TheaterFire

No, Asus isn't going into memory manufacturing — Taiwanese tech giant issues statement smashing rumor

Posted by imaginary_num6er@reddit | hardware | View on Reddit | 21 comments

Reply to Post

21 Comments

games-and-chocolate@reddit

a company like Asus depends on others so much, it is a lifeline. if that line is cut, it is automatically completely game over for this huge company. no memory is no products to sell. you better change Asus. or just give up. memory is only becoming more important if we even get working androids. So are chips.
View on Reddit #74404492

CuddleTeamCatboy@reddit

If memory prices crash that would also be game over for Asus.
View on Reddit #74459255

games-and-chocolate@reddit

if they could produce some, they control their own supply and demand.
View on Reddit #74473184

Strazdas1@reddit

A chef growing their own vegetables is the most inefficient way you can do things.
View on Reddit #75084694

games-and-chocolate@reddit

many restaurants in the world grow their own. importing means lots of aircraft fuel, cost is higher, you have no control over quality. We talk so much about airpolution that we have to stop pumping co2 into the air, but as you see, efficientcy, efficientcy! And totally forget our welbeing of our earth.
View on Reddit #75089191

Strazdas1@reddit

No, they dont grow their own. That would be extremely inefficient. They just have contracts with lower growers.
View on Reddit #75100010

Margoth_Rising@reddit

Tldr- this was never going to happen. Ever lol China has tried for decades to get their DRAM to have performance parity to SK/Samsung/Micron. What makes you think Asus can get there in 2 years starting from ground zero. Even if they had billions to invest on this suicide mission which they don't its not as simple as building a factory.
View on Reddit #74550126

ahfoo@reddit

Taiwan spent a lot bailing out its memory makers during the last crash.
View on Reddit #74384438

GumshoosMerchant@reddit

taiwan doesn't really have much stake in the memory business the vast majority of market share belongs to samsung (kr), sk hynix (kr), and micron (us) companies like nanya (tw) and winbond (tw) are tiny by comparison
View on Reddit #74399293

ahfoo@reddit

https://spectrum.ieee.org/taiwans-dram-bailout
View on Reddit #74399967

Slabbed1738@reddit

Damn, made a claim, backed up with a source and still got downvoted lol
View on Reddit #74427044

Strazdas1@reddit

The claim and the source does not match. He said taiwan bailed them out during last crash (2022). The source said they did in 2009.
View on Reddit #75084657

BabySnipes@reddit

If the source were contemporary it may have been relevant.
View on Reddit #74480676

ahfoo@reddit

What the fuck kind of comment is this? Yes, it was ten years ago. That doesn't mean it is irrelevant or didn't happen. It is precisely on topic and addresses the parent article directly. The article says that Asus is not planning to enter DRAM manufacturing and I pointed out that Taiwan lost big money on DRAM in the last bubble then provided an article to demonstrate that this is a fact. And you mouthbreathers are responding with. . . but it happened ten years ago. And. . . what the fuck does that have to do with anything?
View on Reddit #74501313

justice_for_lachesis@reddit

2009…..
View on Reddit #74400593

Choreboy@reddit

What if we ask really nicely?
View on Reddit #74391667

TemptedTemplar@reddit

There's no plausible scenario where ASUS entering the DRAM market would help anyone other than their shareholders. >Asus denied the report, specifically stating that it has "no plans to invest in a memory wafer fab." They're explicitly just buying existing memory chips to sell themselves. Moving those increased costs into higher costs for consumer goods and bigger profits from themselves.
View on Reddit #74581969

games-and-chocolate@reddit

China was being blocked from havingadvanced technology. Asus is different, they may buy from anyone who can produce the chip making machines.
View on Reddit #74555715

LargeSinkholesInNYC@reddit

It's an industry that requires a lot of capital investment.
View on Reddit #74494370

RunForYourTools@reddit

They will when people stop spending on Asus products, going with competition boards to spare for RAM.
View on Reddit #74491882

AutoModerator@reddit

Hello imaginary_num6er! Please **double check that this submission is original reporting and is not an unverified rumor or repost** that does not rise to the standards of /r/hardware. If this link is reporting on the work of another site/source or is an unverified rumor, please delete this submission. If this warning is in error, please report this comment and we will remove it. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/hardware) if you have any questions or concerns.*
View on Reddit #74369025