Exhibition on “ten centuries of Polish Russophobia” opens in Moscow
Posted by BubsyFanboy@reddit | anime_titties | View on Reddit | 70 comments
A new exhibition titled “Ten Centuries of Polish Russophobia” has opened in Moscow, organised by a Kremlin-linked historical society.
As well as accusing Poles of longstanding and unjusified anti-Russian sentiment, the display presents a revisionist view of history in keeping with the Kremlin’s narrative – but in contradiction to established historical facts.
That includes downplaying Soviet responsibility for the Katyn massacres, in which 22,000 Polish military officers and members of the intelligentsia were executed during World War Two.
The exhibition opened on Monday on Gogolevsky Boulevard in central Moscow. It was organised by the Russian Military Historical Society (RMHS), which was established in 2012 by Vladimir Putin to “counter attempts to distort Russian history” and which is overseen by the defence and culture ministries.
“The exhibition is dedicated to the question of why Russophobia has become the foundation of Polish political consciousness today,” said RMHS’s academic director, Mikhail Myagkov.
His organisation also suggest the exhibition will show how “the origins of modern neo-Nazism in Poland are deeply rooted in history”. In actual fact, neo-Nazism is a completely marginal phenomenon in Poland, and the country has strict laws against the promotion of Nazi or other fascist ideologies.
Vot Tak, a Russian-language news service operated by Belsat, which is owned by Polish state broadcaster TVP, notes that the exhibition “reiterates fake news and Russian propaganda narratives”.
According to the RMHS, for example, the exhibition presents evidence that “a German trace is evident” in the Katyn massacres despite Polish claims that “only the Russians are to blame” for the killings.
When evidence of the massacres first came to light in 1943, the Soviets blamed them on Nazi Germany, a position Moscow maintained until the 1990s, when it finally admitted responsibility for the crime. However, in recent years, Russia has begun to move back towards its former position.
Another section of the exhibition focuses on Poland’s recent policy of removing dozens of communist-era monuments honouring the Red Army, whose “soldiers died liberating Poland”, in the words of the RMHS. “These actions can be explained solely by Russophobia,” it adds.
Poland, however, does not see Soviet actions in 1944-45 as a liberation, however, given that they resulted in further decades of brutal communist rule imposed by Moscow. It removes Red Army monuments in order to eliminate symbols of totalitarian rule from public spaces.
Some parts of the exhibition also look at events since Russia’s “special military operation” in Ukraine in 2022, including making the false claim that Poland wants to occupy western Ukraine, which was Polish territory before World War Two. Warsaw has expressed no such intention.
The exhibition also covers earlier periods of Russian-Polish relations. A display on the 1919-1921 Soviet-Polish War describes Poland as “an instrument of western aggression against Russia”.
Józef Piłsudski, the leader of the newly independent Polish state established in 1918, was “a German protégé, [who] believed that the Poles should march to Moscow and write on the Kremlin walls, ‘Speaking Russian is forbidden’,” said Myagkov.
“Today we see that Polish political leaders are continuing Piłsudski’s policy, guided by the old slogan: ban everything Russian,” he added. “Successive rulers of the country only speak negatively of Russia.”
“They’ve surrendered their territory to NATO. They’re preparing a war against us. And Poland itself is initiating this conflict,” he continued, adding that “only a victory” in Ukraine will “slow this Russophobic trend in Poland”.
Poland’s political leaders are indeed almost universally critical of Russia. However, such criticism has come in response to Russian aggression against Ukraine, as well as other countries such as Georgia.
Recent years have also seen the Polish authorities uncover numerous espionage and sabotage operations orchestrated by Russia in Poland.
In response to those developments, Poland has significantly ramped up defence spending and other security measures. However, it emphasises that such policies are defensive in nature, and no Polish government has expressed any intention of attacking Russia or sending troops to Ukraine.
At the time of writing, there had been no official response from Poland to the new exhibition in Moscow.
Apart-Apple-Red@reddit
Because Russia is threatening pretty much everyone around, I dare to say they can't accuse anyone of Russophobia.
A phobia is an uncontrollable, irrational, and lasting fear of a certain object, situation, or something.
Fear of Russia and their "culture" is completely justifiable and rational therefore the term Russophobia doesn't apply when describing Poland and Polish convictions.
Anyway, whatever Russia is unhappy about, Russia can blame itself for that.
vapenutz@reddit
We really don't care about Russia much, till they start wars in our neighborhood and threaten to conquer us and our friends. Which doesn't fly well here, because Russia has a long history of doing precisely that.
If they weren't on that shit again I'd love to forget they exist. Hell, I'd love for relations to improve between us. For that, I just simply call for total disarmament of Russian offensive military capabilities - then we might follow suit. You have my word that we don't want anything from them.
They also need to give Ukraine all their terroritory back, stop backing separatists, and give back all territory belonging to the so-called separatist groups. This would be a good start of showing goodwill.
If those things won't happen I suggest we just get armed to our teeth and get ready to bomb Moscow if they attack. That also works. If they have such issues with refineries right now, imagine if the country shooting would have multiple times the GDP of the one they're fighting right now, I'm sure this will work well.
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
No, Europe is becoming more and more fascistized, and the biggest stupidity is to be kind, since fascists perceive kindness as weakness.
historicusXIII@reddit
Russia not funding our far right parties would help a lot there.
vapenutz@reddit
Your yapping means nothing to us 🤷♂️ It's you bitching all the time that your victims have the indecency of defending themselves after all
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
Remind me how many victims of American aggression did Europe help?
vapenutz@reddit
Remind me what Russia has been doing in Syria supporting a dictator that shelled his own population using chemical weapons?
You know, when Wagner got that magical smackdown there once you tried to attack the US forces there?
Messier_-82@reddit
Oh so now you’re anti dictatorship regimes, you shouldn’t have problems with what Russia is doing in Ukraine then
vapenutz@reddit
Ivan, this bait is such a shitty quality you should be ashamed of your work. Is this how little they pay you in SPB for this shit? Do better next time. Very bad tradecraft.
Messier_-82@reddit
I know it’s hard addressing your own hypocrisy, but this response is so generic come on
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
According to the Americans who were stealing Syrian oil at the time, and by a strange coincidence, ISIS fighters in Syria were traveling to Israel for treatment.
vapenutz@reddit
https://oilprice.com/Energy/Crude-Oil/Snubbed-in-Syria-Russia-Now-Makes-a-Move-on-Syrian-Oil.html
fretnbel@reddit
Russia has no free elections. You’re the last one to complain about fascism.
Czart@reddit
Moscow is running their own version of "degenerate art exhibition" but sure, it's europe that's the problem.
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
What is the problem with historical facts?
Czart@reddit
Lmao. Let's start that they couldn't even name the thing factually, given that russia didn't exist 10 centuries ago. Nice try, 3/10.
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rus%27_chronicles
Czart@reddit
Wow, look at that, no one even bothered to write in moscow for 500 years.
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
So, the people change when the authorities move the capital?
Alaknar@reddit
Oooh, you're one of those morons who think that Ukraine is just "russia but elsewhere" and that russia started out as Kievan Rus?
Get fucked.
Apart-Apple-Red@reddit
Well, that's something 🤣
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
Isn't Poland an example of a country that licks the ass of the strongest?
Apart-Apple-Red@reddit
Oh, so that's what hurts Russians 🤣🤣🤣🤣
TrizzyG@reddit
Russian society has this malaise that everyone's out to get them, hence this kind of nonsense exhibitionism. It's been kicked into overdrive these past few years too.
I used to think it was an interesting phenomenon but then you see the same garbage repeated with every society which fumbles and goes through national embarrassments.
wq1119@reddit
Russian Nationalists and Zionists have the exact same copypastas and worldview to the extent it's not even funny, just switch the words "Ukraine" with "Hamas", "Neo-Nazis" with "Jihadists", "NATO" with "Iran", "Stepan Bandera" with "Hajj Amin al-Hussein", and "Russophobia" with "Anti-Semitism/Blood Libel" and that's it.
Mein_Bergkamp@reddit
Even for this sub trying to equate the Russian claims that people are out to get them with a country that has had at least three existential wars in less than a century and was founded off the back of a genocide is spectacular.
mediandude@reddit
Empires and imperialists do not practice nationalism.
Imperialists practice a forced form of internationalism.
Nationalism is a bottom-up LOCAL democratic decisionmaking process to upkeep the LOCAL social contract, LOCAL native culture and language and people. Nationalism is NOT about forcibly spreading any of that onto other (non-native) lands. Becoming one with the land and environment (nativity) is a long natural process, it usually takes about 1000 years, give or take 2x, assuming the prior local natives have been fully assimilated or disappeared.
An optimal size of a nation state is that of a nordic country - about 1 to 10 million people with a population density about 10-20 persons per km2. Thus nationalism and a nation state does not scale beyond 1 million km2, usually much less than that.
teo_vas@reddit
well it is not exactly the same situation. nobody tried to systematically exterminate Russians. I mean at least for radical zionists, there is an excuse (legit or not). also nobody from Russia's neighbors officially declared that their purpose was to exterminate the Jewish state of Israel. so you know, I kinda agree with the general tone, there are similarities, but not exactly the same thing.
Dense_Tax5787@reddit
The Nazis were pretty open to exterminate, albeit through different means, the Russian (and Slavic) people. Certainly wasn’t to the same extent as they went after the Jews but let’s not undersell what happened over 4 years on the eastern front.
b0_ogie@reddit
The peoples of the USSR, especially the Slavs, suffered more than the Jews. 3 million Jews died in concentration camps (and 3 million outside the camps) and more than 4 million Slavs (and 10 million during the occupation).
wq1119@reddit
When it came to Slavs, Nazi Germany planned that 1/3 would be exterminated, and the other two halves would be enslaved and assimilated/Germanized respectively.
vvvvfl@reddit
Bulgarians still today deal with this. There is a whole national identity narrative about them being not slavic.
aurumtt@reddit
The better analogy is hungary, where orban also desperately tries to legitimize the concept of widespead magyarphobia in europe. Its ofc pathetic as this is non-existent.
lol_alex@reddit
It‘s the famous Russian paranoia. Lasted through the Czars, Communism and now the Putin era.
XWasTheProblem@reddit
IT's the same thing with every flavour of regime.
A regime needs some sort of a terrifying enemy that is constantly out to get them or they cannot exist.
Frosty-Perception-48@reddit
Should I remind you that Canada supports US intervention on the other side of the world for pitiful reasons? Or perhaps the reason is that the US covered up the sterilization of native women by Canadian authorities?
TrizzyG@reddit
Nice schizopost but im not seeing the relevance here? Did your sensibilities get hurt or something?
kapsama@reddit
Russians attacks against Poland will continue until Polish opinion on Russians improves.
Extension-Street323@reddit
the most delusional statement ever produced
Alaknar@reddit
You're either a bot with the wrong flag, or you need to re-read what he wrote...
jakiki624@reddit
same for Israel
Ugkvrtikov@reddit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Polish%E2%80%93Russian_War_(1609%E2%80%931618) lets start from the beginning
Nahcep@reddit
Let's start from the actual beginning
teo_vas@reddit
well that's not the beginning if the Russophobia is ten centuries old.
Ugkvrtikov@reddit
Ok i worded it incorrectly, I don't know about the whole ten centuries, but lets not pretend they hate you for no reason whatsoever.
IntrepidAd2478@reddit
Russia had helped dismantle the Polish Lithuanian Commonwealth in the 18th century and tried to Russify the whole of Russian controlled Poland.
Ugkvrtikov@reddit
Yeah i wonder why
IntrepidAd2478@reddit
Why do you not give us your idea then?
Ugkvrtikov@reddit
It's all in my link, if a foreign power poses a threat to you and did invade and occupy you in the past you will surely dismantle it so it doesn't happen again. As for dismantling other states that can potentially be a threat to you in any way i am sure you as American know something about it.
malakambla@reddit
No, you worded it carelessly at best. Let's not go to the beginning, let's go to the first Polish-Russian war as opposed to the second that you linked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Livonian_campaign_of_Stephen_B%C3%A1thory
Ugkvrtikov@reddit
With my link i was preferring to Polish invasion and occupation, and reasons for retribution later, among others, Livonian campaign was something else
malakambla@reddit
And the conflicts didn't start with the time of troubles. But if you want to call the following 4 centuries of Russian aggression as retribution stemming from occupation of Moscow, then I might as well call the occupation of Moscow the retribution for previous conflicts.
Apart-Apple-Red@reddit
And what are the reasons now?
I guess Russia is Polonophobe?
Would you agree?
Ohforfs@reddit
Ten centuries is absurd first real contact wasn't until we got into union with Lithuania.
But the absurdity is to be expected from Muscovites.
Mortarius@reddit
It's phobia when irrational, ism when justified. When it comes to Russia It's rationalism.
Impr3ss1v3@reddit
Yeah man, I am a fucking terrorist too. Killed 194729292 Ukranians yesterday and ate 2848294729 babies.
Every Russian is a bloodthirsty brute, everybody knows that.
Keep carrying the burden of being the righteous nation. That never invaded Ukraine or Russia. Polish are the most peaceful people ever, everybody know that. Literal angels.
LatterTarget7@reddit
Russiaphobia isn’t a thing. They just love attacking and threatening their neighbours and any country they dislike. If Russia wasn’t such a warmongering country they wouldn’t be any ill will towards them
gormful-brightwit@reddit
Normal countries' foreign policy - mutual interests, cooperation, trade, shared values. In other words it's about mutual respect.
Russian foreign policy - spreading of terror, intimidation, threats of nuclear destruction and extortion. Everything is about being feared and not about respect. Then they turn around and cry about their neighbours fearing them even though that was their goal in the first place .
Messier_-82@reddit
Western countries doesn’t fit your definition of Normal
gormful-brightwit@reddit
according to you. Thanks for adding nothing
Messier_-82@reddit
I mean should I list the history of Europe and America terrorising the outside world and even their allies in some cases?
PerunVult@reddit
To paraphrase Jean Luc-Picard
"The age old cry of the oppressor"
There is no such a thing as 'russophobia'.
https://youtu.be/uBz9EeLeQ8w
And there never will be. I am certain of that.
AFloppyZipper@reddit
Could we please not start WW3 over Poland again. Let them have their country, they are doing just fine. They aren't bothering anyone. What's the point. You have enough land.
Yeah you don't have ports and I get it. Tough shit. Nukes are enough, common sense.
trungbrother1@reddit
The Russian political class never lived down the spectacular collapse of the USSR, because they got so used to claiming that Soviet achievements are actually Russian achievements, and Russian shortcomings are actually Soviet/Eastern Bloc shortcomings. The hardship of the 90s ingrained those thoughts even further.
trungbrother1@reddit
The Russian political class never lived down the spectacular collapse of the USSR, because they got so used to claiming that Soviet achievements are actually Russian achievements, and Russian shortcomings are actually Soviet/Eastern Bloc shortcomings. The hardship of the 90s ingrained those thoughts even further.
LaSage@reddit
Russian soldiers are long known for raping Women, men, and of course other Russian soldiers. Any phobia or dislike is warranted.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dedovshchina
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexual_violence_in_the_Russian_invasion_of_Ukraine
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rape_during_the_Soviet_occupation_of_Poland
https://www.eiu.edu/historia/Thomas.pdf
https://www.bbc.com/news/magazine-32529679
https://www.theguardian.com/books/2002/may/01/news.features11
https://www.france24.com/en/tv-shows/focus/20230224-rape-used-as-weapon-of-war-by-russian-forces-in-ukraine
https://www.forbes.com/sites/ewelinaochab/2022/10/14/united-nations-rape-is-part-of-russias-military-strategy/
https://news.un.org/en/story/2025/03/1161281
https://news.un.org/en/story/2023/09/1141417
https://www.americanbar.org/groups/international_law/resources/international-law-news/2023-winter/uses-rape-military-weapon-russian-forces-ukraine/
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(04)16036-4/abstract
https://uacrisis.org/en/rosijski-soldaty-gvaltuyut-ditej-na-ochah-batkiv-na-harkivshhyni
https://jamestown.org/program/mass-rape-of-chechen-men-by-federal-forces-2/
https://www.cnn.com/2024/05/30/europe/russia-sexual-violence-occupied-ukraine-intl-cmd
https://www.ecchr.eu/en/case/sexual-violence-by-members-of-the-russian-armed-forces-federal-public-prosecutor-must-investigate/
https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/article/2024/jul/23/central-african-republic-women-girls-rape-sexual-violence-conflict-food-security-wagner-russian-mercenaries-un
https://www.reuters.com/world/europe/ukraine-accuses-russian-snipers-abusing-child-gang-raping-mother-2023-03-14/
https://www.nytimes.com/2023/10/21/world/europe/russia-war-crimes-ukraine.html
https://www.cnn.com/2022/11/02/europe/russia-ukraine-kherson-sexual-violence-intl
https://united24media.com/war-in-ukraine/russian-wartime-violence-history-to-present-5694
Jealous_Lobster_36@reddit
This is absolutely ridiculous, I'd call it shameful but I'm not sure Russia is even capable of feeling shame anymore. This would be akin to the UK doing an exhibition on "8 centuries of Irish Anglophobia"
Soepkip43@reddit
I'd argue a phobia is an unrational fear.. like them coming to destroy your country and gang press people into labor, remove your freedoms and treat you like second class people.. but then you would do something unreasonable like, point to a history book..
lord_alberto@reddit
I wonder what they wrote about what happened with Poland in the 19th century, abd why it disapeared from the maps.
I guess Poland did infiltrate Russia undercover or so, evil Poland!
Multibuff@reddit
I find these exhibitions to be quite interesting. There was a good one on Finnish Russophobia about a year ago, also in Moscow I believe. I’m waiting patiently on the Norwegian Russophobia exhibition