Why do people choose to live in the Gulf Coast region when they risk having their houses completely destroyed every year during hurricane season?
Posted by Stormcrown76@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 110 comments
SquashDue502@reddit
America is very natural disaster prone everywhere, she’s a wild wild place lol
Move inland: tornadoes
Move west: wildfires, mudslides
Move north: blistering cold and scorching summers, also tornadoes again and dumping snow
Move to desert: probably the safest weather-wise but danger replaced by potential to be murdered by a plethora of venomous snakes lizards and spiders, or step on a cactus, also no water.
JudgeWhoOverrules@reddit
Ironically the biggest disaster risk in deserts is floods. Hard sunbaked clay dirt doesn't let water seep in easily so it flows on the surface.
SquashDue502@reddit
Yep that’s why California also had mudslide threats. Dry dirt does not sop up moisture well.
JudgeWhoOverrules@reddit
That's not really a case of desert stuff but of post-burn landslide risk. Fires also burn out the root systems that hold soil in place.
rufflesinc@reddit
Not true
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0063/3818/3250/files/Natural-Disaster-Map-USA_large.png?v=1581537503
Popular-Local8354@reddit
This just kind of proves his point
rufflesinc@reddit
Michigan
Popular-Local8354@reddit
A single state
rufflesinc@reddit
A state with a major international airport, a top public university and more coastline than Florida
Popular-Local8354@reddit
And?
Adjective-Noun123456@reddit
Hey hey hey, they have one major international airport and a college! Michigan is essentially Elysium or Arcadia.
rufflesinc@reddit
Houses in top school district for under $300k
Popular-Local8354@reddit
I’m really not seeing how this is relevant to a discussion on natural disasters but OK
cbrooks97@reddit
The "white" areas aren't trouble-free, just lower probability. I know those areas in Texas take a real pounding every now and then. The horrible flood that killed all those kids recently? White area.
rufflesinc@reddit
Thats just because texass sucks ss
cbrooks97@reddit
Yes. Texas has floods because they "suck". Does everyone else who has floods have floods because they "suck"?
Also, are you 12?
rufflesinc@reddit
No, Texas just plain sucks
Apocalyptic0n3@reddit
What is this supposed to be showing? Michigan gets quite a few tornadoes, for example, but this map doesn't show it. It also doesn't seem to count extreme heat/cold or drought/water scarcity at all and probably should.
Salty-Ambition9733@reddit
One year a tornado whipped through Washington, DC. It killed 2 or 3 people.
The same year part of Georgetown was flooded. No electricity for 2 weeks.
Shit happen where you least expect it.
redditsuckspokey1@reddit
Soth Alaska can be pretty mild during summer time. Went through Sitka, Juneau and a couple other cities during last week of May and it was in the 60's F.
TheRealHowardStern@reddit
Alaska and west coast, also Earthquakes
Scrappy_The_Crow@reddit
New Madrid Fault: "I'mma keep quiet for over 200 years, but..."
SquashDue502@reddit
And sometimes also east coast but not likely to destroy your home, only scare you 😂
TheRealHowardStern@reddit
As someone from Washington State now living in the USVI, hurricanes are definitely something that is a real threat, but you can prepare and have time to plan and build certain ways. I considered the risk before moving here and historically this place gets hit hard every few decades. But it’s not like every hurricane that happens is close to here, see the gulf and east coast. The electrical infrastructure here is terrible tho. Power goes out on normal days. So many people have solar, tesla batteries, generators, starlink etc. Building correctly goes a long ways, but obviously there’s big risks.
Having experienced several earthquakes growing up, none thankfully that bad, but enough to knock things off walls and have the power go out, the total uncertainty of when the BIG hits honestly wore on me in ways. Like being stuck in traffic on an old overpass, these huge concrete stairwells in a school I was attending, I would have moments like wtf I’m dead if it happens now. I think most big buildings and infrastructure is engineered to withstand a big earthquakes, but that fault line at some point will likely change the entire coastline. And it seems like experts say it could be 100 years or 10,000 years but it’s happens and it could happen this year because it’s 700 years overdue for a big one. Just the total uncertainty is why I’d have brief moments of oh shit I hope it doesn’t happen now. At least with hurricanes you monitor the wave formation off the coast of Africa and have a week or so to prepare. And or get off island if you have the means and opportunity.
memes_are_facts@reddit
Last line made me lol
DaughterofTarot@reddit
Well there's these things called Ports, that generate a lot of jobs. And the fact that a lot of people take that risk, to live close to their jobs, is why the rest of the US can get imported goods.
Oh, and this black stuff, sort of sticky and fluid. It's basically what you'd call car food I guess ... lots of that on the coast, takes a few people to get it out now and then.
Deolater@reddit
Let's just move the ports away from the ocean so it won't be a problem!
baalroo@reddit
Maybe we could replace the boats with some other type of transportation? Possibly some sort of port that utilities air transport?
DaughterofTarot@reddit
You’d pay for it. Shipping by plane is at least 3 xs more expensive and produces more carbon emissions as well.
baalroo@reddit
Well yeah, I was just making a dumb air-port joke.
DaughterofTarot@reddit
Sorry. I’m the stodgy audience member I guess wasn’t trustworthy enough. 😳
tsukiii@reddit
Genius!
Tommy_Wisseau_burner@reddit
Weather and beach
cdb03b@reddit
Every region of the US has threat of some kind of natural disaster. Be it Hurricane, Wild Fire, Floods, Earthquake, Volcano, Tornado, or Blizzards. Many have several.
Odds of having your home destroyed by them are low, and you purchase insurance to cover it.
TheBimpo@reddit
Why do people live in Japan? An earthquake could happen at any time.
Phonic-Frog@reddit
Hot_Tower9293@reddit
Popular-Local8354@reddit
I’m sure this comment isn’t racially motivated at all
Hot_Tower9293@reddit
What does the natural geography of areas have to do with race? You are obviously a genius.
Popular-Local8354@reddit
I just don’t think it’s a coincidence that Reddit very frequently like to dunk on the Gulf Coast, and the South as a whole, when it’s one of the blackest regions of the country.
Hot_Tower9293@reddit
Try again, the political criticism of the south on Reddit has more to do with the political leanings of white people living there.
The problem with that area is that it is very hot, humid, flat and yes, the backward cultural and political trends. None of these have anything to do with black people.
Popular-Local8354@reddit
Again with the veiled racism? Calling a culture, that is probably the most African – influenced culture in America, backwards? Just stop digging yourself into a hole.
Hot_Tower9293@reddit
You are truly an imbecile. The culture I am clearly referring to is MAGA culture that is predominantly white. I don't know how I can spell it out more clearly so that someone of your capacity can understand.
Popular-Local8354@reddit
“MAGA culture” isn’t a thing.
Hell, Donald Trump’s base is arguably disaffected white working class voters in the Midwest. You’re not only racist, you’re politically wrong.
Hot_Tower9293@reddit
lol thanks for proving my point
swedusa@reddit
To add to point 3, at least we know a hurricane is coming several days in advance and can prepare and evacuate if needed.
Salty-Ambition9733@reddit
Job brings them to that area
Good place to retire for multiple reasons
rufflesinc@reddit
Seems like when youre one foot in the grave, having to evac is a pain
GreenIll3610@reddit
That’s why a lot of the times they just dont.
benkatejackwin@reddit
Jaymac720@reddit
The house I live in was destroyed when the levees failed after Katrina. That’s incredibly unlikely to happen again though
travelinmatt76@reddit
There are houses in my town that were built in 1910 and are still standing
redditsuckspokey1@reddit
Ask the same question towards people who live in California/Los Angeles.
dr_strange-love@reddit
"Why do people choose to live in the northern region when they risk freezing to death every year during winter season?"
amcjkelly@reddit
The same reason people live in Tornado Ally. The scale of these regions is so vast that your chance in one small area even over a 20 year period is very low.
You are at risk in almost any section of the US. One of the worst Hurricanes in the 30s was in New England.
People just don't remember.
DJPaige01@reddit
There are few areas in the United States that is not prone to natural disasters. The entire east coast and gulf coast are subject to hurricanes. Hawaii has wild fires and volcanos, Alaska and the west coast are prone to earth quakes and tsunamis. The west and mid west are prone to tornados. California has wildfires and mudslides. Many states across the country are prone to flooding. Nevada has earth quakes. There is nowhere that is safe.
Adjective-Noun123456@reddit
Why would you choose to live anywhere since everywhere gets a natural disaster of some for or another?
rufflesinc@reddit
Not truehttps://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0063/3818/3250/files/Natural-Disaster-Map-USA_large.png?v=1581537503
Internetchristian@reddit
So, everyone should move to Michigan 🤷♂️
rufflesinc@reddit
Bingo
butt_honcho@reddit
That map isn't accurate. I live in a white area that absolutely gets tornadoes.
Wallawalla1522@reddit
This map was created by someone from Michigan
illegal_miles@reddit
More likely someone who hates Michigan and wants to ruin it by flooding it with Californians, Texans, and Floridians.
FerricDonkey@reddit
I mean, yes but actually no. The risk of being affected by a disaster varies by location, and is generally higher on the coast than elsewhere.
Maleficent-Hawk-318@reddit
My sister and her husband willingly moved to a hurricane-prone area, and this was part of their logic. My sister grew up in an area prone to wildfires and severe drought, her husband grew up in an area prone to wildfires and earthquakes, and they met while living in an area prone to tornadoes. Hurricanes don't really seem that scary when you're used to stuff like that. I mean, honestly I've never lived in a hurricane-prone area, but they actually seem a lot less scary to me than tornadoes and wildfires (I've also lived in areas prone to those) because you usually have a lot more warning.
The other reasons they moved there are the same reasons anyone moves anywhere--it was affordable, they liked the culture and amenities, and it generally fit their lifestyle and budget.
MrLongWalk@reddit
Why do people live in Italy when they risk having their houses completely destroyed by earthquakes every day?
Vachic09@reddit
Some of them have families that have been down there for generations, so it's home. You also have some areas on the gulf that actually don't get hit very often. Some houses in hurricane heavy areas can withstand up to about a category 3 as long as it doesn't move too slow or it's not a direct hit. You just live with the possibility that this might be your year.
Charlesinrichmond@reddit
risk isn't that high
Ryuukashi@reddit
Everywhere has natural disasters. If not hurricanes, then tornadoes, earthquakes, wildfires, floods, derechos, etc
rufflesinc@reddit
This is not true
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0063/3818/3250/files/Natural-Disaster-Map-USA_large.png?v=1581537503
Ryuukashi@reddit
Lmao at the tornado and flood maps specifically. I have been under tornado warnings multiple times outside that area, and the entire coast floods more each year. Add snowstorms to everywhere north of Florida, too. Lmfao
Horizontal_Bob@reddit
Why do people get in a car knowing they might die in a car crash?
Why do people get in a plane knowing it might fall out of the sky?
Why do people drink alcohol knowing it’s slowly killing them?
Everything can kill you
Why stress it
Silly-Resist8306@reddit
For the same reason people live with mudslides and fires in California or tornados in Oklahoma. The odds are it won’t happen to me and if it does, we will deal with it.
JayOwest@reddit
It’s no different from people who live in the Great Plains knowing there are tornadoes or in California despite the earthquakes and wildfires. Every place has its risks, people either take their chances, or if they already live there, they stay because it’s home.
There's this famous Hellen Keller quote that I love and it applies to this question: “Security is mostly a superstition. It does not exist in nature, nor do the children of men as a whole experience it. Avoiding danger is no safer in the long run than outright exposure. Life is either a daring adventure or nothing.”
BUBBAH-BAYUTH@reddit
I mean why do people live in California what with all the fires and earthquakes
Majestic-Macaron6019@reddit
I grew up on the Gulf Coast. Unless you're on the water or in a flood zone, the risk of a well-built house getting damaged or destroyed in a hurricane is relatively low. In all of the bad storms of my childhood and teenage years, Katrina was the worst, and it just stripped some shingles off the roof (fixable with a few hours of work).
nakedonmygoat@reddit
You're way overestimating the risk. This year not a single hurricane hit the Gulf Coast. We didn't even get a tropical storm.
I've been through two direct hits, a close sideswipe, and a few tropical storms (including downgraded hurricanes) that parked and dumped water. It was 25 years between the first direct hit and the second. The direct hits and sideswipe didn't destroy houses where I live, 50 miles inland, it just left us without power for a bit. Nothing a generator or a couple of power stations can't handle.
Tropical storms, which include downgraded hurricanes that hit elsewhere, tend to park and dump water. But my home has never flooded and it was built in 1955, long before I was born. I have a plan for if I get notice that this is a concern, though. It's not like flash floods along a river where you have only a few hours' warning. If you're paying attention, you know well in advance that you may need to activate Plan B or C.
I find midwest tornadoes to be far scarier. You know for days in advance if a hurricane is coming and you can make plans. Not so for a tornado. There's no warning for earthquakes or wildfires either. And I hate the cold, so Nor'easters and blizzards are a definite "no can do" for me.
For now, I'll stick with the devil I know. At least he announces when he'll come calling.
BouncingSphinx@reddit
Why do people choose to live in California when they risk having their houses completely destroyed every year during wildfire season?
Why do people choose to live in Oklahoma when they risk having their houses completely destroyed every year during tornado season?
Why do people choose to live anywhere when they risk having their houses completely destroyed every year during [yearly natural disaster] season?
nghtmrbae@reddit
We inherited a house here. The real question is why do people choose to live here even though the air is made of boiling water.
alicat777777@reddit
Being from the Midwest, I wonder that too. I guess the benefits outweigh the risks.
simpleme2@reddit
In the Midwest, we have tornadoes, derechos, and hail, or floods
benkatejackwin@reddit
But people would ask why you would live in the Midwest when a tornado could take out your house. It's possible, but unlikely.
Now, buying a house that is literally on stilts right on the ocean on the Gulf Coast? Pretty clearly a bad idea.
runz_with_waves@reddit
- 35+ feet above sea level.
- Cinderblock Construction & Hurricane Rated Roof
- No large trees on property/within close proximity to structures.
- Stand alone generator with tesla battery backup.
- 2 Months food/water supply.
Gamer_Grease@reddit
This is a very valid question and those downvoting you are wrong. The Gulf Coast has increased in population drastically over the past 10 years. It's not just people who live there because their ancestors lived there.
Round-Lab73@reddit
It's one of the poorest parts of the country and moving is very expensive. Most people don't choose where they live, at least not in a vacuum. I can definitely understand being reluctant to leave my home, my job, and my community. And by golly, some people might actually like it there! I like it here in New England but it's not exactly a risk-free paradise either
johannaishere@reddit
Lots of people don’t move from where they grew up because that’s where their people and community are. Moving where you don’t know anyone is often impossible, lonely, and expensive. People who say “Just move” discount that it’s hard to find a job anywhere let alone where it’s “affordable” or “safe” when you could just stay where you know you have community to support you.
Penguin_Life_Now@reddit
You could ask the same thing about people choosing to live in California where their houses might get destroyed by Earthquakes, Mudslides, or Fires.
rufflesinc@reddit
https://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0063/3818/3250/files/Natural-Disaster-Map-USA_large.png?v=1581537503
GreenIll3610@reddit
Do people really choose where to live ?
2NE1Amiibo@reddit
For the most part, if I stayed where I was born I wouldnt be making half the money, seen half the places or met half the people I did now. I learned so much from moving.
GreenIll3610@reddit
Where did you move
GermanMuffin@reddit
Across the street
beyondplutola@reddit
Some of your ancestors did. It’s up to you if you want to accept their decision.
clap_yo_hands@reddit
I grew up on the coast. I inherited my parent’s house when they passed away. Moving is expensive, houses are expensive, everything is expensive. I don’t particularly love living here but staying here gives my children the stability of a house. We have a yard, we have a garden, we have awesome neighbors, we have a wonderful school district. My husband has a good job. We are thriving here even though we don’t love the politics of our region or the climate. When I do a pro and con list I have way more pros than cons.
BigBrainMonkey@reddit
Others have pointed out why people there remain. To spin it to play on the word “choose” of people that move in and/or have options to leave but don’t. I’d argue it is a deep almost certainly not articulated love of socialism. Living in the benefits of great weather, relatively lower cost of living and modern convenience, while spreading risks and costs across insurance and public assistance that reduces the direct financial impact of disasters even if it doesn’t anything to help the emotional and nostalgic cost of damages.
Genius-Imbecile@reddit
The risk of damage from a storm is low.
The chance of having great neighbors who actuallyvknow and look out for each other is high for where I lived. The great food and culture. The no damn snow most winters is a plus.
imissher4ever@reddit
Chances of getting your house destroyed by a Hurricane are extremely low.
Source: I grew up on an island on the Texas Gulf Coast. I still live on the Texas Gulf Coast. In my lifetime (50+ years) we’ve had 3-4 devastating hurricanes. None of which destroyed any of the houses I lived in.
We didn’t get a single storm this year. Not even a threat of a weak tropical storm.
The media will ALWAYS show you the extreme of every situation.
beyondplutola@reddit
People risk death every time they fly or drive. You do it anyway because of the probabilities are in favor of not dying.
FivebyFive@reddit
Do you GENUINELY believe people's houses are being destroyed and rebuilt year after year?
virtual_human@reddit
I lived in south Louisiana for 22 years and my house was never destroyed by a hurricane. Not every house gets destroyed.
Jaymac720@reddit
The house I live in now was destroyed 20 years ago, but the chances of that happening again is slim to nil. With the reconstructed levees, more pump stations, and Entergy fortifying the grid, that risk is decreasing every day
Quenzayne@reddit
The risk of your house being destroyed is extremely low. Hurricanes aren’t as common as people think.
Appollo64@reddit
I can't really think of a part of the US that doesn't have some kind of extreme or dangerous weather. It's also very easy to stay in the place you grew up. You're a lot more likely to have family, friends, and community. That's hard to leave behind to move across the country. There's career paths available in the Gulf that are much less common elsewhere. Tons of jobs in the oil industry, maritime shipping, military bases, commercial and sport fishing, and plenty of tourism related jobs. It's also expensive to move furniture and all of your possessions from one place to another. If you live in the hurricane zone, it's going to cost a lot of money to move all your stuff out of the zone. Plus the Gulf is just a nice place to live. Good beaches, good weather, good food
peaveyftw@reddit
I live 200 miles from the coast, and while I've often thought of moving to a place where summers aren't so miserable and I don't spend most of the year watching out for tornados, it's where all my family are.
winteriscoming9099@reddit
GossipBottom@reddit
Hurricanes, earthquakes on the west… lack of water in the Midwest… extreme heat in the south… cold hell upstate… details, details. You pick your struggle.
Negative-Arachnid-65@reddit
Family/community and economic reality for lots of people, plus the universal human condition of underestimating uncertain risks.
machagogo@reddit
You're understanding of the level of risk is a bit out of whack.
WashuOtaku@reddit
Like many places, the risk is low.
Hugh-Manatee@reddit
Hurricanes are just accepted as part of life and overall while damage to someone’s house/business is 100% with a severe enough storm, risk to YOUR house/business is possible but overall low.
People have friends/family/community here and most people leave here for reasons other than hurricanes.