In your opinion, is there an actor that absolutely nails your state or regional accent in a film?
Posted by Zarathos8080@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 200 comments
I've lived in Oklahoma for almost 40 years, but I'm not from here. The accent is pretty subtle, I think. You can find strong ones, of course, but sometimes you can just miss it.
The two best examples IMO were Ralph Macchio in 'The Outsiders" and Kurt Russell in "Silkwood". I had seen both films before I moved to Oklahoma and didn't think twice about it. But when I saw them in later years, the accents stood out to me. They sounded just like guys I went to high school with.
Honorable mention to DiCaprio in "Killers of the Flower Moon".
Chickadee12345@reddit
Anytime a movie or show takes place in Philly, they sound more like New Yorkers or no accent at all. Kate Winslet did a short series called Mare of Easttown which took place in a suburb of the city. She did a good job with the accent. She said in an interview that it was one of the hardest she's ever tried to master. Which is something because she's a Brit.
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
The cast gave it a very admirable shot. But it still sounded overdone (I just happened to rewatch it last nigh so it's fresh in my mind).
Of everyone, I think Evan Peters does the best job of the accent of those not already from here.
For comparison, mr Carroll's character, played by Patrick McDade is actually from Philadelphia. I use him as a side by side comparison to the other actors accent wise.
My mom is also from Media so I grew up listening to that accent and I can't even mimic it well. It's a bitch of an accent to try and nail. Kudos to all of the cast for making the effort
bunkumsmorsel@reddit
Yeah. I grew up in West Chester, my dad’s from Clifton Heights, and I can’t do the accent. He can’t, but I can’t.
Hairy_Syrup_4780@reddit
YES! I think Tina Fey is the only one who can do it. Kate did a great job. I’m not super impressed by the accents in Task. It’s a weird accent for sure
bunkumsmorsel@reddit
Yeah, but she’s s native and she often exaggerates it for comedy. Which I mean it’s hilarious, but exaggerated.
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
Tina is a local so that tracks
LemurCat04@reddit
I mean, she’s from Upper Darby so I’d hope so LOL.
bunkumsmorsel@reddit
Toni Collete in The Sixth Sense was good too.
freeze45@reddit
I know it's not a movie but the redhead from Abbott Elementary does a good Philly accent
ContributionDapper84@reddit
Great show too imo
LemurCat04@reddit
Youse ‘eard about tha other show cawled Taaahsk? It’s also on ‘Aych-Bee-Ooh an’ takes place in Delco. They mention the Ack-a-me and Rita’s wooder ice in the first scene.
thehoagieboy@reddit
I was watchin with my bruder Moik and I swear dat one scene was in the Poe-ka-nose.
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
They get up into the damn coal region in task! I had to hit pause when I seen they were up at locust lake by Mahanoy City in the one episode 🤣. I did the Leo DiCaprio point and everything
Chickadee12345@reddit
Ack-a-me is a classic. My grandmother and family in the area always said that. They also always said War-min-is-ster. I could never figure out where that came from.
LemurCat04@reddit
Did she take her pockabook to tap MAC at the Ack-a-me?
I moved from Monto to Monmouth County about 25 years ago (down the shore), and I still say “tap MAC”.
inflexigirl@reddit
Speaking of Philly, watching Silver Linings Playbook was such a disappointment. Jennifer Lawrence pronounced King of Prussia as three separate words and it completely took me out of the movie. (I was embarrassingly old when I learned that "Kingaprussia" was not a one-word place/mall. 🤣)
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
Bradley Should have pulled her aside for that. It's "kingaprussa" or kop. 🤣
LemurCat04@reddit
Brad Cooper should have stepped in there.
inflexigirl@reddit
Honestly I am surprised no one, not the dialogue coach, nor the native(s), caught that.
Or am I the one who's been mishearing the name the whole time? 🤔
Chickadee12345@reddit
No, it's only one word, not three. It's the same as djeet?
Hotwheels303@reddit
As someone grew up around Delco that show did such a good job of portraying not just the accents but the whole area especially the interiors of the houses. I swear the set designer just toured a few of my cousins houses and based them all on that
Angsty_Potatos@reddit
The setting was more impressive than the accent for me. Every interior was a house Ive definitely been in before lol
Chickadee12345@reddit
For sure. I grew up in Bucks but have scattered friends/relatives all over the area. It was such a typical representation of the area that it didn't even dawn on me at first how well they did with it.
karenmcgrane@reddit
That interview (if I read the same one) described the lady who worked at the Wawa being astonished that Winslet would come off set talking in her posh British accent and then would turn around and start talking like a Delco local again
milkshakemountebank@reddit
There's also a great thing about the PA accent in Mindhunter
bunkumsmorsel@reddit
Toni Collete in The Sixth Sense Kate Winslet in Mare of Easttown
Savings-Wallaby7392@reddit
Fun Fact if you ever work for CIA as a spy they teach you how to speak like someone from Maryland. It is only state without an accent. Too far south to have northern accent and too far north to have southern accent. Won’t blow your cover.
Negative_Ad_8256@reddit
I say warsh instead of wash. I say Ho-mmm instead of home. Crayon I pronounce as crown. I have tried to correct it but I have stared to embrace it as a part of my home.
adamforte@reddit
TIL that the CIA has never been downey oshun, hon.
They also don't warsh their hands in the zink.
Masshole205@reddit
Those that lived between Warshington and Balmer would disagree
Emotional-Ocelot-309@reddit
Maryland has an accent, dummy.
AskAnAmerican-ModTeam@reddit
Your submission was removed as it violates posting guideline "Do not ask questions that are not on topic for the subreddit."
This includes questions about immigration, travel planning, "where should I live?", general questions better suited to a subreddit such as /r/AskReddit or state specific subreddits, or questions that could be answered with a web search.
Please read rules in the sidebar before posting again.
If you have questions regarding your submission removal - please contact the moderator team via modmail.
fenwoods@reddit
Everyone has an accent, Marylanders included.
Baltimore has distinct features, but even besides that, I’ve known Marylanders from Montgomery Co and PGC and they all exhibited l-vocalization, meaning doing the L after a vowel/before a consonant.
So the Marylanders I know would ask for “Ode Bay” seasoning for their crab.
Valcyor@reddit
Oregon would like to have a word with you. :) The only giveaway for a Northwest Oregon accent is the tendency to not quite enunciate words all the way if we're speaking quickly. But even then, just slow down just the tiniest bit and the Oregon "accent" disappears.
Most national news networks train their broadcasters in an Oregon Willamette Valley accent due to its neutrality; or at least they did in years past.
And I've been to Maryland, Baltimore and DC... they definitely have a accent to my ears. It's not exactly specific, but it's definitely East Coast.
DoctorMoo42@reddit
I've never seen anyone attempt a D.C. accent.
Negative_Ad_8256@reddit
Yeah I’m from PG originally, I can tell a Marylander by how they say wash/warsh, home, and crayon.
vrilliance@reddit
I don't think I've heard anyone really nail a solid Northeast NJ accent. though to be fair, it's a hard accent - most people end up making preconceived assumptions about it and never really end up pulling it off
flustard@reddit
I mean he is literally an Italian American from Bergen county (though his normal accent is very different), but James Gandolfini in the sopranos does a solid job at it. But it is a little exaggerated compared to the people I meet in real life with it, as someone who has lived here for a few years. The super of my building sounds basically just like him lol
Proper-Painting-2256@reddit
He was exaggerating- I knew him a bit before he took the role and he was worried about taking it because he thought mafia guys would be pissed at him for pretending to be one of them - but he played up the accent anyway and all the Italian guys loved him LOL
Cool-Bunch6645@reddit
I think it’s less of a distinct “NJ” accent and more of a unique thing for the Italian-American NYC accent from the families that have moved across the Hudson. Which does make a large enough group of people here. But we all say certain words weird. Just like everyone everywhere
daysie778@reddit
I thought Jason Isaacs did a great job in White Lotus season 3. A lot of people complained he didn’t do an accurate North Carolina accent, but if you know any upper-class Durham natives in his age range, he absolutely nailed it. It made it even more impressive IMO that he was able to do such a distinct class/regional accent.
CunningWizard@reddit
He only missed in the first episode when he told Goggins to fuck off. For that he absolutely let his British accent fly.
nope-its@reddit
Yeah the first episode was a bit rough a few times for him with the accent. It got much better after that.
tcrhs@reddit
I’m from the South. No one ever gets our accents right unless they’re a native Southerner. And even then, some of them still get it wrong.
Lawyering_Bob@reddit
My problem is that they always combine the rhotic and non-rhotic accents.
Like, they'll pronounce light and bright and lot and brot but also drop their r's.
Jessica Tandy in Driving Ms Daisy did a good non-rhotic accent. She's about the only one
PerfectObjective5295@reddit
Yep, hard vs soft R makes a difference in the South
WarrenMulaney@reddit
Sean Penn as Jeff Spicoli
DeathandHemingway@reddit
It's spot on for a beach cities SoCal accent, which makes sense, Penn is from Santa Monica/Malibu.
SheenasJungleroom@reddit
Same with Keanu Reeves, in the Bill and Ted movies. It’s weird, because he’s not a native of Southern California. Actually I think he spent a lot of time in Canada? But he talks/acts exactly like those dudes that I grew up with in LA.
SheenasJungleroom@reddit
and the Valley!
mfigroid@reddit
Yep. Came here to say this. By far, Spicoli was Penn's crowning achievement.
drakeallthethings@reddit
Righteous Gemstones is a masterclass in southern accents. They all do a great job with most of them using Carolina accents. And Eric Roberts’ Memphis accent was perfect.
Masshole205@reddit
Especially Walter Goggins!
awfulmcnofilter@reddit
I am pretty sure that's just his regular accent. He is southern.
Masshole205@reddit
True but I think he plays it up in some of his roles like Gemstones and Vice Principals
awfulmcnofilter@reddit
Not sure if its played up to be honest. He sounded like that the whole time on SNL lol. He is so southern he clogs.
Cadicoty@reddit
Walton
Masshole205@reddit
His accents so southern it makes “Walton” sound like “Walter”
n8ertheh8er@reddit
Katharine Hepburn is Connecticut. Some of my aunts sound like her
tellurdoghello@reddit
William H. Macy and Francis McDormand both had pretty good Minnesota accents - McDormands was very northern and rural and Macy's was more reflective of what you would hear in the Twin Cities.
garublador@reddit
I think it's funny when people try to dispute this and say that's not what people from MN sound like. I gre up in IA but spent 5 years living in The Cities and have friends from there. That is absolutely what people, especially considering the generation of the characters, sound like.
Hot_Aside_4637@reddit
When I moved here in 2001, my coworkers told me they hated Fargo and "We don't talk like that."
They talked like that. But I hear less of it in the Twin Cities now.
And Marge's accent is not only Northern MN, but that extends from "Nord" Dakota to the U.P. where I went to college.
tellurdoghello@reddit
born and raised in the Twin Cities, spent holidays up north with relatives, it's absolutely what Minnesotans sound like, especially in the 80's-90's.
Roadshell@reddit
William H Macy is not at all reflective of what you would hear in the Twin Cities
tellurdoghello@reddit
I disagree. Growing up there in the 80's-90's I heard that accent all the time.
MrPoopMonster@reddit
Bruce Campbell hits that south east Michigan accent on the head. But, that's also his natural accent.
Adorable-East-2276@reddit
Grew up in Houston. People rarely get texas right because
1) The stereotypical Texan accent comes from way out in west Texas where almost nobody lives.
2) the way media depicts Spanglish is not even close to how Spanglish grammar and usage work.
The only show I’ve seen get it is Mo because almost all of the actors are Texan or Chicano
NintendogsWithGuns@reddit
Well, there are several different Texas accents. East Texas is super southern and twangy, west Texas is more of a drawl, South Texas is like a slightly twangy Spanglishy accent, North Texas is a bit more King of the Hill, etc.
That being said, the majority of people growing up in major urban area have a pretty “standard” American accent, save for maybe a couple of words.
Coro-NO-Ra@reddit
I know this is super off-topic, but I really wish there was something like The Wire set in Houston during the Candyman Corll-and-Cocaine years.
I've heard stories about Houston during the 70s and 80s that are straight out of Scarface. The city was like Miami, only much grittier... wildcatters, cowboys, the birth of the local hiphop scene, the Texas Killing Fields, the downfall of Italian mafia groups that had a stranglehold on Galveston for decades... just an absolutely crazy setting.
Martothir@reddit
Tommy Lee Jones in No Country for Old Men. Sounds just like long time West Texans. But he is one, so, I wouldn't know if he really counts. But it's spot on, for whatever it's worth. :p
AliceInReverse@reddit
Somehow Channing Tatum’s Gambit accent is the most accurate Cajun accent I’ve heard onscreen
la-anah@reddit
I have never heard a non-native do a Massachusetts accent that didn't sound cartoonishly over-the-top.
upvoter222@reddit
Here's a movie that nailed the accents.
mst3k_42@reddit
Oh my god, that is amazing!!!
ATaxiNumber1729@reddit
Oh mah gawd!
Doortofreeside@reddit
Christian Bale in the fighter
yiotaturtle@reddit
It's not cartoonishly over the top it's just south Boston/South shore rather than North end. South Boston comes across as kinda cartoonishly over the top if you are used to North End.
My mom grew up on Newbury Street and her first time meeting someone from South Boston was so exceptional she experienced culture shock.
Otherwise-OhWell@reddit
In fairness, no one else but Philadelphians would have a problem pronouncing the word "water" well enough that they could be saved from dehydration if dying of thirst outside of their region.
ContributionDapper84@reddit
Some parts of England too, maybe
ContributionDapper84@reddit
Did anyone do it worse than Robin Williams in Good Will Hunting?
examinat@reddit
Even some locals sound like they’re overdoing it.
beyondplutola@reddit
This is why you have to recycle Damon, Affleck, Wahlberg and Evans for every male lead movie set in Boston.
quidpropho@reddit
Which one? There are so many.
Dio_Yuji@reddit
In fairness, the real Massachusetts accent does sound cartoonishly over the top. Lol
CosmicTurtle504@reddit
Dude, we’re in Louisiana. We’re hardly in a position to talk here!
And no, I have never once seen a non New Orleanian nail the New Orleans accent on film or TV. Especially the “yat” accent, which weirdly sounds like Southern fried Brooklyn or New Jersey. Nobody would believe it.
quidpropho@reddit
Which one? There are like eight.
Dio_Yuji@reddit
I’m aware of the irony of my statement. Lol
The New Orleans accent is tricky. T.I. was in a movie called Cut Throat City a few years back. I think he actually did alright
BuildNuyTheUrbanGuy@reddit
Just watched the trailer and I didn't hear a single new orleans accent lol
Dio_Yuji@reddit
The actual movie has more talking
Retskcaj19@reddit
Waht tha fuck a you tahkin about?
blanknullvoidzero@reddit
Fahk*
PoopsieDoodler@reddit
Totally fair.
ilp456@reddit
I know someone who is actually from Boston whose accent is so thick it sounds like he is from elsewhere and doing a Boston accent.
Anustart15@reddit
Martin sheen saying microprocessors will be permanently burned into my brain. He did the classic "I'll just smash a brahmin accent and a blue collar Boston accent together and pretend that's a real thing that exists" that people love to do.
Tomato_Motorola@reddit
I think Da'Vine Joy Randolph did a great job in The Holdovers with her accent!
Rhubarb_and_bouys@reddit
And when I hear myself on film, I feel like I sound like a sister from "The Fighter". I think because we do sorta sound over the top that's what actor do but -- it still rings untrue when we hear a fake version of it. I dont know why it's so hard to get it right.
Zarathos8080@reddit (OP)
I imagine that people think it's "so easy" to do but they can't hear how stupid they sound
FAITH2016@reddit
Leonardo Dicaprio in Once Upon A Time in Hollywood. There's parts of it I can close my eyes and he sounds exactly like my uncle from Lubbock. Most people mess up a Texas accent. He's the best I've ever heard.
-Minne@reddit
His character mentions he's from Missouri after they fly back from Italy.
Sharon Tate was originally from Texas though; not sure if she had an accent in real life or not.
fetus-wearing-a-suit@reddit
He also perfectly nailed how Mexicans whistle. People over at /r/Mexico praised it. https://www.reddit.com/r/mexico/comments/1o7jw2s/como_se_dice_gracias_en_mexicano/
-Minne@reddit
"Don't cry in front of the Mexicans" is randomly a line that lives rent free in my head from that movie.
lonelytrucker86@reddit
Most film attempts at a Texas accent end up sounding like a Middle Tennessee accent. Which I forgive, seeing as the two regions are extremely closely connected. But the accents are different.
Old_Promise2077@reddit
While we are at it. The worst Texas accent I've ever heard was the girl from Yellowstone that was supposed to be a Texan. It wasn't even that it was over the top... It was just a really strong accent that doesn't exist, it almost didn't even sound like an American accent.
But that show is pretty silly
braxtel@reddit
Tommy Lee Jones in No Country for Old Men nails the West Texas accent, but he is from Midland, so his normal voice has that kind of drawl to begin with.
FAITH2016@reddit
I see. I haven't watched that.
Difficult-Bobcat-857@reddit
Watch it.
G00dSh0tJans0n@reddit
Top 10 film for sure
Dio_Yuji@reddit
Ryan Kwanten, an Australian, does a north Louisiana accent in the show True Blood. The show is set in a fictional town close to where I grew up. I knew many dudes who spoke just like him. Absolutely spot-on.
Maleficent-Hawk-318@reddit
I usually have a fantastic ear for accents and can almost always tell when a non-American actor is doing an American accent. I may not be able to tell you exactly where the actor is from, but I know they're not American.
He is one of the rare ones who managed to fool me. I was genuinely surprised when I learned he's Australian.
L6b1@reddit
Actors don't try because they think my area doesn't have an accent. What gives them away is not pronouncing local place names correctly. It's a deadgiveway they didn't bother to do any research.
Maleficent-Hawk-318@reddit
Breaking Bad was kind of like this for me. Albuquerque does actually have a pretty distinct accent; not everyone has it, so for example it was fine that Walter and Skyler didn't have one, but you'd hear it a lot more in real life than you hear in the show.
I think I've heard that you started hearing more of it in later seasons as more local actors were brought in, but I only watched the first season or so, and the lack of it really stood out to me. I do think they generally got the place names right, though, so not as bad as your location.
Valcyor@reddit
The one that bugs me the most, even though I'm not from the area, is Mary-Louise Parker (a Southerner herself from SC) not pronouncing "Mobile" correctly in the movie RED.
Unless it's intentional, as her character is from Kansas and sounds it, but... come on.
SlamClick@reddit
I mean, Dolly Parton was in 9 to 5. Classic East Tennessee accent.
PsychologicalFox8839@reddit
Accent variation is so interesting! I’m from just outside Nashville and sound nothing as southern as Dolly.
Mueryk@reddit
The closer to any major city you get, the less of a Southern accent there is. The only exception to this may be Birmingham.
DBDude@reddit
I remember visiting Dallas for the first time and wondering why I didn't hear one Texas accent the whole time.
Traditional_Entry183@reddit
Yeah my wife has a lot of family from the same area, and hers is very typical.
Interesting-Run2584@reddit
Matt Damon’s accent as Carol Shelby in Ford vs Ferrari was one of the best Texan accents I’ve ever heard by a non-Texan.
DeByGodCapn@reddit
I don't think I've ever heard a rural Maryland accent even attempted in film or TV. In the few films/shows I've seen that take place in rural MD they usually don't attempt it at all and the actors just speak like Californians. I once saw a Harriet Tubman biopic that had characters in Easton, MD talking in deep south accents which was pretty funny.
cloudstrife1191@reddit
Christian Bale’s accent in “The Fighter” was pretty incredible. The accent in and around the Lowell area is a bit more specific than the Boston accent you often hear in movies (which is usually terrible) and he clearly took the time to get it right. He sounded more like an authentic speaker than even Mark Wahlberg did in my opinion.
Yankee_chef_nen@reddit
I don’t think I’ve ever seen a movie set in Maine (where I grew up) that gets the Downeast accent right.
devstopfix@reddit
I remember thinking "In the Kitchen" was pretty good. They didn't go over the top with it. But, that was a long time ago, so I might be miss-remembering.
There's a book series I listen to as audiobooks where the narrator is a young guy from Maine. The performer's accent is really good - it's subtle, reminds me of people I went to high school with rather than an old-school Downeast Burt-and-I. But, it's not always perfect. In a later book, the character has a back-story that he spent a few years in Boston as a kid. I'm convinced that was added to explain the slightly-off accent of the audiobook performance.
This-Professional-39@reddit
The original Pet Cemetery had the best I've seen
davdev@reddit
No one can do a Boston accent if they arent from Boston, so no. Hell, even Matt Damon sucks at it now, and he is from here. Afflect and Wahlburg still do it right though.
No one in history has done it worse than the wife on Ray Donovan, I had to stop watching it was so bad.
marmaduke-treblecock@reddit
Costner comes in a close second for his butchering of a Boston accent in 13 Days. “This is youah repoard caaaahd!” Practically ruined an otherwise solid movie.
AimlessFred@reddit
Darren Mcgavin as the dad from A Christmas Story sounded exactly like my grandpa, who was from the greater Chicago area, turns out the actor is from Washington State.
Leaf-Stars@reddit
Sylvester Stallone in Rocky
Taz9093@reddit
He wasn’t in it long but Channing Tatum as Gambit in DP3. Best I’ve heard all in a long time.
Ubergeek2001@reddit
Billy Bob Thorton. Here in North Texas
CocaChola@reddit
Tracy Ullman does an amazingly good Baltimore accent.
Masshole205@reddit
Joe Pesci sounds like pure New York
SaltandLillacs@reddit
Ben Affleck and Matt Damon
Masshole205@reddit
It used to be good but they’ve slowly lost it over time. Especially Affleck
Weightmonster@reddit
Boston?
SaltandLillacs@reddit
Yeah, most actors have a horrific Boston accent
Weightmonster@reddit
I’m pretty sure they are from Boston.
Thereelgerg@reddit
Yes there is.
HowardIsMyOprah@reddit
Matthew McConaughey crushed the Texas accent in Dallas Buyers Club and Dazed and Confused.
Sea_Dot8299@reddit
Every actor nailed it in the show Mare of Easttown.
Zealousideal_Draw_94@reddit
No actor has ever done a good Georgia accent in movie or television. It is often forced or drawn out.
Even the actors from Georgia, have blended their own accent to accommodate Hollywood standards, so when they can use it, it is no longer a good.
Georgia also has regional accents, and sometimes different accents from counties, or even between economic factors.
brn1001@reddit
I can't tell.
platoniclesbiandate@reddit
Emily Proctor nails the NC accent. And that so because she is from NC lol. However, when she was on West Wing playing a character from NC, she would get complaints about her fake NC accent.
DifferentWindow1436@reddit
No, but it's rare you see my area as a setting. I am from the NJ shore area.
imthe5thking@reddit
Pretty much anybody who does a standard American accent does my accent just fine. Although, there are some people who have that Fargo accent around here, and they’re 4th or 5th generation Montanans. Like someone I went to school with used to say North Dah-KOH-da, and we’d give her shit for it. But most of us are pretty standard American accent unless we get really excited or mad. Then a hint of that accent can pop out.
seifd@reddit
Tim Allen.
hideandsee@reddit
Matt Damon.
Financial_Basis8705@reddit
Anthony Hopkins as Burt munroe in the world's fastest Indian.
He caught quite a bit of flack for not sounding at all like a kiwi, but I know old timers from Invercargill and they fucking sound like that!
BoSKnight87@reddit
Tony soprano. A little overboard with with the accent but he got it
CantHostCantTravel@reddit
No. Hollywood is incapable of doing authentic Minnesotan accents accurately. The key is subtlety, but subtlety isn’t noticeable to a national audience.
Bundt-lover@reddit
Amen. Although I will say that Matthew McFayden does a very respectable “Twin Cities native who moved to the coast” accent in Succession. Very subtle.
stopstopimeanit@reddit
Few people can do a working class, mid-Atlantic accent. Kathy Bates in AHS?
fakesaucisse@reddit
Several of the non-local actors in The Wire did an excellent job of representing the variations of the Baltimore/Bawlmer accent. It's been a long time but I recall being fairly impressed with Dominic West, especially given that he's not even American.
nothingbuthobbies@reddit
People always say this about The Wire and I swear I'm taking crazy pills. I can't speak for the black actors because I'm not confident enough in my familiarity with regional variants of AAVE accents, but NONE of the white actors sound anything like Baltimore natives. Dominic West sounds like he's from New York. The only ones who sound like they're from Baltimore are Jay Landsman (the actor, not the character), who is actually from Baltimore, and maybe Valchek.
fakesaucisse@reddit
I'm not claiming it's perfect but some of the actors do get the basics down. I grew up and lived in Baltimore City for 23 years, have friends from school who are still living there in middle age, and when the show came out we all thought it was a decent representation of a set of fairly difficult accents and dialects.
I think what makes it hard to see for some is that Baltimore has so many neighborhood based dialects (some of which are further broken down by ethnicity), and if you only grew up around one of them you won't notice the others. I went to magnet schools so I was exposed to so many of them. The Dundalk version is different than the Essex version, which are both very different from the Lauraville version or the Parkville or Owings Mills versions for white people. Then you get into the Black variants which again differ based on neighborhood, as well as the Korean and Vietnamese community variants (though I found those tended to be pretty influenced by the Black folks in the neighborhoods they often shared).
So, for one show to kinda hit on a bit of that variety, often based on where the characters lived or worked, is a pretty big feat.
Tooch10@reddit
S1 Dom's accent is all over the place between his native accent and the Bawlmer one
fakesaucisse@reddit
For sure, but there were a lot of times where he sounded like a typical guy from Parkville. Occasionally he'd slip into some Dundalk, but honestly, everyone in Baltimore has a little Dundalk in them at times.
Zappagrrl02@reddit
I didn’t know Dominic West was British when I first watched it. Michael K Williams (RIP) nails it though.
CriticalSuit1336@reddit
Frances McDormand, Fargo
sto_brohammed@reddit
Jeff Daniels' accent is pretty close to mine but that's because he's from not terribly far from where I'm from.
jigokubi@reddit
I was going to go with him, but decided to go with Bruce Campbell in Evil Dead.
Illinois_s_notsilent@reddit
Whoa
Zappagrrl02@reddit
He’s the only one who gets it completely right. Everyone else always ends up sounding like Minnesota or Canada.
sto_brohammed@reddit
That's because it's his actual accent lol, he still lives down in Chelsea
Zappagrrl02@reddit
Yes! I always try and stop in Chelsea and go to Common Grill when I’m in the area, even though I don’t think he owns it anymore. He still has the Purple Rose theatre there though!
jigokubi@reddit
Bruce Campbell really nails the Detroit Metro accent in the Evil Dead series.
Of course, it helps that it's his actual accent.
baalroo@reddit
Ted Lasso - Jason Sudeikis
tracygee@reddit
The Charleston SC accent is hard to get right and I’ve rarely seen it done correctly.
The exception to me is Albert Finney in a small film called Rich in Love from the 90s, I think. Amazing to see a British actor do that accent so well.
The other actor who does it well is Josh Lucas, but he grew up just outside of Charleston, so his is home grown.
Aggressive-Emu5358@reddit
Well it’s not too hard to nail a Colorado accent so
TokyoDrifblim@reddit
Obviously he's a terrible person, but Kevin Spacey in House of Cards actually is kind of nailing the Charleston/Lowcountry accent. Problem is, his character is from Gaffney in the Upstate and would sound nothing like that in real life. Close enough?
LionelHutzEsqLLP@reddit
It's basically the same as his accent in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil, where he's new money originally from middle Georgia, trying to impress old money Savannah high society.
Traditional_Entry183@reddit
John Corbett (My Big Fat Greek Wedding, Northern Exposure) is from my hometown in WV and his accent is pretty typical.
SkeeevyNicks@reddit
I grew up in Oklahoma and I was going to mention DiCaprio. He even nailed the northeastern Oklahoma accent.
airynothing1@reddit
Everyone who tries Missouri just goes for a broad country/redneck accent without any regional specificity. Even Brad Pitt, a Missourian himself, just does kind of does a standard "cowboy" voice for Jesse James. It's understandable because Missouri's accents are pretty amorphous, ranging from a a nasally, classic midwestern sound in places like St. Louis to a more southern inflection in the Ozarks and Bootheel and often winding up somewhere in the neighborhood of a generic "standard American" voice.
All that being said, I think that Hailee Steinfeld in True Grit, while technically playing an Arkansan, does a good job of sounding like someone from this general region while avoiding cartoonishness. All the more impressive since she was so young!
trinite0@reddit
True, but I can always tell that John Goodman is from Missouri, though.
DeiaMatias@reddit
As an Okie, the new Twisters was the WORST.
As a 5th generation Okie, our accent is definitely different from "southern" or "Texan."
trinite0@reddit
John Goodman always sounds like a true Missourian, because that's what he is.
angellbitch@reddit
Amanda Rollins in SVU is from Georgia. The actress also happens to be from here so it works out quite well.
DropEdge@reddit
Julia Garner in Ozark. I honestly thought she was a native.
No-Conversation1940@reddit
She sounds like one of the old men who would sit at the front of the general store and drink coffee all day when I was a kid. The Ozarks have that accent, but a lot of younger or even middle age people these days have more of a Kansas City/Wichita type Midwestern accent.
I've lived in Chicago for almost 10 years and the only comments I ever received about my accent were based on surprise. Folks from Chicago or Michigan or New York learned where I was from and thought I should sound like the two liter of Mountain Dew kid from West Virginia.
No-Conversation1940@reddit
Grew up in the Ozarks, and a lot of people have more of a Kansas City/Des Moines/Omaha type Midwestern accent than people realize. I think folks think we sound like the two liter of Mountain Dew kid from West Virginia, that accent was fading 20-30 years ago.
gigisnappooh@reddit
No, they always way over do a Southern accent.
DrearyBiscuit@reddit
The guy from "My New Haircut" nails Long Island
My New Haircut
Mushrooming247@reddit
Tom Hardy in Warrior
I only watched the movie because it was set in my hometown of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania, in the northeastern US.
I watched the whole thing thinking they had hired some local meathead to play the one fighter guy, he was just like every yinzer at every local gym.
I didn’t even think he was hot, it was just way too familiar, he seemed like any local nobody. And it was Tom Hardy.
MrsNoodleMcDoodle@reddit
Jim Parsons really nails that Houston metro accent, but he’s from suburban Houston, lol.
riarws@reddit
I don’t live in that area any more, but Jessica Tandy in “Fried Green Tomatoes” sounded exactly like my great-aunt Josie. It was almost eerie.
jephph_@reddit
Anything with Rosie Perez
https://youtu.be/ajBHZKoKYbU
Or, that’s what I think today’s “New York accent” is. That’s the one you’re going to hear most often in your day-to-day.
That said, Rosie doesn’t necessarily nail the accent as an actor.. She’s just talking like a girl from Bushwick
FlappyClap@reddit
No, there are none at all. They, either sound like they want to offer you some lemonade on their front porch or they sound like they’re preparing to sing a typical country song — “Mr. Johnson, I do declare! Would you care for some lemonade?” or “Hey y’all! I reckon y’all ain’t from around ‘ere…”
Dio_Yuji@reddit
In fairness, real coonasses do sound ridiculous
FlappyClap@reddit
That’s true, but it’s not authentic ridiculousness
Dio_Yuji@reddit
Has there been a good Acadiana accent in a movie? I’m trying to think…
NemeanMiniLion@reddit
Just turn on the news and you will likely hear my accent or as most broadcast companies believe, the lack of a distinct American accent.
Chili_Pea@reddit
I dunno about accent (supposedly Connecticut doesn’t have one) but Billy Madison 2 absolutely nails the look of Waterbury Connecticut. It goes from super nice mansions to wood paneled homes real quick
lofromwisco@reddit
John Candy in Home Alone 🙂 🧀
missyrae333@reddit
marisa tomei in "untamed heart" (minnesota accent) so perfect!!!
TonkaHeroDreamCake@reddit
Gosh i love her so much. Everything she does is cute lol.
Vanilla_thundr@reddit
I recently rewatched Best In Show. I was blown away by Christopher Guest's southern accent. It was thick but not exaggerated. He's from North Carolina in the movie, I think but I have met tons of people in my life that sounded like that character. I was blown away when I found out he was from an English Baron born in New York.
ALoungerAtTheClubs@reddit
The regional accent (that neither I nor the vast majority of contemporary residents have) for my part of Florida is a light Southern accent. I don't think I've really heard that in media. Most TV/movie Southern accents are more drawl-y.
Coconut-bird@reddit
Same here. The only movie I can think of that has characters from my area is the Devil's Advocate and they went way too strong with the Southern Accent.
Rarewear_fan@reddit
Scooter from Spongebob: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OCVRnzONLVA
PaBlowEscoBear@reddit
Sandy from SpongeBob