Reddit and internet changes
Posted by SchemeSilly3226@reddit | RedditAlternatives | View on Reddit | 10 comments
I’m sorry, I don’t know your community that well, but I was banned off of r/futurology for this post.
I’m going to say what we all know.
Reddit has undergone a shift, and the presence of bots/AI-generated content, propaganda, and coordinated campaigns is a documented reality.
- Bots & AI Are Proliferating on Reddit
- Automated Accounts: Tools like ChatGPT make it trivial to generate human-like comments/posts at scale. Farms deploy these to farm karma, sway discussions, or spam.
- Karma Farms: Bots repost popular old content/comments to gain karma, then get sold for propaganda or advertising.
-
Detection Difficulty: Reddit’s anti-bot systems struggle to keep up, and AI can now mimic writing styles flawlessly.
-
Astroturfing & Propaganda Are Common.
- Corporate/PR Influence: Companies use bots or paid accounts to promote products, downplay scandals, or attack critics (e.g., gaming, tech, or finance subs).
- Political Manipulation: State actors (Russia, China, Iran, etc.) and domestic groups manipulate narratives on news/political subs. The "news" you see may be amplified or distorted.
-
Agenda-Driven Subreddits: Entire communities are sometimes covertly run by ideological/political groups to push narratives.
-
Reddit is Less "Human"
- Algorithmic Incentives: Reddit rewards engagement (upvotes, controversy). Bots/farms exploit this, drowning out organic discussion.
- Decline of "Old Reddit" Culture: As Reddit commercialized (IPO, API changes), authentic communities shrank. Heavy users remained, leaving voids bots fill.
-
News Aggregation Risks: Reddit is now a top news source, but unvetted. Bots can spread misinformation rapidly via upvote manipulation.
-
How to Spot Suspicious Activity
- Account Red Flags:
> Generic usernames (e.g., "Word_Number123").
> Sudden activity bursts after months of silence.
> Overly polished, emotionless, or repetitive language. - Post Patterns:
> Rapid, identical comments across threads.
> Posts pushing niche agendas (e.g., crypto, supplements, fringe politics).
> "Outrage bait" designed to provoke engagement. -
Subreddit Anomalies: > Sudden shifts in moderation or topic focus.
> Highly polarized discussions with lack of fact checking. -
Protecting Your Trust
- Cross-Check Sources: Treat Reddit "news" as a lead, not truth. Verify via established outlets (AP, Reuters).
- Stick to Niche Communities: Smaller, topic-specific subs (e.g., hobbies, academics) have fewer bots.
- Use Tools: Browser extensions like "Reddit Investigator" or "Bot Sentinel" analyze account behavior.
- Question Consensus: If a thread feels unnaturally polarized or amplified, disengage.
Bottom Line:
Reddit is no longer a purely organic space. While genuine human interaction still exists (especially in smaller communities), the platform is saturated with manipulation. This doesn’t mean "all Reddit is bots," but it does mean healthy skepticism is essential. Trust should be earned through consistent, transparent behavior—not assigned by default.
Stay critical, don’t give out trust, and prioritize subs with active, transparent moderation. The degradation here reflects a broader internet crisis—awareness is the first defense.
Admission: I did use a language model (AI) to collect and format this information. That doesn’t change that it took personal effort, thought, and intention to make this post. and it definitely doesn’t change my message.
pipopipopipop@reddit
Mate, not only is this AI, you have one of the generic bot names you're warning people against lol. This is everything that's making reddit bad. I don't want to read an AI encyclopedia entry, just write some words.
SchemeSilly3226@reddit (OP)
Why are people trying to avoid talking about change? like it or not it’s happening. I’m at least a real person, but there are bot farms across the globe tucked out of sight by our corporate overlords
pipopipopipop@reddit
You're part of the change, you're contributing to what is making me open Lemmy more and more instead of reddit. I don't want to read the result of an AI prompt. It's boring. I want interesting discussion with real people. I hate what this website has become.
SchemeSilly3226@reddit (OP)
Valid points. Coming to this sub has made me realize there are some other options out there, and if I check them out I would honor their rules/ideals.
But I want to encourage open mindedness with AI. Sure it’s impossible to know if you’re talking to a real person, but it’s not all or nothing. Talking to a language model doesn’t suddenly make you a freak. You can engage in a chat with ai like you would engage in a chat with a coworker.
Adapt to the change but don’t diminish it. View AI like a time traveler would view the internet in its early days.
pipopipopipop@reddit
No, I value, very highly, human interaction. If I just wanted to chat to AI I could open ChatGPT and get the same result. Reddit is redundant if that's all it becomes.
SchemeSilly3226@reddit (OP)
Real. I’m 20 and I have never really had much genuine interaction on the web. I know it’s out there though, do you have any suggestions?
pipopipopipop@reddit
Oh man, this makes me sad to hear! When I first joined reddit about 15 or so years ago it was just people. No bots, no ads, definitely no AI. Just people chatting to each other about real things, and so many people too. This website feels empty now compared to what it was like then.
I've found Lemmy is much less busy but has very genuine interactions with real (and nice) people. I've been wondering about looking into forums again, which is how we all used to chat about stuff before reddit/social media was a thing.
ImUrFrand@reddit
Reddit admin's moderation is also automated.
i just got an account "warning" from automation that completely misinterpreted the comment i made on a jump scare video.
DxT_01@reddit
Literally the reason for the creation of Chime.In
We're really hoping to make a change to this ai-driven route that all of these platforms seem to be heading towards
rimu@reddit
In the end, if the interests and priorities of the site owners do not align with ours (spoiler: they do not), then you're swimming upstream. The end result is not going to go your way.
Just leave. PieFed and Lemmy are right there and have our best interests in mind.