity and certainly have nothing to do with the legal New Year holiday we celebrate on January 1, which originates with the Roman Julian Calendar.
webbess1@reddit
I’m saying our New Year on January 1st is based on Christianity. Other religions have different New Year’s. Other religions use different calendars.
Curmudgy@reddit
But January 1st comes from the Julian calendar. It doesn’t have a Christian basis. It’s just used by Christianity because it was the common, functional calendar in the place where Christianity started.
It’s true that the Gregorian calendar came from the Roman Catholic Church, but not all Christians use it; some still use the Julian calendar. And January 1st as the start of the year wasn’t a Christian invention.
beenoc@reddit
And the Gregorian calendar is just a slight correction to the Julian one - even if it wasn't propagated by the Church, someone secular would have made the same change eventually.
Ibbot@reddit
January 1st as the start of the year is actually a few centuries older than the Julian calendar.
Ibbot@reddit
Our New Year on January 1st predates Christianity by centuries, and therefore cannot be based on Christianity.
mistiklest@reddit
Also, the when the Christian calendar resets depends on denomination. For the Episcopal Church, for example, the calendar resets on the first Sunday of Advent.
machagogo@reddit
Two of our biggest holidays Independence Day and Thanksgiving are irreligious.
Baroque_Hologram@reddit
Eh I won’t argue that Christianity isn’t significant but there’s only two of our holidays that are rooted in Christianity
sneezhousing@reddit
Other then English there is really no other pillar same across all states.
TumbleFairbottom@reddit
If language and religion are the only distinguishing aspects of Thai culture, it’s a very shallow culture. Your assertion that they’re pillars is absurd.
We both know that language and religion don’t represent a culture though, don’t we?
Viva_La_Koko@reddit
Short and sweet, a melting pot of other cultures. Nothing truly stands out as individually “American”.
ClickClick_Boom@reddit
We have none, at least according to most of reddit.
Comic_manga_fighter@reddit
Which Reddit is that?
fuckingsheryl@reddit
While this doesn’t answer your question directly, I think it would be a crime to visit the United States without learning about black american culture. First and foremost. You can’t understand American culture without educating yourself on the black american experience. Also there are MANY smaller cultures within America that deserve respect and recognition. Off the top, I’d like people to learn a bit about the Gullah Geechee, Creoles, Cajuns, Native American culture(so many to mention here!!) Tejanos, Mississippi Delta folk culture I mean I could go in for days. To understand American culture you first have to understand that there really is no cohesive center. Americans hold on to our cultural traditions and heritage WHILE maintaining an American identity. It really feels like people are committed to misrepresenting and misunderstanding Americans. Direct your irritation at white Americans if you must, WE are the ones who are having a cultural identity crisis because WE insisted on abandoning our original heritage.
san_souci@reddit
What cultural identity crisis is white America having?
myfourmoons@reddit
We believe that we should be happy at all times and if we’re not something is wrong lol
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
Yes, we treat unhappiness like a disease.
llangstooo@reddit
Compared to most cultures in Europe and Asia, this is what stands out to me
-Radical individualism, encouraging self expression -Optimism, ability to reinvent yourself, try new things -Bias towards action rather than process, freedom to fail and try again -Less emphasis on obligation, tradition, or filial duty -Comfort with tension or disagreement. We see that sometimes messiness can be productive
Of course, different regions have different cultures, so these are broad strokes
humble-meercat@reddit
Excellent answer. I’d add that in addition to these general similarities we are not a monoculture but a polyculture as there are also significant regional differences to American Culture as well that most people who aren’t from here don’t know until they get here.
DentistPitiful5454@reddit
This should be the basic for whenever people ask this.
ALoungerAtTheClubs@reddit
This is a great answer.
lil_Baby_Jeebus@reddit
I 2nd that.
RobotShlomo@reddit
Baseball, hot dogs, apple pie.
ReversedFrog@reddit
There have been some really good answers, especially the ones that explain how America is based on ideas and ideals rather than geography, history, language, etc. I'd like to give some general advice.
There will probably be a lot of students from other cultures in the college. They can be useful for advice on things not to do or to do, but in general stay away from them, or there's no point in coming here. You won't learn what Americans are like from them. I took courses at a college that prided itself on its diversity. And it did have a diverse student body. But that didn't matter. White students hung around with white students, black students hung around with black students, Asian students hung around with Asian students (and divided themselves by country of origin within that), Hispanic students hung around with Hispanic students, etc. It wasn't actually a diverse school, it was a bunch of segregated schools using the same facilities. If you don't do that, you'll find the answer to your question organically.
Unusual-Calendar767@reddit
Melting Pot
Curmudgy@reddit
There is no exact definition of American culture.
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
I agree it does look very fluid on the surface. But is being rude to strangers acceptable anywhere? Wouldn’t that be a part of the culture?
Curmudgy@reddit
If being rude is not acceptable anywhere, then it’s human culture, not American culture.
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
I’ve been to places where people while not actively rude, are openly disrespectful to strangers. I don’t take it personally, it’s just their culture.
webbess1@reddit
Ideas about what politeness and rudeness are, are definitely cultural. Those vary by region, though.
RhymenoserousRex@reddit
If you start treating our states like separate countries that all just happen to speak the same language you’ll start to understand America better.
BulkyMonster@reddit
Cars, guns, rock music, cheeseburgers?
dorkpool@reddit
I think most foreigners think of the US as one would think of France. And while France certainly has some variation in culture such as Parisian vs Mediterranean. The US is actually as diverse as Europe. New England vs New York vs Appalachian vs Deep South vs South Florida vs New Orleans vs Midwest etc etc etc. We just have a common language.
Low_Attention9891@reddit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Culture_of_the_United_States
WhatABeautifulMess@reddit
The US doesn’t have a homogeneous culture so there aren’t really “pillars” in the same way as other cultures. Christianity is the most prominent religion but many people don’t practice it at all and even more only in a very high level “I celebrate Christmas” way that’s basically secular.
WhosCowsAreThey@reddit
Depends on where you are. We’re unified by the English language but English can be very different depending on where you are; Louisianans, Minnesotans, New Yorkers, and Californians all sound very different. We’re united by Cristian traditions, but we’re also not and what Christianity is changes pretty vastly; Catholics in Boston, Amish in Indiana, and Mormons in Utah have very different lifestyles and cultures while still falling under the Christian umbrella.
It isn’t specific enough of a place to narrow down a culture. We are a nation of immigrants and a lot of our old world cultural traditions still shine. I’m considered an Irish-American in the US and my family makes some Irish traditional foods like colcannon but we have been here long enough to adopt “Irish-American” food traditions like corned beef and cabbage. Even then, there is a difference between the Irish-Americans of Boston and the “Scot-Irish” of Appalachia but both still often identify as Irish-American. If you wanna be specific and look into cultures only found here you could look into indigenous or African American culture thats very unique to just the US.
Sports is a big unifier. American football, baseball, and basketball are all popular cultural unifiers here. Our media is also a massive cultural unifier. Film and tv are big tenets in American culture, the majority of movies are made here. Our music is a massive pillar of our culture, especially African American culture. Jazz, Rock and Roll, Hip Hop, and country are all American inventions; I wanna place special emphasis on our music originating in African American culture.
In short it’s a massive and populace country, there’s a few things that unite us but we have a lot of differences. I think the main key is the belief that we’re free to pursue those differences assuming they don’t tread on the rights of others. I’m sure you can imagine the flaws, but that is America in and of itself.
Weightmonster@reddit
College culture isn’t the same as US culture as a whole though.
Weightmonster@reddit
Watch all 30 some seasons of the Simpsons and the movie and get back to us.
elijahjflowers@reddit
AMERICA = ADAPTATION
Cheap_Coffee@reddit
I would say learning about American culture is part of the college experience for them.
85tornado@reddit
Hot dogs, baseball, hand egg, comic books, and TV that rots your brain. Generally speaking, our food is loaded with salt and sugar.
theycallmethevault@reddit
Culture varies drastically by region, is there is a specific part of the country you want to know more about?
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
Michigan and California.
theycallmethevault@reddit
Regions from the states? California is huge, the culture from North to South is going to be drastically different. Michigan is also going to vary depending on West to East, not to mention the Upper Peninsula.
Danibear285@reddit
Yes!
OkMasterpiece2194@reddit
Campus life is a completely new experience for everyone. There are no pillars of American culture, it is like on TV, there will be people from all sorts of different places. What distinguishes us is we don't take our studies as seriously as others and take our opportunities for granted.
Angry_GorillaBS@reddit
Racism, bigotry, greed, stupidity
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
I’m going to poke the bear here. If it’s really that bad, why not leave? 🤷🏻♂️
Angry_GorillaBS@reddit
You paying for it? You got connections so that I can move someplace, since there are conditions that have to be met?
Everybody should be able to go anywhere they want but unfortunately that isn't reality and most of the time you're at the mercy of where you are because you happened to be born there.
And then there's the issue of kids.
And that my girl likely doesn't want to move which makes it all moot anyway.
Angry_GorillaBS@reddit
I guess we're not supposed to be honest here?
LassierVO@reddit
Loud, hedonistic, competitive, weirdly friendly. Degrees of each vary depending on which region you're in.
JimBones31@reddit
Tailgate parties, cookouts, fireworks, camping, national parks, Hollywood movies.
No-Lunch4249@reddit
Assuming this "someone" is you OP, I have some specific advice
America has a very open, pluralistic, and friendly culture. My college had a lot of international transfers and almost without fail they mostly stuck to a social circle of other transfers from their country. I cant imagine more of a waste of your time here. Be proactive meeting American peers during your time, you won't regret it
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
I’m asking in order to advise a French exchange student.
No-Lunch4249@reddit
I was specifically thinking of the french cheek kiss when I said this lol
Joel_feila@reddit
Language is definitely English. Religion is not a big deal on college. Obe thing that really separate American from other is the lack of time and amount of space. Any building over a 100 is acient here. Thete is just nit that much really old stuff. We are also far far more spread out then most countries.
Those have effects on culture. Travling 100km one way to see family ir friends is common. There is also that independence in American culture. Moving away from family and having a separate life.
SenseAndSaruman@reddit
American culture is so widely known globally because our movies and music have a global audience.
America is also a big mix of cultures. I have danish, Swedish, Scottish, Irish and English ancestry. My dad’s a cowboy from a farm and my moms from the suburbs in California. I’ve lived all over the USA and the cultural differences between coasts is crazy.
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
True dat.
Ill-Butterscotch1337@reddit
Unlike many countries defined by a shared ethnicity, history, or religion, America is largely defined by a set of shared ideals and behaviors.
Most important are individualism and agency. In many cultures, the primary unit of society is the family or the community. In America, it is the individual.
Americans are raised to believe they are the authors of their own lives. We value self-reliance, personal space, and the right to define yourself:
I would tell any income student that you will be expected to make your own choices about your major, your schedule, and your beliefs. Advisors will guide you, but they won't tell you what to do. That's because Americans don't want to be told what to do.
Because we don't share a common bloodline, the Constitution serves as our unifying document:
Americans are famously litigious and obsessed with rights (Free Speech, Due Process). You will likely hear students debating rights and laws passionately. The belief that "no one is above the law" (even if it's not always applied) is central to our beliefs.
America is deeply anti-hierarchical in its social mannerisms:
Some international students may be shocked by the way college students dress for lecture or address their professors. Don't mistake informality for a lack of seriousness. An American can be joking with you one minute and doing ruthless business or academic critique the next.
Time is a resource:
In the U.S., time is viewed as a commodity and being late is often considered disrespecting of the other person's asset. Efficiency is important, people prefer conversations that get straight to the point.
America is a peaches culture vs a coconut culture that you might see in some parts of Europe. Europeans can be hard on the outside, seemingly stoic or distant at first but friends to the end once you break the shell. Americans are friendly and engaging with strangers. However, this friendliness is often a social lubricant, not an offer of deep intimacy. International students often feel confused when an American is incredibly nice one day but doesn't invite them over for dinner the next. Americans keep their private life private.
I would definitely tell any incoming student that really wants to stand out to focus on participation. It's oftentimes graded. In some settings, students are expected to be quiet and listen to the professor. In the US, may classes want the students to debate with one another or offer their opinion. Even if it's not graded or expected, engaging with one's professor outside of class or with other students will make a student stand out.
No_Beautiful_8647@reddit (OP)
Excellent response!
No-Reference-5137@reddit
Anything you want it to be.
Bonch_and_Clyde@reddit
Blue jeans, westerns, and hip hop.
TeacupCollector2011@reddit
Baseball, hot dogs, apple pie, and Chevrolet.
incelligent_@reddit
Smoking marijuana and then watching a Joe Dirt movie whilst eating Taco Bell on a Tuesday.
The ability to watch people fist fight in the middle of the highway and then they get into their cars and continue driving like nothing happened.
The lady smoking a cigarette in front of a Waffle House open at 2am during a snowstorm who gets a $20 tip because she’s got kids at home.
I’m sure there’s other things but that’s the first stuff that came to mind.
TheBimpo@reddit
the arts and other manifestations of human intellectual achievement regarded collectively.
the customs, arts, social institutions, and achievements of a particular nation, people, or other social group.
A lot.
SabresBills69@reddit
language us english
culture— it’s blended from folks from around the world
religion — frreevto your beliefs. most are Christian based. Younger generations are not religious.
Constituationnisca USA creation
LHCThor@reddit
There is not one “American Culture.” Because the US is composed of folks from many different cultures, the cultures of America are very varied. However, there are many sub-cultures depending on location and the make up of the community.
DOMSdeluise@reddit
blue jeans... burger.
cbbutle@reddit
BBQ and football
MaximumDerekCat@reddit
Rock, flag, and eagle!
SpeedLow3@reddit
The internet
BookLuvr7@reddit
America doesn't have one single culture any more than Europe does. It varies immensely by region if not by state.
Historical_Call_8349@reddit
This question lacks basic knowledge of America. If you live here, you have to realize different regions can be extremely different. It would be like asking me to describe China or Russia where I'm sure there is a wide variety of cultures within their vast lands.
So how would I describe "America" to a foreigner? What distinguishes America is that the variety of cultures is such that there is something for everyone. If you don't like one place (not the topography, language, politics, vibe, or pace of life your looking for), just keep looking, it's here.
dr_strange-love@reddit
That's like asking fish to describe water
Unsolven@reddit
No bullshit unless you are really good bullshiter.
shelwood46@reddit
None of that, we are like fourteen dogs in a trenchcoat.
FirstPersonWinner@reddit
I think you need to narrow this question down somewhat. This is such a broad topic to cover.
I think if you want some more universal parts of Americana that most people in the country would run with is: Burgers & fries, soda/pop, English (language), cars, blue jeans, donuts, movie theaters with popcorn, spaghetti and meatballs, orange chicken, 4th of July fireworks, St. Patrick's Day, Thanksgiving, Christmas, Halloween, New Year's Eve, American football, baseball, New York style pizza, pancake breakfasts, air conditioning, peanut butter and jelly sandwiches, freedom of speech, the right to bear arms, military flyovers, grass lawns, and leaning on things.
JackTheSpaceBoy@reddit
Most popular music genres, basketball, american football, baseball, BBQ, film, cajun culture, indigenous cultures (there are many), hunting, fishing, stunning nature
Nockolos@reddit
I’m still answering this question for myself and I’ve lived here my whole life. Sometimes I think it’s just…work. Many people ask first upon introduction what you do to earn a living. As far as I can tell, the point of this question is to determine what drives you and what value you add to the community. We attach our identities to work. A lineman will dress differently outside of work than an attorney. They will like different things (music, drink of choice, etc.) You can determine much about an American based on their occupational stereotype. And we are very hard on those that do not work. America is a paradise for the successful and purgatory for the have-nots. We are all born directly and indirectly that in life, there are winners and losers. This is ingrained in all of our minds and I believe it is a core tenet of being American, irrespective of whether or not you believe it to be true.
Anyway sorry for the ramble I’m just musing
Odd-Reward2772@reddit
I'm a New Yorker and your cultural experience would vary quite a bit depending on what school you go to here. Attending CUNY Hunter is a completely different lifestyle from SUNY Binghamton. Shit even the culture between Columbia and Hunter is totally different and they're less than 5 miles apart from each other.
Easy_Potential2882@reddit
At its core America is centered on the idea that everyone gets a fair shot at happiness and prosperity in life here, and that that is based not an any shared ethnic identity at all, but on an idea - personal freedom. The artifacts of our culture ultimately stem from this idea, and from the specific groups of people who've come here on the promise of this idea.
This isn't just rose-colored glasses. Even for the chapters in our history where people have attempted to infringe on the freedoms of others, the people in question are usually motivated by the idea that they have the freedom to do so as Americans, as hypocritical as that may be for them to do.
Prestigious-Comb4280@reddit
Yes different regions are like different countries. English is fairly consistent even if accents differ.
Big_Metal2470@reddit
That varies widely. I've only lived in two regions and the difference in attitude to tradition, religion, individualism, and most other things was wildly different.
I tend to think of Americans as generous, friendly, hard working, materialistic, and deeply principled. Before you give me shit for the last one, those principles vary tremendously, but I know damn well that if I get a flat tire anywhere in this country, someone will stop to help me, I know that I can strike up a conversation with anyone in a checkout line and probably enjoy it, I know that my salary and homeowner status will garner respect, and I know that someone who holds deeply different beliefs will feel I totally deserved it if I'm killed for my beliefs.
Theycallmesupa@reddit
Hotdogs
Perfect_Storm_425@reddit
Glizzies -can you dig it ?!?!?
Cute_Repeat3879@reddit
Pluralism
Act however you want, say whatever you want, believe what ever you want, but respect the right of everyone else to do the same even when it's the opposite of you.
UnicornScientist803@reddit
Honestly, I think this is great
FirstPersonWinner@reddit
The only rule is there are no rules
softgypsy@reddit
Depends on the state, and then also usually depends on what part of the state. Culture can vary greatly from state to state and even town to town in America.
consultantdetective@reddit
What makes up any culture? Just going w my gut, I'd start w music, food & drink. Then sports & film. After that civics, history, literature. Then language & religion. Then after that I'd want to pick out regional cultures w/in the country to focus on.
BuildNuyTheUrbanGuy@reddit
That's a vague question.
the_real_JFK_killer@reddit
This is absurdly open ended. Can you be any more specific on what youre looking to learn about?
What do you mean by a pillar?
theEWDSDS@reddit
Being American
mitchdwx@reddit
That answer varies wildly based on what part of the country you’re in.