Why are people against the Doctors Strike?
Posted by Quirky_Raspberry_901@reddit | AskUK | View on Reddit | 27 comments
How come people are against the doctor strike but they’re happy spend hundreds to watch their favourite artist or football who’s a millionaire
Gadgie2023@reddit
I’m not against it, they just have to be a bit cuter than using RPI when every single other bit of public sector is using CPI.
RPI was phased out a decade ago and even the ONS have said that it is an unreliable figure. They’ll have to be careful or they will lose the public.
I feel that some productivity measures and terms and conditions will be up for debate if they want to secure such a large rise on top of the 22% they got last year.
Onthechest@reddit
Student loans and mortgages use RPI. The two biggest liabilities a junior doctor will have. The government use CPI and RPI whenever it suits them best. RPI is justified in the doctors case.
FantasticGas1836@reddit
The junior doctors only just received a sizeable pay rise. The NHS is recovering. That recovery will be jeopardised by these doctors striking. Not only am I against the strike, but I think they are greedy. I don’t have hundreds to spend on football, artists or anything else much. I see no connection between the two.
Onthechest@reddit
How much do you think they should be paid?
Why do you think they should earn less money in real terms today than they did in 2008?
Why should they have to subsidise the economy by having their wages slashed.
The common argument against the above point is that everyone has had their pay eroded. This is not quite true, most sectors have had their pay restored to around 2008 levels in real terms and no other work group has had anything close to loss of real terms pay as junior doctors have.
This graph illustrates it nicely. Please take the time to read it and let me know your thoughts.
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/GJ1pWKHWkAAAC6G.jpg:large
FantasticGas1836@reddit
You always argue pay alone. Calculate in their pension and benefits. They are more than okay.
Onthechest@reddit
They have the same pension as every nurse, porter and receptionist in the nhs except doctors pay a HIGHER contribution towards it. Models show that if a similar amount was invested in a private pension performance would not be dissimilar.
Additionally the higher contributions of doctors subside the pensions for the lower earners in the NHS. It is likely that if doctors were removed from the pension scheme the entire programme would be unsustainable.
In 2015 there were pension reforms that made the nhs pension significantly worse. It is now a shadow of its former self but is an argument the government keep using as most people are unaware of the intricacies of how the pension scheme actually works. Please don’t let them pull the wool over your eyes.
Please, can you tell me what benefits they get that you are talking about as I am unaware of any?
Again, please let me know your thoughts.
FantasticGas1836@reddit
Just type ‘junior doctors only benefits’ into google. You compare to the private sector which is a mistake. You cannot run the NHS like a business more compare it. They are jeopardising the NHS and they are about to find out just how many people will object strongly to that.
Onthechest@reddit
I am a junior doctor. I’m senior, about 1 year away from completing my training and from a consultant post. I really am not aware of any benefits.
Please can you enlighten me?
If them not wanting to accept a real terms pay cut jeopardises the NHS then perhaps the NHS can not exist. Are you saying that you think junior doctors should shoulder the burden of a failing economy by accepting lower wages to allow the NHS to continue in its current form?
Essentially they are collectively refusing to accept that and I don’t know how anyone can think that’s unreasonable.
If your employer said you had to accept a 30% real terms pay cut in order for their business to remain viable what would you say?
GovernmentNo2720@reddit
Greedy? Most people couldn’t do the shifts doctors do, especially early on in their careers in their early 20s and they get paid a pittance for it. Doctors have the highest rates of divorce, suicide and mental health problems. They are not adequately paid or supported by the NHS for the work they do and the hospitals and surgeries are understaffed and under resourced. They don’t have the tools to do the job they need and want to do but they continue doing it anyway to provide the public with a decent enough level of care which is still free at the point of use. Not to mention the discrimination and vile behaviour they have to deal with from the public on a daily basis which most people wouldn’t stand for even once in their careers.
Independent_Ad_4734@reddit
It annoys me somewhat that when they mention pay restoration to 2008 they miss out they were still working a 72 hour week then, vs 48 hours today and of course the medical schools are still massively oversubscribed with eager applicants and all these resident doctors knew the terms when they started out on this journey. There is a sense that people are responsible for their own choices in life.
On the other side, it’s hard to be comfortable with a health service that behaves like a toxic employer and retention rates are a major problem that if we can fix will end up saving us money. Pay,training job security career progression reasonable rosters decent working environments the role of physicians assistants. There is a lot on the table and precious little money to address it. And of course where the Doctors lead the nurses will follow.
People have I think a keen sense that the country is very close to the edge of economic collapse. Liz Truss demonstrated how easy it is for the whole economy to start collapsing like a pack of cards, and they largely recognise higher taxes more borrowing printing money or taxing evil billionaires or tax evading multi nationals won’t fix our problem. (Some fantasists will of course continue to believe in this till the day they die). That’s why I think they have some sympathy with a government that is trying to balance the claims of cold pensioners disabled people kids with special needs and a host of other priorities with the needs of doctors.
I also don’t think it helps the doctors cause when they play the victim card, however victimised they feel.
‘ the public hate us, no one appreciates us, I think I’llvmove to Florida with my state funded education and earn 350,000 year . You’ll miss me then’
Lonely-Job484@reddit
They got, and received, a fairly substantial deal they agreed to relatively recently- less than a year ago? And now they're again going to go on strike again, so soon after this, causing cancellations, pain and potentially health damage to the public.
It's easy to say "people who save lives should be paid more", but okay... shall we double their pay? Great - so shall we have half as many and close half the hospitals? Or get rid of some of the paramedics/nurses/etc? Or just find the magical money tree where someone else pays for it, because there's an easy answer like "just tax {some definition that means people who aren't me}" ?
E5evo@reddit
A doctor saved my wife’s life by sending her straight to hospital after finding a lump. Turned out it was bowel cancer tumour. A politician, sportsman/woman, or CEO of a nationalised utility company etc are worth zilch compared to her GP. I’m right behind them.
itsadrianastinga@reddit
Because they think 2500£ salary for a doctor its more than enough which is crazy to me.NHS needs to be rebuilt but not by free labour.Sometimes the NHS feels like a slaughterhouse and you are the lamb. On the other hand without the lambs NHS is dead so maybe they need to stop the sacrifices
AutoModerator@reddit
It looks like you've written the pound sign (£) after the number 2500, but it should be written before the number like this:
£2500
.^(I am an annoying bot, so please don't be offended.)
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
pelicanradishmuncher@reddit
Police officers cannot strike due to the detrimental effect it would have on society.
Like it or not but Doctors, paramedics and firefighters are held to this same standard in people’s minds.
MrMonkeyman79@reddit
You make a very good argument. Keep increasing doctors pay till it matches that of a top tier footballer, the government starts defaulting on debt or maybe both.
Responsible_Club_638@reddit
Im not. Good on them. All they are asking for is pay in line with inflation since 2010. I work for an arms length public body and our paynis exactly the same situation, inflation compares to wage rises since 2010 means we are basically working a day a week for free. I wish my colleagues had the balls.tk fight like the doctors are doing.
Amd before anyone jumps in and says they haven't had a decent pay rise either. Well fucking stop moaning and fight for one!
PabloMarmite@reddit
I have no idea what footballers have to do with any of this. But the issue with the junior doctors is that they did this a couple of years ago and got a decent deal out of it.
InfrangibleSexWizard@reddit
How come people don't love paying bills but they'll happily buy chocolate ice cream? There are many reasons to be for or against the strike, but the idea that people are hypocritical if they spend money on entertainment is ridiculous.
SignificanceOld1751@reddit
Strikes = communism, and communists are trans.
Or something equally fucking daft
orbital0000@reddit
Next breath: "health care is a human right."
dxrkestofnights@reddit
Crabs in a bucket mentality.
They'll get the NHS they deserve.
alwaysright0@reddit
The nhs is a victim of its own success
People think it should cure every ill and solve every problem, for free
And that staff should just be happy they've got a job.
It apparently doesn't occur to them that if you want excellent service, you have to pay for it
DavieODaBanks@reddit
Not sure, but that's a false comparison
humunculus43@reddit
Because everyone has it pretty shit at the moment and many people feel they got a good enough deal last year. Also these people will all go on to earn six figures anyway. Just do a deal where they get paid more upfront but a lower salary later in their careers
SuspiciousTomorrow45@reddit
🐑
AutoModerator@reddit
Please help keep AskUK welcoming!
When repling to submission/post please make genuine efforts to answer the question given. Please no jokes, judgements, etc.
Don't be a dick to each other. If getting heated, just block and move on.
This is a strictly no-politics subreddit!
Please help us by reporting comments that break these rules.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.