Tamir Nimrodi killed by IDF bombardment in Gaza, hostage families say
Posted by soalone34@reddit | anime_titties | View on Reddit | 161 comments
Posted by soalone34@reddit | anime_titties | View on Reddit | 161 comments
Morgn_Ladimore@reddit
Don't forget the Israeli military also killed 3 hostages who were waving white flags and yelling in Hebrew that they were hostages. Gunned down instantly by Israeli soldiers.
The same military that bombed international aid workers three times, killing them as they tried to run to different vehicles for cover.
So this doesn't come as a surprise. They had one goal in Gaza, and that was indiscriminate murder of Palestinians. Everyone else that died, including Israeli hostages, were acceptable collateral.
Borealisss@reddit
Gunned down 2 of them from range, the 3rd managed to get away and tried to hide. They chased him down and shot him point blank.. Because somehow with the IOF it's always worse than it first seems.
Norkmani@reddit
According to an IDF official, the three male hostages emerged shirtless out of a building toward a group of IDF soldiers "tens of meters" away, with one carrying a white flag. An Israeli sniper then opened fire on them, killing Shamriz and Talalka and wounding Haim. After being shot, Haim ran into a nearby building and shouted for help in Hebrew. The battalion commander then ordered the troops to hold their fire, while Haim was persuaded to exit the building but when he did so 15 minutes later, a soldier acting against the battalion commander's order shot and killed him.
Future psychologists will study the average Israeli brain. How can an entire nation be this brainwashed?
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
Have you ever fought a CQC urban battle?
Such cheap racism is pathetic.
There's a fuckton of criticism to be made about the israeli forces and the israeli political landscape, and yet, you went for the "these savages must have underdeveloped brains" like a racist colonial measuring the skulls of his slaves.
Sad-Broccoli@reddit
They're saying their brains need to be studied for their psychopathy and susceptibility to indoctrination. Obviously it's not just Israelis, but Zionists in general everywhere. What needs to be studied is the psychology of people relentlessly supporting heinous indefensible crimes. They're not saying their brains are underdeveloped.
It's the same thing as saying Nazis or serial killers' brains need to be studied. That's not racism. It's not the same thing as making up bullshit about an entire race being inferior to you to justify enslaving them.
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
Study their physical brain. Something that is 99% determined by genes. Absolutely not racism, indeed.
There are thousands of conflicts involving such behaviors, over centuries of human history, all over the world.
Africa got multiple past and ongoing genocides, Asia got Imperial Japan mass rapes and massacres, as well as Mao's millions of casualties, Russia got multiple genocides, deportation, mass torture in the gulag camps, Europe got the Holocaust and countless massacres throughout its history, the Middle-East got multiple genocides (especially in the Ottoman Empire) and pogroms, South America got the genocides of natives by spanish conquistadors and between competing tribes, North America got the extermination of native americans.
But surely we need to study the physical brain of an entire ethnic group specifically, because "they" are specifically evil genetically.
This is literally the sort of hate speech that's coming out of israeli settlers and lunatics like Ben Gvir, who argue that palestinian arabs are genetically incapable of non-violence and needs to be removed for the safety of all. That is insane and the most racist thing that can be said about an ethnic group.
And yet, you just parroted that hate speech, simply swapping the ethnic group to fit your own posturing.
Sad-Broccoli@reddit
Idk how to tell you this, but Nazis aren't an ethnic group
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
Oh look at you, so edgy, calling all israelis nazis, just like Ben Gvir calling all palestinians terrorists.
You saw hateful settlers and thought to yourself "hey I like that, I'm gonna be a racist moron and generalize about an entire ethnic group".
This is literally why nobody takes your slacktivism seriously: you're in it to be hateful and racist, not to bring peace and rights for everyone.
Maximum-Hall-5614@reddit
Only an innocent, morally superior Zionist would refer to the killing of unarmed men as a “battle”
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
The 18,500 wounded and 800 killed israeli soldiers would call that a battle yes.
Even if you don't believe it, Hamas (and other factions like PIJ) have guns and explosives, and have been firing them at israeli soldiers for the last 2 years. They even recorded some of their ambushes, that you can watch on telegram and other platforms.
...
But you're right, let me put on my magic goggles that allow me to see through walls and instantly know that someone does not have a grenade or handgun.
You're the sort of genius who wonder why police forces have their hands on their guns when checking a vehicle at 3 am. Why don't they just wear the magic goggles?
KaiBahamut@reddit
Okay but they still shot shirtless unarmed men waving a white flag. Or can Hamas write off all the civilians they killed on 10/7 with 'Have you ever fought a CQC Urban Battle?'.
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
Surely terrorist organizations disguising themselves as civilians and firing rockets from civilian homes and infrastructure for decades would never ever do such thing as perfidy...
Not all, you're being facetious.
If Hamas shot and killed civilians in an israeli military base when they attacked those, absolutely yes. Military on military is okay, accidental casualties during battle are to be expected.
Military positions, in the laws of war, are fair game for offensives, and it is expected that civilian casualties may occur during battles on these positions.
When Hamas decides to use Gaza to conduct military operations against the israeli forces, all these ambushes, they are turning an urban environment occupied by civilians, into a battlefield, which is a series of military positions, exposing civilians (and hostages) to accidental casualties.
That's why it is constantly requested of military forces, all around the world, to not conduct military operations in large cities, or to allow civilians to evacuate these large cities first, before conducting military operations there.
waiver@reddit
lol, what urban battle, shooting unarmed men holding a white flag qualifies as a "urban battle" now?
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
So you haven't a single clue what it's like to move through urban ruins, with snipers and ambushes at every corner, by insurgents disguising themselves as civilians and hostages?
The israeli lost 800+ soldiers in Gaza, we even have multiple video footage of ambushes, recorded by Hamas forces, showing israeli patrols being gunned down out of nowhere. It's pretty obvious that they're constantly on edge while advancing through Gaza, they're fighting a war not picking flowers.
Given 50,000 palestinians know hebrew, mostly from working in Israel (before the war, between 55k to 150k work permits were issued), and Hamas officers all know hebrew (they communicate with the IDF for prisoner swaps that way), and there is documented use of hebrew by Hamas forces during firefights to lure israeli soldiers (even 7th october video showed it), then yes someone speaking hebrew in CQC urban combat is not safe at all and is often treated as particularly suspicious.
Norkmani@reddit
First and foremost, I’m an Israeli citizen with Palestinian heritage so calm your ass down. I live in Palestine, illegally. I recommend you read the IDF report, they fucked up on every level imaginable. The hostages were in their underwear, for fucks sake.
Underdeveloped? The Israelis? Are you sure we are talking about the same country? Nothing I said implied they’re undeveloped.
Racism is shooting a man in his underwear, convince him to step out of his hiding spot and then killing him because you think he may or may not be a Hamas operative. They’re brainwashed not because they’re underdeveloped but because state propaganda is spoon fed to them 24/7. The average Israeli is brainwashed beyond comprehension. I would know considering I am told that visiting the West Bank is going to get me killed. Israelis have no clue how bad the government is lying to them.
HourEast5496@reddit
That person is a Znazis-bot account. Reddit is infested with them bots now.
ilimlidevrimci@reddit
Yup, there are so many layers to their bloodthirst that it never ceases to amaze you.
onepareil@reddit
Sorry, what is a “hostage soldier”? “Kidnapped from his base”? It sounds like he was a prisoner of war, not a hostage.
Regardless, it’s unfortunate he was killed by his brothers-in-arms, but that’s a risk they knew they were taking.
Zipz@reddit
You know the Geneva Convention ?
The answer to why they are considered hostages and not PoWs is because Hamas doesn’t follow it…..
arab-xenon@reddit
Israel rapes hostages in their prisons on video, but carry on doing tricks on it to defend Israeli war crimes
Zipz@reddit
Calling out hamas is me defending rape ?
The fact you have to lie about my argument to defend abuses of hostages is something else
khengoolman@reddit
This!!!
Soldiers can not be hostages, by definition.
meister2983@reddit
Of course they can of they are being hostaged.
khengoolman@reddit
But Palestinians can’t right? Because Israel = good?
meister2983@reddit
They can be hostages if and when Israel demands something to another party to release them
khengoolman@reddit
Oh sorry, you’re right, they’re not hostages.
They are kidnapped, it’s much better now isn’t it?!
meister2983@reddit
depending on your view of hostage taking, yes.
But now I'm not sure what you mean. A kidnapped soldier is just a POW in a sense...
khengoolman@reddit
And a kidnapped civilian by Israel makes Israel a ……. state
Fill in the blank
FudgeAtron@reddit
They literally can soldiers are only POWs if they are held as such otherwise they too are hostages.
khengoolman@reddit
Retarded comment of the year unsurprisingly has to go to the ziobitch
Zipz@reddit
And you’re a Nazi
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zionist_as_a_pejorative
khengoolman@reddit
Zionist: writes article on wikipedia
Zionist: links article to prove point
Anti-Zionist: don’t give a fuck about your definition
Zipz@reddit
Damn really goes to show you what kind of person you are defending a racist dog whistle
khengoolman@reddit
Pot is calling the kettle black, can’t say I’m surprised
Zipz@reddit
The projection is something else with you
FudgeAtron@reddit
I hope your day is as nice as this comment 😊
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
It’ll be nicer cause we don’t have to live with our accumulated evil deeds on our conscience
FudgeAtron@reddit
"There is no one righteous, not even one;"
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
I didn’t perpetrate a genocide though
הממלכה אינה שוכנת בתוכך
FudgeAtron@reddit
Are you Native American?
khengoolman@reddit
Hahaha bit of an admission of guilt huh?
Guess they’re recruiting anyone in the Hasbara army these days
FudgeAtron@reddit
You're Aussie, you don't have a leg to stand on. It was still illegal for non-white people to live in Australia up until 50 years ago.
So same question are you Aboriginal?
Poltergeist97@reddit
I find it hilarious that you point these out, not realizing that we realized this was wrong in the 19th Century. Israel did their genocidal colonization in 1948. Huge difference.
FudgeAtron@reddit
American apartheid ended in 1967 no? And it was still illegal for black and white people to marry in the US at that time too.
Poltergeist97@reddit
Since when did we switch topics to Apartheid? Weird for you to call it out since Israel is still actively implementing a similar system in the West Bank.
Any other criticisms you want to levy, maybe ones that aren't something your country still practices?
khengoolman@reddit
It’s brilliant really, he’s actually talked himself into admitting that Israel is a genocidal apartheid regime, all we have to do is admit we’re native, or that we condemn what our country has done.
So here I go: I’m a refugee in Australia, I didn’t steal anyone’s land, and I acknowledge the elders and traditional native owners of this land. What was done to them was horrible, and governments still struggle to make it right, but they at least acknowledge what was done was wrong, not completely deny the natives’ existence.
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
someone criticizes Israeli apartheid
the most annoying Israeli you’ve ever met: “well acktually your nation committed genocide too!”
a normal human being that doesn’t support their birth country’s genocide because genocide is bad: “so you agree? That Israel’s actions constitute apartheid and genocide just like Australia’s and America’s actions? And you acknowledge that you’re destroying the culture and land of aboriginal people?”
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
I mean, have you seen Israelis?
Israel is not sending their best
FudgeAtron@reddit
Holy shit I just looked at your profile do you think you're going to go cast some magic spells and use your hermetic knowledge to unlock true reality?
Go back to reading tarot cards and stealing native American religion.
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
Was I born from the 1800’s-1960’s and was I actively a person that created modern America that killed native Americans?
I don’t think America’s reign of terror is justified and I’m actively working against it. Meanwhile you’re actively ripping human beings apart as America’s lapdog and not only that, you’re proud of it. The שְׁכִינָה is gone. You bombed it.
FudgeAtron@reddit
By leaving right? Because you understand that your presence there is a form of genocidal theft that you perpetuate through existing.
So are you leaving the US or will you continue to be a hypocrite?
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
Nope. That’s not how decolonization works. You’re being disingenuous. I’d try to have a decent balanced conversation about how decolonization would look in practice. But you’re not looking for that. Cause you’re a pro-colonization ghoul.
Zipz@reddit
By your made up definition?
Funny how that works
They are classified as hostages because Hamas doesn’t abide by the Geneva convention when it comes to PoWs
But I’m glad you just tried lying and justifying war crimes says a lot about you
Pklnt@reddit
Oh look, suddenly the Geneva convention matters, lmao
Zipz@reddit
I mean clearly it doesn’t to you
photochadsupremacist@reddit
On one side, you have "underage men" "prisoners" who were held without charge.
On the other side, you have poor little baby civilians who were kidnapped from their tank.
photochadsupremacist@reddit
On one side, you have child "prisoners"
Sitar21@reddit
Hannibal directive was done way after October 7th as well,I’ve lost track of how many of their own they have taken out
meister2983@reddit
This isn't the Hannibal directive at work. That only applies before a captive is taken into enemy territory. This is simply a casualty of heavy bombardment
kieranjackwilson@reddit
I don’t agree with the logic that the Hannibal Directive is about saving Israelis from being kidnapped. It is more likely that it’s about killing Israelis so Hamas attacks have a larger death toll.
Killing potential hostages then hostage releases doesn’t make sense if you’re going to do a prisoner swap eventually. It would make more sense to do the exchange quickly and then bomb Hamas.
I think Israel kills their hostages because dead hostages benefit Israel. That’s the same reason they do anything.
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
That level of conspiracy delirium is astounding.
The Hannibal directive had always been about IDF soldiers, as a response to a wave of kidnapping of soldiers in the 80s, it never included civilians, which makes your whole scenario completely delirious.
The directive made israeli soldiers in the process of being kidnapped as being active combattants, allowing the use or deadly force in close proximity even if it endangers them.
The reason why Israel did that was the asymmetrical logic in prisoner swaps, where for every released soldier, Israel had to release hundreds or even thousands of palestinian prisoners - of which some were merely suspects, but also several were convicted criminals behind terrorist attacks.
Ha yes, the israeli savages, they drink blood and kill people - including their own - for fun.
It's like how Ben Gvir and other israeli settlers describe palestinians: every single palestinian must be craving mass murder, everything they do is about destroying israel. /s
If you want to denounce an israeli strategy exploiting terrorist attacks, stop recycling the insane "they're bloodthirsty animals" rhetorics, and instead look at Netanyahu supporting Hamas by maintaining the cashflow coming from Qatar (Netanyahu personally intervened in 2018 and onward), to make sure Hamas remains powerful in Gaza, keeping a steady flow of rocket attacks and terrorist attacks against Israel, so that the Likud wins the elections over and over again and no 2-state solution appears at the horizon.
There are very real, documented fucked up things done by the israeli leadership and armed forces, there is no need to sink to some pants-on-fire conspiracy rhetorics to frontally criticize it.
kieranjackwilson@reddit
You do understand that typically when you use quotations, it is to quote someone right? Not to put anti-semitic tropes in their mouth? It is clear you are not confident in actually addressing my argument so you defaulted to the you-hate-Jews defense.
The Hannibal Directive was revoked in 2016, so if you are going to use the defense that it doesn’t allow for the killing of civilians because it stated as such, let’s be clear. The IDF did not invoke the Hannibal Directive on October 7th. They gave an order to kill any militants taking hostages “at all costs”, that is, including the lives of civilians. Israeli publications have referred to this practice as the Hannibal Directive because it is colloquially understood by anyone who isn’t trying to obfuscate to defend the killing of Israeli civilians.
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
The only quote on my message is literally what you wrote, word for word, and you haven't bothered to edit it out before falsely accusing me of altering it. It is still right there, for everyone to see.
If you want to comment on what you wrote, go ahead, explain to us how what you wrote is not some crass racist drivel about israelis being bloodthirsty evils. "That's the same reason they do anything"
Goalposts? Oh they're right over there -->>
You literally said "the Hannibal Directive", not the overall practice of attacking enemy positions even if there's a risk of harming civilians by doing so.
Ha yes, anyone who wants to make things clear about the use of specific terms is surely trying to obfuscate/defend the killing of israeli civilians.
It is particularly amusing that you're projecting this accusation on others, after leveraging the "Hannibal Directive" point that is only ever brought up by militants to downplay the massacres done during the 7th October attack.
kieranjackwilson@reddit
For some reason Reddit hid my reply.
Sitar21@reddit
I don’t respond to zombies usually,but the former defense minister(gallant) and a plethora of other “Israeli” soldiers have admitted to the Hannibal directive used on Oct 7th. Their own media outlets have confirmed this
kieranjackwilson@reddit
And it was revoked in 2016. When the Defense Minister, for example, refers to the Hannibal Directive, it is in a colloquial sense rather than a literal sense. It was replaced with three directives that are not public.
TraditionalGap1@reddit
That must be why several hostages have said exactly that and numerous israeli outlets have discussed civilian deaths for, at this point, almost two years. Because it's all a pants-on-fire conspiracy
HKEY_LOVE_MACHINE@reddit
Read again. This discussion is about the Hannibal directive. This directive *is about soldiers and soldiers only.
Then, separately, the IDF forces have chosen to engage suspected enemy forces even if they suspect there are civilians being used as meatshield there. This decision has nothing to do with the Hannibal directive from the 80s that is about soldiers.
Get your facts straight, it is detrimental to the criticism of the IDF to get into conspiracy theories bollocks, especially when these conspiracies are used by propagandists denying documented events happened.
TraditionalGap1@reddit
So your argument is now 'well, they stopped calling it the Hannibal directive years ago therefore it's all okay'?
Never mind that Israeli commentary frequently refers to Israel killing both soldiers and civilians on October 7th and afterwards using that label, correctly understanding that changing the name for the same behaviour with the same justifications doesn't change the act itself.
Good job being so credulous
Crouteauxpommes@reddit
This Israeli government definitely benefits more from dead hostages than alive hostages.
The manifestation against the war were spearheaded by the families of hostages that wanted a ceasefire and a prisoners swap. If all the hostages had been killed by IDF, or even by Hamas as retaliation for massacre of civilians, they would have been hailed as martyrs by the Israeli car right. But by staying alive, they were a problem that the government couldn't simply bomb its way out of.
Maximum-Hall-5614@reddit
I mean, the day that the living “hostages” (they were all male soldiers and therefore POWs) were released by Hamas, there were countless posts by Israelis saying “now we’ve got the hostages out, let’s finish the job in Gaza and get rid of all those Arabs”
meister2983@reddit
It goes both ways. Hamas holding hostages also gives the government justification to have a war
Crouteauxpommes@reddit
I mean, if it's to bomb the places where hostages are held and kill them in the process, they are barely more than excuses.
meister2983@reddit
Why? Israel got most hostages back on better terms than initially offered. They also achieved huge deterrence.
Gleneroo@reddit
It is not only hostage family who says that, the IDF also confirms it:
Israeli news: https://www.ynetnews.com/article/sjjwfantel
IDF confirmed Wednesday that Staff Sgt. Tamir Nimrodi, an Israeli soldier who was kidnapped alive by Hamas on October 7, was killed in an Israeli airstrike in Gaza two days after the war began — while still in captivity.
DanDan1993@reddit
Casually ignoring how Hamas seniors used him as a human shield to get Israel not to bomb him.
Sadly we took the bait. jfc we took the bait.
Vegetable-College-17@reddit
Brother, that's the whole idea behind taking a hostage. The idea is that you want the poor bastard alive, so you won't lob explosives at him. Israel didn't take any baits here, it just didn't engage in the process and people suffered the consequences.
ShootmansNC@reddit
Hamas took hostages without realizing that Israel doesn't care about it's own people.
DanDan1993@reddit
having an escort of hostages to keep you alive is the idea? Can you name any other instances this happens but some fantasizes?
Vegetable-College-17@reddit
Hostage taking isn't a fantastical concept. I understand that it's morally repugnant, but that's different than being fantastical. I don't know how to explain this any further.
DanDan1993@reddit
Having an escort of hostages to let you roam "freely" or as a check for your safety is a fantastical concept
PartySr@reddit
You're talking like Israel is not using human shields. Your country have been doing that even before oct 7.
hussainhssn@reddit
Israel has abused, kidnapped, and murdered infinitely more hostages than Hamas ever has or ever will quite frankly. The same country that lets American rapists and pedos settle freely and the same country that has an illicit nuclear weapons program which they still deny, unlike every other nuclear power. Every accusation is an admission of guilt with these folks.
Maximum-Hall-5614@reddit
You can act all high and mighty once Israel stops strapping Palestinian children to the front of your armoured tanks and using them as shields against resistance fighters.
Your terrorist “army” has been using Palestinian children as human shields since the first Nakba.
But I guess your country doesn’t consider Palestinians to be humans, so I guess it doesn’t count, right?
Fucking war criminal thugs, the lot of you.
mnmkdc@reddit
I’m confused, are you denying that hostages have been used that way? Israel has even used them that way. It’s horrible, but how are you going to deny that it happens?
Gleneroo@reddit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hostage
Look at the illustration picture
It has always been like this, everywhere. People who take hostages believe they are valuable and the other side would not risk to harm them.
Grichnak@reddit
How about when the IDF puts children tied up on their vehicles to not get shot ?
DanDan1993@reddit
I'm sure you can provide evidence for that
GianfrancoZoey@reddit
What about this
Gaza: Israeli army systematically uses police dogs to brutally attack Palestinian civilians, with at least one reported rape
Maximum-Hall-5614@reddit
Hey u/dandan1993 where are ya, babe? The evidence you asked for has been provided in spades.
No response?
Such a brave, morally superior Israeli 🥰
Poltergeist97@reddit
Any response? Oh right, you didn't expect people to post receipts. Hope they still cleared your hasbara paycheck!
Zakaru99@reddit
Wild how immediately you shut up when you got countless articles proving how bullshit your perspective is.
_Noreturn@reddit
lmao silence
rattleandhum@reddit
you shut up pretty quickly when people provided evidence, huh?
stonkmarxist@reddit
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/middle_east/3650791.stm
AzracTheFirst@reddit
Ofc he's not gonna reply now. Or claim it's AI or something.
travistravis@reddit
lol, "AI" from 2004. (I too totally expect that response)
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
The IDF even uses small children as human shields like they did with 10 years old girl in the West Bank.
"[The IDF soldiers] took the muzzle off their dog and it went straight up to the slight 10-year-old girl and sniffed her. Terrified, she pleaded to be with her mother, but the soldiers seemed to have just one phrase in accented Arabic: “Open the doors.”
The platoon pushed her up to each of the doors in her aunt’s house, according to Malak’s account, while they remained braced behind her ready to fire at whoever might be inside. One door wouldn’t open, and in her desperation to obey, the girl remembers hammering on it with her head."
https://www.theguardian.com/world/article/2024/aug/31/trauma-in-the-west-bank-after-israeli-raids-palestinian-territory
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
Have you heard about "mosquito protocol" aka using Gazan civilians to search buildings for explosives instead of dogs?
Here is IDF soldier giving his testimony to CBS news
https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.cbsnews.com/amp/news/israeli-soldier-palestinians-human-shields-gaza/
AmputatorBot@reddit
It looks like you shared an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of concerns over privacy and the Open Web. Fully cached AMP pages (like the one you shared), are especially problematic.
Maybe check out the canonical page instead: https://www.cbsnews.com/news/israeli-soldier-palestinians-human-shields-gaza/
^(I'm a bot | )^(Why & About)^( | )^(Summon: u/AmputatorBot)
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
BTselem report on Israel systematic use of Palestinians as human shields:
"Since the beginning of the occupation in 1967, Israeli security forces have repeatedly used Palestinians in the West Bank and in the Gaza Strip as human shields, ordering them to perform military tasks that risked their lives. As part of this policy, soldiers have ordered Palestinian civilians to remove suspicious objects from roads, to tell people to come out of their homes so the military can arrest them, to stand in front of soldiers while the latter shoot from behind them, and more. The Palestinian civilians were chosen at random for these tasks, and could not refuse the demand placed on them by armed soldiers."
https://www.btselem.org/human_shields
deleted_by_reddit@reddit
[removed]
AutoModerator@reddit
The comment you submitted includes a link to a social media platform run by fascist/authoritarian oligarchs and has been removed. Consider re-commenting with a link using alternative privacy-friendly frontends: https://hackmd.io/MCpUlTbLThyF6cw_fywT_g?view
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
MountainTurkey@reddit
Bank robbers would do it all the time what are talking about?
Cynixxx@reddit
Every single Hostage taking in the history of hostage taking. Every bank robbing with hostages etc
squeakynickles@reddit
What the fuck are you talking about? That's what a hostage is. Name any other time? Literally every single time there have been hostages is that time.
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
The first half of the Bible
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
The Silmarillion
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Easterlings
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
John Mcclains wife
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Sansa Stark
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Han Solo?
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Suicide Squad
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Yugis dad in Yu gi oh
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
I was gunna start looking some up but honestly it’s just all of history you silly goose. So here some fantasy examples
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
The shogunate
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Opium Wars
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
The entire middle age
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Julius Ceaser
DanDan1993@reddit
Are you having a stroke?
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
I was answering your question friend.
Moppermonster@reddit
Sure. Israel builds military command centers under residential areas for exactly this reason.
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Iran
Brave-Battle-2615@reddit
Gulf war
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
Literally Hamas leaders like Yahya Sinwar were not hiding among the hostages like Hasbara is claiming!!
Firecracker048@reddit
Is Hasbara in the room with us right now?
Literally have returned hostages saying they were kept with him constantly. I know, I know the ~~Jews~~ Israelis lie but the islamo fascist who killed, plundered and raped en mass don't lie at all
I swear the brain damage in this thread right now
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
Are these hostages in the room with us right now?
Firecracker048@reddit
Remember when a journalist reporting on the war for the Palestine Chronicle was found with a hostage? Yeah that was fun
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
And that journalist is a Hamas leader?
themightycatp00@reddit
There are hostages how testified he was in the tunnel with them and they were 100% sure it's sinwar because he talked with them
Pizzaflyinggirl2@reddit
Yes, he came once few days after 7/10, talked to the hostages in Hebrew and told them that they should not worry, that they are safe and that they would be treated well.
Objective_Stranger15@reddit
Hannibal directive, look it up.
TraditionalGap1@reddit
Damn you quieted down right quick. I guess you guys do have some sense of shame
HourEast5496@reddit
As if znazis needed a bAiT to killed Palestinians and israelis. You're acting as if we don't know your lot has Hannibal directives.
Hristo_14@reddit
Israeli citizen learns how expendable israeli citizens are to Israel, shocking amirite
mysoulalamo@reddit
Oh no, the human shield's argument. You really have nothing else? Shame on you.
DanDan1993@reddit
oh no nothing but virtue signaling to add? Shame
Sahaquiel_9@reddit
A pit of tar, that’s what you are
MrTatyo@reddit
You also straight up murdered some waving white flags. Also straight up murdered red cross workers in ambulances. You also straight up murdered the world kitchen workers in clearly marked vans by triple striking them. You also straight up shoot children in the head.
But this it was an accident? And it was Hamas fault since you had to bomb every inch of Gaza?
KaiBahamut@reddit
Israeli soldiers also killed hostages waving a white flag. they literally do not care about the hostages lives.
Kahzootoh@reddit
Not just waving a white flag, they had conversations with one of them (who avoided being killed by snipers) in Hebrew while they were pleading that they were Israelis and not to kill them- and the Israelis were so bloodthirsty that they killed him once he emerged after they convinced him to come out of hiding.
They hear him say he is Israeli in Hebrew and talk with him for 15 minutes in Hebrew, and they shoot him once he comes out.
The escaped Israelis had even put up fabric signs for aircraft to see them saying “SOS” and “help, three hostages” around the building they were sheltering in. Israeli forces had seen these signs and ignored them or decided it was a Hamas trap (and they didn’t pass the information to their replacement unit).
The whole situation was avoidable if Israeli soldiers weren’t killing everything that moved- it’s only when Israeli brutality hurts Israelis that people begin to see what they were doing to Palestinians.
ilimlidevrimci@reddit
Thats not how "bait" works. It's the opposite of taking the bait unless you mean IDF wanted to kill him more than the Palestinians.
shieeet@reddit
Hey guys, my wife baited to beat the shit out of her last night. Oh boy, i suuuuure took that bait and now she's in the hospital, all fucked up.
If it wasn't for that goddamn bait, things would never have ended up like this 🤪
BobRocksBest@reddit
The IDF would know better, they're the ones who strap live Palestinians to the hood of their jeeps as human shields.
Cynixxx@reddit
Maybe, just maybe it's not the greatest idea to try to free hostages via bombing and airstrikes. Just sayin'
squeakynickles@reddit
No one is ignoring it, that's the definition of a hostage.
modianoyyo@reddit
i thought palestinian civilians were human shields?
someone who belongs to the israeli diapered forces and is captured is a prisoner of war.
if you indiscriminately bomb gaza, you will kill the pows. very simple, unless not understanding something is your objective.
DanDan1993@reddit
I love the "indiscriminately bombing Gaza" and also the future use of "IAF dropped the equivalent of eight Hiroshima bombs on Gaza!!!11" not realizing they are totally contradictory.
I'm sure you know the definition of pow's and would tell the class here that Israeli pow's actually got what that status gives. Right?
kieranjackwilson@reddit
If Israel intentionally killed Israelis on October 7th per Haaretz
what makes you think they needed to be baited into killing Israelis two days later?
xray-pishi@reddit
Look, I'm not usually one to go around defending Israel's actions in this conflict ... but to be fair, Netanyahu only said he was gonna get the hostages back. And he did.
Say thank you, Mr and Mrs Nimrodi.
Gubbinso@reddit
Hidden history, hiding your defence of Israeli actions in this conflict I see.
xray-pishi@reddit
Bro this was not a pro Israel comment, I am suggesting these parents thank Netanyahu for killing their son.
I started hiding my comments because Reddit has rules about "supporting terrorism" and crazed Zionists were going through my history and reporting any comment that supported Gaza, one got me banned and I had to appeal.
Gubbinso@reddit
Oh my bad, I've mostly seen the strongest genocidal state supporters turn their comments off
Scientific_Socialist@reddit
Yeah same
erysanthe@reddit
Nah I had to hide my comments cause someone got be banned for a week for calling out the ethnic cleansing plan Israel wanted with putting Palestinians in South Sudan.
xray-pishi@reddit
That's cool, they generally do.
Remember that Reddit has sitewide rules against both antisemitism and "supporting terrorism". Zionists can celebrate the genocide openly on this platform while mocking Muslims and their (apocryphal) 72 virgins. Do anything even roughly equivalent in reply and a Zionist can get you a full ban. And they will dig through your history and submit permissable stuff and hope it lands on the right mod's screen.
HockeyHocki@reddit
🤦♂️
KaiBahamut@reddit
Yeah, the Nimrodi's were pretty ungrateful huh.
BabylonianWeeb@reddit
I can see his pfp and he's very Pro-Palestine
Gubbinso@reddit
Yep, it was my mistake
AutoModerator@reddit
The link you have provided contains keywords for topics associated with an active conflict, and has automatically been flaired accordingly. If the flair was not updated, the link submitter MUST do so. Due to submissions regarding active conflicts generating more contrasting discussion, comments will only be available to users who have set a subreddit user flair, and must strictly comply with subreddit rules. Posters who change the assigned post flair without permission will be temporarily banned. Commenters who violate Reddiquette and civility rules will be summarily banned.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.