Recommendations for EDC pistol? (Glock 43X, Glock 26, Canik Mete MC9, Springfield Hellcat Pro, or a revolver?)
Posted by FishermanAfraid7659@reddit | Firearms | View on Reddit | 69 comments
Hey Redditors,
I'm looking for recommendations on my first EDC (everyday carry) pistol. So far, I've only shot a Glock 17 Compact, and I'm considering these options for concealed carry:
- Canik Mete MC9
- Springfield Hellcat Pro
- Glock 43X
- Glock 26
- Revolvers (no specific model yet, open to suggestions)
What are your thoughts? Any pros/cons, personal experiences, or insights on reliability, concealability, recoil, trigger, or which one might suit a beginner best?
RedneckMarxist@reddit
BG2.0 or S&W642
FishermanAfraid7659@reddit (OP)
Are Revolvers safe to carry?
Acceptable_Curve594@reddit
safer and more reliable than any semi auto pistol. less chances of malfunction because there isnt a reciprocating slide or ejecting rounds. makes it easier to keep rounds on target while shooting in quick succession but thats just my personal experience with them.
Famous_N0body@reddit
My exact choices too. Pocket pistol or bust
FishermanAfraid7659@reddit (OP)
That SW looks wild!
WhiteBufflo73@reddit
I don’t wanna be that guy but the Sig P365XL is top the best carry gun I have found this far. 9mm capacity of 12(+1) and it’s extremely concealable.
murkr@reddit
get the r11 grip module you will like it evenmore.
FishermanAfraid7659@reddit (OP)
I've heard SIG got an problem with self shooting, isnt it the 365 model?
annonimity2@reddit
The 320 is under fire and rightfully so, the 365 is a solid gun that I can and do trust with my life.
TubeSockLover87@reddit
wiltchamberlain1356@reddit
No issues that im aware of with the 365 line, sig may have a bad name right now, but that series is still one of the best CC options out there
Trooper1911@reddit
No, 320. 365 is good to go.
Go to a range with a lot of rentals and try out everything that fits the size and budget you have in mind. Literally every gun maker (Glock, Sig, HK, Beretta, S&W, Springfield, Canik etc) has a model in every size you can think of. Ignore revolvers outside of big-bore for bear country (and even then a Glock20 should be more than enough).
Think about your needs and concealment/layers to decide between a compact, subcompact, single stack vs doublestack and then go test stuff out to see what works for you. I personally shoot glocks and everything with glock grip angle worse than guns with more vertical grip angle. H&K's ergonomy works for my hand shape and finger length, all the controls are where I want them to be etc.
The market has never been bigger, there's really so many choices and what works for one person might not work for another due to high level of subjectivity, personal fitment etc.
Gerporp@reddit
No, that's the p320. I don't own one but haven't heard of any issues in the 365
FishermanAfraid7659@reddit (OP)
Ohhh you right!
BigMammoth415@reddit
just me but personally wouldn’t purchase a firearm from a company that couldn’t openly come out about a serious issue regarding their firearms putting consumers at risk and caring about saving their ass and contracts more then potentially killing someone. Now hindsight could of been user error due to their holsters but there’s a couple vidoes of camera footage that shows the gun literally going off in their holster despite them even being near it.
I can’t speak the same for the rest of their handguns and AR’s but there’s plenty of other options out there.
WhiteBufflo73@reddit
If you don’t want to support them it’s your choice whether you give them your money or not. I have always liked Sig but there’s no denying they have always been a mildly overpriced and they did a terrible job of handling the recent controversy. The fact of the matter is, a lot of their guns are very nicely machined prices of equipment.
TubeSockLover87@reddit
They haven't " handled it" at all.
That's why they're ass.
Fuck Sig.
tjcarbon9@reddit
Unreliable junk.
CaptTremor@reddit
This or the XMacro. Either way, you can pick up an XMacro frame or XL frame and the appropriate magazine, and then you have an another pistol configuration. XL in the summer and Xmacro in the winter
WhiteBufflo73@reddit
I’ll look into the x Macro. I actually tend to carry a larger gun in the winter (S&W M&P40C), simply because I can conceal easier with a big ol coat on. I’m also in the market for a S&W revolver chambered in 357 but I don’t like that a lot of the newer models are hammerless. I have a S&W model 19 with a 6inch barrel but it’s much too big for my pockets.
Crismus@reddit
Same. I love my P365XL. So comfortable and shoots phenomenally well.
My son got a Glock 17, because he wanted something different than me. I say the Sig is better than a Glock.
WhiteBufflo73@reddit
Again, some may disagree but I can’t stand Glocks. They are thick, blocky, and uncomfortable in the grip. I own many many firearms and I cannot bring myself to spend my hard earned dollars on a Glock. Not to mention I can shoot them whenever I want because my friends collectively own every model at this point. lol
murkr@reddit
p365 with an r11 grip module
Boogaloo_Shrmp@reddit
Ruger max 9 or ruger lcp max
VZNRClinch@reddit
Yall really like that lil ugly ass gun “ruger lcp “
AspirantVeeVee@reddit
I have a glock 48 )long slide 43x) and i like it, but prefer my kimber micro , and tbh, im looking to replace the micro.
GoatLoperman@reddit
Bodyguard 2.0. Use the extended magazine if you have big hands. I prefer Talon grips on mine, you do you.
NomadicGunner@reddit
Rost Martin
Emergency_Ad_5935@reddit
The 43X with shield arms S15 mags is a pretty solid carry option. Slim, compact, with 15+1 on board.
Ornery-Exchange-4660@reddit
My EDC is a Keltec P3AT. If I had to replace it with something else, the next best for me would be the Ruger LCP.
These are my principles for EDC:
A gun in hand is worth more than two in the car, unless you are in the car.
The best gun in the world is the one you have when you need it.
You never know when you will need it.
My Keltec is reliable and comfortable to carry. It is reasonably accurate for its size, and a good .380 round is very effective against flesh-type targets.
Many people go for a larger EDC pistol, find that it is cumbersome and uncomfortable to carry, then leave it at home or in the car most of the time. My Keltec is so light that I even carry it in my gym shorts. When I am in the US, if I'm wearing clothes, I'm armed, unless it is a place where I have to go through metal detectors.
TheGunsmith97@reddit
What holster?
Ornery-Exchange-4660@reddit
It has a clip, like a pocket knife.
I just keep it in my left front pocket and make sure there is absolutely nothing else in the pocket.
santar0s80@reddit
Bg 2.0 P365 x macro
RAD_Sr@reddit
Find a range with rentals ( or friends with candidates).
The best option is the one you will enjoy shooting and will be most likely to train with. To find that there's no substitute for trying them yourself.
divok1701@reddit
This! Have shot a variety of different guns using the range rentals. Nothing compares to actually shooting them.
No-Average6364@reddit
For revolvers, you've got plenty of options as they now have revolvers that quite easily handle what would normally be semi sutomatic rounds like forty five acp and nine millimeter and .380. One particularly interesting option is 327 federal magnum. you can get loads that are up in the 357 magnum range.. And its cylinder usually carries an extra round compared to the same size 357 or the gun is overall smaller than your average 357. you have the ability to use 327 or 32HR or old school 32 feed and depending on your extractor star.. possibly 32acp..
datsboi@reddit
Not a recommendation, but I edc G30s.
Altruistic-Bee5591@reddit
Arp 300acc blk
SpectreLLC@reddit
I love my 43x, but stock is quite snappy. I didn’t love it until I put an Arc Reactor slide and barrel in it, now it’s my daily.
WesleysHuman@reddit
I've been carrying a Beretta PX4 Storm compact for nearly 15 years. I own other handguns but I've only run across one that I'd like to change out to: the second PX4 version that came out 2 years ago. They are fantastic firearms!. Soft shooting, easy to rack, DA/SA, almost no muzzle climb due to the rotating barrel.
Stock_Block2130@reddit
Rent them all. Spend an afternoon at a rental range and see what feels best in your hand. And then train with the one you have chosen.
wegiich@reddit
Smith and Wesson shield x
Fragrant_Loan811@reddit
Go and see what feels best in your hand in your price range. If you can rent and shoot a few and see which one you like best.
EffectivePen2502@reddit
I almost always suggest a Double Action / Single Action (DA/SA) hammer fired system, especially for practical purposes. This system is extremely robust, reliable and very forgiving of handling negligence, which makes it very practical for new shooters, experienced shooters and for a pistol that you plan on depending on.
The DA is a long and heavy trigger pull, which is your first trigger pull, which basically means you have to intentionally decide to send that round or be outrageously negligent. After the first round, it gives a nice, very light single action trigger that is short and crisp. After you are done firing, you de cock it back into the double action (DA), which is the native state that it should be in when not being fired. The DA makes it incredibly unlikely that you will have an unintended discharge while holstering the firearm as well, and if you place your thumb over the hammer while holstering, you can feel if anything is interacting with the trigger when holstering, and make it damn near impossible for the gun to fire.
I recently switched to a Beretta 92G from a SIG P226 legion that I carry both as an EDC and duty firearm. When I carried the P226, I was in a very stressful situation where the decision between shooting a suspect or not was in the air. I made the decision that lethal force was clearly applicable, but not quite necessary at that point in time. Well, shortly after I made that decision, the suspect continued to rapidly amp up the situation, and I found that my subconscious reactions had me instinctively place my finger on the trigger, which I immediately noticed when I started to feel that heavy trigger and saw the hammer start to draw back.
I was well within my rights to use lethal force; however, the DA trigger press took me back into more of a thinking state, allowing me to more consciously choose to not discharge my weapon at that time. Keep in mind, this is an instinctual response, especially the more intense a situation gets, and most people don't even register their finger has actually entered the trigger guard or even that the trigger is starting to be pulled at all or until it's already been done.
Long story short, this will happen to anyone, regardless of training when a certain level of stress is introduced, especially if it is rapidly introduced in a very short time frame. That long and heavy trigger press had a key role in making me choose different tactics, which lead to the suspect being uninjured and taken into custody. The DA/SA isn't the most popular thing nowadays, but it is the best option in my opinion and it is making a comeback, and for many good reasons. It does not matter if you are a beginner or an expert shooter, DA/SA is superior for almost any environment and for almost anyone. Learn the double action pull, learn the single action pull, learn the DA to SA transition and learn how to de cock after your firing sequence. All of which can be learned in less than 200 rounds of intentional practice.
Look at Beretta, HK, SIG, CZ and Sphinx (I'm sure there are others) if you are interested in checking them out. The bigger the gun the easier it is to shoot and the harder it is to conceal. I don't typically recommend revolvers because of multiple reasons. I would get something between compact and full size options. With a proper belt and holster setup, you can carry a full sized gun comfortably and discreetly, unless you wear skin tight clothing, then it would be probably be difficult. The bigger gun you get, the more likely you are going to practice with it because it will actually be fun to shoot. Small guns are very rarely enjoyable to shoot. My full size Beretta 92G with a Surefire X300T is with me for \~23 hours a day. When I'm not at work, it is carried in a Tier 1 AIWB holster with an extra magazine attached.
Femveratu@reddit
Try them if you can even just hold them to check the ergos for your hand.
On paper I’m taking the Glock 43x, but I’ve been carrying Glocks a long time and the 43 in particular since it came out.
SetNo8186@reddit
The original P365 with safety. When it came out it was praised for its trigger, which is still good, its small size, its doublestack magazine (can use a 15 rounder) Its night sites, and now it has numerous aftermarket options. It became the reason for all the others mentioned - and while they might do one or another thing better, its still the better all around pistol. Over a million sold, still popular.
And, they don't have any issues. None. If anything, SIG is picking up LEO contracts with the XL model, which is a sign how reliable it is.
For concealed carry, its got the best set of features with the least number of compromises. Just dont add red dots or lights - at that point its a race gun - which it can do well - not a CC gun - which has become a huge mess of confusion with all the marketing of optics, lights and extended mags.
kimodezno@reddit
I usually carry the Walther PDP Pro. They also have the PDP F it’s a bit smaller. The PDP Pro shoots very well.
That being said, I did look at am let guns including the hell cat pro, Glock 43x and 45.
I felt the hell cat pro was snappier than my PDP pro. It felt ok to shoot.
The Glocks didn’t impress me at all.
However I can say to look at the shadow systems elite or war poet. They have different sizes, so head out to a gun store and try out which one works best for you. And here’s a great selling point. If you ever use your gun in self defense they will give you a new gun because the police will confiscate yours for evidence.
That a wing.
danvapes_@reddit
I carry a p365 and p365 Fuse myself. I like the p365 platform. Really I would recommend handling all of these firearms and if you can shoot them to compare. They will have different grip angles, ergonomics of controls, different size and shape grips, and different feeling triggers and recoil impulses. You may find you like them all or that a specific one jives with you more.
ColtMadeThemEqual@reddit
I carry a Glock 26 every day. I use a 15 round spare mag with an X-Grip adaptor. I that I can use any double stack Glock mag with it.
Familiar-Candy4813@reddit
HK CC9
Available-Ad-4934@reddit
Psa dagger is a good choice as well
Relevant_Score7074@reddit
I got the BG 2.0. Same frame as a shield, just smaller. It's tiny yet can control it. Im happy with mine. Break in required though. Safety and rack is stiff. Like a pair of jeans
AHockeyFish@reddit
Springfield Hellcat Micro Compact
KataifiKalamari@reddit
P365 is a no brainer for me every time, and before i could get anything i carried a G2C(I’ve heard the G2’s have quality issues even though mine was fine, but you will need to re-adjust irons here and there after heavy use, no jams or issues here tho). I will recommend glocks as a non-glock guy bc they are definitely reliable but just not for me.
jeffbagwell6222@reddit
HK VP9SK
prudent-nebula3361@reddit
I love my METE Mc9.
FishermanAfraid7659@reddit (OP)
It comes with holdster and many equips here in EU. How the trigger feels?
prudent-nebula3361@reddit
I like the trigger, but you can always swap it out if you don't like it.
CapableExercise5297@reddit
Try them all out and grab what you like the best. Nobody can tell you what works best for you.
No-Performance4989@reddit
It depends on where you live and the weather. Living in the southeast, I wear shorts quite a bit so I carry my ruger lcp or my s&w snub nose. If it is cool enough for long pants and a long sleeve over shirt, I will carry my ruger srs 1911. If by chance I am doing an outdoor activity like hunting or fishing I might open carry my rossi 357, with snake shot going to, while in, and when leaving the woods openly. It all depends on you and your situation. I would never carry or keep a glock in the truck because I don't like them tbh.
youkilledkenny3211@reddit
Glock 26 carry’s good and it shoots a lot better than most carry guns also you can use Glock 19/17 and 33 rounder mags so it’s versatile
Sad-Professor362@reddit
I recently been EDC the MnP shield x comp I absolutely love it. I have a TLRX 7 light and a A Holosun K series
chefmsr@reddit
I like my 43x mos now, but I have dropped a fair amount into it at this point. At this point I would take it over most out of the box comparables.
If I had it to do again, I’d probably go with something better out of the box and just throw a dot on it.
Maybe a sig. if you don’t mind spending a few bucks and still want a Glock, maybe go with a shadow systems.
HelpfulSpread601@reddit
Don't sleep on the S&W shield X. I'm trading my p365xl for one of those next week
throne-away@reddit
I love my Caniks, but the Mete MC9 has been plagued by design issues. Check the /r/canik sub for more dirt.
Personally, Glocks do not feel comfortable to me. You should rent one and try it.
Hellcat is pretty popular although some guys don't care for the trigger.
The Sig P365 is hugely popular and has good aftermarket support. I rented one and it felt great.
ConstantPrecipice@reddit
The MC9 is great if you can handle a really small gun, and I really like shooting mine. However, if you've got bigger hands or can conceal something a little larger, the MC9 Prime is definitely superior for shootability. Both have excellent triggers, are optics ready, and have good texturing on the grip, although the prime is better in that regard.
Sore_Wa_Himitsu_Desu@reddit
Over the years my carry has evolved through:
S&W 638 (.38 air weight J Frame revolver.
S&W 649 (.357 stainless steel J Frame Revolver.
SIG P230 (.380 semi auto)
Ruger LC9S Pro (9mm semi auto)
And now I’m usually carrying a S&W Bodyguard 2.0 (.380 semi auto).
I’m generally a pocket carry guy. Of the ones you list I’d probably go revolver because I don’t care for Glocks, and I don’t find Canik and Springfield to be reliable.
slk28850@reddit
I don't know your build but I would stick with full size if this is your first gun. Easier to shoot and be accurate with than the subs and micro guns. Also depends on wardrobe and climate. If it is cool/cold concealed carry of a full size is easier than warm/hot climates. If you're a tiny person a full size may be too big for you so you may want to go smaller and just train with it until you're proficient. I carry a full size Shadow Systems DR920(Glock17 clone) and it is only a pain the hottest time of year when I don't wear sweatshirts or vests/jackets. I'm 6'1" and 220lbs.
Whatever you choose you should give Swap Rig holsters a look. They have good inside the waistband/IWB and outside the waistband/OWB options and great customer service.
My EDC loadout https://youtu.be/K3jo-BuvysY?si=VopleDdPXVLBfWwL
My SwapRig Holsters https://youtu.be/rOMiELraN_s?si=Se9Q-r-9p4Eb3XWt
TheGurgeMan@reddit
Smith and Wesson bodyguard 2.0
Ive got a g43x and a ruger lcp max that just sit in the safe now.