As a kid, I hated receiving this candy for valentines. I still do now.
Posted by ryhoyarbie@reddit | Xennials | View on Reddit | 96 comments

Posted by ryhoyarbie@reddit | Xennials | View on Reddit | 96 comments
Prudent-Lake1276@reddit
Valentines candy is bottom of the barrel stuff. Easter is where it's at.
DerbGentler@reddit
"This concept of wuv confuses and infuriates us!"
– Lrrr
onsinsandneedles@reddit
Sweet chalk.
GarminTamzarian@reddit
The Valentine's Day equivalent of Mary Jane Peanut Butter Kisses.
Woad_Scrivener@reddit
The best chalk!
LardLad00@reddit
Only slightly sweet chalk
loptopandbingo@reddit
Close!
aakaase@reddit
Funny thing, I really disliked them too, but I would reluctantly eat some of them begrudgingly. Now I absolutely enjoy Necco wafers, which is literally the same candy in a wafer disc form. But if you have me those hearts? No way... lol
Borracho_Bandit@reddit
I like them because they taste like candy cigarettes.
Abidarthegreat@reddit
https://i.redd.it/mx6vbdfvh8je1.gif
caramelpupcorn@reddit
I always thought these were so gross and then later learned it's made from the same company that makes Necco Wafers. It all made sense after that.
gesis@reddit
These and Necco wafers are my favorite candies.
Ok_Breakfast5425@reddit
You're sick
BlacksmithThink9494@reddit
Me too!!
Opposite-Peak5020@reddit
Yes - they're thick Neccos with questionable messaging.
CatchMelodic8249@reddit
I'm not sure what they are supposed to taste like... some combo of black licorice, wintergreen, and despair maybe?
Funkopedia@reddit
Yup, they don't even have to change the formula, just flick a switch,
EternalSunshineClem@reddit
I don't enjoy things a chalky texture or a waxy texture. So I'm all the way out on these, candy corn and sprinkles.
onsinsandneedles@reddit
Where are you on Peeps? This is the true line in the sand.
EternalSunshineClem@reddit
I find them repulsive! You?
onsinsandneedles@reddit
Peeps are not for eating, solely for microwave expansions and explosions.
Rapidwatch2024@reddit
Send them over! Love those.
HallucinogenicFish@reddit
They’re just nasty. I refuse to believe that anyone genuinely enjoys these things.
Ilikelamp7@reddit
I just spent a couple weeks eating a huge bag of them
thatjeffdude79@reddit
Mmmmm Tums©️
gmlogmd80@reddit
Ok-Potato-4774@reddit
Reminds me of 1980s elementary school Valentine's Days.
ArcticTrek@reddit
I LOVE those. I just said that I need to buy myself some.
NachoNachoDan@reddit
My kids don’t like them so I get theirs!
caramelpupcorn@reddit
I love that you were downvoted for saying that! I gave you an upvote for your honest but unrelatable opinion of them 🙂
NachoNachoDan@reddit
Sitting on my kitchen table
I still like the white ones best. Minty!
BlacksmithThink9494@reddit
And I think the pink ones are wintergreen!
NachoNachoDan@reddit
That’s the way of Reddit.
BlacksmithThink9494@reddit
I buy this candy on purpose. 😬
gamblinonme@reddit
Trash
Da-Monkey-Man@reddit
Fuckin love em, I like Necco Wafers too.
iheartnjdevils@reddit
As I sit here with a 2lb bag of them...
boringandsleepy@reddit
These are the candies my local grocery store has been stocking in the highest profile "impulse purchase" spot in the checkout lanes. You know that space next to the raised table where people used to use to write checks? That space.
I am glad, because it is so easy to resist the temptation! If they had Valentine's Reese's cups or Kisses or something I would struggle.
PurplePenguinCat@reddit
I liked the purple and white. The rest were nasty.
EL3MENTALIST@reddit
I liked the purple ones… 💜
schenkzoola@reddit
“I used to hate receiving the candy hearts. I still do, but I used to too.”
nudave@reddit
R/expectedmitchhedberg
panteragstk@reddit
Lol. Just noticed the "expected"
LArocking@reddit
Glorified pepto
TrinityKilla82@reddit
I used to piss my teachers off and wrote on the chalkboard with the candy hearts. 🤣 ah shit my age is showing🤣
notorious_BIGfoot@reddit
I love these chalky bastards
Mwiziman@reddit
Love these
bananapanqueques@reddit
Mmm chalk.
CorgiKnits@reddit
I’m eating them right now. I wait for them every year. But I’m a type 1 diabetic, so my blood sugars pay the price. So I’m glad they’re only around once a year :)
WillowOk5878@reddit
A decade (or so) ago I bought these (type of) hearts from the Vermont Country store. They were incredible tasting, kinda soft chalky and fruity tasting. They were sooo freakin good and they blew the cheap (mass produced) ones away!
billyjack669@reddit
Bone meal and earwig honey?
No thanks.
_shaftpunk@reddit
Sign me up.
Flashy-Share8186@reddit
I kinda liked these! But the candy necklaces were better.
JackpineSavage74@reddit
Until you had multi color sugar stains
NachoNachoDan@reddit
Meh who cares. Wearable candy. Next you’re gonna say that you hate ring pops because they make your fingers sticky
JackpineSavage74@reddit
What's wrong with sticky fingers?
NachoNachoDan@reddit
guardbiscuit@reddit
They’re my favorite candy (along with Neccos). My kid went to get some for me at the grocery store today, and they didn’t have them. 😞
Critical_Liz@reddit
Bitter Sweethearts
Sudden-Dig8118@reddit
Wrong
Reasonable-Wave8093@reddit
Candy Gram!
NachoNachoDan@reddit
Lonely-Safe1835@reddit
I hated these, rockets, those stupid candy necklaces, and the edible stick that you would lick and then dip into a pure sugar mix, I can't remember what they are called. Were these things invented in 1867 when the bar for candy was set pretty damn low?
Dogrel@reddit
I used to hate this candy.
I still do, but I used to too.
OtherlandGirl@reddit
Better off eating the chalk at the board…
loptopandbingo@reddit
I like these lol
shiftdown@reddit
My coworker hands these out
DemotivatedTurtle@reddit
I love those things. Sugary, chalky goodness.
badmongo666@reddit
I used to scrape the words off and replace them with stuff like "EAT SHIT", "LET'S FUCK", "ANAL?", etc. and then put them back. Probably like 90+% just got eaten without anyone noticing, but it was still worth it.
JuWoolfie@reddit
Mmmm… chalky
Funny enough, I loooooved the chalky flavour of Popeyes sticks, aka candy cigarettes
Kinky-Bicycle-669@reddit
I also hate them
JellicoAlpha_3_1@reddit
This shit and candy corn must come out the same factory
Jdojcmm@reddit
I was given a box today. I’ll give them to my wife and she’ll read them and throw em away.
Asinine47@reddit
I can taste them now lol
hdufort@reddit
I liked these!
The ones I didn't like were the little cinnamon heart hard candies. I like cinnamon but not that much!
Abattoir_Noir@reddit
Loved them. Necco wafers were some of my favpurite candies as a kid
frawgster@reddit
LOVE these things. Especially when most of them came outta the box stamped all crooked or with kissing letters. ❤️
erinrachelcat@reddit
My mom put them in my lunches around Valentine's Day and I loved getting them. But they are not delicious.
Mudcreek47@reddit
Shew. They tasted like stale chalk.
TroleCrickle@reddit
omg thanks for reminding me I have several boxes of these to nom nom nom!
also, send me yours!
somethingcool@reddit
How can you love someone and give them these?
redfalcondeath@reddit
Tastes like toothpaste in chalk form
BuggyBonzai@reddit
Just like candy corn i like to have 1 per year to remind myself of how awful it is.
FluffySpell@reddit
I do this with Peeps. "Surely they're not as terrible as I remember." Nope. Still trash.
BeBopBarr@reddit
No way! These are one of my favorite seasonal candies!
kittelamour@reddit
They taste like chalk lol
_WeSellBlankets_@reddit
Here's a Tums with "I love you" written on it.
- Jim Gaffigan
nitrot150@reddit
Toothpaste hearts! That’s what our exchange student from Germany called them! It stuck
Reasonable-Wave8093@reddit
def a mouthwash vibe
TransportationOk657@reddit
I like them, however, I stopped eating them after I cracked a tooth on one and had to get a root canal.
ignatious-d@reddit
Tastes like loneliness
blue_suavitel@reddit
I hate the candy but I love the pattern on things. In fact, I have candy heart socks on right now.
Deep-Interest9947@reddit
I liked them but the purple ones tasted gross
thevmcampos@reddit
I instantly had a bad taste in my mouth after seeing this picture!!
BrilliantRain5670@reddit
Rubber band ammo.
washingtonsquirrel@reddit
I love them! They barely taste edible, which is strangely part of the appeal.