What are the most overrated/underrated American sports franchises?
Posted by sequeno@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 183 comments
Posted by sequeno@reddit | AskAnAmerican | View on Reddit | 183 comments
Ranger_Prick@reddit
People have rightly nailed the Cowboys pick for overrated, so I'll add the New York Knicks. The sports media has held them up as a team ready to blow up for decades, yet they haven't won a championship in 52 years.
For underrated, I'll say the Denver Broncos. They have three Super Bowl wins and another five appearances, but they don't often get mentioned in the same breath as the Patriots or Steelers or Packers (or Cowboys for that matter).
MrRaspberryJam1@reddit
I’ll mention the NY Rangers too, I’m a fan myself. They’re basically the hockey Knicks. They have less of a championship drought, but they won one Stanley Cup (94) in 80+ years. The Rangers are still at the center of media attention, which is expected being an original six team, and playing in NY in Madison Square Garden. They often attract big free agents and players are always linked to the Rangers in trades.
The media and the fans expectations are high and sometimes even unrealistic, but the team often fails to meet them. They’ve had some good teams in the last 15 or so years but have never been able to quite get over the hump. Throughout that time there’s been a lot of turnover with coaches and the front office and players.
Intelligent_League_1@reddit
LGR!
rockninja2@reddit
As a Broncos fan, I appreciate it! Although since 2012 and the Peyton Manning deal, we have had a bit more national media attention, especially in 2013 and 2015 the Broncos (and often Colorado as a whole) has seemingly been included in the "flyover state" category (even the 2007 Rockies seemed to be quickly forgotten about). With home games across all sports, we should seem to have a home-field advantage, and yet we never seem to progress very far in title races or have very bad luck at the wrong times even with historically good players. Hopefully our luck is changing for the better again with Bo Nix with the Broncos, Jokic and now Westbrook with the Nuggets, and the Avs.
ColossusOfChoads@reddit
I chalk that up to so many important media personalities being from, or based in, New York. It's like how most of us would never hear much about New Jersey if it wasn't for New York dunking on them.
wormbreath@reddit
And Bo is gonna get us another!!
datsyukianleeks@reddit
So typically American that everyone answers with only nfl teams.
My vote for underrated is the Detroit Red Wings. The best American franchise in a league no Americans give a shit about. Had a 25 year playoff streak in which they won 4 cups. Taught the NHL how to draft and develop European talent. Assembled the first all Russian 5 man lineup. And nobody cares because it's hockey and it's Detroit.
Overrated...yeah the cowboys take the crown easily.
rabbifuente@reddit
Hard to say a team that hasn’t made the playoffs in nearly ten years is underrated
datsyukianleeks@reddit
Spoken like someone from Chicago.
Stop_Already@reddit
Overrated: Blackhawks of the NHL
The way they handled the Kyle Beach incident is freakin’ appalling. The organization is disgusting.
That they were given the #1 pick soon after makes me ill.
miketugboat@reddit
Underrated goes to the Orioles! One of the best and most iconic stadiums, and even this year their payroll is 15th out of 30, but they punch above their weight (always have).
Plus two years ago their payroll was 29th out of 30th. New ownership means they're finally willing to spend to keep talent, and have added something like $70 million a year to their payroll for the last couple years. I have a strong belief they will win the world series in the next couple seasons.
I'm not big on many of my sports teams but wow are we looking up!
Stop_Already@reddit
Camden Yards is GORGEOUS. The first of the “new stadiums designed to look and feel like old stadiums” and they nailed it.
Wontbackdowngator@reddit
The cowboys are vastly overrated the haven’t been a true Super Bowl contender since the 90’s yet we still treat them like the biggest brand in the NFl.
wetcornbread@reddit
The Cowboys are overhyped by the media because they’re extremely popular. I’m an Eagles fan but every Cowboys fan I know understands that as long as Jerry Jones is pulling the strings, nothing will change.
That’s why I laugh when people think the NFL is scripted. Roger Goodell would probably love if Dallas at the very least made it to a Super Bowl in the last 30 seasons.
The Steelers and 49ers are close behind them. Although Steeler fans acknowledge this typically. My friend always says “I don’t listen to predictions for the Steelers because I already know what’s going to happen, we’re going to go 1-2 wins above .500 and lose in the Wild Card, because that’s what happens every freaking year…”
Doover__@reddit
I know I’m biased as a Steelers fan, but we’ve won two Super Bowls since either the cowboys or the 49er have won one, so it makes sense we’re highly rated. But yeah we’re going to suck until can get a good qb.
Formo1287@reddit
The same thing we do every ~~night~~ season, Pinky
brizia@reddit
Overrated: New York Rangers, Chicago Blackhawks Florida Panthers
Underrated: NHL teams in smaller markets.
TheLastRulerofMerv@reddit
I don't know if Chicago is over rated. They're bottom dwellers in the league right now and not many expected otherwise this season.
brizia@reddit
They’re overrated because of the way they hyped up Bedard.
abcdefghijkistan@reddit
Overrated: MLB: Mets NFL: Cowboys NHL: Blackhawks NCAAF: Notre Dame NCAAB: Indiana
Underrated: MLB: Brewers (feel like TB is properly rated at this point) NFL: Ravens NHL: Devils NCAAF: Iowa NCAAB: Purdue
YaBoiSVT@reddit
I do like watching the brewers play. Since you guys aren’t in our division I’ll root for yall 🤣
YaBoiSVT@reddit
Overrated: probably either the Cowboys or the Yankees.
Underrated: Seattle Mariners. I’m biased because I’m a fan but we have actual talent but our managers are constantly shifting the bed
No-Conversation1940@reddit
The Athletics (their official name now, they don't claim a city) have 9 World Series championships and are one of the most decorated teams in baseball - but they don't seem that way because their ownership is so petty, slipshod, and miserly.
YaBoiSVT@reddit
It’s also difficult when your management is constantly shifting on the fans and either refusing or not being able to sign real talent.
Traditional_Trust_93@reddit
Vikings are underrated. We're gonna win this year for sure...
december151791@reddit
It's a rebuilding year right?
SirGirthfrmDickshire@reddit
Motorsports. It's a dying sport because Karens are getting tracks shutdown.
oodja@reddit
The Yankees are still coasting on the 20th century, no matter how much they science their bats up.
boulevardofdef@reddit
Literally ONE World Series win in this century. They're perpetually good -- insanely enough, they haven't had a losing season since 1992 -- but George Steinbrenner would never have tolerated that.
Extreme-Interview173@reddit
Two, 2000 and 2009
7Pats@reddit
2000 is not this century
Extreme-Interview173@reddit
Fair
ColossusOfChoads@reddit
At first I thought that was a Sammy Sosa reference, but then I remembered he never played for them.
Additional-Software4@reddit
Overrated: Las Vegas Raiders
Haven't won in 40 years and their home games are overwhelmed with opposing fans despite their supposed legion of fans in Los Angeles only a 4 hour drive (or cheap 1 hour flight) away
coysbville@reddit
They're not overrated. Everyone knows they suck. They're like the Browns. It's pretty common knowledge.
ColossusOfChoads@reddit
Doesn't help that you can go to the beach during the months when people in a lot of the big football cities are already having to scrape ice off their windshields.
IAmDJWithoutTheDots@reddit
I am no fan but old Raiders gear always looks sick when I see someone wearing it in public
coysbville@reddit
I agree, black and silver might be the hardest,color scheme in sports. Add an eyepatch and football helmet donning raider and two cutlass, and you got a logo that transsexuals transcends generations. Been running the same one since the 60s.
ColossusOfChoads@reddit
Former Vegas resident there. That was by design, but apparently the Davis family didn't get the memo.
A bunch of guys with disposable income fly in from Cincinatti, dragging their wives with them, and two nights later a decent sized divot has been whacked out of their bankroll? The Raiders may have lost, but Vegas wins.
misterlakatos@reddit
The Raiders fan base in LA is mostly Gen Xers and Boomers at this point. While they still have a strong presence in Southern California, it will not last forever. The Rams fan base has been growing and will continue to grow.
NicklAAAAs@reddit
I hate the Raiders as much as the next Broncos fan, but their main fanbase being a 4 hour drive from where they play is hardly a “despite”.
kirkl3s@reddit
Most overrated is theCowboys by far. One of the most valuable sports franchises in the world and they haven’t been very good in decades.
jarlander@reddit
Who rates the cowboys highly? Im a fan but I live in Texas, outside of my area everyone seems to hate the cowboys. In person and on TV/Radio. Im cool with that, I dont care who other fans hate, I just wonder if at this point they arent overrated as much as they are just infamous.
minnick27@reddit
The Cowboys are the New York Yankees of the NFL. Their merch sales are off the charts Around the world. I live in Philadelphia and even though they are our most hated rival, I see their hat more than any other team except for the Eagles
ColossusOfChoads@reddit
Yeah, but the Yankees win?
jarlander@reddit
That is very odd to me. Im very much a root for your local teams person.
Beachbum313@reddit
The thing to keep in mind is that there are a ton of media markets in the US where a good number of people live but who don’t have their own professional team, which leaves them open to various broadcasts around the country. Love them or hate them, the Cowboys are a team that have historically performed decently on the field and a lot of people have watched a lot of in the past, which makes them an attractive option for the NFL to slot into media markets like this (think of places like Portland, Oregon or Albuquerque, New Mexico or Little Rock, Arkansas). If they’re not the clear home team being shown in media markets like Dallas or Austin or San Antonio, and if they’re not the rival visiting team being shown in places like New York, Philadelphia, Washington, San Francisco, or Los Angeles, they’ll likely just be the closest team in general, which means that they’ve got a lot of geographic area that broadcasts they are a part of cover, and therefor gain fans from- when you’re either the most watched or second most watched team in 6 entire states and portions of another 23, it’s fair to say that you’ve got fans everywhere, regardless of who plays locally. Over the last several decades, those fans have moved around the country, started families and gained friends in just about every part of the country at this point and have spread their fandom, to the point where it’s not an uncommon thing to see cowboys fans outside of Texas.
boomgoesthevegemite@reddit
Nobody hates the Cowboys more than Cowboys fans.
ColossusOfChoads@reddit
Just like with Star Wars.
Wizzmer@reddit
That's me! I think I could love them again, if the fucking Arkansas family would just leave!
boomgoesthevegemite@reddit
Jerruh is going to die before anything changes.
kirkl3s@reddit
Hate and underrate are two different things. In the NFL, teams are usually hated because they are good. For some reason, people have clung to their hatred of the Cowboys since the 90s
Popular-Local8354@reddit
The Cowboys could go zero and 17 for the next 30 years and people will still despise them
agsieg@reddit
Jerry Jones
lundebro@reddit
I was going to say, hardly anybody rates the Cowboys highly. They receive a ton of media attention, but a huge chunk of it is not positive, lol.
OsvuldMandius@reddit
Good lord, winning has nothing to do with it! Forbes ranks the Chicago Cubs as the 4th most valuable MLB franchise, and they went 110 years between championships!
Conchobair@reddit
Dallas Cowboys are the epitome of all hat and no cattle.
DreamsAndSchemes@reddit
The Cowboys are a 53 man advertising agency that happens to show up at football games and play
lorgskyegon@reddit
Do they, though?
Agonze@reddit
Fuck jerry jones
hooplafromamileaway@reddit
Calling yourself, "America's Team," is like a shitty rock band chanting their own name. At the count fair.
educated_dumdum@reddit
I’d say the majority of the fan base is pretty realistic, and has been for a long time. Unfortunately, it’s the Cowboys fans from afar that give us a bad look. And Jerry jones is the president of the clown club
Wizzmer@reddit
Cowboys fan here. Thanks for saving me the typing.
Swimming-Book-1296@reddit
Jerry Jones doesn’t want to win, he just wants to barely get into the playoffs. It’s how he maximizes his profitability.
Seventh7Sun@reddit
If the ownership ever changed to someone with a different last name than Jones it would be undervalued at any price.
minecraftjahseh@reddit
a lot of NCAA basketball programs have legendary reputations but are currently mediocre, and will take a nosedive after rev sharing kicks in next year. Kansas and UNC come to mind.
bringbackwishbone@reddit
This comment is a weaponized dose of UCONN fan
minecraftjahseh@reddit
big east will own CBB next year, watch and wait
The_Saddest_Boner@reddit
Indiana is the king of “we’re a blue blood, trust us.”
That being said I can’t wait for the revenue sharing because WE ARE A BLUE BLOOD TRUST US
Gold_Telephone_7192@reddit
Underrated: My teams that are perfect and good and pure and deserve to win the championship every year only to be thwarted by unfortunate circumstance and dirty opponents and the refs.
Overrated: Every other team in the league that's made up of no-good lowlifes who are dirty and bad people and get help from the refs and only win because they cheat.
MrLongWalk@reddit
Flair says Colorado but you’re clearly from Boston
Coro-NO-Ra@reddit
Or Texas
Sarollas@reddit
Nah, Texans don't like the Mavs right now.
Or A&M/UT depending on the person (or both if they are from Dallas and make the correct decision to support OU.
RealBlueShirt123@reddit
OU? Your are in the wrong state for that kida talk.
Sarollas@reddit
North Texas has a surprising amount of OU fans, in a lot of cases Norman is closer than the major schools outside of the Dallas Christian trio.
Most of my extended family is from Dallas and grew up sooner fans.
RealBlueShirt123@reddit
I can see UT. I can believe Aggies. I can even try to understand those poor souls that support Tech. SMU, TCU even North Texas are ok. The only thing Sooners fans are good for is creating traffic on I35 after the Texas/OU game.
dgmilo8085@reddit
Do they even like the cowgirls at this point?
BorkMcSnek@reddit
It’s wild that like the Stars are the states only hope rn
winteriscoming9099@reddit
Lmfao
Awdayshus@reddit
Maybe for your teams. I know that anyone who says The Vikings have a shot at going to the Superbowl doesn't understand how good they are at falling apart in the playoffs.
velociraptorfarmer@reddit
Big 4 Pro Sports since 1992:
MetroBS@reddit
NBA champ for Arizona should be 0/3
velociraptorfarmer@reddit
This is since 1992
MetroBS@reddit
Thanks I’ll learn how to read eventually
Awdayshus@reddit
I know! And the guy I'm replying to is from Colorado, which has the 6th most titles on your list.
velociraptorfarmer@reddit
Yep. NOBODY has it as bad as Minnesota in the last 30 years.
countertopwise@reddit
Same
siandresi@reddit
i thought this was about sports and not politics
huhwhat90@reddit
That sounds like something a fan of Your Team would say! My Team is perfect and good and pure!
KingTechnical48@reddit
The Jets are definitely winning double digit games next year.
friendsofbigfoot@reddit
Underrated
Baseball Cardinals
Despite being a small to mid sized market they have more world series titles than any team save the Yankees, and more NL titles than anyone save the Dodgers.
hawkhawg@reddit
The A’s have the third most World Series wins.
Danktizzle@reddit
All of college football is because it does it’s athletes dirty. Promise an enducation in exchange for some football. Then when the football is over, they have to quit playing professionally because there is nowhere for them to go. They are on tv, but don’t get the tv money. They are packing 100k seat stadia, but aren’t getting a cut of the door. They deserve a MUCH bigger slice of the pie.
And of course thanks for the downvotes. And I’m not gonna reply to your angry replies.
bringbackwishbone@reddit
Bro hasn’t read college sports news in five years apparently
bathes_in_housepaint@reddit
Nobody is mad at this, most people want the athletes to be compensated. Also, schools start paying athletes directly this upcoming season.
gavin2point0@reddit
Most overrated? The chiefs
Most underrated? Somehow also the chiefs
Fuck the chiefs though
ZonaWildcats23@reddit
Yeah Pats only ever played in the AFCCCG but make this make sense to me on the overrated?
Blahblah3180@reddit
Somehow this is completely accurate.
Knato@reddit
Ohhh, overrated the Cowboys.
Underrated the Texans.
The_Saddest_Boner@reddit
As a colts fan I’m required by law to ask you why in the hell you think the Texans are underrated. They’re literally the only team that’s never even made a conference championship, let alone a Super Bowl!
Knato@reddit
Yet.
They'll get to it.
I am not by any means a Texans fan, but they seem to be good enough to make it to the playoffs. They made it the past couple of years. More than what we say about the colts, the titans, or the mighty Jaguars.
C21H27Cl3N2O3@reddit
At least the Titans and Jags have made conference championship appearances in recent memory.
Knato@reddit
Not in the last 3 years.
C21H27Cl3N2O3@reddit
And the Texans have never. So.
The_Saddest_Boner@reddit
Yeah they might, but I guess “underrated franchise” to me doesn’t mean “one of the least accomplished franchises in all of sports but they might win something someday relatively soon” lol
Extreme-Interview173@reddit
Thing is, They’re in a limbo between being what I’d call a Rockies team and a Rams team. They aren’t a team like the Rockies in which they are the laughingstock of the league year in and out, but they aren’t a team like the Rams that are good, just not like the Raiders and Steelers in the 70’s, the Dolphins and 49ers in the 80’s, etc. The Texans are a good team especially considering how young they are. They aren’t a consistent good enough team, nor are they a consistently bad or even mediocre team, they’re just a young team.
Elivagar_@reddit
Most underrated: The Nashville Predators. They took hockey into a totally unconventional market in the American South, the city has completely embraced them, and they’re a playoff contender more often than not.
MrRaspberryJam1@reddit
Underrated: Indiana Pacers. They’ve never been able to win a championship, but since they drafted Reggie Miller in the 80s they have had several different eras of entertaining teams that have gone on playoff runs. They never go through long stretches of losing seasons.
Dubstep_squid@reddit
Underrated: Army Football
Overrated: Navy Football
blaspheminCapn@reddit
Underrated - as a whole, American Football (soccer) and the talent American footbul players that are coming up.
One club gets it: https://www.chicagofirefc.com/news/chicago-fire-fc-agrees-to-transfer-forward-jhon-duran-to-aston-villa-in-club-rec
DolphinSouvlaki@reddit
The US national team that lost to both Canada and Panama in their last two matches?
Still a long ways to go before anyone seriously has them as a World Cup contender. Still better than Mexico though lol
blaspheminCapn@reddit
Not the national team, the talent being grown in the country
Escape_Force@reddit
You misspelled soccer.
Real-Psychology-4261@reddit
Overrated = Dallas Cowboys by a mile.
Underrated = Buffalo Bills, Baltimore Ravens, Minnesota Vikings. Consistent winning franchises that do things the right way.
DolphinSouvlaki@reddit
Seems as if your definition of “Doing things the right way”= being massively overrated in the regular season and then losing early in the playoffs.
That applies to the bills and vikings, but at least the ravens have won a few super bowls. The Bills in fact were outright terrible for pretty much the entire time Tim Brady existed.
BottleTemple@reddit
All of them are overrated.
zekerthedog@reddit
Not really
BottleTemple@reddit
Yes really.
zekerthedog@reddit
Is this like a “sportsball” opinion you got going on here
monsieurfatcock@reddit
Definitely seems like one of those guys who never went outside as a kid
BottleTemple@reddit
I played sports as a kid.
monsieurfatcock@reddit
So you’re just being the stereotypical contrarian redditor, gotcha. And clearly you don’t watch the Braves
maceilean@reddit
Speaking of overrated teams. Oof.
monsieurfatcock@reddit
This first week has been nonstop pain lol. But the good thing about baseball is one bad stretch of games isn’t a death sentence for the season
BottleTemple@reddit
Nope, I was just answering the question asked by the OP. You decided to give me shit for my answer for some unknown reason.
monsieurfatcock@reddit
And your answer was ridiculous so I ridiculed it. Out of the 100 or so major sport franchises in America you think every single one is somehow overrated? And even if you believe that, there would still be one that’s the MOST overrated lmao
BottleTemple@reddit
Thanks for acknowledging that you were deliberately antagonizing me.
monsieurfatcock@reddit
You’re welcome for that attention you ordered. I didn’t even reply to you directly at first because I knew that’s what you wanted, and yet you still sniffed out my comment. Should’ve known
BottleTemple@reddit
I’m really not interested in attention. I saw your comment in the thread so I replied to it.
monsieurfatcock@reddit
Your comment speaks for itself bud. Pure ragebait that adds nothing to the discussion and is designed to get attention. It’s ok I’ve been there too. Hope you feel better soon
BottleTemple@reddit
I was literally just answering the question. It’s not “ragebait”, you just don’t know how to deal with an opinion you disagree with.
BottleTemple@reddit
It’s like a “I think they’re all overrated” opinion I have going on here.
zekerthedog@reddit
Well they aren’t, particularly the ravens and the titans
BottleTemple@reddit
In your opinion. In my opinion they’re overrated.
zekerthedog@reddit
Yea you’re a “sportsball” guy
BottleTemple@reddit
Because I think American sports franchises are overrated?
GhostOfJamesStrang@reddit
What is this even supposed to mean?
BottleTemple@reddit
It means that they’re all overrated.
GhostOfJamesStrang@reddit
Oh goodness. You're one of the obnoxious "r/ihatesportsball" sort of people, aren't you.
BottleTemple@reddit
You’re the second person who has said that. It’s a really bizarre narrative that you and that person have chosen to to go with. I was literally just answering the question.
GhostOfJamesStrang@reddit
If the shoe fits.
BottleTemple@reddit
It doesn’t. You’re just stuck in the narrative you’ve created.
I don’t have a whole lot of knowledge about foreign sports franchises.
The usual Redditor shtick seems to be taking professional sports way too seriously. You’re definitely living up to that.
StarSpangleBRangel@reddit
Boy, you’re on a roll today.
BottleTemple@reddit
What kind of roll?
Fun-Lengthiness-7493@reddit
The University of Notre Dame football team for, annually, overrated
grannyknockers@reddit
Notre Dame? They were just in the championship game like 3 months ago…
Fun-Lengthiness-7493@reddit
Still overrated.
Orbital2@reddit
For a few decades sure, kinda hard to argue they weren’t the real deal last year though. They have gradually shown themselves more capable of playing with the big boys
Nowadays in CFB it’s probably a mid tier SEC team like Auburn/A&M/Tennessee
TheMainEffort@reddit
Sure did love getting hyped for the badgers every year just to watch them lose the season opener to Northwestern.
huhwhat90@reddit
Eh, they made it to the Natty last year in a newly expanded playoffs. They were definitely overrated under Brian Kelly, but then again, most teams are.
NicklAAAAs@reddit
The Dallas Cowboys of college football.
Fun-Lengthiness-7493@reddit
Agreed. And I’m an alum.
Critical-Term-427@reddit
Relevant
fiestapotatoess@reddit
Overrated: Dallas Cowboys. Goes without saying saying.
Underrated: Baltimore Ravens. Best overall regular season winning percentage in the league and they’ve basically been contenders since they were granted expansion
HoyAIAG@reddit
Since they moved their team in the 90’s. They stole their success from the city of Cleveland.
ucbiker@reddit
Maybe because I’m adjacent to their market but my impression was that the Ravens are a well-known regular season powerhouse.
They also don’t lack post-season success but I think people think Lamar can’t get over the hump.
fiestapotatoess@reddit
I think people who really know football are aware how consistently good they are. I think they’ve just got the curse of being a bit overshadowed by the AFC powerhouse franchises that have been so prevalent in recent years. I think part of that is that they didn’t have a QB with real star power until Lamar came along. McNair was good, but he wasn’t Peyton, Tom or Ben.
When I think of 2000’s AFC, it’s the Colts, Pats and Steelers. In the 2010’s, it’s the Patriots and Broncos. For the 2020’s it’s the Chiefs and Bills. The Ravens have always been in the ballpark though but never seem to get the notoriety of other teams. That’s why I think they are underrated.
ucbiker@reddit
Yeah I get that. Although now that you mention the Steelers, they are another lowkey answer to most overrated franchises.
JustiseWinfast@reddit
The San Antonio spurs are so underrated nobody even mentions them here
PungentPussyJuice@reddit
Packers are overrated. Their teams have been terrible. They just got carried by Rodgers and Favre.
ninjomat@reddit
The bears have one Super Bowl but I feel like you see their logo everywhere
HamRadio_73@reddit
MLB Milwaukee Brewers
inbigtreble30@reddit
For overrated or underrated? No one ever expects us to do well.
bankersbox98@reddit
Pirates are the king of this. They have a great history, loyal fan base and beautiful stadium. They should be a crown jewel of the sport. But the owners just cash the central revenue checks and spend no money.
misterlakatos@reddit
Unremarkable history, too. Only one playoff appearance (their lone pennant in 1982) while in the American League. They were a constant doormat in the old AL East.
They have had more success since moving to the NL; however, they have yet to return to the World Series.
Xcalat3@reddit
Overrated Like others have said are the Dallas Cowboys with their delusional fanbase.
Apprehensive_Soil306@reddit
You’ve never met a cowboys fan in real life if you think this. They’re the most self aware fan base I’ve ever met
Loud_Inspector_9782@reddit
We are not delusional. We know Jerry sucks.
6gravedigger66@reddit
All of them. Team sports are lame.
monsieurfatcock@reddit
Possibly the worst take an American could ever have. Congrats
boulevardofdef@reddit
So many Cowboys answers but in a similar vein, I'd offer the New York Knicks. They're not "America's team" like the Cowboys, and they may be kind of a joke among serious NBA fans, but I think most casual fans think of them as one of the elite basketball teams. They're the most beloved team in America's biggest city. Celebrities go to their games. Their tickets are highly sought after by business leaders and the like. They're the signature tenant of "the world's most famous arena." They're one of the oldest teams in the league.
But they haven't won a championship since 1973 (and only have two all time, within a couple of years of each other), and in fact, despite recent success, they're usually quite bad.
Loud_Inspector_9782@reddit
Our semi-pro team, the Dallas Cowboys. Only Jerry could turn the world's most valuable sports franchise into a perennial loser.
QuarterNote44@reddit
Overrated: Yeah, the Cowboys. Underrated: San Antonio Spurs. Absolute monster of a franchise.
Inside_Ad9026@reddit
America’s Team overrated (obv) but I watched them every Thanksgiving with my dad until he died when I was a kid.
winteriscoming9099@reddit
Overrated: the Dallas Cowboys. You could argue the Yankees or lakers or such, but those teams typically win a lot or get close to it - the cowboys are a lot more inconsistent. I’d also maybe add the Knicks and maybe Notre Dame.
Underrated: some small market baseball team probably - the Rays and Guardians are usually very good despite cheap-ass owners and mini payrolls. I also think the Baltimore Ravens don’t get enough credit, as much as it pains me to say as a Steelers fan. Arguably the Mets too, but I’d argue that their fanbase has consistently overrated them for ages while the rest of baseball underrates them.
nelsne@reddit
Overrated: LA Lakers
Puzzleheaded-Bee4698@reddit
What rating system?
Redbubble89@reddit
Dallas Cowboys. Usually with like the Yankees or Lakers they have won recently or get close to winning. It somehow has the largest fanbase in the NFL but hasn't done shit since the mid 90s. They are good regular season with hour to hour coverage on ESPN but are out by the divisional round. 10-12 national games they don't deserve which is why they are popular. If you give them 5 national games like a normal tv, they will be like everyone else. It's also the America's team crap. I am a Commanders fan but we did something they haven't done in 30 years with a new QB and good ownership. Jerry has to be dead for them to win anything. So dysfunctional and I wish the NFL would stop forcing the Cowboys down everyone's throat.
Underrated is a little tough. A team has to be bad or in a small market to not get any coverage. Mariners and Padres have never won anything. Indians surprise people every year but they haven't won since the war 70 years ago. Winning teams get rated.
Mr_Kittlesworth@reddit
This is going to be an entertaining thread
ConsiderationCrazy22@reddit
Overrated is the Dallas Cowboys and it’s not even close.
PineapplePikza@reddit
Overrated: cowboys
Underrated: Mets
AVDLatex@reddit
The Cowboys, they’re in a league of their own.
TodayCharming7915@reddit
All major league professional sports are overrated with overpaid players and greedy owners who gouge ticket holders.