Honestly - how much do you REALLY care about The Beatles?
Posted by CompetitiveCod76@reddit | Xennials | View on Reddit | 67 comments

IMO their music was sickly and bland. None of them were particularly good looking. Just not my thing.
I totally get that some people adore them and that they are culturally important. In the 90s/00s folk were all like 'I LOVE the Beatles' but usually it was just to sound edgy and cool - challenge them to name 3 songs and they'd struggle.
FOUR biopics seems a bit much. I'll watch the Paul Mescal one but only cos, y'know, Paul Mescal. And maybe the Barry Keoghan one to see if he gets his knob out again 🍆
carriestewbert@reddit
I guess I’m in the minority here, but I love The Beatles. They’ve been my favorite band since the early 90s when I started looking for an alternative to grunge and other popular music at that time.
I’m not, however, even remotely interested in these biopics. They just seem incredibly unnecessary. And the actors don’t even remotely resemble the members they’ve been cast to play. Going to be a pass for me.
IceSmiley@reddit
I love them and spent DAYS downloading their entire catalog in the Napster days. I've actually just been watching that amazing documentary The Compleat Beatles that Malcolm McDowell narrated in the 80s.
Significant_Dog412@reddit
There's plenty of 60s music I'd choose over them, but I get why The Beatles were a big deal and will probably matter forever.
primabelladonna35@reddit
My dad was a huge Beatles fan and I was raised on them. Love their music. Not sure why the biopic needed or why they didn't pick people that look like the band...but CGI exists I guess.
TheREALBaldRider@reddit
My dad was also a huge fan and I don’t need to ever hear them again. I don’t even care for ELO because they were so influenced by them.
Mountain-Fox-2123@reddit
I think its one of the greatest bands in history.
But i am not interested in this movie.
Neither-Mycologist77@reddit
Apparently my grandfather used to call the Beatles "yeah yeah music."
epidemicsaints@reddit
I've had music from that generation forced on me my whole life and I would like to see some peace before death.
OllieFromCairo@reddit
And yet, I bet none of it was Sister Rosetta Tharpe.
Absolutely the best song of 1964: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Y9a49oFalZE
bloomdecay@reddit
Jesus christ, her voice. Incredible.
OllieFromCairo@reddit
Yeah. She’s the real thing man. Deserves to be a legend
epidemicsaints@reddit
Her coat!!!!
OllieFromCairo@reddit
Her SG!
One-Earth9294@reddit
This right here.
I have my own list of greats. I know what the Beatles are responsible for I hate how they try to give you 'the Beatles lecture' if you ever say you don't like them a whole lot.
I love George Harrison, though. He bankrolled some of my favorite films. I think he was the real 'artiste' of the group.
Known-Fee9113@reddit
Yes. I love The Beatles and appreciate their influence on so much music that came after them. I'll probably watch the biopics but don't think they're necessary.
RJRoyalRules@reddit
We grew up in a boomer pop culture dictatorship where the importance of the music that they liked when they were young was super overblown, the Beatles being the quintessential example. I respect the Beatles and their music, but this idea that they're so vastly important beyond anyone else is I think just more boomer cultural supremacy. As a kid the boomer music I gravitated towards was Pink Floyd and the Beach Boys, and to this day I'm still 100 times more likely to listen to the latter two than the Beatles.
My parents were also incredibly disrespectful towards any music that I liked and never showed any interest in anything made after the mid-1970s, aside from dull adult contemporary background music, a posture I always found to be myopic and sort of indicative of how self-indulgent they were about their youth.
illini02@reddit
I'm black. My mom was all about Motown, so that is where my 60s music knowledge lies. Its what I heard growing up.
As a fan of music in general, I know the Beatles and their music. I like some of their songs. I respect their importance in music.
But I don't really care that much.
cloisterbells-10@reddit
My mom had a robust collection of both Motown records (particularly the girl groups of the era) and Beatles albums. As a kid, maybe I just preferred hearing women singing, but I distinctly remember getting chills to "Love Child*" by Diana Ross and the Supremes. I like some of the Beatles' stuff, but it never gave me goosebumps by how good it is.
*Also on brand for me as a child listening to adult music, but I had no idea what a "love child" was and thought it was about poor people in love.
Linfords_lunchbox@reddit
We seem to be going through a "Beatles were over rated" phase in popular opinion. Trends will change and they'll be lauded again in a few years.
TiEmEnTi@reddit
Their music is incredible and historic. But like with most other musicians/celebrities I couldn't care less about their personal life or the process of making their art. I'd rather just enjoy the art.
HerRoyalRedness@reddit
I’m a huge fan. I think this is an attempt to do what The Beatles Anthology did for us - create a generation of fans.
DrMcJedi@reddit
I listened to their stuff, but was never one of those “er mah gherd” fans (we all knew someone like that in high school, yes?).
Honestly, the only time I really think about them is when another documentary or Pepperidge Farms member-berry thing pops up every few years, and the die hards come out of the woodwork to downvote any neutral or slightly negative comments about them…
CompetitiveCod76@reddit (OP)
YES.
djhyland@reddit
I recognize that the Beatles are one of, if not THE, most influential bands of all time. Without their output the musical world would be a very different place. But I couldn't care less if I never heard another Beatles song in my life. I don't hate them, but I don't get the hype.
Quenzayne@reddit
I was never a particularly big fan. I always found them pretty overrated, really, at least in a purely musical sense—but I suppose if you were there in 1964 when they burst onto the music scene then it was probably a pretty big moment and you can’t deny their impact on music.
But, just the songs themselves, meh…nothing special. It gets pretty annoying listening to Boomers gush over them.
UpkeepUnicorn@reddit
I care about The Beatles very much. They became an obsession at one point. Their music is timeless and speaks to me still. I can't imagine liking The Beatles being edgy and cool beyond the time they were active though. If you're asking if I hate the casting choices, the answer is yes.
PuppyJakeKhakiCollar@reddit
I have always been a casual fan. I really only know their most popular hits and like a lot of those, but that's as far as I ever got. Let It Be is one of my all time favorite songs. My brother was the one that was super into them and had all the albums, etc. He even named his cat John Winston.
sitnquiet@reddit
I'm not a huge fan by any means, but some of the recent biopics have been pretty amazing - Rocketman and Bohemian Rhapsody - if they are on that scale, I would be happy to give them a watch. A film that puts them in their time and place, plus charts their influence with songs I recognize and characters I can adore, would be great.
However, I'm going to be quite happy with Yesterday (2019) if that's not an opinion that will be downvoted to hell here!
CompetitiveCod76@reddit (OP)
Tbh I'm biopic'ed out and they're so sanitised you don't feel like you're getting the real story. Love Amy Winehouse but her one is case in point.
Rocketman was good. All time fave is the Tina Turner one.
sitnquiet@reddit
Yeah I get it - I don't watch many movies so I'm not quite at your stage. (I'm kind of avoiding the Robbie Williams one - what did you think of it?)
Should I look up the Amy Winehouse one? I thought that would be a great story.
I will check out the Tina Turner.
CompetitiveCod76@reddit (OP)
Awful. The documentary was okay though (think that came out last year?). Skip the Winehouse one and go straight to Tina.
sitnquiet@reddit
Beauty - thanks kindly.
Far_Cut_@reddit
We had to learn all their big songs in music class in Jr High.
ace_11235@reddit
Since they are one of the best (or best in my opinion) bands ever and influenced the sound of popular music for decades, I’d say lots of people care. Now, do I need a biopic? No, probably not. I prefer the Beatles Get Back doc, and Beatles 64. I don’t need to see actors playing them.
Bomb-Number20@reddit
Same, I am more interested in seeing documentaries than biopics. I tend not to watch biopics because they over dramatize things, and change details to suit their telling.
JadeDragonMeli@reddit
For me, one of the most overrated groups in history and I have no interest watching a biopic about them.
The Rolling Stones were better imo
ModBabboo@reddit
Love the Beatles. '60s rock and soul nights at the club became a favourite pastime of mine in my mid-20s and I've adored the music ever since.
gnark1lla420@reddit
Don't really care much for them. I will listen to a few tracks from The White Album if I do listen to them but rarely
BRUISE_WILLIS@reddit
Hated the Beatles since I was a teen. I’m sure their stuff was groundbreaking in the early 60s, but it’s been run into the ground since the late 80s.
FreezingRobot@reddit
They call this the Seinfeld Effect, something groundbreaking gets copied so often that newcomers no longer see the original as anything special.
OllieFromCairo@reddit
Haha! They called it "The Beatles Effect" before Seinfeld was even on the air!
BRUISE_WILLIS@reddit
Shakespeare too
dw617@reddit
Exactly. I recognize them being influencial and ground breaking, but just not for me. They have one or two catchy songs, the rest are annoying.
ace_11235@reddit
What do you mean run into the ground?
Jonestown_Juice@reddit
I respect the Beatles and credit them for basically paving the way for all of the music I *do* love, but I don't actively listen to them myself.
CompetitiveCod76@reddit (OP)
Yeah that's a good way of putting it.
OllieFromCairo@reddit
Not a lick.
I appreciate their influence, but I'm never going to sit down and listen to their stuff.
MelodiousPun@reddit
A LOT. Best band ever.
woojo1984@reddit
Innovators and influencer of many.
Bomb-Number20@reddit
There is a pretty direct line from most modern alternative/indie/experimental rock straight back to the Beatles.
Zesty_Low5079@reddit
Not one bit
ElectrumDragon28@reddit
Not in the slightest.
blellowbabka@reddit
When the anthologies came out, it really sparked my interest in music. There was a year in my teens when they were all I would listen too. As an adult I can see I got swept up in boomer nostalgia a bit, but their music still holds up. The hate they get now seems a little pick me tbh
js4873@reddit
I love the Beatles. Abbey Road of my top 10 albums of all time.
snwbrdngtr@reddit
I appreciate them for what they did for music. I’ve never been a fan though
Dimplefrom-YA@reddit
they all look like harry potter
matolandio@reddit
none.
Vox_Mortem@reddit
My mom's boyfriend bought me a best of The Beatles tape when I was like ten. It was because it's the only music he liked. I hated that tape after a very short time. I ended up using it to "make tinsel."
upnytonc@reddit
I like the Beatles. I don’t LOVE them. But their music is good and there’s no denying they were very influential. I do NOT understand the old footage of girls just screaming and losing their minds over them. I’ll watch a biopic of them but we don’t need 4.
RoncoSnackWeasel@reddit
Not at all. I know they did stuff for music, but I thing they’re overrated.
CompetitiveCod76@reddit (OP)
Same. Overrated is the word.
cloudydays2021@reddit
I go through phases of listening to them a lot/barely listening to them at all. Can’t deny their immense influence, but I don’t need to see one movie, let alone four movies, about them.
gbyrd013@reddit
The best band ever but biopics usually aren’t very good.
glassArmShattering@reddit
I respect them in a historical sense, but would be happy to never hear a song again in my life.
laurenishere@reddit
I have a friend who was all "I LOOOVE THE BEATLES" throughout high school and college, and then one day when we were in our 20s, I had Abbey Road on when we were in my car, and she was like, "This CD is so weird, who IS this?"
I realized she, like many people, just had the Beatles Number 1s CD (and that's fine!)
I do enjoy Beatles backstories / lore / theories, so I'll probably watch these. I'm not overjoyed by the casting, though.
brokedownbusted@reddit
Love them, they're the best, deserve every bit of their reputation. I rarely watch biopics though lol they're usually absurd if you're familiar with the subject already
DiscordianStooge@reddit
I like the Beatles a lot. I'd enjoy a biopic about the band. I'm not sure I'll watch 4.