It’s my best friends birthday today I made her this

[-]

BernieF15@reddit

This doesn’t belong in this category. You hand made them.

[-]

Defiant_Welder_7897@reddit

Its not good but its not bad either. But the idea or feelings behind why you did this is great and that...is amazing.

[-]

smellyanthropologist@reddit

this is rly cute omg. I should do something like this for my friends bday ty for the inspo :)

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

No problem I hope it turns out well 😊

[-]

Don't worry, it always looks awful from the Creator's perspective, but when you friend will see this, she'll love it! Nobody is criticizing you about this, your cookies are good in the way they are, perhaps you can still cut them into any shape. Anyways, happy birthday to your friend!

[-]

HayYou_ItsMe@reddit

Well, . . . It’s the thought that counts. I am sure it was delicious.

[-]

International_Tree76@reddit

this is far more charming than a neatly manicured cake. i would LOVE this

[-]

Weary_Cantaloupe_647@reddit

It was made with love and it shows. Can't ask for anything else!

[-]

famamor@reddit

lol little under cooked but a nice gesture

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

We perfer undercooked cookies >:D

[-]

Better-Park8752@reddit

Happy birthday. Here’s your pan of turds.

Seriously though, you’re a nice friend. Good job.

[-]

galacticgumbo@reddit

I think this is adorable, and the gesture is so sweet. If you really want to give them some life, just buy one of those cookie icing tubes and neatly outline them. Either way, she’s gonna love them.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you I won’t be able to get any today but I’ll try to figure something out I’m sure she’s going to love it

[-]

recovery_room@reddit

She definitely will love it no matter how it looks.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She loved it 😊

[-]

Rubycon_@reddit

I would love these! You're so sweet for making them

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you :)

[-]

Coldhat@reddit

You could organize little chocolate chips like an outline as well! And melt them in the broiler for a second. <3

[-]

JediKrys@reddit

If you have icing sugar mix a bit with water to make icing texture and put it into a baggie. Cut a corner off the baggie and squeeze out the icing. Cut your corner small so you have a delicate line.

[-]

Twist_Ending03@reddit

Icing sugar? What's that?

[-]

Zizhou@reddit

Powdered sugar. Sugar that's extremely fine and often used to make icing on account of how easy it is to dissolve into a liquid.

[-]

Twist_Ending03@reddit

Oh. Icing made from powdered sugar is gross though

[-]

Zizhou@reddit

No argument here, but it is what it is.

[-]

galacticgumbo@reddit

This is genius. 💜

[-]

happyandveg@reddit

that’s so smart!!

[-]

Yaritzaf@reddit

They look delicious! You’re a great friend and she’s lucky to have you in her life. 🤍

[-]

Inevitable-Bed7487@reddit

I share a birthday with your friend but am older. This is the sweetest thing and y'all can enjoy with a glass of whatever milk you prefer. You are such a great friend 💜

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She loves cotton candy milk so I bet it went good with a tall glass of cotton candy milk also happy belated birthday

[-]

Inevitable-Bed7487@reddit

Thank you so much! Your friend has inspired me to find some cotton candy milk lol I've never had it!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

It’s amazing just check the expiration dates my other friend bought some at a gas station and it was three weeks expired 🤮

[-]

AnxietyBoy81@reddit

Cute, you’re a good friend.

[-]

Sallyfifth@reddit

Made with love is better than made for looks.

[-]

IzzyUS_champion_9483@reddit

It’s the thought that counts and it’s not bad

[-]

hiide0us@reddit

If someone did this for me i would cry, it's so cute😭

[-]

Efficient-Shape-1161@reddit

Remember it’s the thought that counts. And you put both love and thought into this. They are going to love it

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She definitely loved it especially with the strawberry cow plushie best combo

[-]

Good_Ad_5792@reddit

"AWWWWWWWW THANKS! I LOVE THE VAGUELY SUGGESTIVE COOKIES!!!" - me, genuinely, if I was your friend getting this

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

If she said this while I handed them over her parents my mom and me would all die of laughter 😂

[-]

Vegetable-Zone-1978@reddit

This is absolutely adorable!! The heart especially! Also, today is also my birthday so happy birthday to your friend, me, Doja Cat, and Kim K! :)

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Happy belated birthday I hope it was a great birthday

[-]

oldbagofmarbles@reddit

They might not look perfect but they scream made with love.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Ssshhh that’s my secret ingredient everything I make is made with love you can’t tell the others 🤫

[-]

CosmicEntrails@reddit

This is the only post in this sub that's made me smile. Your friend is lucky!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you :)

[-]

k1tt3nfangzz@reddit

This is so adorable and cute hahahah good job!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you 😊

[-]

American-pickle@reddit

I think they are super cute

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you she loved them as well

[-]

Brynosauce@reddit

It’s the thought that counts, massive W

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She loved them so it all worked out for the best

[-]

ieatair@reddit

or get the metal cookie cutter shape, put your dough and bake with it therefore it keeps its shape?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I don’t have anything like that anymore my mom gave all my baking stuff to my aunt so I had to make due with my hands and other baking methods it worked out though my bestie loves these

[-]

ieatair@reddit

hmmmm is it possible to buy new ones? and keep your molds in a safe place

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Not at the moment but it’s fine since she loved them so much :)

[-]

chickpealuvr420@reddit

I would bawl my eyes out if someone did this for me this is so cute

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you me and her have been friends for so long I want to make her 18th special even if it’s not a lot we didn’t get to graduate together since I went to a different high school but we graduated at the same time same day so it’s partially a graduation gift I love her so much she’s practically my sister

[-]

cakeanddiamond@reddit

did you give them to her yet? if so, what was her reaction? i think it’s so sweet you made this for her 😭 a true friend/loved one would be over the moon for any baked good. the first time i made an actual cake was for my husband’s birthday a couple years ago. it was so damn ugly but he LOVED it! it tasted good plus we got a little laugh out of it too. i felt that same disappointment you had bc i wanted it to be perfect, but he thought it was perfect bc i made it for him 🖤

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She loved them I also got her a cute weighted plushie it’s a strawberry cow so she was super duper happy

[-]

Primary_Fold5410@reddit

Me too! So sweet🌺

[-]

Moist_immortal@reddit

Those are THICC

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

😂😂😂

[-]

lobotomy4free@reddit

Awww🖤 I did the same for my anniversary with my bf and it means way more than just buying a random gift🖤🖤

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She loved the cookies plus I got her a weighted plushie it was a strawberry cow she’s very happy with the presents

[-]

langsamlourd@reddit

This is very sweet (no pun intended). It's also my mom's birthday, she just turned 78, so born 60 years before your friend.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Happy belated birthday to your mom I hope she had a great birthday

[-]

Scroatpig@reddit

You gotta embrace and play up how funny this is. I'd laugh so hard if a friend gave me this while laughing embarrassingly. Or, as another poster said, I think maybe they could be saved with icing or even frosting.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I didn’t put icing on it but the cookie broke a bit at the end of the day my bestie loved it I may have just been a bit emotional and hormonal lols I had cramps while making cookies and I was tired the cure for that was to eat some cookies and sit down 😅

[-]

EDM4LIFE25@reddit

My man is gonna rizz shorty rocks up 😂 nah for real though that’s what’s up, I appreciate you doing this!! Shows character

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

We grew up together she’s been my rock since childhood and one of the few friends I have left she deserves some cookies and possibly 18 billion dollars for sticking around so long I love her so much she’s practically my little sister

[-]

HoneyWyne@reddit

Aww, that's cute!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you :D

[-]

cyclorphan@reddit

The thought is there and these look luke very edible cookies. I suspect your friend really appreciates it.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She did she was so happy to get them

[-]

Prettyprettygewd@reddit

Your friend is 100❤️?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Lols she 18 just a few months younger than me on the 29th of October I’ll be half way to 19 years old

[-]

B0hnenkraut@reddit

I think it's the effort you put in that counts. And as fucked up as they look I'm pretty sure they taste delicious

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

They really did I made mini cookies for my household and they were devoured yesterday everybody loved them even my bestie

[-]

lemothelemon@reddit

I'm in my mid 30s but I would still line these up like a dick and balls shooting a heart, laugh about it for far too long, then eat em Coz they looks scrumptious

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I wonder if she did that on her birthday but she loved them

[-]

TypeOpostive@reddit

I love it

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

My bestie loved them too :D

[-]

American_Greed@reddit

It's the thought that counts, right folks?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Yep and she loved them :D

[-]

amberr_starr@reddit

Dih and ballz

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

😭

[-]

thatdudejustin@reddit

This is so nice and heartwarming! You’re an amazing friend

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you she loved them as well

[-]

ledwilliums@reddit

You are a good friend and not a very skilled baker.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Heh yeah I get that now 😅

[-]

the_eggsecutioner@reddit

you did a good job! if you think the shapes are too misshapen (i would disagree tbh i think they're fine) you can always just cut them finer with a knife :) <3

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

The cookie keeps breaking and it’s making me sad the cookie is soft and perfectly baked just it won’t hold together enough :(

[-]

pmgrn8@reddit

Freeze it before putting it in the oven to retain shape.

[-]

Tupotosti@reddit

Apparently less butter and more eggs also prevents the cookies from expanding so much.

[-]

pmgrn8@reddit

That makes sense. Butter is soft with a relatively low melting point and eggs are a binding agent

[-]

SpiritedPark4511@reddit

When my best friend was in hospital on her birthday, I took her a chocolate cake i’d made. I had to take it on the train, tube and bus, it took me 2 hours and I dropped it. It was ruined. But you should have seen her face when I showed her; the effort meant everything. She ate a slice and threw it up and the whole occasion is one of our core memories. The effort and thought is what means the world, hopefully it’ll give you a giggle and probably will also still be yummy.

[-]

Internal-Computer388@reddit

I was going to comment that if she truly is OPs bestie, they will laugh over it, enjoy the cookies together and have a core memory to talk about with others whenever they get together.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

That’s such a sweet story

[-]

Dangerous-Courage412@reddit

😂 how i didnt see an 18 and saw something phallic

[-]

Miagggo@reddit

Ugly or not, the thought behind it is what counts. When I lost my mom my friends made a cake for me, it was terrible, and then we watched the worst movies made by mankind. Also bad, but still I love this memory because it made me laugh in a very dark time for me. I hope your friend will remember these atrocious cookies the same way I remember this cake

[-]

Jumpy-Investment-988@reddit

Not bad.

[-]

alamakjan@reddit

They’re in no way shitty, they’re cookies!

[-]

ImpressiveScreen5017@reddit

If they are soft baked maybe you could cut a hole in each of the round cookies representing the number 18.

[-]

kitkat1224666@reddit

This so so cute, it might look goofy, but in the absolute best way possible. I would be so happy I would probably cry if a friend gave me cookies like these 😭

[-]

blackflameandcocaine@reddit

I honestly don’t see a problem with them at all! They look amazing and I bet they taste fab too. She’s lucky to have you as her friend 🥺🩷

[-]

notoneforlies@reddit

wait this is actually so cute i love it😭 the little heart too this is genuinely the sweetest

[-]

EvelcyclopS@reddit

How be long ago were you friend zoned?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Does it really look like something you would give to someone who friend zoned you :(

[-]

EvelcyclopS@reddit

Ehh. Yea?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Oh ;(

[-]

EvelcyclopS@reddit

Not to be a creeper, but I like your art way more than your cookies :)

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you I don’t draw much anymore but when I do it’s fun :)

[-]

nickythiccc@reddit

Looks like a dick and buttcheeks

[-]

leavethisearth@reddit

People always forget that cookies spread out by twice their original size when baking.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I knew it would expand but not by so much :(

[-]

leavethisearth@reddit

Now you know! Don’t worry though, it didn’t turn out as you expected but it‘s still a very nice gesture and your friend will appreciate it very much.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

She loved it and she’s so happy plus she got a plushie that she loves

[-]

Jipijur@reddit

They look good enough to eat lol I'd be so happy someone thought about me

[-]

symmetra@reddit

This is so sweet but so funny lol

[-]

Graverobber13@reddit

I would be SO happy to get this! Mooshy chocolate chip cookies are the best, PLUS the thought that went into them makes them a million times better!

[-]

schlappydappy@reddit

Icing on top would make this better

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I’m out of icing and I won’t be able to run to the store to get any go back to my house then come back and go to her house

[-]

bethholler@reddit

If you have powdered sugar and milk you can use that to make icing.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I’m out of powdered sugar sadly :(

[-]

Xpertdominator@reddit

If you are desperate you can blend regular sugar to make powdered sugar

[-]

defnotacyborg@reddit

Is that how powdered sugar actually made 🤯

[-]

data_wrangler@reddit

Most have a little cornstarch, too, which helps keep the sugar from clumping and also helps to thicken icing.

[-]

theavocadolady@reddit

Just wanted to say that I think they're awesome without the icing. The thought, gesture and effort are beyond sweet (Also, I'm biased because I don't like icing on cookies). But I'd be beyond thrilled and touched if a friend did this for me.

[-]

CrestfallenLord@reddit

Hahahaha

[-]

spidermaniscool24@reddit

If my friend gave me this I'd love it. There's a certain charm when it's not perfect and noticeably homemade, means you went out of your comfort zone to do something nice for your friend.

[-]

Psychological-Lynx-3@reddit

Its nice that you did this . They will definitely appreciate it and get a good laugh while there at it lol. I know i would !

[-]

CosmicLightning@reddit

I can see why you seem freaked out by honestly it's not that bad. If you ever try this again, make sure to use a metal cookie cutter(shape and keep it in while baking. Pretty thats how most people do it. Or make stents out if tinfoil and make your shape with tinfoil then put your cookie dough in it. Eitgerway keeps cookie from spreading and keeps it looking like the way you want.

[]

Eitherway, she gonna love it no matter what as its the thought that counts.

[]

I'm 35 and I only had like 5 birthdays that actually meant to me. Usually my bdays and holidays turn out bad.

[]

So have a meowtastic week and eat extraordinary foods...you git thus

[-]

RunThruPlayLand@reddit

I'm gonna cry this is so sweet 🥺

[-]

MeepMeepBologna@reddit

They are PERFECT!

[-]

ParkerFree@reddit

Not shitty at all.

[-]

aaaahhatelife@reddit

Foil would do the trick next time, you can make a wall or whatever so the cookie doesn’t spread

[-]

NoMove7162@reddit

This is actually lovely, and I'm sure tasty too.

[-]

ChewbaccaOnFries@reddit

Fwiw I could tell what they were on first glance 🤷‍♂️

Besides it's the gesture, the effort and the thought that makes this a win.

She's lucky to have a friend like you!

[-]

spiritus-mortis@reddit

Nothing shitty about this. In fact, its beautiful in all regards.

[-]

theragu40@reddit

/r/lostredditors

I have smashed cookies that looked MUCH worse than this. These look actually good, they're not even on the spectrum of badness at all.

[-]

Inevitable_Vast_8555@reddit

I should call him

Really though, they look delicious. Chocolate chip cookies just don't hold their shape when you mold them, so that's why they came out that way. They are recognizable enough as 18 and a heart though.

[-]

Sortanotperfect@reddit

You're awesome.

[-]

Sea-Independent-726@reddit

This is the cutest thing i seen today

[-]

ShadowDarkraven27@reddit

i miss when i was onesnowman years old

[-]

GapDragon@reddit

This is chocolate chip cookies, isn't it??? It is in NO way shitty!!

[-]

haikusbot@reddit

This is chocolate

Chip cookies, isn't it??? It

Is in NO way shitty!!

- GapDragon

^(I detect haikus. And sometimes, successfully.) ^Learn more about me.

^(Opt out of replies: "haikusbot opt out" | Delete my comment: "haikusbot delete")

[-]

GapDragon@reddit

Wonky breaking of my sentences, but I'll take it!!

[-]

Illustrious-Bake3878@reddit

You are a good friend. Seriously. It looks terrible, but I’m sure it will taste good and honestly I hope it’s something you and your friend can laugh about together. It’s a good story.

[-]

ThatMBR42@reddit

No way I'd call that botched. I definitely agree with the idea of outlining the numbers, but they come across just fine (especially if you were to use a cookie cutter to punch out the holes in the 8). The heart shaped one turned out perfectly. IMO it's less about the result than it is about the gesture.

[-]

cadaverdelicado@reddit

These are adorable, and they look so tasty too. Could I perchance get the recipe? I’ve been experimenting with baking lately and just can’t seem to get my cookies right.

[-]

umsamanthapleasekthx@reddit

I think from how you describe your friendship that you two will be cackling about these for years to come! I love this so much, you really did a good thing here!

[-]

kb-g@reddit

Wrong sub my friend! I’d be thrilled to get this from someone I cared about for my birthday! Looks delicious and clearly made with love!

[-]

nojunkpunk@reddit

You ARE a best friend !

[-]

medicated_in_PHL@reddit

I think it looks awesome, and I’d be psyched to get this.

[-]

viavxy@reddit

dont mean to be a hater but why no holes for the 8? pissing me off bruh

happy birthday to ya friend

[-]

ortiz13192@reddit

Could have come out looking like twigs and berries, this looks awesome!

[-]

unhappy-rat@reddit

Adopt me as your friend

[-]

Practical_Ad_6025@reddit

Those are beautiful 10”10

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you I’m not a fan of them but I hope my bestie loves it

[-]

SuperSpecialUser@reddit

You two can have a laugh together about how hard you tried. (By the way, it's faaaar better than some I've seen.) This will be one that the two of you smile about when you're still friends at 70. :)

[-]

Poultryman025@reddit

Don't worry I just celebrated my gf's birthday around a week or so ago and I baked the birthday cake for her. Ive never baked before and the frosting made the cake look like a brick. It tasted great though just like your cookie lol.

[-]

speed721@reddit

This is wonderful!

[-]

lvl10burrito@reddit

penis and boobs

[-]

permalink_save@reddit

I saw deconstructed dickbutt

[-]

thefoodiedentist@reddit

Also works if u put em together

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

😂😂😂

[-]

BunnyLady91@reddit

That’s perfect for someone who doesn’t like cake!

[-]

tuck78@reddit

looks fine, not shittyfoodporn

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

It looks like a rocket and melons

[-]

AdExcellent1745@reddit

these are perfect, seriously.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you 🥹

[-]

soulcaptain@reddit

Why did you not cut holes in the 8?

[-]

Ok_Purchase_9551@reddit

You could always trim them so they look more defined but if not, they still look comprehensible

[-]

realjohnny555@reddit

Put some frosting over them.

[-]

sjm294@reddit

That’s really special and thoughtful 👏🏻

[-]

LilArtsyCreature@reddit

Even though they didn't turn out how you wanted them to, as cheesy as the saying goes "It's the thought that counts" Your friend will be happy you made such a delicious, heartfelt, and thoughtful gift for her 18th birthday. One day, you'll both hopefully look back on these memories and laugh together 😊

[-]

darioblaze@reddit

Wrong sub

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

That’s actually so sweet these cookies aren’t perfect but to be told they look to good to be here is really sweet 🥹

[-]

darioblaze@reddit

You did a really sweet thing for your friend in a world on fire, nothing about that is shitty lol

[-]

unnaturalcreatures@reddit

THE HEART IS SO PERFECT 😭😭😭😭😭

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you :DDD

[-]

PugLuVR06@reddit

I snort-laughed at the 2nd Pic. Thank you! I needed that today!

[-]

Ok_Host_5860@reddit

Don’t think this is bad, honestly.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I got told it looks likes a rocket and melons

[-]

Doglover4561@reddit

I’m sure she’s gonna love it regardless

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I hope so :)

[-]

exquisite_conundrum@reddit

I love thse cookies. You did a great job!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you :D

[-]

Spirited_Glass7407@reddit

Sheesh. I'd be fired up if my friend made that for me. I think it looks dope.

[-]

AkuTheNiceGuy@reddit

You tried💯❤️

[-]

FalynorSoren@reddit

The thought and love behind something like this means everything. The finished product doesn't have to be visually perfect for it to be a perfect gesture. This is perfect exactly the way it is, and I'll bet you that she'll wholeheartedly agree.

Bet they're delicious, too.

[-]

justcatt@reddit

would gobble, you're an amazing friend.

[-]

Gpeanut2009pupper@reddit

omg i would cry tears of laughter and joy if i got these for my birthday HSJFJJSJF i would LOVE these

[-]

Optimal-Dragonfly572@reddit

i’m not sure if this could break the cookie but if you have a small, circle cookie cutter i think that would make the 8 look a little better! the 1 looks pretty good as is

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Sadly yes it would break the cookie I don’t have a bottle cap to cut the circle too :(

[-]

SchoolyXP@reddit

If you turn the 1, it looks like something else

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Sadly your not the first to say this

[-]

Shoddy_Asparagus_503@reddit

I think this turned out awesome, and I’d be so grateful that someone was thinking about me! You’re a really good friend OP, hope you two got to enjoy the cookies, bet they were great

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I’m actually going to ding dong ditch the cookies at her house then tell her I left them there the bag is labeled with our names on it

[-]

Sullys_mama19@reddit

Use a bottle cap to cut circles out of the 8! Honestly it’s so cute as it is, it reads as 18! Such a nice gesture. You’re a great friend

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

The cookies hardened already there baked perfectly but it’s at a stage that makes it’s too risky to alter it

[-]

esotericdiarist@reddit

Actually came out pretty good! Well done!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you the cookies expanded more than I wanted but I hope she likes them

[-]

coppockm56@reddit

Really, when you consider the amount of love that's baked into these cookies, they're infinitely more enriching for your friend than any professionally crafted cookies you might have bought her.

[-]

Fragrant_Peanut_9661@reddit

Perfect!!! Made with l❤️ve!

[-]

cynndical@reddit

Are you kidding me?! I'd be over the moon if someone went to the trouble of doing something like that for me. 🥰 I'm 59 and no one has ever made me a birthday treat. I'm serious. It looks like cookies! Yummy, chocolatey, scrumptious, homemade deliciousness 😋. You did great and you seem like a sweetheart... I just know your friend will love it!

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

That’s really sad I hope for your next birthday you get a birthday treat thank you for being so kind

[-]

SmartWonderWoman@reddit

You’re a kind friend!

[-]

WeirdSysAdmin@reddit

Showing off how good of a friend you are.

gif

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I love her so much we’ve been friends for almost our whole lives

[-]

Redbacontruck@reddit

That’s so sweet you made a homemade effect well done :)

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thanks you I’m disappointed in how it looks but I hope she likes the cookies I worked hard and the mini cookies that I made for my house are delicious

[-]

canolafly@reddit

Everyone is right, they are so sweet. You can always try to fetch a tube of icing that is white (or a light color) and try to outline the numbers and heart to make it look for sure that the plan is nailed. Cookies spread 🤷‍♀️

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I wish I could do that but I’m out of icing and have no materials to make the icing

[-]

MerryBerryMudskipper@reddit

Wait this is adorable though

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I’m not a fan of how it turned out but I’m still somewhat new at baking

[-]

MerryBerryMudskipper@reddit

Stop hating on yourself no one shoots out the womb as Mary berry. Not even Mary berry did. You did a good job 💖

[-]

Emergency_Comfort_92@reddit

You're a good friend.🙂

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you :)

[-]

Naive-Musician2006@reddit

Your friend will love it

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I hope so :)

[-]

winelover08816@reddit

New Bad Dragon toys?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Okay that’s funny now

[-]

bookkinkster@reddit

This is hilarious. Go on with your culinary skills! I'd love it!

[-]

degjo@reddit

She's turning 1 fat kid?

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

😭

[-]

nympgirlyy@reddit

yay happy birthday

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

I’ll tell her you said happy birthday:)

[-]

poindxtrwv@reddit

I see no problem with these and would happily demolish them with a tall glass of milk.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

My dad loves them and my mom told me to get it out of her sight (the smaller cookies I made two dozen cookies most are for my boyfriend) she wants to eat one so bad but she’s on a diet so I think that means they look and taste even better

[-]

shelleylove@reddit

They’re awesome and totally recognizable! What a sweet gesture.

[-]

Sleepy_Sheepz@reddit (OP)

Thank you

[-]

PotatoCooks@reddit

Id be happy to just get a cookie regardless of the looks

[-]

Kitsupire@reddit

naaaaaah it's cute.

[-]

Gogobunny2500@reddit

I think it looks good tbh lol I'd eat this and be so grateful someone did this for me! Usually these things look worse baked but yours looks better baked, especially the 1.

Less cookie dough next time maybe? But idk this is cute as is. I love the heart

[-]