What's An American Classic You Read and Absolutely Loved?
Posted by CalmRip@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 744 comments
We recently had a thread asking about American classics you hated. For this one, I'd like to make clear it does not have to be something you were required to read, although it's fine if so.
One I absolutely loved was Lone Cowboy: My Life Story, by Will James. It's the author's somewhat fictionalized autobiography. He was born in Canada, and eventually became a working ranch cowboy, then an author and illustrator.
It's the story of an amazing journey, and it takes the reader into a wild and beautiful world that is both technologically simpler and culturally richer than one might expect. From the viewpoint of someone who's been an actual working cowhand, his observations of working with livestock are dead on--and entertaining as hell.
Throwawayproroe@reddit
The illustrated man is one of my all time favorites! Bradbury has a unique style of sci-fi that focuses more on technology’s impact on the human psyche than the technology itself.
PachucaSunrise@reddit
Does “Walden” count?
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
Most definitely.
cheaganvegan@reddit
The jungle
02K30C1@reddit
Fun fact: The Jungle is why we have White Castle. There was a big distrust of meat and restaurant cleanliness because of the book. White Castle painted everything white and cooked right in front of the customers to show how clean they were.
CadenVanV@reddit
Honestly, GOATed move
WahooLion@reddit
I agree, but I try to forget I ever read it.
althoroc2@reddit
I read The Jungle and Oil! recently. Both were better than I'd expected but I'd stop short of saying I loved them.
Miss_Might@reddit
A tree grows in Brooklyn
aquay@reddit
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
Severe_Flan_9729@reddit
Fahrenheit 451, Great Gatsby, and Catcher in the Rye.
No_Cellist8937@reddit
Only phonies wouldn’t say Catcher In The Rye
Jumpy-Lie8955@reddit
catcher in the rye is overhated
Rocketgirl8097@reddit
15 yr old me read it and thought it was boring. Haven't tried again.
Adventurous_Cook9083@reddit
Is one of my favorite books.
RupeThereItIs@reddit
God awful book.
Glad you enjoyed it, but for the life of me I couldn't figure out why.
ColdMeatloafSandwich@reddit
What a grand answer
Expert_Ad_1189@reddit
Catcher in the Rye is the one that truly baffles me. It’s not even disliking the character, I was straight up bored by it.
dodadoler@reddit
Fuck Holden caufield
Foxy_locksy1704@reddit
Yes, that is the point of the book. You’re not supposed to like him he is in many ways the exact thing he claims to hate.
swampy138@reddit
I did not research anything about the book before I read it and I liked Holden. He’s no saint but it seemed to me that he recognizes that and wants to protect the younger kids from growing up to be like him, as he sees himself as a lost cause and he sees them as not having lost their happiness yet. That’s why he scratched out the bad word at the museum.
WesternCowgirl27@reddit
The only book I threw across my camper for my summer reading lol.
Crankenberry@reddit
HAHAHAHA! I read it when I went to Europe in my 30s. I think the only reason I got through it is I didn't have anything else to read while standing in line at airports until I got to Ireland and bought the Order of the Phoenix the day it was released (yes this was 20 something years ago).
On a related note, I once had a date with a very hot English teacher and I told him my favorite book was a Tree Grows in Brooklyn. He told me that when he taught that and CITR in the same semester, the girls invariably loved Tree and hated Catcher, and the boys invariably loved Catcher and hated Tree. 😂
WesternCowgirl27@reddit
Maybe reading it now that I’m in my 30s will make a difference 😅 I was 16 when I read it the first time, and boy, that was rough haha.
That’s so funny how that works out between books that girls like versus what guys like.
CO is a cool state and fun place to be raised!
HeWhomLaughsLast@reddit
My English teacher was quick to put down any discussion about not liking Holden. He was either a cool rebel or you fail the homework assignment.
Foxy_locksy1704@reddit
It’s sad when even the teacher misses the point of the book. In high school I was told I wasn’t smart enough to understand it. So I borrowed a copy from a friend and read it in my free time. I completely understood the book, then the teacher got pissed when I started asking questions about the book I wasn’t assigned to read.
kgrimmburn@reddit
I had a teacher get mad at me for pointing out she was wrong when she said The Outsiders was set in the 1950s. I pointed out Mustangs were introduced in 1965 so it couldn't possibly be any earlier than May 1964. Argued with me about it and everything...
HeWhomLaughsLast@reddit
My teachers favorite selling point for the book was how controversial and edgy it was. In an era where some kids start watching South Park in middle school you need a better selling point.
Crankenberry@reddit
Jfc 🤦🏼♀️
I hope he didn't make you suffer through On the Road if that were the case. 😂
304libco@reddit
Yeah, tell that to almost every teenager I know who loves that book.
Foxy_locksy1704@reddit
Teens think he is this bad ass rebel, adults understand that this is a kid with a massive chip on his shoulder due to life just happening and him not being able to cope with the world around him.
304libco@reddit
I think that if you’re not a teenage rebel or a popular kid, then you really fucking hate him because he seems just like the kind of person who bullies kids like you.
Spackleberry@reddit
Having read it as an adult, it became clear that his relationship with his sister was the point of the whole story. Holden finally realizes he has someone who cares about him and whom he can care about, and that he needs to quit being an ass for her sake.
Foxy_locksy1704@reddit
Absolutely the only truly positive and “light” relationship he had was with the younger sister.
CampbellsBeefBroth@reddit
Holden is a piece of shit but I understand why he is the way he is
Crankenberry@reddit
I wouldn't go so far as to call him an outright piece of shit, but he's certainly an insufferable entitled little ass.
No-Angle-982@reddit
Because, fiction?
Crankenberry@reddit
Hated that little fucker 😂
AccomplishedEdge982@reddit
Man, I tried to read Gatsby three separate times and I just. couldn't. get into it. I tried. 👍🏼 to Fahrenheit 451 tho.
ucbiker@reddit
Yup love Great Gatsby and Catcher in the Rye. It’s always funny to me that people are like “they’re rich, I don’t want to listen to their problems” like OK man, I guess the only novel worth reading is Grapes of Wrath.
Senior-Cantaloupe-69@reddit
I loved Catcher in the Rye. Kind of. I read it young, not as an assignment. I remember being confused, not liking Holden but somehow being blown away. I probably need to read it again as a 50- something. Why did you like it?
SubUrbanMess2021@reddit
I’ve read all three. Excellent American literature.
Succulent_Roses@reddit
Catch-22
Background-Ear8790@reddit
Most of John Steinbeck's works. My favorite is what he considered his magnum opus, East of Eden.
Neat-Neighborhood595@reddit
Call of the Wild
hohner1@reddit
Longfellow's Tales of a Wayside Inn
Hemingway's Old Man and the Sea
Wouk's Winds of War/War and Remembrance (I liked the miniseries better).
Most stuff by Irving
chillhop_vibes@reddit
"Grapes of Wrath", "Flowers for Algernon", and "White Fang"
AnymooseProphet@reddit
John Steinbeck short stories collection.
Pistalrose@reddit
Sweet Thursday is not as well known or popular as many Steinbeck works but it has a place in my heart.
Rundiggity@reddit
Travels with Charley!
_hammitt@reddit
I love this book! Deeply underrrated Steinbeck
wmass@reddit
He mainly was criticized for concentrating mostly on rural areas in a time when there was a lot going on in our cities.
Rundiggity@reddit
Why would he be criticized… He literally said that he fell out of touch with the people that he was writing about and wanted to go meet ordinary Americans in rural places
wmass@reddit
By criticized I meant he had critical reviews on the topic. I think there is truth in the idea that most ordinary Americans live in or near cities and did even when he was traveling with Charley. I enjoyed the book and it is still selling so it wasn’t a failure but it wasn’t at the top of his work. I’ve read most of his novels, even Sweet Thursday and Cup of Gold.
HaplessReader1988@reddit
Log from the Sea of Cortez is ny favorite.
Rundiggity@reddit
Ordered!
left_justified@reddit
Came here to say this. It's such a great Steinbeck deep cut.
wmass@reddit
My poodle is named after Charley.
Butterbean-queen@reddit
One of my all time favorites.
CupBeEmpty@reddit
I am reading Twain’s biography by Chernow right now… that man was strange and fascinating. Just an absolute jumble of moral and political stances and hard humor even with his own kids. Yet everyone loved him speaking.
FMLwtfDoID@reddit
‘Breakfast’ is my favorite Steinbeck short story. I could not tell you why; it has stuck with me, and always distantly on my mind for some reason.
AnymooseProphet@reddit
My favorite is "The Harness" because of how foolish everyone thought the farmer was a fool for planting 40 acres of the sweat pea crop, a crop that was profitable but often failed, yet the gamble paid off.
I guess instead of favorite I should say most memorable, every time I read one of his short stories it is my favorite while I read it.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Of Mice and Men.
Glove fulla Vaseline.
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
The Long Valley is a great Steinbeck collection.
TheSapoti@reddit
Beloved by Toni Morrison
emoberg62@reddit
One of the best I’ve ever read.
AggressiveSloth11@reddit
That book had some moments. Reading in high school was intense for me.
StanislasMcborgan@reddit
Hell of a book
PrivateTumbleweed@reddit
Catcher in the Rye
All Quiet on the Western Front
For Whom the Bell Tolls
Brave New World
Lord of the Flies
NewYork_NewJersey440@reddit
I know it sucks because (spoiler alert) the dogs die, but I still love Where the Red Fern Grows.
Suppafly@reddit
One of my kids, mostly grown now, is still straight up traumatized by that scene where the guy gets his guts cut out by an axe.
madebysquirrels@reddit
https://www.mentalfloss.com/article/63083/12-things-you-might-not-know-about-where-red-fern-grows
Tigerzombie@reddit
I always stop after the hunting contest on rereads. That way I can imagine Billy and the dogs lived in the mountains until the dogs passed of old age and then the family moved away.
wasaaabiP@reddit
This was my favorite book as a child. I must have read it fifty times and cried every time :-(
sarahprib56@reddit
My mom taught middle school language arts (English) and did this book every year. She cried each time she read it to the kids.
Whose_my_daddy@reddit
But the ending. Tears me up every time.
CliffGif@reddit
Lonesome Dove
Cathode335@reddit
Of Mice and Men
traveler_@reddit
I was an adult when I finally picked up Moby Dick. I loved it. Every single part of it, even the weird parts, even the other weird parts, they all spoke to me. The whole time I was thinking boy, we shouldn't be teaching this to students who aren't into it because it's a lot. But for people who are into it, it's great. And I have no end of joy in talking about the pagan gay marriage between Ishmael and Queequeg, just because I'm amazed at how that scene has been swept under the rug. Like you can't even talk about sex in America unless it's Shakespeare and too obscure for kids to understand.
MagpieFlicker@reddit
I tried several times to read this when I was a teenager, but couldn't make it past the first few chapters. Tried again in my 50s and LOVED it! One of the best books I've ever read, seriously!
TerriblePokemon@reddit
People do not believe me when I say Moby dick is an absolutely hysterical book. The narrator (Ishmael) has such a dry wit once you recognize it, like you said anything with him and Queequeg is pure comedy gold.
My favourite passage is the end of chapter 1, when the narrator is describing the local holier-than-thou minister:
"Being the head of the temperance union, he only drinks the tepid tears of orphans."
Barkeep, one glass of lukewarm orphan tears please, and keep them coming.
awmaleg@reddit
I’ve never tried it but this makes it sound promising
whattheshiz97@reddit
I read it when I was a kid and man that was hard without a reference guide for all the old terminology.
TerriblePokemon@reddit
It's either an incredibly detailed novel, or an encyclopedia of 19th century whaling with a framing device. Having a glossary of antiquated nautical terms helps.
Like many great classics, it's way more fun to read on your own, instead of being forced to for a grade and over analyzing every single chapter.
TheExquisiteCorpse@reddit
I find the scenes with Peleg and Bildad, the ship owners. Two old men who are complete opposites in every way, one is a devout quaker, the other is a salty foul mouthed guy, but they are completely united in being greedy bastards and making sure Ishmael gets paid as little as possible.
LurkerByNatureGT@reddit
I think one of the problems with Moby Dick is that people approach it as “The Great American Novel” and think they have to glean every bit of metaphor from it instead of a wild fucking ride (that yes happens to have a lot of depth to it).
Caloso89@reddit
I also love that the chapters are short and many of them are little self-contained stories.
roboroyo@reddit
Try Pierre or the Ambiguities if you like Melville in particular. Maybe, even The Marble Faun by that other 19th century American novelist, Nathaniel Hawthorne.
Beginning_Cap_8614@reddit
The Color Purple is a brutal read, but also beautiful in how it tells its story. I read it in high school and it's been with me ever since.
4square425@reddit
The Giver, To Kill a Mockingbird, The Great Gatsby, The Old Man and the Sea
madebysquirrels@reddit
I reread The Giver every few years. Different things stand out to me every time.
DidAnyoneFeedTheDog@reddit
My 8th grade teacher read us The Old Man and the Sea. The book was good, but the teacher was awesome!
blitzkrieghop@reddit
The Giver.
catcatcatcatcat1234@reddit
My Ántonia, Willa Cather. Beautifully written.
madebysquirrels@reddit
I was having issues with my Kindle recently and only had access to a collection of public domain classics. I remembered enjoying My Antonia in high school but almost nothing about the plot, so I decided to give it another try. God, what a delightful read. I need to try more of Cather's stuff. I'd love other recommendations of work like hers as well.
Imaginary_Ladder_917@reddit
I’ll have to read this again. It did nothing for me as a high school freshman but I think I might like it now, over 40 years and a masters degree in literature later.
catcatcatcatcat1234@reddit
It's not a book I expected to like, it seemed very boring. But it turned out to be the most beautifully written book I've ever read
MysteryBelle_NC@reddit
Agreed.
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
I love Cather, especially Death Comes for the Archbishop.
Different_Bat4715@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird is probably my favorite book of all time.
Rude_Tax_7494@reddit
Is margaret mitchell's gone with the wind
tu-vens-tu-vens@reddit
Sometimes people from a place have a love-hate relationship with the place’s biggest works of culture or art. They can feel that those works of art present a reductive image of the place to the outside world.
As an Alabamian, that is not remotely the case with To Kill a Mockingbird. Even though I live in a million-person metro instead of a small town 90 years after the events of the book, TKAM captures what this state feels like more than anything else.
Crankenberry@reddit
Have you heard the audible version? It's read by Sissy Spacek.
cIumsythumbs@reddit
Sissy Spacek is from the same tiny rural Texas town as my Step-dad. I love her to bits.
B00k_Worm1979@reddit
Loved this book and movie!!
Myearthsuit@reddit
I threw a fit to get my husband to agree to name our son “Atticus” but I lost the battle…. So I just have a sticker of Scout in her ham costume on my car’s back window 😂
Zealousideal-Slide98@reddit
Where could I find a sticker like that?!
Myearthsuit@reddit
https://www.teepublic.com/magnet/7246979-scout-ham-to-kill-a-mockingbird
Asleep-Banana-4950@reddit
I just read To Kill a Mockingbird for the first time about a month ago.
theatregirl1987@reddit
I love this book so much I named my cats after it!
TheReal-Chris@reddit
Name? Scout?
theatregirl1987@reddit
Catticus Finch. And his sister, Harpurr Lee
Key-Bear-9184@reddit
Catticus kills finches
Prior-Complex-328@reddit
Thank you!!
TheReal-Chris@reddit
🤣
Occomni@reddit
My friend’s cat is named Boo Radley!
No-Picture4119@reddit
Mine as well! By the time my daughter had to read it for school, she had already read it several times based on my recommendation, as well as having any potential essay questions mansplained to her at length by me.
TriciaTargaryen@reddit
My dog is named Atticus after this book! Love this one so so much.
Alarming-Ad9441@reddit
I love this one too! I’ve actually even read it along with each of my kids when it was assigned to them in school. They’ve all enjoyed it as much as I have. I’m even impressed with the movie adaptation and love that my kids have also watched it in school after reading.
sittingonmyarse@reddit
I taught it for years. I always paid for the audio book so they could hear it read well. And I followed along with every page, in every class, every time. With a pencil because there was always something new to note!
When I retired, I was given a plaque by my English department friends listing the things that I had taught them. One of them was “it’s always worth it to buy the audiobook.”
Alarming-Ad9441@reddit
You know I’ve never listened to an audiobook. I’ve always just loved having the book in my hand. I even tried a Kindle once but didn’t like it at all. Might have to look into some though, I’ve often heard there are some great recordings.
sittingonmyarse@reddit
I was always a speedy reader, but 23 years as an English teacher made me a super speed reader, and I’ve had a hard time breaking away from it. Especially since I had a car accident and massive concussion. Listening to books has been a better way to enjoy reading. Also, I can do it in the car or while I’m sewing or doing housework. I do read printed text more and more, though.
OutsideBones86@reddit
Ooh, yes, I read this once every other year or so, usually around the last days of summer.
AggressiveSloth11@reddit
This was going to be my answer. True story- There’s a kid at my son’s school named Atticus Finch. I don’t know if I loved the book THAT much though.
LadybugGirltheFirst@reddit
Agreed! And Hollywood had better not try to remake the movie because it’s perfect as it is.
Zealousideal-Slide98@reddit
I saw the play with Richard Thomas as Atticus, and Mary Badham (she played Scout in the movie) as Mrs. Dubose. I hated it. They played many of the scenes as a comedy. I really, really hated it.
LadybugGirltheFirst@reddit
Seriously?! That’s awful.
MeanOldDaddyO@reddit
I came here to say this.
LetsGoGators23@reddit
This thread reminded me of this book, and I just suggested it to my book loving 11 year old. She is old enough and mature enough for it. Need to keep passing these down to the new generation.
sittingonmyarse@reddit
Hmm…discuss rape before you get to that part of the book.
LetsGoGators23@reddit
We have - but I do appreciate the warning because I don’t remember the details. My girls have the vocab and knowledge for most awful things in this world already, mostly because I openly communicate with them and they have always asked me a lot of questions. Not everyone’s parenting style but it’s worked well for us.
sittingonmyarse@reddit
I had an 8th grade parent tell me that her son couldn’t read Flowers for Algernon because the guy has a wet dream and her son - 13 years old - didn’t know what that was. I told her the truth - he knew what it was, he just wasn’t going to tell his mother!
LetsGoGators23@reddit
Exactly. And unless you talk to them early, often, openly and honestly, you lose your ability as a parent to frame those conversations in a healthy way. My 11 year old asked me in the car last year what a dildo was 😂 and I just … answered her. I didn’t get pissed she knew the word, I didn’t freak out, I just explained what it was. We had some laughs about it and moved on. I’m so much happier she asked me and not Google.
sittingonmyarse@reddit
Funny family story. When my boys were about 7, 9, 11, 13-ish, we were in the car and 11 yo says “mom, my tinkle just got real big and it hurts!” I screeched the car into a parking spot and we had a lively conversation about many “woody” details. They’re all in their 40’s now with sons of their own, and we’ve had a few laughs over that!
auburncub@reddit
Me too! Ironically, I didn't like it when I read it. It was years after when I actually realized the meaning behind it and liked it (don't judge me - my reading level used to be very low - so it took me years to actually click). Now I look back at it and love it.
fbibmacklin@reddit
This was going to be my answer. I have read it so many times. It's like an old friend that I revisit often. I love it so much that I can't bring myself to read Go Set a Watchmen. I need my old friends to be okay and stay okay, you know?
Expert_Pride7285@reddit
Exactly the way I feel.
Comfortable-Tell-323@reddit
Just take my up vote
catiebug@reddit
Saw the title, opened the thread, TKAM is the top comment, all is right with the world.
septidan@reddit
How'd you like the sequel?
Different_Bat4715@reddit
I own it, but I haven’t actually read it. Based on the responses I’ve heard about it, I’ll probably skip it.
casapantalones@reddit
It is a beautiful book.
Senior-Cantaloupe-69@reddit
It is truly amazing. It’s one of the few classics that is great when you’re young and as an adult.
NotLikeARegularMom-@reddit
I borrowed the audiobook through Libby and it is narrated by Sissy Spacek. I’m not sure if it was her southern accent or the source material itself -or even a combination of the two- but I absolutely loved To Kill A Mockingbird.
CommandAlternative10@reddit
The second I finished reading it in high school I ran to the card catalog to find her other books… oops.
_hi_plains_drifter_@reddit
I love this one so much too.
derberner90@reddit
This was assigned reading in my high school and I'm so glad for it. Definitely a favorite of mine!
NIN10DOXD@reddit
I came here to say this. It especially hits home for me as I also grew up as white child in the South, questioning why the adults around me treated people so poorly for being different than them (racism, homophobia, islamophobia, hatred of atheists, etc.).
FMLwtfDoID@reddit
The best dog I ever owned was a deaf English Bull Terrier named Scout. She was so cool, and new sign language commands but often had “selective” understanding (can’t say selective hearing lol). She was named for my favorite character, in one of my most favorite books.
My mom got her littermate, and she named him Atticus, but was later demoted to Gus bc the grandkids couldn’t say his name
Lanky-Position-9963@reddit
Grapes of wrath. Amazing book
Professional_Sea1479@reddit
I love ALL of Steinbeck’s books.
Rude_Tax_7494@reddit
Anything by Agatha, Christie. Arthur cannon Doyle.
Away-Ad4393@reddit
Me too. I have a shelf full of them 😊
awmaleg@reddit
Lots of Steinbeck. East of Eden. Of Mice and Men. The Moon is Down. The goofy Cannery Row/ Tortilla Flat.
dcgrey@reddit
East of Eden was what did it for me and reading. I was a good student but never read for pleasure. Senior year of high school we had to write a long paper on a novel of our choice and I was clueless where to start. My favorite teacher just said “There’s a John Steinbeck book that you should read.”
Over the years I’ve read all his books (though only a handful of his magazine pieces beyond those collected in Once There Was a War) and came to like him much more for books besides East of Eden. But when I look at what I studied in college and grad school and look over the books on my shelves, I know it all started with that teacher, John Steinbeck, and that recommendation of East of Eden.
EngineEngine@reddit
Literature, writing, library studies...? What did you study?
missxmeow@reddit
East of Eden was my first John Steinbeck novel, so good. Currently reading Grapes of Wrath, with The Pearl after.
Rizzpooch@reddit
I just finished East of Edenlast week, and I have a new appreciation for the phrase “the great American novel” now
Global-Discussion-41@reddit
Winter of our Discontent is by far my favorite.
kitchengardengal@reddit
My son decided he wanted to be a marine bioligist like Doc after reading Cannery Row as a kid. He's now the lead fish biologist at a dam in the PNW.
AggressiveSloth11@reddit
We started reading Steinbeck in 4th grade and beyond at my school in California. It definitely increased my interest in marine biology; I got my bachelors degree in marine bio!
OhThrowed@reddit
I love Of Mice an Men. I can't read it often, it leaves me bawling.
sanka@reddit
I re-read East of Eden every couple years.
Orion_69_420@reddit
To a God Unknown may be my favorite and no one talks about it.
Treefrog_Ninja@reddit
The Pearl.
ineedmoreslee@reddit
I really hate the remake/reboot trend in movies right now. I think because they are all pulling for nostalgia dollars. But the movie for this book was so long ago, a well done remake would do great and I think what we really need right now.
Own-Excitement9450@reddit
I read John Steinbeck’s “The Pearl” when I was eight. It was a world of wonder…
AggressiveSloth11@reddit
The longest book I’ve ever read 😂 but it was great.
fbibmacklin@reddit
It's a great one. Definitely in my top 5 for American classics. I can't remember if I had to read it in high school or college first, but I have reread it several times since.
kindof_Alexanderish@reddit
Came here to say this. As a new software engineer I got into the job market after two years of crazy layoffs. There was so much promise when I started learning the trade only to be dumped into the worst job market imaginable. I kept thinking about this during my 13 months of unemployment.
10000 flyers for 300 jobs…
RupeThereItIs@reddit
I graduated college in August 2001, with a degree in CIS.
I thought I was going to be able to right my own ticket, maybe even get a sign on bonus, even coming from a lower tier state school. My peers graduating 6 or 12 months earlier where getting awesome jobs.
Then the entire .com bubble burst right before I graduated!!
OK, no problem, I'll regroup. I'll move back in with my parents, and eventually find something. It's not like an apocalyptic thing, just a nasty recession targeting my industry, I'll find something.
Then a month later someone flies planes into NYC, the Pentagon & a field in Pennsylvania.
It was a very bad time.
rakfocus@reddit
Chapter 14 of Grapes of Wrath...
THE WESTERN LAND, nervous under the beginning change. The Western States, nervous as horses before a thunder storm. The great owners, nervous, sensing a change, knowing nothing of the nature of the change. The great owners, striking at the immediate thing, the widening government, the growing labor unity; striking at new taxes, at plans; not knowing these things are results, not causes. Results, not causes; results, not causes. The causes lie deep and simple—the causes are a hunger in a stomach, multiplied a million times; a hunger in a single soul, hunger for joy and some security, multiplied a million times; muscles and mind aching to grow, to work, to create, multiplied a million times The last clear definite function of man—muscles aching to work, minds aching to create beyond the single need—this is man. To build a wall, to build a house, a dam, and in the wall and house and dam to put something of Manself, and to Manself take back something of the wall, the house, the dam; to take hard muscles from the lifting, to take the clear lines and form from conceiving. For man, unlike any other thing organic or inorganic in the universe, grows beyond his work, walks up the stairs of his concepts, emerges ahead of his accomplishments. This you may say of man—when theories change and crash, when schools, philosophies, when narrow dark alleys of thought, national, religious, economic, grow and disintegrate, man reaches, stumbles forward, painfully, mistakenly sometimes. Having stepped forward, he may slip back, but only half a step, never the full step back. This you may say and know it and know it. This you may know when the bombs plummet out of the black planes on the market place, when prisoners are stuck like pigs, when the crushed bodies drain filthily in the dust. You may know it in this way. If the step were not being taken, if the stumbling-forward ache were not alive, the bombs would not fall, the throats would not be cut. Fear the time when the bombs stop falling while the bombers live—for every bomb is proof that the spirit has not died. And fear the time when the strikes stop while the great owners live—for every little beaten strike is proof that the step is being taken. And this you can know—fear the time when Manself will not suffer and die for a concept, for this one quality is the foundation of Manself, and this one quality is man, distinctive in the universe. THE WESTERN STATES nervous under the beginning change. Texas and Oklahoma, Kansas and Arkansas, New Mexico, Arizona, California. A single family moved from the land. Pa borrowed money from the bank, and now the bank wants the land. The land company—that's the bank when it has land—wants tractors, not families on the land. Is a tractor bad? Is the power that turns the long furrows wrong? If this tractor were ours it would be good—not mine, but ours. If our tractor turned the long furrows of our land, it would be good. Not my land, but ours. We could love that tractor then as we have loved this land when it was ours. But this tractor does two things—it turns the land and turns us off the land. There is little difference between this tractor and a tank. The people are driven, intimidated, hurt by both. We must think about this. One man, one family driven from the land; this rusty car creaking along the highway to the west. I lost my land, a single tractor took my land. I am alone and I am bewildered. And in the night one family camps in a ditch and another family pulls in and the tents come out. The two men squat on their hams and the women and children listen. Here is the node, you who hate change and fear revolution. Keep these two squatting men apart; make them hate, fear, suspect each other. Here is the anlage of the thing you fear. This is the zygote. For here "I lost my land" is changed; a cell is split and from its splitting grows the thing you hate—"We lost our land." The danger is here, for two men are not as lonely and perplexed as one. And from this first "we" there grows a still more dangerous thing: "I have a little food" plus "I have none." If from this problem the sum is "We have a little food," the thing is on its way, the movement has direction. Only a little multiplication now, and this land, this tractor are ours. The two men squatting in a ditch, the little fire, the side-meat stewing in a single pot, the silent, stone-eyed women; behind, the children listening with their souls to words their minds do not understand. The night draws down. The baby has a cold. Here, take this blanket. It's wool. It was my mother's blanket—take it for the baby. This is the thing to bomb. This is the beginning—from "I" to "we." If you who own the things people must have could understand this, you might preserve yourself. If you could separate causes from results, if you could know that Paine, Marx, Jefferson, Lenin, were results, not causes, you might survive. But that you cannot know. For the quality of owning freezes you forever into "I," and cuts you off forever from the "we." The Western States are nervous under the beginning change. Need is the stimulus to concept, concept to action. A half-million people moving over the country; a million more, restive to move; ten million more feeling the first nervousness. And tractors turning the multiple furrows in the vacant land.
Level-Coast8642@reddit
All Steinbeck
2whatextent@reddit
This is the most depressing book I've ever read. I loved it, but just when you think things can't get any worse...they get worse.
Tricky_Ad_1870@reddit
I loved it.
AnkylosaurusWrecks@reddit
A particular favorite of mine too!
Delicious_Sir_1137@reddit
Very impactful but the descriptions were so damn long
Skippeo@reddit
Grapes of Wrath floored me when I read it for school. So impactful.
AnatidaephobiaAnon@reddit
I first read it in the seventh grade after watching it one afternoon with my classic movie fiend of a mom. I loved it. Then when we read it in the tenth grade and I fell in love even more. I haven't read it since I was a freshman in college, but it's still one of my favorite books.
Rude_Tax_7494@reddit
To kill a mockingbird
mads_61@reddit
Little Women
Blonde_Vampire_1984@reddit
I also read the sequel, Little Men.
Both really good books.
Blonde_Vampire_1984@reddit
I also read the sequel, Little Men.
Both really good books.
Hockeytown11@reddit
I've constantly been putting off reading it, even though I love the musical based on it.
BoopleBun@reddit
Winter’s on the and way, and to me, it’s a very cozy book.
_Internet_Hugs_@reddit
I came to post this one. I love this book.
Familiar-Ad-1965@reddit
Little Women for the win!!
IronBeagle79@reddit
Little women is a very good book!
Sledheadjack@reddit
I love this answer!
edmunddantesforever@reddit
Sister Carrie by Dreiser
Straight-Event-4348@reddit
Vonnegut. Anything Vonnegut.
Bigbadbrindledog@reddit
Of Mice and Men
To Kill a Mockingbird
Old Man and the Sea
tickingboxes@reddit
Invisible Man
therealmmethenrdier@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn remains one of the best books I have ever read.
Calm_Firefighter_552@reddit
Little House on the Prairie. It is the very core of American History. The good and the bad.
AncientTallTree@reddit
I read them as a child multiple times and ever since then the Ingalls Family has been part of how I think about everything. I never watched the show. I then reread all the books as an adult. In particular, The Long Winter and Farmer Boy really hold up as quality storytelling.
notyogrannysgrandkid@reddit
Farmer Boy is so excellent. A 300-ish page, year-round love letter to food. Such a good read!
therealmmethenrdier@reddit
It is such an odd juxtaposition to The Long Winter. I reread The Long Winter every January to remind myself how fortunate I am, but then I read Farmer Boy for the food porn.
Matilda-17@reddit
I can still recall so many of the foods in that book! Someday I will try to make a birds nest pudding or apples-n-onions.
IHaveBoxerDogs@reddit
I loved “Farmer Boy.” That and “The Long Winter” were probably may favorites in the series.
Dawn-Storm@reddit
I liked On the Banks of Plum Creek.
IHaveBoxerDogs@reddit
Ah, the introduction of Nellie Oleson! That was also a good one. Maybe I'll re-read the series! I was a bigger "Anne of Green Gables" fan. But the "Little House" series was hugely popular in my elementary school. We read aloud several of the books.
Procedure-Loud@reddit
I also read them multiple times and think of them very very often. I did watch the show, although it absolutely doesn’t hold a candle to the books, much too sanitized and simplified and sweetened.
Crankenberry@reddit
Yes, those two are probably my favorites as well.
dandelionbrains@reddit
I really liked them as a kid too.
AnatidaephobiaAnon@reddit
That's one of those books that we read in middle school and absolutely loved, but never read it again. I really should change that.
Calm_Firefighter_552@reddit
I just read it to my daughter. There was a lot I missed when I read it as a kid. The author fully acknowledges that the settlers and the USA were basically in the wrong in the Indian situation. But they are also very compelling about why so many settlers hated Indians. It describes a complex reality, but doesn't soap box about it.
Karen125@reddit
My ancestor was native. Her husband refused to register any of their 14 children with her tribe because he hated Indians. It makes no sense.
Calm_Firefighter_552@reddit
One reoccurring theme in the Little House on the Prairie books is a group of 10 Indians showing up on a homestead while the man was gone. In the story they would enter the house without knocking, take what food they wanted, make sexual advances on the woman, and then steal high value items. After coming home to a raped wife, an empty pantry, and your valuables missing I bet many people did hate them.
LumpyPhilosopher8@reddit
I fell in love with those books when I was in 3rd grade. I read them all over and over. Especially The Long Winter.
Tofutti-KleinGT@reddit
I just read Prairie Fires, a biography of Laura Ingalls Wilder that also dives deep into the Dust Bowl and the Homesteading Act. It’s an excellent book.
PrettyPossum420@reddit
Was going to recommend this myself, glad you already did. I read the series many times as a little girl and Prairie Fires was a great addition as an adult. It sent me down lots of research rabbit holes
sarahprib56@reddit
Did you ever read the Betsy-Tacy books? My mom was from the Midwest and loved these books. She recorded herself reading them and my sister and I would play them when we went to sleep. I guess mom got sick of reading to us. I found them all on Kindle and read them again sometime in the last 10 years and they are very good. I preferred them to Little House.
eloquentmuse86@reddit
That was my favorite. I used to imagine myself living back then. My grandmother send me the entire box set when I was maybe 6-7?
Crankenberry@reddit
I got the autobiography when it came out. It's a beautiful book and the annotations are amazing.
mnsweett@reddit
I'd highly recommend anyone who enjoyed these books to read Louise Erdrich's Birchbark House series as well.
therealmmethenrdier@reddit
“Roman Fever” by Edith Wharton
cprsavealife@reddit
To Kill A Mockingbird.
Turtleking19@reddit
The Masque of the Red Death is one of my favorite stories
andythro@reddit
Handmaids Tale, In Cold Blood, Catcher in the Rye A Raisin in the Sun
CO_Renaissance_Man@reddit
The Great Gatsby!
Still very relevant today.
artisanmaker@reddit
As an adult, I decided to read John Steinbeck because I never had to in high school or college. I absolutely love his writing. I think I’ve read all of his novels.
quijji@reddit
On the road
Hunts5555@reddit
Catch-22.
3mptyspaces@reddit
Catch-22
Ok_Confusion_2461@reddit
Catch 22
E_sand80@reddit
The Call of the Wild by Jack London. I was big into adventure stories when I was a kid.. Hatchet by Gary Paulson, and My Side of the Mountain and Julie of the Wolves by Jean Craighead George were particular favorites.
devnullopinions@reddit
A Farewell to Arms by Hemingway could probably be considered a classic and one I find myself coming back to every few years.
ThirteenOnline@reddit
The wheel of time. Every single one
devnullopinions@reddit
“My name is >!Nynaeve ti al’Meara Mandragoran!<. The message I want sent is this. My husband rides from World’s End toward Tarwin’s Gap, toward Tarmon Gai’don. Will he ride alone?”
Gets me every time. Such a good series.
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
Love/hate relationship for me. Jordan really needed an editor who wasn't his wife.
ThirteenOnline@reddit
But now that’s it’s all done. And even the Sanderson ending like I love it as a whole. I think if you read it all the way through and don’t have to wait years between books. The slog doesn’t feel as slow and it’s a good full work
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
I did overall enjoy the series, but I have a hard time disengaging the ex-editor in my head. I still have to resist the urge to get out a red pencil everytime I read one of the books. Doesn't even change if I read it as an e-pub, I still want to attach notes/correx to the book.
Juleswf@reddit
Some of the middle books were pure filler. But otherwise I’m with you.
Fire_Mission@reddit
Ah, a fellow masochist.
Embarrassed_Suit_942@reddit
The Great Gatsby and Fahrenheit 451 were both so good imo
Rough-Trainer-8833@reddit
Young Goodman Brown - Hawthorne
Never Bet The Devil Your Head - Poe (anything Poe TBH)
An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge - Ambrose Bierce
Subterranean44@reddit
On the Road
Rough-Trainer-8833@reddit
I love 'On the Road' and a lot of Kerouac. Most folks either love it or hate it. I read it at the right point in my life to really resonate with me.
Also read the EKAT and did a lot of follow up on everyone mentioned. Fascinating times!
StanislasMcborgan@reddit
Electric Kool Aid Acid Test slaps
CupBeEmpty@reddit
I am in absolute full disagreement with On the Road. It sucks and believe it to be the most overhyped book of all time.
That said, we all have our own particular tastes, so I’ll keep my yap shut.
Phrobowroe@reddit
There are very few books I start to read and do not finish. I always, and I mean ALWAYS, think they are going to pull through and get interesting. Truth be told, I also do it because I want to be in a position to truly argue about how shit the book actually is. Sometimes I get bored with a book, read something else, and then come back to the first book, but it is extremely rare that I don’t finish a book that I started.
I put this book down three times in 9 months, and then came back to it a year later. By this time, I had to start over because I couldn’t remember everything. I forced myself to get at least halfway through it & then gave up forever.
There was nothing fun, interesting, insightful, hopeful, or scary. It was so ridiculously milquetoast. I don’t understand the hype.
And I know there will be people who say, “You gave up too soon. It gets really good when…” Nope. I don’t believe you. That book sucks.
dopefiendeddie@reddit
The Cask of Amontillado
Rough-Trainer-8833@reddit
Yep - Poe was the first fiction I liked
PlainTrain@reddit
I was introduced to that story via the Poe homages in The Martian Chronicles, another American classic.
RipeMangoDevourer@reddit
I LOVE this story. So devious
dopefiendeddie@reddit
It’s a level of pettiness I aspire to, frankly.
RipeMangoDevourer@reddit
Oh totally!
casapantalones@reddit
The Telltale Heart scared me so badly when I read it (as a child! Why??)
IronBeagle79@reddit
It’s a pretty good and gripping description of the narrator’s descent into madness.
Badman27@reddit
I think it’s because the feelings it evokes are so familiar. It’s every kids first lie to their parent and the emotions that come with trying to pull it off, and then the accompanying stain of guilt that won’t rinse out afterward. Except in this story, the stain really does get the better of you, and that’s terrifying without life’s experiences.
CZall23@reddit
It's funny in a dark way.
No_Freedom_8673@reddit
Poe was a wonderful author who helped define the horror and detective genres of novels and writing.
JohnnyBrillcream@reddit
If you haven't watched The Fall of the House of Usher I recommend it, each episode is loosely based on a Poe story and the ongoing bind that ties the series on The Fall of the House of Usher.
JosephBlowsephThe3rd@reddit
https://youtu.be/vT0YZLES8DM?si=ZGsirQyqOge4kjGH
Great musical recreation by The Alan Parsons Project. Their entire 1st album, Tales of Mystery and Imagination, is musical recreations of Poe tales. Absolutely great 70s prog
HavBoWilTrvl@reddit
Anything by James Thurber. He picked up the torch of satire from Twain and carried it forth into the modern era. The Catbird Seat is a wonderful short story that perfectly captures the frustrations of the workplace and a genius solution.
I also have to give some love to Flannery O'Connor. Good Country People will always bring a smile to my face.
And a shout out for Dorothy Parker! From Day-dreams:
... if you and I were one, my dear,
A model life we'd lead.
We'd travel on, from year to year,
At no increase of speed.
Ah, clear to me the vision of
The things that we should do!
And so I think it best, my love,
To string along as two.
SkgarGar@reddit
I love anything I've read by Edgar Allen Poe, but the Fall of the House of Usher is probably my favorite of his
FoxyLady52@reddit
Are we allowed to love anything American anymore?
Astute_Primate@reddit
Alice in Wonderland
PurpleUnicornLegend@reddit
A Raisin in the Sun - Lorraine Hansberry
Beloved - Toni Morrison
The Professor’s House - Willa Cather (my class only read Tom Outland’s Story)
The Great Gatsby - F. Scott Fitzgerald
Various Emily Dickinson poems
ArmMammoth2458@reddit
East of eden by John Steinbeck
stabbingrabbit@reddit
Liked Mark Twains stuff.
Makshak_924@reddit
The Awakening by Kate Chopin :’)
HippityHopMath@reddit
Great Gatsby and To Kill a Mockingbird (I refuse to read To Set a Watchman).
jmac409@reddit
How come? I was just thinking of reading it
Adventurous-Host8062@reddit
Don't. Trust me.
HippityHopMath@reddit
It apparently presents a more flawed, segregationist version of Atticus Finch.
Thayli11@reddit
It very much does. The Atticus Finch in Go Set a Watchman bears no relation to the one in To Kill a Mockingbird. It broke my heart. I am jealous of you for not having read it.
fbibmacklin@reddit
I have also refused to read it. It was really her first novel and she reworked it all and turned into TKAM. So, this isn't what she wanted us to read. To each their own, but I have no desire to read it.
PansyOHara@reddit
It’s not good.
Basically it is the first draft of what became TKAM. It was written before TKAM (in its final form), and is NOT a sequel, which many oeoe have the impression that it is.
theatregirl1987@reddit
Harper Lee also hated it. She never wanted it to be published. It was actually written first, but an editor (I may be wrong on who said this) told her it wasn't good and to focus on the story that eventually became Mockingbird. It was published after her death against her wishes.
I read it. Mockingbird is my absolute favorite. There is a reason she didn't want it published. It is not good.
awmaleg@reddit
Agreed. It stinks. Straight up cash grab
am123_20@reddit
I read Watchman, but never picked it up again. It was fine, but Mockingbird is the true masterpiece. It's the only version worth remembering for sure!
_hi_plains_drifter_@reddit
These are my two favorites too.
Juleswf@reddit
Go Cougs! Tried hard to Coug it last night, but pulled it out.
__The_Kraken__@reddit
True Grit
Br00klynBelle@reddit
The Good Earth, by Pearl S. Buck. I read it in high school and loved it. I read it over again every few years. I found the topic of life in China in the early 20th century, the traditions, and the themes of wealth how it corrupts, rural vs urban life, and family dynamics to be quite fascinating.
DevilDogsGirl@reddit
The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett (British American)
Fahrenheit 451 by Ray Bradbury
The Giver by Lois Lowry
Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck
The Tell-Tale Heart, The Cask of Amontillado, or The Pit and the Pendulum by Edgar Allen Poe
Honorable Mention
One Second After by William R. Forstchen (not a classic {2009}, but definitely a must read)
NecromanticRobots@reddit
Anything by Steinbeck holds up well
My favorite story of his that many people never mention is “cannery row”. Just a simple look at a regular working class people who never get attention or respect. Doesnt whitewash the characters into being perfect nor does it demonize them. Just a bitter sweet slice of life.
kitchengardengal@reddit
Doc was a big influence that made my son want to be a marine bioligist. He loves his work.
kinggeorgec@reddit
"The log from the Sea of Cortez", has an epilogue all about Doc. How he died, how they met, etc. I've actually never read Cannery Row (saw the movie ) but now I have to. Especially since we visit the area often.
NecromanticRobots@reddit
I need to read that thankyou!
dreadhawk420@reddit
This is also my favorite. Truly underrated!
Rocketgirl8097@reddit
Probably the stuff for kids. Pippin Longstocking. Ramona the Pest. Misty of Chincoteague. Charlotte's Web. Etc.
swampy138@reddit
I love Catcher In The Rye. Fight me.
G00dSh0tJans0n@reddit
Great Gatsby hits harder when you read it in your 40s and can really understand that feeling of longing for a past you can never get back.
Rarewear_fan@reddit
Will probably have a lot of dissent, but I just finished Catcher in the Rye and really enjoyed it.
Yes the main character is insufferable and doesn’t “learn” from his mistakes, but after reading about the author and the cultural context of when it was written, this is a great story about how young men after WW2 could often be disillusioned and aimless in a new world of constant technological and social changes, and how easy it is to feel left behind and alone without any resources for your mental health.
Also much of the outcry of this book is that it is inappropriate for teenagers. The book was written for adults first, hence the strong language and bleak subject matter. I think most teenagers would obviously hate this book, but an older adult can more easily read this book and reflect on how they used to be, how tragic this main character is, and how they can help others.
BaileyAMR@reddit
I was advised by a friend NOT to read this book as an adult because it would annoy the crap out of me -- his opinion was that only a teenager could like it. Incidentally, many of them do.
Foxy_locksy1704@reddit
I love Catcher. I also love Franny and Zooey as another one of Salinger’s works.
fritolazee@reddit
Franny and Zooey is amazing. I love most of Salinger's stuff.
Foxy_locksy1704@reddit
Me too, there is something about the casual feel of his work with deep themes woven through that really appeals to me.
fritolazee@reddit
Someone once described it to me as the "Seinfeld" of literature im that most of his stories are about nothing and that felt pretty accurate!
dandelionbrains@reddit
I love Catcher in the Rye too, people don’t all have to love a book.
dodadoler@reddit
Fuck Holden caufield
WarrenMulaney@reddit
You ok, man?
Turbulent_Bullfrog87@reddit
whispers : *Gone with the Wind
redhott1@reddit
One of my favorites. While Scarlett isn't always a good person she is a survivor and a great character. Of course there's racism it's civil war times and of course it's not accurate representation of the slave life because it's not from their pov. She saw it one way and that's the point.
I need to reread soon, been too many years.
BaileyAMR@reddit
Scarlett is never a good person.
Hampster412@reddit
My grandmother had an original copy from 1936 which was practically falling apart. I read it in 1975 when I was in 8th grade. Loved it -- read it in 3 days! I also saw the movie many years ago -- on Laserdisc, I think! -- and then just recently for a special showing at my local theater. That movie is epic! Vivien Leigh is so pretty and I had forgotten how wryly funny Rhett Butler is for the first 2/3 of the movie.
dandelionbrains@reddit
I think there is a lot of redemption in Gone With The Wind because Scarlet O’Hara is a bad person that you are not supposed to like. However, it is very much of its time. It gets a lot of deserved flack for racism, but there less criticism for when she is raped by her husband and this makes her fall in love with him again (what?).
Turbulent_Bullfrog87@reddit
I live for opportunities to repost this essay:
A Defensive Analysis of The Staircase Sequence™
Ah, The Staircase Sequence™. The most controversial part of this story. I was widely told that it was much less ambiguous and unnerving in the book than it was in the film, but there’s always someone who disagrees. For our purposes, I don’t think it matters whether or not it would be classified as rape in the 21st century, and we don’t need to examine the classification of 1871. The question is this: what did Margaret Mitchell write in 1936, and what did she want the reader to think?
Firstly, for what it’s worth, Scarlett regretted kicking Rhett out of her bed basically as soon as she did it, in Chapter 51. True, she doesn’t want any more babies, she wants to feel loyal to Ashley, and the sex does nothing for her, but she still regrets turning Rhett away, and she regrets it for selfish reasons, not for fear of retaliation. That regret is not shown in the film.
One of the biggest pieces that the film botched (I say ‘botched’ because I can find no justification for the changes) was Scarlett’s shoving Rhett away when he kisses her. In the book, Rhett’s kisses essentially do a hard reset on Scarlett’s brain. This is seen on the road back to Tara when Rhett leaves to join the fight, and again when he proposes. The third time is in The Staircase Sequence™; Scarlett was afraid because she’d never seen Rhett behave that way and she was not a fan of the way he physically picked her up, but any fight they had, any physical, mental or emotional resistance from Scarlett, was over the moment he kissed her. And this happens before The Wild Thrill™. This can’t be a case of the “orgasm always equals consent” misconception being employed, due to the order of the events.
It makes perfect sense for the actual scene to be cut from the film; putting aside the Hays Code and all of its restrictions, this scene itself contains no physical directions. The reader is just given the thoughts in Scarlett’s mind, clues open to interpretation about what’s happening. This vagueness is the reason I love it. It would be extremely difficult to film even today, simply because the source material does not give much to go on. Writing and filmmaking are different artistic mediums, and things that work perfectly in a book can’t always be translated to the screen. Because (among other things) 21st century audiences need everything spelled out clearly, a modern filming would probably keep the lead-up exactly the same as in the book, add some blocking that would fit, show everything, and slap a PG-13 rating on it because that’s the state of our current society.
Another change that the film made: the last line Rhett delivers before ascending the staircase is not “This is one night you’re not turning me out.” as in the film; it’s “By God, this is one night when there are only going to be two in my bed.” That line is less…rapey than in the film, and while I immediately took notice of this, the reason didn’t occur to me until later; it indicates that Rhett knows exactly what he’s doing, that The Wild Thrill™ was no accident, especially when preceded by his line near the end of Part 4 (chapter 47, pg. 833). The subtext of the line in the film is “I’m taking what I want whether you like it or not.”; it’s Rhett focused on Rhett. The subtext in the book is Rhett focused on Scarlett.
Scarlett’s feelings the next day in no way indicate a lack of consent; indeed, the shame seems to come from her willing & happy participation in the events. She actually feels that she has now gained some degree of control over Rhett.
Finally, a point that is not part of the narrative but does speak to the author’s intent: it would be wise to note that (according to some; I’ve been told that the evidence is in The Road to Tara but have been unable to find it) Margaret Mitchell’s ex-husband at one point showed up drunk at her house, beat her up, and raped her. I cannot imagine someone having that experience and also writing The Staircase Sequence™ the way she did, unless those two things were supposed to be completely unrelated. Someone who has been through such an event would not write a piece of fiction in which the protagonist experiences the same event as a good thing. It’s infinitely more plausible that Mitchell wasn’t writing a rape scene. Remember also that while they had a few things in common, Mitchell in no way based Scarlett O’Hara on herself.
East_Reading_3164@reddit
I don’t think Scarlet was a bad person, she was a complicated person living in difficult times. She was a survivor, and her strength kept many others alive.
oldlaxer@reddit
I started to put GWTW, but I knew what was going happen! My wife grew up in Atlanta, not far from the Margaret Mitchell house. She liked both the book and movie.
kitchengardengal@reddit
The Margaret Mitchell House museum has been refitted in look and content in the past couple years. It's now a thoughtful exhibition of Southern traditions, movie fandom, racism and the impact the movie had on the US at the time it premiered. Well worth the visit.
oldlaxer@reddit
We visited not too long ago. We also visited her grave in Oakland Cemetery, another place in Atlanta worth a visit
kitchengardengal@reddit
We took my SIL to both places last fall. Oakland Cemetery is beautiful- especially in early summer - but it still was lovely in the fall.
WhenProphecyFails@reddit
The Great Gatsby is pretty high on my favorites list.
Practical-Ad6548@reddit
The Catcher in the Rye is my favorite book and I read it every year during Christmas. A lot of people don’t like the protagonist but I was the same age when I read the book the first time and it just kinda hit
Kgb_Officer@reddit
It's a short story but Jack London's "To Build A Fire" was a read I thoroughly enjoyed. I liked it better than the rest of his books.
MakalakaPeaka@reddit
Of Mice and Men, To Kill a Mockingbird, Are a couple.
Mama_Claus@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn
Responsible-Fun4303@reddit
To kill a mockingbird ♥️ also loved the grapes of wrath. I’ve heard so many complain about that one, but I really enjoyed it.
mollyologist@reddit
The Martian Chronicles by Ray Bradbury.
ButterflyOld8220@reddit
The Yellow Wallpaper by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. Little House books
DreamCrusher914@reddit
A Prayer for Owen Meany, Bless the Beasts and Children, Johnny Got His Gun, A Wrinkle in Time, The Phantom Tollbooth, Their Eyes Were Watching God
BelligerentWyvern@reddit
Call of the Wild is one I return to occasionally. The cool part is the prose changes depending on where in the story you are.
Harrold_Potterson@reddit
Surprised I haven’t seen it on the list yet: Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston. Heartbreaking and beautiful.
DreamCrusher914@reddit
Loved this book so much. I’m from Florida and she described so well what it feels like to live in this climate.
StarthistleParadise@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, Little House in the Big Woods, The Catcher in the Rye
neomoritate@reddit
The Twits
noriseaweed@reddit
Blood Meridian. Heavy read but you'll never forget it
Maleficent-Bug-2045@reddit
Meh-
Maleficent-Bug-2045@reddit
Brokeback Mountain. It’s a great novella.
I love short stories and novellas because they leave more to your imagination.
Also, somehow no one has said Hemingway, especially the early stuff. A Farewell to Arms, for whom the bell tolls, etc.
wasaaabiP@reddit
You can read The Old Man and the Sea in a single afternoon. it’s such a simple, profound, sad, and touching story.
GarlicAftershave@reddit
The scene where their head officer is mentally drafting a citation for a medal as he's talking to the narrator about his recent ordeal just floored me. My god, I thought to myself, of COURSE bullshitting on someone's decoration isn't new nor unique.
spaycedinvader@reddit
Lonesome Dove
wasaaabiP@reddit
Ooh, I just read this and absolutely loved it!
hewhoisneverobeyed@reddit
We don’t rent pigs.
cocolovesmetoo@reddit
This. Best book on this entire list.
DaughterofTarot@reddit
McMurtry was a fantastic writer. And nothing at all to what you’d expect when he was interviewed. Almost sort of dreamy, about that tiny sliver of time when cowboys ruled the West.
stevepremo@reddit
And his wife, Faye, is the widow of McMurty's good friend and fellow author Ken Kesey
No_Permission6405@reddit
His kid, James McMurtry, is a damn fine singer/songwriter.
A_j_ru@reddit
The Outsiders.
Bookworm10-42@reddit
True Grit by Charles Portis. Forget the John Wayne film. The book is a masterpiece. Portis' gift for dialogue and humor, interwoven between the drama and action, is one of a kind.
Annual-Duck5818@reddit
Little Women. I absolutely devoured it as a child and my mom was horrified that I wanted to be Meg, since she’s the “happy wife and homemaker” - when it obvious you’re supposed to want to be Jo. I still love Meg, and the 1994 version with Trina Alvarado as Meg and Eric Stolz as John is the only one for me!
Bitch_Goblin@reddit
Really anything by Edgar Allen Poe.
Hampster412@reddit
I can't believe no one has mentioned Uncle Tom's Cabin. I loved it (even though, of course, it is also quite disturbing.)
The characters are so well defined. Your heart will break for many of them and others you would be happy to see burn in hell.
However, I didn't read the book, I listened to it which I HIGHLY recommend. Get the version read by Richard Allen. He is excellent!!
I worried the language would be hard to understand because the book is 150+ years old and flowery in parts but Allen brings all of the characters ALIVE so you easily understand the meaning of their words.
It was 20 hours long but absorbing all the way through.
Lovely_FISH_34@reddit
The Great Gatsby. Idk why, I don’t typically like those types of books but I loved this one.
thunnus0@reddit
Some might not consider classic, but they are:
Rabbit series by Updike. Garp And Owen Meany by Irving. Lonesome Dove by McMurty
AmbientGravitas@reddit
I loved Garp and quite a few of his other novels, but by Owen Meany I was over Irving, completely.
thunnus0@reddit
I can see it, depending on the order you got into them. If I had not read Hotel New Hampshire 2nd, I’d have been over him too. But Owen Meany as the third book, super worthwhile.
Maxpowr9@reddit
Not quite a book but Death of a Salesman
PeaTasty9184@reddit
Upton Sinclair’s “The Jungle”.
It can be a difficult read for some, and even I, a staunch leftie, think he goes a little too far with the socialism recruitment towards the end, but ultimately it is a classic that provides a very valuable insight into what the wealthy corporations want America to be again.
LichenTheChoss@reddit
Oil! is the same thing from a different angle
sadpell@reddit
My Ántonia by Willa Cather. I read it in 11th grade and it has stuck with me ever since.
LichenTheChoss@reddit
O Pioneers! was a beautiful heartbreaker.
mesembryanthemum@reddit
A few years ago I did a "read a book set in every state" challenge and chose My Antonia for Nebraska. Easily the best book I read that year.
abbydabbydo@reddit
Woah. That’s a super cool objective
Easy_Key5944@reddit
What an awesome idea!
WhoaMimi@reddit
Okay, that challenge sounds pretty cool. Did you do it on your own, etc.? The most recent self-imposed challenge I tried was Newbery Medal winners and yikes to some of those.
mesembryanthemum@reddit
I did. Someone suggested it and I went with it. Read some real turkeys.
GuadDidUs@reddit
This is such a cool idea. Maybe this is something I can do with my daughter.
superkt3@reddit
O Pioneers! Was that book for me!
notyogrannysgrandkid@reddit
Oh man, that’s the one I should have said for the last post. I never could see what my freshman English teacher did in that book. She raved about it for the week before we started it. I couldn’t stand it. I’ve never read anything else by Willa Cather.
Vintage-X@reddit
This is one of my all time favorite books as well. It's incredible.
biancanevenc@reddit
I didn't read any Cather until I was in my 30's. Now she's one of my favorite authors. Song of the Lark is my favorite.
kjb76@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn. One of my favorite books of all time.
CloudsTasteGeometric@reddit
East Of Eden
It lives up to the hype, it’s downright revelatory
RetractableLanding@reddit
Moby Dick
earbud_smegma@reddit
Slaughterhouse Five
TsundereLoliDragon@reddit
Also Cat's Cradle. I was obsessed with Vonnegut for a time.
eyetracker@reddit
The dozen or so I read are great, could not get into Galapagos though.
DirtAndSurf@reddit
He's my favorite author, alongside John Steinbeck.
theoracleofdreams@reddit
I loved reading Vonnegut after college. For some reason he hit all the feels I had during the Recession.
BabyRuth55@reddit
Me too, Breakfast of Champions for me
kjm16216@reddit
Breakfast of Champions was just strange.
earbud_smegma@reddit
Busy, busy, busy
FMLwtfDoID@reddit
Just picked up God Bless You, Mr Rosewater yesterday, from a vintage shop. Think I might go back for the Siren of Titans and Breakfast of Champions as well.
pragma_don@reddit
You should! I know it’s not held in the same esteem as some of his other works, but The Sirens of Titan might honestly be my fav from him
SubstantialBat3596@reddit
That was so good. It was so weird, but damn! I’m glad I read it
CupBeEmpty@reddit
My man. Vonnegut is my home town hero.
original_greaser_bob@reddit
so it goes...
jeanneW4@reddit
The Scarlet Letter by Nathanial Hawthorne
jambon3@reddit
Tropic of Cancer
footd@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird and Alas, Babylon
chickenfightyourmom@reddit
I loved The Good Earth. Leaves of Grass. I know why the caged bird sings. A tree grows in Brooklyn. Blood meridian. Call of the wild. The world according to garp.
TSOTL1991@reddit
The Good Earth by Pearl Buck
MasterofMystery@reddit
Three Hearts and Three Lions by Poul Anderson
A Princess of Mars by Edgar Rice Burroughs
Nine Princes In Amber by Roger Zelazney
The Moon is a Harsh Mistress by Robert A Heinlein
Different-Try8882@reddit
All The King's Men - one of the best political novels I've read and still relevant today.
linds3ybinds3y@reddit
Call of the Wild. To Kill a Mockingbird. Fahrenheit 451. Catch-22.
IronBeagle79@reddit
Jack London can be tough to read. His copy editor never stooped to correcting a run-on sentence. That said, I still love Call of the Wild and White Fang and a short story called “To Build a Fire.”
Louis L’Amour is an underrated author too.
MasterofMystery@reddit
Anyone talking down Louis L’Amour is a snob.
mechanicalcontrols@reddit
Catch 22 for sure.
"They're trying to kill me."
"No one's trying to kill you."
"Then why are they shooting at me?"
"They're trying to kill everyone."
"What difference does that make?"
gotbock@reddit
Major Major Major Major
erwaro@reddit
"I'd rather have peanut brittle in my beard than flies in my eyes."
Illustrious-Shirt569@reddit
I just started reading Call of the Wild out loud to my kids for our nightly reading time. I’m excited to read it again myself, though the beginning is more grim than I’d remembered!
DeepThinkingMachine@reddit
try Iron heel
linds3ybinds3y@reddit
Looks interesting—thanks for the rec!
mothlady1959@reddit
East of Eden and The Grapes of Wrath. Read both multiple times. Beautiful books.
American Pastoral by Philip Roth
Lonesome Dove by Larry McMurtry
North81Girl@reddit
Of Mice and Men, Animal Farm, 1985, Lord of the Flies
Oomlotte99@reddit
I loved The Grapes of Wrath.
coorslte@reddit
Lord of the Rings
neithan2000@reddit
So I live in Billings Montana, where Will James lived for many years. There is an old cabin in Four Dances where James used to sleep of his drunken benders, and I taught for a year at Will James Middle School.
Silly-Resist8306@reddit
Green Eggs and Ham. I’ve probably read it 500 times and it hasn’t gotten old yet.
gotbock@reddit
Well...would you?
Silly-Resist8306@reddit
In the rain, on a train…
Silly-Resist8306@reddit
In the rain, on a train….
Federal-Opening-2742@reddit
Anything by Steinbeck = but especially 'The Grapes of Wrath'
Most of Mark Twain
Most of Thomas Wolfe
Many Melville novellas and shorter stories - outside of 'Omoo' I find his larger novels a bit tedious
Most Philip Roth
Most Toni Morrison
Everything by Vonnegut
Aware-Owl4346@reddit
True Grit.
LadybugGal95@reddit
Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston
cube1961@reddit
“My Antonia” by Willa Cather. A fabulous love story set in western rural America during the late 19th century
incirfig@reddit
Maybe not a total classic, per se, but I loved “A Prayer for Owen Meany” by John Irving has stuck with me. Also, any poetry by Walt Whitman.
Outrageous-Lunch7705@reddit
The Great Gatsby
Ms_Jane9627@reddit
East of Eden
fbibmacklin@reddit
I have this sitting on my coffee table right now, and just haven't gotten around to starting it. I'll read it at some point this year. I hope I love it. I have loved all the Steinbeck I have read, so far.
PansyOHara@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
Little Women
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz
Caddie Woodlawn
Gone With The Wind
East of Eden
I know there are more classic adult books and more books about boys/ men that I’ve read and enjoyed, but at the moment can’t think of them ☺️
LightningMan711@reddit
I really enjoyed Huckleberry Finn even though I was convinced before reading it that I wouldn't.
spitfire451@reddit
Is Dune a classic? If so then Dune.
Truckeejenkins@reddit
The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter
Fahrenheit 451
A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court
The Glass Menagerie
Cat’s Cradle
StanislasMcborgan@reddit
This person gets it
StanislasMcborgan@reddit
The Heart is a Lonely Hunter by Carson McCullers, The Sound and the Fury by Faulkner
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
The US Constitution. Specifically the parts about free speech and where it says "The right of the people to keep and bare arms shall not be infringed.".
Otherwise-OhWell@reddit
Thank you for taking the time away from stroking your barrel to share!
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Are you saying you want to watch next time?
Otherwise-OhWell@reddit
Me: "Thank you for taking away from your time (doing a thing that I am thanking you for NOT doing)."
You: "So you want to watch?"
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
That doesn't answer the question. Wait.....maybe it does.
_hammitt@reddit
Shouldn’t be a capital T there, it’s the second cause of a sentence.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Your right. Hows this? "...the right of the people to keep and bare arms shall not be infringed."
_hammitt@reddit
Sure, I just think both halves of the sentence were on purpose. It’s only in the last century that courts started deciding that meant people individually rather than the people as in well-regulated militias
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
I believe the Founding Fathers defined "well-regulated militia" as we define it nowadays. From then to now, it was misunderstood to only mean an actual military. What's that old quote about a people fearing the government and a government fearing the people? Our Founding Fathers didn't fear the king. They fought him because he wasn't being fair. And we were better for it. The Founding Fathers realized this. And the Second Amendment ensures that in this great nation, there is a legal way for the people to do something (if it came down to it) instead of fearing the government.
_hammitt@reddit
Yes, but I presume they included that clause on purpose. The right of the people (collective) to bear arms is not the same as the right of people (individual). That’s the way courts interpreted it for the first 150ish years - the people, formed into well regulated militias, had the right to weaponry. That is not the same as saying every person has the right to bear arms, or that we cannot regulate who can and cannot and under what circumstances.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Unless the militia is a government sponsored military with arms given to them by the government, isn't it just a bunch of private citizens who bought guns on their own? Or maybe I'm misunderstanding.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Regulating who can and cannot bare arms and under what circumstances is one thing. I don't necessarily have an issue with that. But I will never, ever be in support of categorically banning the ownership of any particular firearm to any entire population because of how big the ammunition is/how fast it shoots/whether it is automatic or an assault weapon, or any other ridiculous reason people come up with. It is absolutely unfair to the people who would own/use such arms responsibly.
MrsBenSolo1977@reddit
Do you think you should be able to own a nuclear warhead? That’s an arm.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Interesting question. I never thought about arms such as that. I don't know how I feel about nucular weapons. I'm talking about people who want to ban semi- and fully automatic rifles, assault style weapons and severely limit or outright restrict possession and use of normal (for lack of a better word) pistols, rifles, and shotguns. It's not fair to those who would, and who do, own and use them responsibly. Banning things is the step mist people want to take when they don't know what else to do. But there are things that it's unfair to the population as a whole if you ban them for everyone.
MrsBenSolo1977@reddit
None of those weapons existed really back then either, weapons were basically only just muzzleloading long guns. Where do we draw the line? An automatic weapon was beyond the comprehension of the founding fathers as much as a nuclear warhead.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
Yes. The Founding Fathers couldn't concieve of such technology. But people in the present day want to ban them. And that makes zero sense. One only has to pay attention to see that enacting and enforcing laws does little to prevent things. Mankind's efforts are much better spent by first educating people to the consequences to themselves as well as others. We, as individuals as well as an entire species, are much better off when we understand that we shouldn't do what we are otherwise free to do. My position on many hot legal topics is less about the choices we make and more about whether governments should be in the business of forcing people to do/not do things. George Carlin once said something like "You know the world's in bad shape when it takes thousands of laws to enforce the Ten Commandments.". That line has made me stop and think for years.
MrsBenSolo1977@reddit
Also bare arms = arms without sleeves. Bear arms = carry weapons.
dandelionbrains@reddit
Do you think you are composing this or something? And it’s you’re.
Alpha_Mad_Dog@reddit
I didn't write it. The founding fathers did. Composing? I don't know what your asking.
Sweaty_Ad_1332@reddit
R u dense theyre pointing out the militia part youre purposefully neglecting
Jewish-Mom-123@reddit
Bear.
MacaroonSad8860@reddit
bear*
MollyWeasleyknits@reddit
I really enjoyed A Tree Grows in Brooklyn!
Deaky70@reddit
The Shining
MrLaxitive@reddit
Hatchet
lizzie_knits@reddit
In Cold Blood To Kill A Mockingbird The Great Gatsby And controversially - The Stand (Stephen King).
Squippyfood@reddit
I'm curious to read the other thread you speak about. Imo American classic literature is the best, absolutely blows British crap outta the water.
sarahprib56@reddit
Authors like the Bronte sisters and Charles Dickens are fundamental to literature in the English language. I feel like you can't really separate English and American literature, anyway. They both influenced our culture. Authors from both counties traveled abroad. People read books from both countries.
Squippyfood@reddit
Nah man, give me Twain over Dickens any day. English literature was definitely important in that it told American authors how not to suck
TheCloudForest@reddit
There are a few duds in the canon, no doubt. But that thread seriously called some of the greats of the American literary heritage, "overhyped". Books from the 1840s do not have "hype" lmao.
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
Eh, I kind of think the King Arthur Tales and Chaucer's stuff are pretty good. And then there's good old Willy the Shake, AKA Wm. Shakespeare. I laugh no matter how many times I read Much Ado About Nothing.
Fun-Dragonfly-4166@reddit
"It cant happen here" is happening
GreenerMark@reddit
Invisible Man
Catch-22
Cat's Cradle
Lonesome Dove
The Cider House Rules, A Prayer for Owen Meany
The Moon is Down
The Brothers K
The Poisonwood Bible, Pigs in Heaven
Fahrenheit 451
Jitterbug Perfume
The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian
Blubbernuts_@reddit
East of Eden.
Subvet98@reddit
Lonesome Dove
sarahprib56@reddit
Witch of Blackbird Pond. I still love it.
La_croix_addict@reddit
Anne of green gables
MysteryBelle_NC@reddit
I wish it was an American novel, but I've loved everything LM Montgomery's written.
La_croix_addict@reddit
I don’t know it was Canadian, but tbh I actually haven’t read it in the past 35 years, but I finally have a daughter and I’m looking forward to reading it with her. My son was/is a great reader but it would not have kept his interest.
MysteryBelle_NC@reddit
She's a brilliant writer imo. Hopefully your daughter will love the book, too.
johannaishere@reddit
So so very Canadian.
cv5cv6@reddit
Dude.
sittingonmyarse@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird. It does teach a powerful lesson or two, but the way the words are put together is the best part. Something said well on every page.
Ineedzthetube@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, one of my all time favorites.
HeavySkinz@reddit
Fahrenheit 911
SubUrbanMess2021@reddit
Fear and Loathing in Las Vegas. Forget the movie. Read the book. Catch 22 was awesome, too.
CupBeEmpty@reddit
The book is better but the movie is one of the superior book adaptations of all time.
SubUrbanMess2021@reddit
The movie was okay. The book was far better. Of course, anything written by Hunter S. Thompson is pretty amazing.
j_truant@reddit
2 of my favorites in high school.
chronicallymusical@reddit
A Farewell to Arms by Hemingway
therlwl@reddit
Only one, Black Like Me.
Doomdoomkittydoom@reddit
Catch-22
thomasque72@reddit
If you liked Cowboy: My Life Story, try "A Land Remembered." It's the story of a family living on the edge of a young America in Florida. They make a living driving cattle across the state to the cattle yards that existed in the Tampa area. It's a true-to-life story and gives you a very interesting look at what Florida was like in the 1800's. It was recommended to me by someone I really trust and this book made me trust their recommendations even more.
Whose_my_daddy@reddit
You all just gave me more ideas! I teach 10tb grade American lit this year. Brit lit is where my heart is and this is my first American year.
HurlingFruit@reddit
Almost everything by Cormac McCarthy.
Delicious-Ad5856@reddit
Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep
Anything by Edgar Allen Poe
kiisinipper@reddit
Jonny Got His Gun by Dalton Trumbo Publish in 1939 was a book that was such a powerful a message. I had to read it in High School in grade 10 in Canada.
uncertainmango@reddit
Moby Dick, Blood Meridian, All the Pretty Horses, The Crossing, Confederacy of Dunces, On The Road, and all of Vonnegut's stuff
SomeDetroitGuy@reddit
Great Gatsby, Charlotte's Web, Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep, I Robot
stream_inspector@reddit
Grisham, painted house. Not sure counts as classic, but certainly American.
Kineth@reddit
The Sound and the Fury.
thatsad_guy@reddit
Of Mice and Men
superfastmomma@reddit
It's so awful but such a good book.
Highway49@reddit
It’s great, but my older brother always says it reminds him of our relationship. 🤬🤬🤬
notyogrannysgrandkid@reddit
Hopefully you’re the George?
Highway49@reddit
Nope lol
DaisyPK@reddit
Sometimes a great notion, by Ken Kesey.
HobsHere@reddit
Moby Dick. It's painful when you have to read it in school, but is really a pretty interesting book.
Also, absolutely everything by Twain, except for The Gilded Age, which I've never been able to drag myself through.
CupBeEmpty@reddit
Awww Gilded Age isn’t so bad. It’s also ridiculously autobiographical.
HobsHere@reddit
I know about the autobiographical part. I used to know someone whose great great grandfather purchased some of "The Tennessee Land". I just found the story rather tedious compared to most of his work.
CupBeEmpty@reddit
Yeah apparently that was the main complaint when it came out. Prince and the Pauper had similar complaints. Too serious and tedious without his trademark humor.
I would be so excited to visit some of the “Tennessee Land” just because he hated it so much. I suspect it is quite nice but just not riddled with gold and minerals like the family thought.
HobsHere@reddit
I've been there. There's some coal, but certainly no gold. It is very pretty, very rugged country.
CupBeEmpty@reddit
Where is it? I’ve been to eastern and central TN quite a lot but never western other than Memphis.
HobsHere@reddit
It's North West of Jamestown, in Fentress county. Basically that whole corner of the county.
HaplessReader1988@reddit
Going waaaaay back to something like 7th grade for this -- My Side of the Mountain.
I have an old dead tree in my woods that I fantasize about hollowing out.
RealAlePint@reddit
I don’t get the Hawthorne hate, House of Seven Gables is a slightly better book than the Scarlet Letter, but both are excellent.
Loud_Ad_4515@reddit
The short stories of O. Henry.
I saw Gift of the Magi as a young child, and it stuck with me. It was such an instant classic, and prompted me to later look up other stories by him, of which The Last Leaf is my favorite.
ExtremePotatoFanatic@reddit
Catcher in the Rye was my favorite.
carmineragu@reddit
East of Eden or anything by Steinbeck really
Cautious-Ease-1451@reddit
1) The poetry of Robert Frost.
A favorite:
Nature’s first green is gold,
Her hardest hue to hold.
Her early leaf’s a flower;
But only so an hour.
Then leaf subsides to leaf.
So Eden sank to grief,
So dawn goes down to day.
Nothing gold can stay.
2) The poetry of Emily Dickinson
A favorite:
A Bird, came down the Walk -
He did not know I saw -
He bit an Angle Worm in halves
And ate the fellow, raw,
And then, he drank a Dew
From a convenient Grass -
And then hopped sidewise to the Wall
To let a Beetle pass -
He glanced with rapid eyes,
That hurried all abroad -
They looked like frightened Beads, I thought,
He stirred his Velvet Head. -
Like one in danger, Cautious,
I offered him a Crumb,
And he unrolled his feathers,
And rowed him softer Home -
Than Oars divide the Ocean,
Too silver for a seam,
Or Butterflies, off Banks of Noon,
Leap, plashless as they swim.
Interesting_Arm_3967@reddit
Lonesome Dove
2whatextent@reddit
There's so many, but I haven't seen Lord of the flies or The Outsiders yet.
pumpkin_antler@reddit
Kindred by Octavia Butler Beloved
kydogjaw@reddit
“A Prayer for Owen Meany” by John Irving.
Harbinger_of_Sarcasm@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn
MrsBenSolo1977@reddit
Ok, you found a classic that I love that I’d forgotten about.
dandelionbrains@reddit
This was also one of my favorite books as a kid.
Novel_Willingness721@reddit
A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur’s Court.
I read many classics as a kid, that one stuck because I also started playing Dungeons & Dragons at that as well.
MrsBenSolo1977@reddit
The only American classics I like are all of Poe’s works.
KeekyPep@reddit
The Scarlet Letter.
MegaMiles08@reddit
I've liked a lot of the books mentioned: Little Women, 1984, The Great Gatsby, and in high school's American Lit class, we read Native Son, by Richard Wright.
However, I did not like Catcher in the Rye. I can appreciate it, but the main character was so obnoxious. At least it's short?
Morning_phlegm@reddit
Short read but True Grit
Ok-Trouble7956@reddit
Wuthering Heights
PMcGrew@reddit
Anything by John O’Hara, though he’s been largely forgotten since his death in 1970.
AmbientGravitas@reddit
I love O’Hara; it’s a crime he’s been forgotten.
elpajaroquemamais@reddit
A farewell to arms
judijo621@reddit
Color Purple
bingo-dingaling@reddit
The Invisible Man!
Goliardojojo@reddit
Looking Backward by Edward Bellamy
Minute-Of-Angle@reddit
Fahrenheit 451
Reason enough to never go metric ;)
Specialist-Two2068@reddit
Of Mice and Men and Farenheit 451 are unironically really good.
I did NOT like The Outsiders.
AmbientGravitas@reddit
The Bridge of San Luis Rey.
denverdave23@reddit
A Confederacy of Dunces The Golem and the Jinni
CupBeEmpty@reddit
I was stunned no one said Confederacy of Dunces until way down here.
It is such a strange but wonderful book.
It’s special to me because of the guy that told me to read it. God rest his soul.
RSVPno@reddit
Scrolled way too far to hit Dunces. It won the Pulitzer for a reason. And if you ever want a glimpse into the New Orleans magic that existed before Katrina, it's one of few ways to do so.
flootytootybri@reddit
I was the only person in my class (all girls) who liked “Catcher in the Rye”. I was fresh out of a mental hospital for grief so it was a little too personal. Now I realize he was whiny as hell
Cowboywizard12@reddit
The Phillip Marlowe Books by Raymond Chandler
Grouchy_Account4760@reddit
The poetry of Mary Oliver.
Colodanman357@reddit
Starship troopers. One of the greatest works by one of the all time best American authors. It was my introduction to Heinlein when it was given to me while in Basic Training and told it is the Infantryman’s Bible. It certainly resonated.
bobvagabond@reddit
J. D. Salinger's Catcher In The Rye. I've read the book 4 or 5 times and my daughter has also read it. We've coined a phrase 'A Holden Caulfield kind of Day'. When one of us uses the phrase the other knows exactly what kind of day they've had. I also loved reading the book.
Opening_Yak_9933@reddit
Oh I know this one! It’s “Mosquito Coast”. Best book on earth.
ucbiker@reddit
A Confederacy of Dunces. Literally makes me laugh out loud.
mynameisevan@reddit
It’s not one his more well-known books, but Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc by Mark Twain is so good and I think everyone should read it.
Alarming-Ad9441@reddit
I love to read so I have a lot of classics I enjoy. To Kill A Mockingbird, The Great Gatsby, the Anne of Green Gables series, Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn, just to name a few. It really bothers me that a lot of books have been banned from schools. I think it’s so important for our kids to read, and learn, about literature from all walks of life and times in history. This should include, maybe even especially, the parts we aren’t proud of. You know what they say, if we don’t learn about our history we are destined to repeat it. Just because you read and learn, doesn’t mean you agree, or are being taught that it’s ok.
Gilthoniel_Elbereth@reddit
Anne of Green Gables is Canadian
Alarming-Ad9441@reddit
Is it? I guess it’s been a while since I’ve read them. They were one of my favorites when I was young. The Little House series was another. I watched the show religiously too.
OdinDogfather@reddit
Of Mice and Men, as well as Grapes of Wrath, are phenomenal American classics. IMO, they eloquently describe American life in that time and place.
OhManatree@reddit
I know that Huck Finn is considered to be Twain’s best novel, but I make it a point to read Tom Sawyer every other year.
roboreddit1000@reddit
There is a recent novel called James which is Huck Finn told from the perspective of N.... Jim.
Well worth the read.
LurkerByNatureGT@reddit
Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn are both great books in different ways.
Let me also introduce you to Personal Recollections of Joan of Arc. 😆
ImportantRabbit9292@reddit
Anything Steinbeck or Hemingway.
Bl00p_3r@reddit
Sometimes a Great Notion, by Ken Kesey.
BlutosBrother@reddit
Never give a inch!
Coro-NO-Ra@reddit
Blood Meridian.
Moby Dick.
The Great Gatsby (probably better in your late 20s-30s than as assigned reading).
BlutosBrother@reddit
McCarthy is one of the greats. The Border Trilogy was sooo good.
StopSignsAreRed@reddit
The Yearling, by Marjorie Kinnian Rawlings. I have read it at least 50 times over the last 40 years. It’s so descriptive, so emotionally engaging, and it’s just a lovely story.
crashin-kc@reddit
Where the Red Fern Grows
I grew up in the 80s in a suburb next to a creek and enough woods to spend the whole day outside running wild. I felt a great sense of kinship to the main character and I felt like I lived those pages.
I’m glad to see so many mentions of Mark Twain as well. I also loved those books.
cocolovesmetoo@reddit
I can't believe I haven't seen The Color Purple
Norva13x@reddit
A Land Remembered
Carrotcake1988@reddit
The Bell Jar.
cybersquire@reddit
Red Badge of Courage
wmass@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn by Betty Smith. It’s the story of a girl, Francie, growing up in a poor family in Brooklyn, New York City in the early 20th century. When I was in high school many kids, mostly the girls read it but I only read it recently, as an older adult. It’s great in many ways. The characters are realistic and varied. The time and place in a poor, city, neighborhood is revealed to us. The plot moves along well. The author’s style made me repeatedly read parts aloud to my wife. It would be appropriate for teens but was also great for me as an older adult.
iLiveInAHologram94@reddit
Lonesome Dove, Catch-22, The Rainbow, Emma, and Wuthering Heights come to mind
Puzzleheaded_Door399@reddit
Anna Karenina?
iLiveInAHologram94@reddit
Lmao I got carried away and just started listing off classics and forgot the prompt.
CarlatheDestructor@reddit
Little Women, The Grapes of Wrath, Beloved, The Road, A Raisin in the Sun, The Call of the Wild, Of Mice and Men
tannick@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird
Scarlet Letter
The Odyssey
CZall23@reddit
I enjoyed The Scarlett Letter as well, especially the last third of the book when she interacts with the community.
_hammitt@reddit
So I came here to say I hate the Scarlett letter but then got tripped up because uh… are we calling the odyssey American? … how?
kinggeorgec@reddit
Looks like I'm the only Hemingway fan.
dgrigg1980@reddit
Blood Meridian. The only novel I finished then immediately started reading again
CZall23@reddit
I really love The Legend of Sleepy Hollow by Washington Irving. Edgar Allen Poe's poems and novels are really good too!
Acrobatic-March-4433@reddit
East of Eden... which people seem to hate around here, for some reason.
Perenially_behind@reddit
I read it about 40 years ago when I was on a big Steinbeck kick. Prolific mofo, I read about a dozen of his books and only scratched the surface. Such variety in his subjects and style too. It's hard to believe that the same person wrote Grapes of Wrath, Cannery Row/Sweet Thursday, and Travels with Charley.
At the time I thought its reach exceeded its grasp, like it was a little too self-consciously epic, so I wouldn't have ranked it with his best. Time for a re-read in the light of 40 years of adult life experience.
gothbbydoll@reddit
This is my favorite
OpelSmith@reddit
East of Eden is the primordial novel. Every other book ever written was just leading up to it
Orion_69_420@reddit
It's #3 for Steinbeck for me after To a God Unknown and Grapes of Wrath.
stevepremo@reddit
John Steinbeck was roundly hated by many California farmers, especially in the Salinas Valley, due to East of Eden and Grapes of Wrath.
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
I loved East of Eden, perhaps because I grew up in California ranching county, or perhaps because we did a family read-aloud when I was in eh, third grade?
Highway49@reddit
Bro, that’s some heavy content for third graders!!!
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
Yeah, I guess, but the whole family were avid readers and it wasn't like there was no one to provide context.
Highway49@reddit
I guess Cathy was only 10 when she tied herself to frame 14 year old boys… That scene forever stuck in my head when I read it as a 15 year old lol!
Leoliad@reddit
East of Eden is an absolute masterpiece.
G00bre@reddit
Reading it right now!
A good 100 pages in, I have no idea what it's deal is or where it's going, but the writing is just superb
thunderdome_referee@reddit
You're in for an absolute treat.
G00bre@reddit
I am enjoying the treat already, first bite of the pie.
tsukiii@reddit
I like it, maybe my favorite Steinbeck. I like how the woman is the bad guy lol
MysteryBelle_NC@reddit
That is one of my all-time favorites. I've read it multiple times, probably time for another read. Loved the move so read the book. There's so much story left out of the movie.
NickyWhit@reddit
East of Eden reignited a desire to read, for me. It was my true beginning of reading leisurely. Great book!
idkmanwhyyouaskingme@reddit
This is one of my favorite books, but I also grew up in central California and have always loved the way John Steinbeck writes
ByogiS@reddit
It’s such a good book
AmericanHalmoni@reddit
East of Eden has remained my #1 book for over 50 years. Reread it 25-30 years ago and felt the same as I had after the first read.
rapiertwit@reddit
All the King’s Men
Crissup@reddit
1984 & Shane were both good. As usual, the movies didn’t do either book justice.
_hammitt@reddit
Orwell is British?
Crissup@reddit
No clue
RollinThundaga@reddit
Last of the Mohicans.
I've got a 2nd edition copy from the 1920s I found in a free bin when I was a kid.
khurd18@reddit
Of Mice and Men & Their Eyes Were Watching God
thepineapplemen@reddit
I was fond of The Deerslayer by James Fenimore Cooper
Asleep_Wind997@reddit
The House of The Seven Gables by Nathaniel Hawthorne
Goodlife1988@reddit
Lonesome Dove
Strong-Library2763@reddit
To Kill A Mockingbird by Harper Lee
cmhoughton@reddit
It was in school, but I was surprised how much I liked The Scarlet Letter by Nathaniel Hawthorn. It wasn’t like I thought it was going to be. However, I’m not sure I loved it since I’ve not read it again.
Rogue_Cheeks98@reddit
I know it’s newer but the glass castle by jeanette walls
StarfleetAcademy08@reddit
The Most Dangerous Game if we're counting short stories.
Someone mentioned The Cask of Amontillado and I agree.
JakelAndHyde@reddit
Modern classic but No Country For Old Men, Cormac McCarthy is a legend
SuperDuperLS@reddit
Dune, I don't know if it classifies as an American Classic, but it's definitely a Science Fiction Classic.
Disastrous_Cat3912@reddit
Call of the Wild by Jack London.
BigMom000@reddit
One of my all time favorite books is Pillars of the Earth
Electrical-Volume765@reddit
The grapes of wrath.
PresidentBaileyb@reddit
Catch-22 is one of my favorite books for sure
notyogrannysgrandkid@reddit
Oil! is a good one, although the protagonist being called “Bunny” is a bit odd to a 21st century reader.
I’m a big fan of To Kill A Mockingbird. My top choices for Great American Novel are probably Blood Meridian or Huckleberry Finn.
Mental-Paramedic9790@reddit
To kill a Mockingbird.
rolyoh@reddit
The Jungle by Upton Sinclair
Educational_Bench290@reddit
Moby Dick. Take your time, and take in all of it.
casapantalones@reddit
To Kill A Mockingbird
theoracleofdreams@reddit
Of Mice and men
Accomplished_Mix7827@reddit
I really enjoyed Huckleberry Finn
GeekyPassion@reddit
I like huck Finn a lot
Senior-Cantaloupe-69@reddit
Starting as a teen, I’ve loved everything Hemingway except “For Whom the Bell Tolls”- I couldn’t get into that until my late 30’s. I think he saw the world how it really is and wrote about it in a way that it comes to life in my head. I think what most modern readers miss is how strong the women characters are. It is not the macho bro fest so many seem to think.
I also loved Dostoyevsky short stories. And Mark Twain. And Robert L. Heinlen for SCI-fi. Also loved Dune and Catch-22
cyvaquero@reddit
Catch 22. My kind of humor.
Pizzarocco@reddit
It's laugh out loud funny
Cosmic-Ape-808@reddit
The Giving Tree by Shel Silverstein. One of the first books ever read, still love it yo
dandelionbrains@reddit
I think One Flew Over The Cuckoo’s Nest was really good, however, it directly contributed to the American government closing all mental institutions and now we have none and those people live on the street instead.
stevepremo@reddit
Sometimes a Great Notion by Ken Kesey Moby Dick by Herman Melville Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain
James_Soler@reddit
Of Mice and Men
Altaira99@reddit
Lonesome Dove. Pulitzer prize winner and outstanding characters. For an older one, I absolutely loved A Tree Grows in Brooklyn, but not quite a classic, I guess.
Frequent_Skill5723@reddit
The Autobiography of Malcolm X
It Can't Happen Here, by Sinclair Lewis
At Play In The Fields Of The Lord, by Peter Mattiessen
j_truant@reddit
Catch 22. I read it at 16 and it was so funny and absurd. Still a favorite at 54.
personalleytea@reddit
Friday Night Lights by H.G. Bissinger. It follows the 1988 Permian Panther high school football team in Odessa, TX, but it is about so much more than football. Race, family, economics, education, etc. Though the events happened more than 35 years ago, it is still relevant in a lot of ways.
OlderAndCynical@reddit
Anything by Mark Twain or Edgar Allen Poe.
dandelionbrains@reddit
I came her to say Edgar Allen Poe and I can’t believe how few people are mentioning him. Especially as America is a country that I would say, has really fleshed out stories involving the scary and weird. Maybe more than any other country.
greysonhackett@reddit
The Grapes of Wrath & Of Mice and Men - Steinbeck. Absolutely gut-wrenching.
Adorable_Dust3799@reddit
Call of the wild, and it's companion white fang. Tom sawyer.
Yeegis@reddit
The Wizard of Oz. Probably one of the most important American novels ever written.
Gr8danedog@reddit
I read Tom Sawyer by Mark Twain when I was a child. I still have fond memories of the book.
Orion_69_420@reddit
Grapes of Wrath and The Sound and the Fury.
Lady-Kat1969@reddit
The Wonderful Wizard of Oz, plus Baum’s sequels and connected books.
RadicalPracticalist@reddit
Catch-22.
TheExquisiteCorpse@reddit
Moby Dick is so good. It’s a really funny book and I find Ishmael to be a really chill relatable guy. Even the whale biology chapters everyone complains about are actually full of jokes and interesting things. I like that he’s trying to capture the full understanding of what a whale even is and that includes scientific facts but also the bible, and sailors’ tall tales, and even folklore from around the world.
No_Permission6405@reddit
Robert Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land. Grok?
kitchengardengal@reddit
That was the book that taught me how to kiss properly. Vehemently.
Sunnryz@reddit
A Tree Grows in Brooklyn and To Kill a Mockingbird are my favorite American classics.
mechanicalcontrols@reddit
Catch-22. Existential dread has never been funnier before or since.
WrongJohnSilver@reddit
Everything Edgar Allan Poe.
Danktizzle@reddit
The monkey wrench gang. Simply because its relevant today
RJSquires@reddit
Does The Outsiders count as "classic"? I don't know if there's a book with a more consistent track record with students. Even nearly 70 years later, most kids can relate to the kids in the book. Feeling trapped in a life where everyone else seemingly "makes the rules/choices" and having little to no say is a universal feeling whether you're a poor, working class, middle class, or rich kid. Not to mention there's a little bit of every kind of kid in the cast of characters. They're all layered, even the mostly sunny Two-bit.
To Kill a Mockingbird and Of Mice and Men are the only other American lit options that seem to get near The Outsiders. Gatsby varies depending on how they feel about rich people...
ExtraSpicyMayonnaise@reddit
East of Eden is my favorite. Steinbeck always does it for me.
Reliable_Narrator_@reddit
“True Grit” by Charles Portis and anything by Hemingway, F Scott Fitzgerald, and Steinbeck.
kjm16216@reddit
Just finished In Cold Blood by Truman Capote.
ophaus@reddit
I love Salinger's work, particularly Franny and Zooey. I love some of the lesser-known writers of the Beat era, people like Kenneth Rexroth and Nelson Algren.
4myolive@reddit
I scrolled thru over 200 comments and hope I just accidentally missed this title. True Grit by Charles Portis. I'm 65+ and did not read it until this summer. Like most people my age I saw the movie version with John Wayne and wasn't that impressed. This book was a revelation to me. It doesn't take long to read so please read it ASAP. You'll be better for it.
LHCThor@reddit
It’s even more scarier in our current times.
Tricky_Ad_1870@reddit
I enjoyed The Great Gatsby, The Graoes of Wrath, and surprisingly Moby Dick.
MuppetRejected@reddit
Outsiders
MontanaPurpleMtns@reddit
The Scarlet Letter
I read first in a 6th grade advanced reading class, and again in high school as a required novel.
My take on it back then was that it showed the hypocrisy of the clergy (and I went to to a Christian school associated with our family’s church of choice) and Hester Prynne was a strong woman who refused to bow to society’s convention. Pretty heady conclusion for church school, that she was really the most moral and strongest character in the book.
Mind you I have not reread it in 50 years so I may not be remembering correctly.
Roger though. That man could play the long game.
Much less respect for the minister.
Kay89leigh@reddit
House of Mirth by Edith Wharton
Sinchanzo@reddit
There are a few, but The Count of Monte Cristo was a particular favorite.
Leoliad@reddit
East of Eden
mercurialpolyglot@reddit
Catch-22 is an absolute riot and I’m tired of people thinking I’m pretentious for talking it up
savvylikeapirate@reddit
I loved Johnny Tremain!
Nottacod@reddit
The Jungle-Upton Sinclair
fritolazee@reddit
A Rose for Emily, by Faulkner. It's the only Southern Gothic thing I've ever read but it really stuck with me.
Also Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton.
I think I was just always drawn to stories about the deep sadness that can be part of everyday existence.
buginmybeer24@reddit
Fahrenheit 451
matthewrparker@reddit
Beloved, 1984, Farenheit 451.
ginabina67@reddit
East of Eden was fantastic; Gone With the Wind; Little Women; To Kill a Mockingbird❤️
pkupku@reddit
Robert Heinlein Stranger in a strange land.
Mark Twain Letters from the earth.
Jack London to build a fire.
Michael Crichton Timeline
realPoisonPants@reddit
Preferred The Sea-Wolf to Call of the Wild.
mtcwby@reddit
Once an Eagle was a favorite of mine as a teen. Required reading at the military academies.
Thayli11@reddit
I almost never see Anton Myrer in these lists. I prefer The Last Convertible, but he writes nostalgia so beautifully.
mtcwby@reddit
I enjoyed that as well. One of those authors with that polished gift of words. Him, Larry McMurtry, Pat Conroy, Norman Maclean. Also loved Red Sky at Morning although it was shorter than Myrer but a wonderfully evocative writing style.
lenret19@reddit
Hemingway. The Sun also rises. Read it in High school and it was the first book that blew me away. Changed my life.
Xanadu87@reddit
I have two in mind:
Sister Carrie. It was an optional read for high school English class, and I was surprised how much I enjoyed it. Without giving too much away, it’s basically two parallel stories that intersect, someone’s rise and another’s downfall.
Now another one may not be old enough to be considered a “classic”, but a Confederacy Of Dunces was a weird, fun, wild book that I could never forget.
jackfaire@reddit
Huckleberry Finn. When I read it as a kid I didn't know it wasn't new. It was one of those books that felt like it could have been written in the 1980s rather than the 1880s. Mark Twain's writing was timeless.
PickleQueen24@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird, Great Gatsby, Catch-22, In Cold Blood
I work with high schoolers & middle schoolers & they’re all nuts about The Outsiders. I never read that though.
Thayli11@reddit
You should. SE Hinton is a marvelous author. It's also on the short side so if you don't like her work you won't suffer for long. Lol
DustOne7437@reddit
I grew up in Tulsa. S.E. Hinton’s books were required reading. Being force-fed works because it was a local author was frustrating.
stiletto929@reddit
As I Lay Dying, Of Mice and Men, To Kill a Mockingbird, The Color Purple, The Bluest Eye.
TechnologyDragon6973@reddit
Basically anything by Edgar Allen Poe. I don’t much care for the usual books that English teachers fawn over, but Poe and Twain are worth reading.
Zayneth1@reddit
White Fang is the first novel I ever read and I still adore it.
Puzzleheaded_Door399@reddit
Ooh I should reread this
the_owl_syndicate@reddit
Fahrenheit 451 by Bradbury, Call of the Wild by London, The Raven by Poe
hotlettucediahrrea@reddit
Call of the Wild. Definitively one of the best books I’ve ever read. London was a bastard, but this book is truly beautiful.
TheRandomestWonderer@reddit
A Farewell to Arms
YNABDisciple@reddit
Lonesome Dove!
Okuri-Inu@reddit
I don’t know if I’d say I loved it, but I have a fondness for Catch-22. It’s written in a way that makes it very tedious to read at times, but given that the whole point of the book is that the character is stuck in a no-win and absurd situation, it lends to the atmosphere of the book. I’m glad I read it, but I’m not sure I would have been able to finish it if I hadn’t needed to for school.
CampbellsBeefBroth@reddit
Everything made by Poe. Mary Shelly may have invented Gothic Horror, but Poe perfected it
ZebulonRon@reddit
It’s isn’t American, but Anna Karenina (Tolstoy) is an amazing piece of classical literature that is also technologically simpler and culturally rich. It is a very depressing read though, just a warning.
WesternCowgirl27@reddit
The Great Gatsby. I absolutely love the symbolism in that book! I also really enjoyed The Crucible (I like Shakespeare and enjoy a good play).
jiminak@reddit
I feel like I can take nearly every book from the “hate it” thread, and post it here. lol too hard to pick just one.
I’ve been re-reading as many classics as I can for about the past 10 years with the free Amazon versions on my kindle. Most of them are pretty faithful to the original. Not all are American classics through - I put Dickens and Tolstoy probably at the top of my favorite author list, with Twain in the top 5 and probably #1 on the American list.
caffa4@reddit
I didn’t see the other thread but I opened this one with my brain immediately going “idk but The Alchemist is definitely my most hated” so now I want your thoughts on The Alchemist lol
I also haven’t read it since I was 15 so idk if my feelings would hold true if I read it again today but the deep hatred towards that book has stuck with me for all this time
johannaishere@reddit
The Bell Jar and Song of the Lark I read in an American Women’s Writing class in college and they both changed my life.
I also loved The Great Gatsby when I read it in high school. The writing is just gorgeous and it’s such an easy entry into understanding metaphor and symbolism.
Also don’t know if this counts but I read Dreaming in Cuban in college for a class and it’s about the Latino experience but really about it in America and Cristina Garcia is American and I STILL think about certain passages of that book and how beautiful the writing was. I don’t know if it’s a classic but I read it for school and loved it so much.
TheDreadPirateJeff@reddit
Time Enough for Love, Stranger in a Strange Land. Always loved Heinleins stories. Burroughs too.
68OldsF85@reddit
My Antonia.
paddington-1@reddit
The Last of the Mohicans and To Kill a Mockingbird are my two favorites.
sotiredwontquit@reddit
I’m the only weirdo in my lit class that loved “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovitch”. I thought it was brilliant. I was astonished at how well the author made me identify with a character so thoroughly ordinary in every way.
MattieShoes@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird
Of Mice and Men
The Adventures of Tom Sawyer
JimBones31@reddit
The Moon is Down
Highway49@reddit
Raymond Chandler: The Big Sleep, Farewell My Lovely, andThe Long Goodbye. So many folks picked Steinbeck, so I went for another California legend.
No_Permission6405@reddit
Electric Kool-Aid Acid Test by Tom Wolfe.
One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest by Ken Kesey.
yetanothertodd@reddit
Travels with Charley
thewNYC@reddit
Sometimes a great notion by Ken Kesey
Grapes of wrath by Steinbeck
occasionallystabby@reddit
The Great Gatsby is still my favorite book of all time. I also loved Fahrenheit 451 and plan to read it again.
Relative-Scholar-110@reddit
The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton.
Spiritual-Ad3130@reddit
As a Missourian, I’m obliged to say Huck Finn.
But Truman Capote is a personal favorite of mine. Breakfast at Tiffany’s is brilliant. But In Cold Blood is a masterpiece.
maccrogenoff@reddit
Their Eyes Were Watching God by Zora Neale Hurston.
The Fire Next Time by James Baldwin.
The Ballad of the Sad Cafe by Carson McCullers.
Huckleberry Finn by Mark Twain.
LittleBear515@reddit
This side of Paradise
finnbee2@reddit
A Sand County Almanac by Aldo Leopold.
Disastrous_Ad_70@reddit
A Connecticut Yankee in King Arthur's Court and To Kill a Mockingbird are among the few classics I've been made to read for class that I actually enjoyed thoroughly
xRVAx@reddit
Seconding Steinbeck, Poe, and Twain... Surprised I haven't seen Gone with the Wind on this thread
Also, Sophie's Choice by William Styron is very American
brak-0666@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird
airheadtiger@reddit
Sophie's Choice is the greatest american novel. William Styron put so much of us in this great work.
original_greaser_bob@reddit
Cannery Row and Of Mice And Men.
i had a paper back 2 for 1 that had both stories in it. i think i found it in the give away pile at a library.
people so plain and ordinary they transcend time, place and social order to become universal.
Rando1396@reddit
Slaughterhouse Five
WiseQuarter3250@reddit
Storyteller, by Leslie Marmon Silko
mezolithico@reddit
In Our Time by Hemingway, really anything by Hemingway.
Invisible Man by Ellison.
Death of a Salesman by Miller
MysteryBelle_NC@reddit
Great Gatsby and East of Eden.
sharonclaws@reddit
Death Comes for the Archbishop. It's a love letter to the desert Southwest.
MacaroonSad8860@reddit
Light in August
triple_hit_blow@reddit
Huck Finn. It was great to get assigned reading that had a likable, well-meaning character going on adventures and growing into a better person, when most of the other assigned reading felt like an endless slog of boring people being terrible to each other.
DemonaDrache@reddit
I adore Edgar Allen Poe's body of work. My grandmother had the Raven memorized and I would sit enraptured by the words when she recited it. The first book I ever bought myself was an old Complete Works volume I found at a used book seller when I was 11 or 12. He wrote much more that horror - he also wrote fantasy and comedy as well.
I also love Last of the Mohicans.
Novel_Engineering_29@reddit
Absolutely hated the Scarlet Letter the first time I had to read it in high school, wound up adoring it in spite of myself when I had to read it again.
Lilyflower24681@reddit
I read To Kill A Mockingbird in 9th grade and still to this day I love it.
Pkrudeboy@reddit
Last of the Mohicans.
clever80username@reddit
Hatchet-Gary Paulsen. Greatest book ever written.
Crayshack@reddit
I'm a big fan of anything by Jack London (my favorite is "To Build a Fire"). Also, a good chunk of Poe (my favorite is "The Cask of Amontillado").
KEis1halfMV2@reddit
Moby Dick
michaela_mint@reddit
Great Gatsby and Where The Crawdads Sing!
Captain-PlantIt@reddit
Inherit the Wind and The Crucible. Both courthouse stories that demonstrate the dangers of group-think and ignoring science.
AlfredoAllenPoe@reddit
Great Gatsby and Huckleberry Finn
Hoopajoops@reddit
Adventures of Huckleberry Finn
Unhappy-Jaguar-9362@reddit
The Grapes of Wrath
I_The_Prokaryokte@reddit
Pudd’nhead Wilson and Those Extraordinary Twins by Mark Twain
VLA_58@reddit
I re-read Twain's 'Huck Finn' every 2 years or so, as well as 'The Innocents Abroad'. Anything by Poe is well worthkeeping on rotation, and Whitman's 'Leaves of Grass'.
gaudiest-ivy@reddit
The Grapes of Wrath
MolemanusRex@reddit
Moby Dick! One of the best books ever written.
According-Couple2744@reddit
The Great Gatsby
TucsonTacos@reddit
“Hatchet,” and its sequel “Butterknife”
Excellent_Counter745@reddit
Catch 22. Ragtime. Little House books, all of them.
devilscabinet@reddit
1984 and Brave New World. I'm re-reading them now.
beenoc@reddit
Those are both British books by English authors, though.
devilscabinet@reddit
Crap, you're right. I didn't pay enough attention to the original post.
When it comes to American authors, I really a lot of what Poe and Twain wrote. For genre "classics," Lovecraft.
dodadoler@reddit
Much better than merican
JoePNW2@reddit
"Oh, Pioneers!" (Willa Cather)
Emotional_Signal7883@reddit
It hasn't been described as such, but, What We Talk About When We Talk About Love
DaughterofTarot@reddit
Everything Steinbeck ever wrote.
hardFraughtBattle@reddit
Including Tortilla Flat? Because I'm about a quarter of the way through that one, and it's not holding me.
CalmRip@reddit (OP)
Tortilla Flat is both hysterically funny, and poignantly observant.
Chickenman70806@reddit
Lonesome Dove Eat of Eden Rebel without a cause
sto_brohammed@reddit
A Pickle for the Knowing Ones
DeepThinkingMachine@reddit
Grapes of Wrath
Airacobras@reddit
Not a classic of literature in general but in fantasy:
A Game of Thrones - George RR Martin
23onAugust12th@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird, Fahrenheit 451, and Anthem.
WoodsyAspen@reddit
Song of Solomon by Toni Morrison
Fire_Mission@reddit
Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance. High Quality.
NoGuarantee3961@reddit
Old yeller To kill a mockingbird The Little house series really provides a lot of insight
wormbreath@reddit
My Antonia
Tricklaw_05@reddit
So many good ones: Catcher in the Rye, To Kill a Mockingbird, Farewell to Arms, The Jungle.
USAF_Retired2017@reddit
The Glass Menagerie
nowhereman136@reddit
Almost anything by Mark Twain
dodadoler@reddit
I haven’t read that one
dodadoler@reddit
Green eggs and ham
Fuunna-Sakana@reddit
To Kill a Mockingbird