What do you think about EU asking western balkan countries to introduce visas?
Posted by shockwave_1D@reddit | AskBalkans | View on Reddit | 349 comments

RB-44@reddit
Putting Serbia into the EU when so many of them are pro Russian is like asking for another vote against the interests of Europe.
Not to mention they're a dictatorship the fact remains the serbian population is largely pro russian and even if they became democratic the chances of them electing a pro russian candidate is very likely.
Too many strings
Darkwrath93@reddit
The EU yet again wants us to dislike them even more. When they let us in, then we should align the visa policy. They are gonna introduce ETIAS for us and in return we get to lose access to half the world because of reciprocity. F**k this bullshit
Own-Elevator-2571@reddit
you also get hundreds of billions in funding... id say losing russian toursits is worth it lmao
Darkwrath93@reddit
Funding of our dictator, sure.
RB-44@reddit
Person skill issue
No-Extension-4132@reddit
Bruh if you know anything about regular Serbs and not the EU propaganda, we (especially residents of Belgrade) hate most of the Russians who came here to live. Our rent and apartment prices went to the roof and they act like they own everything. Also, they don’t want to assimilate (at least learn the language, basic words etc) and only talk between themselves, so yeah we don’t care for them, they can go back to serve their country’s war or whatever.
freaxje@reddit
Yes! Fuck the bullshit of having to follow the rules of the club you want to join!
Yess!!! Fuck it! Fuck the rules! Fuck the club too!
Then don't join the club. Serbs. Stay out.
loleenceee@reddit
If we truly get to enter the EU then I am okay with it. But if we make it harder for the 3 biggest tourist groups (🇨🇳🇷🇺🇹🇷)to eneter Serbia for nothing… then we are as dumb as a rock.
agent218@reddit
Bro we are NEVER entering the EU I can bet my house on that.. We made negligible progress for over 10 years.
Even if we somehow met all their requirements (which is never going to happen) the last one would be recognizing Kosovo as independent..
cocoadusted@reddit
lol if you guys know Albanians you would know how similar we are feeling about our governments and our future I hate that we are so divided. Imagine if the balkan people truly united, I bet you might even get killed for saying an idea like that out loud.
agent218@reddit
There is no reason for Albanians and Serbs to dislike each other. One of my dear friends is Albanian and we don't care.
Serbs and Kosovars, well that is a different story. They hate our guts, we don't care about them.
Future-Birthday-1573@reddit
Kosovar doesn’t exit. A kosovar is an Albanian from Dardania. That’s exactly why we hate each other : y’all stole culture, land history, and try to make it yours.
There is no Kosovo. Its Dardania. And it’s not yours.
Krasniqi857@reddit
one day it can be Dardania again. first step for us is to be fully recognized
plenfiru@reddit
You will never be fully recognised because you will never be a real country.
2AM_Walk@reddit
Albanian talking about stealing lands, history and culture..... Very funny.
Calm_Tale1111@reddit
Well we got a language to back our claims up, what do you have? A tendency to lie lie lie lie and cry?
2AM_Walk@reddit
We Have Actual History.
Future-Birthday-1573@reddit
History usable only under Vucic, but totally pointless when you go to a real country (meaning any country on earth except Serbia) where we all agree upon history.
Your fake country was made up fast and it shows, lacks consistently. As bad as if it was written by AI.
2AM_Walk@reddit
Our country is real, internationally recognized, and has a deep, well-documented history. In contrast, your so-called 'country' lacks recognition, and its people's history is constantly rewritten to fit an agenda of appropriation.
Calm_Tale1111@reddit
Thats the problem for you, you think history starts when you arrived in the Balkans but you also forget that there were people there before you. Yep the Albanians, so try go behind the year zero in serbian history and you will see plenty of others
Future-Birthday-1573@reddit
Yeah fairytales written on toilet paper that’s all you have 😂 made up mixed slavicized Albanians that’s what you are, but we don’t entertain you no more
You want Kosovo ? Come and get it. Cause for now, it’s Albanian, and as much as you love to say it’s Serbia, you can’t even step foot in Kosovo lil dog
Kletronus@reddit
And whose fault is that?
MegaMB@reddit
You do care about their juicy land though, to the point where you'd prefer to have Kosovo without locals over letting Kosovo as a well populated neighbore to trade with 🤌
Internal-Date553@reddit
Spain and Romania don t recognize Kosovo either and are in EU
agent218@reddit
Recognizing Kosovo is not a general EU requirement lol but for Serbia it is. Eu is very pro Kosovo oriented in general and they said that resolving that issue is a must.
ZhiveBeIarus@reddit
You're lucky AF, the EU is horrible.
PrzymRzeczLiczba@reddit
Kletronus@reddit
The lack of progress is not because of EU.
Block-Rockig-Beats@reddit
So what happens when Kosovo joins EU in 2030?
agent218@reddit
Ta ti je dobra
Mediocre_Internet939@reddit
As a Dane, I for one hope you join the EU in the near future.
JesusFockingChrist@reddit
You won’t have to recognise Kosovo, just to drop the claims on that territory and to not be in an open conflict with them. Half of the EU doesn’t recognise Kosovo, and Cyprus is a good example anything is possible.
Pristine10887@reddit
The last one is easy and better for everyone, truly a win-win situation
freaxje@reddit
We just need to figure out a way to convince the Serbs of this one.
Pristine10887@reddit
They are too high on Milosevic propaganda still unfortunately
freaxje@reddit
Meanwhile anybody who ever visited Pristina or who knows anybody from Kosovo (my wife is) already knows: Kosovo people don't want to be Serbs.
They just don't.
The damage that has been done is too big to overcome. It's also goes a lot deeper than what happened in the nineties.
If you'd ask you Kosovo people, you'd happily join Albania. I mean. There are more Albanian flags in Kosovo then there are in Albania.
d1r1gbambe1@reddit
The same situation is in Crimea, where, unlike Donetsk and other regions of Ukraine, most people really wanted to live in Russia and called themselves Russians, but for this Russia only received sanctions
EarthObvious7093@reddit
One thing I wonder is: if Albanians in Kosovo can choose to separate themselves from Serbia, then why can't the Serbians in Kosovo decide to separate from Kosovo and rejoin Serbia? I guess self-determination only applies to certain people. 🤷♂️
Krasniqi857@reddit
mate you should take a history lesson
freaxje@reddit
I obviously differ in opinion on this one with my wife from Kosovo. But I think you are right.
It should be possible for those people (in the north) of Kosovo to rejoin Serbia.
For her, this can't be discussed. It immediately leads to conflict.
I also think that it will effectively lead to armed conflict if you do try to make any new border.
nindza22@reddit
You are wrong there. Kosovo is "USA baby", and they want it whole as a matter of principles. If they only winked about splitting it, it would happen very smoothly, without any conflict. Yeah, many Serbs and many Albanians would be pissed off, and then tomorrow they'd be back to their factory lines with lame foreign bosses and minimum wages.
EarthObvious7093@reddit
Definitely. But the hypocrisy is interesting.
freaxje@reddit
I hope that exchanging a certain amount of land between both sides will result in a lasting solution.
With I don't think we are there yet, at all.
Perhaps in a hundred years? That's my own closest estimate.
slava-ua@reddit
I’m from the east of Ukraine and no, most people don’t want to live in ruSSia
freaxje@reddit
I personally am not against Crimea joining Russia. In fact, I think it already happened.
slava-ua@reddit
it wasn’t joined , it was occupied and annexed
SuccessfulResist6385@reddit
A few corrections and additions here: - Albanians from Kosovo don't want to be Serbs which completely makes sense. - Albanians from Kosovo don't want to be part of Serbia which is probably understandable. - Serbs from Kosovo don't want to be part of a country called Kosovo, but Serbia. - Serbs from BiH don't want to be part of BiH but Serbia.
Not imposing that Kosovo should be a part of Serbia, but giving a few points to consider before proposing a solution.
agent218@reddit
Haha yea that opinion is as objective as mine lol
Pristine10887@reddit
Only if reality enrages you
Unable-Stay-6478@reddit
Reality is that some international laws got violated...
Pristine10887@reddit
Nope
Unable-Stay-6478@reddit
Si, siñor
EarthObvious7093@reddit
Sure, you also agree that the Serbian majority in north Kosovo should get independence from Kosovo and rejoin Serbia, right?
Pristine10887@reddit
If they want to. But they know they are better off under Albanian leadership.
mavericki1@reddit
I am sure Vucic can create some kind of " narodni referendum u Kosovsko pitanje", I tip my hat of, to Vucic when it comes to getting whatever result it wants from the serbs in elections.
He could put a question, do you believe the earth is flat, and around 55% of serbs would agree with that. ( I am talking with sarcasm, on how he brings voter from Kosovo and Bosnia )
Fiery_Flamingo@reddit
The Turks who visit Serbia are almost entirely well educated anti-Erdogan people. Almost all of them are just regular tourists with white collar jobs. The only reason they go to Serbia is the visa-free travel.
If Serbia enacts a visa requirement, these people will simply go to Greek islands.
DisastrousDoc952@reddit
Greek visa scheme is stupidly expensive, cumbersome, subject to quotas, and unavailable to anyone who had been refused a Schengen visa. It's easier to apply for a full visa than that thing.
a Turkish citizen with ordinary passport/ID would usually go to other non-EU Balkan countries, Georgia, Ukraine, Iran or Azerbaijan. others with access to a special passport (which means them, their spouse or parents working for the govt) would visa-free access Schengen&China 'for now'.
dcdemirarslan@reddit
Greek islands don't ask visa from Turks.
mrfly2000@reddit
I assume the thought is it could be used as An easy entry point into the rest of the eu ?
bosnian_redditer@reddit
I met a lot of turks at the Nikola Tesla showroom in Belgrade. There were so many that the shortfilm (~10min) were in turkish subtitles. All nice people just wanting a good holiday.
Livid-Donut-7814@reddit
+1 Had a very cool time with a turkish group in a bus from Belgrade to Sarajevo
Abraham-J@reddit
The current EU visas only block the educated, young, anti-Erdogan people from Turkey, because they're the only ones who respect the laws and try to visit Europe through legal ways. Pro-Erdogan government officials and their whole families have diplomatic passports, visa free. Pro-Erdogan businessmen can visit Europe whenever they want. Radical Islamists and pro-Sharia illegals? They're welcome. The EU only blocks Turkey's best.
Abraham-J@reddit
The current EU visas only block the educated anti-Erdogan people from Turkey. Pro-Erdogan government officials and their whole families have diplomatic passports, visa-free. Pro-Erdogan businessmen can visit Europe whenever they want. Radical Islamists and terrorist groups? Backed by the EU, so they're most welcome. EU only blocks Turkey's best.
Spervox@reddit
Absolutely useless visas
Galf2@reddit
It's necessary to be part of the EU. But yeah, if the EU bans Russians, which hopefully happens soon enough, then all countries part of EU need to apply the same rule.
loleenceee@reddit
I don’t mind the russians and other post-soviet people, they are eacaping war and a dictatorship. They opened many cool cafes and restaurants, now Belgrade even has an uzbekistani restaurant….everybody is human
Galf2@reddit
They were escaping war in 2022, the ones that are coming in Europe now are mostly parasites. I'm okay with them if they lose their passport to come here though, they shouldn't be allowed back to Russia under any circumstance.
loleenceee@reddit
Oh nice I did not know that the war stopped…
Galf2@reddit
It didn't. It started in 2014. People who opposed the regime made up their mind in 2022. The only people that can't leave are these too old to do so. Nobody protests. Ukraine shed blood for their right to live, Russians don't even bother. Their society has never known democracy.
ExtremeProfession@reddit
I still don't know why this is asked from the countries before they even have a confirmation that they will indeed join the EU soon.
It takes 18 months from the decision to the actual inclusion and this should be a requirement when you're sure you will join at a set date.
Slow_Independence714@reddit
This is not about joining the EU. It’s a requirement from the new Growth Plan, which Bosnia also signed last December. Basically, the more we align to the EU rules, the more EU advantages we will get without joining (we wont join obviously).
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
As dümb as Monkedonia 🇲🇰*
Romeo_y_Cohiba@reddit
Tourism is a marginal sector in Serbia, we are neither Croatia nor Montenegro. It contributes like 2% of GDP. Also, Turks are indeed the largest group but 2nd and 3rd spot is Romania and Bosnia.
I would very much trade Chinese investments as BYD battery and car factory in Hungary and making Serbia attractive in that area(which EU brings) for Chinese tourists.
Sad-Notice-8563@reddit
Tourism is only great when it's a small part of the GDP, but it is a very nice industry with high profit margins and a good source of foreign currency. We should work to increase tourism as a percent of the GDP because it's only 2% now so gains should be easy, not strangle it with moronic policy because it's already small.
pear_666@reddit
As long as Serbia has its current government, there is no real possibility of joining the European Union. In addition, the Kosovo issue remains unresolved (regardless of which side one supports – it's simply a fact), and may require a solution similar to the Cyprus model.
There's also another important aspect we need to consider: the EU's capacity to admit new members. We're currently struggling to implement a coherent foreign policy due to obstruction by countries like Hungary and Slovenia — so it's questionable whether the EU is ready to deal with a third veto player.
Rather than focusing solely on EU membership, I believe Serbia and the EU should prioritize expanding the Schengen Area to include at least Serbia and North Macedonia. In the meantime, Serbia already benefits from a well-developed highway (E75) that connects northern and southern Europe. This infrastructure could give both Serbia and its neighbors a modest economic boost through faster transport of goods and people.
SlyScorpion@reddit
You mean Slovakia AKA the one with Robert Fico. Slovenia is not the problem child.
pear_666@reddit
Just edited it.
ujgurisuzakon@reddit
we becoming even more of a colony with this one 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥💯
One-Act-2601@reddit
EU isn't asking for anything, it's Western Balkans country asking how they can join, and the EU tells them how.
masterkitty010203@reddit
Fact.
OlivierTwist@reddit
The EU isn't asking directly, but actively pushing in the "right direction". Social systems either grow or stagnate. After Brexit and with weaker economy the EU must grow to stay competitive against the USA.
Hyperion_000@reddit
this
guga76@reddit
Best answer so far.
skyduster88@reddit
No, no. Don't say something sane. EU bad!
GrumpyFatso@reddit
This.
Stverghame@reddit
We are dumb as fuck if we allow EU to force us implement visa on China, Russia and Turkey. This should be done in final phases when we need to enter EU, but as we're never entering it - I see no point in doing this.
Kletronus@reddit
You... don't want visas on Russians? The guys that are attacking Europe are welcomed by you? Of course you see no point joining EU, you are pro-Russian.
Stverghame@reddit
Why would I want visas on them? They are not attacking us at all. Attacking Europe? Attacking a European country - yes, that is horrible and I condemn it. But, since when is Europe a united thing to be attacked fully though?
Judging by the schizo stuff you said, I'll take a wild guess and assume you're from one of the three Baltic chihuahuas or from Finland, usually the most schizo people when it comes to observation of any situation Russia-related lol.
Kletronus@reddit
Ah, so they are not attacking you because you are ALLIES in your mind, against Europe. Putin is attacking Ukraine, if you don't know. It will not end there but that is what you want. Your logic is then "let them attack countries one by one but if they attack them all, that is not ok"....
You are pro Russian, like half of Serbia is. There is a group of traitors in our midst, you are one of them.
Stverghame@reddit
Putin is attacking Ukraine, I literally said that in my comment. You said Europe as if whole Europe is being attacked. Take a deeeeep breath, and think.
How can Serbs be traitors to you? We were never with Baltoids and Fins to begin with. To betray someone, you need to be good with them at first. Fuck both NATO and Russia for all I care, you are the one labeling me as pro-Russian just because I am not having a mental hysterical breakdown at the mention of Russia like you're having right now. I happier knowing that I am mentally stable unlike people like you lol, must be hard living in daily delusion-consumed episodes.
Own-Elevator-2571@reddit
the EU isnt forcing anything... if you want into the EU you need to implement it, if you dont want in dont implement it. idk where exactly is the forcing lmao
CloudsAndSnow@reddit
You have to figure out if you want to join the Schengen area or not (not the EU, that's a different topic). If you don't want to there's no point to doing this harmonization, and if you do there's no point in NOT doing it because a Schengen area with different visa policies makes zero sense. Why do you perceive this as being "forced"? It seems a like a pretty straightforward case to me.
Btw my country (Switzerland) has no interest in joining the EU but we did Join Schengen and I think it was a good call.
Stverghame@reddit
Why are people so lazy to read the whole convo before giving their opinion?
CloudsAndSnow@reddit
My point being if you believe aligning the visa policies is detrimental to Serbia what's the point of joining the Schengen at all? In other comments you say "we can align right before joining the EU" which is not the same question at all. This was a very long debate in my country and I wanted to learn more on how Serbia is going about it but it's ok if you don't want to discuss it or don't know the answer. Have a nice day.
Stverghame@reddit
My point, if you could read, is that we are not even close to Schengen and that it is illogical to implement this now if we have no benefit of Schengen. It should be done in final phases. Jesus Christ, I asked you to read before commenting, and you avoided it yet again.
agent218@reddit
True. We started the integration in 2009 and made 0 progress. We are never joining the EU.
Plus now the public opinion on joining EU is the lowest among any country that is participating in integration
Either_Sock4639@reddit
You have opened chapters and are deep into negotiations. It's not EUs fault that you are a west-hating dictatorship and third most corrupt country in Europe after Belarus and Bosnia. Inadmissible
DrProtic@reddit
Every time before elections we get a visit from EU official to praise that same dictator. Even with these protests pretty much everyone from EU who matters have kept silent or even called for protests to end. EU wants them in power.
Either_Sock4639@reddit
They have to work with the guy Serbs elected. Feel respected.
raven_oscar@reddit
Now tell this to Georgia.
DrProtic@reddit
Sure buddy.
Usernamenotta@reddit
Oh, fuck of. I was literally living in France when Macaron bypassed the Parliament to bring in his unpopular pension reform, no alteration, even in the face of massive protests. For comparison, I also happened to be in Russia in 2018 when Putin introduced their pension reform. People protested less than the French and the parliament altered it in less than two months before becoming official. Just a tiny comparison for those that claim EU is the beacon of democracy. Borell's garden is also full of weeds and animal shit
SPQR_Never_Fergetti@reddit
Lol , because a pension reform which was way overblown in france ( all other countries did it without trouble ) the EU ( not france ??!?! , bad things are in common ? ) is less democratic than Russia ? Fk Off and FLAIR UP!!
Super-Ant2417@reddit
I totally agree with this one.
This should be one of the last things for a country to do before becoming an EU member.
Since enlargement is not on the EU's agenda anytime soon, there's no need to harmonize anything.
True-Ruin-1892@reddit
Who is forcing you? If you want to join the EU do it, if you don’t want to join don’t.
Spervox@reddit
"Eat cookies if you don't have bread"
Stverghame@reddit
That's a textbook showcase of "ucena" lol. But sure, a Croat is there to talk all mighty.
True-Ruin-1892@reddit
Which country joined the EU without allying their visa policies with the EU? Not a single one. Typical eastern neighbours thinking everything is a conspiracy against them.
Future-Birthday-1573@reddit
I’d say typical Serb.
Stverghame@reddit
It is alright to align it right before joining. I see no point in "deleting" our visa free regimes if we ain't joining EU any time soon. Typical Croat wannabe westerner, always have to talk from height acting all noble and just.
Emotional_Rip7181@reddit
Ah, Balkans, never change.
freaxje@reddit
Yes. I'm also popcorning this one here from Belgium.
Balkans, it will never change.
Sad, true, funny all at the same time.
Rich_Plant2501@reddit
The truth is that we have a government that is supported by EU, but that government is actually doing nothing to join EU. Also, we are not forced to do this to join EU, but to keep the same visa policy between Serbia and EU.
One-Act-2601@reddit
You use “ucena” in everyday life too. You won’t give away your product or time unless you get paid. You won’t get into a relationship unless your needs are met. Sometimes “ucena” is normal and expected and healthy. When someone asks you for something you are within your right to lay out the conditions.
Kralizek82@reddit
There is the nice bag cash EU send your way just because you applied.
We can use it otherwise, if you don't like the money. Fine by us.
Techies4lyf@reddit
EU isn't forcing you to do anything, its your option to join or not.
Agavita_Tequila@reddit
Lmao, sure, if we announced that we don't want to join, Eu will unleash a bunch of petty sanctions like moves. We have seen it with the UK.
danirijeka@reddit
Then you need to see an optician
Agavita_Tequila@reddit
You have to be a special type of eurotard to think eu was not litigious and petty towards the UK, making sure they are sort of an example for other countries thinking of exit.
danirijeka@reddit
"why does (a country/a block of countries) pursue its own interests instead of others'? Is it stupid?"
SPQR_Never_Fergetti@reddit
Exactly , wtf , THEY left , they don't get to keep the benefits of EU outside the EU, what are these people smoking ?! If you are out of EU you get treated exactly like a country out of EU .
MegaMB@reddit
We weren't. Some members certainly were a bit more than others on certain topics, and the UK, as no longer a member, is also no longer a country whose interests are european priorities on the same level as a member. That's it. Are you made the EU put irish or french priorities above those of the UK, no longer a union member?
I mean, if you want to continue treating Croatia or Slovenia as yugoslave members when they no longer are that, you do you.
Comfortable-Cry8165@reddit
Don't forget us, you are one of the favorite spots to visit in Europe because of headache-less travel process.
Stverghame@reddit
Idk who you are, no flair
Comfortable-Cry8165@reddit
Sorry, fixed.
Small population, but still
Stverghame@reddit
Ah I see
I haven't encountered any of you here tbh, last time were two exchange students 10 years ago
Rotfrajver@reddit
Yeah, there are far bigger issues currently and this is like stabbing yourself in the foot
rakijautd@reddit
I'm thinking that it is shameful that our governments are acting as colonial deputies, and are destroying whatever little sovereignty we have left.
I also think that such foreign policy adjustments shouldn't be asked to proceed with until everything else is done, and the country is "ready to join", because these actions are 15 min work for the foreign ministry.
Furthermore I think that we shouldn't join the EU ever, because it will take said sovereignty that is still salvageable to restore, but once we are too deep in shit with the EU, we can say goodbye to ourselves deciding for ourselves.
Cordial relations and trading with the EU - ok
Joining to be ruled by Ursula Fon der Hitler is not, and she can't even suck my cock.
Kletronus@reddit
Pro Russian Serbian is not a surprise but it is always sad to see people become enemies just out of sheer stupidity. The stupidest country in Europe, by far.
rakijautd@reddit
0% arguments, 100% assumptions and insults, glad that I am "stupid" and you are "smart".
Kletronus@reddit
I didn't say you are stupid. I said your country is stupid: Pro Russian, anti-European and always on the wrong side of history.
timisanaLugoj@reddit
I mean Romania is doing just fine. Nothing actually changed after 2007. Oligarchs and people who worked in the previous communist party continue to steal the riches of the country from its people regardless of Romania's status. We have EU funds, but 90% of them ends up waisted because the government was to corrupt to use them correctly or respect the time limit and they ended up slashed. EU is all bark and no bite. They cant defeat the entranched corruption that exist in the East Euro countries because they are not willing to acknowledge that these politicians are the problem and end up legitimizing them.
I cant see how would be different from Serbia.
rakijautd@reddit
I won't dispute what you said about Romanian corruption, as I know very little about it.
If joining the EU is going to help our politicians to get even richer, as would be the conclusion from the info you provided, for me that is just another reason not to join, on top of surrendering any remnant of sovereignty that we have left.
ComprehensiveTax7@reddit
In the corrupt East Euro country I view the loss of sovereignty as a positive thing. There are limits on what the corrupt can do.
rakijautd@reddit
To each their own I guess. I don't view a loss of sovereignty of anyone as a positive thing.
Not to mention that it is laughable and naive to think that only east Europe is corrupt.
timisanaLugoj@reddit
Well, I just wanted to say that everything depends on the politicians. If they want to build a better country, they can get funds for that. But if they want to steal, EU cant stop them. They already have Hungary. They dont need another rebelious country, so they're more lenient to internal corruption. You dont see Ursula breaking down what country actually achieved what they promised to do. She knows, some countries are money sinks.
My main point is that it doesnt feel that any sovereignty was given up. After almost 20 years, I observed that the main pattern is that: if EU says that we need to do something (we dont like), we create a understaffed department and delegate the work there, so nothing is done in the end, but we have reports that show that 'work' was done. Pretty much like a corporation. Yes, it is very deceitful. This is why we are on the bottom of any EU statistics.
Own-Elevator-2571@reddit
well depends whether you value your "sovereignty" more than actually living a 10x better life lmao. stupid nationalist bs yall would rather starve and believe thqt you govern yourselves even though you certainly dont than live a good life while you in practice have more sovereignty than you had before.
Osstj7737@reddit
I don’t see any benefit from this
RedFin3@reddit
The benefit is for Serbia to join the EU.
spooky-Dragonfruit1@reddit
Which is never going to happen.
Arlandil@reddit
If you don’t put any effort in complimenting things like this and aligning with the EU step by step it won’t. You are right.
spooky-Dragonfruit1@reddit
Mate, Serbia is a dictatorship. Citizens have absolutely no say in what will be aligned with EU. It’s probably the most corrupt country in EU, maybe with exception of Moldova. Do you really think a dictator would try to join the Union where his power would be limited?
And also EU is kind of his accomplice, there’s video evidence od him stealing in elections, EU had congratulated him for the “win”. EU has condemned Turkey and Georgia governments, supporting the protests, while in Serbia, even though people are protesting for the same reason, EU has stayed silent. So consequently, support to join EU from Serbia citizens has dropped to new low of 42%.
RedFin3@reddit
It is likely to happen, but it will take a few years.
spooky-Dragonfruit1@reddit
What makes you say that? Serbia has not closed any chapters for more than 6 years. For most of those which are open, Serbia has actually regressed instead of progressing.
Public opinion has significantly deteriorated, so public is no longer in favor of joining the EU, atleast those who do, are in the minority.
Own-Elevator-2571@reddit
then dont implement it lmao. all you need to do is look at any other post-communist country and how entering the EU affected them. now if you look at those countries and still say that you dont want in bc the process is too hard, you are just braindead
Ok_Exit_9441@reddit
The last chapter was actually closed in December 2021, but ok. You still have a point anyways. Tho, I'm still one of the few who want the membership to happen. (Even tho I know it sadly ain't happening)
agent218@reddit
Read a bit on Serbia's integration process. It started in 2009 with minimal progress.
RegionSignificant977@reddit
It wouldn't happen if Serbian government doesn't want to happen.
spooky-Dragonfruit1@reddit
Mate, Serbia has not closed any chapters in 6 years. Nor is our government working on closing any. We actually are regressing in all needed reforms. We owe billions to the Chinese, most of which is kept secret, so pretty sure EU would not take in, an economy which is a ticking time bomb.
And the most important one, EU does not let in any countries which have a territorial dispute with other countries. Serbia has two, one of which is not likely to be resolved any time soon. So yeah, my point still stands.
Hot_Distribution_131@reddit
I think you confuse NATO and the EU. You can't join NATO if you have territorial disputes. However, you can join the EU. An example of this is Cyprus.
spooky-Dragonfruit1@reddit
In theory you are right, it is a rule by NATO, not by EU. But EU has requested Serbia to resolve and normalize the relations with Kosovo. And since Kosovo is asking for Serbia to aknowledge the independence, it's quite obvious that it will not happen, atleast officially.
Hot_Distribution_131@reddit
Oh, I understand now. Thank you. Out of curiosity, do you think Serbia will resolve this issue?
RegionSignificant977@reddit
I know. And I know that all of this is sadly on the expense of the people in Serbia. And sometimes issues like that with Kosovo are used by the ones that steal your future and your children future to keep them in power. Vucic isn't that popular lately. But even if he goes away you should make your statement clear. The rule of law and free media are the things that protect the people from the governments. Not that we don't have similar issues here, even if we are in the EU and the EU has more leverage. Even with that it's our job to demand the rule of law from the government and legislative body.
DDzxy@reddit
I don't want to.
deaddyfreddy@reddit
Serbs on r/Serbia: Look, even Serbian products are cheaper in Vienna than in Belgrade!
Also Serbs: 2+ million people live in EU countries
Some other Serbs: ...
DDzxy@reddit
Because EU is a shadow of its former self, the same fucking EU people in power perfectly fine with us having this dogshit leader and don’t give a shit about us. I was for joining before but now? Fuck that.
deaddyfreddy@reddit
nije sloba kriv
Osstj7737@reddit
That’s not gonna happen tho. Why do trivial shit that brings us no benefit and just has the potential to ruin our relationship with otherwise friendly countries?
MegaMB@reddit
That's a very good question given that most union members are pretty convinced the serbs want to get in to backstab the EU.
Which, you know, would be understandable. Most EU members took more or less dorectly part in the bombing of Belgrade that killed 10 000's of people.
One-Act-2601@reddit
Your government thinks it's going to happen. It's something you have to sort out with them. e.g. if they're delusional, elect another government. If you don't, get mad at your fellow countrymen.
Badeer21@reddit
Dear God no.
StuckInStable@reddit
EU entry and funding so that you can build infrastructure from German taxpayers money without going into debt.
Osstj7737@reddit
I do appreciate that, but to be honest that’s putting a bandage on a ruptured artery. We are bleeding a bit slower, but we are still dying as a country. It’s not a long term solution. It’s anyway mostly stolen by the corrupt politicians.
I would prefer the EU sanctioning the Serbian leadership so that we can start going in the right direction first, then work on developing the country.
StuckInStable@reddit
I hear you but it´s but I believe it´s better to put a bandage and heal while then trying to catch up with more developed nations with an advanced industrial and technical base like the western countries using a sick artery. The first thing doesn´t exclude the latter. Balkan nations atm have more people then they can possibly feed with their current economy. It´s not just a Serbian thing. Look at Croatia which is part of the EU. They´re a bit better off economically because of EU funding but despite that they are also dying demographically. I don´t know what the solution is but one big issue is all the wars and warmongering which they never seem to get rid off.
I think EU is a push in the right direction if you want to get rid of your leadership. Look at Sanader. Would never have been possible without EU.
FastBeach816@reddit
I would day don’t trust EU as ukraine did.
alpidzonka@reddit
They can ask anything they want and we can choose to comply or not, and then they can decide whether they're letting us in or not. In this case, I don't think we should comply.
freaxje@reddit
Yes that's fine. Also forget about ever being in the Shengen area then.
Stverghame@reddit
You do realize most of us here will be retired once Serbia is in Schengen? Bulgaria joined EU almost 20 years ago and only now they're entering Schengen. Serbia is not even in EU, let alone Schengen. What's the point of doing this now?
Arlandil@reddit
Yet Croatia has entered the EU 12 years ago and is already in Schengen and Eurozone..
It not hard, if you are willing to actually put an effort in joining the EU.
freaxje@reddit
I consider Schengen to be a lot more easy to join than EU. Bulgaria and Romania where the exceptions here.
For the EU you need to acknowledge the European courts of justice, for example. Ask Poland and Hungary how that goes.
Spervox@reddit
By what logic Serbia will get Schengen earlier than BG/RO? There is zero chance countries like Netherlands or Austria or Baltics would allow "Russian tojan horse" in EU let alon Schengen.
Stverghame@reddit
Oh please, don't tell me EU views Norway and Switzerland the way it views Serbia. Surely we have a chance at joining Schengen earlier than EU. This isn't even remotely funny.
freaxje@reddit
It's all up to you Serbs what you want.
The EU is mostly about economics and justice. You'll need to acknowledge all of the EU's economic/business related rules. And you'll need the accept that all of the final arbitration of all that happens in the EU courts of justice. Not in your own country's courts.
Because a company in let's say France doesn't want to have to know fucking Serbia's local laws just so it can do business with a Serbian company. No. Absolutely not.
EU law applies. Always. With nearly zero exceptions. That means final arbitration of it all, is in the EU courts of justice.
Schengen on the other hand is for traveling. It's for people. If Serbia wants to make it easy for its civilians to travel to the Schengen Area, then it needs to accept all of the rules as agreed with all other Schengen Area members.
If Serbia doesn't want to agree with anything at all. Then Serbia remains where it is now. Isolated. Completely. Nobody really cares. Except Serbs.
We can draw a picture for you too by the way. But it wont change how it works.
Also. Serbian propaganda wont change it either. Serbian politicians certainly wont change it.
You definitely can't change the EU from outside of the EU. It's a consensus model. So even Orban also ain't changing the EU much from within. Although he certainly has some influence. Not much.
You need consensus within the entire EU, to change anything at all.
It also doesn't have to be funny by the way.
SuccessfulResist6385@reddit
Your view is "Here are the rules, you comply and you get in". I believe most Serbs have a different view, "I would like to join EU and I am ready to make changes, but what if we comply and not become part of EU". Having visa free regime with these countries is definitely a nice advantage. And it is not the only advantage we will need to sacrifice so we MAY become part of EU. Macedonia changed its name, Albania loves EU more then any EU country (doing everything EU says) and both are not getting any closer.
Also, in my view, the current government is not doing a good job presenting the purpose and advantages of EU to its people, neither they are capable of negotiating any good deals with EU. The common narrative is "We give up on Kosovo to get into EU" and people get immediately angry. We are somehow missing a point that EU is not about getting a job in the West, but about a creating piece among European nations (that's going pretty well for now).
But let's be realistic, EU letting us join is not only about complying the policies. EU has a certain image of us, mostly drawn during 1995 and 1999. Its people consider us killers and don't like an idea of us sharing borders. Likewise, we have certain image of West drawn as result events like NATO bombing in 1999 or Croats devistating Serb population in concentration camps in WW2. I can understand rage from both sides (usually depicted in Reddit comments).
All of this is not answer to your comment, but rather to give a little more of our perspective.
freaxje@reddit
I understand this.
It is what it is.
So how can we overcome it?
ps. The EU is not about getting a job. It's about becoming more like Germany.
ps. Lately the EU is also about rebuilding a European army. For which we need to be less like Germany. Even Germany is going to increase its debt levels to achieve this. To be like Germany always meant not to have a lot of government debt.
ps. The EU is a consensus. Where there is no easy way to determine what weight matters most to achieve that consensus. Although public outcry seems to have a significant effect on it (climate change, covid-19, rearm europe where all huge contributors to EU's policy changes).
ps. Germany is really influential on the EU. So is France. So is Italy. So is ..
ps. ps.
ps. ps. ps.
SuccessfulResist6385@reddit
I hope there are smarter people in power than us who have a solution.
What you, me, and regular people can do is to have more empathy and less (passive) aggression.
Also, I would appreciate your support for political parties in Serbia willing to bring media freedom and rule of law. Given the huge ongoing protests it may be a great moment.
freaxje@reddit
I support those parties.
freaxje@reddit
ps. The longer I make my comments, the more down votes I get. The shorter, the more up votes I get.
This is silly of course. And it shows how little the Redditors here on AskBalkans try to think.
Stverghame@reddit
You are missing the point Mister Passive Agressive. My goal/intention is not to change EU/Schengen rules, nor to avoid them. I could ask you to read my comments again, but I see it is futile, so I'll just give up.
freaxje@reddit
I think the timing for Serbia to join the EU is fiercely complicated by the problems with Kosovo. I doubt that without a solution for that, neither is joining anything.
I don't know if that answers your question or not.
What is certainly not going to happen, is that the EU is going to import an armed conflict of any kind within its own borders.
Meaning that the moment a single bullet gets fired in either direction, all possibilities of either side joining are all completely over.
The last time this happened was in 2024. You can not send 45 heavily armed gunmen to Kosovo. That single event took away each and every chance for Serbia joining the EU.
Such stuff ain't funny, and it doesn't have to be funny either. The consequences are not a joke. And also wont be laughed at in Brussels in the future.
I also don't think that the nonsense both Kosovo and Serbia did with making each other put idiot license plate stickers on cars has helped either side with Schengen.
TwoZealousideal5698@reddit
Look man, if Serbia wants to remain a nation, it must not join the EU, nor Shengen.Cuz mere moment it does, people will mass leave the country, making it 10% worse than it is even now.And there is no real benefit from it to Serbia either.Money already does not go to the people and country imprpvement but to pockets of our goverment.
freaxje@reddit
This is completely ok. But we can go recursively into this as deep as we want.
The ones who need to make up their mind about it, are the Serbs. And nobody else.
TwoZealousideal5698@reddit
Serbs have FAR BIGGER ISSUES RN than if they will be European yesman and Chinese one.For example our goverment that is more autocratic than NAZI Germany
freaxje@reddit
This is completely ok.
TwoZealousideal5698@reddit
Never said it wasnt.I am just saying Serbians should focus more on overthrowing the goverment (imo only way to do it is by force), and making sure same or worse one does not come next. (Would get rid of nearly all major politiciand in country in last 30 years since they are scum, likely by death penalty to secure it), and not on to which side they will be owned by, since neither brings them good.Worst mistake Serbia made is privatisation.Should have kept stuff nationalised
MegaMB@reddit
Viewed Switzerland, nop you're right.
That said, in the future... Yeah, that'll likely change. The feench are fed up with the swiss advantages and treaties that have signed with the EU, and we're pushing for cancelling them and to push the swiss to accept a new treatie.
alpidzonka@reddit
Honestly, I really don't think we'll join the Schengen area before joining the EU. There doesn't seem to be much to say in terms of the "carrot" part of our EU accession at the moment, what with the rising euroscepticism within the EU and the enlargement fatigue in general.
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
Bulgaria and Romania waited 20 years to get in Shengen I presume Serbia will need to wait at least 30 by then the world politics will be much different than now especially with China's growth and US not paying EU's bill anymore. Also Monkedonia and Albania implemented all the policies EU wanted of them and they are still nowhere near EU membership (both of them waiting around 30 years now)
freaxje@reddit
The 'problems' with Serbia joining the EU, or, Schengen, can be quickly resolved the moment it constructively helps solving the Kosovo problem.
After that it's about signing a bunch of documents, implementing huge quantities of EU laws (yes, huge huge quantities). Agreeing with things that are nearly impossible for the current Serbian leadership to agree with (like acknowledging the European courts of justice). Which comes down to instructing local media channels to say for a few weeks that it's a good thing. Propaganda does magic.
Nothing is as easy to replace than the current leadership of any country. Go ask the nice people at the CIA how that works.
Maybe, for Serbia, it'll be the nice people at The Kremlin? As part of a Ukrainian peace agreement between Trump and Russia perhaps?
You sell me a cow. I will sell you a sheep. We just need to agree in what currency we'll do it.
People can down vote me to -200 for saying this. But at the same time, Balkan people should by now know very well that I am right about how this shit really works.
Timing has less to do with it than you think. Ukraine can also very suddenly join the EU, if we can believe queen Ursula Von Der Leyen. I typed her name in full, so the angry people get really angry.
It's not up to her. It's up to the people with weapons.
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
Yeah, you might be right about all of that but as events go it seems like that EU will be faster Balkanised than the other way around
Aofstb@reddit
If we could indeed join Schengen Area with this reform, that would be a great benefit to our citizens, and we need to be honest about that. Everybody here knows somebody who works or studies in the EU and Norway, and how bureucracy would be simpler if we would have such status. Lot of our people took the dual citizenships of Hungary and Croatia, precisely because of that.
freaxje@reddit
Exactly. And this is precisely why Shengen area and its visa policy/regulations is completely independent of European Union membership, in both directions.
Aofstb@reddit
Thanks for the info, visa/policy regulation is pretty straightforward process. And I agree, EU membership, debating if and when is completely different thing, but this we should be striving to do most definitely. Again, joining Schengen would benefit our people greatly.
freaxje@reddit
As would joining the EU. But I consider joining the EU to be much much more difficult for Serbia than joining the Schengen zone is or would be.
caktz@reddit
There are three countries that have a lot of pull and also economic benefits to Serbia. Which are 🇷🇺,🇨🇳and🇹🇷Guess which countries EU asks to implement visa from Serbia? The same three countries. EU is evil we made the same mistake back then and look how it turned out? I hope Serbia never does the same mistake.
MegaMB@reddit
Real question, would you say these 3 countries have more pull and economic benefit for Serbia than the EU itself?
No judgement here, I'm EU citizen, I also am against Serbia joining.
rakijautd@reddit
Russia has all the resources one would need to import.
China is the production powerhouse of the world that overtook EU in real economy by a large margin.
Cutting all possible ties and economic cooperation with those two countries, because some bureaucrat in Brussels wants so for whatever agenda they are paid to push, is surrendering any form sovereignty for the benefit of someone else, without getting much, if anything.
Not to mention the geopolitical aims of EU leadership that envision smaller eastern countries to be sent to die against whatever "threat" they hallucinate about from the east, or for the Balkans to be the dumping ground for the "unfit" immigrants, or for the vision of Serbia becoming an ecological disaster so that west European car producers can pretend that they can compete with China in EV industry.
As for Turkey we need good economic cooperation for crucial resources that are coming through a southern route mostly. They are an important country for transit that connects numerous regions and funnels them into south east Europe and the Mediterranean sea.
The EU was a good concept, until it stopped being so when corrupt bureaucrats started caring about their own pockets, and started treating members as servants.
If the EU leadership wants good for their own people and members, they should accept reality and start working with all of these countries, otherwise the EU itself is going to stay way behind the rest of the world.
MegaMB@reddit
I mean... No judgement there, but if Russia produces the raw materials and China transforms them, that leaves the serbs with little to nothing economically, outside bankrupting yourselves into buying chinese goods. What makes you wealthy is producing in Serbia and exporting elsewhere. Not sure serb companies can produce and export with the malus to Russia, China. Rukey is a more credible trading partner.
'Cause you know. Geography is a reality Serbia has to face.
But it is pretty funny that the idea Serbia's import and export markets with Romania, Greece, Croatia, Austria or Bulgaria are that marginal. EU members are 63% of your exports, and 56% of your imports.
No judgement for the refusal of the mines in Serbia, if you can continue a bit longer the time for us in France to fully establish our mines and battery production instead of Hungary, it'd be nice. We need those jobs.
And trade with Turkey is a fine idea, but it's still pretty hard by flight. And they kinda are a negligeable export market for Serbia.
But yezh, interesting comment whose whole purpose is to avoid answering to my question. Also, very funny picture of the EU. If more serbs could have it, it'd be nice. As I said, we're not exactly fan of Serbia in the EU either.
rakijautd@reddit
We are a transit and agriculture country. That is what our geography dictates. We need fuels from Russia, and tech from China.
We could export food produce, if our economy wasn't choked by big western companies. Under pressure we were forced to sell most of our drinking water springs to western companies. (Mostly bought by coca-cola for pennies)
Under pressure we were forced to sell our tobacco company. (bought by Philip Morris for pennies)
Under pressure we were forced to sell most of our food processing companies. (bought by various EU companies for pennies)
Under pressure we are being forced to allow an ecological disaster that would bring us 0 gain.
Don't worry, those mines are happening in Serbia only over dead bodies of Serbs. Serbian people are pretty much ready to kill those that want to pollute and rape our country with those same mines.
As I said, cordial relations and trade under fair conditions - sure, would be more than glad.
Subjecting our own lives for the benefit of some western shareholders filling Kurvula fon der Lier pocket - no.
The benefit from the EU is that it is owning a big portion of our economy atm, alongside other entities, so some money spills over here in the process. The negative part is that we can't have a chance to have our own economy if we surrender the right to trade with whoever we want. Without joining there is hope for us to buy back our resources and land, and start doing shit for ourselves. I thought that this was clear from my comment, so pardon me for the confusion.
cnr0@reddit
As a Turkish I can say that - if we didn’t need a visa to visit Greece, I am sure that our tourism industry will definitely bankrupt in one day and all local tourists will just go to Greece, it is cheaper and sometimes even better in many ways. I can’t imagine how much local tourism we will lose when we are in schengen. So thanks to EU we still somehow have a maintained local tourism :)
skyduster88@reddit
Yeah because Russian & cover cronyism is a better alternative.
caktz@reddit
I’m not saying that Serbia should become a Russian/chinese puppet. I am just saying that it’s not a great idea to let other countries implement policies for your own foreign policies. It’s never a good idea.
skyduster88@reddit
Right, it's totally possible to rely on Russia/China for most of your economy, while avoid being controlled by them. /s
Several-Zombies6547@reddit
The "evil" EU doesn't force anyone to join and apply its requirements. And it's pretty lazy to blame the EU, but not the national politicians that brought Greece to where we are now.
NikomedesV@reddit
I was really wanted to see serbia. It's pity.
Nothing_Special_23@reddit
This is outrageous and ridiculous! One more reason to take to the streets and support the students!
Not only are we loosing our soverenty and visa policy, but we're also being hypocrits and making not nice moves towards the countries that have been correct towards us... and for what? For nothing! Literally nothing! Backstabbing correct partners for the sake of alligning our visa policy with the countries that have been.... let' say "unfriendly" (to say the least) for the last 50 years at least....
rakijautd@reddit
Add another 100 years to those 50 years btw, otherwise you are correct.
desertedlamp4@reddit
Turkey is one of their biggest trade partners and investors. Ridiculous
Kaamos_666@reddit
Yes but EU investments are sweeter than TR
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
EU investments will bankrupt your factories then buy it for cheap and then probably sell it to China like they did to Gorenje in Slovenia other big companies like Perutnina were also both and sold several time just so big EU companies don't have competition, in Bulgaria over 50% of the companies shut down after entering in EU. I presume if Türkiye ever gets in to EU, Beko will be the first to go
rakijautd@reddit
HAH! We got all that from the EU&USA even without joining, but just for a chance of joining...
Kaamos_666@reddit
That’s depressive… Do you have any source article about this? I can translate the site to EN if it’s in Bulgarian…
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
https://www.ceicdata.com/en/bulgaria/bulgarian-stock-exchange-number-of-listed-companies/number-of-listed-companies-bse-annual
https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/Bulgaria/Listed_companies/
Kaamos_666@reddit
That’s so weird man, Turkey’s the opposite. Listed companies increase. That sounds real bad… https://www.ceicdata.com/en/turkey/borsa-istanbul-number-of-listed-companies-and-nominal-value/listed-company-borsa-istanbul-number-of-companies
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
Well now 80% of the products in Europe comes from Türkiye and China because of cheap workforce, if Türkiye gets into EU the whole EU is doomed because there will be no more cheap but still acceptable quality stuff. Now EU technological components all come from China they just assemble them in EU
geniuslogitech@reddit
my cousin is manager in Hisense now, former Gorenje, I can vouch for what u/Tenchi_Muyo1 is saying about how EU is fcking up trade with China just to then sell companies to China, 1st way EU citizens profit, 2nd way corrupt politicians profit from big bribes
Thortheonly1@reddit
Yea this is true. My country Montenegro introduced visas to Qatar, Bahrein and Egypt.
As of January 1st 2026 we will most likely introduce visas for Russia, Belarus, Ukraine, Turkey, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Arabia and UAE.
Stelist_Knicks@reddit
I never understood why Qatar Kuwait and Oman have visa requirements. Does the EU really think their nationals (which are very few btw) would over stay their visas?
Djlas@reddit
These things are usually not based on what they think but on data (visa refusal rate, entry refusal rate, overstaying)
Stelist_Knicks@reddit
I know you edited your comment but I severely doubt this is the case with these countries. These guys are loaded. No need to overstay. I'm positive that it is purely political. I don't even know what the Kuwaiti and omanis did lmao. They usually stay in their lane.
Djlas@reddit
ok here's a comprehensive list of criteria considered, it's a bit more than statistics - EU comission proposed to abolish visas: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/cs/qanda_22_2507
But yeah difficult to point to the exact reason, not sure but maybe one country is enough to veto it, which could be just someone scared of Muslims.
Stelist_Knicks@reddit
Reading the article. They admit it isn't anything related to migration patterns. And that security risks are moderate and can be easily mitigated.
It could be a Muslims bad thing. But UAE has visa free access.
And as for human rights, the UAE is the same as Qatar, Kuwait, Saudi, etc.
My guess is this: UAE is an ally of Israel. Qatar and Kuwait are openly not allies of Israel. That's it.
Djlas@reddit
Eh IMO people seriously overestimate its importance, Israel doesn't live rent free in everyone's head.
Stelist_Knicks@reddit
I mean you say that but Germany, Austria, Hungary, France, etc have openly cracked down on pro Palestine protests.
It's not a far fetched conspiracy when there's tangible evidence the governments are trying to supress an opinion. But that's not either here nor there
Djlas@reddit
Yeah but the protests are directly linked to Israel. I meant that not every foreing policy decision depends so much on "what does this country think about Israel"
forzaq8@reddit
We don't align perfectly with EU , they demand stuff they would never demand from USA , like no death penalty
Stelist_Knicks@reddit
or rEcoGniZinG occupied Palestine perhaps 🤔🤔🤔
Funny coincidence how none of Oman, Qatar, or Kuwait recognizes the occupiers of Palestine. Yet needs a visa to enter the EU.
Yet UAE doesn't need visas to go to the EU... Funny huh?
HumanMan00@reddit
Im not knowledgeable enough to understand the higher implications of this information.
WorldlinessRadiant77@reddit
It means you will join around 2030 or so. They made us adopt EU visa policy in 2001 I think.
CharacterSherbet7722@reddit
Nah more like 2070, assuming the EU doesn't detonate by then and these guys in our government die out
We've applied pretty much none of the EU reforms necessary to join, we can't even get into SEPA
Glory to the serbian ret-progressives
gocenik@reddit
Common now, don't be so optimistic. You will join the veto club even if you elect the best politician in the world, and he/she gets to not be killed and reform the society to be modern utopia, it wouldn't matter.
CharacterSherbet7722@reddit
Bold of you to assume joining the EU is the goal and not simply stealing the values they claim to stand for
gocenik@reddit
But we did have even better values than them, yet somehow we lost them and were fooled that they had it better. So now the agenda is that the migrants are to blame and how dare you to let them come, while they don't have a problem to bring fascism back if that's what it takes to keep the euros rolling and keep their masters rich and safe.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Don't spread propaganda, the nationalistic government of MK called VMRO blocked MK for 11 years from 2006-2016 for the name dispute.
gocenik@reddit
Actually, all the governments of Greece were doing that, if you have noticed. As long as I care, you can have VMRO, those guys are either thieves or thugs or traitors. Nothing good has come from them, nothing ever will.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Yes the thieves for which half of MK has voted for them
gocenik@reddit
Yeah, VMRO put the veto, how stupid of them.
VMRO are something like SNS or HDZ, but what they are not is a party like Golden Dawn or Vazrazhdane, or Radikali. The fact that we even don't have a similar far right party, while most of the neighbors keep them in the parliament, is even stranger than yours trolling.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Those far right that you mention don't form governments but are small opposition.
VMRO are radicals which won the most of the votes so it's really nasty. I wouldn't put HDZ as populists either as they are pro European party but definitely corruptive.
gocenik@reddit
Small opposition of neo-Nazis and small opposition of Putin lovers, how romantic.
So extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence, I bet you can prove your claims
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
The vice prime minister of MK is a Serbian who visits Russia despite sanctions and MK being part of NATO.
You should see more openly
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
There are western countries that have Russian parties and politicians thats not argument.
MK is screwed with VMRO because they are radicals hiding behind national identity and claiming other and other ideas except their own are wrongdoing.
Familiar_Anywhere815@reddit
VMRO-DPMNE is not a radical party.
We have not one, but several actual far right parties. They are not in parliament and never get even 1% of the votes.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
I would say they are populist political gang which for me is the same as radicals. I know right wing yes but with heavy conservative and nationalistic ideology is the best atribute for a gang.
Ok_Exit_9441@reddit
Highly unrealistic
hikingmaterial@reddit
There is a lot more to EU membership than visa regulation alignment and it is unlikely that the EU will continue to expand as rapidly as it has before. There are significant problems with countries that join stopping their reforms after, which needs to be resolved first before further accession.
Markomannia@reddit
Wow, let'smake Serbian passport and tourism even weaker.
And get nothing in return.
Best deal ever.
zzgamma@reddit
The day Schengen drops border between Croatia and Serbia will be historic.
Super-Ant2417@reddit
But, why!? No country from the Western Balkans will join the EU anytime soon. Like, for at least a decade or two.
There's no need for any changes to conform to EU rules.
Once the EU is serious about the enlargement process, they can knock on the door again and Serbia and other countries waiting in the line can apply these changes before entering the EU.
Ok_Exit_9441@reddit
They will all join the time when EU is gonna be in it's downfalls.
ZhiveBeIarus@reddit
Eww, disgusting.
Serbia should never become the EU's bitch, screw the EU and long live Serbia.
Ok_Exit_9441@reddit
Screw both, glory to neutralism.
Dismal-Attitude-5439@reddit
Belarus shouldn't have become russia's nuclear weapons disposal site but here we are
scp_euclid_object@reddit
Omg, I thought my eyes deceived me for a moment. I saw a Belorussian with white-red-white flag and “free Belorussia” slogan saying “fuck EU” and has russia as part of his countries in profile. Your country is tyranny, your language is dead, soon whole country will be fully consumed by russia, and none of it was done by EU.
Ok_Exit_9441@reddit
What's the point of doing this?
RoboAdmin1234@reddit
So now serbia is closer to EU, like 2089 or something…
Ok_Exit_9441@reddit
2089 feels way too soon bro.
illyguy998@reddit
That feels soon tbh.
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
Fuck Đurić and whoever else gives up the sovereignty of their country to decide their own foreign policy.
Several-Zombies6547@reddit
Yeah, exit the EU and give full sovereignty to ND, I'm sure this will end up very well. /s
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
I don't have any misconceptions that exiting the EU while having ND as the ruling party will be any good. What's necessary is to have a true left-wing (socialist) party to lead the exit, to make up for the subsequent lack of the EU in the fields where it's actually beneficial, and to do the things that the EU doesn't allow us otherwise, that is to enact a system of worker ownership of the means of production for non-critical stuff, (re)nationalization and state ownership for critical stuff, minimize the colonialist influence of the entrepreneurs, the bankers and the EU itself, which all dictate our economic and foreign policies.
Buy_from_EU-@reddit
Why don't you go back to Serbia then if you don't like the EU so much?
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
And who has told you I'm not considering it? (But remove the word "back", I'm not born in Serbia, nor I'm ethnically a Serb.)
Buy_from_EU-@reddit
Stop pretending to be greek online, that's a start towards your dreams
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
Assuming I was Serbian, why would I pretend to be Greek? 🤔️
Buy_from_EU-@reddit
Cause people were racist to you and you didn't belong so you talk shit about your host country as result and its society. Like most immigrants basically, you are not special
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
We Greeks aren't racist to Serbs lol.
This game is lots of fun. Shall we keep playing?
Buy_from_EU-@reddit
Greeks are racist to anyone non greek.
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
Except to Serbs.
Buy_from_EU-@reddit
Not really. They are not special. Just another flavour of Ivan
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
I beg to differ.
Buy_from_EU-@reddit
Well you don't get an opinion on this as a foreigner really
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
Άντε βαρέθηκα!
CriticalHistoryGreek@reddit
Why do you hate ~~us~~ >!/s!< so much?
MBkizz@reddit
You should measure the decision better, cause you will regret it lol
Sad-Notice-8563@reddit
Why don't you go back to aromania?
anotherboringdj@reddit
Because EU ETA/esta/eVisa is coming
Remote_Succotash@reddit
In the case of the Serbian government, this won’t have any political impact. However, anything else—such as media freedom or the rule of law—that truly benefits the people will not be implemented, as it would undermine the autocratic regime. Instead, they will simply check a box in the report and present it as progress in aligning with EU values. This will please bureaucratic ears.
Super-Ant2417@reddit
Fighting corruption and strengthening the rule of law should be done as default - regardless of whether Serbia is joining the EU or not.
Visas are just so unimportant in this sense.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Western Balkan is simply incompatible with eu. Look at Bosnia or North Macedonia.
A lot of problems and Turkish investments and people are very welcomed there so I don't expect anything to change regarding the EU.
Some-Sense-314@reddit
You dont even know what you are talking about.
Macedonia is has the most EU-aligned visa policy among the WB countries. They only have to introduce visas for Turkey and they will be fully aligned (Croatia, for example, introduced visas for Turkey in 2013, 3 months before joining the EU).
Bosnia also started aligning its policy in 2022 by introducing visas for citizens of Cuba, Oman, Bahrein and Saudi Arabia. Azerbaijan, China, Turkey, Russia, Kuwait and Qatar are remaining.
Super-Ant2417@reddit
Macedonia introducing visas for Turkey would be suicidal for its tourist industry.
Also, Macedonia will not become an EU member for like 15-30 years, so there's no need to self-stab in the back just now.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Those countries are incompatible with the EU in any sense.
I also think many Turkish workers will be imported to these Balkan non EU countries because of tradition and shortage of domestic skills.
RegionSignificant977@reddit
Workers always need visas anyway. I can't see a reason why those countries can't be compatible with the EU.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
If you follow what happens in Bosnia Serbia or MK you will see it's very bad situation I don't believe EU can help them as they simply are too bad.
RegionSignificant977@reddit
I know man. But the reason why we are bad is because we choose the ones that didn't want to make our countries better. Even in Bulgaria where our government postpones legislation changes that will do that for decades, even two because it's convenient for the ones that rule the country. We should demand the right things from the government, that will make our homeland better place in the long run. It's not easy even here where EU has more leverage.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Bulgaria although has problems is far better than what you have in west Balkan. Disputes there are not resolvable and corruption and low economy is thriving only
RegionSignificant977@reddit
Bulgaria is on the edge of the tipping point where there might have more people returning than emigrating. The thing that makes me mad is that it doesn't take much for some things to be far better. And that tipping point would be years behind not few years ahead.
Caged_Rage_@reddit
Goodbye Serbians friends :(
Spervox@reddit
It's not happening
Hyperion_000@reddit
hahaha this is so funny!!!!
Gino-Solow@reddit
Would "visa on arrival" qualify?
zoranss7512@reddit
Stupid mfers
laroche444@reddit
Noo..I am half Serbian half Mongolian and we had visa free stay for 90 days :(
bober8848@reddit
Well, as a Russian citizen living in Serbia for more then 2 years already i have quite a mixed feelings here :D
shockwave_1D@reddit (OP)
Why?
bober8848@reddit
Well, i have quite a pessimistic feeling raised by last 3 years that any changes could result in "you're russian so fuck off, we don't care what the law say", and it'll be quite a sad chain of events.
On the other hand, if it'll lead to Serbia getting into Schengen zone i feel like i'd benefit from it way more then most of local people, as they already have a visa-free travel, and a lot of people actually abuse it to go to work to EU. I need to paln my trips for half a year to get a visa instead.
SuccessfulResist6385@reddit
We will not get into EU but we will lose visa free entrance to China/Turkey/Russia :O
I am fascinated how we manage to pull out the worst from both sides.
Caged_Rage_@reddit
Tf r u talking about. There will never be a visa process for you to enter Turkey like ever.
Bitter_Jacket_2064@reddit
The Balkans need to fight corruption and stop fighting amongst themselves. Without Serbia-Kosovo relationship being fixed I don't think there is a chance of joining.
Inevitable-Use-4534@reddit
Its bullshit, nobody will join the EU anymore
Slow_Independence714@reddit
Western Balkans may not join the EU, but it will enjoy some EU advantages (such as freedom of movement, single market, SEPA…) before joining (something like Norway), according to the new Growth Plan. The more you align, the more you get. Albania and Montenegro have already been admitted into SEPA, so the first thing from the Growth Plan is done. They obviously see that we can’t get in the regular way.
_KingOfTheDivan@reddit
But Montenegro doesn’t have visa requirements for Russians, so why would they ask it for Serbia
freaxje@reddit
Something like Norway = Shengen area.
darksugarfairy@reddit
I can totally see our treacherous government doing this and then the EU being like "see? They're dedicated to their European path. So we have nothing to worry about. Good job, Mr president, for keeping stability in the region 😊"
TwoZealousideal5698@reddit
Ngl people should just gun those bastards down.FFS, we have 40 guns per 100 people in the country
darksugarfairy@reddit
Violence is not the solution to anything!
(just don't open any history book to check this)
TwoZealousideal5698@reddit
😂😂😂 To be honest i am not for violence overall, but here in Serbia there is no other way, they dont care people protest, they even secretly like them all being in big groups so they can track them easier while they steal even more money
Subject-Afternoon127@reddit
Most Serbs I know have the same mindset as those from genocidal era. I don't see why it would be beneficial to the EU to add a more communist and poorer version of Hungary. It makes no sense, IMO.
Serbians love authoritarianism, hate Croatia, hate basically all of the west, and masturbate thinking about Russia. The only thing they want is the visa free travel to the EU, Australia, NZ, and North America.
Djlas@reddit
Normal process when trying to join EU, everyone did it sooner or later. But also to keep visa free access to EU, I don't think anyone is joining anytime soon.
X-East@reddit
As Slovenian i don't think Serbian values align with that of EU and should not be allowed to join until a time when they do. Major thing being their corruption and alignment with Russia, if we let it join before that is fixed we will have another Hungary on our hands that will veto every decision made.
Regulus_Exemplar@reddit
After the mutilation we put ourselves through that has absolutely nothing to do with their Copenhagen criteria just to please everyone around us only to get tossed aside when all of it was done, they can go to hell. I don’t care about most of the countries this photo mentions but introducing a visa regime for Turkey is out of the question.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Your country is dying out from nationalism and corruption and you are not asked but simply your politicians don't care anyway.
Regulus_Exemplar@reddit
Everyones been dying of nationalism since 2015 no ones an exception in this area. The thing is we all know the EU is “pretending” to expand, thats their last card but how long before that mask drops? I’m just preparing for the inevitable to hit in advance.
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
Balkan disputes are not resolvable you are in a bad spot with Kosovo for example which is also not resolvable.
Only one common thing for Balkan and other EU countries is young people emigrate but still in Balkan is way worse.
Regulus_Exemplar@reddit
Bad spot with Kosovo? We have perfectly normal relations and trade with them they’re the least problematic thing on our list.
Bulgaria is a problem only as long as we aspire to join the EU but since that isn’t even a possibility anymore I guess we don’t have anymore problems with them or concessions to give to them. We just need to realize we’ve been on a fool’s errand.
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
First, those countries should join the EU and then regulate the visas so they can join the Schengen otherwise I don't see the benefit of those countries implementing visas
Aggressive_Limit2448@reddit
With such bilateral disputes they will never going to reform and enter. They are simply too bad countries.
psybliz@reddit
Who in their right mind would want to be part of the EU anyway?
GoodZealousideal5922@reddit
If these countries want EU membership (which idk if Serbia wants it or not) then they have to introduce the same visa regulations as the EU because if Germany for example requires visas for Mongolians but Hungary (for example) does not, then a Mongolian can just fly to Hungary without a visa and then travel to Germany (no border checks between EU countries) rendering Germany’s visa policy useless. That is why all EU countries need to have the same visas.
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
I think the main problem here is that they introduce visas for these countries but they will also wait several years for EU membership or might never get in. Also I think this is more of a Schengen problem than EU membership
Tenchi_Muyo1@reddit
They should just go throw the railway system as normal "refugees"
vargaking@reddit
I see what you did there
Kitchen_Lawyer6041@reddit
Their national anthem is written by a Romanian, so it's a cultural thing that has to be done.
Stelist_Knicks@reddit
He's a man of culture
Uriel42069666@reddit
Woah there Atilla 🤣 hypothetically
Romeo_y_Cohiba@reddit
Even worse, what if this prospective Mongolian comes on the back of a horse instead of flying?
freaxje@reddit
It's actually more about the Shengen area than about EU. Norway, Switzerland and Iceland for example aren't in the EU but in Shengen area.
Balkan countries prior to joining to EU (or not) can be in the Shengen area.
But if Serbs don't want that, then that's fine for us. Then they don't.
SecretRaspberry9955@reddit
What you on about man? Unless you mean the schengen village, Romania & Bulgaria been in EU for 20 years before they joined Schengen
freaxje@reddit
Yes, as I say: it's independent. Schengen area is about free movement of people.
In fact the people who bring up EU membership for Serbia, are on the wrong track. If this is about visa regulations, Schengen area is what matters. Not EU membership.
EU is an economic zone:
It's not my fault that Serbs are obsessed with EU membership and make every topic be about that.
This is about Schengen area. Just go read up on the simple facts.
Sea_Square638@reddit
A deal which includes a country subjugating itself to another country is never a good deal
ImamTrump@reddit
No one is gatekeeping Serbia lmao. This is a bureaucratic step to get your country and another country written side by side and signed.
Another check on a list.
Protobugarin@reddit
As much as political core is retarded in Serbia I doubt they were like: "it's fucking boring today, lets impose visas to some random countries".
So yeah, there was some pressure for sure.
freaxje@reddit
Indeed. Nobody is asking Serbia anything at all. They can comply to a variety of rules that Shengen area members all also comply to. Or they don't.
Latter case they aren't in Shengen area. Former they can be.
For the EU membership there are a few million more rules to comply with. They can ask Poland how that works: among them, you need to recognize the European courts. Which I'm certain Serbs will never want to recognize.
That is fine. Then they wont be part of the EU. Meanwhile they can be part of Shengen area. But not if these set of absolute minimal rules on for example visa regulations aren't put in place.
That is fine. They they wont be part of the Shengen area.
That is all fine.
Nobody is asking the Serbs anything.
Serbs here can also stop pretending that anybody is asking them anything. Or that they would even be welcome.
Because there is this Kosovo thing. Which is very hard going to be agreed on with A LOT of existing EU countries.
We ain't importing a civil war thing into the EU. Absolutely not.
sirhearalot@reddit
Good way to keep criminals out
Dickhard1305@reddit
Serbia will join the EU in 2033.
Iraqi_Weeb99@reddit
EU is enforcing immigration control on Balkans but not middle esst or africs....
shockwave_1D@reddit (OP)
Why should EU care about middle east?
ChieftainBob@reddit
Meanwhile, people are attacked for waving EU flags in the protests.
MLukaCro@reddit
Of they want to enter the EU they should comply with EU's foreign policy.
3lijahmorningwoood@reddit
If a Russian soldier is shot to death, there's a very good chance that the bullet that killed him was provided by Serbia.
How does Croatia help Ukraine's war effort when compared to a billion dollars worth of ammunition?
milfshake146@reddit
Kakve to ima veze sa vizom 🤣
freaxje@reddit
This stuff goes further and without this also keeps Serbia forever out of Shengen area.
Travelmusicman35@reddit
As if Croatia does
Individual-Cream-581@reddit
Well well well.. licking putler ballz doesn't pay as good as it used to..
freaxje@reddit
Everybody: Visa regulations -> Schengen area. Not EU membership.
The European Union (EU) is a supranational political and economic union of 27 member states that are located primarily in Europe. Source.
You don't need to be in a political and economic union to have common visa regulations or policy. For that you have the Schengen area.
Ecclypto@reddit
This is a weird post because in the end it says that these countries need to introduce visa requirements too, but not that Serbia needs to introduce visa requirements on them.
What Serbia needs, in my opinion, is investment, primarily in physical capital that can be used to generate export revenue. And a massive cut back on government’s ability to fuck shit up for businesses
Protobugarin@reddit
All of that just to open some irrelevant chapter.
Fuck yeah
Ok_Dentist_1998@reddit
This is share stupidity, 90% of these countries have more much money then we do. Nobody wants to stay in Serbia.. Turkey? Come on..
Comfortable-Dot-5764@reddit
EU needs Serbia or at least its resources, they will have a blind eye for this