TheaterFire

Don't increase the money supply for 10 years.

Posted by NukeDC@reddit | CrazyIdeas | View on Reddit | 53 comments

Reply to Post

53 Comments

sorryformyschizness@reddit

Its not healthy for an economy to not have any inflation at all
View on Reddit #63725000

Valuable-Secret3003@reddit

Hard disagree. The Roman Empire example had essentially no inflation for centuries and they were just fine for a real long time.
View on Reddit #63741311

Augustus420@reddit

The Roman Empire had a pre-industrial economy and the value of their currency was tied directly to the amount of precious metals in their coins. Worked very differently.
View on Reddit #63746610

OrderOfMagnitude@reddit

You have described some differences but not why those differences matter.
View on Reddit #63777446

adam_sky@reddit

Do you genuinely need more of an explanation than “Pre-industrial economy”? If so that’s a google.
View on Reddit #63893691

OrderOfMagnitude@reddit

Ok yeah you have absolutely no idea lmfao
View on Reddit #63897761

Dinkelberh@reddit

The Roman Empire famously had many periods of lots of inflation. Conquering the known world tends to drastically increase the monetary supply.
View on Reddit #63779918

logisticitech@reddit

Lol Roman empire
View on Reddit #63751584

mr4ffe@reddit

It's not healthy for people to have an ever-growing economy.
View on Reddit #63766867

sorryformyschizness@reddit

Duhh
View on Reddit #63770483

VanillaSwimming5699@reddit

Or like with bitcoin slowly decrease the rate of printing on a schedule. However deflation is actually bad for a national currency, as it encourages people to hold their money and not spend it. Inflation actually encourages people to spend their money.
View on Reddit #63715895

Aniso3d@reddit

Deflation isn't actually bad, that's just a lie told by certain economic theorists 
View on Reddit #63734835

Dinkelberh@reddit

'Just a lie' bro doesnt understand that spending slows drastically when money isnt always losing value...
View on Reddit #63779739

chipmunk7000@reddit

> Inflation actually encourages people to spend their money. Is that just because now they have to use more of it to get the same stuff they bought before? Is there more to it?
View on Reddit #63725956

VanillaSwimming5699@reddit

You don’t want to hold a currency that deflates, so you invest that money in the stock market or other investments and purchases. You wouldn’t want to have swimming pools full of cash, because it’s not doing anything and is decreasing in *value*. Like you could invest it with a bank in a savings account, but that’s also good economically because it helps keep the banks afloat, so people can borrow money for example for a mortgage.
View on Reddit #63745181

Facts_pls@reddit

No. Say you want to buy a car. If you buy today, you'll pay 40,000 If you buy after 1 year, you'll pay 43000. Worth noting today. Now imagine if you wait 1 year and it will cost only 38000. Then you'll just wait to buy as much as possible. If everyone waits as much as possible then sales go down
View on Reddit #63726406

chipmunk7000@reddit

But your money is taking on or shedding the same value. Are people just stupid?
View on Reddit #63726463

gc3@reddit

No, people who have savings hold onto their money and put off purchases. Not people expecting income. People who owe debt will have problems paying them back under deflation because they used to sell 1000 widgets for 100 each, for an income of 100k, but now they sell only 500, and the widget is only 50 since the price is lower, so they make only 25k but their debt payment is the same. If that business owner has to cut costs to stay alive he is likely to fire workers, who will find out any new job they get is lower pay. Notable periods of general deflation include the Great Depression and the panic of 1876
View on Reddit #63729203

deleted_by_reddit@reddit

[removed]
View on Reddit #63739532

AutoModerator@reddit

Your post was automatically removed because it contains political content, which is off-topic for /r/CrazyIdeas. Please review the subreddit rules and guidelines. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CrazyIdeas) if you have any questions or concerns.*
View on Reddit #63739533

NiagaraBTC@reddit

Deflation is not bad. It is the natural state, as technology is deflationary. Also just FYI, Bitcoin isn't deflationary, it's disninflationary.
View on Reddit #63731222

VanillaSwimming5699@reddit

Bitcoin is deflationary, its value increases. No?
View on Reddit #63732270

NiagaraBTC@reddit

Inflation properly understood is the increase in the supply of money. As such Bitcoin is currently disninflationary, but does eventually become deflationary (as another responder notes) once more coins are lost per year than new coins issued. Deflation is not bad, however, in a sound money system. In a fraudulent fiat system such as we are in, deflation causes a lot of problems.
View on Reddit #63736502

mkosmo@reddit

Both per the schedule, plus the natural loss. Bitcoin has a fatal flaw in that lost coin is gone forever.
View on Reddit #63732961

Ayjayz@reddit

Oh no, saving, what a terrible thing. Better consume more resources, that's what really makes an economy during.
View on Reddit #63728147

gc3@reddit

Excess savings helped caused the Great Depression as rich people and poor alike took their money out of circulation and put the money under their mattresses. At least the lack of food woukd solve obesity.
View on Reddit #63729565

Aniso3d@reddit

This is a lie told by certain economic theorists 
View on Reddit #63735307

NiagaraBTC@reddit

>Excess savings helped caused the Great Depression Not correct.
View on Reddit #63731246

mkosmo@reddit

Without consuming resources, there's no trade. No trade = bad.
View on Reddit #63732904

carlos_the_dwarf_@reddit

Deflation is actually pretty scary.
View on Reddit #63731211

silentstorm2008@reddit

When yu deposit money in a bank, they can loan up to 90% of that to someone else. So you give them $100, the loan someone $90. You still have the $100 recorded in your account, but now $90 just got created from no where
View on Reddit #63748755

pbemea@reddit

What you're talking about is the reserve ratio in fractional reserve banking. The current reserve ratio is 0%. The bank is not required to keep any of your money in reserve.
View on Reddit #63775591

BanAccount8@reddit

Declare the United States of America has been overthrown and is now “Unified States of America” Issue a new currency and tell all creditors to go pound sand
View on Reddit #63719190

couldathrowaway@reddit

Same damage as simply handing over a 37T dollar bill to the debtor... actually, pay it first in useless money, then rename yourself. New nation will definitely not carry the burden at all.
View on Reddit #63731584

BanAccount8@reddit

Ok. Now to decide whose picture to put of $37 trillion dollar bill
View on Reddit #63731634

penndawg84@reddit

Uh, all of them. They're having a party. jimmy Carter's passed out on the couch.
View on Reddit #63748730

deleted_by_reddit@reddit

[removed]
View on Reddit #63735016

AutoModerator@reddit

Your post was automatically removed because it contains political content, which is off-topic for /r/CrazyIdeas. Please review the subreddit rules and guidelines. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CrazyIdeas) if you have any questions or concerns.*
View on Reddit #63735017

couldathrowaway@reddit

The picture of a Trizillian, obviously.
View on Reddit #63734587

ancientRedDog@reddit

Some of those creditors are just middle class Americans who put some of their retirement savings into treasury bonds.
View on Reddit #63736957

Sundance37@reddit

I love that people don’t realize that social security is a huge creditor.
View on Reddit #63734844

Aniso3d@reddit

That works if the new currency has teeth to it and tied to something with inherent worth 
View on Reddit #63734734

Add1ctedToGames@reddit

[Relevant The Onion video](https://youtu.be/TRgRz3nSG7o)
View on Reddit #63732379

NiagaraBTC@reddit

You should read the novel "The Mandibles"
View on Reddit #63731112

deleted_by_reddit@reddit

[removed]
View on Reddit #63729318

AutoModerator@reddit

Your post was automatically removed because it contains political content, which is off-topic for /r/CrazyIdeas. Please review the subreddit rules and guidelines. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CrazyIdeas) if you have any questions or concerns.*
View on Reddit #63729319

Valuable-Secret3003@reddit

Can’t work. The whole system is built upon increasing the money supply.
View on Reddit #63741229

NiagaraBTC@reddit

If you had a money printing machine in your basement, and it produced *perfect undetectable bills*, would YOU be able to resist using it? Nobody else can either.
View on Reddit #63731034

Colonol-Panic@reddit

Poor people hate this one simple trick
View on Reddit #63725743

Neither_Nothing_529@reddit

R/bitcoin
View on Reddit #63725430

deleted_by_reddit@reddit

[removed]
View on Reddit #63716838

AutoModerator@reddit

Your post was automatically removed because it contains political content, which is off-topic for /r/CrazyIdeas. Please review the subreddit rules and guidelines. *I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please [contact the moderators of this subreddit](/message/compose/?to=/r/CrazyIdeas) if you have any questions or concerns.*
View on Reddit #63716839

DrawPitiful6103@reddit

It's just so crazy it could work.
View on Reddit #63715017