Lower decks is such a sad and rich episode
Posted by julyvale@reddit | TNG | View on Reddit | 31 comments
Not only it expands the universe aboard the Enterprise - by showing casual crew that doesn't know everything like the main characters - it also brings up the story from the First Duty episode and its implications years later. I also like how the episode portraits Picard in a different (mean) light towards Sito Jaxa at first, only to give an explanation on it later through a moral outcome and pretty depressing ending. The performance by both Steward and Fill were fantastic. The speech by Picard at the end, where he omits completely the grave mistakes Jaxa did in the First Duty, and focuses only on the character and bravery, was also a nice touch. And finally, I love the very last scene with Worf sitting down as the episode ends without needing to say an additional word.
TheMightyTywin@reddit
Picard totally manipulated Sito into volunteering for that mission
Brilliant-Deer6118@reddit
Kind of his job, really. Who else could he get to do it?
Soft_Caterpillar5845@reddit
I agree completely with you but I suppose it wouldn’t have been hard for Dr to put nose wrinkles on someone from security.
Durosity@reddit
True, but what if they’d been captured and they did tests on random security officer only to find they were human? Coulda resulted in war. Unfortunately Picard had the tough job of sending her into a very dangerous knowing full well she could be killed, and that’s why he’s the captain.. gotta make those hard decisions sometimes.
Now, let’s return to Deanna ordering Geordie to his death.. just for s**ts and giggles.
ArcherNX1701@reddit
Yep, a tough job ordering someone on a suici*e mission. For the good of the Federation.....
MzOwl27@reddit
I'm pretty sure Sito was a security officer.
Soft_Caterpillar5845@reddit
Oh, yeah. Good point. Then I don’t see the problem here. Picard had a difficult assignment, and he assigned it. I don’t think he was being manipulative.
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
LOL, nose wrinkles.
Brilliant-Deer6118@reddit
Fair point.
Tebwolf359@reddit
Yes, but like Sisko and in the pale moonlight, it’s not without reason.
AND, importantly, Picard’s manipulation is also true. She did mess up, horribly. Many people would gladly take her deal to make up for her mistake.
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
Good point. She had fucked up good and proper, but I'm not so sure it warranted her life with some unknown spoonhead.
WolverineComplex@reddit
Yes it’s incredibly problematic and disturbing.
MythBusterNut@reddit
And then they’re never seen again
Durosity@reddit
Well we saw Alyssa a fair few times both before and after.. and they did consider reviving Sito for the DS9 episode “Hard Time” but decided against it and made it Miles O’Brien instead.. but yeah it woulda been nice if we’d seen one of the others in other episodes.
Boomerang503@reddit
Sito did have an appearance in Star Trek: Lower Decks.
Durosity@reddit
Yeah, I loved that cameo. And frankly as much as I know some people didn’t like that Mariner / Nova Squad connection, I thought it was great and explained why she’d always been so.. delinquent.
Voidstarmaster@reddit
One of my favorite episodes. And Bajoran security girl was cute AF.
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
Sito is the cutest.
MunitionGuyMike@reddit
Was*
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
Too soon.
MunitionGuyMike@reddit
As southpark stated: “it’s funny if it’s been 22 and 1/4 years”
BurdenedMind79@reddit
Oh my god, they killed Sito!
repo_code@reddit
"Defend Yourself!"
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
Doen't Gik'Tal mean to the death?
Fonceday2001@reddit
You speak Klingon...
moktira@reddit
Probably my favourite episode, but really sad ending alright.
161frog@reddit
My mouth dropped open when they made the announcement that [spoiler redacted] was killed
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
It's been thirty years, I think we're spoiler safe.
Ralph--Hinkley@reddit
One of my favorites, and it's because of Sito and her sacrifice.
EepyBoops@reddit
Probably the only episode that makes you *really* care for a character that meets such a tragic end after such a short screen-time. Absolutely a heartpunch
allgoodthings3@reddit
Absolutely one of my favorite episodes.