The fall of the United States
Posted by DogFennel2025@reddit | collapse | View on Reddit | 491 comments
Location: I think the USA is collapsing. I’ve been thinking about the fall of the Soviet Union. I was pretty young at the time and I don’t remember a lot about it, but here is an article: https://www.britannica.com/event/the-collapse-of-the-Soviet-Union. I don’t think Gorbachev was demented, but the coup leaders did claim he was unwell.
Articles: Mike Johnson denying that Trump is unhinged: https://www.thedailybeast.com/mike-johnson-caught-on-camera-admitting-trump-is-unwell/
JD Vance excusing trumps racist videos: https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politics/jd-vance-sombrero-racism-hakeem-jeffries-b2837575.html
Some things are different now but I see a parallel. A few men led the country into dissolution: we have the same. The military was used against civilians: ditto. Immigrants were blamed. The economy was not doing well before the collapse - we are staring down those railroad tracks (wondering about the light we see approaching). Food production was suffering: rising grocery prices.
What is different: social media, climate collapse (meaning agriculture is not going to be reparable.)
I know that people in this sub like scientific articles. I think these events are so new that there are no articles. I would like to hear from people who are historians. Am I seeing something real?
Lovefool1@reddit
So where is a good place to move
FebruaryEcho@reddit
I’m just betting on high elevation.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
We don’t know where is a good place to move to. The world’s entire climate is shifting.
AirAssault_502@reddit
The collapse of the United States is mimicking the collapse of the Soviet Union. I always figured it would happen that way, years of political unrest, coupled with less wars, and trillions of debt. It was only a matter of time before things would inevitably hit the wall. The question we need to ask ourselves is yes it’s going to collapse, but what happens after the collapse where do we go and what do we do?
It’s something that everyone’s gonna have to think about in terms of jobs assets and whatever else may have you. It could lead to a full revolution in this country which we’ve been overdue for, or another first world, power invade, and conquer us. Personally, I’m thinking that the United States will dissolve in split into different regions that would probably war with one another over goods and products and what not.
Something I’ve always wondered is during and post collapse what happens to people’s debt? Whether it’s credit card debt or school debt loans whatever might be where does all that go if our political system in banking system is uprooted
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I, too, think we will split into smaller countries by region. And I’m stuck in Florida - sigh . . .
As regards debt: That is a fascinating question. I don’t know. What about bank accounts? I get paper statements every month just in case the bank gets cyber-attacked and I have to prove I have savings. But if the banking system flops - obviously I need to think about this idea. Thanks!
Depends_on_theday@reddit
Hi from Florida we can share fruit n veggies
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
The plant I’ve been most successful with is pigeon peas. They are a perennial legume here in polk county. Here’s an article about them from the UF (I’m a Master Gardener.)
EDIS.ifas.ufl.edu/publication/EP622
Depends_on_theday@reddit
Thanks! I realise I offered to share fruit and vegetables and yet have not been successful with one single plant. We’re hoping to try a raised bed this winter.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I recommend contacting your local extension. They might even have classes! I’ve also been pretty successful with mustard greens.
lunudehi@reddit
If there is significant inflation and/or devaluation of the USD, debts get effectively wiped out or at least significantly smaller. I am not sure how anyone goes about making sense of it all after the fact though - like if a half a million dollar mortgage goes unpaid to a bank that no longer exists, what happens to the house?
AirAssault_502@reddit
Well I would hope people keep their houses. Banks get wiped out, no bills. More than likely it would be a crap show, and I can’t imagine cops or the military forcing people out of their homes due to this. By then civil unrest would cause too much of an issue for them in more urban/ population dense areas. Suburbs for the most part would be in some sort of turmoil. Guess we need to see.
Seeing debt wiped out would be lovely. We can all start fresh
SnazzieBorden@reddit
I’m not a historian but I think people like you who have been through it before have valuable insight. You’d know better than those who’ve lived in the U.S. our whole lives. Like the meme says, this is my first dictatorship (collapse).
I did just see a you tube video from someone with an economics background saying we were headed for the point of no return of economic collapse. I’ll see if I can find it.
VegasBonheur@reddit
I think the point of no return is somewhere behind us, so obscured that it’ll take historians decades of research and debate to agree on what exactly it was.
CalligrapherSharp@reddit
I've read multiple articles where people claim it was 2003, apparently the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan is typical late-stage empire flailing.
oxero@reddit
Not only was citizens united passed after 9/11 which set up all the current privacy nightmare, the invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan did absolutely nothing besides cost us trillions of dollars and waste valuable resources which could have been better used, on top of giving thousands of veterans horrific PTSD and other life long injuries.
Some could also say that Bush stealing the election was also the tipping point too, by not properly recounting and the Supreme Court ruling Bush won, it was an antidemocratic move which set all of this up in the first place which we never recovered from.
But honestly, all of this probably could have been overturned and cut short when Obama took over, but it wasn't, and Republicans stonewalled pretty much everything Obama tried to do which straight up locked our Government into this whole situation.
So if I had to pick a date of a point of no return, it would probably be Obama's second term starting in 2012. By then Facebook was already a threat to democratic countries world wide, yet no one lifted a finger to stop them from laying the status quo of algorithms pushing false misinformation, our global leaders didn't understand technology one bit to make proper regulations on it. Facebook during Obama's second term created an alternative universe for most people in ways Fox News never could have dreamed of. I personally remember being on Reddit laughing at anti-vaxxers that were just forming small groups, but left unchecked their bullshit attracted more and more people. Likewise Republicans started going off the deep end with the Tea Party and 4chan type conspiracy theories started to resonate with all these boomers connecting on Facebook. By the time 2016 rolled around and Trump was elected, every single Republican voting for him was in their own parallel universe clouded by lack of education and fueled by false misinformation and conspiracy. Without regulations placed on Facebook and other social media to stop this, there was no more proper education back bone which could guarantee our Democracy could survive, and it's also one of the reasons we see so many countries currently sliding along with us into the darkness of authoritarianism.
Key-Increase-6243@reddit
You skipped the 2008 bank bailout. No consequences for bad actors, why bother being good? All war is economic
wikiwikiwildwildjest@reddit
How close the bush/gore election was makes it feel like the perfect tipping point. Down to a few thousand votes and the countries trajectories would have been vastly different. No Cheney and his creating value for Halliburton shareholders, pushing for a war in a country unrelated to 9/11 that lasted 9 years. It's such glaring corruption and clear sign that the people who came into power at that time were focused on using their power for personal gain and not to invest in America's future. If Al Gore won I think we could have focused the country on future technologies like EV's, high speed rail, and renewable energy. Instead we abdicated that position to China so oil companies could keep their market share.
RagingBillionbear@reddit
If Gore won 2000 he would have lost 2004 brutally. I doubt Gore would have stopped 9/11 and that would mean both the Oklahoma city bombing and 9/11 would have happen under the same Democratic administration. With the exception of FDR no party has had control of president for more that four terms.
The turning point I have, what if Ron Paul won the 2012 Republican primary.
livlaffluv420@reddit
It was when they killed JFK.
UmmUhhhShit@reddit
I would probably say it was sometime in the late 60s to early 70s, there’s a really interesting YouTube video that talks about 1971. The rise of newt Gingrich in the 70s, roger ailes, the southern strategy, basically the consolidation of the religious extremists into one of the political parties who are voting as a bloc based on religious belief instead of political principles happened around then.
https://youtu.be/HchNA3a9L5E
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
Who created this garbage? The ADL or the SPLC?
PTSDeedee@reddit
Goliath by Matt Stoller also outlines how this was a time when politics shifted and democrats began allowing monopolies to flourish.
I think the bigger issue is that we let confederate leaders / former slave owners keep their power after the civil war. There should have been Nuremberg-type trials with death and life sentences. Instead, they kept their money and influence, and their descendants have used that power for evil too.
But going back even further? This country was founded on atrocities, and it was probably always headed for this. We stole this land and murdered the millions who had called it home for millennia before us, then never faced justice for it.
livlaffluv420@reddit
Specifically, November 22 1963…
holistivist@reddit
Yes! The Thirteenth is a great documentary that goes into this. It’s wild to see Gingrich literally admit to it all.
Collapse2043@reddit
The re-election of Trump was the point of no return. The beginning was with Reagan and Newt Gingrich,
spicy_noodle_guy@reddit
Which when you really think about it is barely any time at all.
AbbeyRoadMomma@reddit
You have to admire the bastards for their perseverance.
spicy_noodle_guy@reddit
It was Trumps first term. Sure lots of stuff set that up and we could go all the way back to the reconstruction period if we wanted to follow that line of causality. But fundamentally the first time Trump gained power and proved the GOPs theory of governance correct was the moment we were destined for this point. If Kamala wins we just see them try with another Trump like until it works. His first term proved it was the most winnable way to play the game for them and he only didn't get reelected right away because he fumbled the softest ball of a global pandemic he could have been handed.
25TiMp@reddit
JFK, the assassination of a sitting President, was a start.
Cloaked42m@reddit
The point of no return was the Obama Birth Certificate.
No one was willing to just call it stupid and refuse to platform it.
soulstaz@reddit
We have a looming environmental collapse, financial collapse and general economic collapse in the pipeline.
I'm slightly confused about the end game of the ultra wealthy. Chaos isn't good to keep power intact, status quo is the best tool for that.
Square-Confidence650@reddit
These are people who've successfully convinced themselves that their efforts are actually worth 1000x + the salary of one of their employees. They think theyre so smart and special that they'll be the ones to rise above the turmoil
SqurrrlMarch@reddit
I reckon they're so sociopathic they don't care once they're in their bunkers and have control of every possible resource there may be left. Mass attrition of the population is part of the collapse. I reckon the death and immediate catastrophes people will have to deal with will outweigh the "chaos" you think is detrimental to power. That's not how narcissistic abuse/power works. It feeds on chaos.
Status quo is the best tool for democratic republics, not fascist regimes.
MistyMtn421@reddit
I can't remember if it was Miller or a p2025 reference, but their goal is to have no more then 100 million people in the states. They want to eliminate over 2/3 of the population.
nahivibes@reddit
Then wtf why’d they restrict abortion.
roytay@reddit
They're the dog that caught the car on abortion. Besides the basic desire to control women, it was a great tool to divide us.
Since then, they've had to hit harder on immigration and trans issues.
spicy_noodle_guy@reddit
Because they hate women. It's really not more complex or deep than that. Women having the autonomy of their own bodies enrages them, because it means that rape and other tools they use to hurt women lose some of their power.
Rdr2-4-Life@reddit
Well restricting abortion kinda results in more people dying than living, birth mortality rates go up, people who cant afford to have a child but are forced to will struggle financially which makes them more vulnerable to all the other changes the administration’s changes, i dunno maybe theres more statistics on this
Express-Thought6057@reddit
To what end?
spicy_noodle_guy@reddit
Control. It's one of the long term goals of the ghouls that have been destroying our society. They believe that population control is the key to their continued exploitation of us and the world.
score_@reddit
Consolidate control. Eliminate dissidents and the "wrong type" of people.
PTSDeedee@reddit
Here it is from The Guardian: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jun/15/trump-immigration-stephen-miller-influence
SqurrrlMarch@reddit
oh good.
spicy_noodle_guy@reddit
This is one of the great failures that society has made when trying to stop these people. They don't care, because they are mentally ill. You don't do what these people do and have a sane mind. We let the sickest of us take control of and mold the world into the shape that makes the most sense to them. You need only look around to see that the shape is far from one that even the most selfish or greedy could have conjured. The world we live in could only have been forged in the minds of the ill.
americend@reddit
They aren't controlling what's happening. They are benefiting, but not directing. No one is steering the ship.
LifeClassic2286@reddit
They are unable to think that far ahead. Wealth warps their minds and they lose perspective and empathy. This has been scientifically studied - there are physical brain changes that occur with high levels of wealth.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you c
Traditional_Way1052@reddit
I'm not the person who you replied to but I find these guy, a historian from the US originally but working in Denmark, really interesting.
This one was really ... Bittersweet, both upsetting and comforting to hear.
https://youtu.be/x1btBm-081A?si=p90FShQOR82_XcgQ
archontwo@reddit
All very articulate, but he is conspicuously omitting this did not start with Trump.
Successive administrations have behaved consistently at home and abroad almost predictably doing regime changes and unnecessary wars while simultaneously cutting social services and letting infrastructure for transport, energy and water fall to rack and ruin.
It has been going on for 30 years at least.
Traditional_Way1052@reddit
That's accurate, however I believe he's mentioned it's going on for years in other videos.
archontwo@reddit
Well, to be honest I only watched the video shared and it seemed to meche was very much framing it as a 'now' problem. It is not.
If he does, indeed go back decades and exposed the rot of politic by money and lobbying as well as a perverse ideology that gives rise to American exceptionlism and hubris that gives it the self appointed right to be 'The policemen of the world39, then I guess he knows his stuff.
But this shared video did not impress me much, is all I can say.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you!
WontLieToYou@reddit
Your comment reminds me of an article I read years ago that I think of often, as it becomes more and more relevant. The author was explaining how his American friends don't understand Democratic collapse the way others who lived through it do. The Americans keep saying stuff like "our Constitution protects..." or "that would be illegal here because..." The people who lived through it kept trying to explain that tyrants do not care what is legal. They will just do whatever they want. Laws are whatever those in power say they are.
As an American, I no longer feel I need this explained to me.
alibythesea@reddit
I’m still seeing that all over social media! Guess what, people, Trump and his minions/handlers don’t give a damn if something is illegal. They will do it anyway, and even if in the end, the Supreme Court rules against the more egregious moves into dictatorship, they still will not care. Who is going to stop them? Barring a military coup, who can stop them?
fedfuzz1970@reddit
I am so sick of people framing the problems and shouting, "listen to what happened today!" The worst are the refugees from the political parties and the main stream media-continually reciting the outrage of the day as if people don't read and/or have a sense of what is going on. They're cheerleaders but not leaders, influencers but not Action Jacksons. Boycott, work stoppages, something that impacts their wallets is needed-joint, coordinated action. Of course that would impact our wallets, so .....
Cultural-Answer-321@reddit
This.
Tyrants don't care about law.
ImportantDetective65@reddit
Here is a recording of a talk by Richard Wolff's last warning
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XedaCaRbw6A&list=PLtEv6GJmON62zbk4DwAcK4HXLpPL5NqRZ&index=7
reeeelllaaaayyy823@reddit
!remindme two days Link to the video please?
RemindMeBot@reddit
I will be messaging you in 2 days on 2025-10-08 02:07:28 UTC to remind you of this link
CLICK THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.
^(Parent commenter can ) ^(delete this message to hide from others.)
ri1357@reddit
Quality of life in America has always declined every year but it’s speeding up now. I think it’s going to be bad very soon
Alena_Tensor@reddit
Sorry didn’t mean to imply Powell was from that time - My statement contained several items, mentioned Powell and then went on to talk about the genesis of his the movement
HowRu_123@reddit
The US collapsed in 2008.
StealthFocus@reddit
💯 I knew it was important as we went through it but nearly 20 years later you can see how it opened the floodgates to where we are.
That Obama allowed it all to slide after being elected to clean house was such an unforced error and something I’ll never forgive him.
Depends_on_theday@reddit
If u don’t mind, in simple terms, how did Obama contribute. I’m politically homeless cuz it’s too much info and I have schoolwork due kids to feed diapers to change and a job to clock into so I just get lost in the sauce trying to figure it all out.
StealthFocus@reddit
His refusal to prosecute anyone who participated in the crimes. He took a lot of Wall St money for his campaigns and instead of cleaning house he let things fester and they got worse. Trump came about directly as a result of Obamas policies, I don’t recall the percent without looking it up but there’s a substantial overlap of voters between the two. People disillusioned with the system. It’s also sick that they’re now trying to whitewash Bush legacy through his autistic paintings as if he’s some grandfatherly figure and not a bloodthirsty war criminal. And worst of all the fucking Chaneys.
Depends_on_theday@reddit
Really interesting and I’m one of the disillusioned. Thx for your comment
Wide-Chart-7591@reddit
I think people overuse collapse narratives because they want villains instead of systems. It’s comforting to point to a single figure (like Trump) or a single moment and say “this is the reason everything’s falling apart.” But collapse when it does happen is almost never about one man or one event. It’s a slow erosion of legitimacy, trust, and belief in the story a society tells about itself.
The U.S. is under strain polarization, inequality, institutional decay but it’s not the same as the Soviet Union. That state was built around a single ideological myth, and when that myth died, so did the structure. The U.S., for all its dysfunction, still runs on a shared (if contested) narrative: constitutionalism, “the people,” free markets. Even the loudest critics still operate within those assumptions rather than rejecting them outright.
What people interpret as “collapse” might really be a transformation, a shift from unipolar dominance to multipolar reality, from blind faith in institutions to skepticism about them. That’s messy and dangerous, but it isn’t necessarily terminal. And if we mistake every crack in the system for the end of the system, we risk misunderstanding what’s actually happening and miss our chance to shape what comes next
Depends_on_theday@reddit
That’s hopeful Ty
A313-Isoke@reddit
I think US constitutionalism is dead. We don't run on that anymore under this Administration. And, a lot of MAGA has no problem with that.
I've been trying to read everything I can about techno-feudalism, platform authoritarianism, Curtis Yarvin (who wants a monarchy), etc. because that's what Big Tech wants.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
That is a very interesting comment. Thank you. I’m going to think about what you wrote.
Wide-Chart-7591@reddit
The shift is that the U.S. is no longer the lone superpower calling all the shots on the global stage. Today we’re facing competition from other rising powers like China, Russia, and others that are shaping the world’s future. For many Americans, this shift feels like decline, largely because we’re comparing today’s realities to one of the most prosperous periods in U.S. history the mid-20th century, particularly the 1950s to the late 1970s. Looking back at how our parents or grandparents lived, it's easy to wonder what happened to that sense of prosperity and security.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I get it. Thanks.
marssaxman@reddit
The US certainly was the lone superpower for at least a couple of decades, basically by definition, because the term "superpower" was invented just after WWII to describe the globally dominant roles of the United States, Soviet Union, and British Empire. The UK lost their empire shortly after, so for almost seventy years the USA and the USSR stood apart as the two superpowers, the rivalry between the Western Bloc and the Eastern Bloc dominating basically all geopolitics. After the collapse of the USSR in 1991, then, the USA was left as the only superpower remaining.
It would be reasonable to claim that China has now grown to become a second superpower, but the US genuinely had no rival in its capacity to project global power for almost thirty years.
Wide-Chart-7591@reddit
To a large extent, yeah, I do think we were. Does that justify every intervention? No. If it interests you I also think a lot of U.S. intervention has been driven by the deeper story we tell ourselves. that democracy equals progress, and that spreading it is a kind of civilizing mission. That narrative shaped foreign policy just as much as material power did.
truthful32@reddit
I have made the wager that the USA will fall into civil war in the late summer of 2026,if not then than I say within the next 5 years after that.I will admit if a civil war doesn’t happen I’m just objectively wrong, but I’ve been thinking about this since 2023.
Depends_on_theday@reddit
What does a civil war look like to you? I still suck at gardening. Have a bunch of kids to feed and own no guns or ammo. I’m just A regular regular nurse trying to keep my family afloat. 45 min from trumps house.
Logical-Race8871@reddit
I think we're more likely headed for a "Years of Lead" situation than a civil war.
Americans are in a strange limbo of not really supporting either party all that much, and people's politics are all over the place and full of contradiction.
Americans belief that violence may be necessary to right the ship is growing, but the number of people who truly want civil war are less than 10%.
Liberals are still very anti-violence (outside of the police and foreign policy). They don't see it as a viable solution to problems between white people, and are 100% all in on electoralism for now.
Finally, I just don't see an issue that there is an actual clear divide on, like there was with abolition and slavery, and that took 15 years of bleeding-kansas style brewing violence and an difference in economic organization between entire regions of the country and world.
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
Left-wingers are very pro-violence, pro-terrorism - always have been
Ancient-Practice-431@reddit
That's what I think, no big bang but an inevitable slow drop off of a cliff.
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
Thomas Chittum wrote the novel Civil War 2: the coming break-up of America, predicted the civil war outbreak would start in Los Angeles in 2021. Well it didn't happen
No-Insurance100@reddit
There won't be a civil war unless there is division among the elites leading to a split within the military/security forces. The American military has only shown their complete compliance with following orders like the good little robots they are. But that should not be surprising to any observer after the American military did one atrocity after another abroad for decades without notable dissent.
There could be low-intensity prolonged political violence by non-state actors (arguably there already is in the USA) but that's not a civil war.
BenUFOs_Mum@reddit
You dont need that for a civil war.
Thats in a foriegn war, its very different asking the army to go into a US city or town and do those kinds of things. Most will do it of course but you can expect to see significant
You say that but eventually the intensity goes over an arbitrary threshold into civil war. The Troubles in Northern Ireland killed 3500 people in a country of less than 2 million. Scale that to the US population and you could be talking about half a million people dead in 30-40 years due to "low intensity violence"
truthful32@reddit
I don’t think so, I think discontent is so high with Americans and they so hate each other now that it will be a war between left vs right and the federal government now will disintegrate under this crisis.
Ancient-Practice-431@reddit
But the left/right distinction is breaking down (along with everything else) so it won't be so clear. The split between the elites will muddle things and smaller regional wars prolly start first.
truthful32@reddit
It’s largely splitting between the crowds vs the institutions on both sides Republicans and the New Right Democrats and the progressives and left
Both of these crowds make up a majority of the both sides and are consistently hating each other more and more, people are at this point ready and waiting to kill eachother,and many have already started. Crowds are very dangerous chaotic and predatory and are the greatest threat to our republic, that’s why our founders tried so hard to avoid crowd politics.
No-Insurance100@reddit
The American right is in control of government. American liberals are barely distinguishable from the right, while actual American leftists (socialists, communists, anarchists) likely number less than a million people to the point of being mostly irrelevant.
Even if there was violence between the right and the left as you interpret them to be, street brawls or even shootings is not remotely the same thing as a civil war. That would be closer to the types of small-scale sectarian violence common in many countries that has been absent from the US for decades.
truthful32@reddit
It’s very recent seizure of that. The right is still largely incapable of making its own institutions as of now and there’s a split occurring between the new right and the republicans that are currently in government that will continue to widen.The left still has control over most institutions, and most of those institutions they built, where middle management is largely headed by the college educated new leftists that largely serve as a managerial class or influencers (not in the strictly social media sense).The people running these institutions are a different type of leftist in of themselves though either they’re elites like WEF types or a few technocrats in communion with them, or Intellectuals trying to heavily influence society in their image, both of these groups largely do the same things and have the same goals though.So the left still has a large amount of power (though they are waning).
and secondly, your heavily assuming what I consider a civil war, I see the shootings, riots, street brawls as a prelude to civil war where we actually kill eachother en mass. All of the brawls shootings and riots have been happening for a minute and constantly increasing in severity and in most areas incidents too. I predict spring of 2026 will have around 1000 politically motivated deaths.
youcantkillanidea@reddit
Perhaps. Although, by "Civil War" you probably need to consider something different, a 21st century type of violence. And it's already here, LA, DC, Portland, Chicago...
ericvulgaris@reddit
how democracies die came out in 2018, 2 years into trump's first presidency by a pair of harvard professors.
it looks at cases across the world where democratic countries backslide and how/why. Then they apply that to the US. I strongly suggest you check it out.
It isn't just a few men. It's not even a recent thing. This is the culmination. It's a concerted effort going back the last US political realignment in the 60s from civil rights legislation.
Since this book came out even more of their precious "democratic norms" that underpin society have eroded into nothing.
The-Neat-Meat@reddit
The Jakarta Method is also an excellent read that is terrifying in its applicability to our current situation. All the shit the CIA got up to in the developing world and post-colonial nations for decades is now being turned inward.
TheHipcrimeVocab@reddit
The same CIA that investigated Trump's ties to Russia and whose agents are now under siege for doing so.
HikmetLeGuin@reddit
Trump has openly announced that he's using the CIA in Venezuela. He's weaponizing them against other countries just like every other president.
madcoins@reddit
that book is astonishing. Americans have no idea about it and all should read that book
slifm@reddit
The crazy part is that they didn’t even have to try that hard to get fanatics. All it took was a little push.
Collapse2043@reddit
I blame Fox News for all the cultish brainwashing. There used to be a law that News had to be balanced with both sides, both points of view presented to the audience. They need to bring that back.
Motorola68020@reddit
The idea that there are only 2 sides or 2 points of view is bananas.
Alena_Tensor@reddit
Well, it wasn’t an accident. Very wealthy ultra conservative men have conspired for decades to buy media outlets and control the messaging. Print, radio, tv, cable, most recently tic-toc. If all you read and hear is right-wing messages then that’s what you believe. Dem’s have be ostriches with their heads in the sand the whole time. Completely ignorant of the reality changing around them.
MistyMtn421@reddit
A lot of these seeds were also sown in the 80s beginning with Regan and fueled by televangelists like Robertson, Swaggert and Falwell. They helped bring right wing ideology to their followers and Regan helped bring evangelicalism to his.
CheerleaderOnDrugs@reddit
Don't underestimate right wing radio, the precursor to the podcast. Especially drug addicted, bloated bloviator Rush Limbaugh.
Rare-Information5080@reddit
Rush Limbaugh radicalized some of my best friends. They were lost to me forever. To be fair, other close friends were radicalized later - 9/11 was an inflection point. But the Trump era? Those former ones pale in comparison. I still can't wrap my head around it. He's an imbecile, a two-bit conman, a clearly insane megalomaniac and psychopath. But really really incredible stupid. Yet some kind of evil genius? Books will be written for generations (provided we live that long), but I'm not sure we'll ever get to the bottom of it. My theory? Brain worms. Or something like that. If leaded gasoline lead to high rates of violence in American cities in the 70s and 80s, then I have to think there's (at least partially) an industrial cause for why humanity has collectively lost its mind. (I think the social media alien virus is a big part of it as well.)
madcoins@reddit
I swear you’re the first person to mention his name since he left. Amazing how he was their icon and then poof he didn’t ever get referenced again. Let’s hope that happens again
MistyMtn421@reddit
That era was the water and the fertilizer to help all of those seeds grow and flourish!
madcoins@reddit
They knew they had no chance to continue winning in an overwhelmingly liberal nation. They used organized religion to help even the playing field and present them with sheep to mold
madcoins@reddit
Very well paid Ostriches. They are in the upper class. There needs to be a class… something… wow I just now received a huge bribe and forgot the last word I was going to say.
Alena_Tensor@reddit
Ha ha ha …. Well said
ImportantDetective65@reddit
Exactly this. If you want to witness it firsthand, there is a documentary called "The Family" on Netflix that investigates the conservative christian groups in DC doing their thing to prepare for this.
Be prepared for another existential crisis after watching it. This is real and happening right now.
madcoins@reddit
“War is a racket” by Smedly Butler details the business plot. the business class in America will never stop trying to destroy the working class after FDR had the audacity to aid the working class. They’ve been on a warpath for fascism ever since and aren’t going to let that slight go. Haven’t for 100 years
Admiral_Falcon@reddit
The conservatives are ostriches too. This will devolve to people killing each other over the slightest disagreement - money will NOT matter
sloppymoves@reddit
Dems are a controlled opposition party. Nothing more. Nothing less. They exist to stop any progressive movements through political theatre.
But that is what happens when both parties are controlled by and for capitalism. We are just in the end stage of capitalism now.
madcoins@reddit
It’s almost like it was dissolved under Reagan’s terrible presidency for a reason
LOGOisEGO@reddit
Man. That was back in 1985. By 89-90, Fox and every networked blew past those guidelines.
The second they had a realtime gulf-war on the eyeballs, networks gave up on ethics.
Collapse2043@reddit
Was it that long ago? I’m so old and everything feels like yesterday to me.
LOGOisEGO@reddit
Sorry for your loss man. He clearly had a great life and meant alot to others, and that is truly a gift.
And yes man, Im only pushing 40 and have seen this political and media deterioration roll out in real time since I was a kid.
Its crazy to think that fascism and authoritarian rollout can actually happen in a blink of an eye, really.
Collapse2043@reddit
Ah thanks. He was really my brother’s friend but he was hanging around our house since we were kids. He was a member of the Young Conservatives since his teens. A news report says he got involved in politics in University, I thought nope, it was before that, but whatever. I’ve always thought Canadian conservatives were a bit misguided but at least they are not crazy like the Republicans. They are more like the Democrats really and I have a few Conservative friends. As a teen he said he wanted to be PrimeMinister but in his twenties he said he realized the real power was working in the Prime Minister’s office not being Prime Minister and he ended up doing just that by his forties. In fact, he always did everything he set out to do, such a bright, talented guy and very successful. I bet he left a fortune to his mom and sisters. He never married or had kids.
LOGOisEGO@reddit
I really dont want to be the person to have to explain how Canadian conservatism has actually been rocket fuel on the last 20 years especially.
And I dont fault the realtor for selling the house or the car guy selling that finance too. We all had our job. And hey, this is a discussion forum, I invite you to add in anything you like or if youre curious of the tangents of the conversation.
I might be a rabid centralist, but I also have read my history 🤔
MacNeal@reddit
AM talk radio plays a big part in all this also
Collapse2043@reddit
Yeah that was around even before FOX. I know you have to be attracted to that sort of thing to begin with but it makes people more extreme in their views.
HommeMusical@reddit
A policy, not a law: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fairness_doctrine
roytay@reddit
Unfortunately the Fairness doctrine, which is about the use of public airwaves, never applied to Fox News, a cable station.
extinction6@reddit
Fox News is technically an opinion program or so I've been told. When Tucker Carlson was hauled into court for lying the judge let him off saying that no reasonable person would believe what he is saying, but we know that is the furthest from the truth.
I though Fox News would be in trouble when they got fined $787.5 million dollars for lying but people that watch Fox News couldn't figure out who they were lying to.
Sinclair broadcasting, the new shift at CNN and Larry Ellison taking over Tik Tok will create even more right wing propaganda.
If the average American had any critical thinking skills none of this would be possible. The world watched the footage of the US Capitol get attacked and people in the US voting the criminal back into power. "It was a day of love" in full tactical gear with pepper spray and killing.
Cloaked42m@reddit
They settled out of court for a defamation case. Not simple lies.
They defended the lies by pointing out they were an entertainment program.
Alena_Tensor@reddit
Actually prior to that, the Powell Memorandum. You must remember that this conservative movement to take over the machinery of government started back in the guilded age, was derailed by the wars and Roosevelt, and came back with a vengeance as they saw Jim Crow laws being dismantled and equal opportunity laws being enacted. With the growth of social benefits programs that tipped it completely off the scale as far as they were concerned and it was war after that. They started their behind the scenes work in high gear to besmirch and discourage democratic candidates, elevate republican candidates and pick conservative judges.
AdEven7883@reddit
The Powell Memo is from the 70s, not the gilded age, just for historical accuracy. Look it up, it's chilling and underscores how limp and useless the Democrats have been.
AdEven7883@reddit
It's easy to blame Fox News but they just tell people what they want to hear. I have MAGA relatives and they have always been racist, long before Fox News. The real cancer in our society is all the hate that has been normalized. Fox News didn't help and the relatively restrained media we used to have was a lot better, but don't forget there has to be an audience for a Fox News to succeed.
AkitaNo1@reddit
I blame the polarization of politics and the mainstream media. Plenty of other channels doing the same shit over the years just instead for the donkey instead of the elephant. Its so silly. Also creating a dichotomy at all. Asinine. There are more than 2 points of view. And definitely more than 2 choices. But they dont want you to believe that. Hence all the bullshit, chaos, strife, and distractions. They are 2 sides of the same coin. And thats why shit never changes. It only gets worse. Its by design.
Disastrous-Ad-2458@reddit
I know it's cliche, but dark Knight hits a lot different now.
I understand that Nolan was making a bigger point with joker- the natural human life is "nasty, brutish and short" because we are monkeys who want to kill each other for stupid reasons.
We have only advanced as a society because we've suppressed those urges with norms, laws, and the power of the state. But all it takes is a little push for all of that to come down. Just pull on that string and we're back to the hominids at the beginning of 2001.
youcantkillanidea@reddit
Seems like a little push. Plus 30 years of undermining society via FOX News and defunding the education system
Subway@reddit
Yes, can recommend, as well. Another good read: How Fascism Works, The Politics of Us and Them by Jason Stanley.
SimpleAsEndOf@reddit
And here's the really bad news from front page of Reddit today:
https://v.redd.it/upzzkqqta4tf1
It's important that you watch this and spread the news, please!
This is the moment Trump went Full Nazi!
desertgirl27@reddit
This is fucking terrifying!
SimpleAsEndOf@reddit
It’s a surveillance directive akin to COINTELPRO, but with the trappings of the McCarthy era red scare, surveilling people who are deemed anti American, anti capitalist , anti Trump and anti Christian. I guarantee the average Trump voter is totally unaware of its existence. Their right wing media will make zero mention of it.
Tomorrow, it will be linked with ICE or immigration.....
and then they will be using Palantir for this.
Group hug!
ElegantDaemon@reddit
Think of all your social media posts over the last year. Their AIs will be pouring over them and the logs from ISPs. They're building lists already.
None of us are safe.
Tasty-Property-434@reddit
First they came for Diablo Sauce and I said nothing.
#weknow
BayouGal@reddit
Think of all your posts ever. The internet hasn’t forgotten.
AlwaysShittyKnsasCty@reddit
Jokes on them. I have nothing to lose! It is they who have all the “things.”
Trump and crew want to ruin my life? Lol. Go for it. You just wasted your time on a nobody. Now, all you whiny bitches on the other hand have quite a bit on the line.
hazeyindahead@reddit
Someone with nothing to lose is a terrible enemy to make
Majestic-Bowler-6184@reddit
Welp, they won't like it if they pressure their own citizenry past the point of endurance. Maybe they'll win. But in the end, all empires rot. Memento mori.
ElegantDaemon@reddit
This regime will fall eventually, it's true. But how much irreparable damage will it do by then.
SimpleAsEndOf@reddit
It’s a surveillance directive akin to COINTELPRO, but with the trappings of the McCarthy era red scare, surveilling people who are deemed anti American, anti capitalist , anti Trump and anti Christian. I guarantee the average Trump voter is totally unaware of its existence. Their right wing media will make zero mention of it.
Tomorrow, it will be linked with ICE or immigration.....
and then they will be using Palantir for this.
Group hug!
BeardedGlass@reddit
NSPM-7, an executive order creates a legal framework to investigate and prosecute people for "domestic terrorism" using definitions so broad they could apply to almost any political opposition or protest activity.
Away-Map-8428@reddit
Not an executive order
Collapse2043@reddit
Good thing I’m in Canada because I’m all those things. 😬
verdasuno@reddit
If you are in Canada, DON'T GO TO THE USA.
Do not purchase US products or services. Do not give US companies or authorities any information about you.
If you are in the USA and in danger because of your status, politics, gender, etc. consider staying in the country and fighting first - the only way to preserve American civilization is if people fight for it. Only flee to Canada if there is no other option.
Collapse2043@reddit
I’m Canadian. They probably wouldn’t let me in at the border. Not that I would ever go there.
Majestic-Bowler-6184@reddit
Ah.
And if they lock you down from using the words that resist, that soon trickles into your thought patterns conforming to necessity: and in a few generations, if a tyrant is lucky, people will be baffled that there is anything to even resist.
AxelHarver@reddit
A couple others, that while not exactly on the same subject, definitely add good context to the situation we're in:
Irony and Outrage: The Polarized Landscape of Rage, Fear, and Laughter in the United States by Dannagal Young (this one is a fairly easy read, Young is an improv comedian)
https://www.audible.com/pd/Irony-and-Outrage-Audiobook/1705272444
Why America Hates Welfare: Race, Media, and the Politics of Antipoverty Policy by Martin Gilens (this one is definitely a more dry read, so the [completely, totally shocking] conclusion is basically lack of education and racism.)
https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/282124.Why_Americans_Hate_Welfare
Bonus one because I always take the opportunity to plug this book since it shows how easily things can escalate:
Born Red: A Chronicle of the Cultural Revolution by Gao Yuan about China's cultural revolution, details how things escalated during the rise of the Communist Party in China. I warn that parts can be difficult to read, it culminates in students outright murdering and torturing eachother in the name of patriotism.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Born_Red
Rare-Information5080@reddit
I visited Guangxi province, a stunningly beautiful place - the cities of Nanning, Liuzhou, Guilin, and Yangshuo (google images of it!), and at the same time was reading about the Cultural Revolution as it played out in this particular area. In other areas of China, teachers and professors were tortured, or imprisoned, or sent to "re-education" farms in the countryside. But here? They were roasted over a fire and eaten. For the life of me, I could not reconcile what I was experiencing and what I was reading about (which really didn't happen all that long ago - I was already alive when this took place!). So yea, things escalate pretty fast.
MonteryWhiteNoise@reddit
to keep the related reading list going ... Democracy in Chains gives a great historic perspective on how those Civil Rights-era backlash ideas were channeled into reactionary politics.
pippopozzato@reddit
Chris Hedges has written about this, Richard D. Wolff also. For me reading the book JESUS & JOHN WAYNE-HOW WHITE EVANGELICALS CORRUPTED A FAITH AND FRACTURED A NATION helped explain this too.
wouldyastop@reddit
America as Empire, Jim Garrison, 2004. A good read on how empires collapse.
jacktacowa@reddit
Sarah Kendzior also did some good academic work on democrac collapse and rise of oligarchy in the 00’s. The academic world was already collapsed so she’s written four books so far. https://static.macmillan.com/static/fib/sarah-kendzior/
Johan Galtung wrote “The Fall of the US Empire – and then what?” 2009
David P Goldman wrote “How Civilizations Die (and why Islam is dying too)” 2011
For some added historical context, see Eric H Cline “1177 BC the Year Civilization Collapsed” 2021
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
America isn't an empire! And Islam is definitely not going away
MistyMtn421@reddit
Eric Cline is amazing. It's helpful and also eye-opening to see that we haven't really changed a whole lot in 4,000 years.
livlaffluv420@reddit
Except that we have.
We have changed a whole hell of a lot in the past 300 years, but especially the last 80 or so (with the most recent two decades seeing us become literally a new kind of cyborg creature)
The problem is, you are right: we haven’t really been able to successfully tame or change our animal physiology over 4 millennia, & yet here we are, all labouring to create a spiritual successor to ourselves, a technological facsimile of real life, when we can barely even fathom what real life is in the first place.
thekbob@reddit
I had to stop reading it.
It was just prescient and depressing.
comewhatmay_hem@reddit
There's been a few books lately I could not finish because they were predicting the future we live in right now, except they were warning us about worst case scenarios and trying to give solutions.
Reading about how predictions of "worst case scenarios" have not only come true, but have exceeded the at-the-time predicted level of collapse and dysfunction is pure suicide fuel.
ParisShades@reddit
Could you share some of those books, please? I would like to read them. I have a strong stomach.
SeattleSundries@reddit
I’d add the book The Fourth Turning is Here by Neil Howe. It explains a historical theory of generational cycles that culminate in a crisis era (where we are now), before moving into a time of rebirth. I’ve found it both terrifying and reassuring.
comewhatmay_hem@reddit
No Logo by Naomi Klein was the worst for me in this regard, because I lived in Toronto at the time and she was describing the neighborhood I worked in in the first chapter. Hearing about what it used to be like compared to what it is now made me feel sick.
Manufactured Consent by Noem Chomsky is the other one I was thinking about when I wrote that comment, because that book describes future events the author's had no idea would take place, from the Iraq War to Trump's elections.
late2thepauly@reddit
In The Shadows of The American Century by Alfred McCoy is another great one that examines this.
neutralcoder@reddit
I need part two: how “democracies were restored”. These fuckers have had the handbook to crash everything…time for a handbook for the others to get them the fuck out of the way.
NastyWreck@reddit
Try Rebecca Solnit’s “Hope in the Dark”. It’s about times social uprising and change were “successful” in transforming conditions into something better
marswhispers@reddit
If only someone had written a book titled, like, “What Is To Be Done” or something
The-Neat-Meat@reddit
A lot of people on this sub are on the right path by being so disillusioned with the way things are but desperately need to push through to the next stage and read about what comes next. Lenin, Marx, Mao. What we are seeing is the predictable outcome of unfettered capitalism, and there is a scientific framework for how and why this happens and what can be done next.
marswhispers@reddit
b-but those are the scary names of the bad guys I learned about in eleventh grade world history class
livlaffluv420@reddit
Hate to sound like a dick, but whomsoever shall own the means of production going forward is more or less devoid of meaning now, as the production itself is kinda what’s been killing us all.
It would’ve been cool if it had happened when it still mattered, sure.
marswhispers@reddit
There are a lot of gradations in the concept of “means of production,” many of which didn’t exist at the time of the writing.
I would argue having a minimum capacity for primitive accumulation up to and including food, light industry, light chemistry and basic medicine will never go out of style.
Collapse2043@reddit
Masha Gesson has a lot of advise about that,
neutralcoder@reddit
Thanks! Didn’t know about it!
Muted_Resolve_4592@reddit
They don't. They collapse, we return to anarchy and destitution, and we rebuild it again and repeat the cycle. Only this time our biosphere is fucked and we have nothing to rebuild with before apocalyptic climate change starts killing us.
marbotty@reddit
On Tyranny a nice companion book
luminousrose9@reddit
Reading it right now.
Collapse2043@reddit
That’s Timothy Snyder.
big_duo3674@reddit
The defining point in our history is going to be when Trump finally kicks the bucket, he is the glue holding all of the conservative factions together. There is no true "republican" party, they are made up of multiple groups, with different views and opinions, that are only bending the knee right now because it is necessary to further their future ambitions. I really don't think people understand how massive the power vacuum will be when he's gone, and it really could be bad enough to break the US apart. Overnight they will go from "yes, whatever you say, sir" to "that's now how Trump would have handled this, I deserve to be the next great leader!" It will be absolute chaos, and they know it. There is a reason they are so rapidly trying to make changes across the board, and throwing all sorts of things out there even while knowing a lot won't stick. They are trying to brace for the day when he's gone and their party disintegrates into factions fighting each other. They know it could be bad enough (and confusing enough) to voters that they could lose seats all over the place, so they are basically trying to build their "Great Wall" to attempt to hold off the inevitable democrat voting surge. People like Govorner Newsom terrify them more than anything, they are counting on their usual tactic of winning because democrats will just roll over for the sake of keeping the peace. If that were to stop, then it's game over for them
Top_Hair_8984@reddit
It became evident in the 80's with the concerted deregulation of banking, trading etc laws. And here we are.
Lopsided_Newt_125@reddit
I have thought and said the same since the pandemic
colorado_jane@reddit
Another one for the reading list. The Fourth Turning Is Here by a couple of historians dives into cycles of expansion and collapse of the US, talks about our current collapse and has scenarios on how we might come out of it. Not a feel good read but does give some insight into how the reset button may get hit in the next few years.
slifm@reddit
So you also agree that we are not a democracy but a functional oligarchy?
muddaFUDa@reddit
More like a dysfunctional oligarchy
NomadicScribe@reddit
More like an oligarchical dysfunctionality
Meat_Assassin69@reddit
It’s always been an oligarchy. The Senate and Electoral College are not democratic bodies.
Even if they were, voting has been heavily restricted since its inception when it was only while men who were allowed to even vote.
All we are seeing now is Trump’s usual style of doing the quiet parts out loud
Watusi_Muchacho@reddit
I don't agree, and to think so is dis-empowering.
Meat_Assassin69@reddit
I don’t think it’s disempowered to confront the truths of oppression and the power structure in which we live.
Recognition is the first step toward real change.
evilkitty1974@reddit
Highly recommend, as well. Great book. 👍
Soci3talCollaps3@reddit
Are these the same professors who fled to Canada this summer to escape fascism?
Different-Library-82@reddit
No, as far as I know Ziblatt and Levitsky are still in the US. You're thinking about Snyder and Stanley.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you!
ProverbialSandbox@reddit
Thank You for the recommendation. This looks like a great read! I've got it on the book list.
scoobydobydobydo@reddit
peter turchin did some quantitative studies on the subject and suggested something similar.
CatchaRainbow@reddit
As an outsider looking in, I'm in the UK, and reading everything I possibly can on the subject, I would bet my house on the fact that the USA is irretrievably collapsing. And unfortunately, you have nowhere to run to. Mexico? Canada? I Don't think they will tolerate immigrants. Take Germany in the 1930s, exactly the same with the Jews, Roma, homosexuals, and people deemed "asocial" or homeless or habitual criminals. If they didn't get out early, they didn't get out. Ask yourself, are you suffering from misplaced optimism?
scoobydobydobydo@reddit
immigrants lol how the tables turned
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
Europeans like you would love to see America collapse
CatchaRainbow@reddit
You don't even know me lol
fedfuzz1970@reddit
I couldn't agree more. Every day I wish we weren't in our 80's. I know exactly where we would go. No one wants old people unless they're multi-millionaires. How long before actual internal passports, approved reason for travel, restrictions on money movement, etc. Young people should be getting out now but we've been the country of eternal optimism for so long that they probably won't.
frost_axolotl@reddit
Even if you flee to neighboring countries you won't truly be safe, being a neighbor puts you at the highest risk of military invasion from a country devolving into fascism, if people have the means it's better to go to the southern hemisphere or the other side of the globe.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Not me. I’m a trained biologist. My last optimistic thought about the future was when Obama was elected, and look how that turned out.
I had a mildly optimistic thought or two during COVID, hoping the virus world knock some sense into people, or at least kill off some of the quieter actors, but obviously that didn’t pan out, either.
CatchaRainbow@reddit
Plan ahead, get out while the borders are open. They won't tolerate a drop in population for long.
I just reread that, 8-( .... I think it is happening you know.
daywreckerdiesel@reddit
...and go where? It's very difficult to become a citizen of anywhere.
Jaredlong@reddit
You don't necessarily need citizenship, you only really need residency. It's a lower bar and after you're granted residency theirs a clearer path to citizenship.
daywreckerdiesel@reddit
Which countries do you know of that offer a viable path like that?
Jaredlong@reddit
I don't understand the question. I'm assuming you read what I wrote as "residency absolutely guarantees citizenship." If that's what you think I said, please re-read it a little slower.
daywreckerdiesel@reddit
I'm just asking you which countries you know of that have easy residency requirements and a clear path to citizenship once you are a resident.
existing_for_fun@reddit
I can't leave.
My parents are here. My in-laws are here. My brother and sister are here. None of them will go anywhere.
I'll stay and hold whatever line I can. Even if that just means giving them a place to exist if needed. Even if that means taking weekly grocery trips for them.
But I can't leave.
FontMeHard@reddit
Personally, as a Canadian, I hope they don’t come to Canada. We don’t need a large influx of Americans here. I’d rather Canada stay Canada.
TantalumAccurate@reddit
You have increased your population by a third over the course of the last ten years as a result of the bulk importation of student visa holders who never seem to leave. That ship's sailed.
livlaffluv420@reddit
Acting as if Canada even belongs to “Canadians” based on anything other than military-might-makes-right backed colonialism is kinda funny, tho.
The US would arguably have about as much legitimate claims to the land as the British Empire or French did.
It’s a supremely uncomfortable thought, but if America wanted to start lashing out like that, the world would be very hard pressed to stop them.
And shame on you, for saying people fleeing persecution have no place in Canada - historically, that has never been the attitude of the conscientious people living there.
Love your neighbor.
Collapse2043@reddit
Lol, with 800, 000 immigrants per year from all over the world I don’t think some Americans will change Canada that much.
jedrider@reddit
Yeah and we're using your nation as a blueprint to follow towards collapse.
CatchaRainbow@reddit
What the UK? It's bad, but not Fascist bad.
BlueAndYellowTowels@reddit
I think we are in uncharted territory. While a lot of elements seem to “rhyme” there is one thing that stands out as completely different: social media and Big Tech.
The biggest challenge of any authoritarian regime previously is scale. You can’t watch and control everyone.
However, with BigTech snd AI. We are looking at a whole new level of ability of governments and corporations to watch, track and propagandize people.
We are in completely new territory.
…and American Big Tech is poised to control the world. After the TikTok deal, every single large social media platform is now of propaganda arm of this fascist regime. We have never seen this scale and sophistication.
We have to hope things break before those systems come into full effect. Because if they don’t, we are truly screwed.
crispyraven7@reddit
Speaking of government propaganda, this week I was flying home from Albany. In the security line, there was a TV repeating a message from the ghoul named Noem stating that there could be delays because of the Democrats failure to fund the government. It feels surreal to me that there are people willing to swallow this absolute garbage. It's an insult to the intelligence of the American people, a majority of whom are not part of the MAGA cult.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Okay, they can control what people think/say, but they can’t control if the weather destroys crops. They can’t control sea level rise destroying property values. They can’t control floods, or internal immigration.
I suspect that people who are hungry will stop paying attention to social media? Well, they/we won’t be able to afford the internet, or a $600 phone, for sure.
Lost_Afropick@reddit
They control it by directing the populace at whomever they say is to blame for such things.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Like blaming immigrants?
BlueAndYellowTowels@reddit
Oh yeah. You can get a lot of mileage out of blaming outsiders for everything.
…and it’s such a tired, old playbook. It’s obvious immigrants aren’t the problem. They’re literally among the poorest, most vulnerable and powerless.
But it’s such an easy sale for so many people. “The problems in your life are a result of outsiders. Look how different they are? Notice how their values are barbaric and not like ours. They’re like vermin.”
It’s such an old song and dance… I have no idea why people still fall for it.
Lost_Afropick@reddit
The classics. Infallible
BlueAndYellowTowels@reddit
The mechanisms to deliver the propaganda will always be in place. Paying for public WiFi is a small price to control the population.
Cheap phones can absolutely still access social media.
As for crops and climate change… what do you think the propaganda is for? That when they tell the population that the reason food is expensive is because of immigrants. Since they’ve all defunded science and censored education… climate change will just be a buzz word the enemies of the state use to explain the “natural cycles” the planet goes through.
You’re talking about people who were propagandized to reject masks during a pandemic… anything is possible at scale now. The US gov/big tech now control all the conversations.
livlaffluv420@reddit
It’s funny, isn't it?
We’ve never had more information floating around than right now, & yet we have never been more dumb, unable to focus as a species.
I don’t think human brains were built to process this much data & stimulation.
We have all the knowledge we need to make the changes we must, but it is being drowned out by white noise.
We are a terminally distracted society, totally missing the forest for the trees when it comes to preventing, avoiding or at the very least mitigating the possibility of impending self extinction.
So it goes…
BlueAndYellowTowels@reddit
I do think there’s a nugget of truth to this. I do wonder if our evolution prepared us for the sorts of problems we have.
Humans are sort of designed to be tribal. We can only maintain so many relationships and do have like a hard limit of how many people we can know.
I do think we just aren’t intelligent or wise enough to comprehend things like Climate Change. It’s just so bit and massive and there’s so many interlocking systems. The complexity is far beyond what even the brightest of us can properly understand.
I think about that and I also think about Progress Traps. I stumbled across the idea like a decade ago and it’s never really left me.
question_sunshine@reddit
I'm not convinced the anti-mask or anti-vax thing was originally intentional. The backlash to Trump initially taking the pandemic seriously (while spreading misinformation out of stupidity) was intense. I think his team realized they couldn't fully control the monster they had created and went with it rather than lose the support of his base.
Veronw_DS@reddit
I too have been calling it a Dark Age for a hot minute. Now it's becoming so obvious that it's impossible to ignore. Nice to see someone else call it out.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Good point about the masks. I hadn’t thought of that example. I also don’t know very much about phones, obviously!
Cultural-Answer-321@reddit
This. They CANNOT control the forces of nature that are coming to destroy everything. Including them.
And it's all self inflicted.
GovernmentOpening254@reddit
Food price increases will only exacerbate minorities (immigrants, homosexuals, etc.) getting abused and blamed for all the ills in the simpleton’s minds.
monkeybeast55@reddit
Anyone who says anything but "uncharted" doesn't know anything. There has never been a time even close to this in all of history. People who talk about "revolution" are nuts and contributing to all the insanity. Just buckle up, and do your best to do something constructive that genuinely helps.
PTSDeedee@reddit
u/traditional_way1052 shared this video from a resistance historian in a comment above who basically says the same thing:
https://youtu.be/x1btBm-081A?si=p90FShQOR82_XcgQ
But he also points out that we have new tools for resistance too and that the French resistance to nazis didn’t start until 2 years after occupation.
BenUFOs_Mum@reddit
Fascism doesn't tend to last very long. Depending on the exact characteristics of the fascist regime they often are so aggressive they cause so many wars they collapse, I.e. Nazis, Imperial Japan. But even the longer lived fascism of Franco cant survive past the death of the leader. Theres no method for a peaceful transition of power.
brokebuffett@reddit
Great to see there are others besides me who could see how AI can propagandize people with big tech agenda
BlueAndYellowTowels@reddit
AI and Fascism are such a deadly mix. I don’t think people are properly wrapping their heads around the combo. We are in a lot of trouble. Not just nationally but globally as well.
youcantkillanidea@reddit
The fact that their incompetence is our biggest hope is both depressing and somewhat reassuring
BlueAndYellowTowels@reddit
It should be terrifying. Because all you need is one competent person to step up and there’s literally nothing standing in their way. They’ll just be able to seize power because now is primed and all the infrastructure for that to happen is in place.
EpicMichaelFreeman@reddit
Yes. The USA will likely be a technocracy from now on. The general population will be poor as if they lived in a third world country and treated like slaves with lots of hoops in between (near net zero worth at end of life after all of the rent, taxes and subscriptions), but the government, military, and corporations will be powerful and in place for many generations.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
You don’t think climate collapse will affect them?
EpicMichaelFreeman@reddit
Air conditioning
temp_woowoo@reddit
This a a long rant, so skip this if you don't want to read all that, and I may not respond since I just need to get this out and finish my preparations.
He doesn't care what the courts say and we are about to witness a pivotal turn where he combines the SCOTUS nationwide injunction ban with his own interpretation to classify the judge as an insurrectionist (they are now calling her that), and possibly have her arrested. This is the point where judges get arrested, or have their houses burned to the ground as we are seeing.
He's not going to stop his invasion, and at this point he won't even be slowed down. This is war, people need to wake up and prepare themselves because the courts have no enforcement power. Standing on the sideline recording kidnappings and screaming for them to stop may save one or two, but it won't save the rest. We need to stop saying "it's coming", it's already here. This is how it happens.
The military will split slightly or greatly, and some may refuse orders. They didn't call the Generals up for nothing. It was the warning to follow orders or they will be rapidly replaced, and that's already underway. It won't matter if some of the military members refuse orders. They are actively and intentionally bankrupting and starving Americans, the value of the dollar has dropped nearly 11% since the start of the year, that's the largest drop since 1973. They have plenty of people not just wanting, but in needing of the promise of that ICE bonus. By the end of the year the agents that stayed will be too deep that the bonus won't even matter, they will be believe the violence is real because they are on the receiving end of it. They will stay to "protect the nation".
Economically we have reach pre-Great Recession levels and much worse. The credit defaults are underway, WIC will run out of money shortly. The Bureau of Labor and Statistics refused to release their recent economic report and won't make the new deadline of October 30th if the government stays shut down. If you haven't figured it out yet, they have no intention of opening it back up again, and may even work to deliberately sabotage the reopening; assassinations are very much on the menu now.
This is how it happens. There is no going back from this point. No boycott will stop the oligarchs with savings equivalent to the GDPs of multiple nations combined. No peaceful protest, intimidating screaming, or "recording for evidence" will stop them. No voting in a midterm. No court ruling. No Epstien files. No Black Outs. No impeachment with Congress shuttered. Everything, no matter how much it seems like he is losing in courts, has been accounted for, and the Shadow Docket has given them what they need while the rest are tied up in court filing lawsuits thinking that if they win there it that will buy us time. It won't.
This. Is. War. And wars are only won one way. Of you think I'm wrong look up pre-civil war indicators, use whatever source you like. We have met all conditions.
I'm not a religious or spiritual person, but in my own way I pray you will all be safe. Prepare and get a plan in order for your families, reinforce your front doors, get armed and keep your weapons secure as responsible owners, save enough food to cover you for at least 72 hours with the power off, and have a go bag of essentials ready incase you need to leave your home temporarily or permanently. I'm not a preper myself, but it's time. Because it's here, and this is happening. Be safe everyone.
I don't care if anyone thinks I'm crazy, fear mongering, etc. I essentially don't even use Reddit and practically never comment. This is for the people that are like me. The ones that have been observing this go down and actually had the time to follow everything and form as best of their own opinion as possible; not all of us are in financial position, have regional proximity, or even agree with what our level of engagement on this matter should to do more than observe. If you take issue with that, you're barking up the wrong tree if your looking for a fight/debate/to rally those who haven't moved yet, it doesn't mean they haven't chosen a side, and it doesn't mean they don't want to get involved.
This message isn't for you, it is for the observers. The ones that don't comment but have put a lot of the same pieces together, and have for some reason become obsessed with studying and overlaying world history to just understand what is happening. Just know you aren't crazy. And you can prepare a plan of action and defense without getting anyone to agree with your take. And you don't have to obsess about it, but don't you dare take your eyes off of what is happening. Every new piece of information is critical, and if you are like me you already have mental tools in place to deal with the onslaught of information, misinformation, and disinformation as best as possible. Do not look away, do not waste energy trying to explain what you are seeing. Prepare for those that will rely on your accumulated knowledge and will need you, do not obsess and burn out. Moderate and pace yourself as you always have. Just get ready for your family and friends, they don't need to be convinced, just get ready.
Miserable_Chapter252@reddit
I expect nationwide shift and full panic mode if that judge is a arrested.
temp_woowoo@reddit
Do a search for "judges arrested" in Google. They have already been arresting judges.
We have now met 9 out of 10 major civil war indicators. Only 10% of nations have ever turned back once they met 8 of these conditions, and they ALL had Nelson Mandela diplomacy and leadership. The other 90% collapse within months to a year. We will not be among the 10%. Prepare yourselves.
deadface008@reddit
Do you think Trump could have successfully taken over the most powerful country in the world by himself? Ofc not. He pretends to be dumb, but he does his research and is copying old empirical strategies play-by-play. It's amazing that people don't see the 1⋮1 parallels. That said, I don't think America is collapsing. At least, not alone. Most of the world is pissed and hungry right now. We're going to see a lot more than the US evolve from this.
EarthKnit@reddit
He’s dumb. He doesn’t have smarts.
What he does have is narcissism and greed.
He combined them with power that others have and are using him for.
This country isn’t controlled by Trump— it’s controlled by the smart people who are using Trump as their charismatic leader: Voght, Musk, Miller, Thiel… the list goes on. These smart people took another lack-wit, Vance, to be the running mate because Trump is going die. Soon. And the smart people who now worked the entire economic, governmental, judicial, and military complex will use him as their next shill face of leadership.
They won’t need anyone after Vance is spent or dead.
This democratic republic is already over.
AmericanVanguardist@reddit
I don't think Musk, Miller, Theil, or Voght are competent enough to keep the country running.
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
This is all just left-wing cynicism. People on the fringe have been predicting the dissolution of the USA for the last +30 years. Well it hasn't happened! More likely America will continue its slide into a banana republic, where California is now
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
A banana republic? This is the definition I found:
https://theconversation.com/whats-a-banana-republic-a-political-scientist-explains-188573
Check out this New Yorker piece: https://www.newyorker.com/news/our-columnists/is-america-becoming-a-banana-republic
I think most people in power predict the dissolution of the US; it’s a way to create fear in order to manipulate the electorate.
But we are facing climate change. That’s not a political issue, it’s a fact. Combine that with the way my senators have abdicated responsibility for governing (red state), and I’m starting to feel nervous.
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
California is misgoverned, unstable, sucks up to a foreign power(China), has a growing chasm between the rich and the rank & file, and is filled with fugitives from banana republics. Ergo I define CA as a "banana republic"
Bman409@reddit
The economy is booming..there's food everywhere...unemployment is low and the US dollar is the world's reserve, while the US military has no rival.
This may not last forever. Probably won't. Be the US is not at all anything like USSR in early 90s, nor is it going to "collapse" anytime soon
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
There’s food everywhere, yeah, maybe. But food pantry visits are ‘way up in my community, so I’m thinking it’s not as affordable as it was. Also, at the extension where I am a volunteer, our food-growing classes are much better attended than this time last year. Just saying.
frost_axolotl@reddit
I'm sorry but if you think the job market is doing fine, you're delusional and in a survivorship bias bubble. I have a decent job, but I don't know how long that will last and I have to plan ahead for the future. I am also not obvious to people suffering this job market and how many have grown increasingly hopeless.
RollinThundaga@reddit
It's propped up by the AI bubble and inflation. Growth is slowing and we're bleeding jobs, notably including loads of government positions that were cut for no good reason.
Bman409@reddit
"Growth is slowing" is a long way from "a collapse is imminent "
But whatever. We can agree to disagree
BoltsandBucsFan@reddit
The stock market is not the economy. Unemployment is rising, and there’s plenty of reasons to believe that federally reported numbers will be manipulated moving forward to serve the administration’s agenda. The US dollar is at a 3 year low.
Bman409@reddit
Ok..you're right. US on the verge of an imminent collapse
Deep_losses@reddit
It’s not the United States that’s collapsing (it is, btw) it’s the post Bretton Woods international system that’s collapsing. The United States was just the architect and security guarantor for the system. Globalized civilization is collapsing, the USA was at the top so their decline is more precipitous than others.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
That’s an interesting comment. Could you recommend a book about this? (I am woefully ignorant about our global civilization.)
Deep_losses@reddit
‘The End of the World is Just the Beginning’ (2022) by Peter Zeihan. All his books do a fair job of describing geopolitics.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thanks! I put it on my reading list.
Eurydice_guise@reddit
I read On Tyranny by Timothy Snyder and Nuclear War: A Scenario by Anne Jacobsen back to back (2-day timespan) and had nightmares for weeks.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Oh, dear. Thanks for the tip.
thatguyad@reddit
America is hitting its due date for its collapse. The problem is the Nazis in charge are accelerating it intentionally rather than fighting to delay or defy it.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
That’s really what it seems like, doesn’t it? I suppose they think they are so rich that they think they won’t suffer?
I think something else that surprises me is that there are so many American men who are happy to be part of ICE. It’s a pity that the National Guard and our military, who are good people, are being sucked into this.
Old-Journalist9247@reddit
Go watch this like actually watch it before you think decide what exactly is leading us to this fall... https://youtu.be/bX3EZCVj2XA?si=yspxNfVPJtAIM3B1
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thanks, I will.
espomar@reddit
Gorbachev did not lead the USSR into dissolution, he just happened to be there when the economic clock ran out on the Soviets. However much current Putinist Russians want to blame Gorbachev for the USSR’s woes, he did not create them.
On the other hand, Trump definitely is playing a role in the collapse of the United States.
No_Note_597@reddit
Trump was not there when USA was in 17 trillion debt.
I am not MAGA, I am not even white, never been to USA
the end to printing dollar is near, I want to badly pivot away from American clients I have. Soon I will.
-SnarkBlac-@reddit
I wouldn’t say it is collapsing, collapse implies there will be nothing left when it’s over. I disagree. In 100 years there will still the a United States. However what kind of United States that is will certainly be different. We are in the midst of a transformation to which the end result is still very unclear.
Best example I can make is the 200 year transformation of the Roman Republic to the Roman Empire. It didn’t happen overnight and the process began before Caesar was even born. We are seeing a similar process over take us here. Is Trump a Caesar? Debatable. He could be a Sulla or someone that predates the Caesar figure but causes the correct changes needed to eventually bring on a Caesar. If that makes sense.
Not a collapse. Hell Rome got stronger and expanded after the Republic ended; so I don’t see that happening to America.
I could be wrong time will tell. People like to overreact a lot.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Huh. Interesting point of view. Yes: changing.
-SnarkBlac-@reddit
I’d like to further note that true complete and under social-economic collapse hasn’t happened a lot in human history. The only three real examples I can point to are the Indus River Valley Civilization Collapse, Bronze Age Collapse, Collapse of Native American Civilizations upon the arrival of the Europeans due to diseases.
As for everything else, sure a random empire or kingdom could collapse and be conquered but it was always replaced by something that built off the bones of the previous nation. One could argue these are gradual transformations that one would fail to notice. Like how the Western Roman Empire didn’t necessarily collapse when Rome was sacked (not even the capital then) but gradually morphed into Feudal Europe over a few centuries.
We aren’t at that point for the US, its culture, traditions, laws and general strength (both militarily and economically) remains very stable and will take a nearly impossible force to completely collapse it. How it’s run from a governmental structure very well might completely change by the end of the century (who knows) it’s certainly transiting right now. They even called it the “7th Party System” and where this will eventually lead is still unknown as the process hasn’t finished yet. However the very people, towns, states and things that make America, well America? That’s going to endure on as a cohesive unit for a very long time. Geography partially being responsible
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you for the thoughtful reply.
gnostic_savage@reddit
I would take the above answer with a shaker full of salt. The Native Americans did not "collapse" from disease. At least, not in the US, they didn't. The US engaged in 300 years of nonstop warfare against Native Americans in order to take the land, beginning in Jamestown in 1607, and officially ending in late 1890 at Wounded Knee, but in fact continuing into the first decade of the 20th century.
In addition, the word "collapse" can have multiple meanings. The Native Americans in the US were purposely exterminated, with scholars estimating that only approximately two to four percent of their pre-colonial populations remained alive at the end of the 19th century. In fact, it could have been only one to two percent that survived contact. We just don't know.
What we do know is that the estimates for pre-colonial populations range greatly, from a low of three million people, to a high of sixteen million (David Stannard), with most scholars accepting a number of five to seven million people. We also know what the 1900 census tells us. At the end of our three centuries of warfare against them there were only 237K Native people remaining alive in the contiguous US states.
"Disease" doesn't take three hundred years to kill people. That's just colonial apologism to make our violence for wealth more palatable, and to ensure its continuance. And if it had been "disease", well, that disease magically ended at both the Canadian and Mexican borders, where those countries had much higher survival rates of their indigenous populations than the US did, even taking into account the denser population numbers of Mexico.
I would also argue that sacked Rome gradually morphed into feudal Europe. It was about five hundred years between the sacking of Rome and establishment of proto-feudal Europe under Charlemagne, and that's a really long time. There is a relationship between these separate stages of western civilization, no doubt, but to say that it was a "morphing" is more than a stretch. It would be more accurate to say that it was second conquest, and it was an extremely brutal one. Charlemagne's establishment of a new phase of western civilization was viciously, viciously violent. The brutality of it cannot be overstated. And "morphing" is such an ambiguous word for what occurred, ambiguous to the point of meaninglessness.
But do take the ideas as a starting point for your own research.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thanks some more. I must say that I’m enjoying hearing from people who know more than I do. I did not expect that when I decided to try Reddit.
I wrote a reply to -SnarkBlac- (upwards in the chain) which I invite you to read.
I’m planning to follow up on all the suggestions: Powell’s Books, here I come!
gnostic_savage@reddit
I agree that we are in collapse of a kind. Certainly the collapse of the US as the primary world cultural and economic power is well underway. We will not regain our alliances or economic partnerships at previous levels, I don't believe.
I also agree with others who have mentioned the biological-environmental collapse of the planet as a stark reality. We just can't live the way we want to live on this world, destroying so much more than necessary to sustain life because we want wealth, and want to be creative, rearranging anything and everything just to see what we can make out of it all. This culture has won the planetary Darwin Award, and while some of our terrible problems are universal, most of them are cultural and specific to us, and we just can't get over ourselves. We would rather kill the whole place than even try.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I’ve been thinking about your comment (check out the comment below in this chain if you are interested), and I’m not sure I agree with you about a complete collapse not having occurred very often.
On the one hand, a complete collapse, which I might define as all the people dying, which is not a takeover by a non-local gang of humans, would not necessarily make it into history. I recently read an article about the number of times Greenland has been colonized and by whom. The times when humans disappeared are noted by archeologists, not by historians. I’m thinking also of Chaco canyon in the American Southwest, Mohenjo Daro
To the left, cultures have certainly disappeared. I’m thinking of Christianity moving into Northern Europe. Or maybe the way the Taliban are changing Afghani culture.
prostateExamination@reddit
The USA is not going anywhere. Your rights and speech are.
Shoddy-Childhood-511@reddit
First the Roman Republic became the Roman Empire, then it eventually collapsed.
prostateExamination@reddit
And it became ROMANIA. Look how they’re doing
Shoddy-Childhood-511@reddit
Nah. It's actually Tsarist Russia that inherited the institutional characteristic of Rome, so if you wished you could maybe strech Rome until the abdication of Nicholas II in 1917, but anything really Roman died with the Bolsheviks. lol
I think more importantly: Rome's fall was benefitial to Roman citizens longer term. There was a population collaspe before & during the fall. Yet, after the fall evidence from skeletons shows that people were much healthier in the Dark Ages than under Rome. Rome fell because the fall benefited most Roman subjects. See Joe Tainter or similar.
Fox_Kurama@reddit
Healthier than Roman citizens of which time period? Rome had a long history, and some of that history was during times when the peasants were barely getting by, and some of that history was during times when peasants were doing well enough to have a variety of foods.
Shoddy-Childhood-511@reddit
I'm quoting popular sources like Joe Tainter who I think mean the whole Roman empire vs the whole Dark Ages, aka Early Middle Ages, aka before kings & church got too powerful. Tainter boils stuff down, but he's pretty careful.
Afaik it's mostly just saying (a) people lived much longer without high taxes taking away their food to pay for wars etc, and (b) the cities spread diseases, although conversely some literature says the diseases left the population healthier. Importantly, there was still basic medical care during the Dark Ages, so they did not revert to much earlier lifestyles.
I've rarely hear any popular sources discusse helath in the earlier Roman republic. It's possible the medical care was worse before then, or the populations was smaller, or maybe we simply do not know enough about the medical care. We typically have knowledge of tribes mostly from what the empires wrote about them, but Roman officers might not write about the Germanic tribes' doctors.
> when peasants were doing well enough to have a variety of foods.
If people eat some greens, fruits, nuts, and roots, and eat meat on frequent-ish festivals or when lucky hunting, then they should get a pretty varied diet. Roman peasants would've trouble beating that more often than not, in part because of everything being bought & sold.
Fox_Kurama@reddit
Cities spreading diseases is definitely a thing across the ages. Until the past century and a half or so, when sanitation and plumbing started really becoming a thing, cities were pretty dirty places often with negative innate population growth, maintained by people moving into them.
I suppose I didn't recognize that the dark ages were expressly the time BEFORE all the kings got started up again though. I guess I just had the idea that it included the times when the church was really powerful.
Shoddy-Childhood-511@reddit
There were definitely kings, nobels, warloards, wars, and expoitive churches, but they could take less since they were a much smaller elite, and carrier out less adventurous wars & trade than under Rome.
Ilikeyellowjackets@reddit
Rome did not become romania at all. The territory known as Romania today was nothing but a vassal state at the time and most Roman troops were withdrawn from that area long before the collapse.
The Dacic territory was mainly settled by Roman soldiers and a small amount of commoners, which did eventually lead to a fusion of the cultures, but it wasn't at all like a continuation of the Roman empire. It's also why despite Romania using a latin based romance language, it still has a lot of slavic influences, and is further from latin than any romance language.
The actual continuation of Rome was the Byzantine empire, which led into multiple nation states and influenced their development, which did include the Balkans and it's part of the reason why the Balkans are such a mess to this day.
But Romania is not a continuation of Rome, and never was, it's just called Romania because of the weird cultural chimera it is. A combination of 0 record keeping till the 9th century, Roman superiority complex among the settlers, plus an inflated ego due to heavy imperialist influence from both the Byzantine and Ottoman empire.
Romania only became romania after 3 states combined, Transylvania, Moldova, and Wallachia. Wallachia among romanians is also called the Romanian Land due to the belief they are the true descendants of the Romans. Due to the fact that the 3 states usually combined due and under a Wallachian ruler, as there were multiple attempts that failed for different reason, the name they settled one was Romania, to signify the union of all romanian people and continue the legacy of the true descendants of Rome despite being nothing like it.
Tldr; Romania is the middle ages equivalent of the fuckin larping 14 year olds online thinking that because they are white they are Romans or something. In actuality, it's tenuous connection at best and an inflated ego for the most part.
Bman409@reddit
Yes...about 500 years after becoming an empire
Zisx@reddit
What rights of speech you say?,,,
prostateExamination@reddit
Bot. Mod delete this account.subset.0065.
Zisx@reddit
What are you talking about dude? Look at my history, I don't need to defend myself
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I’m sorry, but I don’t understand what you mean. I haven’t been in this social media vey long. Please explain?
HommeMusical@reddit
The President literally said he was declaring war on the great cities of America. I think the U part is going away.
darkpsychicenergy@reddit
How so? They know that their opposition is heavily concentrated in the cities. Those population centers are the only things making any state “blue”. All they have to do is lay siege to the cities and purge them of opposition. Easily done too. Surround the cities, control all entry and exit points, and it’s like shooting fish in a barrel. Then the States will be more ‘United’ than ever.
jarena009@reddit
This. As we've seen with Apple, Meta, Disney, etc, corporations and rhe wealthy will acquiesce and accept fascism, so as long as it remains profitable. They have no values.
deadicated_electric@reddit
All Hail the Corporate Dictatorship!
The owners and controllers of capital always prevail!
https://youtu.be/I5nqjFY0sJk?si=M8lOVLZuyH54l-ng
slifm@reddit
But the corporate executives do.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
The Soviet Union did not go anywhere, but it no longer exists as a political entity.
prostateExamination@reddit
Yet their territory mainly exists? Hmm
Different-Library-82@reddit
The Soviet Union had roughly twice the population of what became the Russian Federation, that Moscow controls a lot of sparsely populated arctic tundra isn't relevant.
feo_sucio@reddit
“i see you disagree with me, checkmate”
HommeMusical@reddit
Countries come and go all the time, though the underlying territory is of course still there, I'm not understanding your argument...?
NeverEndingCoralMaze@reddit
What changed? Not much. It was merely a rebranding.
No-Insurance100@reddit
The existence of the Soviet Union was why you ever had any social democratic concessions from the American elites in the first place, lol
Only an uneducated fool would compare the USSR to contemporary Russia
NeverEndingCoralMaze@reddit
Only a fool would ignore the parallels. America owes Russia nothing.
No-Insurance100@reddit
You would not have a single New Deal Era piece of concessions you depend on without the USSR providing the American proletariat a highly visible alternative after the political and economic upheaval of the 1920s and 1930s
whoisfourthwall@reddit
The White States of America then.
gobeklitepewasamall@reddit
Everything was forever, until it was no more (Alexei yurchak)
& collapse: the fall of the Soviet Union (Vladislav zubok)
& violent entrepreneurs (Vadim volkov)
& End Times (Peter Turchin)
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you. I will follow up your suggestions.
rp_whybother@reddit
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russia_1985%E2%80%931999:_TraumaZone
if you want to see the fall of soviet union watch this
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you!
ttystikk@reddit
"American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America" is a 2007 non-fiction book by the American journalist Chris Hedges.
Highly enlightening and prescient.
Waste_Recognition184@reddit
Chris Hedges is a far far left-wing communist pretending to be a Christian! He hates America and loves Islam
ttystikk@reddit
He's an ordained minister. He hates the extreme of capital, including control of the political system that is currently dragging the West into Fascism. That's a problem with OUR system, not communism.
Finally, only someone completely ignorant about economic.would assume that billionaires exist in a vacuum without adversely affecting the society or economies them live in. In fact, they drive up prices even while representing the worst of wealth inequality.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you v
Extreme-Benefyt@reddit
might be just some fear spreading
deleted_by_reddit@reddit
[removed]
collapse-ModTeam@reddit
Rule 1: In addition to enforcing Reddit's content policy, we will also remove comments and content that is abusive or predatory in nature. You may attack each other's ideas, not each other.
ephemeral22@reddit
Yeah, after all the warnings that were disbelieved, there's a feeling more and more like this is really almost the end and not just a false alarm. I feel it's global, not just the US.
GagOnMacaque@reddit
So at some point in the future the American Republic will invade California.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Could be. Did you ever read David Brin’s ‘The Postman’? It’s fiction, but . . .
GagOnMacaque@reddit
Like most redditors I can't read past first grade level.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I don’t think it has too many big words in it. But maybe you don’t like fiction. It was the first book I’d ever read that talked about a post collapse America that seemed real to me.
(I don’t have any patience with zombie attacks.)
xrm67@reddit
Yes it is happening:
Cascading Collapse: America at the Edge of Systemic Breakdown
Sknowles12@reddit
That is an extensive article. Totally worth the read. TY.
xrm67@reddit
Sequal here: America’s Descent Toward Authoritarianism: Mapping the Mechanisms of Democratic Erosion
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thanks for the link!
PM-me-in-100-years@reddit
The US is a healthy plutocracy. Rich people sit by, comfortably getting richer, and pitting everyone else against each other.
They have their gentlemanly squabbles, but until the rich start assassinating each other, there's no political collapse coming any time soon.
errie_tholluxe@reddit
Unless of course you count political collapse as the death of the social contract which is happening in real time.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
That’s an interesting thought. Write more?
errie_tholluxe@reddit
Both sides share a lot of the same values across the aisle and in a lot of cases the same donors. However, the Republicans seem to have decided that the social contract cost too much money for them to continue, because it takes away value for, well if they were a company shareholders but since they're not oligarchs. The Democrats seem to have decided to draw the line, let's hope they hold it, because they seem to still think the social contract exists and should continue to exist.
Personally, both sides believe in wage slavery, but the Democrats at least believe in giving a bone every once in awhile, and modern Republicans have decided the bones are too fucking expensive. The bones of course, being all the public services that are offered by the government out of the tax, it's all of the lower lower middle class and poor people pay in. Because there is no upper middle class, just rich, richer and holy fuck.
Democrats have always been the party for social contracts, which is why the Republicans call them socialists so often even though they're so far to the right of being a socialist, it might as well be over the horizon. Meanwhile, the Republicans past fascism some time ago and are just letting a system catch up to them.
Sm2x@reddit
Except Clinton enacted some of the biggest cuts to welfare and signed NAFTA. The privatization and union busting of Regan in the 1980's started the fall and what Clinton did accelerated it by turning the Dems from social issues into the blue dog coalition.
The Republicans call anything they don't like socialist, it has nothing to do with some mythical Dem "social contract" since they abandoned that for their donors quite a while ago. In fact Nancy Pelosi was pro universal healthcare in the 1990s but has a much different stance now. Let's also not forget that the Dems have called both Bernie Sanders and Zohran Mamdani communists and socialists. The entire DNC worked harder to smear and stop Bernie's campaigns (especially 2016) than they have tried to stop their supposed "opposition" in decades.
The Dems holding firm on healthcare is wonderful to see but the ACA (aka Obamacare) doesn't go far enough and still allows insurance companies to profit off the backs of sick people. Still nice to see them actually doing something that benefits people even if it doesn't go far enough but I've been burnt enough times to wonder which Dem will crack under donor pressure.
The US gave up on a social contract for it's people beginning in the 80s but again, Clinton's welfare reform is what hollowed out what little we did have. And what we do have now pales in comparison to even places like the UK and Canada which are facing similar issues as we are and is a joke compared to other developed countries (I hate that word but couldn't think of a different term).
errie_tholluxe@reddit
Yes, you are correct. Democrats have moved further to the right for sure. You can't call very many of them progressive and only a couple liberal
Sm2x@reddit
Yup we have right and right lite now as our two parties. I just wish more people saw what's been happening and how we got here. This doesn't just happen because of one President, it's been a long time coming.
HousesRoadsAvenues@reddit
I would not even call the over class billionaires "Gentlemen". I don't even know what to call them.
Otherwise, I agree with your post.
livlaffluv420@reddit
But it’s true!
Who could forget the “Gentlemanly Squabble” between current US Commander-In-Chief/overall slimeball Donald J. Trump & his twice convicted child molesting longtime self-described best pal Jeffrey Epstein over who was gonna have first dibs on a 10 yr old?
Don’t forget that these are highly refined individuals we are talking about here - they aren’t like you or me!
kerelsk@reddit
Parasite class
PM-me-in-100-years@reddit
The idea of 'gentlemen' was always classist. The billionaires consider each other gentlemen, but to us they're scum.
Alena_Tensor@reddit
It’s the old feudal society thing. Structural classes that exist in perpetuity and inhibit mobility
Soci3talCollaps3@reddit
There is nothing healthy here in the US. It's rotting from the inside out, from the top down, and from the bottom up. The population is not in a position to endure much of a downturn, but we're about to face the mother of them all. We're going to find out real fast what we're actually made of. As for the plutocrats, they won't fare well beyond their bunkers.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
And yet, the western states and the northeastern states have both created health organizations in opposition to the Trump/Kennedy vaccination recommendations.
OldBeardy77@reddit
It’s early days to see how that pans out with the overlord
jarena009@reddit
Bingo.
Alexander_Granite@reddit
We are collapsing. Not because of Trump, but because we elected and support him as a country. Trump is a symptom of a bigger problem that we in the US are going to have to figure out.
241ShelliPelli@reddit
It’s stunning, from an outsiders perspective, that IF the US is falling is such a debate and people are still talking about it like a what if. Bizarre to us.
You’ve already fallen. It’s over. Even if, let’s say, everyone in a group as a whole who are sane and reasonable and intelligent comes into power TODAY, it’s already fallen.
It’s so bizarre to us, there is still any sort of a debate within your walls. It’s not if or when. That’s long, long, long pass. It’s over.
25TiMp@reddit
We get propaganda 24/7 from birth.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Check out this reply by snarkblac (they say it much better than I did):
https://www.reddit.com/r/collapse/comments/1nyn7bi/the_fall_of_the_united_states/ni07c4x/?context=1
If that link doesn’t work, I apologize. I'm not quite sure this is the way to show you their post.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I think that it’s harder to see what’s happening from the inside. It’s so easy to get distracted by daily life.
I expect more concern from my neighbors, for instance. When I’m hopping up and down about armed, masked men grabbing people off the street, they’re planning a birthday party.
The whole thing is just so amorphous to live through.
AgencyNew3587@reddit
I have tried to tell people this but they don’t want to hear it. We live in such a delusional time now.
The-Neat-Meat@reddit
There’s also the fact that the fall of the USSR was the direct result of DECADES of meddling by America, and particularly the CIA; what we are seeing now is the imperial boomerang finally coming back home.
25TiMp@reddit
An under-appreciated fact!
freemochara@reddit
Emmanuel Todd(who predicted the downfall of the USSR)has just written a new preface to his book La Défaite de l’Occident (The Defeat of the West) which I believe will be getting an English publication now
https://open.substack.com/pub/emmanueltodd/p/the-dislocation-of-the-west-what?utm_source=share&utm_medium=android&r=9pikv
'Less than two years after the French publication of La Défaite de l’Occident (The Defeat of the West) in January 2024, the book’s main predictions have come true. Russia has weathered the storm militarily and economically. The American military industry is exhausted. European economies and societies are on the verge of implosion. The Ukrainian army has not yet collapsed, but the stage of the West’s disintegration has already been reached.'
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you for the reference - I will look for a copy. (I don’t think my high school French is up to reading the original.)
It sounds interesting.
Midnorth_Mongerer@reddit
As I recall (I'm old), under Gorbachov the USSR softened its attitude to Western norms (Glasnost). Gorbachov was committed to preserving the Soviet state and its Marxist–Leninist principles, but believed significant reform was necessary for its survival. The rest is history.
In regard to the USA, bearing in mind I'm on a Distant Shore, I observe the opposite. There is a hardening of attitudes as the USA moves to the Dark Side. Something I read the morning referred to the USA as "the American Empire". So, no, there are no similarities between the decay of the USSR and the current USA situation.
However, it leaves me bewildered as to why the USA citizens have allowed an autocrat gain control so easily and so quickly.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I was thinking more about the collapse of their infrastructure. I remember reading about the collective farms not producing enough food. (I’m old, too.) Of course, we have corporations panting to seize the land of farmers who go under, and the Soviets didn’t.
Thanks for your thoughtful comment.
Regarding why people voted for Trump: I think Republicans see themselves as a tight-knit group and value their clique over all, certainly over the wellbeing of the nation. That’s one reason voters supported Trump (and remember, he barely won.) - because they wanted to be in the cool group. That’s certainly true of people like Mike Johnson and Clarence Thomas. They value their own groups interests over their duty.
And there are cultural reasons, too. I personally know Hispanic men who would NEVER support a female politician.
GhooricZone@reddit
Trump as our Yeltsin-transition figure I could see. The thing that intrigues me is the federation-quality of America. I would guess that some balkanization of different regions of the United States would be the eventual result. This country has been most consistent in its proto-cultural legacies of about a dozen different nation-traditions. Historian Colin Woodard and others have written about it. (https://colinwoodard.com/books/american-nations/) But I'm not sure those would be predictable lines of separation. Certainly centers of commerce like California and New York splitting off in some manner from the rest of the country would be immediately devastating economically. An interruption in the network of trucking and delivery would crush some communities, and mess up air travel. And whatever sectarian group claims authority over the military would affect a lot. Hard to believe these are things I'm thinking about.
roytay@reddit
I fail to see how any splits would actually happen. The Federal gov has the biggest military in the world and has said "no" to succession in the past.
Plus, no state is truly Red or Blue. They're all some form of Purple.
BenUFOs_Mum@reddit
Yeah no chance of a balkanisation. The american civil war will look more like the syrian civil war than the first.
GhooricZone@reddit
Yes, that's part of what I was hitting: that it's difficult to imagine the how more than the why. Buttons are certainly being pushed, and they are state and city focused, but how would that lead to a separation from the culture, the commerce, the community? And yet an event like that is palpably on a lot of peoples' minds right now. Strange times.
Kim_Jong_Unko@reddit
Whatever final form it may eventually take, the years leading up to it will be very unpleasant for everyone involved.
The Alex Garland Civil War film may end up being comparatively tame...
No-Insurance100@reddit
The US honestly deserves a period similar to the severe trauma of 1990s Russia considering how many times the US government has done "shock therapy" and regime change to other countries - with the overt or implied support of the majority of the American population
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I can see that, without actually wanting to live through it.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I’ve see that, without actually wanting to live through it.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you for your thoughtful answer.
Soggy-Bed-8200@reddit
The age of nations is ending, the rise of business is beginning. Business will not last very long. Then we have a shot of something better than nation states, you will still have global communications, we will have to get our physical needs locally.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
The rise of business, like corporations ruling the world?
Terrible-Classic-222@reddit
To save our Republic all of us need to speak up. President Trump is attempting to redefine our liberties. He is testing the biundries of power in a democracy. It is clear tge Republicans have failed to choose the Constitution over their own selfishness. Peaceful protest and fair elections are the method we need to pursue to save out freedoms.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
You are preaching to the choir, brother. I have attended every protest in my county. And I work for the supervisor of elections (which were fair and free under the last supervisor. We just got a new supervisor and I hear she’s a trumpette, so I don’t know what to expect going forward.)
Churrasquinho@reddit
Since the 1970s, the US saw a significant change in its pattern of wealth accumulation:
· from trade profits to be reinvested in expansion of production (of industrial goods, mostly) · to speculative gains derived from valuation of assets
Which was in response to a few different factors:
· the tendency of the rate of profit to decline, especially as productive inputs and market expansion plateau · the diminishing EROI (energy return on investment) of oil, which made energy more expensive
A conundrum that was brilliantly solved, as the US had the capacity to impose military victories (through Israel) and stitch deals with Middle Eastern countries, securing control of global oil markets - not only through direct sales.
Key producers, like Saud Arabia, agreed to only sell oil for dollars. That cemented a structural global need for American currency, debt, debt markets and assets, since oil was an absolutely necessary input industrial production.
This arrangement, in turn, allowed the American economy to disengage from a dependency on industrial profits, which have lower returns, and indulge in much higher margin sectors: real estate, entertainment, stock trading, consulting, private health and education, law. And crucially, from a geopolitical standpoint, the useful industries: military and surveillance equipment, drugs, oil.
Those high returns enabled American dominance in modern digital technologies and their markets.
BUT those digital markets are also highly financialized, which means high leverage/debt, which calls for higher guaranteed returns, continuing the cycle: the US sells software, licenses, stocks and debt while other countries make the actual goods.
Come to today: global oil demand is on the verge of being undercut by Chinese solar/ev exports; oil and commodities are being increasingly traded outside the dollar; Central Bank demand for treasuries had fallen of a cliff around the world; American military supremacy is under serious question.
Meanwhile, the country has divested from infrastructure, from production of material goods. Copper wires, face masks, tooling machines, steel. It has divested from education, from creating the skill base needed to build those things at scale, competitively.
Public debt is in a spiral. There is no containing it, exactly like there is no containing the oil capital, which is linked with military profits, which are linked with tech stocks and a never-ending apocalypse in the Middle East.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
This is really interesting. Thank you for your thoughtful reply.
JHandey2021@reddit
I have no idea where we are. But I do know Trump or whatever faction around him is governing this week is pushing hard towards… something. They are badly miscalculating the appetite for it but could fuck up everything with their ineptitude.
Kind of like the Soviet coup plotters, in fact.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Whatever they want, it’s probably in that project 2025 book. I haven’t read it (I say this with shame.) because that kind of stuff puts me to sleep.
It would be really cool if somebody on this sub who has read it would explain what they want.
CivilPerformer9980@reddit
I think one difference is that at the time the Soviet Union collapsed, it was not being run by individuals determined to destroy it. The collapse was due to a multitude of factors and the SU wasn’t doing great leading up to it.
In our case, we weren’t so far down the road as to make collapse imminent, as in within 6-12 months.
25TiMp@reddit
Gorbachev was a paragon of sanity compared to Trump.
ksixnine@reddit
It seems as if a whole lotta people need a refresher on US history in order to understand that we swing between being democratic to being republican, and the media (all of it) plays a massive role in public opinion as to how this plays out.
People need to be reminded that “our” Jim Crow laws were a blueprint for both the Nazi and Apartheid regimes — which means we’ve been dynamically authoritarian for a long long time [re: Operation Wetback, Japanese internment, No Irish Allowed, anti-Catholic, the sterilization of indigenous women, the Tuskegee experiment (which might well be a backlash against them providing so many pilots during WW2), the Zoot Suit issues, the multiple race riots against black incorporated towns which blended into the decades long lynchings, McCarthyism, etc…]
The point I’m making is that the US has a less than minor appreciation on the non-white/ non-US born/ non-male achievements which helped us grow, especially during and post WW2, into the lone powerhouse post sed war — we weren’t the smartest, and we weren’t the best when we entered, but we had a deep desire to not be conquered by someone else developing a nuclear weapon.
We are re-repeating parts of a playbook that doesn’t wish to accept how or why we rose to top dog global prominence by favoring political fealty over competence, as we pretend that our economic strength will carry us through, because too many weak men don’t want to accept the blood soaked reality of how this country was made in order for us to be able to stand as the rest of the first world was caught up in rebuilding itself — it’s as if we chose to abandon our perch in order to craft chaos (economic/ political) without being genuine with all of our populace that that chaos was definitely going to come home.
A key thing that the current administration has forgotten is that although (more) people voted for a white man vs a black•South Asian woman, the plurality of those voters aren’t in lock step with him for myriad reasons — they see the lies … the faux justifications … it’s only a matter of time before they are affected by this administration’s policies and turn.
This is less than a collapse, and more of an untethered revisiting of the gilded age of corporatist growth, where our beliefs in our politicians and courts are being challenged.
No-Insurance100@reddit
People are fools if their entire focus is on Trump and not the logical culmination of the crisis of late stage capitalism. AI speculation and the American rich cannibalizing the imperial super-profits of the American "middle class" are part of the same necessity for capital to always find a new "frontier" to generate infinite growth. If they can't find it abroad, they'll do it at home, if they can't find it reality they'll make it up. The only things that make this uniquely American is how stupid and crass everything is and how much Americans deserve it as accumulated karma for terrorizing the world for decades
Natural-Result-6633@reddit
It’s not the American people that have been terrorizing it’s the same men that have been stealing from the American people that have been terrorizing the world for war and profit.
Ancient-Practice-431@reddit
Yes but the American people have allowed it all to happen. Remember the book, What's the Matter with Kansas? People in some states have been manipulated into voting against their own interests for a long time, it's just happening at a wider scale now.
SiegelGT@reddit
The American people didn't allow shit. What the people want there statistically has near zero impact on what their government does.
newfound_brightness@reddit
Don’t waste your mental energy with these fools. They are mentally unwell.
This-Fruit-8368@reddit
WTF are you talking about? For 40+ years Americans have been electing politicians precisely BECAUSE they were running on cutting taxes for the rich, privatizing everything, and forcing christianity into everything.
Ree_on_ice@reddit
Apathy and non-action is allowing it. They look the other way.
I mean, you're literally pointing to a fictional 'them' as your big bad guy. Even though you're right that majority opinion rarely if ever affects the outcome (profit does), that's not the same as having no power.
newfound_brightness@reddit
Literally insane psychotic rhetoric. You are not well. This speak is what happens before gas chambers are built. Seek help.
NPVT@reddit
Mike Johnson himself is betraying democracy by not swearing Adelita Grijalva
HalfwaydonewithEarth@reddit
We are not collapsing. Our currency is surging. The EU is sinking.
GundamPilotMex@reddit
As a teenager, I grew up watching WWII documentaries. So having people ignore me when I try to warn them of how Hitler rose to power, drives me slightly insane
frost_axolotl@reddit
Collapse doesn't happen overnight but it's usually the same, unmanageable levels of corruption, what worries me is that America won't obviously go out without a fight and will rather turn to fascism and take resources by force as they have been eyeing multiple countries including Canada, Greenland, Venezuela, possibly Mexico. It's not like the USA doesn't have a history of invading countries rich in natural resources with dumb justifications.
tracenator03@reddit
In the 90s the post Soviet states underwent shock therapy by rapidly selling and privatizing everything. They had an economic crisis worse than the Great Depression. I feel like we've been getting the slow burn version of that and are reaching the end.
Ok_Pie3834@reddit
A bit karmic that the root of every issue in this country stems from it's refusal to let of go bigotry and hate, and that will ultimately lead to it's downfall.
KrishnaChick@reddit
The country's been collapsing for a while. The current administration is one small party of an ongoing process.
ejpusa@reddit
America survived the Civil War. We'll do fine. We're resilient. 50,000 dead in 3 days. And this went on for years.
This-Fruit-8368@reddit
One data point does not make a trend.
ejpusa@reddit
If we can survive the Civil War, we can survive Donald Trump. I’m not worried, at all.
This-Fruit-8368@reddit
Yeah, absolutely NOTHING has changed in the last 200 years. The comparison is spot on. 🤦♂️
ejpusa@reddit
Americans are more concerned that Starbucks is going to run out of Pumpkin Spice this Fall than a /collapse.
Just ask them. They’ll tell you the same thing.
This-Fruit-8368@reddit
That’s half the point. Too many people don’t care or don’t understand. You’re not helping your argument the way you think you are.
ejpusa@reddit
20% of Americans cannot read beyond the 3rd grade. And they never will. Absolutely nothing I can do about it.
This-Fruit-8368@reddit
Again, why do you think your comment supports your original position? Illiteracy is one of the primary weapons used against people. How can an illiterate population survive??
ejpusa@reddit
We’ll find out.
Logintheroad@reddit
The only thing that will save this land is breaking up into several smaller countries. We don't have the social culture to be a single nation. There are too many people to be governed by one.
A313-Isoke@reddit
I agree. The most unstable countries tend to be very populous and cover too much territory. People don't have the sense of connection to one another in circumstances like that. I just hope that it's not violent.
ChefSkeetz@reddit
It’s actually just not the USA. This is Earth. The corrupt system running it. We know it’s collapsing. However the main issue I think is happening:
Most of the population is being gaslit and manipulated into thinking this nonsensical reality isn’t collapsing.
all-day-pj@reddit
All of the dominos have to fall at some point or another!
nomadicding0@reddit
And it’s YOUR fault
PLUTO_HAS_COME_BACK@reddit
American leaders have a long-term plan (17) Post from The New Atlas - YouTube
bobbdac7894@reddit
What do you mean by fall? Balkanization? Doubt it. The federal government would send in the military if States try to separate.
What I predict happening is a lot of our issues just continuing to get worse and worse. This in a way is worse than States separating. Because, the scenario States separate, some might end up doing well. I think there will be more mass shootings. I think there will be wider wealth inequality. I think there will be more climate disasters. I think things will continue to get more and more expensive. I think Americans will get more and more unhealthier and fatter and fatter. I think they will get stupider and stupider. I think Americans will be more unhinged with their Christian nationalism. I think there will be more censorship. I think there will be more and more a police state. I think the billionaires and corporations will hold on to power and will continue to control our media, the politicians, market. Everything. I think all of these things will get 10 times worse. This scenario is a fall.
MairusuPawa@reddit
Some people om Reddit are still defending the idea that nazi salutes actually aren't nazi. So yeah, it's all kinda fucked up.
CommentingAccount4@reddit
Pluto got himself another one lol
themuleskinner@reddit
Saw this post on Instagram last night. The person in the video discusses how the US is a "complex system" and zooming out you see the US is part of an even larger global complex system. They talk about how comples system scientists are seeing a "failure cascade" which is how complex systems collapse. The interconnected systems, e.g. supply chains and military dependency, under the right conditions work efficiently but when there are failures in the system, the interconnectedness causes the failure to spread to other systems causing a domino effect. And once it starts, it's irreversible
I recommend watching it. It speaks directly to what we're all seeing ever day in this sub
livlaffluv420@reddit
aka the Threads effect
Nuclear war will happen because by that time it has to happen…
Livueta_Zakalwe@reddit
Cy is brilliant! Read her Substack!
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you.
trnwrks@reddit
For what it's worth, Kuba Wrzesniewski had probably the best take on Gorbachev's legacy, Perestroika, and the end of the Soviet Union.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you. I have a serious reading list ahead of me, and I will add your suggestion.
Peyaka@reddit
Stopped reading at source: The Daily Beast. Jeff Reddit is a joke platform these days
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Well, actually, I accidentally left out the paragraph linking those two sources. Sorry for the confusion.
MistyMtn421@reddit
I mainly just want to say thank you OP, for this post. Lots of fantastic discussion in this entire thread.
I appreciate you and the members of this sub so much. I appreciate the different viewpoints, resources and intelligent discourse. For all the crap we get IRL this is the most sane and logical place I have online.
Although we can't change the world in a post, I feel so much clarity and calm after reading everyone's comments.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I do, too. I joined this group in an effort to shake the late-night panic attacks and it seemed to work to know that I wasn’t the only one who thought this way.
Although, I can always see things I should have written about 5 comments into any discussion.
It’s amazing to me sometimes how civil people are in this sub. So far not one person has called me a name. Can’t say that for our government, huh?
StarlightLifter@reddit
I’ve had this thought for a while: the US is a heavy, HEAVY train moving across the tracks. There are little tiny obstructions on the track that slow it down very incrementally.
I’m US. I’m not saying it should be slowed down necessarily, as much of the world relies on it for trade and global stability etc. But the divisiveness injected into us as a nation especially by foreign actors, blatant misinformation etc is splintering it. The train is heavy and will take a lot to bring it to a halt but it is slowing. To ignore that is to ignore reality.
If only the slowdown of a train was as banal as the slowdown of a nation, unfortunately it isn’t. People will grasp at straws (MAGA) etc to try to hold on to some vestige of power while failing to unify under causes that should be universally accepted or condemned.
Anti vax movement? Clearly anti intellectual. Pro JAN6? Clearly an insurrection. Anti immigrant? Clearly ignoring our collective heritage, painting people who have both been clearly exploited and clearly punished by the same system. Climate change - arguably the biggest threat we face as a nation and the world - liberal hoax.
We have been played to work against ourselves here and it’s obvious and it’s obvious why. But the train will keep slowing no matter how heavy and we are going to suffer for it.
dseanATX@reddit
People have been suggesting the US is on the brink of collapse since 1776. While we are in a time of change and volatility, that doesn't equate to collapse.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I think we need a tighter definition of collapse. I would argue that a government shutdown that is greeted with joy by the rulers, is a pretty good sign of collapse.
DalmationStallion@reddit
Ya reckon?
New-Manufacturer-365@reddit
Air conditioning doesn’t stave off hunger nor protect against fire, floods and storms.
PowerandSignal@reddit
The wealthy have been successful at hoarding the excess of society's production since Reagan. This has produced a previously unimaginable disparity between the haves and the rest of society. This is an inherently unbalanced state, and we are experiencing the perturbations that result. One of which may lead to breakdown of democracy itself, which I suspect would only be a prelude to broader civil "unrest."
TheCrazedTank@reddit
This is nothing new, researchers and philosophers have been pondering on the rise and fall of societies since long before the birth of the USA.
Look up Polybius’s doctrine of Ana-cyclosis, or The Cycle of Civilization Collapse.
None of this is new, and in fact America is in the stage where a “Strong Man Figure” emerges before the end really kicks off.
Keep in mind collapse isn’t a single event but a series of them, and Human history is full of circular cycles.
Pythia007@reddit
A new work worth considering is Goliath’s Curse by Luke Kemp. A sweeping overview of what caused the collapse of over 400 societies. Hint: greedy elites driving extreme inequality play a big part but there’s a lot of fascinating detail and analysis.
Aqua-Hazelnut@reddit
I grew up with relatives trapped behind the Iron Curtain. I got to visit Once. "Careful, rhey have microphones in the trees!" warned my grandmother walking in a park. What was on TV? The dictator posturing, all him all the time. A nice man I met was given a rare, fast-acting cancer that left his little boy and wife without him, Just like Each previous director of his job. Secret police followed us eveywhere and pretended to be restaurant patrons, etc. It was truly surreal.
That was half a century ago, so imagine the tech as advanced for the time. My parents were the lucky ones who had escaped and we felt bad for the rest of the family.
Now my cousins who survived childhoods there and grew up, and are respectably employed, see what is happening over here! I'm just glad my parents don't have to.
mia181@reddit
But with the amount of people that are against Trump and fascism I am pretty sure we can come back from this once he's gone
Livueta_Zakalwe@reddit
It’s going to take decades to repair our reputation. And some of the damage is irreparable. Will any country ever trust us again, when it seems like we can elect a lunatic at any point every four years?
MistyMtn421@reddit
Eventually. But "coming back" is going to feel like the rebuild after a cat 5 hurricane vs fixing the roof after a tree fell. It's going to take a lot.
PervyNonsense@reddit
Everyone is talking about it which means it's happening.
There was a time not long ago where the suggestion that American democracy was at risk would be laughed at... like, globally.
Now we're at a point where "is America becoming an authoritarian state?" is a more common discussion than almost any other.
People dismiss the zeitgeist almost as gossip but this whole structure is a belief system that's only as strong as the faith people have in it, so when the global media, including social media, are clearly questioning the legitimacy of American democracy, it's over. It hasn't burned down but the glue that holds it together has dissolved.
MistyMtn421@reddit
Saw a post this morning in r/Europe about what were they going to do after we fall/collapse. So, not if/will/when, just making plans for the aftermath. And they aren't safe either as fascism & authoritarian political parties are on the rise everywhere.
EarthKnit@reddit
They’re smart enough to know that the United States is already lost.
DisturbingPragmatic@reddit
Not being an American, it's blatantly obvious that Trump is, and has been, a Russian asset. Putin's goal is for the US to be the USSR circa 1989-1993.
It's the only thing that explains everything he's doing. Everything he does has 2 outcomes: 1. harming the US internally and externally, and/or 2. Helping Russia.
But yeah. The US is cooked unless Americans actually have a revolution over what he's doing.
Bobcatluv@reddit
There’s a Netflix documentary, Turning Point: The Bomb and the Cold War (no, not that Turning Point) by documentarian Brian Knappenberger that covers all you mention and I saw a lot of parallels to our country. Particularly, the effectiveness of their disinformation campaigns in ruining their and now our country.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Thank you for the reference. I’ll follow up.
darkpsychicenergy@reddit
Nothing on Netflix is going to be politically or historically enlightening, especially in any international context.
antijoke_13@reddit
I think what we're looking at is closer to the transition from the Roman Republic to the Roman Empire. America is not going to collapse so much as it's going to shed the mask of benevolent civility it currently maintains and become properly expansionist. I fully expect us to do to Canada and Mexico what Russia is currently doing to Ukraine, though I suspect we will generally be more successful in the matter. This is not to say that Canada and Mexico will cease to exist as independent nations, but we'll take large parts of their territory in the name of "national security."
Doing so is going to completely kill what little political legitimacy America has left on the world stage, but I don't think the current crop of politicians or their voters care: an America divorced from international politics has been a pipedream of right wingers everywhere, despite the fact that global trade and travel is the lifeblood of modern American prosperity. Russia will be more than happy to back a US empire pushing into South America since it will decrease the likelihood of us meddling in their own efforts in Europe. If China is smart, they'll make some deal with the US guaranteeing access to (significantly lower quality) semiconductors and computer parts in exchange for abandoning our allies in the Pacific. China will take over as the reserve currency of the world, since they'll be the only ones both stable enough and internationally involved enough to make that happen.
Europe will get split between the new Big Three (US, China, Russia) and sold for parts.
nachohk@reddit
Why? Ukraine at least has farmland. What do Canada or Mexico have that the United States hasn't got already? I don't think this is plausible at all.
If we're predicting an American military campaign to try to prop up its self-destructing economy, which I think is possible though I'm not really that convinced of, I think Cuba, Haiti, and/or the Dominican Republic are the more likely targets. It's inconceivable that they could meaningfully threaten the United States due to American naval dominance and the lack of shared land borders, it's distant enough and foreign enough that I think there would be much less severe backlash from the public compared to Canada or Mexico, and there is at least a somewhat convincing pretext available that such conquest would help to create a kind of buffer and staging post and solidify American naval superiority in the Atlantic.
darkpsychicenergy@reddit
https://data.footprintnetwork.org/#/??_ga=2.265925839.1799298812.1758556840-1647542885.1758556840
The majority of people, including those on this sub, consistently ignore this data and all its implications, to their ongoing and endless detriment.
Canada has far more available biocapacity than the US, especially at US rates of consumption. Mexico doesn’t really have shit, but it is in the way.
Note which other countries have massive biocapacity deficits and which have reserves. The last thing Russia needed or wanted was Ukrainian farmland. It was never about that, for Russia. But certain other countries definitely do need more biocapacity, from somewhere.
antijoke_13@reddit
Don't fall into the trap of thinking this is about some kind of strategic objective: it's pure political theater where the cost of admission is thousands of innocent lives.
You have to think of Trump as a dumber but more powerful Putin. Putin invaded Ukraine because they desperately need access to Ukrainian farmland and warm water ports. It's the only way to breathe life in to their dying economy. Trump would invade Mexico and Canada because that's what he thinks a strong leader does. There are people around him who likely have more thought out objectives, Trump's just doing it for the photo op.
They are already replacing the Joint Chiefs of Staff with Yes Men, and the military has a long standing tradition of nonpartisanship: if the president says jump, all the generalship feels they get to ask is "how high?"
For what it's worth these are all worst case scenario predictions, and I'd love to be wrong. Im just worried that I won't be as wrong as we'd all like.
bizzybaker2@reddit
What dose have in Canada? Potash which you need for your agriculture (We have the largest reserves in the world), large amounts fresh water, the Northwest Passage which will be crucial in the future as ice recedes, to name a few....
youcantkillanidea@reddit
Canada has got large reserves of fresh water and Mexico's got oil. Surely a decadent USA will want to take both. But wait to see another Vietnam
winston_obrien@reddit
Oceania, Eurasia and Eastasia.
ruinatedtubers@reddit
can we fucking not? i’d like to not be from a country that haphazardly and belligerently annexes its neighbors’ land
Collapse2043@reddit
I don’t think science can explain what is happening in the US but I saw an interview with Timothy Snyder recently. He’s a historian and an expert on fascism. He sees a lot of signs of danger but also some signs of hope that the US can still turn back from the path it’s on. I’ll go find it for you.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I think you guys can pretty much count on an invasion, although I don’t have a timeline in my head. The question is: what are you going to do about it?
Collapse2043@reddit
I don’t think Trump will invade. He says he wants to annex us by destroying our economy though. So we are diversifying our trade much more. Just in the past six months, we have doubled our exports to Europe and Britain. It was really Harper’s fault for enmeshing us with the US. I was always against the free trade agreement. We also have a new trans mountain pipeline and are sending our oil overseas to Asia much more. Some want to build one eastward but others say oil will be over before that ever gets completed.
As far as military defense goes, even though it’s not an immediate concern, we have doubled our spending and have stopped buying American equipment which often has a kill switch such as the F35 jets. We are purchasing from Europe now. The rest of NATO would help defend us so it would be NATO and probably other Common wealth countries too like Australia and New Zealand vs America.
okiepilgrim@reddit
I’ve heard the “what good does it do?” question more frequently lately. Civil unrest and protest brings change. Look at the civil rights act of the 1960s. The “velvet revolution” in Czechoslovakia or the Arab Spring. NOT protesting is acceptance and submission. The right to protest and speak out against things you disagree with has been paid for in blood and it’s our duty and privilege to exercise it.
Ok-Secretary455@reddit
Well fascism is a perfect 50 - 0. When its voted into power it has never once been voted back out of power. Its either war or old age that finally ends things. Average length of 31 years. So thats cool.
https://medium.com/@carmitage/i-researched-every-attempt-to-stop-fascism-in-history-the-success-rate-is-0-a665e2e048a2
AntiBoATX@reddit
The only issues I see are 1) the implosion is self-inflicted. We could choose democratic rule of law and social democracy and healthy capitalism and continue to innovate and lead the world. We’re the richest nation with the most science and business friendly environment, highest number of academics, and can grow our own crops and consume our own natural resources. This is purely an issue of greed and power. 2) our military is not going to bow to a dictator. Thus, it’ll have to be dismantled in order to be removed as a threat to the authoritarians. 3) we still remain the most viable economic center of power. Europe and Asia have good companies but population education, work ethic, and innovation all still favor the US. Ai may negate this advantage/ aspect to contend with.
All in all, it’s fucking stupid and frustrating. We could have economically defeated Russia, regained Ukrainian sovereignty and put the non-nato axis on permanent defense only mode and continued to innovate science and technology while exploring the stars and raising standard of living for our 300m population, along with a major focus on climate mitigation. Instead we have lizard men building bunkers in New Zealand and the first half a trillion dollar man playing with a government like it’s a sandbox game.
Greed is our monkey brains’ Great Filter.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I agree. It is frustrating to watch us shoot ourselves in the foot.
But you don’t think anyone in the military will try for a coup? They can’t possibly respect Hegseth, Trump, or Vance. Maybe not today, but . . . I dunno, say in a year, if the republicans manage to control the mid-term elections, or there’s an actual recession?
I’m absolutely sure there were factions in the Soviet Union‘s armed forces.
And where did all the warlords come from, who control places like Georgia or Azerbaijan?
HommeMusical@reddit
They have been taught that the honorable way to resist is to resign and that is what they'll do - resign, and make way for the Fascists.
MistyMtn421@reddit
They have already fired many top level people and after that weird pep rally of the top brass, probably will fire even more. And absolutely those who disagree and haven't been let go will resign.
I was 18 when the wall came down in Berlin. Came of age in a time where as a woman I was able to send myself to school, buy my first home by myself at 26 and thought Al Gore was going to save the planet in 2000. Now that all feels like a fever dream.
HommeMusical@reddit
It does indeed. Things changed so fast. History in the making, if there are indeed historians in the future.
detreikght@reddit
Capitalism is working as intended. It's just got harder to exploit Africa, Asia, SA (on whom the prosperity was built). So colonialism had to turn inward.
Worldly-Flow-185@reddit
At the rate the world is progressing, the rest of the world's propserity will eclipse the US'. Every country is removing the USD out of their reserves, the US government keeps printing money to bail out corporations, and our debt has reached the point where the US will likely have to default on it soon. Manufacturing, agriculture, education, and even social services have been gutted to the point that the country will be unable to rebuild itself when it economically collapses.
vicnoir@reddit
I love finding Fermi’s Paradox in the wild. ❤️
HommeMusical@reddit
All the evidence we have says quite the reverse.
Generals who disagree with Trump are already retiring like the cowards they are.
RollinThundaga@reddit
"If destruction is our lot, we must be its author."
howardzen12@reddit
So true!!!! America like Ancient Rome is collapsing.All great empires eventually fall throughout history.China is now the rising star.China later in the century will be the leading power on earth.
Someones_Dream_Guy@reddit
About time US got some karma for all the wars and parasitism.
Proof_Register9966@reddit
You see a parallel because it is from the Russian playbook. Putin runs the transnational mob. Dementia Don has been laundering money for them since the 80’s. Russia is also a kleptocracy- that’s exactly what they are doing here. Billions of dollars are missing from the treasury- coincidentally the same time as trump became a billionaire and Elon became a trillionaire.
darkpsychicenergy@reddit
This sounds exactly the types who blame “The Jews” for everything. Deranged, historically denialist, raving about “Jewish Cabals” running everything and “Jewish Conspiracies” and space lasers. Just a coincidence, surely.
They see a parallel because it is the Capital playbook.
Weary_Base_209@reddit
Check out Naomi Klein’s “Shock Doctrine”. Pretty much what the Repubs and Trump are applying to the US. When all the chips are cashed we will be a rue Soviet style autocratic oligarchy.
Apprehensive_Put463@reddit
Empires decline after 250 years.
Kite005@reddit
If MAGA gets their way, the USA I grew up in is done, that's a sad thing.
Masterventure@reddit
The people in trump 2 admin are trying to play the nazi playbook and a lot of them are not shy about saying so.
Nodebunny@reddit
it only falls if your passive aggressive ass lets it. we are the ones responsible not someone else
jaymickef@reddit
If there’s a parallel who is the Lech Walensa and Solidarity standing up to it?
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
He is Polish. I don’t think Poland was part of the Soviet Union.
Also, I don’t know. Bernie, maybe?
96-62@reddit
Poland was a part of the Soviet Union.
No-Insurance100@reddit
Open the schools
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
My bad. Thanks for the correction.
ArendtAnhaenger@reddit
No, Poland was part of the Warsaw Pact and a Soviet satellite state but it was not a Soviet republic the way Russia, Belarus, Estonia, etc. were.
It would be like saying Britain was a part of the USA.
No-Insurance100@reddit
Bernard Sanders, the genocide apologist?
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Well, who, then? AOC? There’s a real dearth of leadership in this country.
jaymickef@reddit
That’s what Gerald Ford said to lose the presidential race. I can’t tell if you forget the /s or not.
TheArcticFox444@reddit
It isn't just democracies that die. For the past 10,000 years, give or take, civilizations have risen, flourished, even did astonishing things but all...all...have faded, faultered, and eventually failed. *
Ours will go the same way for, essentially, the same reason. Humans are good at building civilizations using various political, cultural, economic, geography, etc.. Humans just aren't good at sustaining them.
Oxford also puts out a world history.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Good point. You might enjoy a book called The Dawn of Everything, by Graeber and Wengrow
TheArcticFox444@reddit
Thank you. I'll check it out.
Warning_North@reddit
It's fallen
aflix62@reddit
No
thatmfisnotreal@reddit
Any day now
ScientistUnhappy2072@reddit
Other countries are built differently from the ground up. Expecting every country to have the ideals of the west is a recipe for total defeat and collapse of Western democracy.
GamerGuyAlly@reddit
I don't think its a hot take to say the US is collapsing. It's blatantly obvious it is from observation.
aucool786@reddit
So personal thought, I don't think the United States will collapse the way the USSR did with all 50 component states gaining independence. What I'd say is far more likely is a low level insurgency, similar to The Troubles in Northern Ireland.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
Well, the western states and the northeastern states have taken the step of telling their populations to ignore Trump/kennedy vaccination recommendations.
The Making of America's Culture Regions is a book by Richard Nostrand that popped up when I searched for references about the cultural regions of the USA.
Somewhere in the responses to this post there’s another recommendation for a book on this topic.
I live in the Deep South - I would expect these states to stick together as a political unit.
Also, I get what you say about insurgency, But (again I’m not an expert), it sort of seems like the political right is its own insurgency, in spite of their efforts to control the narrative. Although, having the military attack Democratic states could change that.
SCUMDOG_MILLIONAIRE@reddit
It depends how you define the collapse or fall of a nation. There’s an ongoing and very real decline in the US Democracy Index, but countries remain countries through shifts in governance types. When viewed in certain fiscal lenses the US is doing better than ever and leads the world, even if at the same time more population slips into poverty.
There’s a classic definition of state collapse which is defined by about 12 metrics. I think there’s solid evidence that America is declining in all of them at various rates. Some areas have been declining for decades while other areas have seen a sharp decline in recent years. The other leading nations are already working towards a world that does not include the US as the leading power, and once they can successfully shut out the US from the economic table I think that’s the final straw
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
You know what? That’s a good question. How do you define collapse (of a nation)? I need to think about this.
My background is in agriculture, and the collapse of an industry (citrus in Florida, for example) or the collapse of a clade or emptying of a niche have clear definitions.
I’ve wonder if the sub has a definition. I’ll go look.
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I’d like to read that study, if you could provide a reference?
reggieLedoux26@reddit
Trump presiding over the collapse seems inevitable
DogFennel2025@reddit (OP)
I dunno. I think he’s in a bad way. I think something in his body will break and Vance will be president. He seems to be a strong supporter of the collapse of our country.
I just don’t get how these P2025 people think the economy will survive as climate change progresses.
TinaKedamina@reddit
My Titans are so ass they aren’t even including in posts about the worst teams in football
uglyugly1@reddit
What's happening here in the US now reminds me of the beginning of Fernando Aguirre's story on his blog "Surviving in Argentina", which chronicles his experiences navigating post-collapse Argentina after 2001.
Basically, the politicians go nuts, everyone but the richest few becomes broke, and the regular people all turn on each other and fight over the scraps.
Sound familiar?
IWantoBeliev@reddit
The day Mexican (and rest of South American) don't illegally come, is the day USA fails.
In usa an Latino, Asian, African has a chance to make more than a European, no where else in this world that's possible.
Wish_Wolf@reddit
I think we are heading towards collapse. I am guessing everyone here sees that dark black wall in their minds whenever they try to do analysis of this country's future. I honestly think people just deny it because they feel it could never happen to us like it does to other countries.
lovely_sombrero@reddit
The USSR disbanded because the leaders believed they didn't need the USSR anymore, they can just be friends with the benevolent US & NATO. It was crazy that they believed this, the cold war really was won with propaganda.
Almost immediately, the US took control over policy in ex-USSR states and sold Russia off to the oligarchs.
_jgmm_@reddit
This is the American Perestroika.