Is this how chain of thought model works? 💀

Posted by vinam_7@reddit | LocalLLaMA | View on Reddit | 46 comments

This is my first time using a `chain of thought` model (deepseek-r1 preview) as I have never used the o1 variants because of the pay wall but man!, look at the chat it hallucinate itself then correct than again hallucinate, it is quite funny to read.

Question: your mother has 4 children name north, south, east. what is the name of the 4th one?

Thought for 39 seconds:
```
Alright, so I've got this riddle here: "Your mother has 4 children name north, south, east. what is the name of the 4th one?" Hmm, okay, let's see. At first glance, it seems straightforward, but I have a feeling there's a trick to it. So, my mother has four children, and three of them are named North, South, and East. I need to figure out the name of the fourth child.

First, I'll just list out what I know. The names given are North, South, and East. Those are directions on a compass, right? North, South, East, and West are the four cardinal directions. So, maybe the fourth child is named West? That would complete the set of four directions. That seems logical.

But wait, is there more to it? Maybe I'm missing something. The way the question is phrased is a bit tricky. It says, "Your mother has 4 children name north, south, east. what is the name of the 4th one?" There's no comma after "east," so it could be interpreted in different ways. Maybe the names aren't actually North, South, and East.

Another angle: perhaps the names aren't directions at all, and it's just a coincidence that they sound like compass points. Maybe the names are North, South, East, and something else entirely. But that doesn't seem helpful.

Wait a minute. The question says, "Your mother has 4 children name north, south, east." Maybe it's a play on words. It says "name north, south, east" – could it be that the mother's name is North, South, and East? That doesn't make much sense.

Or maybe it's saying that the mother has four children, and their names are North, South, East, and... Well, I need to find the fourth one. If the first three are North, South, and East, then the fourth is probably West. That seems to fit.

But let's think deeper. Is there another possible answer? Maybe it's a trick question. If it's "your mother," then the fourth child is "you." So, if I'm being referred to as "you," then the fourth child is me. That could be the answer they're looking for.

Wait, that's a clever twist. The riddle might be playing on the fact that "you" are one of the children. So, if your mother has four children named North, South, East, and you, then "you" would be the fourth one. That makes sense.

But which one is it? Is it West or me? Hmm, I'm not sure. Both seem plausible. Maybe I need to consider the wording again. It says, "Your mother has 4 children name north, south, east. what is the name of the 4th one?" The way it's phrased, it might be emphasizing that the fourth child is "you." So, perhaps the answer is "me" or "my name."

But if I take it literally, the names are North, South, East, and... Well, if it's a riddle, it's probably looking for a clever answer, not just the obvious "West." So, maybe the answer is "you."

Wait, but I'm supposed to provide the name of the fourth child, not "you." So, maybe it's "West." That seems more straightforward.

I'm a bit torn between the two possibilities. On one hand, it's a play on words where "you" are the fourth child. On the other hand, it's a straightforward riddle where the fourth child's name is West, completing the set of cardinal directions.

Maybe I should consider the context. If it's a riddle, it's likely looking for the clever answer, which would be "you." But if it's a logic puzzle, the answer would be "West."

I think the most common answer to this riddle is "you," because it's a play on the wording. It says "your mother has four children named North, South, East, and..." implying that "you" are the fourth child. That makes sense.

But I'm still not entirely convinced. I need to make sure I'm not missing something. Could there be another interpretation?

Perhaps the names are not related to directions at all, and it's just a coincidence. Maybe the mother has four children named North, South, East, and something else entirely. But that seems less likely, especially since North, South, and East are cardinal directions, and West is the obvious missing one.

Alternatively, maybe the mother's name is North, South, East, and the fourth child is West. But that doesn't fit the wording of the question.

Wait, the question says, "Your mother has 4 children name north, south, east. what is the name of the 4th one?" The way it's phrased, it seems like the mother has four children named North, South, East, and the fourth one's name is to be determined.

Given that, I think the answer is "you," because it's a riddle that plays on the wording to make you think about the names of the children, but the trick is that "you" are one of them.

So, in conclusion, the fourth child's name is "you."

```
Answer:
The riddle asks, "Your mother has 4 children named North, South, East. What is the name of the 4th one?" At first, it might seem like the fourth child could be named "West" to complete the set of cardinal directions. However, the clever twist in the riddle lies in the wording: since it says "your mother," the fourth child is actually "you."

**Answer:** The fourth child's name is "you."