Making a forum that has no politics, mods, heavy manual verfication + invite only, and no algorithm. Literally just a sleek UI with posts and real people.
Posted by Affectionate_Pear977@reddit | RedditAlternatives | View on Reddit | 31 comments
Been on Reddit for a while. I also happen to be a developer. So, I decided, why not. I built a really sleek, simple forum that doesn't have all the bs. Not trying to self promo, the forum's free to join.
These are the things I was tired of and made a point not to incorporate:
Mods on power trips,
Seeing content I never asked for,
Karma-driven junk,
Bots
I have no algo, heavy manual verification that requires a public profile + reason to join, all verified manually. No point system. It's not foolproof, but it's a start. I don't want huge traffic, just a focus on quality with a few people rather than mass.
I added minimal features on purpose to give space for additional stuff that are community guided.
I made the skeleton of the website, you can see attached screenshot of the feed page. Forum's going to be focused on one specific community, just not sure which one, I'm searching my fav subreddits.
Let me hear thoughts, would be cool if someone told me what's missing and helped me make this better for people.
polymath_uk@reddit
For about the first 25 years of the internet, everyone used phpbb or one of the other bb freeware programs to implement forums. What you're describing could be set up in 15 minutes with LAMP and unzip.
The problem isn't the lack of a platform, it's that nobody will use it.
ravenfreak@reddit
There's still plenty of people who use those traditional threaded forums and I'm one of them. They not only look better than Reddit and Reddit alternatives they're much more organized.
dandylover1@reddit
Where can I find said forums? I am totally blind and I appreciate simple, clean, text-based layouts.
ravenfreak@reddit
Forum Promotion dot net, many people have promoted their forums over there including me. I'm staff on the forum too! There are other communities that are promoted on FP that also allows promotion. Happy hunting!
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
I agree with you, but what I wanted was a forum that is highly customizable to the community. Basically a website formed around the community's personality. I'm not familiar with LAMP and unzip, but do they offer customizability on par with building a website manually through code?
rgvtim@reddit
Not familiar with LAMP and unzip?
Manlor@reddit
Sounds like a vibe coder
Inside_Jolly@reddit
gemini://bbs.geminispace.org/
Doesn't ban politics but people who care about politics don't use Gemini.
The only strict moderation it needs is Gemini itself. No HTTP => No scale => No bots.
Here's a nice Gemini browser: https://gmi.skyjake.fi/lagrange/
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
I didn't know Gemini channels existed before your comment, I appreciate you informing me about them
Inside_Jolly@reddit
What channels? The word "channel" is mentioned 0 times in the latest protocol spec: https://geminiprotocol.net/docs/protocol-specification.gmi
Inside_Jolly@reddit
5 downvotes. Can anyone explain wtf am I missing?
UnflinchingSugartits@reddit
Make an dedicated mobile Android app please.
ocelotsporn@reddit
Tech is not the hard part of this equation. If you have aspirations of getting the public to use your solution over existing platforms marketing is your problem.
IMO build this for yourself and your community of friends / close contacts. Building something for strangers on the internet is a sure fire way to spend a lot of time building nothing
hastogord1@reddit
Interesting.
You can announce this on our website.
https://www.letit.net/
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
Love what you guys are building!
hastogord1@reddit
Thanks and hope the best.
We are reaching 700 registered and we will improve on.
Mobile app is on the plan.
Bortcorns4Jeezus@reddit
You can just make a Lemmy instance 🤷🏻♀️
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
True, but not high customizability. I built this from ground up and I can add features, sky's the limit
Pamasich@reddit
I don't like Lemmy either, but this is the wrong argument. Lemmy is opensource, you can literally just edit the code and add whatever features you want. Or remove them, like support for bots.
There ARE some problems I can see you having with Lemmy, like how the federated nature means you can't really prevent profile stalking. But I don't see how customization is an actual problem when coding is in the picture.
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
I do agree, it's personal preference really because Lemmy's codebase is different than what I'm used to. For a small community, I just thought I'd go with the stack I'm used to so I can quickly iterate features based on member thoughts.
Bortcorns4Jeezus@reddit
It has literally all the features in your checklist... But I guess you can re-invent the wheel instead
Pamasich@reddit
This is either a lie, or you took their avoid list as a need-to-have list.
Considering OP's requirements are that all of those DONT exist, it's wrong to say that Lemmy fulfills all of OP's requirements.
Bortcorns4Jeezus@reddit
Oh my bad, I missed the"no stalkingc bullet point.
But.. I think you can defederate and just isolate the instance and then customize it how you want
Pamasich@reddit
Oh yeah, I guess you CAN take the truthsocial approach of just defederating from everyone. Forgot about that.
Bortcorns4Jeezus@reddit
Defederated instances are great. I belong to several
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
Yea, but I wanted to add other features later on that some other users said would be great on the forum. Like just for the community. A website that is built around the community within, and constantly changing
raju_sohi@reddit
Have a look at https://AnonX.org. it checks almost everything you mentioned.
Inaeipathy@reddit
Dead on arrival without a hyperspecific niche with rich participants.
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
Yea that's the intention. Want to start off with 20 ppl who care abt a topic
Inaeipathy@reddit
Why make a website for it then? Might as well just make a private discord/matrix server or something.
Affectionate_Pear977@reddit (OP)
Well, I actually want to make a bunch of forums. Like each for a niche group. I'm part of niche subreddits that are overflowed with memes. So I want to make forums, and then tailor each one to the community within, feature wise. Discord won't offer much flexibility other than bots.
Also I just wanted to build something lol