What are the top creative writing models ?
Posted by TheArchivist314@reddit | LocalLLaMA | View on Reddit | 18 comments
Hello everyone I wanted to know what are the top models that are good at creative writing. I'm looking for ones I can run on my card. I've got a 4070. It has 12GB of Vram. I've got 64GB of normal ram.
Iory1998@reddit
I still prefer the output of Mixtral and Mistral models. I use them as editor to help write. I don't know why, but their output style is just unique.
celsowm@reddit
https://eqbench.com/creative_writing.html
silenceimpaired@reddit
Does that match your experience? Isn’t this judged by AI? I read a paper recently that challenged their ability to judge fairly.
TheRealMasonMac@reddit
There is no good data corpus for evaluating literary work across clearly specified dimensions. Therefore, the models will reflect the extremes biases and lack of nuance evident in existing human ratings:
(Figure is a plot of the distribution of average ratings for \~10,000-20,000 most read works on GoodReads.)
stoppableDissolution@reddit
People are even worse at judging creative anything tho. It would require a lot of opinions to gather something resembling objectivity, while somehow avoiding fatr of lmarena.
harlekinrains@reddit
People are even worse at clicking through 2 links deep to read the actual samples provided.
Why would you, when you can ask unpaid randoms on the internet?
jacek2023@reddit
I don't know what happened but this list is now very limited, previously it had all the finetunes
terminoid_@reddit
it's expensive to run them. kick him down some cash =)
Reader3123@reddit
Wish that included the finetunes
Background-Ad-5398@reddit
darkest muse, Ifable and probably some finetune of gemma 3 12b, for your vram size
Chasmchas@reddit
What kind of creative writing? Are you looking for short and snappy Instagram marketing headlines? Your best bet is likely a fine-tuned Llama 4 model. Are you looking for long-form conversational content? Your best bet may be Deepseek.
TheArchivist314@reddit (OP)
I wanted to act like an editor for the stories I'm writing so I can write then I feeded the story it looks through the story part I'm giving it looks over the grammar punctuation and stuff like that and then it rates it and tells me where I can improve and it gives me some examples or if I ask it to help me figure out a name for a character or spitball ideas with it for a background and things like that
tengo_harambe@reddit
If you have a VRAM constraint you should put it into the headline... most people don't read beyond that. with 12GB your options are very limited, best bet is probably Mistral Nemo.
CitizUnReal@reddit
you might wanna try this one as well:
Psy-Cet-Mytho-ED3-Prose-Crazy-Ultra-Quality-D_AU-29B-ALPHA-IQ4_XS-imat13
it's an old model, but it checks out ;)
TheArchivist314@reddit (OP)
Thats way to large for me to run lol.
AppearanceHeavy6724@reddit
This question keep get asked every week, and the answer is more or less same - Gemma 3, GLM-4, Mistral Nemo, Gemma 2.
ttkciar@reddit
I've had best results from Gemma3-27B, but that's too large to fit in your VRAM. Perhaps you should try Gemma3-12B, but I can't speak from experience about that.
c--b@reddit
I don't do creative writing, but I have noticed that both 4b and 12b are quite associative and creative.