Who is the greatest British guitarist of all-time?
Posted by debrisaway@reddit | AskABrit | View on Reddit | 239 comments
Where it was like an extension of their body and they could command it to do whatever they want.
Jones
Richards
Clapton
Gilmour
May
Harrison
Page
Apple2727@reddit
Johnny Marr
Fun-Brush5136@reddit
Had to scroll way too far down past the usual dinosaurs to get to Marr :)
Apple2727@reddit
Everyone always seems stuck in the 60s and 70s when they think of the best guitarists.
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Surprised no one else said Marr. Very original player.
Ok-Application-8045@reddit
And massively influential on guitar music from the 80s until now.
keeponkeepingup@reddit
Slash for me
herwiththepurplehair@reddit
If we are going to go with British born, and personal preference, I’m going to pick Angus. Born Glasgow, he was 7 when they went to Australia. And I named my dog after him lol.
debrisaway@reddit (OP)
Can you claim him as British?
keeponkeepingup@reddit
Yeah I'm claiming him, he's ours
All-Hail-The-Ale@reddit
Born in London, I'd say so.
debrisaway@reddit (OP)
But his formative years?
All-Hail-The-Ale@reddit
Stoke on Trent, but we don't talk about that haha.
debrisaway@reddit (OP)
Not Los Angeles?
All-Hail-The-Ale@reddit
I suppose it depends on what you define as formative. Sure he moved there at the age of 6, but still.
vctrmldrw@reddit
*Provides list from the 60s and 70s
herwiththepurplehair@reddit
Well yeah but I guess these are some of the guitarists who inspired today’s bands/artists - I mean Mozart has been dead for almost 250 years but they’re still playing his stuff…..
Captain_Chappie@reddit
Yeah, guess the OP's age...
Unusual_residue@reddit
My favourite is Adrian Smith. Talk of the 'greatest' is pretty pointless in my humble opinion.
herwiththepurplehair@reddit
Exactly so. My husband has a rock and metal channel on YouTube, and even he will admit that these kind of questions are so subjective. Maiden are his favourite Brit band, but I suspect he’d plump for Brian May, just for sheer innovation as much as anything else.
CBWeather@reddit
Burt Weedon.
herwiththepurplehair@reddit
Bert. He was born Herbert, shortened to Bert.
BraveCourt9521@reddit
His " Play in a Day " guitar instruction book was the first port of call to budding guitarists years ago.
Nickjc88@reddit
What about Slash? He was born in London so he's British.
the_roguetrader@reddit
he was born in Stoke On Trent dear boy
Public-Magician535@reddit
Surprised Page hasn’t received more love, saying that. Knopfler
Cosmic-Hippos@reddit
None of the above imo, John McGlaughlan / Martin Taylor/ Mike Oldfield / Jeff Beck / Richie Blackmore / Alan Holdsworth
EiectroBot@reddit
Anyone else for Rory Gallagher?
ImInTheMealDeal@reddit
Not British..
All-Hail-The-Ale@reddit
The Irish would have something to say about that. Would be a worthy claim though if at all possible.
EiectroBot@reddit
That’s an excellent point. I had thought he was born in Northern Ireland, but it turns out I was wrong and he was born in County Donegal.
Fit-Pomegranate-2210@reddit
You know northern Ireland isn't in Britain Right?
EiectroBot@reddit
The original question was who was the greatest British guitarist. Anyone born in Northern Ireland is British by nationality. In this case Rory was not in fact born in Northern Ireland, so he was not British by nationality.
It’s a common mistake to confuse geography with nationality. But always best not to. Great Britain is an island, and it’s the largest in the group of islands known as the British Isles. Ireland is the second largest island in the British isles.
The term “Britain” is more of a concept than a place, and has been historically difficult to pin down. Further than that, Britain and British are not interchangeable. Most would agree that Northern Ireland is part of Britain.
Fit-Pomegranate-2210@reddit
Except that its literally not part of britain great or otherwise...
EiectroBot@reddit
I detect an educational lacking! My condolences.
Live your delusion if it makes you content in your small world.
Fit-Pomegranate-2210@reddit
Britain isn't a place so i don't consider britain to be anything.
You suggested northern ireland was in britain. It is not. Because A. Britain isn't a place and B it is not on the land mass known as great britain which may occasionally be shortened to "Britain".
However, british is more vague and as someone posted above United Kingdomish is just daft.
So once again... I have no issue with someone from northern Ireland calling themselves British, infact i don't give a fuck if anyone calls themselves British.
Fit-Pomegranate-2210@reddit
I saw your education comment btw which immediately tells me alot more about you than than you assumed incorrectly about me. :-D
maccathesaint@reddit
Northern Irish people consider themselves British or Irish, usually. The whole "United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland" doesn't really leave much room for a UK identity beyond British. United Kindomish isn't a nationality (though feels pretty apt given how the UK govt treats NI).
Fit-Pomegranate-2210@reddit
Thats not quite what i was saying. I was just pointing out Northern Ireland wasn't in Britain. Whether you are british or not is a bit more up to personal opinion.
Sailorf237@reddit
Johnny Marr is a guitar craftsman. I love his playing.
Beanieboru@reddit
Jeff Beck.
mcbeef89@reddit
Strong agree. Technical genius with such soul
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
And he always sounded like he was having so much fun as he played. Some guitarists sound as though they’re just going through the motions, but every Beck solo sounds as though each note has been thought about.
Beanieboru@reddit
https://youtu.be/ussqi8yjAks?si=mvowz1HzZLG6igXG
Alice Cooper explains it nicely.
GarrySpacepope@reddit
Some youtube guitarist must have learned the trick he talks about where you slowly drop the guitar and hammer on notes as it falls through your hand. If anyone knows of a video please share it!
Also I love how everyone Alice Cooper is chatting to is dressed as blandly as possible.
JumpinJackCilitBang@reddit
Either him, John McLaughlin or Allan Holdsworth. Saying that, I seldom listen to any of their music.
Astr0Scot@reddit
Jeff Beck guitar parts on Amused to Death album by Roger Waters
222for2@reddit
My heart says Richie Blackmore, but my head agrees with you
BookishHobbit@reddit
Went to a Clapton gig a few years back. Beck was support. He was brilliant. Clapton not so much.
drtoboggon@reddit
Your favourite guitarists favourite guitarist
biggwermm@reddit
James May
EnjoysAGoodRead@reddit
Got to be Knopfler for me.
SweetCryptographer72@reddit
Paul Gilbert.
IIJOSEPHXII@reddit
Johnny Marr but he ain't done anything noteworthy since The Smiths
durhamdale@reddit
Johnny marr
Japhet_Corncrake@reddit
Peter Green.
NoPaleontologist7929@reddit
Saw him at our local jazz and blues festival about 20 years ago. He was very good, but the magic was slightly lacking. Back in the day, absolutely top tier.
ConfidentialX@reddit
Glad he is so high up the list. Unbelievable talent, what a magical player.
"He was the only player to give me the cold sweats" B.B King about Peter's tone.
criminalsunrise@reddit
I know he’s not English, so is outside of this list, but that quote reminds me of when Hendrix supported Clapton somewhere and Eric had a massive go at someone for making him have to follow Hendrix.
Viking-Bastard-XIV@reddit
Came here for this answer, was not disappointed.
An absolutely unbelievable artist
QuietVisit2042@reddit
Came here to mention him.
theMooey23@reddit
Peter Green us better than God
Walt1234@reddit
John Williams was pretty good
kollectivist@reddit
Born in Melbourne.
exkingzog@reddit
Bert Jansch.
Fresh_River_4348@reddit
The correct answer
RickJLeanPaw@reddit
Or John Renbourn. Too many to mention.
exkingzog@reddit
Pentangle fan spotted.
RickJLeanPaw@reddit
I was just there for the Danny Thompson!
BraveCourt9521@reddit
Davey Graham deserves a mention too. His " Anji " instrumental became the tune new guitar players had to master before they thought of themselves as anywhere near capable.
exkingzog@reddit
Yes, good shout.
astidad@reddit
Bill Nelson, and it’s not even close.
PricklyScot01@reddit
Mark Knopfler
DefinitelynotDanger@reddit
Guthrie Govan
Upset_Language_1511@reddit
Peter Green by a mile
Salty-Value8837@reddit
Gilmour but the greatest guitar player wasn't British. Jimmy Hendrix
hooahhhhhhh@reddit
What about Rory Gallagher
illarionds@reddit
Mark Knopfler for me. He really makes it cry and sing.
Honourable mention for Dave Gilmour.
Alecmalloy@reddit
James Dean Bradfield can play anything. They're not the best, per se, but the britpop era produced a fair number of highly influential and idiosyncratic guitarists: Greenwood, Butler, Oakes, Coxon, McCabe to name a few.
Swimming-Pear-7985@reddit
I agree he probably isn’t the best per se but is well deserving of a mention and I specifically scrolled to see if someone mentioned him. The best of his era anyway and underrated as a guitarist I think.
Alecmalloy@reddit
I think Richard Oakes is painfully overlooked. He replaced Bernard Butler as a teenager and immediately co-wrote a number 1 album. I love his style too. His work on Suede's run since Bloodsports is superb.
nogeologyhere@reddit
Another support for our James - he's rarely mentioned when the topic comes up and I find that a shame as he's incredibly talented and has written some belting riffs.
Petrichorbs@reddit
Was about to comment for JDB! The goat? Maybe not but phenomenal nonetheless.
Wossname76@reddit
Guthrie Govan, and it’s not even close
Tasco_420@reddit
Surely John Squire is worth a mention
maccathesaint@reddit
Finally! Soooo far down. I saw him live years back. Small venue. The furthest you could be from the stage was about 50m at the furthest point and I was bang at the front due to it being my local and being let in through the other bar next door before the main doors opened by the bar manager lol
Got to chat to him, he was incredibly sound and signed my copy of The Stone Roses lol.
He is technically superb and he has made that sound his own. Was really a joy to watch him play for 90 mins, basically standing right in front of him lol
HorseFeathersFur@reddit
Jonny greenwood
maccathesaint@reddit
He's really far down the list here for some reason! I do find people seem to have a weird irrational dislike for him as a guitarist, not really sure why. He's exceptionally talented at guitar (and probably most other instruments he decides to have a crack at lol)
No_Olive_2785@reddit
Yer man from dire straits
jungleddd@reddit
Please don’t compare musicians like this. There’s no such thing as ‘greatest’ when it comes to music. There are musicians who touch my soul but do nothing for other people. And that’s fine. We’re all different. This sort of debate always degenerates into either “who is the most famous guitarist?” or “I’m gonna be edgy and nominate someone really obscure” or “who can play the most notes per second?” Pointless.
RickJLeanPaw@reddit
True.
I’ve got as far down as this and, whilst there are tons of good ones from many genres, Julian Bream has been missed out. Criminal!
Coolnamesarehard@reddit
Exactly. Let's just ask have fun naming people whose work we've particularly enjoyed, without trying to rank someone no. 1. Some days, that's just a matter of what style you're in the mood for, or who you've ignored for a while.
VodkaMargarine@reddit
Slash is technically British
Astr0Scot@reddit
Then so is Angus Young
Impossible-Taro-2330@reddit
Sir Brian May, PhD.
So accomplished is may ways.
BusAdditional6518@reddit
I think Knopfler is the only one that I’d know it was him after about 3 notes. Not necessarily a good thing though.
AtomicMook@reddit
Andy Gill
TheLordMed@reddit
Robert Fripp
malcolmmonkey@reddit
Thank you. So overlooked!
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Another excellent choice. Such an original musical thinker.
IrukandjiPirate@reddit
Brian May
sparkielev@reddit
Angus young
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Controversial…
Pure-Boot3383@reddit
And also an Aussie, right?
BraveCourt9521@reddit
Born on Scotland.
Pure-Boot3383@reddit
Well, I learned that today. Cheers!
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
I think probably more Aussie than Scot tbf.
WearyLeopard85@reddit
John McLaughlin
temmoku@reddit
Alexis Korner. Grandfather of British blues
nattydread74@reddit
Isn’t Hendrix technically British….
FlorianBellicus@reddit
Hank Marvin. Helped pave the way.
PiotrGreenholz01@reddit
John McLaughlin
RRevvs@reddit
Mark Knopfler. No contest.
stereoworld@reddit
Neil Buchanan
GuyDLakes@reddit
Marseille were a great band. Saw them several times in the 80s
tplambert@reddit
I wasn’t a massive fan of his seminal works in the 90s. Art attack was a bit all over the place and I always wondered if he left so much toilet paper in fields and it was wet, then who was going to clean it up?
GuyDLakes@reddit
Jeff Beck
Cantdecide1207@reddit
I mean Slash is technically from Stoke so I'd say him.
And May in my opinion. He is much more gifted than he gets credit for.
Broonmoose@reddit
Add in Bernard Butler.
BraveCourt9521@reddit
For my choices ( in no particular order ) I'll go for Nick Drake , Mick Ronson, Eddie Phillips ( the Creation), Mick Green ( the Pirates), Big Jim Sullivan, Dave Edmunds, Alvin Lee ( Ten Years After ), Tony Hicks ( the Hollies ), and Nic Jones.
Coolnamesarehard@reddit
A bit obscure, but John Lees of Barclay James Harvest.
omgwtfnerdrage@reddit
Brian may for sure especially the early stuff
debrisaway@reddit (OP)
Brian Jones
Leytonstoner@reddit
Richard Thompson deserves a mench, too.
hoverside@reddit
He's my number one. Singularly distinctive style, incredibly fluid and expressive.
exkingzog@reddit
More than a mention. He’s got to be in the top 3
larusodren@reddit
Slash
TheGentlemanWombat@reddit
Stoke on Trent's finest!
BristowBailey@reddit
I'm going to say Jimi Hendrix because he lived in London for a while.
ResponsibleBend2195@reddit
Steve Marriot
Wonderful_Move_4619@reddit
Jeff beck, no contest.
BarkingMad14@reddit
Not sure about "all-time" but surprised you didn't mention Mark Knopfler. I think he is more talented than the other guitarists you mentioned.
TurnoverStreet128@reddit
100%
Familiar_Benefit_776@reddit
Definitely makes it look and sound effortless
LeTrolleur@reddit
Completely agree, there are plenty of videos of him playing with the focus on the guitar online, and every one of them is a treat.
eatseveryth1ng@reddit
Yeah it’s insane he’s not mentioned
lucylucylane@reddit
John squire
Organic_Mechanic_702@reddit
Gary Moore has to be right up there..
CappucinoCupcake@reddit
Gary Moore
Brian May
horrified_intrigued@reddit
Automatic update for Gary Moore. Just unbelievably underrated. Listened to his blues album on a phenomenal audio system in the late 80’s…was astonishing. Horribly underrated musician.
Ok-Application-8045@reddit
Johnny Marr should be on that list. He's a superb technical player, draws on a lot of different influences from US folk to African jazz, and was a massive influence on most post-80s guitar music.
RushBear@reddit
Greatest: David Gilmour. Best: Allan Holdsworth. Precise halfway point making them a contender for both: Jeff Beck.
Bitter-Policy4645@reddit
Lonnie Donegan,
Jimmy Cauty
Interceptor@reddit
I'm not a big fan, but you could make a good case for Alan Holdsworth.
For my money Ritchie Blackmore is up there as well.
ProfessionalVolume93@reddit
Alvin Lee
Any-Equal6791@reddit
Gregory, D.
ProfessionalVolume93@reddit
Allan Holdsworth
SirPooleyX@reddit
Jimmy Page and it's not even close.
EnbyArthropod@reddit
I just wish he hadn't raped teenagers.
rarararapido@reddit
Derek Bailey, Jonny Greenwood
Clapton is a cunt.
scarygirth@reddit
Allan Holdsworth perhaps, or maybe Guthrie Govan?
EnbyArthropod@reddit
Second Guthrie Govan, but if it's based also on success and crossing genres, he's going to sadly miss out.
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Yeah Guthrie Govan’s playing is fucking mind-blowing…
Artistic-Morning-659@reddit
Richard Thompson of Fairport Convention fame
shinymcshine1990@reddit
Alan Holdsworth
Dico80@reddit
Davy Graham and Bert Jansch need to get on the list.
fartingbeagle@reddit
Bert Jansch
dcmwmfinft@reddit
I think most of that list who are alive would still say the key one you’ve missed, which is Jeff Beck.
Arguably the most technically proficient is probably Knopfler but they’re all terrific in their own ways.
Pukit@reddit
Jimmy Page, Knopfler, Slash are likely my must favourable three with honourable mention to Bellamy.
thereverendpuck@reddit
How is Page so low?
A_finger_of_fudge@reddit
Alvin Lee is up there.
Japhet_Corncrake@reddit
Maurice Deebank.
SnaggingPlum@reddit
You've missed slash off the list
Jinkii5@reddit
Tony Iommi (Black Sabbath) created a whole genre of music (Heavy Metal) while missing the tips of the fingers on his left hand due to an accident while working a steel press, there is video of May professing that he wouldn't have been the guitarist he is without Iommi's inspiration.
Some first names would help, which Moore? Gary?
Jones? Laurence? Wizz? Dan? certainly not Brian right?
QuietVisit2042@reddit
Mick Taylor is the Stone's guitarist who should be mentioned
CrossCityLine@reddit
Iommi’s genius is that what he writes is incredibly simple, yet so iconic.
ProwerTheFox@reddit
Iommi not being mentioned more is criminal
Academic-Ad-3677@reddit
John McLaughlin
lubbockin@reddit
Julian Bream.
KFlaps@reddit
I'd like to throw Mick Ronson into the mix
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
One of his final performances was the guitar solo on The Wildhearts’ “My Baby is a Headfuck” lol. A true boss right up to the end.
KFlaps@reddit
Absolutely! One of my favourite songs of all time and actually how I heard of him originally lol (WH have been my favourite bands since I was a teen in the 90's so I was into them before I was into Bowie).
Did you ever see the behind the scenes take from the studio? I'm sure it was his actual last recorded performance
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Ahh no I haven’t seen this before! Cheers for recommendation. Was also a massive WH fan back in the ‘90s. My girlfriend did not appreciate me playing this song as I drove her around in my shitty, beaten up Peugeot 205 lol.
BiscuitBarrel179@reddit
Steve Harris, bass guitar is still a guitar and he plays that mf like its lead.
Englishbirdy@reddit
Robin Trower
Teaofthetime@reddit
Greatest isn't realistic but one of my favorites is David Gilmour.
bachatacam@reddit
Peter Green
Federal-Nectarine612@reddit
Nick Saloman aka The Bevis Frond.
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Don’t know about the greatest, but I’ve always loved Ace from Skunk Anansie. Not flashy, but love his sound.
Captain_Chappie@reddit
Graham Coxon.
Fragrant-Prize-966@reddit
Very original player…
Camarupim@reddit
Vini Reilly
MattheqAC@reddit
Dave Lister
Delicious_Link6703@reddit
Prince ?
Pier-Head@reddit
Not British
BedaFomm@reddit
You missed Peter Green.
nabster1973@reddit
How can Jeff Beck be omitted from the original list?
Agitated_Ad_361@reddit
I’ve no idea how you miss him off. Easily the best of the lot.
nabster1973@reddit
He was from near to where I live. A true local legend!
Agitated_Ad_361@reddit
Kent and Sussex borders?
nabster1973@reddit
That’s where he lived later on. He was from Wallington in Surrey (since 1965 it’s within the London Borough of Sutton in Greater London)
BusyBeeBridgette@reddit
May or Knopfler for me. Just so, incredibly, gifted.
Agitated_Ad_361@reddit
Jeff Beck.
Tall-Budget8130@reddit
It’s Johnny Marr. I’m not even a huge Smiths fan but he can do complex and intricate and have it never feel like fret wanking. Can also do simple stuff incredibly well.
sweetcomputerdragon@reddit
Bose and Fender are responsible for guitar gods.
JollyPhysics1394@reddit
Mike Oldfield is way underrated. He was a master of so many instruments, the guitar included.
Charming_Ad2323@reddit
Stewart
Willing-Confusion-56@reddit
Best guitarist I've seen live is Matt Bellamy from Muse. He's an absolute demon.
ElectricalEcho3429@reddit
Hank Marvin. Mark Knopfler.
No-Efficiency250@reddit
There is no conceivable way you can say that any one person is the greatest guitarist of all time. There are many amazing guitarists who are amazing for their own reasons, but that doesn't necessarily make them better than somebody else because it's not a level playing field.
Crazy_Breakfast_6327@reddit
Julian Bream??
ume-shu@reddit
Me. Please don't ask me to prove it.
VodkaMargarine@reddit
Depends how you measure greatness.
Best at guitar? Brian May, Clapton or Mark Knopfler
Most commercially successful? Ed Shearan or Slash
el_duderino_316@reddit
Nobody will ever agree on "best" so I'm going to answer a most underrated question instead.
The answer is Nick McCabe.
EUskeptik@reddit
Clapton.
Great guitarist, horrible guy.
-oo-
DeepNegotiation4542@reddit
John Martyn
https://youtu.be/pYLVM560Fok?si=VwmbknYks-0AQEP2
ShameSuperb7099@reddit
Hackett
FjortoftsAirplane@reddit
John McLaughlin or Allan Holdsworth. Unless you fear jazz, in which case Knopfler.
All-Hail-The-Ale@reddit
The guitarist i would pick as most technically proficient would be Guthrie Govan, but the one I enjoy listening to the most would be Eric Clapton. He (along with Sambora and Hendrix) was the reason I picked up a guitar in the first place.
Unique_Score_5874@reddit
slash is my favaourite british guitarist
Jeff beck is no1 stunning gutair player who kept evolving
deep1986@reddit
I think Matt Bellamy would be up there.
scarygirth@reddit
What makes you pick Matt Bellamy? I'd consider him more of a songwriter than a raw instrumentalist. As a guitarist he's pretty bang average, you'll find more impressive guitarist playing at open mic nights.
deep1986@reddit
He's incredibly talented on the guitar, he can do incredibly intricate riffs and his technical abilities are really good.
scarygirth@reddit
Fair enough, I've been fortunate to see muse a couple of times so I can absolutely attest to him being phenomenally talented, and you're right he has penned more than his share of iconic riffs!
deep1986@reddit
As an overall musician he'd be top tier, taking all his talents into account but as just a guitarist he'd be very high up but probably not the best.
1_2_3_4_5_6_7_7@reddit
Mick Taylor's pretty good too
thenorters@reddit
Guthrie Govan.
Gluebagger@reddit
https://youtu.be/WMdbsmuhLZ0?si=PMa2C_MvWBXrw993 you NEED to watch this OP
debrisaway@reddit (OP)
Ok sold
Gluebagger@reddit
What a performance.. live he is incredible!
-SG6000-@reddit
Without browsing albums/lists etc, the dude that first comes to mind for me at the moment is John McLaughlin.
I don't even know much of his solo or original stuff to be honest. His guest spots on various other people's work in the late 60s / early 70s is enough to make the cut.
borokish@reddit
How come no cunt has said David Gilmour?
elementarydrw@reddit
He's in the OP
borokish@reddit
Oh. Ffs. My bad.
Southern-Ad4477@reddit
Mark Knopfler
Infamous_Box3220@reddit
John Renbourn?
HMSWarspite03@reddit
Brian May has to be in the mix.
Zealousideal_Till683@reddit
It's Clapton, but Iommi is worth a mention.
dowker1@reddit
My old neighbor Tony Iomni deserves to be in consideration
Infamous_Box3220@reddit
No Éric Clapton?
46Vixen@reddit
Jimi Hendrix
withnailstail123@reddit
British ?
Oghamstoner@reddit
He was famous in Britain first, so definitely worth an attempt at claiming him.
dockers88@reddit
James Hendricks
46Vixen@reddit
Yeah, misread the title.
elementarydrw@reddit
Richie Blackmore is my favourite. With Gary Moore coming second. I like my guitarists Baroque influenced!
Gluebagger@reddit
Gary Moore said hi
Moore or Clapton
Lost-Droids@reddit
You missed slash from the list. Stokes own...
Merciless-Dom@reddit
Clapton or Page IMHO.
qualityvote2@reddit
Hello u/debrisaway! Welcome to r/AskABrit!
For other users, does this post fit the subreddit?
If so, upvote this comment!
Otherwise, downvote this comment!
And if it does break the rules, downvote this comment and report this post!