PSA: Don't buy cheap spring compressors
Posted by TheAngryBad@reddit | projectcar | View on Reddit | 51 comments
You'd think I'd know better, but apparently not.
I thought I'd treat myself to some new spring compressors to replace my ancient but sturdy old ones. I didn't want to spend too much as it's not something I do very often. So I bought some fairly cheap ones off ebay.
Did the first spring, great! Really nice and easy to use. Second spring; came apart nicely. I was really liking these. But putting the new spring in was where it went wrong. I was just at the point of putting the top mount on when one of the compressors broke apart with a hell of a bang! It sent the top spring cap flying right across my driveway, thankfully missing me and my car.
I got seriously lucky; if I'd been just a little quicker with the mount then my hand would have been on top of the spring when it went and I'd probably have broken a finger or worse.
Looking at the damage, these things are seriously weak at the point they join together; the joint is probably 1mm thick at best. Maybe there was a manufacturing defect on the one that broke, but it was just a matter of time really. They're simply not designed to stand up to the kind of stresses spring compressors deal with.
So yeah; cheapy chinesium tools can be worth a punt sometimes, but not when it comes to something as safety critical as spring compressors. Lesson learned!
Shame really, these worked really well for the 1.5 springs they managed to do. I guess I'll stick with my old ones that don't work that well, but have at least managed to last 20 years or so without trying to kill me.
Sarionum@reddit
Holy shit i have similar spring compressors and yeah... one went off on me too, but there was no real damage I could see like yours. Insane, maybe I'll go back to the solid black ones.
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Yeah, that's what I'm going to do. Rather than another set like this I'll just find a better version of the ones I already have.
StanChesterbaan@reddit
Don’t buy cheap tools or condoms
Gregarious_Buffoon@reddit
I bet that put some spring in your step!
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
There was certainly some recoil.
belleayreski2@reddit
The suspense almost killed you!
eatshit311@reddit
I'm shocked!
PM_ME_SOME_ANY_THING@reddit
Kinetically combative!
belleayreski2@reddit
The suspense almost killed him!
AKA_Squanchy@reddit
I don’t buy anything cheap that has potential energy; you need to rely on that to not injure you!
johnnytom@reddit
Death clamps!!
Wizzle-Stick@reddit
my wife was telling me about a time she and my father in law had to go to the junkyard to get some top hats for his car. my wife had my 6ish year old son with her because he liked visiting grandpa. well, grandpa was slowly removing the springs like one does and should, when a young man that was recently hired to the junk yard came out and offered to assist. he thought my father in law was struggling (as a skinny man in his early 70s would, reasonable assumption really) because he was going so slow. So the kid offered to help and went really, really fast. my father in law told him to slow down and take his time, but before he could finish the sentence, the spring came loose and went straight into this kids face. split him open like a can of tuna. broke his eye, jaw was busted, massive lascerations. kids face was soft and limp when they took him away in the ambulance.
it really messed my son up. now when he works on any kind of spring, hes terrified. my wife, shes scared to open a can of biscuits like they are some kind of yeast filled hand grenade. my father in law...yeah, he basically said "see, i told that kid he should slow down" and then proceeded to continue working. the man has seen some shit (south vietnamese vietnam vet that worked with the americans during the war, what i know about is horrifying, and there is shit he refuses to ever mention).
sheepsqueezers@reddit
Most importantly, are you okay? 🤔🤔🤔
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
By sheer luck, yes. No harm done to me or my car, but it could easily have been bad.
cgtdream@reddit
I got a lot of "spring" work to do myself and was wondering what tools yall recommend. Any suggestions?
patx35@reddit
If you live in North America, I recommend the loaner strut spring compressors from places like O'Reilly or AutoZone. It doesn't remove the sketch factor from improper use, but it never seems to break from normal use.
ultramilkplus@reddit
I had an old Branick on the wall but it took up too much room, I bought one of these and it's been fine for my needs. https://www.summitracing.com/parts/otc-6494
I'm too old to live adventurously with the Temu/Amazon compressors anymore. If you have to have this style, at least make sure they're the made in Taiwan versions.
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Interesting, never seen that style before. Not cheap, but I can see they'd be worth it.
look_ima_frog@reddit
I bought that guy's old Branick and put it on the wall. I don't need it often, but when I do, it's so nice to not worry at all. That bastard isn't going anywhere.
I mean, I don't think I bought that guy's Branick, but I may have. Got it from some dude selling it out his tool trailer out in the country for about $350.
ridiculusvermiculous@reddit
holy shit i've only used the rental ones and they're at least 1.5x beefier than that.
they're actually heavy as shit with big ol grippers
leesfer@reddit
There is no amount of money I wouldn't pay to NOT compress my own springs. Lesson learned and it's just not worth losing a limb, let alone your life.
minuteman_d@reddit
I hate those things, even the nice ones with the locks and whatnot.
interests_are_random@reddit
Had a spring slip out of one of these. Luckily it didn’t hit me or the other car in the garage. Easily the scariest garage moment I’ve ever had and that includes a car falling off jack stands.
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Probably the second scariest for me.
Scariest was when I was lying under a bare shelled car, fitting the rear axle. I went to pull myself out by grabbing the back of the car but instead of me rolling out, the whole car lifted up at the front, pivoting on the jack stands. My life flashed before me for a moment then, lol.
interests_are_random@reddit
Code brown moment 👀
Glad you’re alright, that would be enough to not want to go back out there for a few days.
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Yeah, I was almost done for the day anyway and that was enough for me to say 'yeah, I'm going inside now'. Scary moment.
teambanzai2001@reddit
A friend of mine lost several teeth, and had his cheek bone and eye socket broken when one let go on him.
Alieges@reddit
I heard a story where one lets go and the spring magically goes Sproing right between a couple guys, over the top of another ones head and almost out of the garage by going halfway through the wall. No injuries, but a nice hole in the garage wall with a spring half in and half out of the garage.
It was at that point when I said "Remind me to not be a bystander when a spring compressor is use."
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Ouch! That's a nightmare I have, I always try to take care with spring jobs for just that reason.
Aside from buying cheap tools, apparently 😆
BikerDave69@reddit
That is the world's most dangerous game of jack in the box
Lichenbruten@reddit
Yea, I have a Harbor Freight set that I used twice. The fear is real. They (and I) have survived, but I don't feel a 3-0 record level of trust.
DakarCarGunGuy@reddit
I have a set like that. When I used it I also used the cheap ass HF one with nuts and hooks on ready rod type as a backup. None of that made me comfortable period! I'd much rather use the wall mount compressor but that was absolutely NOT possible. 2 inch lift springs in a Jetta are NOT fun.
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Yeah, these handheld ones always feel sketchy AF. But tbf my old cheap ones have never let me down yet, they're just really awkward to use.
DakarCarGunGuy@reddit
Did the end pull out or pull off?
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
I think it pulled out. I guess there's another part to it that went flying off into the bushes somewhere, idk.
DakarCarGunGuy@reddit
As long as it didn't fly into you you're good!
YousureWannaknow@reddit
Buy these that are priced reasonably 😉 Seen similar, costed 5 times more than these I got, seriously, I'm thankful I went cheaper.. Simple construction, to forks and single massive treaded pole. Unless fork breaks, there's nothing that can fail
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
If you mean the really cheap basic ones, that's what I already have. My main complaint with them is that the head of the screw thread sits too close to the spring and can chew up the coating. Otherwise, they've done great for me for the last few years.
YousureWannaknow@reddit
I meant these cheapest, no springs, nothing
These to be precise
velowa@reddit
Don’t like. There aren’t retaining pins on those. At least get the ones that have a pin that locks in with a little ball detent. Pretty much the same design as the ones you posted but they don’t allow the spring to slip out of the jaws.
YousureWannaknow@reddit
There are different designs. Ones I have just grab spring from inside, there's no way for it to slip, since mine, cover 75% of wire. But as said, there are different designs, these were just example
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Yep, that's the ones I already have. But on mine (a slightly different design I guess), the head sits right next to the spring and rubs against the powder coating. Looks like the ones in your pic sit a bit further out. I might just have to get new ones in that style.
YousureWannaknow@reddit
When it's for projects and stuff that doesn't have to pay off, I highly recommend these. Well, you may want to grab few different designs of these tbh. Some of this require actually mods to fit in weird places 🤣
Makabajones@reddit
Gotta yell "generade!" Before using that
PhantomOfTheNahBrah@reddit
Hey look, a literal death trap!
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
I requested a return with the ebay seller. He came back and offered me a £6 discount and I could keep them. Yeah right, there's no way I'd use these again even if they were free!
Grouchy_Explorer_243@reddit
thats an odd way to meet god
Avalock_@reddit
One of these almost crushed my finger. I lost the balance between the pair resulting in one of theme violently spin to the other side of the spring against the other one. Had my finger on it a second ago.
The much safer and convenient alternative is the 100$ variant with a hydraulic ram and arrestor chain. Well worth the slightly higer price.
TheAngryBad@reddit (OP)
Yeah, next time I need to do a spring job I'll probably shell out the extra for a decent one. I did have these slip on me a couple of times but only while they weren't tightly compressed.
FormulaZR@reddit
Went cheap and now you need new britches.
3threat@reddit
Your sphincter probably let loose about the same time. Funny how that happens.