What was the best steak you ever had?
Posted by stevie855@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 461 comments
The U.S. has some legendary steakhouses, like Keens and Peter Luger in New York, etc.
Bonus points if you mention the wine that accompanied your steak!
Where was y’all’s best steakhouse experience?
XtraChrisP@reddit
Rib eye or porterhouse prepared at home by me.
beebeesy@reddit
We had this old raggedy cook at our small town country club when I was a kid that was 10000% hated by the health department but BOY he could grill the best 2.5in filet mignon to absolutely perfection. Aside from that, I do not order steak out. I can season, marinate, and grill a better steak at home 99.9% of the time for a fraction of the price. My dad and all his friends spoiled me. If my future husband can't grill, we gonna have an issue.
Artlawprod@reddit
The best steak I ever had was here:
https://riverpalm.com/our-menus/
I went with my Grandpa for his birthday. I live in NYC. Literally the day before I had been here for a steak I had been taken on an expensive business dinner here:
https://www.smithandwollenskynyc.com/
I have also eaten at Keens and Peter Lugers.
The steak at the River Palm was truly one of the best things I have ever eaten.
OhThrowed@reddit
Best steak I ever had wasn't at any steakhouse. It was at home, on a grill, from an ornery cow we butchered the day before. Steak, seasoned with spite.
codefyre@reddit
Same, and honestly, it's why I can't eat steak in restaraunts. My wife was formerly a chef and is friends with the owners of a local carniceria. They have a small text group they notify whenever they get some particularly special beef or other interesting meats. So when I have steak, it's at home, prepared by a CIA trained pro-chef, using meat hand picked by a professional master butcher who actually gives a damn about her opinion.
I had steak at the French Laundry once. I liked my wife's better, because it was genuinely a better steak (no shade to Thomas Keller, who is a phenomenal chef.)
BigBlueMountainStar@reddit
We really struggle to make a decent steak at home, we’ve tried all kinds of methods but we just can’t get them as good as a decent professionally cooked one!!!
Chime57@reddit
Get a sous vide. Seal your steak in a bag with very little seasoning, pop it in the 137 degree water tub, and when you're ready to eat anytime after a couple hours to later tonight, sear it off. Medium rare every time.
Adjust the sous vide to your desired temp for rare or well done, whatever you want. A lot of restaurants use them.
Faceornotface@reddit
I find the reverse sear to be the most effective method but only if you have cast iron or a blow torch
Foreign_Plate_4372@reddit
So cow now tell us about your contacts in the bovine resistance and we let you go free or face "the butcher"
goodcleanchristianfu@reddit
CIA trained pro-chef
Anyone not familiar with the fact that we have two CIA's is picturing this: a small room, lit by a single dangling overhead lamp whose light doesn't reach the corners. A terrified looking cow is strapped to a chair, tilted back precariously. A damp towel covers its mouth and snout. Over it stands a woman, pouring water from a pitcher onto the towel, screaming "Where are your most tender cuts!? Where is the best marbling?!"
codefyre@reddit
I showed that to my wife about five minutes ago. She still hasn't stopped laughing. Well done!
Well, not well done. That's an affront to a good steak.
For what it's worth, my wife also found it hilarious that I was talking all this foodie awesomeness and still managed to misspell the word "restaurant".
chongrulz@reddit
I would say a joke of this quality is rare indeed.
upthedips@reddit
I am sure your wife's steak is better than mine, but honestly anyone can learn to cook a steak better than a steakhouse. Find a butcher, buy a high quality steak and learn to cook it properly. Cooking a good steak well is really not difficult. I like to buy a thick prime ribeye, salt and pepper, and reverse sear it. Way better than any steakhouse I have ever had.
Trigger109@reddit
Once I learned to get my steaks at or near room temp before cooking, rather than right out of the fridge, it changed my life.
davidm2232@reddit
Very true. But on the flipside, I have done steaks from frozen in the air fryer that actually come out very good. Not as good as something fresh but more than acceptable.
SteelRail88@reddit
Best way to get the inside of a steak up to 125 without overcooking it is to start out at 75.
The_Saddest_Boner@reddit
How do you feel about dry aged steak? Because I really enjoy it, and it’s the only reason I’ll splurge at a steakhouse every year.
Other than that, if you can find a usda prime from a local butcher the home cast iron usually does as well as a steakhouse imho. I’ve never butchered a cow though lol
peesteam@reddit
They have some dry age bags on Amazon check them out. You can get close with diy.
SpatchcockZucchini@reddit
Onrey steers make the best steaks haha
velociraptorfarmer@reddit
Same. 16oz prime ribeye that I got as a gift that I dry brined and threw on my charcoal grill, then ate alongside a glass of rye.
gsxr@reddit
The pleasure of eating that cow that tried to kill you at least once a week, but you had to keep because she dropped good calfs, is something everyone needs to experience. Sounds wrong but it’s a different thing.
Jesuswasstapled@reddit
If you took my babies away I'd try to murder you also.
Particular_Night_360@reddit
Never had that, but did meet the pissed off goat before it got castrated. Then ate its balls. Shockingly good.
Bender_2024@reddit
Same here. I went to a pretty expensive local steakhouse. The owners have about a dozen upscale restaurants so they know what they are doing. I got a dry aged ribeye and frankly while it was cooked properly I wasn't impressed. I could do the same at home with a reverse sear on a steak from the local butcher or grocery store.
somecow@reddit
Ouch.
hajimoto74@reddit
Didn't age the beef at all?
tepid_fuzz@reddit
I can 1000% relate to this.
Reddittrip@reddit
Agreed.
However, what I can’t replicate are some of the great side dishes.
So an occasional steak house is still a treat.
Lacylanexoxo@reddit
That’s the only way to do it.
melston9380@reddit
I came here to say something like this: When I was younger I helped a friend wrap meat from a cow her family butchered. That afternoon, her mom grilled rib eyes. I'm not certain it was from the same cow, but I've never had such a glorious steak experience since.
calidrew@reddit
Mastro's Ocean Club, Newport Beach CA - Medium rare ribeye paired with a 2016 Villa Antinori
There was Le Relais de l’Entrecôte open in West Hollywood for a minute and I loved that whole experience. Highly recommend it if you get a chance.
cocaine_jaguar@reddit
Freight house in Hartselle AL. I forget the exact seasoning by in was a sirloin cooked to perfection. Had an old fashioned instead of wine with it. Best steak I’ve had in all my travels.
Little-Plane-4213@reddit
A Cajun ribeye from Pacific beach Ale house
koleton_@reddit
No steakhouse can make a steak to my liking better than I can
IAmMey@reddit
Steak raised by a friend, butchered by another friend, seasoned by me, cooked by my wife in a caste iron skillet. 10/10 $7
Steak from idk, cooked in a local steakhouse, served with atmosphere and beer on tap. 8/10 $80 for just my food.
Rather have steak cooked at home than any steakhouse. They’re good usually. But doesn’t even compare.
Malt_and_Salt@reddit
Restaurant wise, NY Strip at The Tornado Room in Madison, WI. That place hits every time. Old school relish tray to start with a Brandy Old Fashioned, then steak and potatoes with a glass of rye whiskey, then a pink squirrel or grasshopper for an after dinner dessert drink. Yes I am a Wisconsinite and I love a good supper club experience
Yeah_Mr_Jesus@reddit
I went to Crescent City Steakhouse in New Orleans. Got a ribeye. It was cooked perfectly medium (I know everyone like medium rare, but I just really prefer it cooked medium, sue me). Their au gratan potatoes and creamed spinach and onion rings were the perfect sides. And then for dessert my wife and I shared their Z Pie (an oreo crust with ice cream and caramel and chocolate) and home made cheesecake. It's named Z Pie after the original owners youngest daughter and now that her older brother is the owner, he decided to keep it.
Maybe my perception of the meal is skewed because it was the day after my wife and I got married? Idk, but it really very very good. They definitely stepped their game up from when I worked there in high school. I ate many steaks from there when I worked there lol. They were never bad by any stretch of the imagination, but the meal I had there that I described in the previous paragraph was just S tier.
Neither of us drank any wine or beer or cocktails. We aren't drinkers 🤷🏻♂️. Although, since I used to work there over 20 years ago when I was in high school, I know they have a pretty big selection of wine. Matter of fact, I even got fucking trapped in the wine cellar one day when I was helping out the waiter by grabbing a bottle of wine for him. The door handle broke off and I was trapped in there for like 15 or 20 minutes. This was before cell phones so little 16 year old me is just trapped in this dim ass room knocking and saying "HELP" over and over. The next time someone came to get wine they found me lol
investinlove@reddit
A7 Wagyu at Bacara Resort in Santa Barbara, Angel Oak restaurant.
I was doing a review for Somm Journal, so also got comped. (I still tipped.)
It had all the best aspects of a perfect steak and the umami of seared foie gras.
PossibleJazzlike2804@reddit
At some bar in Newport Oregon.
martlet1@reddit
I soaked two vines in Italian. Dressing overnight. Salt and pepper. Threw it on the grill. After getting the grill marks I dumped garlic butter on top.
I still think about it to this day.
BanalCausality@reddit
Best steak ever? At home, grilled by my dad.
Best steak in a restaurant? A steakhouse in Coahuila, Mexico.
drpuck2@reddit
Bob's Steak and Chop House Ft. Worth TX. Tomahawk ribeye. Spectacular! Sides were magnificent as well. Sorry, not a wine drinker.
HoneyWyne@reddit
Ruth's Chris in Minneapolis. I literally dream about it sometimes. The sides are meh, the desserts are great, but the filet with the Bleu cheese crust is insane. I don't drink wine though, sorry!
mstrong73@reddit
I’ve had the opportunity to eat at great steakhouses all over the US for work so I’ve had many great steaks. I’ve made some Santa Maria style tri tip at home that is the most memorable. Just the perfect crust on the outside from a slow cook on the smoker with a great sear over an open flame. I think about it often.
Particular_Tone5338@reddit
My favorites were a nice Wagyu in Tokyo, and a sirloin in Dublin.
However, to answer your question - Fleming’s in Lincolnshire had a a melt in your mouth (I think I used a butter knife) fillet & my spouse had a Tomahawk that they still rave about. It’s been more than 5 years & we still haven’t found a lamb chop that was as memorable as theirs.
I do not remember any wine’s I had with it.
Savingskitty@reddit
Prime Rib on the bay in Green Bay 30 years ago or so. Not sure the place still exists.
osteologation@reddit
A speakeasy a couple away. It was when I was a teenager probably early 90s.
Vegetable-Star-5833@reddit
Steak is nasty
Purple-Mud5057@reddit
Don’t even recall the name of the place, but as a teenager my dad took me to this really fancy, really small steakhouse just a few blocks off the strip in Vegas. Got me a ribeye that was like $120 which I thought was absolutely ridiculous until I had a bite. I don’t think a better steak is possible.
milehigh11@reddit
Best steak I had was in Iceland before I did a glacier hike
Big-Profit-1612@reddit
https://guide.michelin.com/us/en/california/san-francisco/restaurant/niku-steakhouse
Niku in San Francisco.
dexymidnightslowwalk@reddit
For me it was Sushi Samba in Las Vegas. Japanese Wagyu before it became a fad. It was served tartare with hot butter and a hot stone...fantabulous.
NewMexicoVaquero@reddit
Cattlemen’s Steakhouse in Fort Worth, TX. That Porterhouse was delicious. Texas knows how to do steak.
Comfortable-Study-69@reddit
Steakhouse? I keep it simple. Saltgrass new york strip steak cooked medium rare.
Best steak ever? This is very much to my particular taste preferences, but sous vide boneless shank steak covered in tony chachere’s with a worcester dipping sauce and ruby port.
Maednezz@reddit
Steak 38, although Top of the World and Ruth Chris are decent also
bae125@reddit
Craftsteak, Vegas.
Work trip, no reservation, walk in and happen to grab two seats at the bar.
Absurdly priced A5. Worth it.
ConsumingTranquility@reddit
A place called Fahrenheit 132, Fredericksburg VA
AccomplishedWar5830@reddit
Roots steakhouse in NJ, I remember it being dry aged. Looking at the menu now, I see they are calling it dry aged cowboy steak. It was amazing. Also their “slab of bacon” appetizer is amazing, and I’m not even a bacon person tbh. Other than that steak, I’m usually disappointed by steaks at restaurants. We are able to make them better at home for cheaper.
roughlyround@reddit
Hitching Post in Casmalia, CA
SpatchcockZucchini@reddit
Cattleman's in OKC!
elqueco14@reddit
There are great steakhouses but if you can cook a steak yourself you can save a LOT of money by just getting a nice cut to cook at home. Best steak I ever had I cooked myself on a shitty grill.
Overall-Tailor8949@reddit
It was at a place that I don't believe exists anymore. Bluebeards Castle in St. Thomas USVI. I didn't even need a steak knife to cut the steak it was so tender and tasty. Sorry, I don't remember the wine since this was over 40 years ago.
mothehoople@reddit
The Angus Resturant, Coffiville, Kansas
ALmommy1234@reddit
Hot and Hot Fish Club in Birmingham, Alabama, Highland Bar and Grill in Birmingham, Alabama, and The Grey in Savannah, Georgia (although that might have had something to do with the perfect icy Cosmopolitan I had a few of).😂
GhostGirl32@reddit
The Vig, downtown Phoenix, Arizona. (Fillmore).
I had the New York steak frites, and a Blackberry Smash from their cocktail menu which is Jameson, blackberry puree, lemon and mint, then the pie snob apple pie.
Typical_Breakfast215@reddit
I can think of at least 2 steaks within walking distance I'd prefer to the vig. Bacanora and the Roosevelt
GhostGirl32@reddit
I was there for literally one night to be fair. But it was fabulous— it’s the seasoning (for me) and that chimichurri sauce was 💯
Evapoman97@reddit
The filet at Ruth's Chris has never disappointed me, mashed potatoes were just right as well as the broccoli! I had a cup of coffee with dinner because I don't drink, and I don't drink because I used to DRINK!!
Ok_Dog_4059@reddit
I have never had a steak so good that it stuck in my mind. Basically I had forgotten about them before they ever made a turd.
_aelysar@reddit
I’ve been to a pretty good amount of high end steakhouses- Luger’s, Delmonicos, Burke’s, Jordan’s and more. They’re all pretty much the same as far as the steak goes. Or at least the difference between them is negligible. And to be honest— pretty much the same as I make. I’ve been cooking steaks for 30 years and once you get the skill down, a good, high-quality piece of meat, that you’ve seasoned and cooked correctly is sometimes better than what you’ll pay $200 for. I will also NEVER order a steak outside of a high-end joint, because even good restaurants’ steaks will be nowhere near as good as what I make.
One thing that really does stand out at a high end steakhouse, though is usually the sides and appetizers. I’ve had some amazing mashed potatoes and Mac and cheese at some of these places. Michael Jordan’s used to make this garlic bread that they’d cut into toast sticks and stack like a log cabin and serve with a melted Gorgonzola cream sauce that was amazing. They also had crispy Brussels sprouts leaves that I loved. I think it was at the Wynn that I had some lobster mashed potatoes that were killer. Ironically— some of the best seafood I’ve ever had was at steakhouses. The seared scallop addons at Delmonicos were probably the best I ever had.
Can’t help on wine—- I don’t drink wine.
Delicious_Oil9902@reddit
Best steakhouses or best steak? Best steak is the au Poivre at Raouls in SoHo. Had it paired with a Syrah (it wasn’t what we originally ordered but they recommended this one instead) that was served maybe 20 degrees below room temp. Best steakhouse was a bit of a Bacchanalia a friend and I had at the Mastros in Thousand Oaks CA. Started with toro sashimi, then tomahawk ribeyes with thick cut bacon and lobster mashed potatoes. Started with a 2014 Sea Smoke Pinot Noir and then a bottle of 2015 Scarecrow.
304libco@reddit
At a local chophouse that’s now closed. I had a fillet that I could’ve cut with a fork. Had I not been in public I would’ve licked the plate.
Turkeyoak@reddit
A ribeye at the Cattleman’s Steak House in Oklahoma City down by the stockyards. Founded in 1910 or so.
A 100 years of experience lay in that steak.
Wine? Sweet tea, of course.
ConceptOther5327@reddit
Agree 💯
I’ve never had any restaurant steak come close to as good as a steak from Cattlemen’s Steakhouse. Have had a couple home cooked steaks that were just as good but I’ve never had one better.
Anytime I have to drive through Oklahoma City, I try to make sure I will have time to stop at Cattlemen’s for a meal. Depending on the day the smell from the stockyards can be potent when parking, but the moment I get through the door, it’s like Heaven to me.
professorfunkenpunk@reddit
Manny's in Minneapolis. Don't even remember the cut (probably a ribeye or a strip, just knowing how I roll). Incredibly tender and flavorful, and cooked perfectly. Creamed spinach and some sort of potato as a side.
jrbighurt@reddit
I was lucky enough to get the Waygu fillet at Butcher and the Boar when we hosted the super bowl. I'll never be able to afford anything like that again, but was sooooooooo worth it at the time!
SteveDaPirate@reddit
Alright, talk me through this part.
Is there a happy medium between "not well seared" and "instant burned butter / smoking oil"? I feel like I'm always ending up with one or the other...
professorfunkenpunk@reddit
I actually like the butter a little burned, as it gives some char flavor. If you do t want that,Probably best bet is using oil with a high smoke point. Ghee would do better than oil. I think canola has the highest smoke point of the common oils. Refined avocado is even higher, but I don’t know that I’ve ever seen it locally
karenmcgrane@reddit
Home of the Silver Butter Knife Steak!
someolive2@reddit
my husband and i have a gift card here. cant wait to go!
Puzzleheaded-Bee4698@reddit
That's funny. I had a gift card for Murray's in Minneapolis. I gave it to my wife & daughter. I'm not a big fan of steakhouses.
stevarino1979@reddit
I'm a mannys guy but can't go wrong with murrays.
professorfunkenpunk@reddit
I've been to Manny's too and it's great. There was just something extra special about this particular night at Murray's. Sadly, I don't live in the cities anymore and I haven't been to either in ages
Emotional_Ad5714@reddit
I prefer Murray's too. It's the butter knife steak.
Typical_Breakfast215@reddit
Not at a steakhouse. A Mexican restaurant in phoenix called Bacanora. Monster tomahawk grilled perfectly with beans, fresh tortillas, grilled green chilis. So insanely good.
sanesociopath@reddit
Texas roadhouse's "Dallas filet" is probably my best.
I haven't really been able to go to some real high end steak houses to try and find it a competitor though.
HayTX@reddit
It was a ribeye from a cow we butchered paired with a coors lite and a baked potato first time my sister brought her future husband home. I think we had chocolate chip cookies after.
stevie855@reddit (OP)
Who prepared though?
Shoontzie@reddit
Honestly, a good steak doesn’t need to be “prepared”. It only needs proper seasoning and the proper amount of heat.
itds@reddit
Yep. If you’re not 1) salting it the night before and 2) letting it get to room temp before cooking, you’re doing it wrong.
HayTX@reddit
I think I grilled them.
lwp775@reddit
…and milk.
brewerbruce@reddit
Growing up, my parents brought grass fed beef by the side for our family of 6. Meat came from my grandparents' farm, which had beef cattle on it after Grandpa died. It was very good, between the garden, the beef ,and grandmas eggs we ate pretty well.
BankManager69420@reddit
Rib Eye from Nel Centro in Portland. Don’t drink so no wine came with it.
Ocron145@reddit
Morton’s steakhouse, was a porterhouse for 2 so me and the wife shared. Was absolutely amazing. Would do it again but it’s pricey. It was $114 for that one steak back in 2011….
Ultimate_Driving@reddit
I've never had one that didn't taste like metal.
nickzillo@reddit
Best steak period and best steakhouse experience are not the same. I have a hard time spending money at steakhouses because I know I can do it better.
discop0tato@reddit
I have a couple very good local steakhouses I frequent depending on what I'm in the mood for. The best steaks I make myself. I grab dry aged ribeye from a high quality local butcher, then sous vide it for a few hours and finish it on high heat in the grill.
Adventurous_Bit1325@reddit
I’m cooking some medium rare filet tonight for the three of us, and I have never had better steak at a restaurant than what I can make. Sides of popcorn shrimp, asparagus and corn and some inexpensive cab all for under $60. No tipping.
CCrunner36@reddit
I work in the service industry. Steaks specifically are one of those things that once you can cook a steak it's never worth it to buy one out at a restaurant. I'm not spending 70+ dollars on a ribeye that I could've put a better crust on at home
Bigbird_Elephant@reddit
Boudros in San Antonio.
Zardozin@reddit
To be honest, it isn’t that hard to cook a good steak,
My Dad travelled a lot when he was young on business, at a time when foodie hadn’t been invented and the franchise was in its infancy. His claim was that most somewhat competent chefs can cook a steak, even in a crappy restaurant. I’ve yet you prove him wrong,
SnowblindAlbino@reddit
For me it was a 24oz ribeye that a friend cooked for me at a mountain cabin in Wyoming, the steaks having come from a rancher friend. We did not have wine with them, we drank beer.
Liathano_Fire@reddit
I had a Bison ribeye at a chophouse near me, and I haven't stopped telling people I know about it.
LillyCort@reddit
My husband’s, he cooks them with a bit of olive oil, butter, garlic, rosemary and thyme salt and pepper and they are always amazing.
Dry-Sky1614@reddit
Wasn't in the US. Wife and I were on vacation in Provence, and on a cab ride from the train station to our AirBnb, she started talking with the driver (I don't speak French) and he recommended this winery/installation art/landscape art place that sounded great. When we looked on the website, saw they had a rotating restaurant with different chefs in residence and Frances Mallmann was the chef for that period. Most insane steak I have ever had in my life.
darksquidlightskin@reddit
Corralitos steakhouse - El Paso Texas for the US Viva Mexico in Juarez Mexico is the best ribeye I’ve ever had though
KimBrrr1975@reddit
No steak in a restaurant no matter what it cost is ever better than sitting on the patio drinking a Maker's and Cherry Pepsi Zero while my husband grills. But I had a pretty good steak at Ocean Prime in DC where we went for my son's graduation from grad school. But I think the food tasted better just because we were celebrating. He was my first kid to graduate college and we didn't get to have a graduation in 2020 because of covid. So his master's celebration was twice as awesome.
surfinforthrills@reddit
Other than one that was grilled to perfection at home, the best was a ribeye steak from the Metropolitan Grill in Seattle. So tender it melted in my mouth. Had a Cabernet Sauvignon with it. Service was so good, it made the meal better. Finished with crème brulee. Delicious!
Outrageous_Dream_741@reddit
My best steak was in Osaka.
America does have some great steak, though. Just my personal experience.
ca77ywumpus@reddit
It was on a camping trip, just some cheap-ass skirt steak we bought at Piggly-Wiggly and seared over a campfire in a torrential downpour. Side dish was potatoes we bought from the back of a pickup truck and sweet corn on the cob. Accompanied with Leinenkugel's Canoe Paddler ale.
Prestigious_Day_5242@reddit
Prime rib from Binions
InsertNovelAnswer@reddit
Best steak was in Iceland... Whale Steak with a nice cold beer.
grannyknockers@reddit
Wagyu short rib at Homewood in Dallas, if you count that as steak. Was hands down the best piece of beef I’ve ever eaten and nothing has ever come close.
voodoo_zero@reddit
Jack’s Steakhouse in Minneapolis about 10-12 years ago maybe. In town for training and the guy I was with read about it in Delta Skymag on our flight up. I figured it’d be touristy but it’s still one of the top places I’ve ever eaten. Not sure if it still is.
EngineersFTW@reddit
Dry aged strip from Abe & Louie's in Boston, with a Merlot from Napa but I'll be damned if I can remember the name. Meat melted like butter and the wine was like drinking liquid velvet. Awesome experience all the way around.
lasion2@reddit
Delmonico from But her and Singer in Philly.
I live here and refuse to go back, I don’t want to tarnish its legacy.
FivebyFive@reddit
I find Peter Luger to be coasting on reputation at this point.
Best steak ever for me was at Kevin Rathbun Steak in Atlanta. Ordered the spinalis. I'm still dreaming about it.
Purplehopflower@reddit
Kevin Rathbun’s is one of my favorite restaurants in Atlanta. I’ve had the Spinalis and the filet, both were fantastic, and the sweet potato/potato gratin amazing.
lupuscapabilis@reddit
Eh, I still think Peter Luger is pretty good. I've had WAY, WAY worse steaks than theirs.
JEharley152@reddit
Always been a beefeater—was en-route to a friends wedding in LA—got a overnight layover in Vegas—asked hostess at the check-in counter where to get a really good steak(after hours by the way), and she said the best in town was in the basement of circus circus—followed her directions, through service corridors, etc to a tiny restaurant with a huge round grill—had a porterhouse you could cut with your fork with all the trimmings—more than I could eat in 1 sitting, BEST EVER!!!
stevarino1979@reddit
My top 3 are
1 Mannys in Minneapolis
2 Bavettes in Chicago
3 STK in Vegas
Honorable mentions
Mo's in Milwaukee St. Elmos in Indianapolis Gauchos do Sul in Houston (Brazilian style) Prime at the Bellagio Las Vegas Hugo's Las Vegas Murray's Minneapolis Vic and Anthony Las Vegas Barry's Las Vegas Gibsons Chicago Peter Luger Las Vegas
VoluptuousValeera@reddit
MANNYS SHOUT OUT. I love a good dry aged steak.
alwaysboopthesnoot@reddit
I had a fabulous steak and a game pie as a side, at Colonial Williamsburg in one of the taverns there on-site, many years ago. Roasted veggies. Sourdough bread. The wine was a Montepulciano. Inexpensive. Delicious!
A friend took us because their kid was at the college nearby, The College of William & Mary, in Virginia.
The historical site is interesting because of its architecture, the gardens, the reenactments, the walking tours are fun, but unless they’ve started doing a much better job of explaining plantations and slavery, our country’s legacy and tradition and reliance on slavery and immigrants to forge and defend and build our country, today it may be place that will not appeal to everyone.
Alexander’s in the Champaign, Illinois area, is pretty good too. Go to Culver’s for a custard cone, though
Mistermxylplyx@reddit
Chop House of Raleigh, you pick your cut, ribeye for me, tell em how you want it cooked, and fixings. They bring it out and you feast. Simple, but they focused on quality. They charged for the quality of course, it was far from the best deal, but it was a company dinner to celebrate a good year, and the owners said get what you want. Still remember how good it was a couple decades later.
Craigh-na-Dun@reddit
The ones my dad grilled. Hands down the very best!
tcrhs@reddit
My spouse’s grilled filet is better than any restaurant steak I’ve ever had. And I’ve been to some high end steak restaurants.
Juache45@reddit
Mine too and I’m not much of a steak eater. I’ve been to high end restaurants as well and I worked at one, here in LA while I was in college. My husband’s filet is the perfect medium rare and I love it.
Longjumping_Bar_7457@reddit
The best steak I had, was when my uncle cooked it for a family gathering.
KeyAstronaut1496@reddit
Steiner Ranch Steakhouse in Austin, Texas. Out of this world good. Paired it with a nice Malbec.
FishermanUsed2842@reddit
I'm from Nebraska. A small hole-in-the wall bar & grill or restaurant can have the most outstanding steaks. I've paid anywhere from $25-$85 for ribeyes, new yorks, filets or prime rib and the cheapest ones are every bit as good as the fancy steakhouse ones. It's very hard to order steaks when we travel because I'm almost always disappointed. And I can usually make them better at home.
spiffysimon@reddit
I'm not making this up-the best steak I have ever had was served at a Chili's in Dayton Ohio. I don't know if it was the particular cut of meat, that particular cow, or that line cook was just on absolute fire that day, but man that was an incredible steak. It was a New York Strip
I had never been to a Chili's, but my wife and I had a gift card. I accompanied it with a tall Coors Light if memory serves.
InevitableRhubarb232@reddit
Hope you have never been back to a chilis, it would not stand up to your memory!
tibearius1123@reddit
I’ve been to some incredible high dollar steak houses. Texas Roadhouse beats the dog shit out of most of them. Not even based on value, steak for steak.
BM7-D7-GM7-Bb7-EbM7@reddit
It is not difficult to make a good steak, it just takes a little practice. Like someone says, the cow matters for sure, but if the chef that knew how to cook it, I totally believe you.
Leemage@reddit
What the heck! I came hear to say that the best steak I ever had was at a Chili’s too. We had a bunch of Chili’s gift cards and husband and I decided to just go all out. That steak was so juicy and flavorful, just perfectly cooked. My husband still makes fun of me that my favorite steak ever was from a Chilis.
Jaqen-Atavuli@reddit
The cow 100% matters. I'll die on that hill.
Puzzleheaded-Bee4698@reddit
Normally, it's the steer that dies in a slaughterhouse, not the patron that dies on a hill.
Jaqen-Atavuli@reddit
We all gotta go someway. :)
I_amnotanonion@reddit
It 100% does. Black Angus breeding is big in my part of VA, and there’s a local farmer who sells beef shares. That guy has the good cows. Knows how to feed them/treat them/raise them/ whatever. Has great stock and makes consistently great meats. Sometimes you still get an okay cow. Not that dudes fault, some are just better than others
No-Comfortable9480@reddit
lol
boulevardofdef@reddit
I've had some really excellent steak at Outback! At least they have "steakhouse" in the name, unlike Chili's, I guess.
vcamm61@reddit
So funny, I had an argument with my husband while on vacation about where to eat. I wanted to eat at a local, expensive restaurant, he said Chili's was 3 minutes from our hotel and he wanted to eat there, we'd had a long day and he wanted something easy. I ordered a steak and broccoli with house red. I took the 1st bite and said " damn, that's the best steak I've had in months " Side note, I live in a big beef state and the broccoli was steamed to perfection. Chili's for the win.
Eastern-Musician4533@reddit
This happened to me recently! Was on a work trip in a city where a good friend of mine lives. I had planned on treating him to some fancy schmancy meal. I then pivoted and said "actually, can we just hit this Chili's?" He said "FUCK YEAH!" We went and it was great. I did the same, NYS and double broccoli. It was perfect.
Eastern-Musician4533@reddit
New York Strip at Chili's slaps. Had it for the first time recently. You kinda have to be in the mood and understand it's not fine dining. But so good.
nopointers@reddit
Coors Light, the fine wine of urine-based beverages.
InevitableRhubarb232@reddit
Husband says strip steak in Vegas. I think he got rib tips?
BAforNow@reddit
Smith and Wollensky Wagyu steak. It came out in a class container filled with steam. Absolutely incredible.
lupuscapabilis@reddit
Probably Wolfgang's in Manhattan near Grand Central. I still think about it. Outstanding steak, and unbelievable mushrooms. I've never had mushrooms like they made them.
I was likely having a pinot noir with that, because red wine is necessary.
FishingWorth3068@reddit
Best steak I ever had was at a nice restaurant in Cape Town. It had blue cheese in it and some kind of hollandaise sauce. Cooked a perfect med rare. I still think about that steak often.
Nakagura775@reddit
Best steak I ever had was at the USO at Naval Station Pascagoula.
Samson_J_Rivers@reddit
2016 Freezing half to death in a downpour of sleeting rain waiting for a bus that wasn't coming in front of an Applebee's at 7pm after a shift. Applebee's server hollered at me to come in and said she looked up and saw the bus wasn't going to make it. Sat me down at a table with a phone book to see who I could call to get home. Manager said they hadnt had anybody in all day after lunch because of the weather and he was comping all the staff food for the fuck of it becauee they cleaned the whole place. Offered me a plate of whatever i wanted on the menu free of charge. Best fucking steak i ever had. The Cook gave me a ride home because he lived 4 blocks from me.
SirCharlito44@reddit
I went to a concert with my dad in Chicago. We happened to ask someone while we were walking back to our hotel where we could get a good steak. They pointed us in the right direction and we went in. We were def underdressed (everyone was in suits) but they let us in. It was the best steak I’ve ever had. We both had a steak and a beer and it was over $200. One of the best memories I have with him. We still talk about it to this day. I have no idea what the name of the restaurant was though. I hope I can bring him back some day.
daddyjackpot@reddit
Palms Steakhouse in West Hollywood gave me one that had me putting down my fork to savor every bite. some kind of magical cow that one was.
olemiss18@reddit
Best steak I’ve had in the KC area in the 2.5 years I’ve lived here: Piropos.
But the most memorable was a filet & salmon combination at Twin Springs Supper Club in Decorah, Iowa. That place rocks. Admittedly I think the salmon was the highlight but the steak was great too. One of the best meals I’ve ever had.
RichardCleveland@reddit
I get steaks everywhere, and I have eaten at some of the top steakhouses in my city. But mind blowingly the one I remember the most was a filet wrapped in bacon, crusted with blue cheese from wait for it.... Outback Steakhouse. This was probably 10 years ago though, as I don't have any near me anymore so I imagine things have gone down hill. But the fact that I can still remember it is fairly telling.
netvoyeur@reddit
Years ago in Chicago at a place called Magnum
winteriscoming9099@reddit
I’ve only had 3 steaks ever, by my count. But the best one was at the Lincoln steakhouse in Scottsdale AZ
Chunderdragon86@reddit
Tavern on the green in central park great frie also
AdInevitable2695@reddit
Not a steakhouse at all, the best steak I've had was at a coffee shop that has a "tavern" that serves brunch attached to it. NY strip and eggs with a side of fries, ordered "as rare as possible" because that's how I like it. Paired with a brunch cocktail made with gin, prosecco, kina, lemon, and peach puree. It was like the best mimosa you could imagine.
Man, I was almost disappointed that the steak came with chimichurri on top. That was the best piece of beef I'll probably ever have. It was perfectly rare with a bit of blue in the thickest part of the steak. I dream about that steak sometimes. I've been to Texas Roadhouse many times and I'm always disappointed by how well done my rare steak is there.
Rebel Dog Coffee Co. in Plainville, CT if anyone's curious.
shthappens03250322@reddit
Butter in midtown Manhattan. About 9 years ago they had a ribeye for two that was divine.
SillyScarcity700@reddit
Porterhouse I got on a cruise in the South Pacific was pretty dang tasty. A friend owned a few steakhouses in Northern CA for a little while and I would get their ribeye when I went. Also very good. But as others have said it's pretty easy to make a great steak at home which is what I would do now if I wanted a great steak. I do that maybe a few times a year.
TikaPants@reddit
Backyard on a charcoal Weber. My dad used to buy a quarter side of grass fed, grain finished beef. That beef also made one of the best burgers. I’ve ever had.
naynever@reddit
My grandmother’s cook made a killer porterhouse. It was my favorite dinner, so if I got to pick what we had, it was that. Somehow, she got one part of it to medium for my grandfather, while leaving the rest of it rare.
CorporalVoytek2@reddit
1- Cabana Las Lilas in BA, Argentina 2- NY Strip at Lewnes in Annapolis 3- Filets at Ruth’s Chris
real_mcflipper@reddit
Keens is dynamite, but I have to say the best steak I ever had was at a random Argentine place in Hollywood, Florida. It was ages ago and probably isn’t even around anymore, but I can remember the flavor to this day.
tibearius1123@reddit
Vaca Argentina in Puerto Vallarta is hard to beat but the steakhouse in the M Casino is damn good too.
borisdidnothingwrong@reddit
Homemade.
I bought some dry aged robe ribeyes, and made a paste of garlic and sea salt in a mortar and pestle, rubbed that in like a masseur, left it in the fridge overnight, then grilled out back.
Served with baked potatoes and roasted Brussels sprouts.
No wine. Water for me, and Jameson for the lady.
Aggressive-Emu5358@reddit
The ones I make at my house
braincovey32@reddit
Merriman's on Big Island
"Brunate" Barolo by Vietti from Piemonte, Italy
frr_Vegeta@reddit
Best steak I ever had was a tomahawk on the Norwegian Gem cruise ship. Second best was a tomahawk I reverse seared myself about a year later. I'm still working on my grill game and this spring I have high hopes. Also just got a smoker which I'm going to try and involve in my steak work.
My wife's favorite was at the Capital Grille in Baltimore. I think a Filet but I was too focused on my tomahawk which was also fantastic. (I tend to stick with some sort of bone in ribeye).
Free-Sherbet2206@reddit
I cook my steak at home and it almost always turns out perfectly for me. I’m not willing to pay steakhouse prices.
mothlady1959@reddit
Craftsteak
My own Tomahawk Chop
pugdaddy78@reddit
The Star, Elko Nevada.
witchy12@reddit
Off the path a bit, but I had a tuna steak at a random restaurant near Cape Cod and I have never found another tuna steak as good as that one. I've been searching for a while too, and nothing has ever compared.
HauntedDIRTYSouth@reddit
La Boca in New Orleans. Overpriced, but you go for the atmosphere. Damn was it good though. The second best was cooked myself... often.
Grouchy-Big-229@reddit
Angus Barn in Raleigh, NC. Funny thing is, it was leftovers that were brought back that I ate the same evening. The ribeye still melted in my mouth.
Murdy2020@reddit
Winchester Steakhouse in Buffalo Wyoming -- Pretty sure it changed hands since I was there 10 years ago.
CombinationWhich6391@reddit
A churrasco in rural Brazil, with a friend who lived there.
xczechr@reddit
NY Strip at Flemings. It was cooked perfectly.
ehbowen@reddit
I don't know about "best" best, but the most memorable steak which I had was the Teriyaki steak served at Jimmy Wong's Chinese Restaurant in Chicago, the day I graduated from US Navy boot camp in 1983. Perfect seasoning and flavor and so tender you could cut it with a fork. Came as part of a "family dinner" for five; my parents, sister, and grandmother had driven up to see me graduate. I was almost sorry I had to share it!
Youknowme911@reddit
Bone-in Kona at The Capital Grille
The best meat I had was 20+ years ago at a Brazilian steakhouse called Porcāo
I’ve been to Peter Luger twice and it was good but not somewhere I’d go again
Oldbayistheshit@reddit
TIL capital grille is nationwide. Thought it was just DC
Youknowme911@reddit
Have you tried their other restaurant The Capital Burger?
Oldbayistheshit@reddit
I haven’t and didn’t know they owned it. I pass by it all the time and I’m a burger freak haha
Tudorrosewiththorns@reddit
Outside the house for me is probably Capital Grill. Their lobster Mac is also amazing.
Youknowme911@reddit
And don’t forget the Stoli Dolis
let-it-rain-sunshine@reddit
That Kona rubbed steak is wonderful.
ahmeeea@reddit
The Kona was soooo good!
limbodog@reddit
I had "Omi beef" while in Japan and I'd swear it was actually unicorn meat.
davidm2232@reddit
I have had better steak at home than at any steakhouse. They always put some crazy sauce on them. You don't need that. Salt, pepper, maybe a little garlic powder. Grill to medium rare and top with a pat of butter while still hot. So tender and flavorful. You should taste mostly the meat, not the sauce. If I want a sauce to cover the taste of the meat, I'll do that with a way cheaper meat like cubed steak.
armstaae@reddit
I used to love Texas Roadhouse because it was always good and consistent. Until I started properly pan frying my steak at home. Nothing will beat my homemade Aldi's steak in my eyes.
5DsofDodgeball69@reddit
Three way tie:
The first time I ever went to Ruth's Chris, they had everything 100% dialed in. I ordered a ribeye a couple ounces larger than what they had on the menu, and everything about it was just perfect. You always hear about "melt in your mouth" steaks, and sure, I had had very tender perfectly cooked steaks up that point, but this one was seasoned perfectly, perfectly fatty, perfect crust, buttery, and legitimately melt-in-your mouth.
Next was what I imagine was a lower end chain steak house. Texas Land and Cattle. They had a ribeye that at the time, as the chef explained it to me, had been smoking low and slow as part of a large rib roast, and was cut and grilled to order. It was my first experience with what later became known as reverse-searing, and it was the perfect smokey, salty, perfect crust, perfectly tender etc.
The enormous tomahawk ribeye I made at home a few weeks ago. Heavily salted, in the fridge for a couple of days, garlic and pepper added when I took it out of the fridge, smoked with a mix of hickory, apple, and peach wood, and then hard seared on the grill, and it was immaculate.
Both-Ad1169@reddit
Hands down it was at the steakhouse inside the bellagio hotel in Las Vegas. Filet mignon was like butter.
Curmudgy@reddit
A Romanian steak that I had in a restaurant in south Florida 30 or 40 years ago. It's usually made from skirt steak, which isn't something most people would use for steak, but it's covered in seasoning and smothered in onions.
I haven't had steak in several years but I can't think of any other steak that really stands out the way that Romanian steak did. Steak for me usually just came in three types, standard, extra tender, and bad, with standard by far the most common.
onelittleworld@reddit
We have a fairly decent butcher shop nearby, and you can usually get a good ribeye there (which is my cut of choice). Anyway, it's hard to improve upon one of those, seasoned with kosher salt, cracked pepper and granulated garlic, seared and cooked to a perfect med. rare on the Weber grill on my deck in the beautiful Fox Valley of Illinois.
Sides: seasoned grill fries, roasted bell pepper, tomato-basil salad.
Wine: a nice Sonoma or Napa cabernet.
rosemaryscrazy@reddit
As others have said the best I had was at home not at a restaurant. The quality of American meat in most restaurants isn’t any better than the local supermarket.
I get my meat through MOINK. Which is a meat delivery service. So it’s shipped straight from various farms in the Midwest grass fed etc. So obviously that’s going to taste better just based on the quality of the meat as opposed to whatever restaurants have going on.
justmisspellit@reddit
Atsteak
ksay9104@reddit
A "drunken ribeye", medium rare, at Sweetwater Tavern in Merrifield, VA.
BrainDad-208@reddit
Dad used to buy a side of beef from a farmer in the “thumb” of Michigan every year. Grilled steaks over charcoal even in winter. Those were the best
dave65gto@reddit
The $9.95 Steak and Baked Potato from Petro Truck stop just before hitting Delaware on I-95 in the 90's. Not a trucker, but they were so good on those long distance drives coming home from vacation down south.
Lothar_Ecklord@reddit
I’ve been to a handful of steakhouses around New York and the best so far was a tomahawk ribeye from Old Homestead.
Humbler-Mumbler@reddit
Charcoal-grilled porterhouse in my backyard. Steak at a restaurant is kind of a waste because it doesn’t take that much skill to cook steak to a restaurant quality. All that really matters is heat, timing and the quality of the meat. I love charcoal for the smoky flavor it gives and this one was cooked just right (which is harder with charcoal because there isn’t just a knob to set the temp.)
justamom2224@reddit
The best steak I’ve ever had at a restaurant was at Eddie Merlots for Valentines Day. We both had tried wagyu for the first time. It was great. 10/10.
I haven’t had a steak compare to that one, from a restaurant. But the ones I cook myself? Almost always a 10/10.
Lumpy-Ring-1304@reddit
Halls Chophouse Charleston, SC
Watcher0011@reddit
I was on a road trip in San Antonio Texas, we told the cab driver we wanted steak, he took us to a really fancy restaurant, this steak was hands down the best steak we ever had, even the fat was better lol. In some ways it ruined steak as now I have no expectations of finding a better steak
Environmental_Fan348@reddit
Omaha Prime, Omaha Nebraska. Went there twice on a business trip. Shortly after that, the company had them black listed because we spent way too much money. Worth every penny, especially since it was a corporate expense.
StopSignsAreRed@reddit
It was at Texas Roadhouse in Kentucky…sirloin…very juicy, and it was well done 😮
BM7-D7-GM7-Bb7-EbM7@reddit
Honestly, I make better steaks at home than I can get from any steakhouse.
There is one place I love to go however, Chama Gaucha, a Brazilian steakhouse. It's special, the steaks are amazing and of course the Brazilian style means
MastiffArmy@reddit
It was in Namibia of all places cooked by my friend in his backyard.
Meilingcrusader@reddit
God help me, it was overseas. You really just can't beat the steak you get in Kobe. Honestly, I'm not a huge steak fan, they are often kinda tough. I tend to prefer burgers, and when I'm in the mood for a hunk of meat, I like to have lamb chops bc they are more flavorful.
wpotman@reddit
In all honesty I kind of believe there is a level of filet excellence that, once reached, is hard to greatly surpass. If the sear is done well, it's salty enough, and it's cooked appropriately medium rare...they are near equally excellent. You can pay $100 more and get something that is...basically the same.
The sides actually tend to make more of a difference for me, even though they aren't the stars. Are the mashed potatoes appropriately buttery and creamy? Are the vegetables 'medium crispy' with a good flavor? Is the wine solid?
I couldn't tell you which combo I thought was the best: in my mind about ten of them are near tied.
Lothar_Ecklord@reddit
If the creamed spinach doesn’t put me into a happy food coma, I’m not going back.
02K30C1@reddit
Yup. Once you get to that level, it’s things like the atmosphere and service that make a difference. A great steak in a quiet restaurant with a spectacular view and excellent service will taste better than the same steak in a crowded noisy restaurant with crappy service
wpotman@reddit
Agreed
BoliverSlingnasty@reddit
Beefmaster Inn in Wilson, NC, USA.
I’ll fight you on this.
From the outside this place looks ready to close for business. But the line and wait tell the real story. All you get for a side is a baked potato and there’s a small salad station if you want. The waitstaff come to the table with a giant cut of beef and describe the cut of the night then ask how many ounces you want. The kitchen is completely open and dude’s over there with charcoal.
I’ve eaten steak in almost every state and in a few countries outside of the US. Nothing, literally nothing, compares to this place.
Aggressive_Age8818@reddit
In Buenos Aires for me at a place called Cabernet - cut the steak with a table knife and probably could have sliced it with the side of my fork
intotheairwaves17@reddit
I’ve had some really great ones but the best I can think of at the moment is the filet mignon I had on Father’s Day last year at Ishnala Supper Club in Wisconsin. It was phenomenal!
SlamClick@reddit
I'd say Ruth's Chris filet medium rare.
Jen_the_Green@reddit
Our local Ruth's Chris has gone downhill. I don't eat steak, but my husband is a huge steak lover and we used to go a few times a year, but the last two times we've gone were disappointing experiences. We did have a nice meal at two different Jean Georges steak restaurants, but it's too expensive to be a regular thing.
Renny4400@reddit
Ruth’s Chris for me too. I know it’s a chain restaurant but I’ve never had a bad filet there. It’s been 100% perfect every time, regardless of location.
crazdtow@reddit
I’ve had many many great steaks at Ruth Chris!!!
sysaphiswaits@reddit
I’m glad to see this mentioned, and so much support! I was a little embarrassed to say this one because they cook a lot of their steaks in butter, and that kind of seems like overkill? But, it’s so good!
crazdtow@reddit
Yeah it was one of the first “nicer” steakhouses I went to and it just stuck with me because it was so good and the service was usually incredible. I do also like Morton’s, Sullivans and the good ole Texas Roadhouse so I’m pretty diverse when it comes to my steaks 🥩
Trillion_G@reddit
My local mom and pop Brazilian steakhouse. Just as good as Fogo for half the price. The waiters only speak Portuguese. It’s the best.
nosidrah@reddit
I’m going to have to second this. But it was with a couple of martinis instead of wine. But the best non-steakhouse steak was at a TGI Friday’s. The first and only time I’ve ever been there and that steak was awesome.
Hulahulahoopla@reddit
I bought a beef tenderloin from Costco for New Year’s. I followed a recipe and it came out perfect. My MIL said it was the best meat she’s ever eaten and that is a huge compliment. Also my kids had seconds and they are pretty picky. If it wasn’t so expensive, I’d buy one every week to cook.
jasonreid1976@reddit
I can't ever think of a steak that impressed me that much.
I chalk it up to never being at a good steak place.
SideEmbarrassed1611@reddit
Frederick Inn St. Joseph, MO. They sear on very high heat and make perfect blue rare. It's cheap. Steakhouses typically overcharge for their cut of meat. I can cook the steak better than them at home. And I do. Using soy sauce and worscerstershire and cracked pepper marinade. 4 minutes each side high heat. Done.
Bones in Atlanta is also very good.
I do not drink wine with steak. I prefer to make a red wine mushroom sauce and drink water at dinner.
Cultural_Horse_7328@reddit
The best stear i ever had was at a tiny restaurant in Versailles, France. It was served with a green peppercorn butter sauce.
AutoModerator@reddit
The use of URL shorteners on this subreddit is prohibited. Please repost your link without the use of a url shortener
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
ATLDeepCreeker@reddit
Honestly, I don't judge based on a superior cut of meat. Any line cook or chef SHOULD be able to make it great. But what can you do with subpar to ok meat. That being said, the best steak I've ever had cooked for me was at a diner somewhere near Berlin, NJ in about 1999.
After I commented on how delicious the steak and eggs were, the waitress told me that the current cook was from Argentina, where his family owned several restaurant. Apparently this kid came to America and got on drugs, committed some crimes, and did a little time.
He must've been sponsored by the diner owners, because they all loved him. And what he made that grisly piece of dog meat steak taste buttery, melt in your mouth delicious.
Lucky_Forever@reddit
I'm on the made it myself bandwagon...
as for Steak house restaurants, my experience is pretty limited.
Best experience was probably Murry's in Minneapolis Minnesota.
Funny story: when I was a kid, on a family vacation in Salt Lake City Utah. We went for a big brunch at an all you can eat buffet. Then only a few hours later went to a fancy steak house for dinner, I don't recall the name. I ended up getting so sick from over eating you can imagine what my night was like. I could not eat a grilled steak again for at least 10 years. I was so happy when I could finally enjoy a good steak once again!
EagleCatchingFish@reddit
Was it Maddox Ranch House? It's not a super fancy place, but it's the one you go to if you're visiting Utah. I went once in the 90s, and it was pretty good, but I've heard it's not as good as it used to be.
Lucky_Forever@reddit
Sorry I don't recall, I was like 12.
marvelguy1975@reddit
Big texan steak ranch in armadillo TX.
On a cross country road trip and we stopped in for lunch. To die for.
https://www.bigtexan.com/
Ocstar11@reddit
Keens has a great mutton chop
Sloanepeterson1500@reddit
There was a place near the North Western Campus in Evanston, whose name escapes me…maybe “Pete something??” Best steak I’ve ever had. Everything was perfect. They’re closed now 😔
Ear_Enthusiast@reddit
I'll be honest, I can cook a steak as well as any steak house. I use Kenji's reverse sear and Chef John's steak rub recipe. The only real challenge for me is getting beef as good as a steakhouse. Costco sells prime. Our local butcher sells prime. It's pretty fuck'n easy.
hahahahnothankyou@reddit
Tokyo, new otani hotel, there is a steak house in their arcade of shops. I think it’s called rib room
Super thin, melts in your mouth.
shooter9260@reddit
I once got a filet at the Strip House in Las Vegas Planet Hollywood and it was so good. Sort of a pepper crusted thing and cooked really good. And compared to many of the other steakhouses there it was fairly less spendy.
adbedient@reddit
Best best steak I've ever had was at a gas station outside Ellsworth, KS. There was a small restaurant inside the station, and everyone knew that you got there early or else they'd run out of steak.
I was stationed at Ft. Riley and one of my buddies was from Kansas, and kept talking about this hole in the wall with great steaks. One Thursday night we drove the 2.5 hours west to Ellsworth and found ourselves at a dumpy gas station in the middle of nowhere.
Everything else I ate was barely mediocre- a dry and mealy baked potato with a side of "what the hell did they do to them" green beans accompanied by a small iceberg lettuce salad with 2 watery tomatoes and ranch dressing- but good god that STEAK.
You didn't get to choose your cut, really. They had what they had and it was a bit of dinner roulette luck for what you would get- I got a ribeye- but each and every steak was about as perfect as I could have asked for. It was a huge-like 24oz- cut of meat- seasoned and grilled perfectly. I've been chasing the memory of that steak for almost 20 years now.
OrdinarySubstance491@reddit
The ones we make at home
athensslim@reddit
Brisbane, Australia. Served with a pepper sauce and a side of steak fries. Don’t remember the drink, but I probably had a beer with it.
25 years ago, but I still remember that steak.
EagleCatchingFish@reddit
I've been to churrascarias where I've had a good variety of steaks for the money, but I've never had as good a steak as I can make at home. Steak is really easy to cook perfectly, so I don't see the point of paying $100+ for a prime chunk of meat I can get from a butcher for a fraction of the cost.
sideshow--@reddit
The best steak I ever had was at Don Julio in Buenos Aires. I had a filet and a NY Strip. I’m a NY strip guy, but that filet not represents the pinnacle of what a filet could be.
And the wine that accompanies the steak was a fantastic Argentine Malbec.
EagleCatchingFish@reddit
I have a friend who was a Mormon missionary in Uruguay. He said he's never had better steak than at an asado.
No-Comfortable9480@reddit
Whoa
AssassinWog@reddit
My cousin got married in Buenos Aires. The amount of high quality cheap steak was mind-blowing.
stevie855@reddit (OP)
Love the Argentine Malbecs, they're almost always very good!
Couscousfan07@reddit
At a brasserie in Paris, believe it or not. And I’m from Texas.
OmniscientSpirit@reddit
Pacific 333 in Oceanside, California was hands down the best steakhouse experience I’ve ever had. Went with their DRY AGED NEW YORK STRIP—a 14 oz. Tasmanian Wagyu, 100% grass-fed, 20-day dry-aged, with that deep, robust, nutty flavor that only a proper dry-aging process can bring out. Easily the most expensive steak I’ve ever ordered, but absolutely worth it.
Paired it with their mac & cheese, which was next-level: a 4-cheese blend of fontina, gouda, gruyere, and parmesan—creamy, rich, and the perfect contrast to the steak’s intense umami.
No wine for me that night, but if I remember correctly, I had an Old Fashioned made with Maker’s Mark—smooth, slightly sweet, and just enough bite to complement the steak without overpowering it.
10/10, would absolutely go back.
FoundationAny7601@reddit
Berns Steakhouse in Tampa
FoundationAny7601@reddit
Berns Steakhouse in Tampa
thisismyburnerac@reddit
The best steak I ever ate wasn’t beef. My ex-FIL took us to have elk in Jackson Hole. Nearly every steak I’ve had since then pales in comparison.
Monte_Cristos_Count@reddit
Bacon wrapped filet mignon
karenmcgrane@reddit
I am in Japan right now and I told my husband I wanted Waygu while we're here. So he booked us a place where we got to try like 12 different cuts of Waygu and cook it tableside.
Not a steak, exactly, but definitely the most satisfying and delicious steak eating experience I've had in a while.
Cael_NaMaor@reddit
Probably the various ones at a local restaurant called Saskatoons. Lot's of variety. All of it delicious.
geri73@reddit
My aunts roommate put some Sam's club steaks on the grill, and they were the best.
Aggravating_Anybody@reddit
The one I make at home. 30 day dry aged prime ribeye from my local grocery store. Reverse seared in the oven at 250 degrees to 125 internal ten then finished on the stove in cast iron for 2 minutes per side.
AlternativeDue1958@reddit
Prime at Bellagio. I ate there twice, both times out on the patio overlooking the fountains. I was there on my 21st and 22nd birthdays.
Revolutionary_Roll88@reddit
Bistecca Sydney
ron_spanky@reddit
Haleiwa Joe’s. In Haleiwa, north shore of Oahu. It’s not the traditional American steak house but I had the best prime rib. Cooked perfectly, thick cut, enormous portion. I want to go back to Hawaii.
ExS619@reddit
Had an exceptional filet at the Paris, Las Vegas w a MollyDooker Boxer.
Designer-Carpenter88@reddit
The picahna cut at a Brazilian steakhouse. My local one is called Serra Gaucha and it’s spectacular. I don’t drink wine, so I couldn’t tell you, but they gave a great regional Brazilian drink called a caipirinha that’s made with lime. It’s delicious
legion_XXX@reddit
You mean the whiskey and the cigar?
Dry aged ribeye. I had a double pour of George T Stagg. The restaurant was very dim and had a couple of fire places going. The steak and the atmosphere were perfect.
SL13377@reddit
I eat wagu a lot and it’s probably the aged ribeye Wagu I got at Born and Raised here in San Diego
damnyankeeintexas@reddit
Pappas in Houston. The filet was mind blowing
pharrison26@reddit
A random breakfast steak at a Denny’s. It was like a hungover miracle. Or maybe I was just hungover. That steak haunts me.
concrete_isnt_cement@reddit
It was the prime rib at the Pioneer Saloon in Ketchum, Idaho. I had a Moscow mule and a fully loaded baked potato with it.
Cptn_Jib@reddit
Best steakhouse experience? Keen’s in Manhattan. I’m a big whiskey guy and they have the best scotch list I have ever seen. Got an Ardbeg Supernova which I had been wanting to try and the sommelier came out to speak with me, very cool. Best steak ever was probably Smith & Wollensky, also in Manhattan but there’s a few around the country
FakeAorta@reddit
Daniel's Broiler in Seattle. It was a slider of 3 different Filet steaks.
TreyRyan3@reddit
I once cooked two ribeyes over a 1400 -1600 degree (F) wood fire. It took maybe 3-4 minutes. My wife says it was the best steak she has ever eaten and we’ve eaten a lot of steaks.
OpheliaMorningwood@reddit
Hate to admit it, but The Yachtsman Steakhouse at Walt Disney World. Was aged and seasoned and marbled and cooked perfectly. They had a side of Cabernet sautéed mushrooms that had reduced and was so flavorful. If I could have licked the plate I would have,
Lulusmom09@reddit
There is a steakhouse in Brigham City, UT called Maddox that has been around since 1949. It literally has the best steak I have ever had.
I have eaten in fine restaurants all over the United States, but the home-style Maddox steak is seriously where it’s at.
They serve a 2 pound porterhouse if any of you gluttons are interested……I’ll take the 6 oz filet, about a dozen of their rolls and cornpones with fresh whipped raspberry butter, and a sarsaparilla. You’ll have to roll me out. 🤤
Shoontzie@reddit
Murphy’s steakhouse in a post office in Texas
Blackbox7719@reddit
As dumb as it may sound, I had a really memorable steak at Outback one time. It was very much a fluke (since I’ve eaten there several times before and since and it’s never happened again) but something about the sirloin that day hit jist right in terms of taste, sear, and cooking time.
Best steak I’ve had, period, was at home. Had it with a bottle of red wine (forget the exact brand).
Legitimate-Frame-953@reddit
Sirloin steak I bought at Sam's Club. Up in the Black Hills, snowing about 15 degrees out, cooked over open flame in a fire pit with a good beer in hand. Salt, Pepper, and garlic powder for seasoning.
NatAttack89@reddit
Pintos in Albuquerque NM. Hands down, tastes like a steak made at home in the best way. I'd be willing to vacation in Albuquerque just to go back to that steakhouse. 🤤🤤🤤
It's a really popular restaurant with celebrities and articles written about them all over the walls. We had no idea when we went, we just wanted to try New Mexican red and green salsa.
I dont drink wine, but the drinks were cold and our glasses stayed full.
Oldjamesdean@reddit
Chops Grille on a Royal Caribbean ship like 20 years ago. Ruth Chris in Portland was almost as good.
hajimoto74@reddit
Get an aged prime cut from a local rancher\butcher. Reverse sear in a cast iron with just salt and pepper. I prefer mine blue so it's rare to find a place that knowS what a proper blue steak temp is. They'll also mess it up with a bunch of unnecessary things to make it fancy. Nice and simple and you'll have the best steak of your life.
DropTopEWop@reddit
36 oz ribeye from Big Texan in Amarillo.
dr-tectonic@reddit
Misono restaurant in Kobe, Japan.
The place that invented the teppanyaki steak house
It was the absolute best meal I've had in my entire life. By a wide margin.
If you ever get a chance, do it. It was extravagantly expensive and still worth every penny.
bdouble76@reddit
2 of the best steaks I ever had was at an Applebee's. Really wasn't expecting that. But perfectly cooked, seasoned, and extremely tender.
I've paid over $100 at fancy restaurants only to get a bland, tough steak.
99% of the time, I wish I were just at home cooking it myself.
Feisty-Tooth-7397@reddit
Went to a place that was supposed to be the best steaks in town. 200 bucks later and I was thinking, well I don't think they were the best by a long shot.
Give me a ribeye, throw a little salt pepper and a dash of soy sauce, leave it in the fridge until the grill is ready (charcoal thank you very much) and mmmm mmmm medium rare.
My boyfriend used to travel for work and we had dinner at my uncle's and he said my uncle's steak was the second best he had in his life.
My family loves to grill. Mostly beef. Well, that and for about 10 years we lived in the woods without electricity, hippies, we grilled a lot in the summer. So I grew up grilling. I have grilled in the rain, snow. I don't care, i feel like I am sinning if I pan fry a ribeye.
bdouble76@reddit
I didn't come from grilling people. I did some years ago decide that I needed to learn to make a good steak. I went the cast iron route. So far, I've been told I make better than just a good one. The best compliment I have ever received was from 2 people who didn't like steak. Not that they hated it, but were never impressed by one enough to understand the infatuation. My wife didn't tell me this until the night of. They both finished two 1.5 to 2 inch steaks and said they get it now. I'm fine with criticism because I want to improve if something is lacking. But I've been my biggest critic thus far.
Love that you had that wooded/no electricity experience as a kid.
Feisty-Tooth-7397@reddit
It's definitely interesting to have grown up in the 80s and 90s without electricity. I remember when we got a cell phone and it was hooked up to a car battery. We didn't have a phone for a long time.
Probably why I really don't like them.
I started reading really young.
I can live without electricity, but I can also use HTML to build a webpage.
When you see those pictures "could you live here for a year without electricity or Internet" please that's would be great thank you. I loved it.
GhostGirl32@reddit
Was there a week or so ago and came to the realization is that I just like when my steak is flavored with more than just salt and pepper. They had a garlic butter skillet steak. Had some icky cartilage bits but I did not care since the rest was perfect.
bdouble76@reddit
This was years ago. I think 06. Happy that Applebee's is still surprising people.
g_mmy1@reddit
Feel you on the 99% of the time.
bdouble76@reddit
I'm at a point where I'm afraid to order steak at a restaurant.
literallywhat66@reddit
Capitol Grill in Boston
Cool_Reputation_694@reddit
The one I made last week
Organic_South8865@reddit
Would anyone believe me if I said it was at Buck Owen's in Bakersfield CA? I'm still surprised.
Educational_Mess_998@reddit
Fioré at Harrah’s Rincon in So Cal
az_desert_rat_@reddit
Ruth's Chris is great. But some Wagyu steaks my husband cooks from a local farmer are where it's at.
paka96819@reddit
Sizzler's. I don't know what cut but it was good. Maybe because I was expecting terrible. Ruth Chris is always good.
BENNYRASHASHA@reddit
Rome. Like 15 years ago. Still remember it.
Bargle-Nawdle-Zouss@reddit
Ruth's Chris in Seattle, in 2003 or 2004. I believe I had the filet mignon, medium rare. My table shared a bottle of L'Ecole No. 41 cabernet sauvignon, from the nearby Walla Walla Mountains. I don't recall the vintage, but I'm guessing it was a 1999 or 2000.
Runner up: Joe's Seafood, Prime Steak & Stone Crab, in Chicago, 2004. I had the bone-in ribeye medium rare. Sadly, I can't recall if I had any wine.
Fragrant_Spray@reddit
I had a fantastic NY strip at Smith & Wollensky (Boston) years ago. Probably the best one I’ve had.
AssassinWog@reddit
Bos Taurus in Bend, Oregon. I got a real nice strip loin (I can’t remember if it was non-Wagyu or a Wagyu hybrid). Real nice bordelaise and chimichurri sauces.
And I had a coke (Non-Alcoholic heathen. But it was a really good coke).
Weary_Anybody3643@reddit
Some cheap cut I got from the local butcher first thing I bought with my paycheck after moving out and getting my own place. It's apart of tradition now every Friday I have a steak . Might not have been the highest quality I've ever eaten but with my own money made by my own hand it tasted like my own little piece of Olympus
DifferentWindow1436@reddit
Porterhouse at Wolfgang's Park Ave. This was like 20 years ago, so not a recent review but damn that was good. Also went to Keane's which was great but had a better meal at Wolfgang's.
themcp@reddit
The porterhouse steak is named for Porter's Hotel, which stood in Cambridge MA. It was torn down decades ago, and there's a supermarket there now. You can buy a raw porterhouse steak there, but it won't be anything special. The people who work there don't even know.
JudgeOld843@reddit
At Jocko's in Nipomo, California.
SurpriseEcstatic1761@reddit
Just east of the Colorado border in a small town a couple miles off the interstate. It was the kind of place where pick up your sides cafeteria style then order the steak at the register. They give you a number to place in your table to deliver it.
nb150207@reddit
There’s this place in Ashford, Washington, right at the entrance of Mount Rainier National Park. It’s called Copper Creek Inn.
This place makes fantastic steaks. They go out and collect locally grown blackberries on a daily basis. Then they turned them into a jam that they spread over their steaks. You can get em with blue cheese.
You wouldn’t necessarily think so, but they’re absolutely delicious. My ex and I stayed in Ashford for three nights while we’re on vacation in Rainier and we went to Copper Creek every one of those nights. I still think about their steaks
themcp@reddit
There used to be a luxury food supermarket called "bread & circus". (They were eventually bought by Whole Foods, which isn't nearly as good.) I was going to visit a friend, and I wanted to bring a nice dinner, so I went there and spent like $35 on two raw steaks. I took a portable gas grill to his place and grilled them.
They were perfect. Best steak I ever had, and my friend told me the same.
It wasn't at a steakhouse. There was no wine.
blizzard7788@reddit
Antoine’s in New Orleans, the year after Katrina. The French Quarter had about 25% of the tourists they normally would have on the Labor Day weekend. We went down in a group of 12. Every place we went to treated us like royalty because there was such a lack of business. I ordered a filet and when the waiter brought it, he said,” here’s your steak knife, you won’t need it.” And he was right. It was tender, juicy, and delicious. After our dinner was over, he asked if we would like to see a tour of all the rooms. He even brought us into their wine cellar. It was a great experience.
Less-Perspective-693@reddit
My dad’s. That man fucked up just about everything in his life but dammit he makes a good steak
AddemF@reddit
Not lying when I tell you it was the one my grandmother made one day from a cheap cut of meat, on no particularly big occasion. She was just an incredible cook.
Aggravating-Ad-8150@reddit
The best steak I've ever had was at Doe's Eat Place in Little Rock Arkansas. It's a little hole in the wall in a sketch neighborhood, but boy, is the steak good! Served by the pound, family style, with fries and Texas toast.
tacmed85@reddit
Admittedly I don't often order steaks when I eat out because it's something I can generally make as well or better myself at home and I'd rather get something where that's not the case if I'm going to pay a premium. That said I think the best steak I ever had at a restaurant was a ribeye at a place called Stockman's in a little town in the middle of nowhere Texas as I was driving through. Nothing really crazy unique, just really well seasoned and seared high quality beef.
_Operator_@reddit
Best Consistent Steak: Peter Luger
Best One-Off Steak: Prime at the Bellagio 2/16/2020
kalelopaka@reddit
At home, medium ribeye on a grill, seasoned with Montreal steak seasoning and herb butter. Served it with a twice baked loaded potato, and a salad with romaine mix, radish, slivered carrots, a little red cabbage, red onion, snow pea pods, diced tomatoes, sliced cucumber, peppers, hard boiled egg chopped, fresh grated cheddar, chopped bacon, homemade red wine vinaigrette. Served with Antler Hill Cabernet Sauvignon. Made this the night I proposed to my wife.
Visible-Shop-1061@reddit
Yeah probably Peter Luger. I've never been to any of the other big name steakhouses in NYC though. My friend's dad used to take us to Peter Luger for my friend's birthday in high school in the 90's. I remember one year we sat at a table next to Paul Rudd, Peter Krause, Josh Charles and some other guy, before any of them were super famous. I was the only one who recognized them.
Cosmic-Ape-808@reddit
Other than my own steaks which hit the top 10 of all best steaks ever, and other than friends’ steaks which hit the top 20 ever, I would say Ruth Chris in Beverly Hills while it still has that sizzle at the table presentation
CrystalZZ88@reddit
My husband makes the best steak. I’ll never eat at a steakhouse, idk how he does it.
Cambot1138@reddit
My family and I just got back from a trip to Italy. We had a lunch at a place called La Giostra where I had risotto with carmelized onions and a tagliata. So that’s fresh on my mind.
It’s not an American steak, but you are asking an American.
LightningMan711@reddit
The best commercial steak I have had was at THE Steakhouse, the house steakhouse at Circus Circus Hotel and Casino in Las Vegas. How good was it? My traveling companion said his was better than the wagyu steak he had at a fancy restaurant the next night.
Roscoe_Filburn@reddit
Georgia James in Houston, Texas until they moved to their new location and became a shell of their former selves.
CitizenMillennial@reddit
I'm not a big steak person but the best I ever had was on my 30th birthday in Las Vegas at PRIME Steakhouse. I ordered the Porterhouse and it was amazing.
We ate outside next to the Bellagio fountains.
It was magical.
ZorroMcChucknorris@reddit
Two blocks away from the Obelisk in Buenos Aires. Overcooked, per local custom, three chimichurris, creamed spinach and a bottle of Malbec. Under $40 US. Amazing.
Emotional_Ad5714@reddit
There are a lot of great steaks, so at some point, the atmosphere is what makes it the best ever.
For me I have 2 standouts. My bachelor party at Strip Steak at Mandalay Bay, and at my friend's bachelor party at Gibson's in Chicago. Both had great friends, and started with an Old Fashioned. I'll start with a side salad with 1000 Island, Oysters or a Shrimp Cocktail, the move on to a medium rare Ribeye or T-Bone with a glass of Malbec, a loaded baked potato. I'll finish the night with a Stinger or a Golden Cadillac and a cigar or cigarette.
FallenEagle1187@reddit
Carmine’s in St Louis. I knew I was in trouble when the menu didn’t have a price, it just said market rate. But it was a damn delicious steak. I paired it with Woodford Reserve Double Oaked. I can still remember how good that meal was.
Ppl_r_bad@reddit
Rare in Madison, WI and Evoke in Charlotte, NC
bdreamer642@reddit
Bone in ribeye at the jw marriott in marco island, florida. Served on a cutting board with broccoli and a loaded baled potato. Nothing has surpassed it, and I've been to some pretty good restaurants
AwarenessGreat282@reddit
The one I cooked. I've yet to beat it.
Shirleysspirits@reddit
Had phenomenal steaks at Keens and 801 in Omaha. Had a bottle of Masi Amarone with the ribeye at 801 and it was off the charts delicious. At Keens (been a few times) I don't remember the wine but it was Lagavulin or Balvenie followed by a Cab with either the ribeye or mutton.
Sorry-Government920@reddit
Tomahawk ribeye from my grill . I'm not great at getting steak the right temp bit nailed it on this huge ribeye perfect med rare
hungaryboii@reddit
Honestly my dads t-bone steaks on the big green egg are top notch, paired with a twice baked potatoes and a portobello mushroom with balsamic and minced garlic, I don't drink booze anymore so I had it with a good local cream soda
Dobby_Club_@reddit
Tortoise supper club in Chicago Then surprisingly Gibsons in Chicago
Ramius117@reddit
I cook it myself. Dry rub is just equal parts salt, pepper, paprika, garlic powder, onion powder. Let it sit for a few hours. Sear it in garlic butter and finish it in the oven. We like ribeyes but I've done the same to other cuts too
CupBeEmpty@reddit
Best one I had that I recall is my sister’s boyfriend doing them for a pre Christmas family get together. He’s an executive chef at a very nice place and so got them from a local farm that sources them and he cooked them to perfection.
As far as steakhouses go I rarely go to specific steakhouses but will order steak at nice restaurants sometimes. I’ve found over the years that it’s much better to go to a really good restaurant and order what looks best rather than going with the intent to just get steak.
Black Trumpet in Portsmouth is the one I remember being superb. St. Elmo’s in Indianapolis is the only specialty steakhouse I can recall going to in recent memory and it was great.
Seul7@reddit
Best I ever had was at my sister's wedding reception at a now out of business place called Cafe Jonelle in Fort Wayne, IN. You could cut it with a fork!
I had water with it
grynch43@reddit
St Elmo’s
FoxyLady52@reddit
Any kind of food tastes best when you’re starving and someone else cooks it.
rotatingfan360@reddit
House of Prime Rib in San Francisco. Well worth the price for the experience
Pernicious_Possum@reddit
At my house. Cooked sous vide, then seared in a carbon steel skillet. Second best was at my house. Cooked in a carbon steel skillet. I will NEVER order a steak in a restaurant. I go out to eat for things I can’t/won’t make at home
BoseSounddock@reddit
A5 wagyu picanha. It’s not fair to normal food that something could taste so good
KonaDog1408@reddit
If not at home, G&D in Columbia, Missouri.
slugo17@reddit
A locally sourced ribeye I cooked on a Weber Kettle.
ianfromdixon@reddit
I got a prime porterhouse, patted it dry, left it uncovered in the fridge for a day, salted and peppered it, and put it on the warm side of the grill for about 45 minutes, until it hit 115. Transferred it to a smoking, lightly oiled cast iron pan.
Cooked it for about 1 minute, flipped it, added a hunk of garlic and rosemary-infused butter, pulling it on and off the heat. Tilted the pan and used a spoon to scoop the melted butter over it again and again for about a minute. Flip again, remove from heat, scoop with seasoned butter.
Plate, let it sit for ten minutes.
Best steak I ever had. Porterhouse cost me about $38, $5 worth of charcoal and about $1 worth of seasoned butter. Served with caramelized onions, sautéed onions, and corn on the cob off the hot side of the grill.
Washed down with Ménage a Trois Silk Red Blend (about $7.99/bottle.)
RodenbachBacher@reddit
When I was a kid, my grandparents raised beef cattle on their farm. I hated eating it. As an adult, we buy locally produced beef, take our time cooking it, and it’s better than any restaurant I’ve been to. I’m not a particular steak guy, so to speak. But, the steak I make is my favorite.
Luckyangel2222@reddit
Alan’s Steakhouse in Las Vegas, Nevada!
Kitzle33@reddit
Small, obscure restaurant in Rochester Michigan called the Golden Eagle. It's a bit hit and miss, but when the New York strip is on, it's by far the best steak I've ever had. Period
notmyname2012@reddit
Ok, so I don’t remember the place but a little steak house in the middle of nowhere. I was 20-21 years old (I’m pushing 50 now). It was a filet mignon, first one I had ever had. I’ve had some amazing steaks since but I’ll tell you why it was the best.
Growing up my mom always cooked steaks WELL done, steak was always chewy but that’s how she made it. When we would go out to a restaurant my dad ALWAYS ordered them well done so that’s what we ordered as kids. My dad would say that’s the best way to eat them. My sis and I would always put ketchup on the steak to help chew it, as I got older I would occasionally do steak sauce.
Now as a young adult with a good friend of mine who took me to this restaurant with his other wealthy friends he suggested I get the filet and I was ordering and he quickly chimed in to say he’d like it medium rare then he glared at me to not say anything. After the waiter left he said that everyone at the table and the chef would be offended if I ordered it well done. I was confused but didn’t want to offend anyone.
I was hesitant as I cut into the red almost pink juicy meat, was I going to get food poisoning, would it taste terrible??? I took that first bite and the meat melted in my mouth and actually had SOO much flavor without any sauce or seasoning!! I was shocked. It was the most delicious thing ever.
I’ve never eaten a well done steak again. Years later I asked my mom why she cooked them well, she said my dad made her do it like that otherwise he was afraid he would get worms or food poisoning or something so most foods were over cooked. Which sucks because my mom was a good cook.
Then later I remembered my dad had always said “Red Meat is bad for you, that’s what the doctors say”. I finally asked him about that statement, his idiotic idea was that “red” meat it was unhealthy so if you cooked it til it was brown it was healthy. I wish I was making that up but seriously he thought it was the color and not that it was beef! Looking back at a lot of things, he wasn’t a smart man.
Baymavision@reddit
Prime 44 West at the Greenbriar Resort in West Virginia.
I've had a lot of great steaks, even made a few myself, but holy hell. This ribeye just melted in my mouth. It was perfectly and lightly seasoned, medium rare, great size.
It was absolutely the best steak I've ever had.
uberphaser@reddit
Even tho I do not like him, Bobby Flay's place in Caesars Palace was a holy shit moment for me.
Artimesia@reddit
The best steak I ever had was in Scotland. Delicious
audvisial@reddit
Omaha, NE - tie between Boiler Room and Au Courant.
solojones1138@reddit
A5 Wagyu at a street stall in Tokyo. Perfect medium rare. Unbelievably good.
the_funk_police@reddit
Hmm Maybe a veal chop special I got at Y.O. Ranch in Dallas. That, or a bone-in filet I got from the same place.
brian11e3@reddit
Fresh Elk steak cooked on the grill by my dad. We raised Elk, but we rarely ate the.
Gold-Leather8199@reddit
Was in Florida in the early 70s at the K Pac Tree restaurant, had a t bone that pulled apart with a fork, used my knife to butter buns
AnitaIvanaMartini@reddit
Peter Luger is good, but the very best is Jess & Jim’s Steakhouse in Martin City Missouri. I live in San Francisco and am tempted to fly to KC just to eat there again.
G00dSh0tJans0n@reddit
I’ll admit I am not a very good cook. I can make some perfectly serviceable meals for myself and my kids but nothing I make can really compare to the professionals you can find in any fine dining establishment or even any run of the mill Chili’s.
Dad said the best steak I ever had was one that I made myself over a campfire up in the mountains so it’s probably 20% that it was a great cut of meat, 70% the wood fire and high mountain air, and 10% any actual cooking skill.
LeSkootch@reddit
I was a vegan for a long long time and a few months after I gave it up I had my first steak. It was from a restaurant I worked at in Boston called Sonsie. Had a 16oz sirloin au poivre cooked rare. Was a fricken delight. This was back in the mid 00s and I was veggie/vegan for about 7 years. Best hunk of meat I've had. I rarely (no pun intended) eat steak or meat in general often these days but when I do I go for something special.
NPHighview@reddit
My wife, a veterinarian with meat inspection training, found some Prime porterhouse in a local store at Utility prices. We grilled it over charcoal and sage, and it was spectacular.
spilltojill@reddit
Peter Luger Brooklyn
SassyMoron@reddit
I've been to every famous NYC steak house and the best steak I've ever had was at Brother Sebastian's in Omaha. Been there 4-5 times over the years and it's always the best freaking meat I've ever tasted.
Traditional_Trust_93@reddit
Rare steak made by my grandfather at family gatherings.
blipsman@reddit
Either Bavette’s or Mastro’s in Chicago…
Dear_Milk_4323@reddit
At J-Prime Steakhouse in Austin TX
zRustyShackleford@reddit
I have a friend that can make a mean steak. The best streak I've had was at his house.
whybother5000@reddit
Peter Lugar’s in Brooklyn. The t-bone steak was perfection but the real breath taker was the beefsteak tomato and onion sliced and served with their house sauce. Chefs kiss.
dgrigg1980@reddit
Hunting camp over the campfire with my dad.
jahozer1@reddit
I sat next to a cattle farmer at a bar in Rochester Mn. He was from Texas, there getting cancer treatment at the Mayo Clinic. I was waiting for my wife to recover from a major surgery. We had time to kill.
I asked him what makes the best steaks. He said you've never had it. They split off the top 5 cows early. They go to him and his friends and family. They are the best of the best. The next in line go to high end chop houses like keenes. The next level goes to high end chains, like Sullivan's and Ruth's Chris. The rest to everyone else.
I've been lucky to have had some great steaks at places like Keens, Rothmans, Delfriscos, and others. Can't remember which I liked the best best I know I like a New York Strip dry aged. That hint of funk from the mold is just heaven.
Legend_017@reddit
I had a filet at Carson’s in Lexington Kentucky that was excellent, but the best steak I’ve ever had was made on a grill in the dark by my drunk friend. He determined it was done because “it smells done” and holy shit he was right.
twincitiessurveyor@reddit
The best steak I've ever had was in the dead of winter a couple miles out on Lake Mille Lacs.
ZealousidealPoem3977@reddit
Cooked it myself
DeFiClark@reddit
So …I’ve eaten well at Peter Luger’s, Smith & Wollensky, Wolfgang’s …
But the best steak I’ve eaten in the US in a restaurant that still exists was Bern’s in Tampa. Think the wine was Rubicon.
Second was at Hen of the Wood in Burlington VT.
Best wine with steak pairing ever was an Opus One tasting at Smith & Wollensky in Philadelphia.
Best steak I ever had though in a restaurant was at Julie’s in Horsham PA. Sadly gone but the most perfect ribeye I ever ate.
stevie855@reddit (OP)
Opus One! Rich man!
DeFiClark@reddit
Lucky man. I got an invite from a friend who sold restaurant furniture, or at least that’s what he told us.
chicagotim1@reddit
My dad's , at home on a grill has been the best steak I've ever had, but Swift & Sons in Chicago is a close second. Old fashioned aperitif , bottle of Pinot noir for two, and Irish coffee
ChessieChesapeake@reddit
Lewnes’ Steakhouse in Annapolis, MD. Old school classic steakhouse.
Tommy_Wisseau_burner@reddit
I was in Brazil and Peru and everywhere we went was god tier. In the US no idea. I don’t go anywhere fancy because I’m cheap
Texan2116@reddit
A RibEye from the Big Texan, in Amarillo Texas. This is the place with a "free" 72 oz steak , if you can eat it all.
I didn't try that, but e Ribeye I ate while I was there was incredible.
Washed it down w a Dr. Pepper.
lelocle1853@reddit
Best steak is made in my own backyard. Best steakhouse steak I’ve had is the porterhouse, rare, at Barclay Prime Philadelphia.
daveescaped@reddit
Best steak? Peabody’s in Birmingham, Michigan circa 2006 (before they closed). It was a filet. Rare. Oscar (lump crab and Bernaise and asparagus). Good sear. Actually rare. Well seasoned.
Best value steak? Market Street, Salt Lake City. 2002. Early Bird Special. $15 for a Prime Rib. At 5 pm they still had rare available. Best $15 piece of beef by far. Included a salad, soda, and dessert (Hagen Daz).
joepierson123@reddit
Cheese steak from the roach coaches
xmetalheadx666x@reddit
The A5 Wagyu cooked ishiyaki style at Bazaar Meats in Las Vegas. Had that with a nice woody bourbon as imo whiskeys are a better pairing with steak than wine.
Automatic_Air6841@reddit
The ones I make at home. Everyone’s else sucks ass. Cast iron is king.
Crowsfeet12@reddit
Had a damned good ribeye steak in Sisters, Oregon with a bunch of spears, roasted red potatoes and a salad. They put a blue cheese sauce on the steak… and a pint of stout.
ThriceHawk@reddit
Bavette's in Chicago. Unbelievable.
stevie855@reddit (OP)
What did you order?
ThriceHawk@reddit
Dy aged bone in ribeye with bearnaise.
Matchboxx@reddit
Well, I gotta break sub rules because it wasn’t here. But you didn’t explicitly make that a rule.
I’m a picky eater and only speak English. My wife is French Canadian and we went to a little place in Quebec City, Les Affaires des Ketchup. You have to make reservations months in advance because they only have 3 tables and a kitchen like you’d have in your house. The menu changes daily. I don’t speak French but I smelled a good steak nearby and gestured that I wanted it. It came with vegetables I couldn’t identify but it was the best steak I ever had and the vegetables were so tender and flavorful.
Finally the manager comes by and he speaks English. He asked how I enjoyed my venison, beets, and Brussels sprouts - 3 things I would die before eating if they’d told me that’s what they were. But it wasn’t gamey at all and the veggies were fantastic. 12/10. I’ve toyed with the idea of flying back just for dinner but it’s so built up in my head now that they probably can’t meet my impossible expectations now.
But anyway best steak in the US is the A5 wagyu at Gordon Ramsay in Las Vegas’ Paris hotel, fight me.
dgmilo8085@reddit
Tough to beat the one I had last night in Kyoto. A Wagyu ribeye done to perfection.
tirewisperer@reddit
A bone-in Fillet Mignon at Alfred’s in SF.
NarrowAd4973@reddit
Honestly, the best steak I ever had was at a bar in Gdinia, Poland. Girl really knew how to cook a steak. Almost seemed like I could cut it with the fork, and it tasted amazing.
Second best was Hard Rock Cafe in Key West.
platoniclesbiandate@reddit
The Beefmaster Inn in Wilson, NC. The meat and the experience. It ain’t fancy though:
https://www.ourstate.com/beefmastor-inn/
CashWideCock@reddit
I like Texas Roadhouse.
Oceanbreeze871@reddit
I had a flight of Wagu and Kobe at a some high end restaurant in San Francisco. I wasn’t paying for it…somebody else was expensing it.
It was pretty good. Not worth $250 or whatever it cost
Jobless0321@reddit
Ruth’s Chris while in Jacksonville FL on business. Plate comes scalding hot so steak stays warm until finished. I cook a great steak myself, but their ribeye is hard to beat.
My “wine pairing” was a double Jameson neat.
BeachAdjacent@reddit
A bone-in Delmonico steak from 22 Bowen's in Newport, RI. Can't remember the wine, but probably a pinot noir.
someolive2@reddit
best steak i had was in southern italy in a town called carovigno.
stevie855@reddit (OP)
Was it from Braceria Pomodor?! I was there once and it was sublime!
someolive2@reddit
yes it was! did you head to moon after dinner as well? haha
TheDeaconAscended@reddit
No wine, but at one point Strip House in NY had the best steak for a short period of time 15 years ago. Hawkmoor and Wolfgang’s are tied for second best. No wine for me though.
BensOnTheRadio@reddit
The Dining Car on Amtrak.
oldkafu@reddit
They didn't ask the most expensive.
Fun-Lengthiness-7493@reddit
San Francisco. 1990s. Harris’s Steakhouse. Dinner date with my now wife. I order a double Jameson on the rocks, feeling like I’m Sam Spade in the Maltese Falcon. The waitress brings me a vase of Irish whiskey and I say, “wow!” like a newbie (I was). The waitress, all brass and sauce, says, “Honey. Guys drink three of those at lunch and go back to City Hall.”
The steak—appropriately aged—was divine.
QuarterNote44@reddit
Never really been to a fancy steakhouse. So the best I've ever had came from my kitchen. 2 hours in the sous vide at 130°F, reverse seared in butter.
fenrirwolf1@reddit
Niku Steakhouse in SF
Bored_Dad_Scrolling@reddit
Gibsons in Chicago lived up to the hype
Vernon’s speakeasy in Albuquerque is great if you’re ever in the area.
I prefer a Fleming’s over Ruth’s Chris for big chains.
Not a steak but pork ribs from Terry Blacks in Austin is top tier meat.
Sorry not a wine drinker
TheLonelySnail@reddit
Wouldn’t you like to know….
Really it was a ribeye at the Sycamore Inn in Rancho Cucamonga CA.
http://www.thesycamoreinn.com
Cake_Donut1301@reddit
It was at Gene and Georgettis in Chicago. Or else some place in Mexico around Oaxaca.
Malcolm_Y@reddit
Probably the 1872 Ribeye at Molly's Landing in Catoosa, OK
Xavier-Cross@reddit
Prime Quarter in Wisconsin and Illinois. But only if I pay the extra $2 for them to cook it. If I do it on my own, it always turns out crap.
MaleficentCoconut594@reddit
Tough call.
Best steak ever? Costa Rica, specifically at the Dreams Las Mareas resort. It was like butter, and so juicy. Probably because it was probably one of the cows wandering the streets in front of the resort a few hours prior (kidding, although I can’t be sure and there were a ton of cows on the roads)
Best steak in the US? Tough call, I’ve been to some really good steakhouses
League-Ill@reddit
Como, Mississippi
robertwadehall@reddit
Some of the best have been at Mastro’s in Scottsdale and Newport Beach and at Marble Room in Cleveland.
BippidiBoppetyBoob@reddit
I'm not really a big steak guy (I tend to prefer seafood or burgers at places like that), but the best one I ever had was a Bison filet with some gorgonzola and garlic truffle fries at Eddie Merlot's in Pittsburgh. My favorite part of that meal though was the dessert. This delicious peanut butter cup pie thing that they made. The last time I went there, they'd stopped offering blue cheese with steak, so I ended up getting something else.
RunnerGirlT@reddit
Two best steaks I’ve had.
1) a butcher shop/restaurant in Austin called Salt and Thyme
2) Jeffries steak house, also in Austin
AntiSombrero@reddit
Best steak I ever had was one my now wife made me while staying at her parents cabin. We had made sausage in the cast iron that morning and cooked the steak in the grease. It was absolutely incredible. I've had plenty of steaks all over in the years since, but have never forgotten that one.
Bungalow_Man@reddit
Best steak I ever had was from Peter Luger. I don't drink wine, but it went down good with the Luger Lager.
2nd best was from The Drover in Omaha with a Fairy Nectar hazy IPA.
stinson16@reddit
Best steak I ever had was in Lisbon. Tasca da Esquina. I'm not big on steak, it's usually too dry and chewy, even when medium-rare. But this was so tender, juicy, and mostly tasted like butter in the best way possible.
Rj924@reddit
The best steaks come from a quality local butcher, and are cooked by your friend Steve on his patio.
whatintheactualfeth@reddit
Porterhouse at Wolf Lodge in Coeur d'Alene Idaho. Cooked over a tamarack fire with a baker, buckaroo beans, and krebel bread. The whole meal is worth it for the beans alone, but everything else is just as good.
It burned down last year. We're hoping that they rebuild but haven't heard anything.
ilovepoop7@reddit
Tokyo skytree musashi restaurant kobe beef
No-Asparagus-5122@reddit
I’m going to Tokyo in Oct so maybe I’ll check it out! Ty
Chuckles52@reddit
It was a medium rare steak at the Pink Elephant in Marquette, IA. Sometime in the 1960's. It was aged. You could cut it with a fork.
msabeln@reddit
The White Mule Winery in Owensville, Missouri is known for its good steaks. Yum.
joemoore38@reddit
On a bet, I ate a 48oz porterhouse at Manny's in Minneapolis. To this day, despite the size, it's the best steak I've ever eaten. We like a lot of the higher end chains like Capital Grille, Ruth's Chris, Morton's etc. and none of them have measured up to that 48oz beast. You would think a monster like that couldn't possibly be cooked properly but it was magnificent Midwest beef.
Hikinghawk@reddit
I was about 12 miles in on a canoe trip, tired as hell, salt and pepper over a campfire. 12/10 nothing has compared.
SlamClick@reddit
Even the powdered garlic mashed potatoes are fire in those instances.
Gecko23@reddit
I wish I knew the restaurants name…but I was on a business trip and went to a Japanese restaurant somewhere near Pittsburgh. The wait staff were all local women dressed in kimonos. Interior was very plain.
The customer ordered for me, with a trust me kind of deal, and they brought out a perfect, melt in your mouth ribeye sliced thin, and topped with a sweet and sour mustard sauce of some kind. I still dream about that steak and it was thirty years ago.
More recently the best was also a ribeye at Jeff Ruby’s in Columbus, OH. Just cooked to perfection.
Master-CylinderPants@reddit
I have a sous vide and an offset smoker, and there's a cow farm a few roads over. The best steak I've had is the one I do up on my porch.
brzantium@reddit
Best steak I ever had was a bacon-wrapped filet mignon at a friend's wedding years ago.
Pabst_Malone@reddit
Kid down the street had a show steer, gave that fucker a 10 day hang, and a nice SPG sesh on the grill. Best goddamn beef I’ve ever had, and I’ve spent my entire life in the beef industry.
Opposite-Peak5020@reddit
It's been 25 years so I don't remember the name of the place, but it was a restaurant inside of Circus Circus in Vegas. It was the best steak I've ever eaten.
GrimSpirit42@reddit
The Chop House on Magazine Street in New Orleans. Take out a mortgage before you go.
Old Hickory Steak House in Columbus Mississippi. It’s an old, repurposed Pizza Hutt. We picked it because it was surrounded by POS pick-up trucks. Your only choices are what cut of steak, how you want it cooked and whether you want cheese on your side salad. Drink options are water, sweet tea and three different brands of canned beer. They ONLY serve steak. No chicken, no fish, no tofu.
SomethingClever70@reddit
I cook a steak as good as anything you can get in a steakhouse. Just need a cast iron pan, a good quality piece of beef, seasoning of your choice, a timer and thermometer.
I’ve been to many steakhouses where to steak was good, but the service sucked. Again, cooking a steak is easy, but running a restaurant well is another thing. If you’re eating out, get something you can’t make at home.
UnderstandingDry4072@reddit
At a totally random mom’n’pop Italian place in Alliance, OH: Polinori’s Palm Garden Inn. Legit amazing.
pinniped90@reddit
My favorite steak is off my own grill, but at a restaurant, Anton's in Kansas City is pretty fire.
Ambitious-Sale3054@reddit
Morton’s Steakhouse in Atlanta and Capital Grill in Atlanta(Buckhead)
Valuable-Life3297@reddit
Best steak was at home. My husband made a wagyu on the grill. It melted like damn butter. Perfectly seared on the outside. The salt and fat were just out of this world
rockandroller@reddit
I had a transformative steak at Ray's the Steaks in Atlanta back in the early 2000s. While I do not remember the exquisite wine pairing, I also cannot forget the bone marrow app that preceeded the steak.
I see that they closed in 2019. I'm so glad I got to have that experience. Amazing food, great company, and it was all paid for as I was on a work trip. Can't beat that.
OldRaj@reddit
Peterson’s in Fishers, IN.
tepid_fuzz@reddit
Right out of my own kitchen, from a grass finished steer raised by us on our place. Do it up on the cast iron, finish with a butter baste and salt, let it rest and get after it nice and rare. Lord!
BobsleddingToMyGrave@reddit
Touch of garlic and oregano mmmmm
lanfear2020@reddit
Berns Steakhouse in Tampa Florida, I still think about it and the table side Caesar salad. No idea on wine but they have an enormous wine cellar
SeparateMongoose192@reddit
Probably Ruth's Chris in Philadelphia. I don't drink wine so I can't tell you what wine I had.
BobsleddingToMyGrave@reddit
Grass fed from 3 farms over. Ribeye served with a Cesar salad and a big glass of ice water.
Adept_Thanks_6993@reddit
I haven't been to many steakhouses, but my dad made a good one. Always rare.
I prefer beer or cider but if I'm having wine I prefer champagne, or a qevri.
Jaqen-Atavuli@reddit
Restaurant: Filet at Hal's in Atlanta.
Cooked: Ribeye we cooked camping over a nuclear bed of oak wood coals.
TheBimpo@reddit
The best steak that I have ever had was cooked on my Weber kettle in my backyard.
The best steakhouse that I have ever been to is the El Gaucho in Seattle: https://elgaucho.com/seattle/ It’s a classic spot, dark and romantic.
ShiraPiano@reddit
Selanne's Steakhouse in Laguna Beach, CA.
andrew2018022@reddit
I’m basic. Probably Fogo de Chao
halforange1@reddit
Not a huge fan of steak at restaurants, even steakhouses. I read Kenji Alt-Lopez’s Food Lab (a nerdy cookbook). Just follow the directions in the chapter on steak and you can cook your own cuts better than a restaurant.
Shellsaidso@reddit
The best I’ve ever had in a restaurant was Pappas Bros in Houston. The service was exceptional too. We have great steaks at home on the Webber too though.
jluvdc26@reddit
Tavern on the Green in Central Park NYC back in 1999. I don't remember the wine, but it was really good too. It was a magical trip so that might influence my memory of it!
curlyhead2320@reddit
My dad took me to Keen’s for my birthday many years ago and it was fantastic.
qu33nof5pad35@reddit
Del Frisco’s
GotWheaten@reddit
Ore House - Durango CO. We went there for our honeymoon in 2009. Steak was absolutely the best one I have ever had. Wife really liked hers too.
WaveOk2181@reddit
Cattleman's Club Steakhouse outside of Pierre, SD. Served with caramelized onions and a Bud, after a long day of working outside. I've been to fancy steakhouses, but the simplicity of an extremely well cooked, beatiful cut of meat that was raised in a posture less than 10 miles from where it was eaten can't be beat.
HorseFeathersFur@reddit
My friend’s farm. We had fresh t-bones. Home grown. Yum.
MrLongWalk@reddit
Best steak I ever had was one dad fried for me, no occasion and nothing special about it but he simply hit it out of the park.
deleted_by_reddit@reddit
[removed]
AutoModerator@reddit
The use of URL shorteners on this subreddit is prohibited. Please repost your link without the use of a url shortener
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.