What do you think is the most underrated candy bar of our youth?

[-]

Bedbouncer@reddit

Zero is the ginger ale of candy bars for when you're in the mood for something completely different.

[-]

adjperiod@reddit

Man I loved Zero. Found one a couple years back and only had one bite. It was bad and I was sad

[-]

ollie_hondro@reddit

This was always my go-to at the gas station or rest stop on trips. So good for some reason, I don’t even usually like white chocolate.

[-]

timshel_turtle@reddit

My grandma used to give me and my cousin a frozen zero bar to share so she could watch her stories. 💙💙

[-]

My dad would give us frozen ones. He bought the big packs of them from this big box store we had nearby. We would get one every once in a while for special summer occasions. Which as I type this I realize my mom and dad must have been housing frozen zero bars behind our backs.

[-]

poopypants206@reddit

These are in almost every convenience store by my house

[-]

HopelesslyHuman@reddit

Came to say Zero.

They can be tricky to find and they're so sweet they hurt your teeth but goddamn are they delicious.

[-]

rogue-lonely-path@reddit

I forgot about Zero so creamy.

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

Zero is really solid. I never see it anymore.

[-]

trustme1maDR@reddit

I've found them at World Market, if you are in the U.S. They kinda make my teeth hurt now, but I have fond memories.

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

Haha I believe it. I did not take care of my teeth as a kid (drank a lot of soda and ate tons of candy/treats) so I pretty much stick to mini/fun size candies (usually Kit Kat, Reese's, Snickers or Twix). Anyway, I will have to look for one. I remember enjoying them.

[-]

jjjhhnimnt@reddit

5th Avenue!!!

PB and chocolate are my favorite combo but Butterfinger gets stuck in my teeth. 5th Ave is much more enjoyable to eat. I used to steal change from my Memaw’s purse to get one at the gas station haha

[-]

CaleyB75@reddit

I liked Snickers bars and Reese's Peanut Butter Cups, but I wouldn't say either of them was underrated.

[-]

AlbatrossBulky4314@reddit

Summit Bar 2nd place: 10:30 Bar, it was my introduction to white chocolate

[-]

Victory33@reddit

Skor

[-]

Admirable_Egg_4562@reddit

Yep. That was the bar for sophisticates.

[-]

Searchlights@reddit

I like Skor better than Heath

[-]

Varuka_Pepper343@reddit

my husband just had one yesterday

[-]

Boetheus@reddit

The toffee in Heath tastes overdone, like slightly burnt

[-]

writtensparks@reddit

Heath has bits in it too doesn't it? Like nut pieces? I don't care for that. Skor is just plain toffee, much better.

[-]

Searchlights@reddit

I think Skor's chocolate is darker too

[-]

gingersrule77@reddit

Sammmme

[-]

SlimJim0877@reddit

Skir is the goat

[-]

otiliorules@reddit

This has been my favorite candy bar since the days where my grandpa would buy them and we’d share one. I still get them all the time.

[-]

Relative_Desk_8718@reddit

Had one of these today.

[-]

fermentedradical@reddit

They're both good but alI prefer Heath. Slightly less sweet and nuttier

[-]

Horty519@reddit

Skor is still around in Canada. Can you no longer find it?

[-]

Warhammer517@reddit

I can get them here in Michigan.

[-]

Flat-Product-119@reddit

We still have it in the US too

[-]

ninetentacles@reddit

From the way these things expire on the shelves, I didn't think anyone liked them...

[-]

blacktrufflesheep@reddit

Anytime I shop at CVS, I check to see if the candy bars at the register are on bogo sale. If so, I get one Skor and one Whatchamacallit. Sometimes, two of each.

[-]

BrambleVale3@reddit

So much better than Heath.

[-]

Lindsayr28@reddit

Such a good answer

[-]

ChromeDestiny@reddit

I always loved when I got fun sized Skor at Halloween.

[-]

GroovyGramPam@reddit

Butterfinger. They taste like crap now.

[-]

NateDoggR110@reddit

Skor.

[-]

turnpike37@reddit

Whatchamacallit...more like WhyCantChaFindIt

[-]

Cthulhaka@reddit

This. Mars Almond is a close 2nd. Of course, Mars got the shaft so they could give the shitty Snickers moniker to yet another candy bar.

[-]

Doubleucommadj@reddit

One of the last times at trivia, a lightning round was 20 different bars bisected. Pointed at it, said 'I think that's a whatchamacallit,' was ignored. Whittle options down further, 'I'm pretty sure that's a whatchamacallit!' 'Okay, but what's it called?' Someone else: 'That's what it's called.' Then I ended up having to write it out! 😂

[-]

Doubleucommadj@reddit

Do you fools need additional BS to appropriate? Inexcusable.

[-]

pebbles_temp@reddit

I used to eat a whatchamacallit and a diet coke for lunch at high school. It cost $1 total. No idea how that was enough food to get me through the day.

[-]

elpese@reddit

Ha! I ate a package of mini chocolate donuts and a Pepsi most days for lunch, sometimes a hot pocket instead of the donuts - from a campus lunch cart. My high school was huge and we had open campus lunch for all because the cafeteria couldn’t handle the number of students.

I’m not sure how I survived on this for lunch either!

[-]

Sidetrackbob@reddit

75 cents got me a mini slush puppy and a m&m or chocolate chip cookie. That's how my poor ass kept from starving at lunch time, but I almost always felt like shit afterwards too.

[-]

nocandu99@reddit

My first thought.

[-]

cheffartsonurfood@reddit

Actually I see it everywhere. They have a second one now. Whozeewhatsit and is superior in my book.

[-]

sporazoa@reddit

I dunno if you're telling the truth or not, and I'm too lazy to google it.

[-]

cheffartsonurfood@reddit

I am. Its a more chocolatey-pb version.

[-]

Ok-Potato-4774@reddit

I think Thingamajig was superior to Whatchamacallit, but it's discontinued.

[-]

Ryvick2@reddit

Heck yes I had that some years ago

[-]

cheffartsonurfood@reddit

Is that real? Never saw that one.

[-]

Ok-Potato-4774@reddit

Yes, discontinued in the late '90s, though.

[-]

cheffartsonurfood@reddit

I wonder if it's the same one that's just been renamed.

[-]

Warhammer517@reddit

Along with Thingamabob.

[-]

WeathermanOnTheTown@reddit

I've got twenty, but who cares, no big deal, I want more

[-]

DBE113301@reddit

How does it compare to doohickey?

[-]

Slippery-Pete76@reddit

Yeah, they even have them at the little snack shop at my office.

[-]

REO_Speed_Dragon@reddit

Wait what now?!

[-]

KittyCubed@reddit

I usually find it at Walgreens, often on sale. Gas stations usually have it too. But other than those, it is difficult to find.

[-]

Whitworth_73@reddit

The ad jingle:

https://youtu.be/9-ZUM0Jb9pQ?si=gI8tJG8SDd3p6FuR

[-]

nerdburgger84@reddit

That gave me a candy boner.

[-]

Flowerdriver@reddit

I stock them at Atwood's, Sutherlands, and maybe cabela's

[-]

LeafyCandy@reddit

Was just going to say this. I don't see it much anymore either. I loved that damn candy bar.

[-]

Particular-Loan5123@reddit

That’s the one

[-]

Conscious-Beyond2006@reddit

My most favorite!!!

[-]

seche314@reddit

They have them at Menards

[-]

violet039@reddit

There was a chocolate version for a while in the 80s or 90s, but it didn’t last long. Can’t remember the name.

[-]

_TheHalf-BloodPrince@reddit

Yep

[-]

Elly_Higgenbottom@reddit

I never see them in person, and they aren't as good as they used to be, but I get a full-size box to give out on Halloween as an excuse to have the extras.

[-]

jediphoenix1976@reddit

Totally agree - those were a favorite of mine as a kid.

[-]

suprunown@reddit

THIS. When I go to the States, or anyone I know goes, I get them to bring me back as many BOXES of these as they can. The local import candy store sells them for about $6 a bar, or $8 for the super-size ones.

[-]

JIMMYJAWN@reddit

Wawa has them

[-]

Greenteapots@reddit

The thrill I felt seeing this was the top answer! Truly an elite candy bar.

[-]

rojoshow13@reddit

My grandma would often ask me to get her a whatchamacallit, but it was because she couldn't remember what something was called. Sometimes she wanted a Butterfinger. Sometimes she wanted lightbulbs. Or dish soap. But at least one time she wanted an actual Whatchamacallit candy bar. I'm not joking.

[-]

otiliorules@reddit

🎵Chewy, chocolatey, crunchy, muncheeeeee🎵

[-]

KellyGreen55555@reddit

My favorite! They’re easy to find in the Midwest.

[-]

Glass-Guess4125@reddit

They’re so good! But relegated to like second or third tier by inferior candy bars.

[-]

Relative_Desk_8718@reddit

This or 100Grand

[-]

OptimistSometimes@reddit

This was my very first thought. It's like an even batter Nestlé Crunch bar.

[-]

Left-Cry2817@reddit

Was my go-to after-school treat at the local general store.

[-]

NGinuity@reddit

I can only find them sporadically everywhere else, but Home Depot has them at the pro checkout line without fail. It's my favorite.

[-]

Quenzayne@reddit

King Size Watchamacallits abound at Walmart.

[-]

Far-Pie-6226@reddit

I can still remember the commercial.

[-]

ringobob@reddit

It's still sold around me in pretty much any gas station, and most grocery stores. North of Atlanta, for what it's worth.

[-]

Rhizobactin@reddit

Was my top thought and happy to see it here

[-]

_hi_plains_drifter_@reddit

I thankfully see them all the time.

[-]

Tiny-Reading5982@reddit

Walmart has them

[-]

Searchlights@reddit

Gobbledegook, what's its face, what you can call it, whatever it is, whatever it was. Chocolatey, chocolate, how's it go? Well do chewy caramel. You know what I mean? Peanuty crisp. Crunchy, do that, let's get a ring. More than a mouthful."

[-]

30AMike@reddit

The last time I heard the first word in your sentence was when I was interviewing a cannibal from Vietnam.

[-]

maggie320@reddit

How about a Whoozeewhatzit?

[-]

DontBuyAHorse@reddit

It's still around, but not as good as it used to be. That's the case with almost everything nowadays though, especially candy bars.

[-]

Cancyrus@reddit

Publix

[-]

ButterscotchAware402@reddit

They're usually on the bottom shelf. Definitely not a bottom shelf candy bar though.

[-]

attigirb@reddit

I find them at 7/11 and cvs sometimes.

[-]

macklin_sob@reddit

This was my favorite as a kid and was my first thought.

[-]

queenofcaffeine76@reddit

Same, absolutely the childhood favorite! All the stores in my area sell the supersize ones

[-]

HermioneMarch@reddit

Yes! Whenever I do find one I get excited. I hardly ever eat candy bars any more but I’ll buy that one.

[-]

ModBabboo@reddit

Used to see the commercial for this all the time and it wasn't sold in Ontario. Saw one on my first trip to the States in my early 20s and it was like seeing a mythical creature.

[-]

ddiknosaj@reddit

This is the only answer

[-]

KevinStoley@reddit

I've been a huge fan of these since I was a kid. They still have them at local gas stations and I usually still buy one every so often and they are delicious. I remember also loving the commercial growing up too.

[-]

ZarquonsFlatTire@reddit

More than a mouthful.... it's Whatchamacallit.

[-]

Frosty_Cloud_2888@reddit

5 Below

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

Haha holds up well and I still see it sometimes.

[-]

HerebutNotreally9@reddit

If you have a five below near you check there!

[-]

EternalSunshineClem@reddit

Kudos

[-]

Swimminginthestorm@reddit

My mom thought we were eating healthy when she threw those in our lunchboxes.

[-]

EternalSunshineClem@reddit

Yeah it's truly a wonder we don't all have diabetes

[-]

cellrdoor2@reddit

It’s crazy how little education we got on over consuming sugar. My Mom was a life long diabetic and you would think we would have been raised without all that junk but nope. I used to wonder why I often had stomach aches after breakfast. It was the copious amounts of sugar.

[-]

UgandanPeter@reddit

Because there was a decades-long campaign against consuming fat, I don’t think we understood the negative effects of sugar until pretty recently

[-]

cellrdoor2@reddit

Definitely. The recipes in our house were all about removing fat and salt from meals. Everything was so dry and over cooked without much flavor. Really heavy on the carbs too.

[-]

Notwastingtimeiswear@reddit

This and Nutella were not marketed as junk food-- and I dont remember them being marketed as healthy, but for some reason we all thought Kudos bars and Nutella were acceptable options as part of a balanced diet!

[-]

homerj681@reddit

Kudos and some Boku?!? Summer memories unlocked

[-]

glorfindelreddit@reddit

The original PB Twix was amazing. The recent one was bad. I miss the old stuff

[-]

Philo_T_Farnsworth@reddit

“Magically delicious. Kudos, I’m yours!”

[-]

Prelude9925@reddit

Jeez I haven’t thought about those in decades!

[-]

YEMolly@reddit

I loved those!!!!!

[-]

abernathym@reddit

PB Max

[-]

MauriceLevyEsq@reddit

Came to say this. Gone too soon but man those were awesome.

[-]

Chiefbutterbean@reddit

They were great and I loved the commercials, The PB stands for….Porlty Ballerina, Plywood Bobsled and so on.

[-]

abernathym@reddit

Yeah, that and Dr. Pepper bubble gum were my favorite treats

[-]

Ghosts_of_the_maze@reddit

This should be the king of Halloween candy IMO. You could make single piece packages. If they have done that they sure as hell didn’t get the word out hard enough because PB Max rules

[-]

carport888@reddit

Real shame why they were discontinued, too. Apparently, the Mars family didn't like peanut butter, so they discontinued it when they acquired it.

[-]

abernathym@reddit

That's what I read as well

[-]

LavenderMcDade@reddit

These were top tier! I'm so glad you remember them too - they were my absolute favorite, but I haven't known anyone else who remembers them.

[-]

abernathym@reddit

I'm a big fan of peanut butter

[-]

toasterb@reddit

I remember getting those at the corner store at the end of the block.

Definitely a rarity having a corner store in the burbs back in the 90s, and I love that I had that growing up. Still had jars of candy at 2, 5, 10, 15, and 25¢. I think the PB Max bars were 45¢ in grade 2 when we moved to that neighbourhood.

Amazingly the shop is still around, but the deli/cafe side has taken over, which makes sense as that keeps them in business, but still sad to not have the great candy display.

[-]

abernathym@reddit

I always felt so cool riding my bike to the nearest gas station to buy snacks. It was the taste of independence.

[-]

ollie_hondro@reddit

Oh yeah these were good. And I remember the commercials for them: “PB don’t mean Parachuting Buffalo, Pineapple Beanie…”, etc.

[-]

LavenderMcDade@reddit

Pig Ballerina

[-]

abernathym@reddit

Oh yeah, I forgot all about the commercials.

[-]

panda_football79@reddit

Came here for this. I would buy one practically every day in the early 90s. Tragic loss.

[-]

danbob411@reddit

Also the Peanut Butter Snickers bar. It was perfection while it lasted.

[-]

abernathym@reddit

Yeah, it was good too

[-]

rootsquasher@reddit

5th Avenue

[-]

Automatic-Count2092@reddit

Agree. To me it's the perfect candy bar.

[-]

spiral_larips@reddit

my grandpa had boxes of these in the pantry. I would grab one every time I visited!

[-]

ConstructionWise4365@reddit

Gravel crunch!

[-]

Philo_T_Farnsworth@reddit

To this day I still can’t enjoy Butterfingers. 5th Avenue was that concept perfected.

[-]

pogulup@reddit

The new Butterfingers are pretty good, much improved. The old ones were nothing compared to a 5th Ave.

[-]

KittyCubed@reddit

I prefer the old Butterfingers. But I’ve never had a 5th Avenue.

[-]

eastbayted@reddit

[-]

Ok_Pea_6054@reddit

This was my favorite as a kid, hell yeah!

[-]

Human-Ad1643@reddit

Thank you! I came here to post this! Nobody seems to know what it is around me

[-]

Scared-Ideal-1483@reddit

YES!! Absolutely the best peanut butter and chocolate candy bar out there!

[-]

freshleysqueezd@reddit

🎵It. Will. Make. You. Go. CRUNCH. ^5th ^avenue 🎵

[-]

Automatic-Count2092@reddit

Either 5th Avenue or Zero.

[-]

IloveRizza@reddit

USA mars bar, I found the European version and it was nothing like the US version. I miss mars bars.

[-]

Mulliganplummer@reddit

1000 Grand

[-]

aceisback29@reddit

Marathon

[-]

Firm_Accountant2219@reddit

Chunky

[-]

Dance2GoodbyeHorses@reddit

Mars bars. I can’t find them anymore :(

[-]

Mario17837@reddit

Zagnut

[-]

TimMacPA@reddit

3 Musheteers never got much love; that was my favorite bar.

But Milk Duds were my favorite movie candy. Eaten with fresh popcorn and 1 box lasted the whole movie!

[-]

FormNo2644@reddit

I was an adult by this time but it was still like 20 years ago, so, Hershey’s S’Mores bars. I will never forgive them for discontinuing them.

[-]

Selmarris@reddit

Anybody remember the Wonka Bar? Chocolate with graham crackers. So good.

[-]

ouch_that_hurts_@reddit

My fav. There have been counterfeits in the UK.

[-]

wall_kicks_will_work@reddit

I was about to ask this same question. I remember getting them near the registers at Hastings Books and Toys R Us. They were so good!

[-]

Sidetrackbob@reddit

I recently started liking pay day. Never gave 'em a chance when I was younger. They're pretty good. But although they're a loose candy and not a bar, I have always loved and always will love Junior Mints. Cookies and Cream Hershey's - severely overrated. Yuck.

[-]

acer-bic@reddit

The Zero bar. Also can’t find it.

[-]

Aurantai@reddit

I cant remember the name, it was some whatchamacallit type of candy bar. It was a lovely blend of pb chocolate and rice krisp. Damn. Maybe I will remember the name someday.

[-]

O2BAKAT@reddit

Marathon Bae

[-]

Glad_Lychee_180@reddit

Charleston Chew, duh.

[-]

petehutch54@reddit

ZERO bar

[-]

Impossible_Camera302@reddit

frozen charleston chew

[-]

excitaetfure@reddit

Skor

[-]

zopelar1@reddit

At convenience store check outs there was always a place for chocolate “Ice Cubes”. They melted so fast and were so good they weren’t even really chewable. Melted in your fingers. Yum happy memory!

[-]

ConsequenceIll6927@reddit

My top suggestion is Twix. Both chewy and crunchy.

Second place is Payday. Salty and peanuts in a bar. Delicious.

Third? Mr. Goodbar. I never.knew anyone else who ate these, but I did.

[-]

AceUnderTheHole@reddit

Technically not a bar, but I'm gonna take a little liberty and say Rolo.

[-]

Boetheus@reddit

You can roll a Rolo to your pal

It's chocolate-covered caramel

You can roll a Rolo to your friend

It's chocolate-covered caramel from end to end

[-]

ChristianlyShimmy@reddit

Glad to see the Tim & Eric representation for Rolos

[-]

nefastvs@reddit

Rolo Tony, Brown Town!
Check yourself at the door.
Gimme some more,
Gimme some more,
Gimme some more of those Rolos!

[-]

malaise-ennui@reddit

Give it to your friend...as a GIFT

[-]

nefastvs@reddit

—AS A GIFT.

[-]

ciccacicca@reddit

We used to smooth out the rolo wrappers and cover our front teeth with them to make them look like gold teeth

[-]

Rhizobactin@reddit

Loved it except for all of the unwrapping. I just want to eat it!

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

One of my grandmas always had Rolo in her house. Grew up eating it and miss it.

[-]

candid84asoulm8bled@reddit

My grandma always had a roll of Rolos or Mentos in her purse. They were rationed very meticulously though.

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

Haha love it. Hilarious how frugal certain grandparents could be.

[-]

BugEquivalents@reddit

Have you ever melted a rolo on a pretzel? It’s incredible.

[-]

AceUnderTheHole@reddit

No, but I want to immediately.

[-]

the_matthman@reddit

Melted between two Ritz crackers is amazing.

[-]

AceUnderTheHole@reddit

No, but I want to immediately.

[-]

ElfDestruct@reddit

Yeah, one tube of Rolo would go down in a couple minutes, exactly like a bar.

[-]

VioletEMT@reddit

I have a very specific, happy memory associated with Rolos. Eating them always makes me smile.

[-]

DigitalMunkey@reddit

Rolo was NOT underrated in our house, lol

[-]

Gen_X_MenoBadass@reddit

Violet crumble!

[-]

subbychub@reddit

Barnone

[-]

RareSetting7856@reddit

5th Avenue

[-]

LiftedMold196@reddit

It's so much better than a Butterfinger

[-]

_NoleFan6@reddit

Yes!! You could use your front teeth to bite them without fear of them falling out, and they don’t crumble once you bite them 🤣

[-]

_NoleFan6@reddit

PB Max…. Iykyk 😌

[-]

TurdFerguson2OOO@reddit

Zero

[-]

Change_Request@reddit

Zero...how cool was it that it was white chocolate covered.

And Payday

[-]

Significant_Dentist3@reddit

Bar None!

[-]

smittymoose@reddit

Mallow cups.

[-]

gmoney-0725@reddit

Mounds.

[-]

Al_Tilly_the_Bum@reddit

It is still around but I never knew why 100 Grand didn't get more love. I would take it over a snickers

[-]

cssdayman@reddit

I wish Take5 was around when I was a kid. I freaking love that salty pretzel and caramel! 100 Grands are amazing frozen.

[-]

JBLBEBthree@reddit

My kids love 100 grand!! We stock up when they are easy to find at Halloween.

[-]

Fast_Enthusiasm8728@reddit

Oh, you and I are long-lost besties! 😆 These candy bars were always in my stash.

[-]

aubreypizza@reddit

Yup this was my fave

[-]

Geoff-Vader@reddit

It's a weighted random (some guy did an analysis on the r/Costco sub) but there's usually a handful in the big Halloween mix bags Costco puts out. Not the most efficient way to get them of course. But I immediately sift through the bags once we open them and snag all the 100 grand bars.

Didn't appreciate them when I was younger but love em now.

[-]

Golden_Enby@reddit

Hundred Grand was one of my favorites. Glad I wasn't the only one.

[-]

peachslicer@reddit

I love these but they’re so often stale & hard as fuck. I think these guys might have a short shelf life.

[-]

WoefulKnight@reddit

What would YOU do with a 100 Grand??

I'd eat it!

[-]

Warhammer517@reddit

Afterward, I would recycle the wrapper.

[-]

booyakasha99@reddit

At least in my area it was considered an “adult” candy. This was great for me during post-Halloween trading. 100 Grand is great.

[-]

it_swims@reddit

100 Grand is usually available half off after halloween.. I've scored two years in a row.

[-]

4Jolly2Green0Giant@reddit

This right here!

[-]

the_matthman@reddit

100 Grand has ice cream bars now!

[-]

Solintari@reddit

100g is the first bar consumed on Halloween for me. I trade the kids all of the suckers for them.

[-]

supergirlsudz@reddit

My grandma would always buy me 100 Grands!

[-]

Calbebes@reddit

Take 5 is SO good

[-]

aqaba_is_over_there@reddit

Reception has a candy bowl and I always grab the 100 Grand when they come up.

[-]

Mother_Echo4502@reddit

100G and Take 5 were good. My favorite was a SkyBar

[-]

willworkforwatches@reddit

I clicked this post to offer the same suggestion. Criminally underrated candy bar.

[-]

Roland-Of-Eld-19@reddit

Hundred Thousand Dollar Bar haha

[-]

cssdayman@reddit

I freaking loved that REGGIE! bar. Also anything I could freeze like Marathon or a Charleston Chew. I liked the Chunky too. Huge fan of Heath bars too.

[-]

Repulsive_Tie_7941@reddit

Chic-o-sticks. Toasted coconut over a flakey peanut butter core. Think a Butterfinger, but dryer.

[-]

ReadyLaugh7827@reddit

it's a damn shame i had to scroll this far down for the correct answer..

[-]

AudaciousNeedles@reddit

I’ve been scrolling along to see if anyone said this. Loooved these damn sticks. I haven’t seen one in years. I’m guessing a candy store may have it. 🤷🏼‍♀️

[-]

Zucc@reddit

And they were like 10c! I always wondered about the branding but man I loved them.

[-]

poopypants206@reddit

Strawberry Charleston chew after being in the freezer

[-]

throwngamelastminute@reddit

1000%

[-]

LMurch13@reddit

Yes!

[-]

Real-Championship331@reddit

I was always a fan of chocolate Charleston Chew

[-]

VioletVenable@reddit

I loved the strawberry ones. Especially frozen. (Hey, those baby teeth were going to fall out anyway…)

[-]

Maryssaraptor@reddit

All 3 flavors were so good! Now I can only find the vanilla ones

[-]

throwngamelastminute@reddit

There's only one place in my town where I can consistently find the strawberry ones, and I'm going there later this morning to get gas.

[-]

Waterproof_soap@reddit

We would buy the huge ones, freeze them, break them into pieces and eat during movie night

[-]

c_b0t@reddit

Came here looking for frozen Charleston Chew.

In like 5th grade we had Swim Day (a field trip to a pool) and they had a snack bar that sold frozen Charleston Chews. First time I'd had one and it was amazing.

[-]

frendly9876@reddit

Skor bar! My babysitter would bribe us with Skor and Rolos. Rolo days we got to be naughty but I went to bed early for my Skor bar

[-]

renb8@reddit

Chokito

[-]

HorangiBae@reddit

Candy corn... just injecting straight sugar into my veins.

[-]

Aggressive-Check1096@reddit

Man as a kid I loved me a Reggie. Like a giant turtle if I recall.

[-]

OkConsideration7721@reddit

Oh Henry.

[-]

ChasingKayla@reddit

Skor. I still love them, even though that toffee gets stuck in my teeth.

[-]

Accomplished-Key-408@reddit

Bar None was and remains the greatest candy bar of all-time.

[-]

Major-Form3362@reddit

100 Gram

[-]

Major-Form3362@reddit

Rolos

[-]

villagust2@reddit

Symphony. It wasn't really marketed to kids, but I chose it whenever it was an option.

[-]

SciFi_Wasabi999@reddit

Me too!!! It was my favorite

[-]

peggysue_82@reddit

The almond toffee has always been my favorite.

[-]

KittyCubed@reddit

This is my favorite one too.

[-]

miianwilson@reddit

I feel so old commenting this, but those giant bars were $1 in the 90s. We always got them cause they were huge and cheap. I saw them at the grocery store the other day for $4.50. I get inflation and all, but I can’t imagine it’s that much

[-]

SlackerDS5@reddit

Was looking for this. I liked them and Skor bars more than all the other candy bars out there.

[-]

SquatchoCamacho@reddit

I still buy those, I think that's the best regular grocery store chocolate you can find

[-]

Capital-Meringue-164@reddit

I was obsessed with Symphony as a kid. I always felt sophisticated haha

[-]

VioletVenable@reddit

I distinctly remember that my dad’s mom sent me a Symphony bar for my birthday when I was 4 or 5. Best chocolate I’d ever had in my little life! It makes me happy that they haven’t changed the label very much in the last 40 years, and I always think of her when I see them at the store. Obvs, it’s not gourmet and I’m clouded by sentiment, but I still think Symphony is pretty good!

[-]

Swimminginthestorm@reddit

My grandma always had them around and would share.

[-]

j_dick@reddit

Zero bar! I loved those. And Charleston Chews

[-]

Sea-Pain3633@reddit

Oh my gosh, what happened to barnone?!!

[-]

Polkawillneverdie17@reddit

After Eight

[-]

Polkawillneverdie17@reddit

Take 5

[-]

Allureme@reddit

Oh Henry

[-]

CheesyRomantic@reddit

Sweet Marie

It’s similar to a Oh Henry but fudgier. And the chocolate was better.

[-]

olkangol@reddit

Called "RSVP".

Had a limited run 2-3 yrs in the 90s, caramel inside. Hershey or Cadbury probably made it

[-]

Frequent-Walrus-2652@reddit

Chunky

[-]

Frequent-Walrus-2652@reddit

Forever Yours

[-]

MashedPotatoesDick@reddit

Skor

[-]

CreativeFedora@reddit

Mr. Goodbar and Krackel!

[-]

knivesofsmoothness@reddit

Mr goodbar makes bomb ass smores!

[-]

SensibleBrownPants@reddit

Krackel > Nestle Crunch

[-]

CreativeFedora@reddit

The Krack is simply the best!

[-]

Varuka_Pepper343@reddit

fact

[-]

underdeterminate@reddit

Hard agree. So hard

[-]

midnight-dour@reddit

Do full size Krackle bars exist? I’ve only ever seen them as the Halloween size.

[-]

Miz_momo82@reddit

You know I've never thought of this and according to the internet the full-size bars were discontinued in '97, brought back in 2014 before being discontinued again. I don't recall ever eating or seeing a full size bar either way

[-]

ScreenTricky4257@reddit

Twix used to have four flavors. Peanut butter, caramel, cookies-and-cream, and fudge.

[-]

KittyCubed@reddit

I found the PB one a while back, but I’m wondering if it was a limited edition or if it’s just really hard to find. Love the PB ones.

[-]

-Bk7@reddit

Twix ice cream bar ftw!

[-]

Nire_Cats_Rule_888@reddit

I loved the cookies and cream!!!

[-]

bibibethy@reddit

Aw, I forgot about that! I used to really like the peanut butter ones

[-]

Ok-Jellyfish2013@reddit

Milkshake.

It's long gone now.

[-]

raccoondog69@reddit

Chicko -Stick

[-]

dontletyourcrownslip@reddit

Payday!

[-]

HuckleberryHappy6524@reddit

Every time I buy a payday, it’s stale as fuck. It pisses me off because they are awesome. I haven’t had a fresh one in years.

[-]

babbling_homunculus@reddit

So sad. I used to have this or the 99 cent whopper for lunch in high school before I got a car when only the 7-11 or Burger King were walkable.

[-]

Damet_Dave@reddit

I did a 5 year stint at Hershey in IT. One perk (or curse) was that almost all the conference rooms had candy bowls with minis.

Paydays were my kryponite. Even at 8 AM meetings.

Was interesting the first time I was in a morning meeting and got to watch folks drop KitKats or Hershey’s kisses into their coffee.

[-]

dontletyourcrownslip@reddit

Definitely a perk/curse. I can just hear myself justifying this 😂

[-]

DrMcJedi@reddit

Pearson’s Nut-Roll will always be the superior nut roll to Payday. (It was local to me as a kid - I think they’re still made in St. Paul, MN)

[-]

gesis@reddit

I haven't had one of these in ages, but you are absolutely correct.

Payday is still my go-to mid bike ride snack though.

[-]

REO_Speed_Dragon@reddit

I have a chocolate allergy and this was amongst the fewest options. Still a fan.

[-]

machomansavage666@reddit

Never cared much for payday. There’s a brand in dollar tree called Pearson peanut roll and it’s the same but far superior and it’s huge. They also have a cinnamon version that’s fire

[-]

Holmes221bBSt@reddit

Payday and Baby Ruth. Both are fire!

[-]

Amy_Macadamia@reddit

gif

Baby Ruth!

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

I actually saw a Payday commercial the other day much to my surprise. I always loved this one.

[-]

Stillwater-Scorp1381@reddit

PB Maxx

[-]

SaintStephen77@reddit

The Marathon Bar.

[-]

Calbebes@reddit

Skor bars! I would sell my soul. So much better than Heath bars.

Luckily, you can still find them.

[-]

peachyfuzzle@reddit

I still see them all over the place

[-]

Tiny-Reading5982@reddit

Zero

[-]

mortmortimer@reddit

Crunch

[-]

Samurai-Pooh-Bear@reddit

Zagnut

[-]

Ceemurphy@reddit

nestle milk chocolate

[-]

rickitytick@reddit

Chick-O-Stick

[-]

rickitytick@reddit

Skor

[-]

SgtBearPatrol@reddit

Peanut Butter Twix.

[-]

Myrtle_Snow_@reddit

3 Musketeers. I know they’re still around, but I only started eating them because of the low fat craze in the 90’s since they have less fat than most. I love that nougat center though, it’s delicious!

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

They get a lot of hate. I like them once in a while and remember enjoying them as a kid.

Like Milky Way and Snickers, they are better as a fun size/mini bar.

[-]

SplatterFart@reddit

Agreed. Minis have a higher chocolate/filling ratio.

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

Definitely the right amount.

[-]

OrganizationOk5418@reddit

Rowntree Nutty

[-]

violet039@reddit

Does anyone remember Summit bars? I just remember the name. They might’ve been done after the early 80s.

[-]

greenberg17493@reddit

ZERO.

[-]

nstc2504@reddit

Baby Ruth never gets the love it deserves...

Also shoutout to Mr Goodbar

[-]

Krymestone@reddit

Reese’s Outrageous bar. Instead of peanuts, pieces. What a great thing.

[-]

Selmarris@reddit

Nutrageous!

[-]

Lilworldtraveler@reddit

This because it came out in 1994 and it’s amazing 🤩

[-]

Left-Landscape-3890@reddit

Nutrageous?

[-]

Warhammer517@reddit

Reese's Nutrageous bar. Peanut butter, peanuts, caramel, and covered in chocolate.

[-]

kmikk30@reddit

Bit-o-honey

[-]

SpaceAce1956@reddit

Zagnut

[-]

Glitterbug1128@reddit

gif

Baby Ruth

[-]

JoeFromStPaul@reddit

Not of our youth, but I miss the Smores bar.

[-]

AcadiaRemarkable6992@reddit

PB Max

[-]

traveling_man182@reddit

Clark

[-]

dolorous_marvin@reddit

Zagnut

[-]

toondoggie@reddit

I love Zagnut. I will see them around where I live sometimes. They aren't everywhere but they still exist. Last time I went to Hershey Park, I went to the big candy store in Chocolate World and bought a case.

[-]

nickml007@reddit

Scrolled a long time before seeing this right answer

[-]

dolorous_marvin@reddit

Haven't seen one in years. I miss them so much.

[-]

abernathym@reddit

I wish they were not so hard to find

[-]

BrambleVale3@reddit

Definitely the best answer to this question.

[-]

Ok_Pea_6054@reddit

Even though my favorite growing up was 5th Avenue, I have to shout out Alpine White. My kids' mom (she's a 1984 born) laments this not being around anymore.

I am not too crazy about white chocolate myself, but I can see where she comes from lol.

[-]

SquirrelBurritos@reddit

Zagnut, I can still find it every once in a while but yeah… my ass was riding my bike to my tiny towns general store after school with my 50 cents on the regular

[-]

FairBaker315@reddit

Clark Bar

[-]

kkaos84@reddit

Nutrageous. When it came out, it immediately became my favorite candy...well, ok, tied with plain M&Ms.

[-]

elizable9@reddit

Drifter. They did bring them back in my 20s but now they're gone again 😭

[-]

enginbeeringSB@reddit

The flat laffy taffy bars. Still find them occasionally, but they’re so rare they days. The small ones or long round ones don’t taste like the same product, just not the same!

[-]

willgreenier@reddit

Payday

[-]

caaat_foood@reddit

Charleston Chew and Caramello

[-]

True_Prize4868@reddit

The Bar None by Hershey RIP

[-]

keener_lightnings@reddit

I was just telling my husband a couple of days ago how much I miss Bar None 😭

[-]

Much_Wishbone6058@reddit

They still exist. I bought one at an antique store that has a vintage. Candy store section about a year ago. It was such a treat! I just looked and they sell them on Amazon.

[-]

True_Prize4868@reddit

I got one that was remade but not from Hershey. It was slightly different and in a yellow and brown wrapper.

[-]

Sail0r_Jupit3r@reddit

There’s a bulk food store by my house that sells them. I was so stoked when I saw it the first time a few years ago, I ate it as soon as I got into my car. It was definitely not the same and beyond disappointing, I’m still salty about it.

[-]

Emergency-Ad3619@reddit

Bar None! I saved all the wrappers in middle school to get the Scared Guy tshirt

[-]

True_Prize4868@reddit

That’s awesome! Even cooler if you still have it!

[-]

Blackbird136@reddit

My favorite ever.

[-]

sdavidson0819@reddit

I used to think my Dad was weird for liking candy with raisins in it, but I recently had a Cadbury Fruit n Nut and really liked it.

[-]

ApathyxExhaustion@reddit

ZAGNUT

[-]

suprunown@reddit

4 Treasures bars.

[-]

SbMSU@reddit

Chunky

[-]

OneHumanBill@reddit

Milky Way Midnight. I can't eat them anymore but they were super rare but goated.

[-]

Dee_Buttersnaps@reddit

I get them in the tiny fun size around Halloween

[-]

xVercetti@reddit

Skor!!

[-]

cheffartsonurfood@reddit

Not a bar, but Sixlets were my go to.

[-]

VioletEMT@reddit

My dad used to buy me Sixlets at the gas station on road trips.

[-]

elquatrogrande@reddit

The only reason I liked going to one of my uncle's house was because the only gas station on the way had Sixlets and we always stopped.

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

I saw them all the time growing up. They were a popular arcade/school candy.

[-]

Redcatche@reddit

This is the correct answer.

[-]

grandma_millennial@reddit

Yes! So much better than m&m’s IMO

[-]

thatquinnchick@reddit

YES.

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

I loved Sixlets as a kid.

[-]

ElfDestruct@reddit

Also not a bar, but ate them like one anyway. A tube of Rolo.

[-]

Dimplefrom-YA@reddit

i dunno if this is a candy bar or not but nutty buddy.

[-]

TheSaltyJM@reddit

Bit O' Honey

[-]

Exact_Friendship_502@reddit

The OG Butterfinger

[-]

squashhandler@reddit

Mallow cups!

[-]

HBK42581@reddit

Caramello. Stretch it out.

[-]

Varuka_Pepper343@reddit

they're delicious. I grab them when I see them

[-]

HBK42581@reddit

Me too. Anything chocolate and caramel is my jam.

[-]

diablero_T@reddit

Funky chewy Caar-a-melloo 🎶

[-]

PileofTerdFarts@reddit

Whatchamacallit, BarNone, and 3 Musketeers... all delightful.

BUT, do you all remember when Nestle Crunch came in a FOIL wrapper? They were thinner back then too. It was the blue and white paper sleeve, then inside that was a cellophane-thin layer of real FOIL. I remember those tasting SO MUCH better than they taste now. They had a "snap" to them that just isn't there anymore and hasn't been since the 90s. Gosh those were incredible.

Finally, not a candy bar, but I have to give some love for Choc-o-Bliss. I remember scarfing those down and being so happy. In an era before I knew the joys of sex and drugs, I think Choc-o-Bliss cakes were the closest my little 9-year-old mind came to euphoric/orgasmic pleasure.

[-]

Sad-Math-2039@reddit

Zero Bar

[-]

IONaut@reddit

Big hunk

[-]

Consumer_Distributin@reddit

Choclair. It was wafers and chocolate mousse. So good!

[-]

gojo96@reddit

Chunky

[-]

096624@reddit

Bar none

[-]

Repulsive_Sleep_3197@reddit

$100,000 bar from Hershey’s

[-]

Wild-Ad-2721@reddit

Oh Henry!

[-]

Prelude9925@reddit

And the heiress to the fortune wears a bra as a top!

[-]

christophervolume@reddit

Boutros Boutros-Ghali !

[-]

jasonrubik@reddit

We'll grow oranges in Alaska

[-]

blacktrufflesheep@reddit

We have a cute little vacuum cleaner named Henry at my workplace.

[-]

MlsterFlster@reddit

This. Oh Henry got slept on. It was a fantastic bar.

[-]

therebill@reddit

Charleston chew

[-]

ah-mazia@reddit

Bar None 🤤. I think about it more often than I’d like to admit

[-]

dcott44@reddit

Charleston Chew

[-]

poondoggydog@reddit

Mr. Goodbar.

[-]

Sal_Paradise81@reddit

Skör

[-]

momolala@reddit

The Wisconsin Cowpie.

[-]

allamingo@reddit

Zero bars

[-]

actvsvibe@reddit

Alpine White

[-]

Blazenkks@reddit

5th Avenue

[-]

Lord_Puppy1445@reddit

Zagnut

[-]

Low_Lack8221@reddit

Charleston Chew

[-]

topshelfvanilla@reddit

Zagnut

[-]

Wise_Security3954@reddit

Take 5 bars

[-]

Frequent-Interest796@reddit

Clark

[-]

The2ndComingOfGoku@reddit

Butterfinger Crisp, put in the freezer, is the GOAT. Straight off the shelf it'd be Take 5 or 100 Grand.

[-]

Ok_Honey_2057@reddit

The old Butterfinger recipe is my answer

[-]

CharmyLah@reddit

Me too! I was so disappointed when they changed the recipe, they're so gross now.

[-]

wmubronco03@reddit

100 grand followed closely by a Payday

[-]

louisbarthas@reddit

Abba Zaba

[-]

llamatador@reddit

Had to scroll too far for this.

[-]

ReverendHambone@reddit

[-]

OldBanjoFrog@reddit

Lion

[-]

im_a_turtle@reddit

Reese's Fast Break. I don't think I've ever heard another person talk about them (proved by this thread) or seen them eat them but the way it added in that Nougat to make the Reese even fluffier and smoother going in was so sublime to me. They hung around in every store for so long too.

[-]

sparkypme@reddit

Symphony

[-]

speekloud@reddit

Nestle Alpine White

[-]

MrGrim421@reddit

American mars bar and no almond Snickers is not the same

[-]

Dame_Ingenue@reddit

Mirage. Like Arrow with the bubbles, but much better.

[-]

ooyat@reddit

I remember like Zero bars but could only find them at the water park.

[-]

Alternative-Light514@reddit

100 Grand. I swear they only sell them during Halloween!

[-]

Proper_Training2358@reddit

Caramelo

[-]

SplakyD@reddit

Mr. Goodbar, Payment, Zagnut, Almond Joy... I've got a bunch.

[-]

mfwicswoman@reddit

5th Avenue bars

[-]

mssheevaa@reddit

Choclairs. So good and I miss it

[-]

MrPawsBeansAndBones@reddit

I dunno when they came out but there was a dark chocolate mint musketeers that was fucking perfect 😚 👌

[-]

WarriorGoddess2016@reddit

Heath.

[-]

icelax99@reddit

Nutrageous

[-]

DaveinOakland@reddit

Do Jawbreakers count?

[-]

orangepaperlantern@reddit

Hershey’s Cookies and Mint bar, RIP.

[-]

Boozy_Cat_@reddit

Zero bars.

My dad used to freeze Zero bars and give them to us for special occasions during the summer.

[-]

Shigglyboo@reddit

Skor

[-]

SignificantApricot69@reddit

Zero

[-]

Odafishinsea@reddit

PB Max

[-]

Knight_thrasher@reddit

gif

[-]

MegaRadCoolDad@reddit

100 Grand, Symphony

[-]

ETxRut@reddit

Zero.

[-]

LovingComrade@reddit

Zero bar

[-]

Flooffighter416@reddit

Crispy crunch. Just perfection.

[-]

FunctionalRazzmatazz@reddit

Milky Way Dark. It made regular Milky Way not matter.

[-]

Companyman118@reddit

Abba Zabba, you my only friend…

[-]

NicklovesHer@reddit

Charleston chew

[-]

princesspur@reddit

Marathon bar.

[-]

BigGirlPlanties@reddit

Chic o stick!

[-]

chunkerton_chunksley@reddit

Mr Goodbar

[-]

Frdmgir7@reddit

A frozen zero bar at the pool.

[-]

soopirV@reddit

Scrolled pretty far and didn’t see my fav, the Zero bar.

[-]

playdontpreach@reddit

Charleston chew

[-]

-Banana_Pancakes-@reddit

Butterfingers in the 90s were the best.

[-]

PM_ME_UR_PIKACHU@reddit

Fifth avenue

[-]

slyfox2884@reddit

Clark bar. Better than a butterfinger amd I don't think they make them anymore

[-]

RecruitingLove@reddit

Aussie Bear chocolates! Maybe I'm the only one who liked them 😂 I think now there is a similar candy called Caramellos, but they aren't the same as the ones from the 80s.

[-]

tinykitty78@reddit

P.B.Maxx

[-]

Throw-away17465@reddit

IYKYK

[-]

Just-Try-2533@reddit

Any other midwesterners here who love the old Twin Bing?

[-]

tatumnolita@reddit

Cadbury Flake

[-]

hombre_bu@reddit

Mr. Big Shaq’s Snaqs!!!

[-]

InfiniteOxfordComma@reddit

Hundred Grand.

[-]

slothbuddy@reddit

No love for Mounds I see

[-]

jonnovich@reddit

100 Grand. It was almost impossible to find until assortment bags came out for Halloween. Amazingly good candy bar, but never seemed to be a big seller for some reason.

[-]

BossSandwich69@reddit

Baby Ruth - Jokes aside of it being the “poo” candy, it’s a damn fine candy bar! Wish it was more readily available. I love a 3 Musketeers but as an adult now, Baby Ruth hits better than a Snickers

[-]

thundrbud@reddit

10/10 I always choose a Baby Ruth over a Snickers, it's chewier AND crunchier. Top tier candy bar in my opinion

[-]

Rocketsloth@reddit

1) Whatchamacalit

2) 100 Grand Bar

3) Choco-Bliss

4) (not a candy bar) M&M's pretzel M&Ms

[-]

Big_Surround3395@reddit

Oh Henry. I miss it so much. I know you can get it in canada.

[-]

Ok_Difficulty6452@reddit

Chunky is so good. And Payday

[-]

Alternative-Draft392@reddit

Skor

[-]

Away-Conference3584@reddit

Bounty

[-]

CaptainJeff@reddit

100 Grand. Hands down.

[-]

ProtectionFromStupid@reddit

Skor is really under appreciated for what it is. Might be too hard for some, but I love that crunch

[-]

thatquinnchick@reddit

Not technically a candy bar, but I feel like Chick-O-Sticks never got enough love. I was so elated when I realized my neighborhood bodega still sold them.

[-]

remedialhandwriting@reddit

Chunky!

[-]

meltfellow@reddit

nutrageous

[-]

misterlakatos@reddit

Hershey's Fifth Avenue is the perfect road trip boost. I have done this twice on road trips across incredibly boring stretches of the U.S.

I have not eaten that candy bar in years, but it's the perfect size/proportion and flavor for something quick to eat while driving.

[-]

Rhizobactin@reddit

Yeah, like how 5th Avenue street signs in cities would be designed differently to look like a 5th avenue bar?

[-]

ringobob@reddit

Honestly, my go to from back then has already been mentioned (Whatchamacallit), but special mention to Uno Bars, which were a special treat since I only got them because my grandparents sent them to me, they didn't sell them where we lived.

[-]

Rpd840@reddit

Fifth Avenue bar

[-]

mtron32@reddit

Oh Henry

[-]

blownout2657@reddit

100 grand

[-]

MadcatFK1017@reddit

5th Avenue, way better than butterfinger!

[-]

funatical@reddit

I guess I’m the only one loving Paydays. They have a chocolate one now. That’s neat.

[-]

HighOnGoofballs@reddit

A frozen Skor bar

[-]

jeffreyrolek@reddit

[-]

Green_with_Zealously@reddit

The Summit Bar

[-]

86scirocco@reddit

Skor bar, served chilled.

[-]

Chemical-Flan-5700@reddit

Have you tried a frozen Charleston Chew?

[-]

iloveyourlittlehat@reddit

How do you have teeth?!

[-]

quickblur@reddit

gif

[-]

SubstantialFeed4102@reddit

Not a full bar.... But the lack of butterfinger bbs in this miniature world is WILD

[-]

glencoe606@reddit

Butterfinger

[-]

SubstantialFeed4102@reddit

Symphony toffee and take 5

[-]

Inc-Roid@reddit

Big Hunk and Chic-O-Stick

[-]

boone209@reddit

Dunno about Big Hunk one way or the other, but I came to make sure Chic-O-Stick made the list. Pretty sure it's more of a regional thing, but definitely was a thing in TX growing up

[-]

clumsystarfish_@reddit

Hershey's Take5

Wunderbar

[-]

BarleyBo@reddit

I haven’t seen a Chunky in years.

[-]

gesis@reddit

CVS stocks them at the counter. We used to have a guy come in and buy us out when I worked there.

[-]

BarleyBo@reddit

I actually get prescriptions from a CVS. I’ll have the check the counter next time I’m in there.

[-]

OldJames47@reddit

Clark Bar > 5th Avenue > Butterfinger

[-]

audiate@reddit

Heath bar. I did not discover this glory until I was an adult.

[-]

jenniferlee562@reddit

Reese's crunchy cookie cups

[-]

Flight_Not_Fancy@reddit

100 Grand

[-]

BushStrokerKushSmkr@reddit

Chocolate Charleston Chews

[-]

mlo9109@reddit

I'd do some questionable things for a Coffee Crisp.

[-]

blacktrufflesheep@reddit

I don't know your location but they have those in the UK foods section at my local Stop n Shop in the US. Yes, I know they're from Canada. I guess they didn't know where else to put them.

[-]

Eikthyrnir13@reddit

100 Grand

[-]

namesmakemenervous@reddit

The original Butterfingers.. they changed the recipe and it sucks now. It used to be crumbly and flaky, now it’s hard and brittle.

[-]

Dry_Inspection_4583@reddit

Pep

[-]

DaughterofJan@reddit

All these Americans with their candy bars no one else knows.

Not bars, cause I want that into them, but we had candies called "meeuwenflatsen" (seagull splatters) and "mierenzeikers" (antpissers). They were GOOD.

[-]

crazyharold@reddit

I’m upvoting this just for the wonderful names. Dutch?

[-]

DaughterofJan@reddit

A quick search reveals that we also had hondenscheten (dog farts) koeienvlaaien (cow pats) and vieze luiers (dirty nappies/diapers).

[-]

DaughterofJan@reddit

Yup! There were a couple of other equally naughty names for other candies in the series, but these were not as good IMO, so I don't remember those

[-]

windupshoe2020@reddit

Caramello

[-]

neoistheone79@reddit

100 Grand. Caramel and crunch, can’t beat it.

[-]

cargobroombroom@reddit

5th avenue

[-]

KinderEggLaunderer@reddit

Hands down salted nut roll. I always want more peanuts, and snickers ain't doing it.

[-]

DisgruntledTexan@reddit

100 Grand

[-]

cbatta2025@reddit

Bar None and Summit.

[-]

AttemptVegetable@reddit

Krackel was superior to nestle crunch but never got the shine until Halloween

[-]

4163101@reddit

I think it was just a cdn thing, but Choclairs was my go to

[-]

Psycosteve10mm@reddit

Zero candy bar. White chocolate, caramel, and almond nougat.

[-]

pop5656@reddit

Heath bar.

[-]

lorazepamproblems@reddit

Rocky Road was my favorite

[-]

motorevoked@reddit

Crunch in the foil wrapper

[-]

More-read-than-eddit@reddit

If someone can say Rolo I can say Chuckles

[-]

SnowboardSyd@reddit

Either Nut Rolls or Caramellos.

[-]

JonasSharra@reddit

Kracle

[-]

No-Hospital559@reddit

Coffee Crunch (Canadian) I don't understand why it's not available in the US.

[-]

senator_fatass@reddit

I was a big fan of nutrageous!

[-]

holymole1234@reddit

Peanut butter Twix!

Runner up: Clark bars

[-]

LunaSea1206@reddit

Coffee Crisp. I don't know if it was my proximity to Canada living in Northern Washington, but it was one of my favorite candy bars growing up. As I got older, I could only find it during trips to Canada. On my most recent visit to Washington, I found it sold in an Asian grocery store (I bought six of them) and found it in a small toy shop in Coupeville on Whidbey Island. It's still as good as I remember. I really wish it was still sold in the US, but for some reason it never took off here.

[-]

Solintari@reddit

Going to have to go with chic-o-stix. None of my friends liked them for some reason.

[-]

Moonbase0@reddit

5th Avenue

[-]

BlinkMCstrobo@reddit

Koetjesreep

[-]

crazyharold@reddit

I can’t find Peanut Butter Twix anywhere anymore but I loved those.

[-]

ovenmit_@reddit

Youth includes our early 20s, right? RIGHT?

If so, then the original Peanut Butter Twix. Not the reformulated crap they made before discontinuing the line. The OG Twix bar with PB instead of caramel. I could eat a box of them. I miss you, PB Twix.

[-]

analyticalscience11@reddit

Mr. Goodbar.

[-]

lrsdranger@reddit

5th Avenue

[-]

ButterscotchAware402@reddit

Whatchamacallit. Now I need to run to the gas station for a treat...

[-]

EastTXJosh@reddit

Payday doesn’t have never received the love it deserves.

[-]

867-53-oh-nein@reddit

100grand

[-]

Forward_Damage4779@reddit

100 grand

[-]

a-ha_partridge@reddit

Salted Nut Roll. Bottom shelf merchandising, top shelf taste.

[-]

aybiss@reddit

Milo Bar

[-]

gingersrule77@reddit

Score bar

[-]

RegularAd9418@reddit

Charleston Chew. Loved freezing these bad boys.

Also Kudos.

[-]

TheWorldsOnlyHope@reddit

Charleston Chew. The vanilla kind

[-]

_deep_thot42@reddit

ABBA Zabbas are still my favourite (same as my grandma)! Also LOOK bars, mmmmm

[-]

CrypticTurbellarian@reddit

Chocolate Fudge Twix! Honorable mention to Cookies ‘n’ Cream Twix, and yes, I know they brought them back, but they’re not the same.

[-]

Acceptable_Class_576@reddit

5th Avenue and Whatchamacallit

[-]

RachelPalmer79@reddit

Skore

[-]

TransportationOk657@reddit

Can't say whether it's underrated or not (don't really pay attention to the popularity of candy bars), but I've always loved the blue Symphony bar with toffee chips.

[-]

LVDan01@reddit

PB Maxx

[-]

KevinStoley@reddit

PB Max

I don't know if I'd call it underrated though. They definitely seem to have been popular and I often see others mention them with nostalgia.

The reason they were discontinued is incredibly stupid. Supposedly the family who owns the parent company (Mars, I think?) were not fans of peanut butter. Despite PB Max being quite profitable, they had it discontinued.

To this day I can still sort of remember the taste in my head. They were so delicious, I swear they used actual, real peanut butter that was so delicious and creamy inside. I miss these so much even like 30 years later.

[-]