I just performed a landing so badly I over heard the cabin crew asking if everyone was OK. What's your worst landing (make me feel better).
Posted by Healthy_Awareness_98@reddit | flying | View on Reddit | 206 comments
I had the A320 struts working overtime
somerndmnumbers@reddit
Much different rig but I just bought my first aircraft, and on the 4th landing I absolutely greased it in, just as I was about to pat myself on the back, "clunk!" The right wing slowly lowers until the scratching sounds come, the prop touches, and we slide off the runway. Gear collapsed due to maintenance oversight. Plane totaled. Flew it for 3.1 hours.
darth_mufasa11@reddit
Used to work air medevac. There was a story going around about a landing so hard, it woke the patient up from a 6 month coma.
Far_Top_7663@reddit
Tearing the wing off due to landing gear loads must be worse than all the "terrible horrible super hard" you guys are mentioning here.
girl_incognito@reddit
I absolutely piled a CRJ-700 on in Denver once after having not flown it in a while. That's gotta be my worst landing to date.
I apologized to the aft FA and she just laughed and said "yeah it got real quiet in here." Lol.
girl_incognito@reddit
In light of recent events... maybe I csbbforgive myself for this landing :P
hoosier06@reddit
I have what my LCA described as airbus ptsd after cratering one in. I have two or 3 that keep me on my toes.
al_andaluz@reddit
I just had mine yesterday. Weather deteriorated terribly and went from clear and OVC 7000 to 1/2sm and ceilings at 1300’ (our MDA was 1310) in less then 10 minutes. Approach gave us a super terrible intercept which led us to go straggling to get aligned on the course. Once we did we were already at GS intercept and with the AWOS barely reporting the changes quick enough we only saw the runway at 100’AGL. Add that to a +- of about 10 on final along with a sturdy right x wind of about 25kts that when I finally got the runway and straightened it out to land, I went to kick the rudder but was too early with it and came down what felt like damn near sideways. While the landing itself wasn’t hard, per se, it was not pretty and definitely not straight. Glad that’s over lol
Bunslow@reddit
i fear the sideload
fallstreak_24@reddit
Hate to say it, but these things happen. Especially early in your type experience. Not sure if my hard/firm landings are thinking about me still but I’m still thinking about that one in Roatan…3 years later. FA submitted an OJI for it from the jump seat. RIP. Wasn’t technically a hard landing but it wasn’t an ego booster that’s for sure. Live and learn, have since redeemed that landing many times.
flightist@reddit
Hah, the one I keep thinking about years later was RTB too. 07?
fallstreak_24@reddit
Yeah RWY 7 at night. Had to get a waiver to go in at midnight lol. 737 flaps 40 landing and just dropped in on. Took the short field landing technique a bit too literally that time.
flightist@reddit
Mine was during the day, but was my first 40 flaps landing in a 737 about a week into flying the thing. Shortest runway I’d seen in it by probably 3000+ feet, and my lizard brain just sort of took over and went ‘you’d better pull power a little early and land it firm’.
Check and, uh, double check.
Bunslow@reddit
god scrolling down these comment chains is peak comedy
BUTTER_MY_NONOHOLE@reddit
We inevitably all end up with the "I wonder if my shitty landing is still thinking about me, too" meme in our possession
_toodamnparanoid_@reddit
r/121stWorldProblems
Bunslow@reddit
that is a great name for a sub damn
Big-Carpenter7921@reddit
My friend set off their ELT with a landing
Twice
chuckop@reddit
I had an instructor who would often tune 121.5 after landing and announce he was checking to see if the ELT went off.
Bunslow@reddit
that's part of my manufacturer's recommended shutdown procedure, they cite specific instances of it happening in the type before
sirduckbert@reddit
You should do that every landing. Not so bad with 406’s since it tells on you, but ELT’s go off daily on airports causing work for those monitoring the SAR system.
And if you do set it off, tell ATC or the rescue center so they can close the loop on it faster :)
goodatgettingbanned@reddit
It’s not called the Excellent Landing Tester for nothing.
Fourteen_Sticks@reddit
Why would they announce that on the frequency?
sennais1@reddit
No it's set to trigger off if it registers an impact.
Fourteen_Sticks@reddit
I know that. The comment makes it sound like the instructor would announce on 21.5 that he was checking for an ELT activation
sennais1@reddit
It's a joke.
chuckop@reddit
No, announce to the student on the intercom that they were checking 121.5 for the sound of a ELT.
Done jokingly, but kind of a passive duck move.
Schpiegelhortz@reddit
No it doesn't.
Sk1900d@reddit
That was part of the shutdown checklist at my school
BUTTER_MY_NONOHOLE@reddit
"Function tested serviceable"
FromTheHangar@reddit
My student set off the Apple Watch fall detection 😂
Elehctric@reddit
Well at least they know it works lol
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
You absolutely cannot listen to cabin crew about your landings. They compliment the ones that float halfway down the runway and butter on while shit talking the perfect ones you purposely plant on a contaminated runway in bad vis and gusty winds.
We've all had at least a few. The best pilot I know had such a hard landing that it dropped the masks in the back. Live and learn and move on.
MBayMan94804@reddit
I had one of those at old Stapleton after 3 go arounds. The last landing was a borderline crash. Masks deployed, overheads emptied, total yard sale/shit show w minor injuries. As I left I said “You’re allowed to divert you know”. Fucker ended up dead heading in the seat next to me on my connection to SJC. He hated me…
Bunslow@reddit
redditor, meet karma. karma, redditor
pooserboy@reddit
Oh. My. God. Last week I was landing on a 6500 ft runway and it was gusting 25 direct crosswind. I’m still relatively new to the CRJ and this was a textbook landing. Centerline, no side load, touchdown zone. I open the door and the forward FA says “who did that one? Breaking my back out here!”
theArcticChiller@reddit
As a lowly Cessna pilot, I am often appalled by airline crosswind landing videos, where they touch down aligned (kicking* the rudder) and immediately release the rudder completely, ending up in pilot induced oscillations around the centerline.
Is it not possible to control rudder appropriately due to weight (inertia), is it really bad technique or do I just fail to understand that this is how it's done?
*why not keep exactly the rudder input to maintain centerline, like on small planes, with only small adjustments?
Face88888888@reddit
KC-135 inboard engines hang so low that they can impact the ground.
It’s been a while so this might be wrong, but I think it was at 4 degrees of bank where the inboard engines could touch pavement.
theArcticChiller@reddit
Sure, but my question wasn't about wing low technique, but maintaining continuous rudder input to maintain centerline after touchdown, instead of releasing rudder pressure fully and then oscillate around the centerline
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
Your question will be answered if and when you find yourself in a big jet battling a crosswind and wet runway, knowing that if you let a wing up you'll have a pod strike. It's easy to judge a bit of wobbliness from the sidelines when you've never been there.
theArcticChiller@reddit
My question still isn't about wing low technique, it's only about rudder control to maintain centerline
Bunslow@reddit
maintaining centerline is as much about keeping the bank into the wind as using the rudder. just because you have weight on wheels doesn't mean the wind isn't still pushing you (and your wings) off the centerline.
as you slow down, naturally, it becomes less aileron more rudder, but there's a reason we're taught about aileron corrections even just to taxi straight. i definitely had some funky taxis where i didn't keep the aileron in, and the instructor could feel the wind trying to flip my plane. (i didn't feel a damn thing, still dont really, on account of still being greener than my flair)
Face88888888@reddit
Yeah you don’t just release the rudder after you touch down and start oscillating back and forth across the runway. You still have to keep the nose going down the runway.
IceHutAttendee@reddit
Yep, 4 degrees in a 3-pt attitude will scrape the inboards. TO states you’ll have, at most, 18in of ground clearance on 2 & 3.
Face88888888@reddit
Pickle power boards flaps gear flaps. COLCANBARF, FLIP. Are those still things? Kinda funny how much of this is coming back to me after ~10 years. 😂
confusedguy1212@reddit
Inexperienced pilots are those videos for the most part or just crappy technique. You usually also see the ailerons flatten out rather than held in.
And yes Airbus pilots I know you don’t normally hold your ailerons because of roll rate. That’s fine. Not all airplanes are like that.
Athana@reddit
On the ground you can keep some aileron into the wind but is not recommended because of spoiler deflection.
In normal law the a320 is in ground mode. Ground mode is a direct relationship between sidestick deflection and elevator deflection, without auto trim.
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
Never flown the bus but why would spoiler deflection bother you after you've touched down and they're all up anyway? Or do you mean on TO?
Athana@reddit
On take off
confusedguy1212@reddit
We found the Airbus pilot!
fountainsofvarnoth@reddit
The times that I’ve kicked a crab out, only to have a little swerve after weight on nose gear…it’s always been because my feet were too low on the pedals, and I needed to slide them up higher to get more pedal pressure for braking…and it’s hard to do that without letting the pedals move a bit. Airliners require significantly more brake pedal pressure than a GA airplane…hell, I rarely use the brakes in my Cessna.
NevadaCFI@reddit
That’s interesting. The Beech Premier jet has very touchy brakes. Just a little pressure, and you are stopping right now. 😂
pooserboy@reddit
I can’t speak towards other planes, only the CRJ. But it handles crosswinds fairly similarly to a Cessna. Kick some rudder in before touchdown, aileron into the wind and hold it. You are pretty limited with bank angle since you don’t want to wing strike but overall it’s fairly similar. I have no problem holding centerline once I touchdown. These videos you’ve seen could have way gustier winds or a new pilot on IOE or some other factors that we won’t know about but at least on the CRJ it’s almost just like landing a 172 in a crosswind.
ATACB@reddit
Cry’s in normal law
Yuri909@reddit
Cries
ahpc82@reddit
Do say more lol
bamfcoco1@reddit
I feel this.
theArcticChiller@reddit
Thanks for the insight!
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
Bad xwind landings are always at the top of the algo. Good technique and appropriate inputs are boring to watch for people who don't fly them and a joy for those who do
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
Choice use of words from that FA
pooserboy@reddit
I had a great chance to say something inappropriate but I am indeed still on probation 🥲
jonsmcintosh@reddit
I’m voting for the cabin crew announcement I heard on a Southwest arrival into SNA several years back…”Welcome to Orange County, the captain will now taxi what’s left of the plane to the terminal. Please remain seated. “
appletreeinthewoods@reddit
Oh my god im the cabin crew always making compliments on the landings hahah the pilots are probably like shaddup 😂
I dont say anything negative on landings tho. Learned my lesson when i was new.. Was joking around and the pilot looked like he was a wet puppy thrown head first into a lake :(
TheOneEyedPussy@reddit
awww
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
Haha sorry didn't mean to make it sound like hey, shut the fuck up back there. It's just that there are so many things that go into an operation and then everyone in the back judges our abilities as a person and pilot by the last .1 seconds. You'd be very popular with the flight crew if you complimented the overall performance (if true).
HaatOrAnNuhune@reddit
As a cabin crew member this is so true, we can 100% be the worst. I’ll never forget this senior mama I flew with way back in the day when I first became an FA. She was soooooooo pissed off about the ‘rough landing’ we had on a flight we worked. I didn’t have the shiny steel spine I do now, but all I wanted to ask her was if she was on the same flight as me. Because even though I only had a few months experience at the time I could tell that landing was difficult af due to the crosswinds/wind shear. And it wasn’t even a rough landing! It just wasn’t smooth as silk, though I strongly suspect even if it had been she still woulda bitched about something else. Those old Northwest girlies could humble a saint lmaooo.
RudderRamen@reddit
I was on a Captain OE, dudes first flight in the left seat. Absolutely cratered it into the runway in HKG. Hardest landing I’ve felt in my life. I thought the plane was fucked. Even the plane ratted him out, had to write it up. Poor dude
frostyhongo@reddit
Morning on 09R with the wind off Lantau?
sennais1@reddit
Getting PTSD thinking about living in Caribbean Coast hearing the late all night freight departures off 07R.
Uncabuddha@reddit
Oh yeah, max TO weight in the MD11 at night thinking "please don't lose an engine"!
MikeAU@reddit
Ahhh a fellow CX refugee
sennais1@reddit
KA
sennais1@reddit
Who doesn't miss telling themselves "It's not as bad as the 49ers." at night.
frostyhongo@reddit
Not as bad as a good old “Back in Ansett”
sennais1@reddit
Fuck me dead "at the old company". Even VA had the Ansett logo on Sabre up until recently and they wondered why retention was an issue.
linuxid10t@reddit
Wings go up, wings go down, wings go up, wings go down, wings go up, wings go down...
confusedguy1212@reddit
Flaps 25 landing?
russellvt@reddit
Doh! LOL
Academic-Access-9874@reddit
Old Hong Kong or new Hong Kong? Old you had to slam that bitch down after you made turn to final or you were gonna end up off the runway like air china
sennais1@reddit
CLK is on Lantau.
OldResearcher6@reddit
Lmfao
canyoutriforce@reddit
A new FA who was on one of her first flights started crying because she thought we crashed sooo
PutOptions@reddit
That first night landing in the ol' Cherokee. Good Lord, Piper really knew how to build a main gear for trainers.
A year or so later -- with many near perfect landings in my DA40 -- I was out with my instrument instructor shooting approaches and decided to land at a short little strip atop a small mesa. I was familiar with the funky mechanical turb common to that RW but this was another league of shit altogether. I finally wrestled her to the ground after quite the carnival ride. Instructor looks over at me slowly, says "Dude. I've never seen a better candidate for a go around."
It struck me then that I had not gone around once since my PPL checkride. I simply forgot it was an option. Oof.
Zathral@reddit
Unfortunately I cannot post a video in the comments, but there is a fantastic video of me on my second landing in a single seat glider I had just converted onto that day. I turn it into the closest thing a glider can do to a touch and go, then land it so hard (3 more times) that the wings visibly shake. That was.... quite embarrassing.
And to add insult to injury, I landed so long we had to tow it back to the launch point.
I have since got better at landing Astirs.
FunAbroad7432@reddit
Landed a 172 so hard the alt static knob flew off and landed in the back seat. It was a visor dropper.
Stan23XLR@reddit
Forward lav door flew open.
RicHarDNoGgiN7@reddit
I have 2….I had a brand new FO give me my first load 15 report. Coming into IAH the approach wasn’t great but he flared even more trying to save it and we hit hard. Too late do anything about it. 2nd going into ponce Puerto Rico, never been in there before and a lot of terrain landing east with a relatively short runway. I stuck it pretty hard after an ugly but safe approach. I went to the bathroom in the terminal and the guy pissing next to me asked if I let junior land the plane. I couldn’t throw him under the bus
Reputation_Many@reddit
Did you get a LOAD 15 report? If Not it probably wasn't as bad as you thought it was.
But My worst, was in a CRJ. The captain looked at me like I was a dumb ass and thought I hit the wing and we both did a walk around. I didn't do any damage to the airplane. But that wasn't the worst I ever was in. Back in the CRJ again... The Captain was landing and I was new. We had ground spoilers not working. He told me when he says now flip the ground lift dump switch. Well he told me at about 10ft flip the switch. We dropped straight down... BOOM! (no damage thank goodness also) The FA asked who landed that was the worst landing she had been in in her 20 years as an FA. I said if its a good landing it's always the captains landing if it's a bad landing it's always the FO's landing. He bought my dinner and drinks that night.... lol
I somehow never landed the A320 hard... I know it's SUPER easy to do it as I've got friends who did LOAD 15s. My secret on the a320 was start a mini flare at 50ft, then normal flare at 30ft and at the first retard pull the power out, and It was smooth almost everytime and in the landing zone.
Good luck out there.
Spare-Growth@reddit
One day the pilot of a Cherokee 180 was told by the tower to hold short of the active runway while a DC-8 landed. The DC-8 landed, rolled out, turned around, and taxied back past the Cherokee. Some quick-witted comedian in the DC-8 crew got on the radio and said, "What a cute little plane. Did you make it all by yourself?" The Cherokee pilot, not about to let the insult go by, came back with a real zinger: "I made it out of DC-8 parts. Another landing like yours and I'll have enough parts for another one."
mi_pilot@reddit
LMAO! 😂
False___9@reddit
Had to go around slammed it down so hard still haunts me
cageordie@reddit
If you didn't trigger the hard landing check it really doesn't count.
1TLC1@reddit
I'll just chime in that when I experience horrible landings as a passenger, I just assume it's one of their first days on the job and that everyone has to start somewhere. I'm just grateful to walk off the plane. :)
Then_Bar8757@reddit
When you touch down so hard that the crew in the aft complain of spinal pain, then have lasting ill effects, you done effed up, pilot boy. One word: FLAIR.
SWADRVR@reddit
Don’t flare in a Lear!
SWADRVR@reddit
Never forget it 30 years ago Houston hobby runway 4. I was a 1st year FO. I bounce that new 737- 300 on so hard it jump 10 feet in the air TWICE…we learn from our mistakes. My captain told me this ain’t no LearJet buddy😎The he went out and stood in the galley and took the heat for me as I shriveled in my seat. Best move I EVER made in my life was joining Southwest Airlines Co.
cuttawhiske@reddit
There's 3 secrets to a good landing and no one knows them. sometimes maybe good sometimes maybe shit Do not listen to the FAs about your landings they don't fly.
Morganater123@reddit
That runway was looking at you funny man. You just had to show it who’s boss.
EntroperZero@reddit
That's what I thought you said, 13R.
weech@reddit
That runway talkin shit? 🧐
KeyOfGSharp@reddit
Definitely going to use this
indiearmor@reddit
I crushed a 737-200 into MHT.
I still remember 20 plus years later.
😲🙃
TrouljaBoy@reddit
Also an A320. Landing on the longest runway in BOS. Clear and a million. Calm winds. Slammed it so hard I was convinced we’d get a print out and be calling the paramedics at the gate for all the bags that came out of the overhead bins and knocked out pax in the back. Somehow didn’t get a print out, but maybe because the landing knocked the paper spool out of alignment. Pull into the gate, look over at CA and say “Dude I’m sorry.. that was a top 3 worst landing in an airplane for me.. not in the Airbus, not in jets, literally in an airplane since day 1.” He tries to make me feel better saying he’s been flying the bus for 15 years and still has one randomly sneak up on him every couple years. I said “No man you can tell me it sucked, but in 15 years was it the worst you’ve seen?” He says “oh no of course not I’ve seen one maybe two worse than that..”
To add insult to injury about 10s after that conversation the FAs call up. FAs don’t normally call up at this point. I’m thinking the worst. People are actually hurt. CA picks up and FA says “hey we’ve got a write up back here, the aft galley JS is broken.” CA says “did TrouljaBoy’s landing ACTUALLY break something back there??” “Yeah….” In my head I’m thinking holy shit. 4000hr in airplanes, multiple type ratings, 10 years of flying, perfectly clean record, and this is the first time I’ve actually damaged a plane landing. Then she says “no I’m just kidding it actually broke about an hour ago we were just busy with service and forgot to tell you.” -_-
I took the first leg the next day. Had move on from that landing and not sit on it any longer. FLL, gusty as shit, grease it. Which actually managed to piss me off more about the previous landing lol.
ASELtoATP@reddit
Calm winds in the bus are the kiss of death. I feel you.
RedWingFan5@reddit
On OE I slammed a 319 so bad I could hear the people in the back laughing and clapping (presumably because they were happy they were still alive). Safe to say my brain was about 30 feet behind the radar altimeter.
BChips71@reddit
Or you scared him so badly he'll never fly again. ;)
RedWingFan5@reddit
Or that!
J50GT@reddit
I bounce my Cherokee more often than I'd like to admit, I'm sure you're good. I was on a commercial flight once though that had a dozen overheads open up on landing, not sure how common that is.
J50GT@reddit
I bounce my Cherokee more often than I'd like to admit, I'm sure you're good. I was on a commercial flight once though that had a dozen overheads open up on landing, not sure how common that is.
49-10-1@reddit
Load 15 yes or no?
Healthy_Awareness_98@reddit (OP)
Nope. Nothing printed so in the clear. Sitting pretty at 1.7g lol
BigJellyfish1906@reddit
Hawt. So it passed the strut compression check?
Healthy_Awareness_98@reddit (OP)
Strut Was still there and kicking
BigJellyfish1906@reddit
Can’t say for sure if the struts compress all the way if you never compress them all the way.
Bravo-Buster@reddit
I porpoised on a landing on my IFR cross country with my CFII. As I was saying go around, he was saying "my controls" and landed it. Embarrassing as hell, but at least I got to record 3 landings. 🤣
Ted_Striker02@reddit
I had a super bad landing in FLL when I was new to the airbus. Slammed that 321 on so hard we got a load 15 report. Bachelorette party came up after the flight. I totally owned the landing. I asked the bride to be what she thought of my landing. She said she was glad she was drunk because she probably would have shit herself. They can’t all be winners.
Electro04@reddit
It happens, had one in the 73 last week with med tailwind that had one of the flight attendants call me “good landing” for a whole day, made sure I ended the trip with a good one but man was it an ego bruiser.
But then as others have said, those guys aren’t the best judgement of landings, had awful ones that got praised.
airbusman5514@reddit
First 121 job, second trip, day four leg two. DCA to PIT. We were coming down the ILS 28L in some decently gusty winds. Until about the last hundred feet, I was doing fine. Then my brain shit the bed and decided to try and land a Canadian torture tube line a 172 at the same moment we had a decent shear. Slammed it so hard we bounced. When I got off the runway I looked back to make sure we hadn’t lost an engine. At the gate I legit asked my LCA if I needed to put my resume together. Trust me, yours couldn’t have been that bad
Snowboard757@reddit
San Antonio, old friend in the Jumpseat, I was just about to flare when BAM!!
fighting_gopher@reddit
Two separate instances: I was complaining the whole flight about Pittsburgh (where we were flying to) and I slammed it in and the captain yells “TAKE THAT PITTSBURGH!”
Second instance: I just didn’t flare enough. But the captain was a former check airman and he saw it coming so as soon as we touched down he yelled “BOOM!” And started laughing. (This was prior to the Costco guys rise to power)
Somant@reddit
Night landing in a helicopter was two feet above the pad and slammed it into the pad
FringeActual@reddit
My mother, a FA for Continental for 47 years, was sitting up front for a landing back in the 70s or 80s and they landed so hard that when it was over she got up and said, "I'll go back and check for survivors".
Ok_Truck_5092@reddit
On the last landing of my private pilot checkride I slammed the nosewheel so hard I thought I destroyed the plane. It was probably the hardest landing of my life to date, and of course a DPE was in the right seat. I was absolutely horrified and slowly turned my head to see his reaction. Poker face. I guess I did decently well before that because he didn't say a word and I walked away with my ticket.
silverwings_studio@reddit
You’re a pilot and they aren’t. Take your opinion of it in higher regards
Gazoom757@reddit
Welcome to Fight Club. The first rule of Fight Club is: you do not talk about Fight Club. The second rule of Fight Club is: you DO NOT talk about Fight Club!
ATACB@reddit
lol pull a load 15 report next time and show us the g load.
RaiseTheDed@reddit
First landing in a big airplane, Q400. Fucking cratered it in, full boat of people in the back. I knew it was going to be bad when the captain pulled the yoke back a bit more lol.
Funny thing is FAs didn't say a word, they knew I was on OE.
Photon_0@reddit
I’ve had a few sudden arrivals myself, where you don’t want to open the flight deck door after parking. None registered as hard though, so far.
Also had one approach, where the captain kept stressing that there were to be no floating what so ever (short icy runway in a 320). Well, I certainly didn’t float, didn’t really flare either. Probably was close to max runway utilization there :p.
No_Reserve_262@reddit
First ever landing in a 737, a dead heading pilot asked if the company insurance covered his chiropractor costs.
It was not a pretty landing, nor smooth.
Justaplaneguy@reddit
About 300lbs under max landing weight with 25G35ish for 22 at LGA I planted it pretty firmly before crossing 13/31 (my mental go around point if I’m not down) with medium brakes. Still had the CAB knob (FA intercom) out on the audio control panel and on the taxi in, the FAs were like “OMG everyone ok with that landing? Like omg I had to look up his seniority number. He hasn’t even been flying for 2 years.” All of them were less than a year on property.
Passenger comes off and asks how long I’d been flying, I respond with my first lesson being 19 years ago. He says something to the effect of “I could tell someone who knew how to get it down today was flying! Nicely done!”
FA goes “why’d you lie to that man? You haven’t even been flying two years.”
Take what they say with a grain of salt.
Swedzilla@reddit
Reminds me of the time NAX landed in Oslo one night. Not only did PF check exactly how deep the struts are but it cleared up a kink in my neck 🤷♂️
Independent-Jicama-8@reddit
I once cratered a 757 so hard in Central AmericaI, I broke 2 of the squat switches and was AOG for a few days. 🫣
Grand-Jacket-8782@reddit
I was in the jumpseat and FO on IOE hit so hard, it needed a hard landing inspection.
FRICKENOSSOM@reddit
I was a brand new 727 captain landing in MSP. The crosswind was something like 25G35. I added the maximum of 20kts to Vref. At about 20 ft someone pulled the rug out and we came down hard. Because of the 20kt additive and the big hiyaka pitch change and throttle burst I had just made we bounced way up. So I turned it into a go-around. The second attempt was good and we taxied to the gate. As the passengers were deplaning a 4 ft tall, little old lady stopped and as she repeatedly poked me in the chest said “THAT. WONT. DO. That won’t do at all!!” And she left. That was 30 years ago.
humboldtreign@reddit
My boss went out to inspect the landing gear once the brake was set at the FBO.
Whistlin_Bungholes@reddit
I don't know much about flying. But as a frequent passenger, if I walk off the plane, your landing gets an A+ from me.
sensor69@reddit
I was back seat with another IP up front, he wanted to show off what "fully flared" looked like and we ended up in a sabre dance, luckily at an altitude of only a foot or so, but I was scared for sure
Fr3nch_Toa5t_@reddit
Made a cat throw up in the back of the RJ once lol
fallingfaster345@reddit
Don’t feel bad, sometimes cats just barf. It was probably the oscillations more than anything! My cat has puked on the plane before (most unfortunately) but I can’t blame the pilots.
russellvt@reddit
Hairball?
sennais1@reddit
We've all punished a lav.
fallingfaster345@reddit
Former FA turned 121 pilot and never in all my years as a flight attendant did I comment on a pilot’s landing (definitely not a negative or critical comment or “joke”) and honestly anyone who does is rude AF. Can they land a jet? Do they even know what they’re talking about? Didn’t think so.
Professional_Low_646@reddit
I usually fly self-unloading cargo, aka paratroopers. They have a pretty tight wind limit for static line drops, 12 knots. We took off, while setting up for the drop tower informs us the wind has gone up to 25 knots, so no drop and we should rtb. The airfield sits on top of a hill, and the way the wind was blowing I knew we could expect some serious downdraft on short final. When it came, I aggressively moved the throttle forward and pitched up, then sat her down rather firmly (well within limits).
Overheard several of the paras afterwards talking about how that landing was the scariest part of their entire training lol.
delcielo2002@reddit
I used to fly jumpers at a Cessna dropzone, and I always kind of smiled when I got those calls. The runway at our little airport was close enough to the hangars that you would get mechanical turbulence from them and gusts through the gaps. So when that call came, you knew that the landing would be sporty. Most of the jumpers hated flying anyhow, and watching the change from daring sky gods to white knuckled scared passengers was always amusing.
satans_little_axeman@reddit
Had a partial engine failure in my meat bomber days below their min alt... for two of them that was their first time ever landing in an airplane.
PNESSWrinkle@reddit
I go through phases where I can’t land to save my life, then at times I feel like I’m just rolling them on. When my landings are just absolute shit, I always tell myself that I have a lot of good ones behind me, and ahead. Keeps me from beating myself up over them.
legitSTINKYPINKY@reddit
To be fair the cabin crew can’t tell a good landing from their behinds.
BigJellyfish1906@reddit
It wasn’t my landing but I was standing out there and a passenger said “that was a real Mr. MaGoo landing wasn’t it?”
I had another captain where he totally planted it in LaGuardia and without skipping a beat said “and that’s what I think of your fuckin airplane.”
Ace_Laminar@reddit
Hunny moon flight. We were flying flair into cancun. Buddy cratered it all the passengers let out an audible “oooooo” best part buddy rolled into customs with the a Top gun bomber jacket full of patches. What’s a tool
samwisegamja@reddit
I had one where a pax approached the flight deck and ask if I was a navy pilot… this was on a Canadian airline. My captain got a good laugh but he had a worse landing on the next one so theres that
russellvt@reddit
As a passenger, I've done that before ... hmmm.. LOL
bobdole145@reddit
Do you ever wonder if your bad landing is still thinking about you too? :)
ainsley-@reddit
Flying jump seat had an ex navy guy talk about how soft the civil industry is and how they used to crater their landings and aircraft’s just ate it up. Proceeded to crater it so hard the plane reported it and he missed the centreline so bad the left main was rumbling on the runway centreline lights.
serrated_edge321@reddit
I think they trained "carrier landings" too much. 😅 Short runway crowds tends to plant it... Not necessary or nice at all when there's a beautiful long runway in front of you.
SecureThruObscure@reddit
“They paid for all that runway, why are you so opposed to using it?”
andrewrbat@reddit
I used that excuse when i floated 85% of the tdz last night haha
maverick715@reddit
If a Navy guy lands off centerline, tell them "Gonna need you on centerline next time". I think its a required call if one of the mains was over the centerline.
sennais1@reddit
"Wrong line champ"
Sacharon123@reddit
Back when I was on the right seat, first night landing with full flaps with a sidestick airliner, I hear 50-40-30 and suddenly the captain starts shouting "flare-flare-FLARE-" bam. Also grounded the AC. Luckily not more wrinkles then there were before in the lower skin ;)
diegom07@reddit
Was it in TDZ and centerline ? Did the plane print anything? If both are No keep going on with your life some days are good others are bad
yx717pirate1@reddit
Made a few masks drop
TristanwithaT@reddit
Third ever landing in the CRJ. I touched down somewhat firmly but not horribly, but the main problem was when my toes accidentally hit the brakes and the nose wheel came slamming down. Yeah, I scurried out of there to do the post flight walk around pretty quickly lol
pooserboy@reddit
The 700/900 brakes are insanely touchy
LaserRanger_McStebb@reddit
I went up with my instructor on a day when it was 25G30... Which is nothing for you jumbo jet guys, but this was in a clapped out 172.
I had like 25 hours at the time. I was so behind the airplane trying to manage wind corrections that when I tried to round it out and flare, I did so WAY early and ended up stalling out the airplane like 15 feet above the ground. I never heard the cabin creak like that when it slammed down onto the tarmack.
By some miracle I didn't break anything, but it sure felt like I almost turned that poor fixed gear rental into a 172RG.
InformationYankee@reddit
I pancaked a crj-200 a few decades ago and it still haunts my dreams.
Zapatos-Grande@reddit
First landing in the A320 in Boston in beautiful weather. Flared too late, so pounded it on. All I could do was laugh and say sorry. Next landing in O'Hare with thunderstorms and rain was like butter, so a little redemption.
sennais1@reddit
Pretty sure I changed field elevation at the Gold Coast/Coolangatta after greasing it so hard it knocked my headset off.
NuttPunch@reddit
Flight attendant gossip, no point in stressing over it.
HotRecommendation283@reddit
Hoes gonna say how shit, amiright
AmyLikesItRough@reddit
One of the FA’s overhead lights was allegedly inop in the outstation. Planted it so hard the light turned back on.
VNAV_PATH@reddit
Very gusty wet night, had a baulked landing. Went around after touchdown, flew the missed approach, did a brief hold & assessed options (we had plenty of additional fuel due weather, but the gusts were getting close to our company limits) then got vectored around for another approach. This landing was still rough but, given the conditions I didn't think too much of it. Exited runway, reported what the wind had been doing on short final and were on our way to the gate when ground asked us if we had hit anything on the runway. We replied negative. Ground asked us if we were sure as Airport Ops had just discovered quite a few smashed runway edge lights. That was a very slow and awkward taxi to the gate. Happily the post-flight inspection showed no damage and it was determined a bit afterwards that the offending flight was two ahead of us on our first approach.
I've done worse, but lets not talk about those...
kytulu@reddit
A CFI porpoised 5 times on a landing, went around, and flew back to base...
...with both ends of the prop bent, the firewall bent, the floor creased, plus whatever internal engine damage was caused by the prop slapping the runway into submission.
Strict_Horror_4015@reddit
Did everyone walk away? If so, sounds like they nailed it.
chaoticcole_wgb@reddit
I mean, everyone walked away except those without legs and wheelchairs right?
Good enough for government work.
mustang__1@reddit
Couple years ago we were on a 787 for the pilots last flight. Family onboard, taxied through the fire trucks, etc. it was a little bouncy on the descent and my wife is very susceptible to motion sickness
So we had to carry the bag of shame off the flight in front of the outgoing captain.
minfremi@reddit
My dad was on my flight for the first time with my company. I was flying; I landed. FA announced on landing: “Are y’all’s teeth intact? Welcome to XYZ”. Yes my dad was recording.
alani_777@reddit
Hey man, every landing you walk away from is a good landing. With that being said, i was probably supposed to try and stay on the runway :/
Murky-Baby-3003@reddit
You were in STL on Wednesday then, huh?
Dalibongo@reddit
I had a landing into Aruba a few months back that was going perfectly until the last 10 feet.
The aural alt call out was in perfect rhythm, the plane was right in the TDZ, on centerline, and all of a sudden BAM!
It wasn’t hard enough to trigger any FOQA report but the airplane did give a slight rebound, not a bounce, but it sort of decompressed the struts and came back up for a half second.
CA turns to me and says, “damn dude so it’s not just me, I have landings like that all the time, I can’t get consistency.” He’d been on the Airbus for 20 years.
I didn’t feel too bad since it was my first “firm” landing since I started flying it last year… that was until an old lady who was seated in the rear of the plane remarked on her way out, “what a wonderful flight!… Well, Up until the last 10 seconds. You guys scared me half to death.”
So yea that one stung a bit.
EpicDude007@reddit
My worst landing was in an A320. It was my first night landing in the type. Now I don’t think I even flared, though I thought I did at the time. The OE captain just said: “I think you woke EVERYBODY up.” He was nice about it though. I still think of that one sometimes when I’m coming in for a night landing.
Redbob73@reddit
I've definitely had my fair share of rough ones, but I heard on a podcast once a DPE talking about a time a commercial student set off the ELT on the check ride lol. Apparently he still passed
Fourteen_Sticks@reddit
I was riding shotgun in a G450 into a 5,000’ runway that was pretty heavily upsloped on the approach end. Came over the numbers with a little more sink rate than usual, but nothing unsafe. The guy flying was a bit late to react, flared too aggressively and drove the mains right into the ground as the airplane pivoted around the CG. It was the firmest I’ve ever experienced. He let me get up and get the door for the passengers.
On the leg home to our nice wide 9,000’ long runway, I rolled it on so smooth that you couldn’t feel it. He said “I swear to god…if one of these passengers makes a comment about the difference in the two landings…”
The first one out the door said something like “I see that we saved the best landing for last”.
No_Radio_7641@reddit
Was it on center?
Healthy_Awareness_98@reddit (OP)
On centre and in the TDZ
michellesmith1187@reddit
Sounds like a perfect landing to me then. The good news is that you’ve got thousands of future landings to F up too😂
No_Radio_7641@reddit
All that matters.
BUTTER_MY_NONOHOLE@reddit
My early eyes thought you said "was it on a carrier?" lol
michellesmith1187@reddit
I had a new FO lower sea level. Looks at me and says, “What do we do now?” I said, “I’d go stand by the door and thank all of your new fans for flying with you.” 😂
scrollingtraveler@reddit
It’s not a hard landing unless the headsets fly off!! Had a landing into DCA that was so hard I heard a scream and a gasp from the cabin. I sat there acting like I was post flighting the bird while my copilot got everyone off the airplane.
TourAcceptable4864@reddit
These things happen sometimes. The most difficult landings are CAVOK and still wind. I once cratered a 320 so hard that on my way out to do the walk around, the CM asked if I was going to check the strut hadn’t come through the wing. lol
Healthy_Awareness_98@reddit (OP)
We definitely held our breath waiting to see if it printed
ButtonPresser72@reddit
I was on a massive greaser streak and feeling really confident with the plane. Came into a short runway at night, no PAPIs and a slight tailwind, so figured I'd put it down a little bit firmer just to get it stopped.
I guess I overdid the short field landing technique, felt like I damn near destroyed the airplane. Captain laughed his ass off while we were rolling out. FAs were super funny about it too on the van ride to the hotel. The worst part was having to go through literally all of the passengers near baggage claim because the cargo door actuator was MEL'd so MX was still hand cranking the door to unload their luggage.
That humbled me real nice lol.
ryleypav@reddit
Shorter runway than we normally operate on, but totally legal and valid told. Standard "don't float it, don't be fast, don't go short either" up in the cockpit. A little heavier than we needed to be for the circumstances. Forgot to finish my flare an boy was she firm. Kinda startled us all.
Had to leave the best in place for a few weeks before they could ferry it to maintenance support. Needed a new main truck and some other things, that may or may not have already been an issue, just not looked at until a inspection such as Hard Landing inspection is completed.
Fit-Bedroom6590@reddit
S80, B707, B727, B757, B767, B777, DC8, DC10. Comanche owner
New Captain S80 first trip 2nd day LGA Shea stadium approach passing over the dike the bottom fell out. Hard but not damaging hard. Waited at the door took my beating until retirement never had it happen again with my hands on the controls. First officer landing in South America that was a different story. New FO 100 hours good weather clear he had a reasonably decent touchdown (767) then he slammed the nose down full throw. The force was severe enough requiring some skin replacement on the crown. It has since happened on 4 767's for major air carriers. Three were hull loses. If I had my hands on the controls I could not have prevented the unexpected force that was exerted. When he was asked why he threw full downward elevator during the main gear skip. He simply said; "that's what the 767 manual tells you to do." The manual said in a crosswind put the nose gear, "rapidly on the ground." It does not say uncoil your arms and torso like a striking snake. He was very tall and had very long arms. It turned out he had under a hundred hours FO in type. During the flight down he implied he was a long time on the machine. In this incident I learned that without a doubt when the FO is flying the leg he is flying on your license. I had extensive experience with hearings as the base chairmen of a 4000 person base. So perhaps the best part of the story was the after incident stuff, I called the chief pilot he asked; first question if anyone was hurt as a matter of fact it was not a discernible hard landing normally distributed to a plane via the main gear. The damage was translated to the crown skin of the aircraft by the force between the main gear and the nose gear. That is not even the best part of the experience I knew from my chairmanship and hearing expertise to take charge of the voice and flight recorders - to my surprise the mechanics gave them to me; 12 hours later for the trip home.. I also knew that debrief and drug test would be imminent. I advised the system chief pilot to book 3 first class seats home for for us. Brought the flight recorder in the over head bin. That created an international front page every newspaper incident; recalling one head line "Gringo insults Brazil." the Company was extremely supportive the feds dismissed immediately me as a non problem. Flight recorder showed a startling anomaly that the elevator was manipulated so fast that a split elevator signal was sent to the flight recorder.. Boeing well that is another story. My system Chief, nick named me fang because I bit into Boeing pretty hard threatening to make them more famous then they were. If you are ever involved in an incident keep your cool, zip the lips as you exclusively knew what happened and the flight recorder is your best friend. Show no fear as you know more then anyone else whats next- take charge. Get all the paper work together do not let it go like sleep with it. Then relax enjoying the couple of free paid days off. I suggest that this narrative will make you feel much better.
Any_Buy5102@reddit
just write a novel at this point
Plastic_Brick_1060@reddit
"My Life in One Paragraph" 700 pages
JayArrggghhhh@reddit
Solid story that makes me wish reddit handled Return/new line/paragraphs better. I'll add 5-7 spaces as a line break for that purpose before a Return.
Fit-Bedroom6590@reddit
If you don't want learn skip to the one sentence replies when it is a long narrative.
d_zeen@reddit
Bouncing from this to “I made a cat throw up” haha
dragonguy0@reddit
2: First was a student landing in gusty, at limit crosswinds who flared a bit too early... aircraft immediately lost the gust it was on, stalled, and scraped both wingtips. Oops.
Second was a student that flared stupid high (probably 8 or 9 ft) who was already slow...the struts compressed so far I was convinced there'd be tire marks on the bottom of the wings.
So yeah, protip: don't let your students get slow xP
slugworth1@reddit
Had a pretty rough bounced landing in the Cessna once. After I rolled out and asked for taxi instructions, ground asked me over the radio “hey Nxxx got any teeth left?” It was a pretty embarrassing landing.
hendrixsrv@reddit
Tell em “Go Navy”
waveslikemoses@reddit
Not sure if I’m allowed to share since I’m still in the road to 1500 phase but hear goes:
I was renting a Warrior one time and was just about to land at the home airport at night. Lights went out right before touchdown, and yet my dumbass continues the landing instead of going around. When I tell you I SLAMMED this plane on the runway to the point where I thought I broke something. Thankfully I was all good tho.
738lazypilot@reddit
I flared a little early and hold it there, I knew I was in trouble the moment I saw the captain screaming wow wow wow wow while he raised his back from the seat to protect it from the impending hard landing. It was a nice positive touchdown.
flygirlsworld@reddit
As a flight attendant , this is hilarious LOL
Worried-Ebb-1699@reddit
Helping a friend bring his new-to-him piper lance or may be archer to his home field in southern Florida. This was his first time flying it post Cfi insurance ride along where he did ok.
Guy slams it in so bad my headset falls off my head and he broke his right main landing gear.
He spent a gazzillion to fix it, but I never got near a plane with him again
rFlyingTower@reddit
This is a copy of the original post body for posterity:
I had the A320 struts working overtime
Please downvote this comment until it collapses.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. If you have any questions, please contact the mods of this subreddit.